Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Games Alliance review of GPL slightly better than Avaults.

14 posts by 7 people · 27 Oct 1998 - 27 Oct 1998

I didn't find it a particularly insightful review. The majority was rehashed PR material with the occasional subjective statement. I'm trying to figure out his logic on some of the final evaluations. For Graphics, he said "great", with a footnote saying 3dfx graphics were great and software rendering was horrible. For Control, however, he said "good", with a footnote saying control was good with keyboard, but great with joystick/wheel. ???????!!
Quoted text (31 lines)> Games Alliance review [link lost in import: /;rated] > it much better 75%, but still doesn't give the game justice. From reading > the review I get the distinct possibility that I have read most of this > information else where. Eg. Game Features, staight from the Papy site. > Finally a review that does take about the Multiplayer aspect. > "Since the car reacts to the throttle more than cars today it's easier to > spin out. This was the case for me, as I spent 20 minutes simply spinning > out, trying to get the hang of controlling the car." > The main reason why this is happening to him. > "Controlling the car using the keyboard takes times to get the hang of" > "Since GPL only supports 3Dfx and Rendition 3D acceleration, users with > other 3D cards will have to do with software rendering, which is > unfortunately, crap. This of course is only my opinion." > What type of *** site would let someone review Games without a 3DFX > card?????? > Ashley. > ---------------------------------------------------------------- > Ashley Clifford. > Sim Racing News - http://www.simnews.com/~accli/simnews > Melbourne, Australia. > Web: http://connexus.apana.org.au/~ashleyc > ----------------------------------------------------------------
Zonky 27 Oct 1998#430761
>"Since GPL only supports 3Dfx and Rendition 3D acceleration, users with >other 3D cards will have to do with software rendering, which is >unfortunately, crap. This of course is only my opinion." How is this not true? i think his comment says that software rendering in GPL is a joke, which we all know it is. Good to see an OpenGl (beta) patch has immerged. My read of the piece is that he was using hardware acceleration. Z
meij 27 Oct 1998#430762
Quoted text (20 lines)>Games Alliance review [link lost in import: /;rated] >it much better 75%, but still doesn't give the game justice. From reading >the review I get the distinct possibility that I have read most of this >information else where. Eg. Game Features, staight from the Papy site. >Finally a review that does take about the Multiplayer aspect. >"Since the car reacts to the throttle more than cars today it's easier to >spin out. This was the case for me, as I spent 20 minutes simply spinning >out, trying to get the hang of controlling the car." >The main reason why this is happening to him. >"Controlling the car using the keyboard takes times to get the hang of" >"Since GPL only supports 3Dfx and Rendition 3D acceleration, users with >other 3D cards will have to do with software rendering, which is >unfortunately, crap. This of course is only my opinion." >What type of *** site would let someone review Games without a 3DFX >card??????
I've had a fair bit of contact with GA and I know they wouldn't do this. He's probably tested it under all modes available to him as any good reviewer would. I've tried GPL in software even though I have 3dfx, just to see what it's like. M
Zonky 27 Oct 1998#430763
Quoted text (13 lines)>>"Since GPL only supports 3Dfx and Rendition 3D acceleration, users with >>other 3D cards will have to do with software rendering, which is >>unfortunately, crap. This of course is only my opinion." >>What type of *** site would let someone review Games without a 3DFX >>card?????? >I've had a fair bit of contact with GA and I know they wouldn't do this. He's >probably tested it under all modes available to him as any good reviewer >would. I've tried GPL in software even though I have 3dfx, just to see what >it's like. >M
M, and i'm sure you think that the software rendering mode is.. er... Crap? Z.
meij 27 Oct 1998#430764
>M, >and i'm sure you think that the software rendering mode is.. er... Crap? >Z. Z, I wouldn't say crap... just exactly what you'd expect. M
Zonky 27 Oct 1998#430765
Quoted text (11 lines)>>M, >>and i'm sure you think that the software rendering mode is.. er... Crap? >>Z. >Z, >I wouldn't say crap... just exactly what you'd expect. >M
I'm sure you've seen the Software mode in Shopgo, and must admit it's been scaled very well to allow it to be playable- maybe not pretty;) GPL software mode is simply unplayable, hence crap. Z.
meij 27 Oct 1998#430766
Quoted text (18 lines)>>>M, >>>and i'm sure you think that the software rendering mode is.. er... Crap? >>>Z. >>Z, >>I wouldn't say crap... just exactly what you'd expect. >>M >I'm sure you've seen the Software mode in Shopgo, and must admit it's been >scaled very well to allow it to be playable- maybe not pretty;) >GPL software mode is simply unplayable, hence crap. >Z.
Shogo is indeed ugly but it's playable. GPL is just about playable too... just not *as* playable. M
Zonky 27 Oct 1998#430767
Quoted text (11 lines)>On Tue, 27 Oct 1998 06:10:03 GMT, >>"Since the car reacts to the throttle more than cars today it's easier to >>spin out. This was the case for me, as I spent 20 minutes simply spinning >>out, trying to get the hang of controlling the car." >>The main reason why this is happening to him. >>"Controlling the car using the keyboard takes times to get the hang of"
Er, any particular reason while you left out the next part of that sentence? becuase it dispproves your point? ", however using a wheel does make the driving experience easier, and a lot more fun. " Granted, he could have assumed this, though i suspect it's fairly safe to say he raced this way. Or the people who slag of reviews based on fairly selective quotes, or who have not even read the damn thing? Z.
The problem was that he based his "control" rating on how well he could use the keyboard (with "great" for wheel/joystick in a footnote). He could have at least been consistent with his "graphics" rating - either both "good" with footnotes saying "great" for 3dfx/wheel/joystick, or "great" for both with footnotes reading "good" for software/keyboard. Of course, his "good" rating on software mode in the footnote doesn't really seem to follow from his comments in the body of the review itself where he stated it was "crap" - which is it? I felt his review was mediocre, not because he only gave the game 75 percent, but because he was inconsistent in his ratings and didn't give much justification for his conclusions. Just looking at his point-by-point rundown of the game, one would have expected a somewhat higher overall rating.
Quoted text (36 lines)> >On Tue, 27 Oct 1998 06:10:03 GMT, > >>"Since the car reacts to the throttle more than cars today it's easier to > >>spin out. This was the case for me, as I spent 20 minutes simply spinning > >>out, trying to get the hang of controlling the car." > >>The main reason why this is happening to him. > >>"Controlling the car using the keyboard takes times to get the hang of" > Er, any particular reason while you left out the next part of that sentence? > becuase it dispproves your point? > ", however using a wheel does make the driving experience easier, and a lot > more fun. " > Granted, he could have assumed this, though i suspect it's fairly safe to say > he raced this way. > >>"Since GPL only supports 3Dfx and Rendition 3D acceleration, users with > >>other 3D cards will have to do with software rendering, which is > >>unfortunately, crap. This of course is only my opinion." > >>What type of *** site would let someone review Games without a 3DFX > >>card?????? > >>Ashley. > >Or a joystick. Or a wheel. Unbelievable..... > Or the people who slag of reviews based on fairly selective quotes, or who > have not even read the damn thing? > Z.
ymenard 27 Oct 1998#430769
Zonker wrote What's Shopgo ? A Japanese grocery cart robot ? ;-) Im able to get 20fps with everytying off... But of course, we all have different opinions of what is ***;-) . It's still the same racing simulator for me. Im probably that hard-core to say that even if it had the Indy500:The Simulator graphics that would be enough for me ;-) I would say, "unacceptable for the current stade of ***". - Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard> Good race at the Brickyard! - Official Mentally retarded guy of r.a.s. - Excuse me for my English (I'm French speaking) - Sponsored by http://www.awpss.com/ - "People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."--
Zonky 27 Oct 1998#430770
>Path: >Zonker wrote >>I'm sure you've seen the Software mode in Shopgo, and must admit it's been >>scaled very well to allow it to be playable- maybe not pretty;) >What's Shopgo ? A Japanese grocery cart robot ? ;-) Yup, take your MCA down to the local Supermarket and by Mr Sparkle! Remember! For lucky best wash! use Mr Sparkle! Z.
Quoted text (13 lines)> >Path: > >Zonker wrote > >>I'm sure you've seen the Software mode in Shopgo, and must admit it's been > >>scaled very well to allow it to be playable- maybe not pretty;) > >What's Shopgo ? A Japanese grocery cart robot ? ;-) > Yup, take your MCA down to the local Supermarket and by Mr Sparkle! > Remember! > For lucky best wash! use Mr Sparkle!
LOL! I am disrespectful to dirt!
Joe McGinn 27 Oct 1998#430772
>"Controlling the car using the keyboard takes times to get the hang of" ROF,LMAO! Web game reviews: the clueless leading the cluless. Present company (i.e., Randy M.) excepted of course. Joe

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy