Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

GPL - Its just a harder version of any arcade game.

24 posts by 14 people · 12 Apr 1998 - 18 Apr 1998

Rebuttals to 'GPL is a harder arcade game'

Responding to Charles Mak's claim that GPL was just a harder arcade game, posters pointed out contradictions in his earlier statements and noted that period footage showed cars bouncing and sliding. David Fisher asked why CPR fans had not received the same support, prompting more argument about CPR.

physics/realism debatecommunity/metaGrand Prix LegendsCART Precision Racing

Automated summary.

On Sat, 11 Apr 1998 20:54:18 -0400, "Charles Mak" >I'll keep saying it until you all realise it. GPL has got all the bounce >and roll and swerve of any arcade racer. Real 60's stuff was never so >bouncy, rolly or swervy. Just watch Speedvision and you'll see. "I'll keep saying it until you all realise it"? Doesn't that sound a bit like "the whole world is wrong except me"? You said it, I heard you, I laughed a little, I went back to playing GPL. You said it again, same result. It's difficult to believe you when the evidence to the contrary is on my hard disk in the form of the GPL demo, but even assuming GPL were "arcadey", it's infinitely less arcadey than anything released until now, so I think I'll hang onto it until something comes along that's better. Cheers! John
>I'll keep saying it until you all realise it. GPL has got all the bounce >and roll and swerve of any arcade racer. Real 60's stuff was never so >bouncy, rolly or swervy. Just watch Speedvision and you'll see. Ever notice how whenever a new driving sim or demo is released one or two guys come out of the woodwork who dedicate their lives to opposing the general consensus of opinion, usually just to see how much argument they can generate? You can bet that if the general consensus on the GPL demo had been negative this guy would be touting it as the best and most accurate sim ever created.
LOL!! > Real 60's stuff was never so > bouncy, rolly or swervy. Yeah....sure Mr. Mak. And you were there, of course, weren't you? --- Bruce. (At home)
I'm sorry you don't enjoy the GPL demo (really!). I don't drive (I'd love to race for real, but day to day driving has always seemed a rather expensive and tedious process) but I've raced driving games/sims since Geoff Crammond's "Revs" on the BBC Micro over ten (twelve?) years ago. IndyCar1 (and the flight sim Tornado) were what got me into PCs and I've had a lot of enjoyment and superb value for money out of all the Papyrus sims + GP2. I've never been particularly good, which may be why I dislike F1rs, but I've always enjoyed myself. But none of these has ever engaged me the way the GPL demo has. I'm absolutely *certain* it's not perfect, and I'm willing to bet large amounts of money that in a year or two someone will do a better job. But here and now, I'm having the most satisfaction I've ever had out of learning a sim, and that's all that matters. Best 0.00p I've ever spent :-) BTW, for the record, I've "driven" one of the high street arcade games but I don't remember which one and it was only once. So overall I'm probably the least qualified person to have an opinion on any driving game/sim in the history of RAS. But then, if everyone had to be qualified to have an opinion, this place would be a graveyard ;-) Andrew... RAS's most under-qualified opinion
Boy, I was going to stay out of this one, but let's review the Charles Mak quotes on this one: > Some people on this NG think that I percieve GPL to be an arcade racer. This is entirely wrong.>> From previous Charles Mak posts: "GPL is really made for the arcade racer..." "GPL is nothing but a souped up arcade racer." "GPL has got all the bounce and roll and swerve of any arcade racer." Now, correct me if I'm wrong, but I'm sensing a hint of inconsistency here. I must say, I thought I was pretty good at long-winded gibberish, but your posts have taken the proverbial cake. First, this is a demo -- not the actual game, so it may be a bit premature to draw too many conclusions. Second, IT'S A GAME. I hate to be the one to break this to you, but you are NOT actually sitting in a late-'60s GP car, you are NOT actually at bumpy, lovable old Watkins Glen, the view you see in front of you is ACTUALLY a computer screen, and you're NOT actually going anywhere. Is this news to you? GPL, like GP2, F1GP, or any other racing "simulation" is a piece of entertainment software. You keep blubbering about how accurate GP2 is, but accuracy, like beauty, is in the mind -- specifically in the "willing suspension of disbelief" -- of the beholder. To say GP2 is a more accurate simulation of modern F1 racing than GPL is of late-'60s racing is like saying a wet dream is an accurate simulation of real, live, waking sex -- maybe it is for YOU old boy, but not for everyone! How is it that your personal opinion of whether a game is accurate or not has somehow become holy writ? Let me relate a little true story: When John Frankenheimer wrapped up the shooting and editing for the movie Grand Prix, he had a private screening for many of the people involved in the film, including most of the drivers who appeared. Now, to modern eyes, many of the crashes staged in "Grand Prix" look exactly like what they are: old engineless F3 cars being shot from what amounted to a pneumatic cannon -- not exactly Industrial Light and Magic. But when the infamous Bruce Beresford/James Garner shunt at Monaco came on screen, Graham Hill dropped in his theatre seat and tried to curl up in a ball. He had quite a chuckle about it later, but my point is: AT THE MOMENT, HE BELIEVED. Now here's a World Champion in the midst of a very long career, demonstrating that the willing suspension of disbelief happens even to the most professional of critical observers. Yet you would have everyone believe, just because you say so, that one sim is a sham and another is an accurate representation of the real thing, and that there is some sort of difference between "arcade" driving and "real sim" driving, and that one actually has some "truer" relationship to ACTUAL driving than the other. Have you ever considered the heretical notion that perhaps those differences exist in the individual mind, and each person has a different, but equally valid, experience of the things you do? Apparently not, from your signoff: "I may look like a heretic but hey I'm really only showing you all the light." No, what you're showing us is YOUR light. To my mind, it's a bit of a dim bulb. Bart Brown
Good points but why didn't CPR suporters hear the same thing? Could it be because MS made it? Dave
Quoted text (8 lines)>Yet you would have everyone believe, just because you say so, that one >sim is a sham and another is an accurate representation of the real >thing, and that there is some sort of difference between "arcade" >driving and "real sim" driving, and that one actually has some "truer" >relationship to ACTUAL driving than the other. Have you ever considered >the heretical notion that perhaps those differences exist in the >individual mind, and each person has a different, but equally valid, >experience of the things you do?
Don't confuse your lack of talent with how realistic the sim is, I have watched replays of guys do laps in the 1m07sec range that looked pretty controllable, and thats without having access to the setup screen to adjust the car to there style -- Kevin Anderson ICQ # 6769389 Oscar FB Div. 10 >I'll keep saying it until you all realise it. GPL has got all the bounce >and roll and swerve of any arcade racer. Real 60's stuff was never so >bouncy, rolly or swervy. Just watch Speedvision and you'll see.
> I'll keep saying it until you all realise it. GPL has got all the bounce > and roll and swerve of any arcade racer. Real 60's stuff was never so > bouncy, rolly or swervy. Just watch Speedvision and you'll see. I mentioned it in a post before. I saw footage of late 50's (Fangio) and late 60's and they were racing bouncy, rolly AND swervy. Keep on trolling... PLONK! l8er ronny -- How to get rid of censorship in German game releases <http://www.gamesmania.com/german/maniac/freedom/freedom.htm> |\ _,,,---,,_ I want to die like my Grandfather, ZZZzz /,`.-'`' -. ;-;;,_ in his sleep. |,4- ) )-,_. ,\ ( `'-' Not like the people in his car, '---''(_/--' `-'\_) screaming their heads off!
Quoted text (7 lines)> Good points but why didn't CPR suporters hear the same thing? Could it be because MS made it? > Dave > >driving and "real sim" driving, and that one actually has some "truer" relationship to ACTUAL driving than the other. Have you ever considered the heretical notion that perhaps those differences exist in the individual mind, and each person has a different, but equally valid, experience of the things you do?>>
Sorry to quote my quote, but it's germane to the point David has raised. First, let me correct myself -- it was late, very late, when I wrote the post to which David refers: it should have read "the Brian Bedford/James Garner shunt..."; Bruce Beresford is, of course, an excellent Australian director. Now, David, I'm afraid that once again, in your zeal to ascribe ALL criticism of CPR to the satanic machinations of the fabled World-Wide Anti-Microsoft Cabal, Inc., you have gotten the cart (excuse the pun) before the horse. Dealing with GPL and GPII, we are talking about, respectively, a pre-Alpha demo, and a long-established, stable standard. CPR fits neither of these categories, though it's far closer to the former than the latter. I believe that the overwhelming majority of experienced gamers/sim-drivers in this newsgroup who have tried CPR have found it wanting, particularly in the areas of AI (not so much a concern to those who race exclusively head-to-head over a network) and the exceptionally poor or nonexistent implementation of specific technical aspects, e.g., yellow flags and tire temp/pressure data and adjustability. Where you've gotten it wrong way 'round, in my HO, is in the attitude these discontented customers have displayed towards Microsoft. I would be willing to wager that a very large majority of those who've expressed their disappointment in CPR own, use, enjoy, and praise many Microsoft products -- if you're using a PC, it's a bit difficult to avoid at least SOME MS presence on your system, don't you think? So people perceive, with some justification, that Microsoft is a competent, technically-advanced company with tremendous resources and a huge pool of talent. Is it any wonder then, that these same people, having been bombarded with MS' ballyhoo about the "greatest racing sim ever produced" should be rather MORE disappointed when such an industry giant hands them the load of unfinished codswallop that IS CPR in its present form? This has nothing whatsoever to do with individual perception of how a game immerses one in its "world" -- the ludicrous and absolutely subjective "argument" that Mr. Mak is currently waging as his personal jihad regarding the GPL demo and GPII. With CPR, we're talking about a failure to deliver on MS' promises; a failure only compounded by the inept "patches", the stonewalling by everyone involved at MS' end about whether or not the game will EVER be fixed, the smoke and mirrors/bait and switch aspect of responding to complaints about the sim's basic playability by offering track editors and an "awesome" Monster Truck Game instead of delivering CPR as advertised, and this constant nonsense which translates "If you don't love CPR, it's because you HATE Microsoft". These are NOT the actions and response people expect from a company of Microsoft's stature -- they wouldn't be acceptable from a low-budget code joint in Lower Silesia, they certainly wouldn't be acceptable from a company like Sierra/Papyrus or Microprose, so WHY on earth should they be acceptable from Microsoft? Your desperation in tacking this "Anti-Microsoft" *** theory onto a discussion that has no bearing on Microsoft OR CPR just shows the weakness of your basic premise. Bart Brown
Wow. You just said a mouthful but you didn't answer the first question at all. Dave >> Good points but why didn't CPR suporters hear the same thing? Could it be because MS made it? >> Dave >Yet you would have everyone believe, just because you say so, that one sim is a sham and another is an accurate representation of the real thing, and that there is some sort of difference between "arcade" relationship to ACTUAL driving than the other. Have you ever considered the heretical notion that perhaps those differences exist in the individual mind, and each person has a different, but equally valid, experience of the things you do?>>
Cossie 12 Apr 1998#404374
Go watch some Nurburgring races. I dare you to say those cars at the track didn't bounce, roll or swerve.
Cossie 12 Apr 1998#404375
Quoted text (7 lines)>>I'll keep saying it until you all realise it. GPL has got all the bounce >>and roll and swerve of any arcade racer. Real 60's stuff was never so >>bouncy, rolly or swervy. Just watch Speedvision and you'll see. >Ever notice how whenever a new driving sim or demo is released one or two >guys come out of the woodwork who dedicate their lives to opposing the >general consensus of opinion, usually just to see how much argument they
can >generate? You can bet that if the general consensus on the GPL demo had been >negative this guy would be touting it as the best and most accurate sim ever >created. hehe are you refering to CHARLES MAK
Cossie 12 Apr 1998#404376
Quoted text (7 lines)>LOL!! >> Real 60's stuff was never so >> bouncy, rolly or swervy.
He must be thinking about his BMX bike
Cossie 12 Apr 1998#404377
>> I'll keep saying it until you all realise it. GPL has got all the bounce >> and roll and swerve of any arcade racer. Real 60's stuff was never so >> bouncy, rolly or swervy. Just watch Speedvision and you'll see. Since when did they create a motorsports that doesn't bounce, roll or swerve?!? Stock cars?? NOT Indycars?? NOT Rally cars?? NOT Trucks?? NOT Street cars?? NOT Mountain bike?? NOT F1?? gee I wonder what those suspension are for Charles Mak's BMX?? YES IT DOESN'T BOUNCE, we got a winner here
Remco Moedt 12 Apr 1998#404378
Hi Charles, I don't agree with you. Why not? Because my lap times went down when I did "clean" laps, with less sliding. If you say "GPL is an arcade racer" you should say "Fast laps in GPL are archieved in an arcade ride style". Now think. Why is that so? Could it be that the line between sliding and not sliding is VERY small compared with todays racing cars with a lot more downforce? Could it be that those "unrealistic" fast laps with a lot sliding going on is just a start of more to come? I predict laps in the 1.05 in a week of so, with a lot less sliding. BTW,I think that the setups in the demo are pretty loose, so that the cars slide more easily. Just for fun. In the release version, with the possibility to alter the car, you can create a much more stable car. Cheers! Remco >I'll keep saying it until you all realise it. GPL has got all the bounce >and roll and swerve of any arcade racer. Real 60's stuff was never so >bouncy, rolly or swervy. Just watch Speedvision and you'll see.
% Good points but why didn't CPR suporters hear the same thing? Could it be % because MS made it? Basically MS and TRI promised us simmers the moon, but only delivered a crumb or two of stinky ole cheese! <G> If they had delivered what they promised, you would have seen the same hyperboles being heaped on GPL. Instead, mostly we just saw good ole plain hype. -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
> Wow. You just said a mouthful but you didn't answer the first question at all. Dave>> Well, I did, but I can understand how one can be lost in a forest of unfamiliar words. Let me try to answer your original question: "Good points but why didn't CPR suporters hear the same thing? Could it be because MS made it?" in words you may be able to process a little more easily. 1. The post to which you replied had nothing to do with CPR. 2. My rambling discussion in that post concerned (at least the part to which you referred) the "willing suspension of disbelief" while playing a sim. 3. It is a well-documented fact that a certain amount of concentration and comfort must be achieved for the dramatic phenomenon of "willing suspension of disbelief" to occur. 4. Many people, wiser and far more experienced than I, consider CPR unfinished, and so damnably flawed as to be quite unrealistic, specifically citing the fact that the game's faults are so intrusive that it is difficult to get comfortable playing it. Thus, the "willing suspension of disbelief" is nearly impossible to achieve, and the "simulation" of a putative "real" experience does not occur. Perhaps this is not true in *your* experience with CPR, but it seems to be true for the majority of people who have played it. 5. You, like "Charles Mak", apparently cannot conceive of anyone having an experience different from yours, unless they are unrepentantly stupid (in Charles Mok's definition) or motivated by the dark forces of the World-Wide Anti-Microsoft Cabal (the David Fisher version). However, 6. many, if not most, of the people who have commented unfavorably on CPR own other Microsoft products which they find perfectly satisfactory and even laudable. 7. Microsoft is a huge company with lots of money and unimaginable resources. It is not likely that they could not have finished CPR to the satisfaction of the majority of their customers. Yet they have NOT done so, and they refuse to answer direct questions about when, or if, they PLAN to do so; choosing instead to strut and crow about their track editor and Monster Truck Madness. If you had bought a Corvette from your friendly local Chevy dealer and it had no transmission in it when you went to pick it up, would your desire for a finished Corvette be amply fulfilled by the dealer telling you what a fabulous Chevy StepSide they were coming out with next month? I rather think not. If there is any of this you don't understand, be sure to let me know. Bart brown
>> Wow. You just said a mouthful but you didn't answer the first question at Read this Byron: >Yet you would have everyone believe, just because you say so, that one sim is a sham and another is an accurate representation of the real thing, and that there is some sort of difference between "arcade" relationship to ACTUAL driving than the other. Have you ever considered the heretical notion that perhaps those differences exist in the individual mind, and each person has a different, but equally valid, experience of the things you do?>> I asked if CPR supporters were given the same consideration as he asks for. So no, I'm not happy with your reply because you didn't even address the question. Now I've said before that I am an idiot, so I'm sure I'm wrong, but isn't Barton saying in this paragraph that we all can have a different opinion as to what seems realistic in a sim and that our different opinions are all, equally valid. My question was pretty simple. Is this the same way he and others have treated the opinions of CPR supporters here at r.a.s.? You just said something I like is a piece of shit, so I don't get the feeling you don't agree with Barton's statement. Dave
> Wow. You just said a mouthful but you didn't answer the first question at > all. Let me try then. CPR full and patched is a piece of shit! GPL demo is a work of art and the artists still aren't happy and want to do a few more brush strokes before they put it on the shelves for show. But your still not happy with that answer are you Dave?
Quoted text (15 lines)> >> I'll keep saying it until you all realise it. GPL has got all the bounce > >> and roll and swerve of any arcade racer. Real 60's stuff was never so > >> bouncy, rolly or swervy. Just watch Speedvision and you'll see. > Since when did they create a motorsports that doesn't bounce, roll or > swerve?!? > Stock cars?? NOT > Indycars?? NOT > Rally cars?? NOT > Trucks?? NOT > Street cars?? NOT > Mountain bike?? NOT > F1?? gee I wonder what those suspension are for > Charles Mak's BMX?? YES IT DOESN'T BOUNCE, we got a winner here
ROFL!
>> Wow. You just said a mouthful but you didn't answer the first question at >> all. > Let me try then. CPR full and patched is a piece of shit! GPL demo is >a work of art and the artists still aren't happy and want to do a few >more brush strokes before they put it on the shelves for show. But your >still not happy with that answer are you Dave? Read this Byron: >Yet you would have everyone believe, just because you say so, that one sim is a sham and another is an accurate representation of the real thing, and that there is some sort of difference between "arcade" relationship to ACTUAL driving than the other. Have you ever considered the heretical notion that perhaps those differences exist in the individual mind, and each person has a different, but equally valid, experience of the things you do?>> I asked if CPR supporters were given the same consideration as he asks for. So no, I'm not happy with your reply because you didn't even address the question. Now I've said before that I am an idiot, so I'm sure I'm wrong, but isn't Barton saying in this paragraph that we all can have a different opinion as to what seems realistic in a sim and that our different opinions are all, equally valid. My question was pretty simple. Is this the same way he and others have treated the opinions of CPR supporters here at r.a.s.? You just said something I like is a piece of shit, so I don't get the feeling you agree with Barton's statement. Dave
>Andrew... RAS's most under-qualified opinion I doubt you can defend this title with such strong competition. :) Maybe one just remembers the good things, but I believe even at his prime, Ymenard wasn't as annoying as some people are today. BTW, Fran?ois grew up to become a reasonably sensible member of this NG. Goes to show how useful kill files with a time limit are. Oh, while speaking of defending titles, I think he has to drop the honor of being "Official Mentally retarded guy of r.a.s." The competition never sleeps. :) -- Wolfgang Preiss \ E-mail copies of replies to this posting are welcome. Uni des Saarlands \ and U.S. law. You have been warned.
Quoted text (11 lines)> I asked if CPR supporters were given the same consideration as he asks for. > So no, I'm not happy with your reply because you didn't even address the > question. Now I've said before that I am an idiot, so I'm sure I'm wrong, > but isn't Barton saying in this paragraph that we all can have a different > opinion as to what seems realistic in a sim and that our different opinions > are all, equally valid. My question was pretty simple. Is this the same way > he and others have treated the opinions of CPR supporters here at r.a.s.? > You just said something I like is a piece of shit, so I don't get the > feeling you agree with Barton's statement. > Dave
My point is that I don't see the CPR shitfight as a matter of realism. It's a matter of a non finished, totally unpolished product!
ymenard 18 Apr 1998#405420
>Maybe one just remembers the good things, but I believe even at his >prime, Ymenard wasn't as annoying as some people are today. I don't even want to get into this subject anymore. Darn I hate DejaNews ;-P Thank you for your good comment, I myself think I went from very low to "good", so now If I start to do my Eric T. Busch interpretation, I will maybe get spot by Papyrus and work for them ;-) (just joking, congratulations another time Eric). I still have the line in my *.sig file, but did some very high research and I work very hard to minimize the ratio it takes into my posting (I did around 50 drafts to finally arrive to my real signature file). I still have the line in an sarcastic way, maybe to make people laugh, I don't know, I would have to self-analyse myself but this could make me go crazy and ill (not-joking). Naw, I think Joel Putty is still the All-time leader here. :-P Just saw your post today btw (slipped by my ISP). Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard> Good race at the Brickyard, (-o-) Official Mentally retarded guy of r.a.s. Member of the r.a.s. Ego-maniac club Excuse me for my English (I'm French speaking) Excuse me for being provocative (I'm dumb speaking) --"People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."--

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy