If Dennis Hulme got the pole at Kyalami in 1967 with a 1:28, then why is Jim
Clark getting the pole in GPL with a 1:21? I realize Clark wasn't driving a
Lotus at Kyalami, but.... How about other comparisons of real 1967 pole times
at other tracks with the times the pole sitters are getting in the simulation.
James
Jlarson88 wrote
simulation.
Kyalami is somehow in a different mood than the other tracks to talk about
this.
Most of us are on the low 1:20's and sub 1:20's are now starting to appear.
Remember our engines and tires are in perfect conditions and are at the top
performances.
At Kyalami, since it was the first race of the year, about all of them had
1966 car, chassis and motors. Remember that race was on January 2nd (Jan 4
maybe ?) that the race was held up. It was sooner from the 1966 season than
the 1967 (the next race was way up in May).
Hmm, if anybody can back me with the 1967 race report URL, you will see that
you shouldn't really compare real-life qual attempts at that track ;-) The
others you can, but this track is out of context somehow...
- Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard> Good race at the Brickyard!
- Official Mentally retarded guy of r.a.s.
- Excuse me for my English (I'm French speaking)
- Sponsored by http://www.awpss.com/ on the NROS
- "People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."--
Hence, the question: are the pole times in GPL realistic? The AI is
turning solid 1:22's in practice; J.Clark has the pole at 1:21.89. I'm
clocking along at a nice steady back-marker pace of 1:29. This is using
a Monza setup, but I can't *feel* where the car needs help. What are the
fast boyz running at Kayalami? Nice track -- very narrow entrances to
corners -- but frustrating as heck not being able to run with the pack.
Michael.
Quoted text (8 lines)
> Jack Brabham took the pole at Kylami in 1967 at 1:28.3 > Hulme 1:28.9 > Clark 1:29.0 > Rodriguez 1:29.1 > John Love 1:29.5 > Hulme had the fastest race lap at 1:29.9You seem to have a good point, but on the other hand, the actual racers
didn't have hour after hour to round the course under repeatable conditions
like we do. According to the manual they only had a few hours of
practice/setup time, and then the race. And perhaps more importantly,
they couldn't really drive on the edge like we can because they were risking
it all.
With weeks to practice, no expenses, and no penalty for mistakes, their
times certainly
would have been faster (wouldn't they)?
rob.
<snip>
I tell ya what..if I were in a race with real cars ect.,Id be as far on
the edge as possible..I guarantee ya real race drivers are! At least the
good ones :)
Jack Brabham took the pole at Kylami in 1967 at 1:28.3
Hulme 1:28.9
Clark 1:29.0
Rodriguez 1:29.1
John Love 1:29.5
Hulme had the fastest race lap at 1:29.9
MM
> If Dennis Hulme got the pole at Kyalami in 1967 with a 1:28, then why is Jim
> Clark getting the pole in GPL with a 1:21? I realize Clark wasn't driving a
> Lotus at Kyalami, but.... How about other comparisons of real 1967 pole times
> at other tracks with the times the pole sitters are getting in the simulation.
> James
According to Alison Hine's website, it was Hulme who got the pole (thanks to
Roman Harvst), but either way it illustrates my point: the fastest laps on
full grand prix mode in GPL at Kyalami are usually 1:21, not 1:29 like in
reality in 1967. I have laps faster than Hulme (low 1:26's), and I'm not that
good. I think a SIMULATOR ought to match reality, not EXCEED it, IMHO.
James
Quoted text (24 lines)
>Jack Brabham took the pole at Kylami in 1967 at 1:28.3 > Hulme 1:28.9 > Clark 1:29.0 > Rodriguez 1:29.1 > John Love 1:29.5 >Hulme had the fastest race lap at 1:29.9 >MM >> If Dennis Hulme got the pole at Kyalami in 1967 with a 1:28, then why is >Jim >> Clark getting the pole in GPL with a 1:21? I realize Clark wasn't driving >a >> Lotus at Kyalami, but.... How about other comparisons of real 1967 pole >times >> at other tracks with the times the pole sitters are getting in the >simulation. >> JamesQuoted text (20 lines)
>Jlarson88 wrote >>If Dennis Hulme got the pole at Kyalami in 1967 with a 1:28, then why is >Jim >>Clark getting the pole in GPL with a 1:21? I realize Clark wasn't driving >a >>Lotus at Kyalami, but.... How about other comparisons of real 1967 pole >times >>at other tracks with the times the pole sitters are getting in the >simulation. >Kyalami is somehow in a different mood than the other tracks to talk about >this. >Most of us are on the low 1:20's and sub 1:20's are now starting to appear. >Remember our engines and tires are in perfect conditions and are at the top >performances. >At Kyalami, since it was the first race of the year, about all of them had >1966 car, chassis and motors. Remember that race was on January 2nd (Jan 4 >maybe ?) that the race was held up. It was sooner from the 1966 seasonKen, Francois... you seem to be correct.
Kyalami '67 is below. It was the first race of the 3 litre formula.
Lots of mismatched motors and chassis, old chassis, old motors, etc.
etc.
I have checked a bunch of sources, I'll stand on the '67 pole times I
posted earlier. Even Allison misses one once in a while...
MM
1968 Grand Prix of South Africa
1 January - Kyalami: 328.32 km (4.104 km x 80
laps)
Pole positon: Jim Clark, Lotus-Ford, 1.21.6
Results:
1 Jim Clark Lotus-Ford 1:53:56.6 =
172.886 km/h
2 Graham Hill Lotus-Ford - 00:25.3
3 Jochen Rindt Brabham-Repco - 00:30.4
4 Chris Amon Ferrari - 2 laps
5 Denny Hulme McLaren-B.R.M. - 2 laps
6 Jean-Pierre Beltois Matra-Ford F2 - 3 laps
7 Jo Siffert Cooper-Maserati - 3 laps
8 John Surtees Honda - 5 laps
9 John Love Brabham-Repco - 5 laps
Not Classified:
Jackie Pretorius Brabham-Climax -10 laps
Fastest Lap: Jim Clark, Lotus-Ford, 1:23.7 = 176.516 km/h on lap 73
Retired:
Dan Gurney Eagle-Weslake 58 laps
Oil Leak
Jacky Ickx Ferrari 47 laps
Oil Pipe
Jo Bonnier Cooper-Maserati 47 laps
Overheating
Jackie Stewart Matra-Ford 44 laps
Engine
Sam Tingle L.D.S.-Repco 35 laps
Overheating
Basil van Rooyen Cooper-Climax 22 laps
Engine
Pedro Rodriguez B.R.M. 20 laps
Fuel Vaporization
Jack Brabham Brabham-Repco 17 laps
Engine
Andrea de Adamich Ferrari 14 laps
Accident
Mike Spence B.R.M. 8 laps
Fuel Vaporization
Brian Redman Cooper-Maserati 5 laps
Oil Leak
Dave Charlton Brabham-Repco 4 laps
Crown Wheel and Pinion
Ludovico Scarfiotti Cooper-Maserati 3 laps
Water Pipe
----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Starting Grid
Jim Clark Graham Hill
Jackie Stewart
Lotus 49-Ford Lotus 49-Ford
Matra MS9-Ford
1:21.6 1:22.6
1:22.7
Jochen Rindt Jack Brabham
Brabham BT24-Repco Brabham BT24-Repco
1:23.0 1:23.2
John Surtees Andrea de Adamich
Chris Amon
Honda RA300 Ferrari 312
Ferrari 312
1:23.5 1:23.6
1:23.8
Denny Hulme Pedro Rodriguez
McLaren M5A-B.R.M. B.R.M. P126
1:24.0 1:24.9
Jacky Ickx Dan Gurney
Mike Spence
Ferrari 312 Eagle AAR104-Weslake
B.R.M. P83
1:24.9 1:25.6
1:25.9
Dave Charlton Ludovico Scarfiotti
Brabham BT11-Repco Cooper T86-Maserati
1:26.2 1:26.3
Jo Siffert John Love
Jean-Pierre Beltoise
Cooper T81-Maserati Brabham BT20-Repco
Matra MS7-Cosworth
1:26.4 1:27.0
1:27.2
Jo Bonnier Basil van Rooyen
Cooper T81-Maserati Cooper T75-Climax
1:27.3 1:27.8
Brian Redman Sam Tingle
Jackie Pretorius
Cooper T81B-Maserati L.D.S. Mk5-Repco
Brabham BT7-Climax
1:28.0 1:28.6
1:29.0
1967 Grand Prix of South Africa
2 January - Kyalami: 327.52 km (4.094 km x 80
laps)
Pole positon: Jack Brabham, Brabham-Repco, 1.28.3
Results:
1 Pedro Rodriguez Cooper-Maserati 2:05:45.9 =
156.255 km/h
2 John Love Cooper-Climax - 00:26.4
3 John Surtees Honda - 1 lap
4 Denny Hulme Brabham-Repco - 2 laps
5 Bob Anderson Brabham-Climax - 2 laps
6 Jack Brabham Brabham-Repco - 4 laps
Not Classified:
Dave Charlton Brabham-Climax -17 laps
Luki Botha Brabham-Climax -20 laps
Fastest Lap: Denny Hulme, Brabham-Repco, 1:29.9 = 163.949 km/h on lap 3
Retired:
Sam Tingle L.D.S.-Climax 57 laps
Accident
Piers Courage Lotus-B.R.M. 52 laps
Fuel Line
Dan Gurney Eagle-Climax 45 laps
Rear Suspension
Jo Siffert Cooper-Maserati 42 laps
Engine
Jochen Rindt Cooper-Maserati 39 laps
Engine
Mike Spence B.R.M. 32 laps
Oil Pipe
Jo Bonnier Cooper-Maserati 31 laps
Engine
Jim Clark Lotus-B.R.M. 23 laps
Engine
Graham Hill Lotus-B.R.M. 7 laps
Accident
Jackie Stewart B.R.M 3 laps
Engine
--------------------------------------------------------------------
Starting Grid
Jack Brabham Denny Hulme
Brabham BT20-Repco Brabham BT20-Repco
1:28.3 1:28.9
Jim Clark Pedro Rodriguez
Lotus 43-B.R.M. Cooper T81-Maserati
1:29.0 1:29.1
John Love John Surtees
Cooper T79-Climax Honda RA273
1:29.5 1:29.6
Jochen Rindt Dave Charlton
Cooper T81-Maserati Brabham BT11-Climax
1:30.2 1:30.2
Jackie Stewart Bob Anderson
B.R.M. P83 Brabham BT11-Climax
1:30.3 1:30.6
Dan Gurney Jo Bonnier
Eagle AAR101-Climax Cooper T81-Maserati
1:30.7 1:31.8
Mike Spence Sam Tingle
B.R.M. P83 L.D.S. Mk3-Climax
1:32.1 1:32.4
Graham Hill Jo Siffert
Lotus 43-B.R.M. Cooper T81-Maserati
1:32.6 1:32.8
Luki Botha Piers Courage
Brabham BT11-Climax Lotus 25-B.R.M.
1:33.1 1:33.8
Ken Beard wrote:
Quoted text (35 lines)
> ymenard wrote in message <710i87$[email hidden]>... > >Jlarson88 wrote > >>If Dennis Hulme got the pole at Kyalami in 1967 with a 1:28, then why is > >Jim > >>Clark getting the pole in GPL with a 1:21? I realize Clark wasn't driving > >a > >>Lotus at Kyalami, but.... How about other comparisons of real 1967 pole > >times > >>at other tracks with the times the pole sitters are getting in the > >simulation. > >Kyalami is somehow in a different mood than the other tracks to talk about > >this. > >Most of us are on the low 1:20's and sub 1:20's are now starting to appear. > >Remember our engines and tires are in perfect conditions and are at the top > >performances. > >At Kyalami, since it was the first race of the year, about all of them had > >1966 car, chassis and motors. Remember that race was on January 2nd (Jan 4 > >maybe ?) that the race was held up. It was sooner from the 1966 season > than > >the 1967 (the next race was way up in May). > >Hmm, if anybody can back me with the 1967 race report URL, you will see > that > >you shouldn't really compare real-life qual attempts at that track ;-) The > >others you can, but this track is out of context somehow... > It'd be curious to see the 1968 results, assuming this was before they > started grafting wings, etc. on the cars (and that they ran here of course). > This would be more like the cars we're driving here, the ones from later in > the '67 season. > KenI agree with what you're saying, however, you can reverse things by saying that
the real life drivers had several years, decades, to prepare for every race
(since it was their livelihood), and they were truely the best in the world.
In that sense, a small amount of practice time before a race shouldn't make
them five or six seconds slower than somebody who's been driving this simulator
a couple of weeks, like we have.
Really, I'm just irritated that I can't forsee the possibility of ever winning
the race a Kyalami. I'm doomed to always come in 10th or 11th. :)
James
Quoted text (18 lines)
>You seem to have a good point, but on the other hand, the actual racers >didn't have hour after hour to round the course under repeatable conditions >like we do. According to the manual they only had a few hours of >practice/setup time, and then the race. And perhaps more importantly, >they couldn't really drive on the edge like we can because they were risking >it all. >With weeks to practice, no expenses, and no penalty for mistakes, their >times certainly >would have been faster (wouldn't they)? >rob. ><snip> >> I think a SIMULATOR ought to match reality, not EXCEED it, IMHO. >>JamesOne of our big problems in simulating the 1967 season was that the
technology continually evolved during the course of the year. Our
philosophy in choosing the cars we did was to model the "best" car each
manufacturer fielded that year. While it would have been very cool to
simulate the evolving technology in World Championship mode (i.e. if you
drove for Lotus you would have to drive a model 43 or 33 until Zandvoort -
when the 49 made its debut...), it was simply impractical for us to do so.
The extra artwork, physics, and QA time involved in modeling all of those
other cars would have set the project back by an unacceptable degree.
As a result of this design decision, we do indeed have some anachronisms in
the game, particularly at Kyalami. The 1967 South African Grand Prix took
place on January 2 - only 2 1/2 months after the last event of 1966.
Because of this, the vast majority of the starting field was comprised of
1966 cars. The works Brabhams were BT20's (while the privateers showed up
in BT11's), Lotus used the 43 (with a BRM engine), the Eagle did not use
the Weslake engine, and Ferrari didn't even bother to show up. The pole
time: 1:28.3 - by Jack Brabham in a BT20.
In order to make an "accurate" comparison of GPL vs. real-world lap times,
you really need to compare apples to apples - and in order to do this at
Kyalami, you need to look at the 1968 South African GP - not '67. The '68
race took place on 1/1 - again, about 2 months after the last event of the
previous year. The fastest cars were the "best" of the '67 season, and the
ones used in GPL: Lotus 49 (the 49B didn't show up until Monaco), Brabham
BT24, Ferrari 312, and Eagle/Weslake T1G. The pole time: 1:21.6 - by Jim
Clark in a Lotus 49.
Since the best GPL drivers out there seem to be doing 1:20 - 1:22 at
Kyalami, I think you'll find that the times at this track are quite
realistic indeed given the considerations detailed above. Granted, this
for the best in GPL vs. a 3:28 1967 pole time (in a Lotus 49), is probably
the most glaring example (although I did read one account of 1967 Belgian
GP qualifying in which Clark said that he thought a time "considerably
below 3:25" was possible given optimal conditions), but I certainly think
it gets us off the hook at Kyalami.
Richard Yasi
Senior Designer
Papyrus Design Group
> Hence, the question: are the pole times in GPL realistic? The AI is
> turning solid 1:22's in practice; J.Clark has the pole at 1:21.89. I'm
> clocking along at a nice steady back-marker pace of 1:29. This is using
> a Monza setup, but I can't *feel* where the car needs help. What are the
> fast boyz running at Kayalami? Nice track -- very narrow entrances to
> corners -- but frustrating as heck not being able to run with the pack.
My best GPL laps are at:
http://www.impactmotorsports.com/pd.html
--
Pat Dotson
IMPACT Motorsports
http://www.impactmotorsports.com/pd.html
Thanks for posting, Richard - on another topic, was any consideration given
to implementing the warm up loop at the Nurburgring? This would have enabled
a qualifying lap to start without doing an entire 9 minute lap.
I was reading a 1967 report of the German GP, and apparently on the Friday
quite a bit of time was spent circulating the loop before anyone wanted to
risk a full lap.
- Michael
what about just a crack to allow the car to start behing the start/finish line
so your initial lap is also timed?
Quoted text (9 lines)
> Thanks for posting, Richard - on another topic, was any consideration given > to implementing the warm up loop at the Nurburgring? This would have enabled > a qualifying lap to start without doing an entire 9 minute lap. > I was reading a 1967 report of the German GP, and apparently on the Friday > quite a bit of time was spent circulating the loop before anyone wanted to > risk a full lap. > - MichaelThat would be better than nothing, but your tyres would be stone cold.
- Michael
i can barely crack 10:00. tires are the LEAST of my problems!
Quoted text (7 lines)
> >what about just a crack to allow the car to start behing the start/finish > line > >so your initial lap is also timed? > That would be better than nothing, but your tyres would be stone cold. > - MichaelThis is definitely something I would like to see enabled in the future. The
9min warm-up lap is a killer; cross the line, breath a sign of relief, then
I lose it on the braking into the South Loop :(
Pete
> It'd be curious to see the 1968 results, assuming this was before they
> started grafting wings, etc. on the cars (and that they ran here of course).
> This would be more like the cars we're driving here, the ones from later in
> the '67 season.
Jim Clark got the pole in 1:21.61.He also won easily that race, his last grand
prix victory.
--
Massimo "Moro" Macagni


































