Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

GPL vs F1RS - There's something wrong here.

9 posts by 8 people · 09 Oct 1998 - 13 Oct 1998

dbon.. 09 Oct 1998#426077
Now I know GPL has better graphics than F1RS, but F1RS is certainly no slouch with very good graphics in it's own right. Now my problem with GPL is the fact that with graphics that are only marginally better than F1RS, why the heck does it need to run like a dog compared to F1RS on a comparable computer. With 22 cars in F1RS it's super smooth, much more smoother than GPL with only 19 cars on the track. And don't tell me that it's the fact that the "far superior" AI in GPL is the reason why it takes so much more computer power. In my mind, F1RS's AI is very good and not far off GPL's. For everything that GPL is, it does a major poor job of running on a computer. Come on Sierra, you can do better than that! PS: You would think Sierra manufactures computer equipment.
Adam 09 Oct 1998#426078
the reason why it takes so >much more computer power. It's the fact that the "far superior" AI in GPL is the reason why it takes so much more computer power.
In my mind, F1RS's AI F1Rs AI cars are a joke.They don't obbey physics laws.You can feel this clearly when racing in the rain.AI cars run at impossible speeds on certain turns,like on the stadium complex in hockenhein. AI being agressive is not bumping at your rear when you brake at the right point and simply there's no place to be overtaken. this message should have been posted on rec.auto jokes Rafael
Grant Reeve 10 Oct 1998#426361
Quoted text (12 lines)> Now I know GPL has better graphics than F1RS, but F1RS is certainly no > slouch with very good graphics in it's own right. Now my problem with > GPL is the fact that with graphics that are only marginally better > than F1RS, why the heck does it need to run like a dog compared to > F1RS on a comparable computer. With 22 cars in F1RS it's super smooth, > much more smoother than GPL with only 19 cars on the track. And don't > tell me that it's the fact that the "far superior" AI in GPL is the > reason why it takes so much more computer power. In my mind, F1RS's AI > is very good and not far off GPL's. > For everything that GPL is, it does a major poor job of running on a > computer. Come on Sierra, you can do better than that!
the difference? the difference is in the simulation of the car's physics. Sure, GPL has more advanced AI, but the AI routines themselves don't really take up all that much CPU at all - it's the physics of modelling each car that sucks up lots of CPU time. F1RS has pretty simplistic physics which is why it can run so many cars without impacting the framerate much at all, while GPL has much more advanced physics requiring significantly more processing power.
It's not, actually. It's the extremes of physics modelling that takes the CPU poer. > >And don't tell me that it's the fact that the "far superior" AI in GPL is > the reason why it takes so >much more computer power. > It's the fact that the "far superior" AI in GPL is the reason why it takes > so much more computer power. -- Regards, Bruce. ----------
ttam 10 Oct 1998#426363
>AI being agressive is not bumping at your rear when you brake at the right >point and simply there's no place to be overtaken. So M Schumacher was not aggressive when he bumped Coulthard's rear? ;^)
Quoted text (9 lines)>Now I know GPL has better graphics than F1RS, but F1RS is certainly no >slouch with very good graphics in it's own right. Now my problem with >GPL is the fact that with graphics that are only marginally better >than F1RS, why the heck does it need to run like a dog compared to >F1RS on a comparable computer. With 22 cars in F1RS it's super smooth, >much more smoother than GPL with only 19 cars on the track. And don't >tell me that it's the fact that the "far superior" AI in GPL is the >reason why it takes so much more computer power. In my mind, F1RS's AI >is very good and not far off GPL's.
Two reasons. One is that GPL models _vastly_ more of the car than F1RS does, and runs it's physics engine several times faster as well. On top of that, in almost every sim I've seen the AI follow a set of predetermined lines at predetermined speeds, following some rules to overtake or avoid other cars. The GPL AI cars obey physics also, so it's not just one car the calculations are done for, it is up to twenty! When you take that into account you can see GPL is actually very highly optimised given what it is doing. Cheers! John
>>AI being agressive is not bumping at your rear when you brake at the right >>point and simply there's no place to be overtaken. >So M Schumacher was not aggressive when he bumped Coulthard's rear? >;^) No,he was just as stupid as F1RS AI cars .And just because his "agressiveness" on that race,today he would be in a much better position to win the championship. Rafael
Jo Helsen 13 Oct 1998#427295
Interesting info. But with my critical mind, I immediately get to this next question: is this really NECESSARY???? Does it really matter? Wouldn't it have been faster and just marginally less sophisticated to simplify the AI cars? Would anyone notice? I don't own GPL, so I don't know. Just a hypothetical question. JoH Please remove *anti-spam* from the email when replying. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-= When everything else failed, we can still become im- mortal by making an enormous blunder.... John Kenneth Galbraith =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy