Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

I have gotten THREE flames --------------------

20 posts by 13 people · 16 Nov 1998 - 19 Nov 1998

Complaints about flames and GPL cheerleading

Doug Haithcock complained about anonymous flames, and David G Fisher said criticism of GPL was impossible amid the enthusiasm, prompting Pat Dotson to accuse him of double standards over CART Precision Racing. Mike Laskey, who worked with Papyrus during development, acknowledged GPL had faults, and the thread ended discussing rain modelling and rallying.

community/metaGrand Prix Legends

Automated summary.

--------------------------- from people who haven't had the guts to put their REAL e-mail addresses in their messages. That is the mark of cowardice. This newsgroup is here to allow everyone to express their opinions and objectivity. I have never felt someone was out of line becasue he or she stated what they felt was important enough to post here -------- that is what this newsgroup is for. I have to admit I do not have the millions of dollars to develop MY OWN software company ------------- but I AM in business and I attempt to supply each and every customer with a product that he or she can utilize to their best. I DO NOT just take for granted that "TAKE IT OR LEAVE IT" attitude. That is what MICROPROSE did ------------ I sure didn't hear anyone being easy on them about GP2 and it's inherent problems and their lack of coming back and attempting to utilize thier background to make the consumers happy with their product. IF I have an opinion ------------ I am going to express it --------- and if you LAME-BRAINS what to flame me and NOT IDENTIFY yourselves ---------- fine I used to be a police officer --------- I am used to idiots calling me names and the like ---------------- I just catagorized them with the other***ant ---- snot nosed ------- punks that make up this society. You three who haven't the guts to identify yourself are obviously just another three in that group of low life of this world DOUG
MeatWater 16 Nov 1998#434760
FLAME++++FLAME++++FLAME++++FLAME++++FLAME++++FLAME++++FLAME++++FLAME++++FLAM E Whatever that be... me names and the like ---------------- No wonder. Look at yourself. the other***ant ---- snot nosed ------- punks that make up this society. That could be the reason why you ain't a POLICE-OFFICER no more Aaaw, Mister POLICE-OFFICER-NO-MORE, why don't you just...ooops, almost got onto YOUR level... Mea***er FLAME++++FLAME++++FLAME++++FLAME++++FLAME++++FLAME++++FLAME++++FLAME++++FLAM E
At this particular moment, it is impossible to discuss any criticisms of GPL here at r.a.s. The emotional cheerleading will drown you out. This has happened before with sims and r.a.s., and it will happen again. Same exact situation, different sim. I think it's an excellent sim but it does have faults. Pointless though in bringing them up with these guys. You could have a logical discussion with some of them, and maybe get a beter understanding of the causes, but it would get drowned out by the rah, rah, stuff. Then statements get twisted, insults fly, and you end up with nothing but nonsense. What's funny is that the Papyrus folks would probably be far more open to any criticisms, and infinitely less defensive if you were able to talk with them. I don't know that they really learn much form someone who just tells them everything is great. Developers don't come to r.a.s. and discuss their sims, except to maybe give technical help. I wonder why? :-) If the knowledge here is so incredible....... What you'll get here is the "cult" of GPL. "My sim is better than any other, therefore I am better than any other." Odd because no one here is on the Papyrus payroll. Guys try to attach themselves to a sim by supporting it strongly, then maybe they feel like they helped develop it. The same situation happens with sports teams and their fans. It's a shame because this newsgroup is supposed to be about sims in general, not a competition. Guys get pissed at me just because I happen to appreciate the efforts of more than one company. Too bad. Lawrence and Zonker described the situation well last week. David G Fisher > --------------------------- from people who haven't had the guts to >put their REAL e-mail addresses in their messages. > That is the mark of cowardice.
Pat Dotson 16 Nov 1998#434762
> It's a shame because this newsgroup is supposed to be about sims in general, > not a competition. Guys get pissed at me just because I happen to appreciate > the efforts of more than one company. Too bad. No. People get pissed at you because you hype something like CARTPR, and blow off real complaints that people have about it (controller problems come to mind as a recent example). Then you nitpick the hell out of something like GPL. People have endlessly tried to engage you in conversation, only to be dismissed as cultists. -- Pat Dotson
go Dougie, go !!.... you tell 'em hah hah!! I'm sure they're quivering in their boots now. Hah hah ha, whoo hoo hoo, hah ha !!
Quoted text (38 lines)> --------------------------- from people who haven't had the guts to >put their REAL e-mail addresses in their messages. > That is the mark of cowardice. > This newsgroup is here to allow everyone to express their >opinions and objectivity. > I have never felt someone was out of line becasue he or she >stated what they felt was important enough to post here -------- that >is what this newsgroup is for. > I have to admit I do not have the millions of dollars to develop >MY OWN software company ------------- but I AM in business and I >attempt to supply each and every customer with a product that he or >she can utilize to their best. > I DO NOT just take for granted that "TAKE IT OR LEAVE IT" >attitude. > That is what MICROPROSE did ------------ I sure didn't hear anyone >being easy on them about GP2 and it's inherent problems and their lack >of coming back and attempting to utilize thier background to make the >consumers happy with their product. > IF I have an opinion ------------ I am going to express it >--------- and if you LAME-BRAINS what to flame me and NOT IDENTIFY >yourselves ---------- fine > I used to be a police officer --------- I am used to idiots calling >me names and the like ---------------- I just catagorized them with >the other***ant ---- snot nosed ------- punks that make up this >society. > You three who haven't the guts to identify yourself are obviously >just another three in that group of low life of this world > DOUG
Pat, Again someone bringing up CPR. I haven't discussed CPR here for a long, long, time, except to reference it's online play recently. I doubt I'll play any one sim for a year or more anymore. I offered help to anyone who needed it with controller problems, and spent a number of hours of my time giving that help (hardly call that "blowing people off") in private e-mails to people. I gave them setups and controller settings which solved their problems 90% of the time. Where have I "nitpicked the hell" out of GPL. I said it's "excellent", an "A", and "one of my two current favorite sims". IMO it has some faults as well. As if no one here is guilty of nitpicking, let alone all out attacks, on sims. It's easy to see where this thread is headed. Will I be "allowed" to like PSCR when it's released? Will I be allowed to recommend it to people, and state that it may do some, or many things, in an excellent fashion? Can I criticise it too, or should I just go with the crowd? You guys tell me. I don't want to upset you anymore. David G Fisher
Quoted text (10 lines)>No. People get pissed at you because you hype something >like CARTPR, and blow off real complaints that people >have about it (controller problems come to mind as a >recent example). Then you nitpick the hell out of >something like GPL. People have endlessly tried to >engage you in conversation, only to be dismissed as >cultists. >-- >Pat Dotson
Ben Coleman 17 Nov 1998#434982
Doug, why do you need private emails? Just reply in this NG for all to see. One thing that's been bugging me: what's with the dashes? What emotion are you trying to convey? Ben
Quoted text (38 lines)> --------------------------- from people who haven't had the guts to >put their REAL e-mail addresses in their messages. > That is the mark of cowardice. > This newsgroup is here to allow everyone to express their >opinions and objectivity. > I have never felt someone was out of line becasue he or she >stated what they felt was important enough to post here -------- that >is what this newsgroup is for. > I have to admit I do not have the millions of dollars to develop >MY OWN software company ------------- but I AM in business and I >attempt to supply each and every customer with a product that he or >she can utilize to their best. > I DO NOT just take for granted that "TAKE IT OR LEAVE IT" >attitude. > That is what MICROPROSE did ------------ I sure didn't hear anyone >being easy on them about GP2 and it's inherent problems and their lack >of coming back and attempting to utilize thier background to make the >consumers happy with their product. > IF I have an opinion ------------ I am going to express it >--------- and if you LAME-BRAINS what to flame me and NOT IDENTIFY >yourselves ---------- fine > I used to be a police officer --------- I am used to idiots calling >me names and the like ---------------- I just catagorized them with >the other***ant ---- snot nosed ------- punks that make up this >society. > You three who haven't the guts to identify yourself are obviously >just another three in that group of low life of this world > DOUG
Flyin 17 Nov 1998#434983
Hi all, Well its been almost umm 6 or 7 months since I last read this NG. Pretty amazing that your still pretty much having the same discussions :-) Hi Pat, Im not sure I recall you from back then but actually Dave is a nice guy. He helped me with set-ups for CPR back when I first got it and couldn't control it at all. After that I really enjoyed and supported CPR as many will remember. Hehe I think at some point some even thought I was some kind of MS spy or something because I had the audacity to like it. See Dave like myself never said CPR was "THE" sim we just liked it. For its time it had a unbelievable sense of speed. But it was very disliked here due to unfulfilled promises made here by MS. Anyway its just funny that back then the "THE" sim for this NG was F1rs man everyone here was singing the F1rs praise hehehe guess what? Dave was saying hey you know what? this F1rs has the same problems as POD. Man-O-Man they just about burned him at the stake. Funny also that while they/we cried and cried for MS to patch CPR, Ubi patched the hell out of F1rs some helped some didn't. But..... Dave was saying hey guys this F1rs has ummm like sticky grass or something :-) They said he was nitpicking then too. But he wasn't it was true :-) It was also true that CPR had problems too but, F1rs wasn't all that and as far as I know "THE" sim has not yet been built that will be all things to all people. CPR, F1rs, GPL etc. etc. etc. all good in some ways all have problems in others. We all like sims right? Cool my favorite right now is the demo from *** or is it EA now? SBK World Superbike Championship! Man this thing is fun I hope they can fix up the steering a bit but this is the best bike sim I have tried to date. I wonder if it will be "THE" sim next week :-) Aloha, Mike > > It's a shame because this newsgroup is supposed to be about sims in general, > > not a competition. Guys get pissed at me just because I happen to appreciate
Quoted text (12 lines)> > the efforts of more than one company. Too bad. > No. People get pissed at you because you hype something > like CARTPR, and blow off real complaints that people > have about it (controller problems come to mind as a > recent example). Then you nitpick the hell out of > something like GPL. People have endlessly tried to > engage you in conversation, only to be dismissed as > cultists. > -- > Pat Dotson
> I used to be a police officer --------- I am used to idiots calling >me names and the like ---------------- I just catagorized them with >the other***ant ---- snot nosed ------- punks that make up this >society. This is scary..... Cheers! John
> > I used to be a police officer --------- I am used to idiots calling > >me names and the like ---------------- I just catagorized them with > >the other***ant ---- snot nosed ------- punks that make up this > >society. > This is scary..... ...and he probably shot a few of those punks ("Make my day!"), just wonder how many were needed until they took away his Magnum... ;^) l8er ronny -- Toys'R'Us '99: "So, would you like a hand gun with that action figure, kiddo?" |\ _,,,---,,_ I want to die like my Grandfather, ZZZzz /,`.-'`' -. ;-;;,_ in his sleep. |,4- ) )-,_. ,\ ( `'-' Not like the people in his car, '---''(_/--' `-'\_) screaming their heads off!
Pat Dotson 17 Nov 1998#434986
> Pat, > Again someone bringing up CPR. I haven't discussed CPR here for a long, > long, time, except to reference it's online play recently. Uh, then what is this: ****** Subject: Re: GPL vs. Cart Pecision Racing Date: Mon, 16 Nov 1998 13:25:14 -0500 Organization: Prodigy Services Corp Newsgroups: rec.autos.simulators References: 1 , 2 Funy how r.a.s. works. I was able to drive inches from the wall at 225 mph the entire length of the track whenever I wanted or needed to. David G Fisher
Quoted text (7 lines)>Well, it was the first thing, I turned off while trying the demo...then >after >bouncing off the wall like a tennis ball for 5 times I just deinstalled >the ***... >l8er >ronny
******* What about the other 10% then? Your main complaint that I see is that sim-drivers don't use the same line the AI use. Fine, it's obvious that they are different. But comments like, "something got lost between the realistic physics and a realistic driving experience", when talking about GPL, are ludicrous if you compare GPL to any other sim out there. It's so inconsequential. You spend lots of time arguing that small point, yet gloss over 10% of the people you've personally come in contact with who can't get CARTPR to work right. Then you call people who have major, glaring problems with CARTPR cultists. I apologize for getting into personal criticisms of you. But you seem to lack perspective of problems with different sims. I hope that you and I and everyone else love PSCR so much that we don't do anything else, including post here, for a while. -- Pat Dotson
Graeme Nash 17 Nov 1998#434987
I -- presume ---------you have------- strawberries--------- and--------- - cream in yours -------then-----------! Cheers! -- Graeme Nash You know what to do with "don't_spam_me"... http://www.karisma1.demon.co.uk/ ICQ# 11257824 "My car appeared to disagree with my preference for living"
>Uh, then what is this: >****** >Subject: Re: GPL vs. Cart Pecision Racing >Date: Mon, 16 Nov 1998 13:25:14 -0500 Well, after barely discussing it here at all for months, I guess you got me started again by bringing it up from out of the blue the other day. I only have so much time in my life to devote to writing e-mails to people with problems with their sims. If I couldn't help someone, I referred them to a web site or someone who could. Usually, the people I couldn't help had a particular controller which I knew nothing about. A web site had detailed instructions to fix the problem. Also, some people never bother to tell you if you solved their problem or not. Christer Anderson made comments regarding the handling of the cars and realism about a week ago which I completely agree with. I think his comments explain why I see what I do when I look at replays. It's that simple. He didn't rip the sim at all (he likes it a lot if I believe), and neither have I. Randy Magruder had similiar concerns in his interview with Doug Arnao. People here at r.a.s. have joked about what GPL with rain would be like but really consider it for a moment. The real drivers of the past, which you can see in film, still were able to race fairly controlled in the rain. What would it be like for us? Byron made comments about multiplay this past week which I also agree with. They basically went ignored by certain people here. You guys view my comments differently because you think I don't like the sim at all, even though I've said over and over I do. Since day one, I have said it's great. I think I know why too. Somehow, I'm connected with a particular software company which is the Evil Empire on r.a.s. Because I beta test? I guess that company will want me shot now since I've praised Ubi and Papyrus a lot lately. I'm about to beta a flight sim (Fly!) for another company soon. Should I be worried? Silly. Who cares? I've had criticisms of every sim I've tried. I am probably far more POSITIVE overall than most here though, and I appreciate what many sim developers have done, which also seems to draw criticism (probably more than anything else). MS, Ubi, and Papyrus, have each done some amazing things in the past year in their sims. Others have too. It's a no win situation unless I agree completely with the most vocal, core group. If the consensus opinion was always correct, then everyone in this world would be happy and rich. To be honest, I'm not sure why you've come after me so strong. If I've ever ripped you, then I apologize, but I honestly don't remember doing so. Your name on this group is very familiar to me, and I've always read your posts on different topics so apparently I must respect them. I also don't remember ever sparring with you on anything in the past. Dave
-Pau 17 Nov 1998#434989
Hey, isn't that the same company that wrote CPR..... :-)
Mike Laskey 17 Nov 1998#434990
I've spent about the last year or so actually driving GPL, and have a couple of brief comments I'd like to put forward. It would be niave to think GPL was perfect or void of faults. As somebody who worked reasonably closely with Papyrus in the early stages as well as the latter, I don't mind telling you that of course it can be improved, but as far as I can see it is certainly ahead of its competition in most aspects of its design. Some of the physics, for example, aren't quite right - collisions for example can often produce dubious results, but what you have to try to understand is the scope of what has been attempted in GPL. None of the GPL physics are canned (pre-calculated). What happens when your car crashes is the result of real-time assessments of every aspect of the car model. If you do a 360, or go vertical, or whatever, that's the result of some pretty darn nifty impact calculations. I guess the thing is, GPL isn't perfect, but show me something better and I'll be impressed. I think it would be hard, just like real racing in in the rain is. I don't know how much experience you have wet weather racing, but it's certainly a challenge, and straight away will separate the men from the boys in terms of racing ability. Racing in the rain is a great equipment leveller and you soon see the differences between those who can drive constantly on the edge of adhesion and those who "perceive" the adhesion to be at a lesser speed. I don't for one moment think driving GPL in the rain would be impossible - you would just have to learn to drive slower. :) I didn't see those comments. The thing is, if you recognise the positive and negative aspects of a particular sim, you can feed that back into your other projects. Of course, your opinion is by nature always subjective. Mike.
Quoted text (21 lines)> The real drivers of the past, which you > can > >see in film, still were able to race fairly controlled in the rain. > What > >would it be like for us? > I think it would be hard, just like real racing in in the rain is. I > don't > know how much experience you have wet weather racing, but it's > certainly a > challenge, and straight away will separate the men from the boys in > terms of > racing ability. Racing in the rain is a great equipment leveller and > you > soon see the differences between those who can drive constantly on the > edge > of adhesion and those who "perceive" the adhesion to be at a lesser > speed. > I don't for one moment think driving GPL in the rain would be > impossible - > you would just have to learn to drive slower. :)
IMO, GPL would have had rain if the computers were up to it. I have yet to see a sim modelling this in *any* realistic way. Oh, and it would be totally possible to drive.In the IGPLC, we just had a league race at Monaco. With realistic damage, and we ran 40 laps, that's over an hour. Previously, I had done 5 laps at Monaco without damaging the car, in the race I managed them all! 14 started, 4 finished in close order, 3 people who I am certain would have finished were disconnected. And that was because they haven't got good enough hardware. (The trend is that the *same* people disco..) And two blew their engines. Makes me think that it would be possible to overcome bad weather..... Rain? Just concentrate even harder, just like in real life. I'd love it!! :-D Ask Ed of The Paddock, he got to know puddles REALLY well, at 100 MPH+! Here's to Papy taking their lovely physics engine, modelling a Mk II Escort RS 1800 BDA, and drawing the '76 RAC Rally!! Cheers, Matt_K,Norway (currently driving on STUDS!)
'76 rally season in a MkII !! - now that idea I like ... alot!! :-D I rally (mostly tarmac though) a MKII with a non turbo Cossie motor, BDA's are too expensive!, so it would be fun to have a good sim of the same thing - there certainly would be a lot of people with real world experience of them! c'mon Papy ....like da man say "Just Do IT" -Lindsay
Quoted text (43 lines)>> The real drivers of the past, which you >> can >> >see in film, still were able to race fairly controlled in the rain. >> What >> >would it be like for us? >> I think it would be hard, just like real racing in in the rain is. I >> don't >> know how much experience you have wet weather racing, but it's >> certainly a >> challenge, and straight away will separate the men from the boys in >> terms of >> racing ability. Racing in the rain is a great equipment leveller and >> you >> soon see the differences between those who can drive constantly on the >> edge >> of adhesion and those who "perceive" the adhesion to be at a lesser >> speed. >> I don't for one moment think driving GPL in the rain would be >> impossible - >> you would just have to learn to drive slower. :) >IMO, GPL would have had rain if the computers were up to it. I have yet >to see a sim modelling this in *any* realistic way. Oh, and it would be >totally possible to drive.In the IGPLC, we just had a league race at >Monaco. With realistic damage, and we ran 40 laps, that's over an hour. >Previously, I had done 5 laps at Monaco without damaging the car, in the >race I managed them all! 14 started, 4 finished in close order, 3 people >who I am certain would have finished were disconnected. And that was >because they haven't got good enough hardware. (The trend is that the >*same* people disco..) And two blew their engines. >Makes me think that it would be possible to overcome bad weather..... >Rain? Just concentrate even harder, just like in real life. I'd love >it!! :-D >Ask Ed of The Paddock, he got to know puddles REALLY well, at 100 MPH+! >Here's to Papy taking their lovely physics engine, modelling a Mk II >Escort RS 1800 BDA, and drawing the '76 RAC Rally!! >Cheers, >Matt_K,Norway (currently driving on STUDS!)
Quoted text (12 lines)> '76 rally season in a MkII !! - now that idea I like ... alot!! :-D > I rally (mostly tarmac though) a MKII with a non turbo Cossie motor, > BDA's > are too expensive!, so it would be fun to have a good sim of the same > thing - there certainly would be a lot of people with real world > experience > of them! > c'mon Papy ....like da man say "Just Do IT" > -Lindsay
You lucky devil! :) Does it sing in the forest like they used to? Still got the occasional BDA's flying through the norwegian woods - did some work on a Mk I with a 2.2 BDG in the workshop, just could not resist taking it for a spin round the block; it had plates, and it was late, so.....:)) Got a 2.0 Hart engine lurking now... Matt Knutsen
On Tue, 17 Nov 1998 15:36:03 -0500, "David G Fisher" >People here at r.a.s. have joked about what GPL with rain would be like but >really consider it for a moment. The real drivers of the past, which you can >see in film, still were able to race fairly controlled in the rain. What >would it be like for us? I see no reason to believe we wouldn't get the same demographics in the sim as you would het in real life (and indeed as you get in GPL in the dry). A small percentage would be blindingly quick, a larger bunch would be "there or thereabouts", those who could tame their right foot would get around the track and the remainder would have a nightmare. The thing is that in real life it's very obvious that the driver is at fault since the laws of physics can hardly be questioned. In a sim it's more appealing to question the interpretation of the physics than to consider the fact that one might be coordinationally challenged. Cheers! John
On Wed, 18 Nov 1998 00:58:56 +0100, Matthew Knutsen >In the IGPLC, we just had a league race at >Monaco. With realistic damage, and we ran 40 laps, that's over an hour. >Previously, I had done 5 laps at Monaco without damaging the car, in the >race I managed them all! The difference in people's approach to racing when realistic damage is enabled is very interesting. It really does become much easier to race since respect is forced upon people rather more quickly than it would be otherwise. Cheers! John

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy