Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Best current F1 sim?

24 posts by 13 people · 19 Mar 2008 23:56 UTC - 31 Mar 2008 08:47 UTC

Looking for the best current F1 sim

Peter Gagg asked for the best modern F1 sim. Most recommended rFactor with the F1RFT 2008 or BMW Sauber mods, since other F1 titles were outdated. The thread turned into a debate over whether rFactor's huge number of mods is a strength or a burden, using a restaurant-menu analogy, with some noting that mod fragmentation hurts online racing.

game comparisonmods/tracks/carsrFactor

Automated summary.

P Gagg 19 Mar 2008 23:56 UTC#4109
Yep, the F1 season has just started again (Come on Lewis!) and rekindled my interest in F1 Sims, so... What is the best current F1 Sim? I already own several older versions, Microprose Grand Prix 2 & 3, EA F1 2000 & 2002, etc. I have a demo version of rFactor, but was not that impressed, and am not sure if there is a good F1 add on for it? Info would be appreciated, thanx... PJGTECH
P Gagg 19 Mar 2008 23:58 UTC↳ reply to P Gagg#4110
PG wrote:
Quoted text (14 lines)> Yep, the F1 season has just started again (Come on Lewis!) and rekindled > my interest in F1 Sims, so... > > What is the best current F1 Sim? > > I already own several older versions, Microprose Grand Prix 2 & 3, EA F1 > 2000 & 2002, etc. > > I have a demo version of rFactor, but was not that impressed, and am not > sure if there is a good F1 add on for it? > > Info would be appreciated, thanx... > > PJGTECH
Sorry, should also have clarified, I'm interested in a MODERN F1 sim, not retro, (as I have GPL for that - Obviously!) 8-)
Fritz 20 Mar 2008 04:42 UTC↳ reply to P Gagg#4111
lookie here: http://www.rfactorcentral.com/detail.cfm?ID=2007%20Sauber%20BMW%20F1 or http://www.rfactorcentral.com/detail.cfm?ID=CTDP%202005 "PG" <[email hidden]> schrieb im Newsbeitrag news:TMhEj.8038$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (20 lines)> PG wrote: >> Yep, the F1 season has just started again (Come on Lewis!) and rekindled >> my interest in F1 Sims, so... >> >> What is the best current F1 Sim? >> >> I already own several older versions, Microprose Grand Prix 2 & 3, EA F1 >> 2000 & 2002, etc. >> >> I have a demo version of rFactor, but was not that impressed, and am not >> sure if there is a good F1 add on for it? >> >> Info would be appreciated, thanx... >> >> PJGTECH > > Sorry, should also have clarified, I'm interested in a MODERN F1 sim, not > retro, (as I have GPL for that - Obviously!) > > 8-)
I think you won'get past rFactor if you want to run the current season's car liveries. All other sims feature older seasons (some may have been updated to recent years), and the only 2008 season project I know of is for rFactor and called F1RFT_2008_Basicpack.exe I only managed to download it yesterday and haven't tried it out yet, so I cannot really comment on its quality. On the other hand, the MMG mods are usually very good, and the 2007 version 1.0 has recently been released (check rfactorcentral, for instance). All the best, uwe
Here's the download URL for the 2008 mod I memtioned earlier: ftp://ftp.szasztv.hu/szasztv.hu/F1RFT/F1RFT_2008_Basicpack.exe Cheers, uwe --
[email hidden] (PG) wrote: > I have a demo version of rFactor, but was not that impressed, and > am not sure if there is a good F1 add on for it? I'm not a huge fan of rFactor, and I thought the F1 mod was a bit too fast for my liking. Then I watched that programme where Richard Hammond 'learned' to drive an F1 car in a day, and changed my mind. Those things are a bit quick, so it's probably pretty accurate. :-) Anyway I get mod-fatigue when I think of rFactor these days. So many vehicles to choose from... so I end up choosing none. Andrew McP
If you haven't tried F1 mods for rF in a while, check out F1RFT 2008 which was discussed in another thread. I was pleasantly surprised by its driveability and the pure fun factor of throwing these cars around Sepang-GP4. Cheers, uwe
Andrew MacPherson wrote: > I'm not a huge fan of rFactor, and I thought the F1 mod was a bit too > fast for my liking. Then I watched that programme where Richard Hammond > 'learned' to drive an F1 car in a day, and changed my mind. Those things > are a bit quick, so it's probably pretty accurate. :-) The "problem" with simulating F1 is that the pure exhilaration, terror and need to do things so quickly when driving an F1 car ably demonstrated by Hammond is mostly lost. The doing things quickly bit comes across which at the risk of being flamed makes it feel a bit arcade. It doesn't help that F1 cockpits look like toys these days too. Driving one for real the sheer performance, grip and braking capability would be simply awe inspiring, plus the physical effort would have most of us coming in after just a few laps. I just don't think modern F1 works well in simulations. Of course your mileage may vary... Cheers Tony
Andrew MacPherson wrote:
Quoted text (12 lines)> [email hidden] (PG) wrote: > >> I have a demo version of rFactor, but was not that impressed, and >> am not sure if there is a good F1 add on for it? > > I'm not a huge fan of rFactor, and I thought the F1 mod was a bit too > fast for my liking. Then I watched that programme where Richard Hammond > 'learned' to drive an F1 car in a day, and changed my mind. Those things > are a bit quick, so it's probably pretty accurate. :-) > > Anyway I get mod-fatigue when I think of rFactor these days. So many > vehicles to choose from... so I end up choosing none.
That I really don't get. You prefer restaurants with 3 menus max, right? If they offer 20 different meals, you'll rather eat somewhere else, right? SCNR ;) ronny
In article <fs0mi4$4u3$[email hidden]>, [email hidden] says...
Quoted text (9 lines)> > > Andrew MacPherson wrote: > > > > Anyway I get mod-fatigue when I think of rFactor these days. So many > > vehicles to choose from... so I end up choosing none. > > That I really don't get. You prefer restaurants with 3 menus max, right? > If they offer 20 different meals, you'll rather eat somewhere else, right? >
You can discount a lot of those, as they are made by people that are in the kitchen only to make good *looking* meals, regardless of how the meal *tastes*. MRSisson -- LOAD "GPL",8 SEARCHING FOR GPL LOADING READY. RUN
Ronald Stoehr wrote:
Quoted text (19 lines)> Andrew MacPherson wrote: >> [email hidden] (PG) wrote: >> >>> I have a demo version of rFactor, but was not that impressed, and am >>> not sure if there is a good F1 add on for it? >> >> I'm not a huge fan of rFactor, and I thought the F1 mod was a bit too >> fast for my liking. Then I watched that programme where Richard Hammond >> 'learned' to drive an F1 car in a day, and changed my mind. Those things >> are a bit quick, so it's probably pretty accurate. :-) >> >> Anyway I get mod-fatigue when I think of rFactor these days. So many >> vehicles to choose from... so I end up choosing none. > > That I really don't get. You prefer restaurants with 3 menus max, right? > If they offer 20 different meals, you'll rather eat somewhere else, right? > > SCNR ;) > ronny
Actually, your analogy is inappropriate. It is not like preferring a restaurant with 3 menus max. A typical racing game already has an assortment of racing vehicles that is equivalent to that of a typical restaurant menu. On the other hand, rFactor is like walking into a restaurant with 1000 different meals listed. This is a problem, as one of the roles of a restaurant is not to give you every possible food imaginable, but to reduce the choice down to those that are especially good - at least in terms of their ability to make them...
Michael Sisson wrote:
Quoted text (12 lines)> In article <fs0mi4$4u3$[email hidden]>, [email hidden] says... >>> Andrew MacPherson wrote: >>> >>> Anyway I get mod-fatigue when I think of rFactor these days. So many >>> vehicles to choose from... so I end up choosing none. >> That I really don't get. You prefer restaurants with 3 menus max, right? >> If they offer 20 different meals, you'll rather eat somewhere else, right? >> > > You can discount a lot of those, as they are made by people that are in > the kitchen only to make good *looking* meals, regardless of how the > meal *tastes*.
Of course, I disregarded meals that taste like cardboard, or something. There are at least 20 GREAT mods for rfactor, and there are restaurants with 20 GREAT menus. I'm just not confused by the big number of mods, I just drive one at a time. Of course, I'm not talking about MP, because that may well be a nightmare... l8er ronny
[email hidden] (Tony R) wrote: > I just don't think modern F1 works well in simulations. I agree for all the reasons you mention. I think that's why GPL was able to be so successful... it's the right era of car technology to model for those driving a desk, not a 3D object. Andrew McP
[email hidden] (Ronald Stoehr) wrote: > If they offer 20 different meals, you'll rather eat > somewhere else, right? I'd rather have no choice at all, and a *superb* meal, than lots of choice and little satisfaction. :-) Andrew McP
Well there are certainly some SUPERB meals available for rFactor. ( Of course I don't even understand someone that complains about too many choices. ) But - I don't care for dirt racing or oval racing (show-business-racing). That sure doesn't stop me from racing in multiple 79 mod leagues!! It doesn't stop me from having a blast racing the 'preview' CSGT mod! It doesn't stop me.... oh nevermind... don't want to put to many 'options' here and confuse or frustrate anyone ;) ==--== "Andrew MacPherson" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (9 lines)> [email hidden] (Ronald Stoehr) wrote: > >> If they offer 20 different meals, you'll rather eat >> somewhere else, right? > > I'd rather have no choice at all, and a *superb* meal, than lots of > choice and little satisfaction. :-) > > Andrew McP
Andrew MacPherson wrote:
Quoted text (7 lines)> [email hidden] (Ronald Stoehr) wrote: > >> If they offer 20 different meals, you'll rather eat >> somewhere else, right? > > I'd rather have no choice at all, and a *superb* meal, than lots of > choice and little satisfaction. :-)
You are actually saying there are no SUPERB mods for rF available???? You're ... Oh, I give up! l8er ronny
On Mar 22, 2:35 am, [email hidden] (Andrew MacPherson) wrote:
Quoted text (8 lines)> [email hidden] (Ronald Stoehr) wrote: > > If they offer 20 different meals, you'll rather eat > > somewhere else, right? > > I'd rather have no choice at all, and a *superb* meal, than lots of > choice and little satisfaction. :-) > > Andrew McP
Hmmm...interesting. If you have no choice at all, what happens if it is not to your liking? It may be the most superbly prepared meal in history of cooking, but if you don't like it, then how good is it really, to you? For example, if the most exacting physics model for drag racing on a PC was released as a mod for rF and its performance was documented as 99% accurate by verifiable sources, I still wouldn't give it the time of day as I find drag racing an amazing bore. However, if presented with an 85% accurate mod of stock cars, I would download and try it without reservation. Choice is good.
Darus wrote:
Quoted text (24 lines)> On Mar 22, 2:35 am, [email hidden] (Andrew > MacPherson) wrote: >> [email hidden] (Ronald Stoehr) wrote: >>> If they offer 20 different meals, you'll rather eat >>> somewhere else, right? >> I'd rather have no choice at all, and a *superb* meal, than lots of >> choice and little satisfaction. :-) >> >> Andrew McP > > Hmmm...interesting. > > If you have no choice at all, what happens if it is not to your > liking? It may be the most superbly prepared meal in history of > cooking, but if you don't like it, then how good is it really, to you? > > For example, if the most exacting physics model for drag racing on a > PC was released as a mod for rF and its performance was documented as > 99% accurate by verifiable sources, I still wouldn't give it the time > of day as I find drag racing an amazing bore. However, if presented > with an 85% accurate mod of stock cars, I would download and try it > without reservation. > > Choice is good.
I should not have started with the restaurrants at all! Your explanation why his rejection of choice is silly is a lot better than mine... l8er ronny
Ronald Stoehr wrote: > I should not have started with the restaurrants at all! > Your explanation why his rejection of choice is silly is a lot better > than mine... Forgetting the restaurants, rejecting choice isn't necessarily silly. As we know Multiplayer is diluted to the extent that pick up racing is pretty much impossible. Whilst many leagues are successfully running with rFactor, many have to deal with updates mid season and drivers running in multiple leagues with varying versions and multiple installs to avoid mismatches. Offline the never ending stream of mods and update to mods mean that by the time you have get to grips with a setup for the latest best ever physics there is another version, or a new FFB setting or plug in. This generates its own excitement with new material to drive on an almost daily basis. However, some yearn for the days of more stability which mimics reality where a driver sticks with a car for at least a season and improves and gets to know it it intimately. Those who put the mileage in with GPL will understand this. As usual there is no right answer, however, those looking for a return to quality pick up racing as we often had in VROC/GPL before it got fragmented by zillions of add on tracks will be watching what happens with iRacing very closely and that maybe less is more... Cheers Tony
Tony R wrote:
Quoted text (13 lines)> Ronald Stoehr wrote: > >> I should not have started with the restaurrants at all! >> Your explanation why his rejection of choice is silly is a lot better >> than mine... > > Forgetting the restaurants, rejecting choice isn't necessarily silly. > > As we know Multiplayer is diluted to the extent that pick up racing is > pretty much impossible. Whilst many leagues are successfully running > with rFactor, many have to deal with updates mid season and drivers > running in multiple leagues with varying versions and multiple installs > to avoid mismatches.
Well, I already excluded MP, which seems to be hell with rF. It was about the old tired general complaint about to much choice in rF, that I just find silly.
Quoted text (11 lines)> > Offline the never ending stream of mods and update to mods mean that by > the time you have get to grips with a setup for the latest best ever > physics there is another version, or a new FFB setting or plug in. > > This generates its own excitement with new material to drive on an > almost daily basis. > > However, some yearn for the days of more stability which mimics reality > where a driver sticks with a car for at least a season and improves and > gets to know it it intimately.
Easy solution: don't jump between mods every hour. You could even have only one mod installed and pretend, there are no others!!! ;) > > Those who put the mileage in with GPL will understand this. Oh, I have lots of milage with rF SCCS. And the thought of 20 other mods I COULD be driving instead doesn't drive me nuts... =8^O l8er ronny
Backspace 24 Mar 2008 22:45 UTC↳ reply to P Gagg#4140
PG wrote:
Quoted text (14 lines)> Yep, the F1 season has just started again (Come on Lewis!) and rekindled > my interest in F1 Sims, so... > > What is the best current F1 Sim? > > I already own several older versions, Microprose Grand Prix 2 & 3, EA F1 > 2000 & 2002, etc. > > I have a demo version of rFactor, but was not that impressed, and am not > sure if there is a good F1 add on for it? > > Info would be appreciated, thanx... > > PJGTECH
Sony has the rights to F1 now so you can forget finding a good current F1 sim.
Uwe Sch�rkamp wrote:
Quoted text (7 lines)> Here's the download URL for the 2008 mod I memtioned earlier: > > ftp://ftp.szasztv.hu/szasztv.hu/F1RFT/F1RFT_2008_Basicpack.exe > > Cheers, uwe > >
6.0kb/s on broadband?! Thanks, but no thanks.

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy