Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

GPL is HARD!!!

50 posts by 28 people · 01 Oct 1998 - 12 Oct 1998

GPL is hard: tips and the throttle-brake axis debate

A player found GPL very hard even on novice. Jim Sokolov said smooth inputs and less throttle were key, and others advised practice, starting slowly, lighter fuel loads and Alison Hine's tip of starting in the 200hp trainer cars. A long side debate covered why separate throttle and brake axes matter, since a combined axis cannot register both pedals at once.

setup/driving techniquehardware: wheels/pedalsGrand Prix Legends

Automated summary.

Vam 01 Oct 1998#423399
I know it has been said before but GPL is really hard. At novice setting I have a tough time staying on the track. Never mid even trying to keep up with the other cars. I find that even on the straights I can at best only keep up with them. I would have assumed that at novice setting I might have a little more power. Any suggestions? I like the fact that it is hard but I think it may be so hard that I'm not sure I'll ever get good enough to even be competitive. Vamp
dafn 01 Oct 1998#423400
Agreed . I am even thinking about getting a wheel for this sim. Never needed one with the Indycar , Narcar for f1rs series. I wonder if it would make this any easier?
Quoted text (9 lines)>I know it has been said before but GPL is really hard. At novice setting >I have a tough time staying on the track. Never mid even trying to keep >up with the other cars. I find that even on the straights I can at best >only keep up with them. I would have assumed that at novice setting I >might have a little more power. Any suggestions? I like the fact that it >is hard but I think it may be so hard that I'm not sure I'll ever get >good enough to even be competitive. >Vamp
Jim Sokolo 01 Oct 1998#423401
> I know it has been said before but GPL is really hard. At novice > setting I have a tough time staying on the track. Never mid even > trying to keep up with the other cars. I find that even on the > straights I can at best only keep up with them. I would have assumed > that at novice setting I might have a little more power. Any > suggestions? What you probably need is LESS power. :-) This is not a full-throttle/no-throttle game; smooth control inputs (and often, using less than full power) is the order of the day. ---Jim
P Gagg 01 Oct 1998#423402
> I know it has been said before but GPL is really hard. At novice > setting I have a tough time staying on the track. Never mid even > trying to keep up with the other cars. I find that even on the > straights I can at best only keep up with them. I would have > assumed that at novice setting I might have a little more power. > Any suggestions? 1) Practice. 2) If you don't already have one get a wheel and pedal set-up. 3) Practice some more. 4) Memorise the circuits by heart so you know whats coming (anticipation). 5) Practice some more. 6) Start off slowly and gradually build up your speed, not the other way around. 7) Practice some more. 8) Memorise how the car reacts, so you know what to expect when you brake, turn, etc. 9) Practice some more. 10) Watch other peoples replays, you can learn a lot from these? 11) Practice some more. 12) Read the manual, this can usually help, its surprising how many people don't bother to read this important document! 13) Finally, did I mention practice? 8-) *Peter* 8-) (NB: remove asterix to e-mail)
rob 01 Oct 1998#423403
That's an interesting one. I've wondered sometimes if it's better to start off fast and work on consistency, or start consistent and work on speed. Would you mind explaining the advantage of the latter? rob. <snip>
x.. 01 Oct 1998#423404
Quoted text (9 lines)>I know it has been said before but GPL is really hard. At novice setting >I have a tough time staying on the track. Never mid even trying to keep >up with the other cars. I find that even on the straights I can at best >only keep up with them. I would have assumed that at novice setting I >might have a little more power. Any suggestions? I like the fact that it >is hard but I think it may be so hard that I'm not sure I'll ever get >good enough to even be competitive. >Vamp
Vamp, The first time I played a Single Race at the Novice setting I came in last and could hardly stay on the track. But here is a tip that might help you: alter the default car setup by only putting in enough gas for the race. This reduces the weight of the car - it makes a lot of difference. Also, I'd start with the Monza track. enjoy...
Grant Reeve 02 Oct 1998#423759
><snip> er, you didn't emphasise practice enough! So i'll continue the list for you :) 14) Practice! 15) Practice! 16) Practice! . . . 22843) Practice! . . . ad infinitum
LLam5559 02 Oct 1998#423760
Yeah, it's hard!! That's what I like about it! I don't have the final yet (heading to Elbo tomorrow) but I've been playing the CGW demo for a while now. The thing to remember is the game simulates technology that's 30+ years old. No wings, no aerodynamics, no ground-effects packages to keep you stuck to the track in the curves. Plus you're racing on narrow, high-profile treaded tires that have more in common with the tires on your family car than those on a modern race car. From what I've found running practice laps in the demo, you gotta pretend you've got eggs strapped on the pedals. Smooth & easy does it. Just a little too much throttle coming out of a turn & I'm doing 360's down the track! Same thing if I'm braking too long into a turn, I'll spin off every time. So, learn the tracks inside out, have all your moves thought out before you make them, and do everything SMOOTHLY. Jerkiness or suddenness will get you in trouble. Don't worry if you lose. You'll lose a lot. Then, if you keep at it you'll start winning. And winning. And winning. Lee
Ed Benson 02 Oct 1998#423761
Umm, you don't spend as much time admiring the track from the sandtraps? > That's an interesting one. I've wondered sometimes if it's better > to start off fast and work on consistency, or start consistent and > work on speed. Would you mind explaining the advantage of the > latter? > rob.
You all forgot the most impotant issue, HAVE FUN!!!!!! Don't be bothered by the fact that you can't win the first 5, 10, 50, etc.(?) races. Just be proud if you break your personal record. Even if that just means you made it to the second lap. // Johan
Quoted text (16 lines)> ><snip> > er, you didn't emphasise practice enough! So i'll continue the list > for you :) > 14) Practice! > 15) Practice! > 16) Practice! > . > . > . > 22843) Practice! > . > . > . > ad infinitum
Remco Moedt 02 Oct 1998#423763
>You all forgot the most impotant issue, HAVE FUN!!!!!! Hmmmmm.......:-\ What's wrong here? Remco
heheh, talk about a BAD typo :-) >>You all forgot the most impotant issue, HAVE FUN!!!!!! >Hmmmmm.......:-\ What's wrong here? >Remco
% Agreed . I am even thinking about getting a wheel for this % sim. Never needed one with the Indycar , Narcar for f1rs series. I % wonder if it would make this any easier? Actually what is more important than the "wheel" are analog pedals. If you are trying to "drive" GPL with digital (on/off) breake and accelerator, you are indeed in for a long haul. While you are at it look for pedal setup that will allow for the brake and accelerater to be on separate axes. -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
LLam5559 03 Oct 1998#424113
Quoted text (15 lines)>% Agreed . I am even thinking about getting a wheel for this >% sim. Never needed one with the Indycar , Narcar for f1rs series. I >% wonder if it would make this any easier? >Actually what is more important than the "wheel" are analog pedals. If >you are trying to "drive" GPL with digital (on/off) breake and >accelerator, you are indeed in for a long haul. While you are at it >look for pedal setup that will allow for the brake and accelerater to be >on separate axes. >-- >**************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* > Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. >=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
You mean gas & breaks via keyboard? <gasp> I'm using my Thrustmaster Elite rudder pedals (I'm also a flightsim freak) which are digital I believe, they do quite nicely. And the Thrustmaster joystick for steering tho I'm a *little* less satisfied with that. I've got an ancient Thrustmaster Formula T1 wheel & pedals but I haven't use it yet, I hate the pedals. They're too stiff for me, they've got these big rollers your feet go on which I don't like, & they're too close together. With a foot on the gas & one over the brakes my knees bang together :( What I'd *like* to do is hook up my Thrustmaster wheel to my Thrustmaster rudder pedals. But I bet that won't work. Anyone know if that could be made to work? Lee
P Gagg 03 Oct 1998#424114
Most people get a new racing game/sim and jump straight in with both feet and immediately try to break all known lap records at the first attempt without even glancing at the manual!!!! This usually results in lots of unscheduled *off-road* driving admiring the scenery when you should in fact be on the track practicing. This is caused because the drivers have not learnt how to control the car, not learnt the circuits, and they are driving *TOO FAST* and end up continually crashing. This in turn dents confidence, and can get very annoying? and you do not learn that much from continually crashing (apart from where the barriers are situated? and how slow it is to get out of the gravel trap?) The more conservative approach (driving slower and gradually building up speed) will ultimately be more beneficial (IMHO?) because of many reasons... 1) Driving slower gives you more time to react. 2) You can see & learn the correct racing line easier at lower speeds. 3) Car control is easier at lower speeds. 4) You will crash less at lower speeds. 5) If you crash less your confidence will rise. 6) Remembering circuits is easier at lower speeds. My method for a new game/sim is to take a few laps to just drive around the circuit, not fast at all, to familiarise myself with the general layout. (Also check out any maps or diagrams in the manual, etc). Then try some faster laps, but the object is to just try and stay on the track without spinning/crashing off. Once I can do this consistently (I have learnt to anticipate the corners and bends) I start to gradually increase speed and try to lower my laptimes, but the emphasis is on gradually. As you gradually drive more laps, you get more familiar with the circuit, and can anticipate better, try to go faster on the straights on each lap by accelerating out of corners earlier. also try to brake into corners a little bit later on each lap. Each lap you are only trying to improve on the last one (even if it is only by 1/100th of a second) and not trying for an out and out record. Although, obviously, if you drive an outstanding lap, then that is a bonus! As the laps count off, you will find the best braking points, the best gear change points, and the correct line for the circuit. You will also be learning about the car, how it brakes, how it accelerates, how it slides, how the wheels lock up, etc. Because you are doing it gradually, you are learning that little bit extra on each lap, feeling for the limit of the car, the braking limits, the traction limits, etc. I find using this method, after about 20 - 25 laps of pretty much any circuit, in any game/sim, that I have learnt enough about the car and circuit to drive a fairly competitive lap? This means after say about half an hour to an hour I can be pretty quick and fairly consistent. Whereas, the guy that just jumps in feet first and drives hell for leather (unless he is *very* talented?) ends up spending the first half an hour to an hour spinning all over the place, crashing out, smashing into things, *AND* at the end of it all, he knows *** all about the cars limit or the layout of the circuit, cos he has spent more time off the circuit than the marshals!!! 8-) *Peter* 8-) (NB: remove asterix to e-mail)
Stuart Boo 03 Oct 1998#424115
>From what I've found running practice laps in the demo, you gotta pretend >you've got eggs strapped on the pedals. Smooth & easy does it. Just a little >too much throttle coming out of a turn & I'm doing 360's down the track! Same >thing if I'm braking too long into a turn, I'll spin off every time. Get back on the power into the corner after, or even perhaps during braking. Hence the need for separate axis pedals so that you can balance the car more. It feels, to me at least, that the car is under far greater control under power than braking into the corner. Unfortunately I've only got the demo so far... Stuart -- Stuart Booth Somewhere in Buckinghamshire, England, UK Note: My email address is in disguise! Remove trailing Z
Alison Hine 03 Oct 1998#424116
This advice from Peter Gagg is terrific. The only thing I would add is to start out in the Advanced Trainer, rather than the Grand Prix car. The AT cars all have 200 hp, vs about 400 hp for most of the GP cars. This makes it much easier to learn to control the cars; they are not quite so ready to leap at the scenery at the slightest touch of throttle. Also, in terms of overall lap times, the Advanced Trainers are not too much slower than the GP cars; I've done a few laps in the 1:32 range at Zandvoort, for example. I found that when I was learning to drive in GPL, if I did a few laps (maybe 50 or so) in an AT, then I did much better in the GP car. Don't feel like a wimp if you choose to race the AT's for a while. With their size and weight, the ATs are roughly comparable to the full-house 1.5 liter GP cars of 1961 through 1965, and not much different from the cars derived from the 1.5 liter cars which many of the teams used as interim cars in 1966 and early 1967. It is possible to race against the AI with the Trainers if you change a single character in your player.ini file. See the general FAQ on my GPL site for details: http://www.simracing.com/~alison/gpl/ [address restored] One other point which may not have been emphasized in this thread quite enough: you need to practice a lot. <Very Big Grin> I drove more than 500 laps at Monza before I felt I really was competitive there, and Monza is the simplest track. And I'm still learning. Although I know all the tracks fairly well by now, I find that I need about 200 laps at most circuits to get down to reasonable times, if I've been away from that circuit for more than a week or two. Yeah, I guess I agree with the title of this thread. :-) Alison
Quoted text (77 lines)>> That's an interesting one. I've wondered sometimes if it's better >> to start off fast and work on consistency, or start consistent and >> work on speed. Would you mind explaining the advantage of the >> latter? >> >6) Start off slowly and gradually build up your speed, not the >> other >> >way around. >Most people get a new racing game/sim and jump straight in with both >feet and immediately try to break all known lap records at the first >attempt without even glancing at the manual!!!! >This usually results in lots of unscheduled *off-road* driving >admiring the scenery when you should in fact be on the track >practicing. This is caused because the drivers have not learnt how to >control the car, not learnt the circuits, and they are driving *TOO >FAST* and end up continually crashing. This in turn dents confidence, >and can get very annoying? and you do not learn that much from >continually crashing (apart from where the barriers are situated? >and how slow it is to get out of the gravel trap?) >The more conservative approach (driving slower and gradually building >up speed) will ultimately be more beneficial (IMHO?) because of many >reasons... >1) Driving slower gives you more time to react. >2) You can see & learn the correct racing line easier at lower >speeds. >3) Car control is easier at lower speeds. >4) You will crash less at lower speeds. >5) If you crash less your confidence will rise. >6) Remembering circuits is easier at lower speeds. >My method for a new game/sim is to take a few laps to just drive >around the circuit, not fast at all, to familiarise myself with the >general layout. (Also check out any maps or diagrams in the manual, >etc). >Then try some faster laps, but the object is to just try and stay on >the track without spinning/crashing off. Once I can do this >consistently (I have learnt to anticipate the corners and bends) I >start to gradually increase speed and try to lower my laptimes, but >the emphasis is on gradually. >As you gradually drive more laps, you get more familiar with the >circuit, and can anticipate better, try to go faster on the straights >on each lap by accelerating out of corners earlier. also try to brake >into corners a little bit later on each lap. Each lap you are only >trying to improve on the last one (even if it is only by 1/100th of a >second) and not trying for an out and out record. Although, >obviously, if you drive an outstanding lap, then that is a bonus! >As the laps count off, you will find the best braking points, the >best gear change points, and the correct line for the circuit. You >will also be learning about the car, how it brakes, how it >accelerates, how it slides, how the wheels lock up, etc. Because you >are doing it gradually, you are learning that little bit extra on >each lap, feeling for the limit of the car, the braking limits, the >traction limits, etc. >I find using this method, after about 20 - 25 laps of pretty much any >circuit, in any game/sim, that I have learnt enough about the car and >circuit to drive a fairly competitive lap? This means after say about >half an hour to an hour I can be pretty quick and fairly consistent. >Whereas, the guy that just jumps in feet first and drives hell for >leather (unless he is *very* talented?) ends up spending the first >half an hour to an hour spinning all over the place, crashing out, >smashing into things, *AND* at the end of it all, he knows *** all >about the cars limit or the layout of the circuit, cos he has spent >more time off the circuit than the marshals!!! >8-) >*Peter* 8-) >(NB: remove asterix to e-mail)
Alison Remove the spam blocker NOSPAM to email me. [link lost in import: /,ultranet.com/~alison]
% >% Agreed . I am even thinking about getting a wheel for this % >% sim. Never needed one with the Indycar , Narcar for f1rs series. I % >% wonder if it would make this any easier? % > % >Actually what is more important than the "wheel" are analog pedals. If % >you are trying to "drive" GPL with digital (on/off) breake and Did I actually type this ^^^^^ ? ECCK! % >accelerator, you are indeed in for a long haul. While you are at it % >look for pedal setup that will allow for the brake and accelerater to be % >on separate axes. % > % You mean gas & breaks via keyboard? <gasp> I'm using my Thrustmaster Elite % rudder pedals (I'm also a flightsim freak) which are digital I believe, % they do % quite nicely. And the Thrustmaster joystick for steering tho I'm a *little* % less satisfied with that. % I've got an ancient Thrustmaster Formula T1 wheel & pedals but I haven't % use it % yet, I hate the pedals. They're too stiff for me, they've got these big % rollers your feet go on which I don't like, & they're too close together. With % a foot on the gas & one over the brakes my knees bang together :( % What I'd *like* to do is hook up my Thrustmaster wheel to my Thrustmaster % rudder pedals. But I bet that won't work. Anyone know if that could be made to % work? First you can move the brake pedal/roller over to the far left hand slot with no problem. Second, I found that wearing heavy soled shoes helped alot with the T1 roller/pedals (Marcis wing-tips?). What axes are the rudder pedals on? If they aren't on X1, they should work with the T1 wheel. -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Doug 04 Oct 1998#424436
Passing in this game is often best accomplished at the turns, not in the straights. Just watch F1 on TV .. you'll get the idea
Quoted text (9 lines)>I know it has been said before but GPL is really hard. At novice setting >I have a tough time staying on the track. Never mid even trying to keep >up with the other cars. I find that even on the straights I can at best >only keep up with them. I would have assumed that at novice setting I >might have a little more power. Any suggestions? I like the fact that it >is hard but I think it may be so hard that I'm not sure I'll ever get >good enough to even be competitive. >Vamp
Mart 04 Oct 1998#424437
Quoted text (11 lines)> The more conservative approach (driving slower and gradually building > up speed) will ultimately be more beneficial (IMHO?) because of many > reasons... > 1) Driving slower gives you more time to react. > 2) You can see & learn the correct racing line easier at lower > speeds. > 3) Car control is easier at lower speeds. > 4) You will crash less at lower speeds. > 5) If you crash less your confidence will rise. > 6) Remembering circuits is easier at lower speeds.
7) Starting slow keeps you on the track so you can string together consecutive laps which leads to a rhythm and the necessary timing to drive consistently near the limits of the car and your ability. Oh, and practice, practice, practice. Marty
% > The more conservative approach (driving slower and gradually building % > up speed) will ultimately be more beneficial (IMHO?) because of many % > reasons... % > % > 1) Driving slower gives you more time to react. % > 2) You can see & learn the correct racing line easier at lower % > speeds. % > 3) Car control is easier at lower speeds. % > 4) You will crash less at lower speeds. % > 5) If you crash less your confidence will rise. % > 6) Remembering circuits is easier at lower speeds. % 7) Starting slow keeps you on the track so you can string together % consecutive laps which leads to a rhythm and the necessary timing to % drive consistently near the limits of the car and your ability. % Oh, and practice, practice, practice. 8) Starting off slow and smooth vs. fast and wreakless also helps prevent learning "bad habits" which may get in the way of really being fast further down your career. And yes, practice, practice, practice. While I am on this important aspect... It's best to take your learning "curve" one turn at a time. Concentrate on attacking one turn until you get it down and then work on the next turn. Sorta like putting a puzzle together, when the last piece locks into place! -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
LLam5559 04 Oct 1998#424439
Quoted text (12 lines)>First you can move the brake pedal/roller over to the far left hand slot >with no problem. Second, I found that wearing heavy soled shoes helped >alot with the T1 roller/pedals (Marcis wing-tips?). >What axes are the rudder pedals on? If they aren't on X1, they should >work with the T1 wheel. >-- >**************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* > Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. >=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Hey thanks for the info :) I'll try this out. Remove the "X" to email
[This followup was posted to rec.autos.simulators and a copy was sent to the cited author.] So have you got any recommendations to what wheel to buy? Keeping in mind value for money. The other problem I've got is justifying the purchase of a wheel to my wife. She is not a petrol head like me. -- Rob Yates Found in the Land of OZ http://users.netcon.net.au/ryates/index.htm
% So have you got any recommendations to what wheel to buy? Keeping in % mind value for money. I think the main criteria should be pedals on a separate axes. For starters (and probabily the cheapest -- unless you make your own), the NASCAR Pro by Thrustmaster is the entry level that I am aware of for separate axes pedals. And this IS needed for controlling the car in GPL. When the pedals are on the same axis, letting off the gas is the same as touching the brake. For more information check http://www.thrustmaster.com Thrustmaster is selling the NASCAR Pro for $99.95 <http://st1.yahoo.com/thrust>, so you may find it out there in the discount stores for even less. If you think you might need to build your own check out Wally's World <http://www.oz.net/~wottenad/wheel.htm> % The other problem I've got is justifying the purchase of a wheel to my % wife. She is not a petrol head like me. Well, we may just have to do the "honey, look how much I would be saving" routine (they love to do it, so turn about is fair play <G>). Show her the top of the line goodies and tell her how they cost: o Thomas Enterprises ($220-725) http://soli.inav.net/~thomas/index.html o Virtual Vehicles from Interactive I/O ($695-1295) http://www.interactiveio.com o Extreme Competition Controls ($995-1299) http://ourworld.compuserve.com/homepages/extreme Then promise to buy her something special with the money you save! % > Actually what is more important than the "wheel" are analog pedals. If % > you are trying to "drive" GPL with digital (on/off) breake and % > accelerator, you are indeed in for a long haul. While you are at it % > look for pedal setup that will allow for the brake and accelerater to be % > on separate axes. % > % -- % Rob Yates % Found in the Land of OZ % http://users.netcon.net.au/ryates/index.htm -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Neil Yeatma 06 Oct 1998#425066
BZZZZT! Wrong answer. Letting off the gas is letting off the gas, not pressing the brake. Pressing on the gas and brake simultaneously is where the problem is...holding the gas then pressing the brake reduces the amount of gas, and the reverse is true. To get full throttle, you cannot have any brake input, and vice versa. I just added a 2/3 axis switch to my TSW, and I have to learn to drive GPL all over again. -- Neil Yeatman Ajax, Ontario, CANADA
On Tue, 06 Oct 1998 06:30:09 -0400, Neil Yeatman >BZZZZT! Wrong answer. Letting off the gas is letting off the gas, not >pressing the brake. Pressing on the gas and brake simultaneously is >where the problem is...holding the gas then pressing the brake reduces >the amount of gas, and the reverse is true. To get full throttle, >you cannot have any brake input, and vice versa. AFAI understand Michael is/was right. As long as gas/brake are on one axis then while on half throttle you get exactly the same effect if by the sae amount you lift the throttle or depress the brake. Essentially you just change the level of throttle reported to the sim by that axis. If the gas/brake are separated onto different axes then it becomes a different picture. Cheers! John
Quoted text (7 lines)>As long as gas/brake are on one axis then while on half throttle you >get exactly the same effect if by the sae amount you lift the throttle >or depress the brake. Essentially you just change the level of >throttle reported to the sim by that axis. >If the gas/brake are separated onto different axes then it becomes a >different picture.
An interesting question, just how the game interprets it. In past sims, it didn't make much difference, but in GPL, there is a distinct difference in effect between gas (or lack of same) and brake (or lack of same). In older sims, gas/brake was more a single continuum of acceleration/deceleration, versus the distinct simulated mechanical and physical differences in GPL. I would assume that with a single axis set-up in GPL, the sim does not allow simultaneous inputs on both controls: so long as you are on the gas, you can't apply the brake, and vice versa. I doubt that the game compensates and "dumbs down" the inputs (mixing gas/brake) if you are on a single axis. (So I'd tend to agree with Neil on that point.) Using a single axis would put you at a great disadvantage, I would think. Me, I'm using a single axis (so this is all theoretical on my part) and have gotten down to 1:34 flat at Monza soloing with the default Eagle on my P133/V1000, how's that? Of course, once I upgrade, I won't have any more excuses. ;) It's interesting how the increased realism of sims has been accompanied by a raised need for finer input. GP1 could be driven with the keyboard. For ICR1 you needed analog steering, but could get by with digital gas/brakes. For N1 you really needed analog gas/brakes as well. Now you need independent gas & brakes for GPL. We're getting there, slow but sure... NAR Northeast Regional Contest Board site - points and more...
Marty U'Ren 06 Oct 1998#425069
You could point out much *** you'll be saving on the family grocery getter by doing your four-wheel-drifts on the computer. :-) Marty
Marty U'Ren 06 Oct 1998#425070
Yes, and the point here is that with separate gas/brake you can use both at once for car control in certain situations. Marty
Quoted text (24 lines)> On Tue, 06 Oct 1998 06:30:09 -0400, Neil Yeatman > >BZZZZT! Wrong answer. Letting off the gas is letting off the gas, > not > >pressing the brake. Pressing on the gas and brake simultaneously is > >where the problem is...holding the gas then pressing the brake > reduces > >the amount of gas, and the reverse is true. To get full throttle, > >you cannot have any brake input, and vice versa. > AFAI understand Michael is/was right. > As long as gas/brake are on one axis then while on half throttle you > get exactly the same effect if by the sae amount you lift the throttle > or depress the brake. Essentially you just change the level of > throttle reported to the sim by that axis. > If the gas/brake are separated onto different axes then it becomes a > different picture. > Cheers! > John
Bley 06 Oct 1998#425072
Quoted text (8 lines)> On Tue, 06 Oct 1998 06:30:09 -0400, Neil Yeatman > AFAI understand Michael is/was right. > As long as gas/brake are on one axis then while on half throttle you > get exactly the same effect if by the sae amount you lift the throttle > or depress the brake. Essentially you just change the level of > throttle reported to the sim by that axis.
Under that logic then a joystick works by everything being either left or down and the right or up motions just dampen the that input. Wrong. Analog inputs have a range of -256 to 256 The brake pedals uses half of an axis, from -256 to 0. The gas pedals uses the other half, from 0 to 256 So, with neither pedal engaged there is neither braking force nor acceleration force. The input is 0 - nothing. With the gas pedal down , while the brake pedal is up, there is still no braking force, as the input is greater than 0. It only becomes different in the fact that you get the full range of 512 input values for either the gas or brake pedals. This gives a finer control. You can think of it as a separate axes setup counting by 1s, while the single axis setup counts by 2s. Both get to the same total range, but one setup gets twice the amount of available steps to get there.
It's pretty simple really since there's nothing GPL can do. Let's say you have gas at "10" (to pick an arbitrary number). That is the _only_ piece of information your gameport can give since it is simply a measure of the changing resistance delivered from the gas and brake pots. If that number now changes to "8", GPL has no idea if I lifted off the gas by "2" or I depressed the brake by "2". Whichever I do the effect is the same within GPL or indeed any sim. Only with separated gas and brake will you get added benefits (where the game models and supports it). Cheers! John
>Under that logic then a joystick works by everything being either left or >down and the right or up motions just dampen the that input. >Wrong. It's not wrong - please tell me how you can apply a left AND a right force simultaneously on a joystick? That is what we are discussing.... Cheers! John
Quoted text (18 lines)>> I would assume that with a single axis set-up in GPL, the sim does >>not allow simultaneous inputs on both controls: so long as you are on >>the gas, you can't apply the brake, and vice versa. I doubt that the >>game compensates and "dumbs down" the inputs (mixing gas/brake) if you >>are on a single axis. (So I'd tend to agree with Neil on that point.) >>Using a single axis would put you at a great disadvantage, I would >>think. >It's pretty simple really since there's nothing GPL can do. Let's say >you have gas at "10" (to pick an arbitrary number). That is the _only_ >piece of information your gameport can give since it is simply a >measure of the changing resistance delivered from the gas and brake >pots. If that number now changes to "8", GPL has no idea if I lifted >off the gas by "2" or I depressed the brake by "2". Whichever I do the >effect is the same within GPL or indeed any sim. >Only with separated gas and brake will you get added benefits (where >the game models and supports it).
Now that you put it that way, I'll agree and pretty much contradict what I said above. My only defense is that I'm currently stuck in the joystick mindset, so it physically is gas *or* brake, not both (not two separate pots coupled on the same axis as a T2). So I guess the game is smarter than I thought... (big surprise ;) NAR Northeast Regional Contest Board site - points and more...
Pat Dotson 06 Oct 1998#425077
(some irrelevant/inaccurate information snipped) Not true. It is different in that, while on separate joystick axes, throttle and brake inputs can be made at the same time - which is almost a necessity in GPL. -- Pat Dotson IMPACT Motorsports http://www.impactmotorsports.com/pd.html
% Does the T2 have seperate axes? No it doesn't, but it shouldn't be too hard to rewire it so that it does (assuming that TM has all of the wires available in their cable). The hard part would be to make it switchable (though not that much harder). This was discussed awhile back by a few folks. Did anyone ever do it successfully and would you be so kind as to share your method? Also one of the TM support people offered to see if he could dig up a wiring diagram for us. I'll see if I can dig up their address and "pester" him again. -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Neil Yeatma 06 Oct 1998#425079
> Yep! I agree...Neil reacted without thinking. Nope...I responded from experience. What we are discussing is Michael's original comment, "letting off the gas is the same as touching the brake", which I disagree with. When you let off the gas halfway, you are *not* applying the brakes...you're applying 50% gas. In any joystick calibration routine on a 2-axis setup, pushing the gas all the way down shows 100% on the "gas" side of centre. Pushing the brake halfway in at the same time reduces the gas by 50%, and the net result is 50% gas..no brakes. Pushing the brake all the way zeroes it out. So...100% gas + 100% brake = Zero. The reverse is true if you push the brake fully and then apply gas pedal. Not until the pointer crosses over to the braking side of centre is brake being applied - unless GPL is interpreting this differently, which I don't believe it does. Whichever input goes in first is the one that then is counteracted by the other pedal. All of the above assumes that your pots apply the same amount of resistance, of course. -- Neil Yeatman Ajax, Ontario, CANADA
Neil Yeatma 06 Oct 1998#425080
> Does the T2 have seperate axes? It depends on how old your T2 is. The original T2's came wired as a 3 axis joystick. They supplied an adapter to make it a 2 axis stick. At some point however they changed it to work as a 2 axis stick only, and stopped shipping the adapter. -- Neil Yeatman Ajax, Ontario, CANADA
Bley 07 Oct 1998#425370
says... Why not quote the part I was quoting, so you don't take my comments out of context... Let's back up a bit and get the -whole- picture --- The person I was quoting was under the impression that on a single axes pedal system the only input being sent to the sim is throttle. This isn't true. The sim "sees" separate brake and gas inputs. Brake force is -256 to -1 and gas is 1 to 256. 0 is neutral. Yes, a two axes system allows for separate brake and gas inputs simultaneously. I didn't really clarify that in my original post. I was more concentrated on the fact that dual axes gives finer control But, from my own experiences I don't see dual axes pedals as an absolute necessity for GPL. It's probably slightly advantagous, but you can drive the sim perfectly well with a single axis pedal system. I do just fine with my CH Products EXL-500.
>Does the T2 have seperate axes? No. The Thrustmaster "Nascar" (or "F1") wheel does, however. It is possible to rewire the T2 pedals. Unfortunately, Thrustmaster choose not to have spare wires in the cable that leads to the gameport, so you have to either add a wire or replace the cable. That's why I haven't done this yet. -- Wolfgang Preiss \ E-mail copies of replies to this posting are welcome.
% % > Yep! I agree...Neil reacted without thinking. % Nope...I responded from experience. % What we are discussing is Michael's original comment, "letting off the % gas is the same as touching the brake", which I disagree with. When you % let off the gas halfway, you are *not* applying the brakes...you're % applying 50% gas. % In any joystick calibration routine on a 2-axis setup, pushing the gas % all the way down shows 100% on the "gas" side of centre. Pushing the % brake halfway in at the same time reduces the gas by 50%, and the net % result is 50% gas..no brakes. Pushing the brake all the way zeroes it % out. Yes, looking at the "calibration" screen or TMScope, but I don't think that the sim makers actually model it this way. I know that in Papyrus sims, the car handles differently with separate axes than an single axis. It is evident in the way the car noses down when there is a sudden lift of the accelerator (ICRII & N2). It acts the same way when the brake is being applied. When I switched to pedals on seperate axes this behavior was greatly lessened. While the nose still dipped (as it should, since sudden deceleration will transfer the weight to the front wheels), it wasn't as pronounced. I also experienced greater control over subtle throttle changes. But, you are correct in saying that separate axes are more prominent while applying both brake and throttle (e.g., trail-braking). Which I haven't spent too much time playing with in GPL. I mainly either brake or accelerate. Maybe it's just my imagination, but I sense a finer control when they are on a separate axix. % So...100% gas + 100% brake = Zero. The reverse is true if you push the % brake fully and then apply gas pedal. % Not until the pointer crosses over to the braking side of centre is % brake being applied - unless GPL is interpreting this differently, which % I don't believe it does. Whichever input goes in first is the one that % then is counteracted by the other pedal. % All of the above assumes that your pots apply the same amount of % resistance, of course. -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
% > Does the T2 have seperate axes? % It depends on how old your T2 is. The original T2's came wired as a 3 % axis joystick. They supplied an adapter to make it a 2 axis stick. At % some point however they changed it to work as a 2 axis stick only, and % stopped shipping the adapter. Well sorta. . . The T1's and early T2's had the wheel on one joystick 1 and both pedals on joystick 2. Many Windows games couldn't cope with this and thus the adapter/converter to put both devices on the same joystick. The pedals were always on the same axis (be it joystick1 or joystick2). -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Neil Yeatma 07 Oct 1998#425374
> > Does the T2 have seperate axes? > It depends on how old your T2 is. The original T2's came wired as a 3 > axis joystick. They supplied an adapter to make it a 2 axis stick. At > some point however they changed it to work as a 2 axis stick only, and > stopped shipping the adapter. Well...this is incorrect. It was a 2-axis 2 joytick setup without the adapter. My apologies...it's been too long since I had that T2. -- Neil Yeatman Ajax, Ontario, CANADA
On Tue, 06 Oct 1998 23:46:24 -0400, Neil Yeatman >What we are discussing is Michael's original comment, "letting off the >gas is the same as touching the brake", which I disagree with. When you >let off the gas halfway, you are *not* applying the brakes...you're >applying 50% gas. Yes, but it is the _same_ as applying the brake given that you are using a single axis for both brake and gas. Psychologically it may be considered different but in terms of information passed from the pots to the joystick port to the sim there is no difference. Taking the example above, if I am at 100% throttle and want 50% throttle I can either lift the throttle halfway or I can depress the brake halfway - on a single axis this brings the same result and agrees with what Michael originally stated. As far as I can see we are arguing the same thing, only you think Michael was wrong and I don't! Spooky :-) Cheers! John
>The person I was quoting was under the impression that on a single axes >pedal system the only input being sent to the sim is throttle. This isn't >true. The sim "sees" separate brake and gas inputs. Brake force is -256 >to -1 and gas is 1 to 256. 0 is neutral. I think we are talking about the same thing from a different perspective. The point I was making was related to what the original post said - reducing throttle is the same as applying brake. It is, provided you still have the throttle depressed and are on the same axis. Agreed. To drive fast and consistently you need to be smooth. The problem with sing axis is that in order to get fully on the brakes you have to jump fully _off_ the gas - instantaneously. So you get weight massively pitched forward, huge engine braking, AND full braking force the same time. In a real racecar setup to be driven on the limit that would set up massive forces on the car that smoothly decreasing throttle and applying brake does not do. The comment was made about Schumacher that he often _sounds_ like he takes corners flat but is actually braking against full throttle - often massively so. That plays hell with brake wear of course, but his laptimes show what it does for car stability and finesse of control. The question then becomes how well are these effects modelled? Of course sims don't model the increased downforce from hot exhaust gas venting under the car, but the improved pitch control will help. Cheers! John
Joe McGinn 07 Oct 1998#425377
Thanks, but I'll probably just get a Nascar Pro. My T2 is getting pretty old anyway (the calibration seems to "slip", even though I have fairly new pots). Joe
Keith Cals 08 Oct 1998#425680
Thanks for answering my question before I posted it! I have a T2 with the adapter. When GPL came out, I thought, "hey! I'll just remove the adapter and have the gas and brake on separate axes!" This did not work even remotely as planned and now I know why. Poop. Maybe if someone knows exactly how to rewire this thing and could explain it to non-electrical-heads like myself... --Keith "Coming in 2nd place just means that you are the first to lose!"
% >Well sorta. . . The T1's and early T2's had the wheel on one joystick % >1 and both pedals on joystick 2. Many Windows games couldn't cope with % >this and thus the adapter/converter to put both devices on the same % >joystick. The pedals were always on the same axis (be it joystick1 or % >joystick2). % Thanks for answering my question before I posted it! I have a T2 % with the adapter. When GPL came out, I thought, "hey! I'll just % remove the adapter and have the gas and brake on separate axes!" This % did not work even remotely as planned and now I know why. % Poop. Maybe if someone knows exactly how to rewire this thing and % could explain it to non-electrical-heads like myself... You can find a wiring schematic at http://www.monmouth.com/~lw4750/home.htm Look of the thread "Seperate axis on a T2? (long)" here in r.a.s. and read the reply by jsilva (LavaBoy) for information on how to... -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
EldredP 12 Oct 1998#426794
Really? I do MUCH better with just socks... ________ Eldred Pickett e-mail address altered to deter spammers - remove the '*' to reply Put your message in a modem - and throw it into the ***-sea...

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy