Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

NASCAR vs F1, Gozilla vs King Kong, take your pick...

6 posts by 5 people · 18 Dec 1998 - 19 Dec 1998

Jan Kohl 18 Dec 1998#440835
I've been sitting on the sidelines watching this (rediculous) battle of words...and the only think I can say is...too much time between racing seasons! I've heard this ***y stupid argument 3 times this week from 3 different fronts (this forum, a touring-car mailing list, and a NASCAR sim racing board), and it comes around every year about this time when race fans get too much time on their hands and use it to slaughter any other types of motorsports they can get their hands on. End result? Stupid inane arguments that won't change anyone's mind, and only goes to prove that us race fans can't even stick together. I've *driven* go-carts, drag cars, circle track cars, off-road trucks, and a few other things, and I can only say...I've enjoyed them all! They all have their good and bad points, and for every bad point you can find in one form of racing, you can find a few good points. Me, personally, I watch almost anything racing I can find...it's even been hinted by a few of my friends that if cows had numbers plastered on the side and raced around a cow pasture, I'd tune my set in for a good race! ;] So why the dumb arguments? From what I've seen, most of the people who have slammed another form of motorsport knew little about the one they were slamming, and consequently made some very poor and erroneous statements about something they knew nothing about. I say, unless you've made a point to sit down and WATCH and understand a racing series, you've got NO cause to badmouth it. I'm not saying that everyone who posted about this was clueless, but looking at alot of the messages, quite a few were spouting statments that echoed ignorance about what they were talking about... Let me quote a few of the more outlandish statments... 'Formula 1 is boring, no one passes' - not true. Every Formula 1 race I watched this year had some very exciting conclusions...my personal fave was when the Jordan team won in the pouring rain after some complete disasters by the front runners. Lap after lap I was on the edge of my seat, hoping they could come through and not blow it, and they finally managed to persevere...it was one of the great moments of racing to see the team owner, who had tried for so long to win one finally come through. And yes, the last 8 laps, not one of the front runners passed a car, but in the pouring rain, it's a very easy slip to make that would put you in the gravel pit to wish you hadn't tried so hard... 'NASCAR is boring, big rolling billboards doing 5 million laps and then cautions again' - again, very untrue. Cautions play a major part in this sport, and not knowing how they affect the racing means you know nothing about them. While some may say it puts all the races in a 'start over' position...this is not true at all. Some cars won't pit. Some cars will put on 2 tires and go. Other cars will opt for just gas and beat all the rest out. Some cars will put on 4 and plan for the long run. You can never tell, and pit strategy changes each pit stop. And when the cars come into pits, it's not just the cars who are racing, it's the pit crews who are proving who's best each week. And when it comes down to 5 million laps...each one is completely different than the next. You see Mark Martin diving low and hugging the white line. You see Jeff go high and try for a wide one. Next lap Dale Jarrett takes Jeff's line and starts moving up. Then Rusty follows Mark and it's a 4 car battle for the lead! Not exciting? You got to be kidding me! NASCAR runs 2 road course point races during the year, and those are MOST exciting. I've heard a few comments about how NASCAR drivers can't do anything but turn left...and obviously the speaker knew nothing about NASCAR racing, otherwise they would know there are about 10-12 drivers who are excellent road course racers, and have proven that time and time again. Even Richard Petty made his mark on road courses, having won Riverside in California several times. Mark Martin is a very accomplished road racer, (speaking of just one)and Roush cars (without Martin) have won several Trans Am championships, Mark himself won the 24 hours of Daytona (in class) in a Roush Mustang in '95. In this modern era of corperate sponsorship, I've YET to see ANY car that didn't look like a rolling billboard. NASCAR and touring cars are NO different...(What, you think Menu's Nescafe' is alot more 'tasteful' than Rusty's Miller???? Inane comments, again). Just because Formula 1 and CART cars have about 1/2 to 1/3rd the side area that NASCAR and touring cars do don't make them any less rolling billboards than the rest. What, did you miss the huge Ferrari on Schumacher's car? Or the Target on Zanardi's car? In this day of mult-million dollar teams, it is very doubtful you'll see many cars in a winners' circle that DON'T have something plastered all over the side of them. Just because the side of the car is half as small doesn't make it any less of a rolling billboard than the next one... In conclusion: So instead of taking cheap pot shots at the 'other' motorsport, why not sit down and watch a race or two and try to understand it? I love and enjoy watching any form of motorsport, and wouldn't dream of making asinine statements about drivers and teams who have worked so hard to get to the pinnacles of their sport...it only goes to prove how short-sighted and narrow-minded racing fans can be... Cheers! -- ??Jan Kohl?? **The Pits Performance Team** Computer Systems Programmer USAF Air-Ground Operations School Hurlburt Field, FL Castle Graphics - http://www.castlegraphics.com The Pits - http://www.theuspits.com
> I've been sitting on the sidelines watching this (rediculous) battle of words...and the only > think I can say is...too much time between racing seasons! <snip> Well said Jan and an example of commentary from one who knows all forms of autosport, I agree completely and couldnt have said it better :). Trev
dduell 18 Dec 1998#440837
I couldn' agree more, or said it any better.
Goy Larsen 18 Dec 1998#440838
Jan, I think all those nominations has gone to your head, you gonna start kissing babies too ? :-) Relax, I and all my friends has already woted for you Beers and cheers (uncle) Goy PS. I DO agree though, I like Nascar more and more, did I just say that, geez
Jan Kohl 19 Dec 1998#440964
> Jan, I think all those nominations has gone to your head, you gonna > start kissing babies too ? :-) Sure, are they 5'8" blond Norwiegians? Any time! ;] Cheers! -- ??Jan Kohl?? **The Pits Performance Team** Computer Systems Programmer USAF Air-Ground Operations School Hurlburt Field, FL Castle Graphics - http://www.castlegraphics.com/ The Pits - http://www.theuspits.com/
EldredP 19 Dec 1998#440965
Godzilla! Well, nobody ELSE said it... <g> Eldred

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy