Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Celeron A vs Pentium II in GPL

12 posts by 9 people · 17 Oct 1998 - 21 Oct 1998

Anybody know if PII 512 kb of cache will be much better than 128 kb of Celeron A? Will I see 2, 5, 10 fps difference? 10x, Borut.
> Anybody know if PII 512 kb of cache will be much better than 128 kb of > Celeron A? Will I see 2, 5, 10 fps difference? > 10x, > Borut. The only time the cache size should come into play is with many programs running at once or if a system is transferring a gazillion files per second like a server. The small cache on the Celeron A (offset by the fact that it runs at processor speed, as opposed to half-processor speed as on the PII) runs games and standard apps without a performance hit. Source: www.tomshardware.com www.anandtech.com www.cyrellis.com www.cpumadness.com
rob 17 Oct 1998#428242
Also, you didn't specify anything else about the system. For instance, on earth could make the game run any faster because the video card is the weak link in the chain. In fact, I can play Unreal with practically equal frame rates in hardware and software modes! So don't blow a bunch of extra dough on a p2 rather than celeron if that leaves you without $$ for a voodoo 2. rob. >Anybody know if PII 512 kb of cache will be much better than 128 kb of >Celeron A? Will I see 2, 5, 10 fps difference? >10x, >Borut.
Actually the Celeron 300A is a little bit faster than P2 300 at running 3D games, see - www.tomshardware.com -. It's probably because of running the 128 kB cache at full speed and the fact that Celeron has the newer CPU core, Mendocino. The Celeron 300A is also very easily overclockable to 450 MHz were it beats the new P2 450 in 3d ***, but just with a little margin. See this NG for a Celeron FAQ. /Christer, have the Celeron 300A running at 450 MHz with original cooling device :o) > Anybody know if PII 512 kb of cache will be much better than 128 kb of > Celeron A? Will I see 2, 5, 10 fps difference? > 10x, > Borut. -- [link lost in import: /~w-41236/] (Read all about the "Global online racing"-proposal under "For developers". Read it a couple of times, cause noone has understood it the first time they've read it yet :o)).
Knudse 18 Oct 1998#428447
Read somewhere that GPL uses 2level cache quiet heavily. Dont remember where ... maybe one of the manuals. Knudse. .
Quoted text (14 lines)> > Anybody know if PII 512 kb of cache will be much better than 128 kb of > > Celeron A? Will I see 2, 5, 10 fps difference? > > 10x, > > Borut. > The only time the cache size should come into play is with many programs > running at once or if a system is transferring a gazillion files per > second like a server. > The small cache on the Celeron A (offset by the fact that it runs at > processor speed, as opposed to half-processor speed as on the PII) runs > games and standard apps without a performance hit.
Sorry, I have voodoo2 8 mb. I'm in beetwen Celeron 300A ( overclcking to 450 ) and the new Pentium II 300 ( if I can find one ) that is overclockable to 504 or something. Here in Slovenia it's like a bit more than 100 DM price difference ( cca. 60-70$ ). BOrut
Quoted text (18 lines)>Also, you didn't specify anything else about the system. For instance, >on earth could make the game run any faster because the video >card is the weak link in the chain. In fact, I can play Unreal with >practically equal frame rates in hardware and software modes! So >don't blow a bunch of extra dough on a p2 rather than celeron if >that leaves you without $$ for a voodoo 2. >rob. >>Anybody know if PII 512 kb of cache will be much better than 128 kb of >>Celeron A? Will I see 2, 5, 10 fps difference? >>10x, >>Borut.
Vampy 18 Oct 1998#428449
Actually, my Celeron 300a runs at 504 with extra cooling. This might sound stupid, but to test it on whether i could run it that high.. I left the windows open in my room overnight when the temp dropped to about 36 degrees F. I immediately changed my bios to 4.5x112 and lo and behold it started up at 504. Unfortunately I was having problems accessing my hard drive. For some strange reason when my floppy would do a seek, it locked up on it. Basically, what it looks like is not the CPU,memory,or motherboard... but possibly the I/O devices on my computer. I didn't wanna spend time tweaking it since 450 is easily reachable without any extra cooling. >Sorry, I have voodoo2 8 mb. I'm in beetwen Celeron 300A ( overclcking to >450 ) and the new Pentium II 300 ( if I can find one ) that is overclockable >to 504 or something. Here in Slovenia it's like a bit more than 100 DM price >difference ( cca. 60-70$ ). >BOrut
Dave Henrie 18 Oct 1998#428450
Quoted text (9 lines)>Also, you didn't specify anything else about the system. For instance, >on earth could make the game run any faster because the video >card is the weak link in the chain. In fact, I can play Unreal with >practically equal frame rates in hardware and software modes! So >don't blow a bunch of extra dough on a p2 rather than celeron if >that leaves you without $$ for a voodoo 2. >rob.
keep in mind that many users have reported the 8meg V2200 cards are giving slightly better framerates than even 2 Voodoo2 cards in sli. also remember that Rendition is working on a 3rd generation chip that is supposed to be faster than the new Riva TnT chip and has the Renditiion vid quality to boot. We'll see ....If GPL is your focus, you may want to consider a Hercules or other brand V2200 card for the time being..8 meg is almost mandatory.... dave henrie >>Anybody know if PII 512 kb of cache will be much better than 128 kb of >>Celeron A? Will I see 2, 5, 10 fps difference? >>10x, >>Borut.
Jarrod Smit 20 Oct 1998#428993
>Read somewhere that GPL uses 2level cache quiet heavily. >Dont remember where ... maybe one of the manuals. Well, the way you've written that, it could mean one of two things: 1) 128K is enough to hold the data that the GPL code works on without too many cache misses. The CeleronA will be faster than the PII, because its cache is running at twice the speed. or... 2) 128K isn't enough to fit the data that the GPL code needs. The PII will be faster than the CeleronA because while PII cache is slower, it's also larger, which means there will be significantly fewer cache misses. A smaller cache doesn't necessarily mean the CPU will run slower in cache-intensive apps. If the data will fit in the smaller, faster cache, then the it will win. If not, the bigger, slower one will. Which is it? I don't know. Someone will have to benchmark it. Jarrod Smith The Scripps Research Institute http://www.scripps.edu/~jsmith .
Quoted text (14 lines)> > Anybody know if PII 512 kb of cache will be much better than 128 kb of > > Celeron A? Will I see 2, 5, 10 fps difference? > > 10x, > > Borut. > The only time the cache size should come into play is with many programs > running at once or if a system is transferring a gazillion files per > second like a server. > The small cache on the Celeron A (offset by the fact that it runs at > processor speed, as opposed to half-processor speed as on the PII) runs > games and standard apps without a performance hit.
J 21 Oct 1998#429267
Hi rob, I'm also going for this setup. Have a Voodoo I and will change my mobo. What GPL-preformance can I expect? Thanks in advance Jens >on earth could make the game run any faster because the video >card is the weak link in the chain. --------------------------------------------- Remove "NOSPAM" before using my email-address
Vampy 21 Oct 1998#429268
Well... I have a Celeron 300a running at 464MHz, 128MB PC100 Ram, and a Diamond Monster 3D 1 card. With EVERYTHING turned up.. including a full field of 19 cars and 640x480 res, I get an easy 35 FPS while driving during training.. no matter what. It's about 30 FPS at 800x600 while driving training mode. During a race, at 640x480... when I pull out of the pit lane first session and all cars.. FPS drop to about 12 FPS.. once I get away from all the cars it goes back up in the low 30's. At the starting grid of the actual race session.... FPS is about 12 FPS. How does this compare?? Well.. on my 200mmx with 64 MB RAM and the same Voodoo 1 card. Everywhere that I stated above that had 12 FPS was about 3-4 FPS before (all settings the same). Where I was getting the 30s FPS was around 18-23 FPS on my 200mmx. I know it's not exact and all.. most of this testing was done on the Monza track with the Ferrari as my car (oh yeah.. my sound channels were set to 4 on my AWE 64 Gold... I've noticed that turning it up higher doesn't have any effect on gameplay but has a HUGE effect on performance.. really slows it down)
Jarrod Smit 21 Oct 1998#429269
I've noticed this in certain games, too. High quality audio on an ISA AWE card costs big in the performance dept., while not giving much increase in the enjoyability of the game. Time to go for a PCI 3D audio card, I guess :-) Jarrod Smith The Scripps Research Institute http://www.scripps.edu/~jsmith

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy