Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

grass in GPL: realistic?

19 posts by 18 people · 05 Oct 1998 - 09 Oct 1998

Well, at Zandvoort I know that it's 50% sand, so it's not that slippery! But normal grass is hard to drive on! So don't try that at home :-) Bart
Bill Mette 06 Oct 1998#425194
The grass in GPL is roughly equal to driving on ice. To me, it seems almost too slippery. However, I have no experience in a real race car. I know there's a few of you in this ng that have actually raced. If you have, please let us know how it compares. Also, it almost seems like the grass is slicker than the loose dirt. I routinely drop a wheel into the dirt at Kyalami with no ill effects. But if I just barely touch grass, whammo, I'm going in circles. I can think of arguments both for and against this, but I have no real experince to make a judgement here either. -Bill -- Bill Mette | "A person is smart. People are dumb." MCSNet, Chicago | - K MiB
Marty U'Ren 06 Oct 1998#425195
Trust me, there is almost nothing as slippery as grass. Marty
Quoted text (16 lines)> The grass in GPL is roughly equal to driving on ice. To me, it > seems > almost too slippery. However, I have no experience in a real race > car. I > know there's a few of you in this ng that have actually raced. If you > have, please let us know how it compares. > Also, it almost seems like the grass is slicker than the loose > dirt. I > routinely drop a wheel into the dirt at Kyalami with no ill effects. > But > if I just barely touch grass, whammo, I'm going in circles. I can > think > of arguments both for and against this, but I have no real experince > to > make a judgement here either.
B. Farme 06 Oct 1998#425196
Quoted text (11 lines)> The grass in GPL is roughly equal to driving on ice. To me, it seems >almost too slippery. However, I have no experience in a real race car. I >know there's a few of you in this ng that have actually raced. If you >have, please let us know how it compares. > Also, it almost seems like the grass is slicker than the loose dirt. I >routinely drop a wheel into the dirt at Kyalami with no ill effects. But >if I just barely touch grass, whammo, I'm going in circles. I can think >of arguments both for and against this, but I have no real experince to >make a judgement here either. >-Bill
It's been a few years(let's see... '98 - '73... ouch!), but grass is slippery as snot when you're at (or near)the edge while cornering. Raced a FF(Formula Ford) for 3 yrs in the Midwest at tracks like Gratton Mich., S. Beloit, Ill.(Blackhawk Farms), & State Fair Park(Milwaukee Mile, but we used only part of the oval, the rest was an infield circuit). Even got to try a race at Elkhart Lake, Wis., but only practiced(engine probs). Plain dirt wasn't as bad, 'cause you dug in a little, instead of just planing across the grass (yeah, I did that alot at first, & never really got good enough to not do it at all). Also, I noticed that if the grass adjoining the track was higher than the pavement, it wasn't nearly as bad as when the grass was lower (almost all newer pavement surfaces were higher than the grass), sorta like a berm in motocross. Wonder if Papy modeled the difference? Personal observation: The car I had, a Lola (202 I think), was built in 1969, & was very similar to the cars in GPL(only about 115 hp, tho), no wings, etc. & Papyrus has done an amazing job recreating the feel of a race car. For those who complain about how difficult the game is, remember that racing is not easy, & the feeling of satisfaction one gets from finally getting just one turn right, is worth all the time & effort spent just to get there. Brian (remove ns to reply)
> Trust me, there is almost nothing as slippery as grass. > Marty Wet grass? :) Gian Vitzthum
=rez 06 Oct 1998#425198
I would agree that the grass always seems wet! My main beef, however, is that traction with 2 wheels still on the pavement is not as good as it should be... It should be possible to 'save' a spin when putting 1 or 2 wheels off by using very sensitive input of throttle and steering to get the car settled and back on the track, as in real life situations.. =rez=
Quoted text (14 lines)> The grass in GPL is roughly equal to driving on ice. To me, it seems >almost too slippery. However, I have no experience in a real race car. I >know there's a few of you in this ng that have actually raced. If you >have, please let us know how it compares. > Also, it almost seems like the grass is slicker than the loose dirt. I >routinely drop a wheel into the dirt at Kyalami with no ill effects. But >if I just barely touch grass, whammo, I'm going in circles. I can think >of arguments both for and against this, but I have no real experince to >make a judgement here either. >-Bill >-- >Bill Mette | "A person is smart. People are dumb." >MCSNet, Chicago | - K MiB
You CAN do this, quite easily (I am not so good a driver that I haven't lots of opportunity to try it!!). I think the traction differences of the various surfaces (asphalt, grass, gravel traps, sandy grass, etc.) are phenomenally well done. If you truly want slippery grass, try CART:PR. Its grass is like ice with a very slight snow covering. If you want grass like glue, try pre 1.09 F1RS. If you want grass like slightly hardened glue, try F1RS 1.09. GPL has the best off-road traction simulation yet...by far. Marc. >I would agree that the grass always seems wet! >My main beef, however, is that traction with 2 wheels still on the pavement >is not as good as it should be... It should be possible to 'save' a spin >when putting 1 or 2 wheels off by using very sensitive input of throttle and
Quoted text (21 lines)>steering to get the car settled and back on the track, as in real life >situations.. >=rez= >> The grass in GPL is roughly equal to driving on ice. To me, it seems >>almost too slippery. However, I have no experience in a real race car. I >>know there's a few of you in this ng that have actually raced. If you >>have, please let us know how it compares. >> Also, it almost seems like the grass is slicker than the loose dirt. I >>routinely drop a wheel into the dirt at Kyalami with no ill effects. But >>if I just barely touch grass, whammo, I'm going in circles. I can think >>of arguments both for and against this, but I have no real experince to >>make a judgement here either. >>-Bill >>-- >>Bill Mette | "A person is smart. People are dumb." >>MCSNet, Chicago | - K MiB
Pat Dotson 06 Oct 1998#425200
Quoted text (18 lines)> You CAN do this, quite easily (I am not so good a driver that I haven't lots > of opportunity to try it!!). I think the traction differences of the > various surfaces (asphalt, grass, gravel traps, sandy grass, etc.) are > phenomenally well done. If you truly want slippery grass, try CART:PR. Its > grass is like ice with a very slight snow covering. If you want grass like > glue, try pre 1.09 F1RS. If you want grass like slightly hardened glue, try > F1RS 1.09. GPL has the best off-road traction simulation yet...by far. > >I would agree that the grass always seems wet! > >My main beef, however, is that traction with 2 wheels still on the pavement > >is not as good as it should be... It should be possible to 'save' a spin > >when putting 1 or 2 wheels off by using very sensitive input of throttle > and > >steering to get the car settled and back on the track, as in real life > >situations..
Finding a more forgiving setting for the ramp angles and clutches will make it easier to avoid spinning in this situation. -- Pat Dotson IMPACT Motorsports http://www.impactmotorsports.com/pd.html
% I would agree that the grass always seems wet! % My main beef, however, is that traction with 2 wheels still on the pavement % is not as good as it should be... It should be possible to 'save' a spin % when putting 1 or 2 wheels off by using very sensitive input of throttle and % steering to get the car settled and back on the track, as in real life % situations.. It's been my experience in GPL, that this is possible, but you can't breath while attempting it. But, you have to be sensitive in your "output" of throttle not input. Let up ever so slightly so as not to get more grip from the wheels on the track (which will then spin you around). The not breathing part is to keep from turning the wheel too much as you "will" the car back on the track. -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Jef 07 Oct 1998#425478
> > Trust me, there is almost nothing as slippery as grass. > > Marty > Wet grass? :) Grass with frost on it? :)
The thing is with those cars, that the engine puts the power to the wheel with the least resistence. So if one wheel is on the grass and the other is on the pavement, almost all power is suddenly moved to the wheel on the grass, thus causing you to spin. // Johan
Quoted text (9 lines)> I would agree that the grass always seems wet! > My main beef, however, is that traction with 2 wheels still on the pavement > is not as good as it should be... It should be possible to 'save' a spin > when putting 1 or 2 wheels off by using very sensitive input of throttle and > steering to get the car settled and back on the track, as in real life > situations.. > =rez=
Raev 07 Oct 1998#425480
It seems to me that the grass is more forgiving in GPL than in say, GP2, where touching a tire off is notorious for forcing you into a spin. In GPL I've actually been able to wildly go off the track onto the grass and then recover,, which is a nice change. It is slippery, don't get me wrong,,,,but it seems like it's done much better. Rae
Richard Cow 07 Oct 1998#425481
writes I do not have GPL yet ( I'm in the UK ) but I do have lots of experience of driving on grass because I live on a dairy farm! To get to the point. Yes, grass is VERY slippery, usually more so than loose dirt, not quite as bad as ice though. Your observations in GPL are consistant with real life, I think. Can't wait to confirm this myself! -- Richard Cowl
LLam5559 08 Oct 1998#425773
Quoted text (14 lines)> The grass in GPL is roughly equal to driving on ice. To me, it seems >almost too slippery. However, I have no experience in a real race car. I >know there's a few of you in this ng that have actually raced. If you >have, please let us know how it compares. > Also, it almost seems like the grass is slicker than the loose dirt. I >routinely drop a wheel into the dirt at Kyalami with no ill effects. But >if I just barely touch grass, whammo, I'm going in circles. I can think >of arguments both for and against this, but I have no real experince to >make a judgement here either. >-Bill >-- >Bill Mette | "A person is smart. People are dumb." >MCSNet, Chicago | - K MiB
Well I've never done any racing, so I probably don't know, but I do have a thought... 1st, you've got all these blades which are fairly slippery to begin with. 2nd, they are filled with water. When the tires hit the grass & spin, this ruptures the cells & tears up the blades, releasing that water all over the place. It gets on the tires, on the ground, & makes things even more slippery. Then there's the torn-up bits of loose grass on the ground & sticking to the tires. Not exactly ideal for traction... I'm not saying this is simulated in the game, just that that's what happens if you spin your tires on real grass. I rode dirt bikes as a ***ager, and I could go a hell of a lot faster on loose dirt than on fresh grass. Lee Remove the "X" to email
I agree. I think there's two basic factors with grass as a contact surface, or with any surface for that matter. They are grip and resistance. Grass is high resistance low grip and asphalt is low resistance high grip. Gp2 IMO overplays grass's resistance way too much. So that when you're half on grass and half on asphalt the resulting rotational forces are too great. You shouldn't be ***ly rotated towards the grass simply because you've touched one sides' wheels on it. To some extent yes but Gp2 is too much. In Gp2 if you get half on the grass you must lift off the acelerator fast and turn more towrds the grass run-off area to minimise the rotaional forces. Once you're fully on the grass its actually a bit easier to control than when half on and half off. GPL feels better than Gp2 in this respect IMHO. Phillip McNelley.
Quoted text (10 lines)>> The grass in GPL is roughly equal to driving on ice. >It seems to me that the grass is more forgiving in GPL than in say, >GP2, where touching a tire off is notorious for forcing you into a >spin. In GPL I've actually been able to wildly go off the track onto >the grass and then recover,, which is a nice change. >It is slippery, don't get me wrong,,,,but it seems like it's done much >better. >Rae
Robert 08 Oct 1998#425775
Sierra has made this game so realistic that you actually have to mow the grass! :-P
Bill Mette 08 Oct 1998#425776
So that's what those storage shacks next to the track are for!
Quoted text (10 lines)>Sierra has made this game so realistic that you actually have to mow >the grass! :-P >> The grass in GPL is roughly equal to driving on ice. To me, it seems >>almost too slippery. However, I have no experience in a real race car. I >>know there's a few of you in this ng that have actually raced. If you >>have, please let us know how it compares.
-- Bill Mette | "A person is smart. People are dumb." MCSNet, Chicago | - K MiB
Yeah, but the Lawn Mower companies wanted too much for the licenses so no lawn mowers were included :((((
Quoted text (19 lines)> So that's what those storage shacks next to the track are for! > >Sierra has made this game so realistic that you actually have to mow > >the grass! :-P > >> The grass in GPL is roughly equal to driving on ice. To me, it seems > >>almost too slippery. However, I have no experience in a real race car. I > >>know there's a few of you in this ng that have actually raced. If you > >>have, please let us know how it compares. > -- > Bill Mette | "A person is smart. People are dumb." > MCSNet, Chicago | - K MiB
-- Byron Forbes Captain of Team Lightning Bolt http://members.tripod.com/~HOSHUMUNGUS and http://www.frontiernet.net/~godsoe/bolt/home.htm
Marc 09 Oct 1998#426043
Quoted text (9 lines)> You CAN do this, quite easily (I am not so good a driver that I haven't lots > of opportunity to try it!!). I think the traction differences of the > various surfaces (asphalt, grass, gravel traps, sandy grass, etc.) are > phenomenally well done. If you truly want slippery grass, try CART:PR. Its > grass is like ice with a very slight snow covering. If you want grass like > glue, try pre 1.09 F1RS. If you want grass like slightly hardened glue, try > F1RS 1.09. GPL has the best off-road traction simulation yet...by far. > Marc.
It has to, I am there the most :-).
Quoted text (27 lines)> >I would agree that the grass always seems wet! > >My main beef, however, is that traction with 2 wheels still on the pavement > >is not as good as it should be... It should be possible to 'save' a spin > >when putting 1 or 2 wheels off by using very sensitive input of throttle > and > >steering to get the car settled and back on the track, as in real life > >situations.. > >=rez= > >> The grass in GPL is roughly equal to driving on ice. To me, it seems > >>almost too slippery. However, I have no experience in a real race car. I > >>know there's a few of you in this ng that have actually raced. If you > >>have, please let us know how it compares. > >> Also, it almost seems like the grass is slicker than the loose dirt. I > >>routinely drop a wheel into the dirt at Kyalami with no ill effects. But > >>if I just barely touch grass, whammo, I'm going in circles. I can think > >>of arguments both for and against this, but I have no real experince to > >>make a judgement here either. > >>-Bill > >>-- > >>Bill Mette | "A person is smart. People are dumb." > >>MCSNet, Chicago | - K MiB
-- Thank You Marc Johnson Outside of a dog, a book is a mans best friend. Inside of a dog, it is too dark to read -Groucho Marx

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy