Okay, I've just been watching 'Grand Prix' the movie and I want to
race at Monaco. Is it definite that this course will not be in the
sim?
*Fingers crossed.*
Why Monaco is missing from Grand Prix Legends
Fans asked whether Monaco would be in Grand Prix Legends. Posters blamed licensing, noting Monaco falls under the FIA licence, and debated whether Monaco is F1's jewel or a poor racing circuit. Others discussed the difficulty of recreating 1967 street layouts and welcomed the Nürburgring.
Automated summary.
Especially since it's possible to jump the barriers... *splosh*
:-)
--
Spudgun
Quoted text (16 lines)
>If there is no Monaco on this sim I'll consider it a disgrace. Monaco is<BR> >the jewel of Formula One. Papyrus should be crucified if they do not put >it<BR> >in the sim.<BR> ><BR> ><BR> >>Okay, I've just been watching 'Grand Prix' the movie and I want to<BR> >>race at Monaco. Is it definite that this course will not be in the<BR> >>sim?<BR> >><BR> >>*Fingers crossed.*<BR> >><BR> ><BR> ><BR> ></HTML>>You can blame the Principality of Monaco for this situation, NOT Papy. It's all
>about licensing.
>Don
Oh, bullshit... I suppose it's some sort of *** too. THey let GP2 and
Ubi f1RS use it cause they're nice guys, but Papyrus represents the evil
empire so we'll add a ridiculous fee...
Makes sense to me.
Fine...shoot the messanger. Happy Easter to you to.
>>Oh, bullshit.
>Fine...shoot the messanger. Happy Easter to you to.
Were you just born stupid, or did you have to work at it?
GPL when released is gonna sell a gajillion copies. Figure
they sell 250,000 copies ( not unreasonable) at 50.00 each
Thats a gross revenue of 12.5 MILLION dollars.
Now tell me about not being able to afford a liscencing fee
( if there even is one) when every other F1 sim seems to
have Monaco.
BTW you now owe me a fee for reading your drivel.
-=MAX=- wrote :
Gross revenues to CUC Software. They are known to not be very generous on
the pocket. THey let the Indianapolis Motor Speedway and also the Daytona
International Speedway slip under their hands to SEGA of America.
There is number of reason the FIA and the Monaco Principality don't want to
see a track modelled into the game. From the dangerous layout of these old
days, the security that was laking. If CUC doesn't offer a higher price than
other titles, why should they accept to model it ??
Oh and btw, for those who tried Andretti Racing (old one) on the PSX, check
out the track layout. Some of them are ACTUAL tracks (I can recall
Interlagos) but under different name and graphics. They are really close to
actual illegal copyrighting.
I'm sure you will buy it even if it's not in the simulator. Shame to you if
not. There is enough challenge besides.
Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard> Sponsored by http://www.awpss.com/
Good race at the Brickyard, (-o-)
Official Mentally retarded guy of r.a.s.
Excuse me for my English (I'm French speaking)
Excuse me for being provocative (I'm dumb speaking)
--"People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."--
>Papyrus should be crucified if they do not put it in the sim.
According to you, Papyrus should be crucified anyway .. although I note
that your statement at least acknowledges that what you've been berating
from press and pulpit is NOT the actual sim, but a demo. Keep going with
that thought...
Bart brown
Quoted text (11 lines)
> If there is no Monaco on this sim I'll consider it a disgrace. Monaco is > the jewel of Formula One. Papyrus should be crucified if they do not put it > in the sim. > >Okay, I've just been watching 'Grand Prix' the movie and I want to > >race at Monaco. Is it definite that this course will not be in the > >sim? > >*Fingers crossed.*Here we see, once again, that the people who are the most deliberately
insulting are, curiously enough, those who hide their identities behind
exceptionally lame "spam blockers". Trolling has become such an art form
in this NG that rank amateurs need not apply...
BTW, the paraphrasis regarding spammers which you ascribe to "B.
Franklin" is actually a (crudely) disfigured line from W. Shakespeare.
If you're going to affect a level of literary erudition to which you
clearly have not risen, at least get the attribution right...
Bart Brown
On Sun, 12 Apr 1998 10:03:50 -0400, "Charles Mak"
>If there is no Monaco on this sim I'll consider it a disgrace. Monaco is
>the jewel of Formula One. Papyrus should be crucified if they do not put it
>in the sim.
Isn't that just a TOUCH extreme? I couldn't even crucify MS for
releasing CPR without any tracks that could be driven realistically so
I'm unlikely to consider such atrocities for anyone else.
Monaco is acknowledged by F1 drivers to be the worst track of the
year, and to say Monaco is the "raison d'etre" or the "jewel in the
crown" is to exhibit a spectacular misunderstanding of the sport.
Either that or simply a wish to moan about everything related to GPL.
Shall we take a quick vote on which it is?
AFAIK there is nothing announced one way or the other about Monaco, so
unless you are a manic depressive please wait to be disappointed
before being so.
That's quite enough attention for now.
Cheers!
John
> You've "got a spectacular misunderstanding" about what Monaco represents to the F1 community. The cache of Monaco is so great that it has remained on the F1 calendar year in year out despite the fact that it is totally unsuitable for a present day F1 race.>>
Dear God,
Without argument, Monaco has a "cachet" (the word for which you were
unsuccesfully groping); but truth oft wears a wry face, and your
assertion that Monaco is "totally unsuitable for a present day F1 race"
is about the only sensible thing I've seen you post yet, though I'm sure
you meant it entirely differently: since we're talking about F1 races of
a generation ago rather than today, perhaps your circuitous reasoning
has a logic you didn't intend, or quite possibly even perceive.
Be that as it may, in the last few years the Automobile Club of Monaco,
like the ACO, FIA, and IMS, have awakened to the cachet of their own
venue, and started demanding licensing fees for the use of their name
and various "trademark" elements of the yearly GP. If you don't think
that's true -- and you've apparently convinced yourself that WHATEVER
you think has the imprimatur of the One Truth -- you might want to
contact M. Roy Hulsbergen, of Interactive Media Development S. C. S. in
Monaco. I'm sure he'd be glad to explain it all to you.
<<You are so wrong. Why are people in this NG so misguided?>>
Do you troll in every newsgroup, or just this one?
Bart Brown
> Just a thought. But recreating a race track that was actually city streets in the condition it was in over 30 years ago would be a task of extrem difficulty.>>
The only truly major change since 1967, other than the merely scenic,
has been the re-routing of the quayside straight around the new swimming
pool complex. Certainly the tunnel looks completely different, Rascasse
is a new name but a very minor variation of its former trajectory, and
the crowds are most emphatically not as well-dressed. Whatever else of
consequence is easily recreated from the voluminous pictorial record of
the circuit, probably the most-photographed more-or-less 2 miles of
urban streets in the history of the world.
Bart Brown
Hmmm...you don't suppose Bandini's fatal '67 accident would have anything
to do with this decision, would you???
Earl
> If there is no Monaco on this sim I'll consider it a disgrace. Monaco is
> the jewel of Formula One. Papyrus should be crucified if they do not put it
> in the sim.
The JEWEL OF FORMULA ONE?!!!!!!!!!Come off it!!
Monaco is the thorn in the soft, fleshy part of Formula One.
--
Bruce.
(At home)
>> If there is no Monaco on this sim I'll consider it a disgrace. Monaco is
>> the jewel of Formula One. Papyrus should be crucified if they do not put it
>> in the sim.
wrong again Charles, in F1 now, the race that people want to win are either
Italy or Belgium. Back in the 1960's, they all want to tame the Nurburgring
monster
Monaco meant a lot to the people in Monaco of course, but if you do a survey
elsewhere or just between the drivers, they will tell you the race they want
to win is Monza
Quoted text (14 lines)
>You've "got a spectacular misunderstanding" about what Monaco represents to >the F1 community. The cache of Monaco is so great that it has remained on >the F1 calendar year in year out despite the fact that it is totally >unsuitable for a present day F1 race. To get rid of Monaco is unthinkable >to those who run F1. >Monaco is acknowledged by F1 drivers to be the worst track of the >>year, and to say Monaco is the "raison d'etre" or the "jewel in the >>crown" is to exhibit a spectacular misunderstanding of the sport. >>Either that or simply a wish to moan about everything related to GPL. >>Shall we take a quick vote on which it is?Just a thought. But recreating a race track that was actually city
streets in the condition it was in over 30 years ago would be a task of
extrem difficulty. I read someware that the streets have changed so much
that racers who actually raced there at theat time dont even recognize
most of the course. And working from old city plans and diagrams wont
reveal any of the minor details witch destinguished it. At the beast the
can create a general aproximation but there is no longer any way to know
how close you got to the real thing.
But all that aside, I also feel that it should be included in any sim
or arcade racer, that trys to represent that time. It was both loved and
hated by the racers of the day. but it cant be denied that it is
legendary. Good track or bad, it is still one of the most revered tracks
of all time.
Barton Spencer Brown wrote with regards to the evil C. Mak:
I resent that!!Trolls are a *fine* part of Norwegian folklore, and
should not be put down!! :)))))
Matt,
Up North
--
Matthew Birger Knutsen
Cheek Racing Cars (http://home.sn.no/~kareknut)
"Racing cars is like dancing with a chainsaw"
-Cale Yarborough
Monaco is still an F1 track today, and hence will most likely be
covered under the FIA license.
Cheers!
John
I can assure you, Mr. Mak, that in this era of non-sentimentality, when the
directors and entrepreneurs associated with F1 are more interested in all that
glisters rather than all that is of historical interest, if it weren't for the
vast amount of money that the Monagesque event brings in, its place would have
been taken away years ago.
What it (the event) represents to the "F1 community" is stuff all. It may be a
sentimental favourite of the so-called beautiful people who inhabit the
principality for the race week and it may be a favourite of television viewers
but it is NOT a favourite of the teams.
> You've "got a spectacular misunderstanding" about what Monaco represents to
> the F1 community. The cache of Monaco is so great that it has remained on
> the F1 calendar year in year out despite the fact that it is totally
> unsuitable for a present day F1 race. To get rid of Monaco is unthinkable
> to those who run F1.
--
Bruce.
(At home)
On second thoughts, you're not French-Canadian by any chance, are you?
> You are so wrong. Why are people in this NG so misguided?--
Bruce.
(At home)
Excuse my Antipodean ignorance, but isn't the term "trolling", when used
herein, the same as the fishing term....as in "trolling a line" and
hoping that something bites?
--
Bruce.
(At home)
Quoted text (19 lines)
> Barton Spencer Brown wrote with regards to the evil C. Mak: > > Do you troll in every newsgroup, or just this one? > > Bart Brown > I resent that!!Trolls are a *fine* part of Norwegian folklore, and > should not be put down!! :))))) > Matt, > Up North > -- > Matthew Birger Knutsen > Cheek Racing Cars (http://home.sn.no/~kareknut) > "Racing cars is like dancing with a chainsaw" > -Cale YarboroughAll that goes for any race track though, they've all been through
significant variations with corners being made wider, tighter, bumps
being evened out, surface material being changed, etc. There may not even
be accurate plans of the old track layouts.
There is a lot of vintage footage of Monaco available though, indeed
rather more so probably than for any other track except maybe Indy. So
recreating the 'feel' isn't likely to be a problem.
If Monaco doesn't make it into the final game then it will be due to
intractable licensing difficulties. Nothing else.
Cheers,
Richard
On Sun, 12 Apr 1998 19:50:12 -0400, "Charles Mak"
>You've "got a spectacular misunderstanding" about what Monaco represents to
>the F1 community. The cache of Monaco is so great that it has remained on
>the F1 calendar year in year out despite the fact that it is totally
>unsuitable for a present day F1 race. To get rid of Monaco is unthinkable
>to those who run F1.
The "cache" of Monaco? I was unaware of any SRAM fabs in the
principality. Heck I'm not doing my job properly!
Monaco represents very little to the F1 community, and even the greats
of Monaco like Senna, Prost and Hill (snr) would far rather have raced
somewhere more entertaining. Monaco does of course have a strong
attraction and that is with the fans and "the beautiful people". The
attraction to a worldwide audience, promoters and sponsors of having a
race there and being invited is inestimable, and that is the reason it
has satyed on the calendar so long. Nothing to do with the track or
the driver's love of it.
I hope it's in there, as racing a '67 GP car around Monaco would be
awesome, but given the choice of Monaco v's Spa, or perhaps Monaco v's
Nurburgring and I'd forget Monaco.
Cheers!
John
I didn't say it would be easy or perfect ;-) But I've seen a lot of
footage from before the swimming pool complex was introduced and the
'Nouveau' chicane was introduced and there are plenty of camera angles to
choose from for most bits of track. So I really don't see why the 1967
Monaco should be any harder to reproduce than the 67 Silverston, 67 Glen
or any of the other tracks. And if there are some minor flaws it's fgoing
to be damn difficult to spot them <g>
I suspect that it will be more to do with using the name 'Monaco Grand
Prix' or similar than the track layout or views of buildings that are
effectively in the public domain. Also even if Papy could legally get
away with something they might not want to do so if it would annoy any
existing or future license holders. Sad, though :(
Cheers,
Richard
<chuckle> Monaco doesn't seem to have much in the way of sand. Perhaps
they'd be interested in your high quality processed variety? They could
certainly afford it ;-)
G_B
On 12 Apr 1998 23:31:22 EDT, Barton Spencer Brown
>The only truly major change since 1967, other than the merely scenic,
>has been the re-routing of the quayside straight around the new swimming
>pool complex. Certainly the tunnel looks completely different, Rascasse
>is a new name but a very minor variation of its former trajectory, and
>the crowds are most emphatically not as well-dressed.
La Rascasse is pretty different actually. In 1967 it was a simple
hairpin, whereas nowadays it is a slow three corner complex. The
swimming pool is the main addition though, and everything else should
be exactly the same AFAI recall from "Grand Prix".
Cheers!
John
treebark wrote :
Hmm, most of the time Papyrus track modeling is made from photos, and in-car
video took from actual SimRacers. I can recall AFAIK Brian Tate who was in
charge of taking pictures of some BGN track (Hickory and/or Myrtle Beach).
But I don't remember 1 track that was from a Papyrus title who was
criticized. Sure some of them (especially early titles) weren't very
realistic. Well, it was in relation with their old game engine.
Non-straight pits on oval, walls where they shouldn't be (to prevent
cheating and stuff).
I think you are probably talking about Cart:PR, by Microsoft, who has a
poor (very poor) Cleveland track.
Fran?ois Mnard <ymenard> Good race at the Brickyard, (-o-)
Official Mentally retarded guy of r.a.s.
Member of the r.a.s. Ego-maniac club
Excuse me for my English (I'm French speaking)
Excuse me for being provocative (I'm dumb speaking)
--"People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world."--
> If there is no Monaco on this sim I'll consider it a disgrace. Monaco is
> the jewel of Formula One. Papyrus should be crucified if they do not put it
> in the sim.
Don't you think Papy should be crucified anyway?
Quoted text (8 lines)
> >> If there is no Monaco on this sim I'll consider it a disgrace. Monaco is > >> the jewel of Formula One. Papyrus should be crucified if they do not put > it > >> in the sim. > wrong again Charles, in F1 now, the race that people want to win are either > Italy or Belgium. Back in the 1960's, they all want to tame the Nurburgring > monster> You are so wrong. Why are people in this NG so misguided?
Ok then, on behalf of this NG I grant you leave!
> You've "got a spectacular misunderstanding" about what Monaco represents to
> the F1 community. The cache of Monaco is so great that it has remained on
> the F1 calendar year in year out despite the fact that it is totally
> unsuitable for a present day F1 race. To get rid of Monaco is unthinkable
> to those who run F1.
As I'd expect, you've made a complete idiot out of yourself again.
Those who run F1 are as spastic orientated as you. F1 is supposed to be
all about going faster yet over the last decade we see every attemp
being made by the brilliant rulemakers to slow F1 down. Slow F1 down?
That's like trying to build the lowest skyscraper! Both Monaco and the
F1 rulemakers should be pissed right off out of F1 altogether!
Quoted text (7 lines)
> > Just a thought. But recreating a race track that was actually city streets in the condition it was in over 30 years ago would be a task of extrem difficulty.>> > The only truly major change since 1967, other than the merely scenic, > has been the re-routing of the quayside straight around the new swimming > pool complex. Certainly the tunnel looks completely different, Rascasse > is a new name but a very minor variation of its former trajectory, and > the crowds are most emphatically not as well-dressed. Whatever else ofQuoted text (13 lines)
> >Just a thought. But recreating a race track that was actually city > >streets in the condition it was in over 30 years ago would be a task of > >extrem difficulty. I read someware that the streets have changed so much > >that racers who actually raced there at theat time dont even recognize > >most of the course. And working from old city plans and diagrams wont > >reveal any of the minor details witch destinguished it. At the beast the > >can create a general aproximation but there is no longer any way to know > >how close you got to the real thing. > All that goes for any race track though, they've all been through > significant variations with corners being made wider, tighter, bumps > being evened out, surface material being changed, etc. There may not even > be accurate plans of the old track layouts.Actually I think reproducing any of these tracks as they were will be/
was difficult to do. Monaco may be more so though. Your right tough, no
matter what the result, wether acurate or not, we wont notice the flaws.
I never raced there so I could never tell the difference. If monico
makes it into the game I would like to hear the impressions of some
drivers that did really race there.
Yes very sad!
Lets all hope Monaco makes it into the game. I havent had a good racer
in a while and this game has certinly got me interested again.
Unfortanately I have to upgrade the computer just to play it, but I have
to do that anyway.
**Spelling mistakes are curtasy of my laziness to use my spell
checker.**
Aha! Does the name "Doctor Evil" mean anything to you, Austin? Hmmmm?
--
Bruce.
(At home)
Quoted text (15 lines)
> No I am an International Man of Mystery; born in Brazil raised in Europe, > Far East, and Canada and possess three citizenships plus a US green card. > And I am not kidding! > >On second thoughts, you're not French-Canadian by any chance, are you? > >> You are so wrong. Why are people in this NG so misguided?-- > >Bruce. > >(At home)snip
> I hope it's in there, as racing a '67 GP car around Monaco would be
> awesome, but given the choice of Monaco v's Spa, or perhaps Monaco v's
> Nurburgring and I'd forget Monaco.
Nurburgring, Nurburgring, Nurburgring, Nurburgring..... prozac
Sorry, it`s just that I love that track SO much and having on a couple
of occasions gone round the Nordschleife reasonably fast in roadcars, I
want to do it in a (simulated) racecar as well :-D
Beers and cheers
(uncle) Goy
UncleGoy on TEN
> No I am an International Man of Mystery; born in Brazil raised in Europe,
> Far East, and Canada and possess three citizenships plus a US green card.
> And I am not kidding!
No wonder your so confused! Settle down somewhere and get it together
will ya! And I'm not kidding either :)
Monaco is a classic track, just like Spa and Monza. I would like to see it
included in this game. It does not matter if the turns are not very accurate,
or if layout is not perfect. What matters is that this track is a classic.
Wouldn't you guys like to win a race in Monaco? I would!!!! I know it is a hard
track, specially for today's race cars, but it is fun to drive. Have you guys
ever tried to race a complete race in Monaco on GP2?? Is there anything more
challenging than make the first turn without crashing and without losing too
many positions??? Is there anything more challenging than trying to pass the
leader in the last laps???
I really would like to see it on GPL, it doesn't matter how good it is....
Cheers,
Domingos
Papy is probably trying VERY had to get all the tracks they want in.
But sometimes you run into licesing snares that you can do nothing
about, wheather you have $12.50 or $12.5 million... it's the same deal
with why Papy cant get Daytona in their NASCAR sims. I'm sure they
would LOVE to put that track in, but Sega has a deal where they get the
sole rights to the track. I'm sure Monaco wont be THAT complicated to
get, but somethimes there is just nothing you can do.
Brian Short


































