Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

CPR: what breaks the full game?

77 posts by 18 people · 19 Mar 1998 - 02 Apr 1998

Flame warCPR's remaining flaws and a feud over its critics

A poster found the new CART Precision Racing demo smooth and asked what was wrong with the full game. Replies cited frame rate drops with more cars, missing yellow flags, braking and steering issues, while George Sandman defended the game and online racing. The thread became a heated exchange between Byron Forbes and CPR supporters, with side arguments over Microsoft requiring Internet Explorer for the Zone.

review/impressionscommunity/metaCART Precision Racing

Automated summary.

ttam 19 Mar 1998#400254
I've seen people complain about the slowness of CPR, among other things. That's how I felt with the old CPR demo too, without dashboard it was smooth and crisp, but with it pretty jerky at times on my P233MMX. Yesterday I decided to try the _new_ CPR demo, and I was pleasantly surprised how fast and smooth it ran with full graphics and the dashboard. Much improved from the first demo, I couldn't tell any fps difference between with or without***pit anymore. It ran fine even with two cars in sight, as I recall it slowed down quite a bit in the same situation in the first demo (with dashboard). The only way I got the frame rate take a definite hit was to go reverse, the smoke I saw in front of me slowed the game down quite a bit. When people complain about the jerky graphics, are you talking about the first version or the patched version of CPR? Demo has only four cars I believe, is it much worse with more cars? What are the things that really break the full game? What exactly is wrong with the computer AI? I probably couldn't tell with the demo because of only a few computer drivers. How about the lack of yellow flag, I've seen it has been the killer for many people. Other than being unrealistic, how does the lack of it degrade the gameplay? Is it now official that CPR is as good as it gets, no patches anymore? Thanks for any information. I think I like F1RS more, but I just want to know if CPR is worth it if and when it can be found in discount bins. On related news, funny thing though how one place here in Finland had just reduced the price of Nascar 2 as the 3Dfx patch came out, funny coincidence. Nascar (both the race and game) never were that big in Europe it appears, so Nascar 2 found its way to the discount bins pretty quickly here, and it seems to have completely disappeared from most shelves and price lists here already. The place where there were still a few of them, they sold it for 89 FIM, whereas new games generally cost around 270-310 FIM, F1RS for example. The software dealer wasn't very happy when he heard from me (after paying that 80 of course) that they had just released a 3Dfx patch for the game. I guess he figured out he could probably add another digit in front of that price, and it would still sell for a few 3Dfx owners. Heh heh, you can't always win. ;-) Too bad that also probably means the extra track packs for Nascar 2 won't be available here either. Oh well. *** [link lost in import]
The yellow flags degrade gameplay because there would be ALOT of them had they been put into the game. which means the AI sucks in that it can't keep crashing you or other cars.
Quoted text (50 lines)>I've seen people complain about the slowness of CPR, among other >things. That's how I felt with the old CPR demo too, without dashboard >it was smooth and crisp, but with it pretty jerky at times on my >P233MMX. >Yesterday I decided to try the _new_ CPR demo, and I was pleasantly >surprised how fast and smooth it ran with full graphics and the >dashboard. Much improved from the first demo, I couldn't tell any fps >difference between with or without***pit anymore. It ran fine even >with two cars in sight, as I recall it slowed down quite a bit in the >same situation in the first demo (with dashboard). The only way I got >the frame rate take a definite hit was to go reverse, the smoke I saw >in front of me slowed the game down quite a bit. >When people complain about the jerky graphics, are you talking about >the first version or the patched version of CPR? Demo has only four >cars I believe, is it much worse with more cars? >What are the things that really break the full game? What exactly is >wrong with the computer AI? I probably couldn't tell with the demo >because of only a few computer drivers. How about the lack of yellow >flag, I've seen it has been the killer for many people. Other than >being unrealistic, how does the lack of it degrade the gameplay? >Is it now official that CPR is as good as it gets, no patches anymore? >Thanks for any information. I think I like F1RS more, but I just want >to know if CPR is worth it if and when it can be found in discount >bins. >On related news, funny thing though how one place here in Finland had >just reduced the price of Nascar 2 as the 3Dfx patch came out, funny >coincidence. Nascar (both the race and game) never were that big in >Europe it appears, so Nascar 2 found its way to the discount bins >pretty quickly here, and it seems to have completely disappeared from >most shelves and price lists here already. The place where there were >still a few of them, they sold it for 89 FIM, whereas new games >generally cost around 270-310 FIM, F1RS for example. The software >dealer wasn't very happy when he heard from me (after paying that 80 >of course) that they had just released a 3Dfx patch for the game. >I guess he figured out he could probably add another digit in front of >that price, and it would still sell for a few 3Dfx owners. Heh heh, >you can't always win. ;-) >Too bad that also probably means the extra track packs for >Nascar 2 won't be available here either. Oh well. >*** >[link lost in import]
Kevin 19 Mar 1998#400256
>When people complain about the jerky graphics, are you talking about >the first version or the patched version of CPR? Demo has only four >cars I believe, is it much worse with more cars? The latest patch improves the frame rate significantly. I saw improvements that averaged 25% in FPS. However, the frame rate still takes a major dive when you increase the draw ahead distance, increase the graphics detail (sky, track-side objects, etc.), or race against more than a few computer controlled cars. I have 200 MMX system with a Pure3D card. For comparison purposes, I can max F1RS out in every category and get liquid smooth frame rates. And the maxed out graphics detail of F1RS is superior to the maxed out level of CPR. The AI is slow, even if you max it out in the .ini file. They are reluctant to pass, stick to their line, and avoid you like the plague. They are better on the road courses than on the ovals. I don't race the ovals, but I've heard the most complaints here. I finally became fed up with the game. If you don't own F1RS, I highly suggest purchasing it instead. Racing against the AI is very fun in this game. -- Kevin (Remove the "x-" prefix from my address in order to reply via email)
>> The yellow flags degrade gameplay because there would be ALOT of them had >> they been put into the game. which means the AI sucks in that it can't keep >> crashing you or other cars. > Hey George, good point. All the stuff about CPR and this is the first >time I've seen the reason for the ommision of yellows in CPR. Dunno how >we all let that one slip by! Between the steering wander, bad breaks and >the AI, all races would have been nothing but yellows :) Hehehehe, Is this the same guy that is complaining about the off track performance in F1RS? What are you doing off track anyway Byron? Having problems controlling your car there too huh? Hmmm I guess ICR2 is the only Sim that lets you get away with a little off roading right? Maybe it is best that CPR dont have full course yellows cause your whole race would be under yellow! The Sandman
> The yellow flags degrade gameplay because there would be ALOT of them had > they been put into the game. which means the AI sucks in that it can't keep > crashing you or other cars. Hey George, good point. All the stuff about CPR and this is the first time I've seen the reason for the ommision of yellows in CPR. Dunno how we all let that one slip by! Between the steering wander, bad breaks and the AI, all races would have been nothing but yellows :)
>> >> The yellow flags degrade gameplay because there would be ALOT of them had >> >> they been put into the game. which means the AI sucks in that it can't
Quoted text (22 lines)>> keep >> >> crashing you or other cars. >> > Hey George, good point. All the stuff about CPR and this is the first >> >time I've seen the reason for the ommision of yellows in CPR. Dunno how >> >we all let that one slip by! Between the steering wander, bad breaks and >> >the AI, all races would have been nothing but yellows :) >> Hehehehe, Is this the same guy that is complaining about the off track >> performance in F1RS? What are you doing off track anyway Byron? > Well, it's rare and so that's what makes it stand out so much! >> Having problems controlling your car there too huh? Hmmm >> I guess ICR2 is the only Sim that lets you get away with a little off >> roading right? > You should know George. (gee, 2 Georges in 1 thread - alter egos?). >ICR2 models off track stuff very well. If the car is loaded up highly >then your history. If not, it's as drivable as you'd expect. Can you say >that about CPR or F1RS?
ICR2 Models off track stuff very well. hmmmm Go check out my 1:36.490 replay at Elk again Byron. I never lifted the throttle at exit of Turn 1. hmmmm I guess thats the way I would expect a real race car should run right. Full throttle on the grass that feels just like the track. Right hahahaha And you obviously havent tried getting a Tire off track in CPR in the Pro or Interm modes with the latest ver huh Byron? You will get dizzy you will spin so fast! No you just keep torturing us with comments on CPR which you have never owned!
Quoted text (12 lines)> >> The yellow flags degrade gameplay because there would be ALOT of them had > >> they been put into the game. which means the AI sucks in that it can't > keep > >> crashing you or other cars. > > Hey George, good point. All the stuff about CPR and this is the first > >time I've seen the reason for the ommision of yellows in CPR. Dunno how > >we all let that one slip by! Between the steering wander, bad breaks and > >the AI, all races would have been nothing but yellows :) > Hehehehe, Is this the same guy that is complaining about the off track > performance in F1RS? What are you doing off track anyway Byron?
Well, it's rare and so that's what makes it stand out so much! You should know George. (gee, 2 Georges in 1 thread - alter egos?). ICR2 models off track stuff very well. If the car is loaded up highly then your history. If not, it's as drivable as you'd expect. Can you say that about CPR or F1RS? I'd say it's best because otherwise I might be tempted to run CPR and torture myself again. Nah!
>>> Hehehehe, Is this the same guy that is complaining about the off track >>> performance in F1RS? What are you doing off track anyway Byron? Probably the same thing most F1 drivers do regularly...putting a wheel off after running out of rumble strip on the exit of a turn. Which is completely wrong (in more ways than one). First of all, you do NOT always "spin so fast" by putting a tire off the track in CPR. Secondly, after having sat in the turn 4 grandstands for a CART race at Laguna Seca, I can tell you that these guys put tires off the road FAR more often than you ever see on TV. And they do NOT spin 99% of the time. Most of the time, they just let off a bit and carefully guide the car back onto the track. Vasser went all 4 wheels off on the exit of 4 and nearly scraped the wall, and more drivers than I can count put tires off, kicking up dirt. The problems with CPR have relatively little to do with the off-course behavior. The simple truth is the physics model is all wrong for a high downforce car, and the brake-travel to braking power ratio is way out of whack. Randy
Quoted text (7 lines)>>>> Hehehehe, Is this the same guy that is complaining about the off track >>>> performance in F1RS? What are you doing off track anyway Byron? >Probably the same thing most F1 drivers do regularly...putting a wheel >off after running out of rumble strip on the exit of a turn. >>And you obviously havent tried getting a Tire off track in CPR in the Pro
or
Quoted text (12 lines)>>Interm modes with the latest ver huh Byron? You will get dizzy you will >>spin so fast! >Which is completely wrong (in more ways than one). First of all, you >do NOT always "spin so fast" by putting a tire off the track in CPR. >Secondly, after having sat in the turn 4 grandstands for a CART race >at Laguna Seca, I can tell you that these guys put tires off the road >FAR more often than you ever see on TV. And they do NOT spin 99% of >the time. Most of the time, they just let off a bit and carefully >guide the car back onto the track. Vasser went all 4 wheels off on >the exit of 4 and nearly scraped the wall, and more drivers than I can >count put tires off, kicking up dirt.
Well if you had seem the Elk replay I was talking about Randy and did the same in CPR I guarentee you will spin like crazy. I suggest you check it out if you have ICR2!! And Of course if you do get off throttle and ease it you wont spin and that is just what you would have to do in reality. I agree that the travel wasnt what I was used to in ICR2,GP2 or other sims burt you really think that CART drivers move there pedal 4 inches. hehehehe Come on Randy, You of all people should know that there braking is set up with little travel, Maybe more than CPR but not near the other Sims. Hey Even on my work truck I move my brake pedal about 3/4" to 1 inch and the ABS kicks in??? BTW I even have my Pedal travel reduced by 1.5 inches or so and I can still threshold and Trail brake CPR? Took me about 10 mins to get used to it. How about we suggest to them that we want to slam the brake to the floor and we dont want it to lock up. I'm sure that would make alot of you guys happy! George
> And you obviously havent tried getting a Tire off track in CPR in the Pro or > Interm modes with the latest ver huh Byron? You will get dizzy you will > spin so fast! Never got that far. Too busy laughing after first couple of laps like most normal, non CPR fanatical, non MS employed people. Btw George, how much did MS pay you for that advise about traction that you gave them for the latest patch? Yeah, I'm certainly a fool for not buying CPR. I suppose us lesser individuals just can't appreciate the brilliance of CPR like you George. One day I hope to be able to get up to your level so I can properly appreciate such things. Until then I'll just stick to playing with my train sets.
> The problems with CPR have relatively little to do with the off-course > behavior. The simple truth is the physics model is all wrong for a > high downforce car, and the brake-travel to braking power ratio is way > out of whack. > Randy Look out Randy! George is one of the people who advised MS as to what they should do to fix CPR ie traction, heheheheheh. Looks like they paid him for that and to do a little CPR defending on various forums!
>Well if you had seem the Elk replay I was talking about Randy and did the >same in CPR I guarentee you will spin like crazy. I suggest you check it out >if you have ICR2!! Fine. I know that this happens a lot in ICR2 and I know that in ICR2 its relatively easy to cut corners for big time savings. Cleveland was so bad many leagues had to adopt some special replay rules to ensure people weren't mowing the grass too much. Yes, little travel but HIGH PRESSURE. I've never seen a brake system for a PC which accurately simulates the fact that brakes are PRESSURE devices, not deflection devices. The ideal brake would be on with almost no travel, because you'd press harder and harder rather than get more pedal deflection. A real car can have little brake pedal deflection because its truly a pressure device. Since we don't have that with almost every set of PC pedals out there, it has to be made up for with travel, and the fact of the matter is that CPR doesn't have enough travel, nor does there appear to be any difference in travel-to-lockup at high speeds vs. low speeds. This isn't really a debatable issue. If you want realistic travel for CPR, you're going to have to tell me how I can come by pressure-sensitive brakes that make that deflection worthwhile and realistic. Its not that you can't get used to it. Its that a) it shouldn't be necessary, and b) the amount of braking which will lockup the wheels is nearly unchanged at high or low speeds. Check the telemetry traces and you'll see what I mean. You end up braking exactly the same regardless of whether you're doing 50 mph or 150 mph. Find someone else to insult, George. I'm not going to be baited by this strawman argument. No one wants to not emulate lock-up, but neither do people want the same braking characteristics at any speed, and since most PC pedals don't offer the kind of resistance a real brake pedal would, its unrealistic to assume that everyone should just 'touch' their brakes, as you do in CPR. Its unrealistic and you know it. Besides, I get the feeling you're arguing for arguments sake. I'm really surprised you would even choose to debate brake pedal travel. You had to know how easily the points you made were going to get refuted. Randy
> Look out Randy! George is one of the people who advised MS as to what >they should do to fix CPR ie traction, heheheheheh. Looks like they paid >him for that and to do a little CPR defending on various forums! I've raced George on the Zone and he's a fine driver in CPR. I'm glad he's doing so well with CPR. However, his experience is not the same as most other people. I've found that I can get used to the problems with CPR and drive it reasonably well, but it wrecks my ability to drive any other sim, because of the poor brake pedal travel and massive high speed oversteer. Randy
Scott White 23 Mar 1998#400881
Yeah I think sticking to trains would probably be best for a person like you anyway. However I dont think there is a model train newsgroup for you to flame on so your life should be easier. If you do find yourself a model train newsgroup just remember to actually play with your train set before you actually flame it. You might be taken seriously. >> And you obviously havent tried getting a Tire off track in CPR in the Pro or
Quoted text (16 lines)>> Interm modes with the latest ver huh Byron? You will get dizzy you will >> spin so fast! > Never got that far. Too busy laughing after first couple of laps like >most normal, non CPR fanatical, non MS employed people. Btw George, how >much did MS pay you for that advise about traction that you gave them >for the latest patch? >> No you just keep torturing us with comments on CPR which you have never >> owned! > Yeah, I'm certainly a fool for not buying CPR. I suppose us lesser >individuals just can't appreciate the brilliance of CPR like you George. >One day I hope to be able to get up to your level so I can properly >appreciate such things. Until then I'll just stick to playing with my >train sets.
Scott White 23 Mar 1998#400882
The tiltle says it all. Byron, everyone knows CPR has huge short comings. Get a life dude! You dont own the game, I doubt you even played the demo. You are a flaming idiot on the newsgroup. Do you have anything enlighting to say about this game and the people who enjoy it? Or are you just a flaming idiot? All I see in your posts are the same old things that have been run over and over again about CPR and how bad it sux. Who cares anymore that CPR sucks? Who cares if you think people who play CPR are fools? You arent shedding any light on anything that hasnt been dicussed here before. From all the posts I see on this NG from you is a bunch of negative posts about a game that is clearly below par. Your existance must be hell
Kevin 23 Mar 1998#400883
>BTW I even have my Pedal travel reduced by 1.5 inches or so and I can still >threshold and Trail brake CPR? Took me about 10 mins to get used to it. I don't think the effects of trail braking are modeled in CPR. The car doesn't seem to turn in when trail braking or lifting the throttle. Several others have commented on this also. The brakes shouldn't lock up when you're at high speed. Too much downforce. So, yes, this would probably make many people happy. -- Kevin (Remove the "x-" prefix from my address in order to reply via email)
> Yeah I think sticking to trains would probably be best for a person like you > anyway. However I dont think there is a model train newsgroup for you to > flame on so your life should be easier. If you do find yourself a model > train newsgroup just remember to actually play with your train set before > you actually flame it. You might be taken seriously. Thanks for the tip Scotty. Since CPR has no yellows, pitiful AI and terminal speeds on the ovals, (sorry, I don't own the game so this could be wrong since it's just what I've heard from a couple of million sources) etc, etc, etc, and consequently fails to offer a full CART experience, especially after offering sooooo much, I just can't seem to bring myself to make the purchase. It's interesting to note that George and others got it for free and that seems a fair price for an alpha/demo. PS - Scott, I think we could all live without the garbage tacked onto the end of your last dribble. PS #2 - can anyone reccomend a good train set, preferably one with round wheels and a tendancy to stay on the tracks? Thanks in advance :)
Quoted text (12 lines)> > Look out Randy! George is one of the people who advised MS as to what > >they should do to fix CPR ie traction, heheheheheh. Looks like they paid > >him for that and to do a little CPR defending on various forums! > I've raced George on the Zone and he's a fine driver in CPR. I'm glad > he's doing so well with CPR. However, his experience is not the same > as most other people. I've found that I can get used to the problems > with CPR and drive it reasonably well, but it wrecks my ability to > drive any other sim, because of the poor brake pedal travel and > massive high speed oversteer. > Randy
Ditto. George is a great driver who's dominated with ICR2 and is sick of it. He desperately wants/wanted CPR to be its replacement. I just don't understand why he and others are so defensive about CPR though.
> Ditto. George is a great driver who's dominated with ICR2 and is >sick of it. He desperately wants/wanted CPR to be its replacement. Well, lets see, how many other up-to-date CART sims are there out there to compete with it? None. All you have to be is a CART fan and you want CPR to be the one, simply because its THERE and its got all the new goodies we are getting in F1 sims. But unfortunately, WANTING a sim to be the best and saying that it IS the best are two different things. George obviously has overcome the problems that others have with it and are happy. I'm not going to rain on his parade. As I said, he's proven himself a very capable sim-driver and I'm glad he's having fun. I wish I could be as gung-ho about CPR as he is. I'm a CART fan before I'm an F1 or NASCAR fan, and given a choice would go for a CART sim before anything else...but the thing is what it is. Some things can be glossed over and others ignored...but in my case there are a few too many things I have to 'get over' before I can properly enjoy the game. I wish I was in George's shoes and could enjoy this one the way he does....but I can't. Perhaps he's just a CART fan, like me, and figures he's just going to make do with whatever comes out. I dunno...ask him. Randy Randy Magruder Contributing Reviewer Digital Sportspage http://www.digitalsports.com
Quoted text (10 lines)> The tiltle says it all. Byron, everyone knows CPR has huge short comings. > Get a life dude! You dont own the game, I doubt you even played the demo. > You are a flaming idiot on the newsgroup. Do you have anything enlighting to > say about this game and the people who enjoy it? Or are you just a flaming > idiot? All I see in your posts are the same old things that have been run > over and over again about CPR and how bad it sux. Who cares anymore that CPR > sucks? Who cares if you think people who play CPR are fools? You arent > shedding any light on anything that hasnt been dicussed here before. From > all the posts I see on this NG from you is a bunch of negative posts about a > game that is clearly below par. Your existance must be hell
Firstly Scott, thanks for not tagging all that ***on the end of this post. I have used both demo's and have read much on CPR hoping it would shape up to be all it was supposed to be. My continued telling of the truth about CPR is exactly what this NG is all about and I would hope someone like myself was here to tell it like it is in case I was interested in buying it without knowing to much about it. Whilst CPR remains in the state it's in, so does people's attitudes toward it. For those that don't like that, TOUGH! I take great pleasure in robbing MS of as many sales as possible for this dismal effort and support. If I was writing reviews I would write the following about CPR; "Although on the shelves in your local software shop, this title is not complete and so there is no review at this point in time" PS - thanks for the extra opportunity to put CPR down :))))
Mmmm, all I can see here is the same lack of tolerance of other's opinions that you are levelling at Byron - and expressed infinitely less eloquently as well. Frankly speaking I think CPR is a few patches short of a product, but all that has been done to death around here and is best left to fester quietly. However........ if someone comes along and asks for an opinion, or a fan of CPR expresses a fondness for the game, surely it is entirely understandable that someone posts also a fully justifiable contrary view? Surely you're not advocating that someone should have to make a buying decision without knowing the full picture? If someone feels the need to say CPR is good, I feel the need to point out that CPR is also known for being very poor. I wasted a lot of time on CPR, and I'd hate to see someone else do the same. Cheers! John
Scott White 24 Mar 1998#401039
Thats pretty original. Yes CPR sucks. That is the truth. Who doesnt know that by now? Since you are doing everyone a service why dont you focus your anger towards CPR and MS on something constructive like saying what games are worth the money. It gets a little old saying the same boring thing about CPR over and over for months doesnt it? Keep on flaming Byron you do it well
Safe-T-Lit 24 Mar 1998#401040
Less eloquent huh? Well I have never been so insulted in all my life. : ) I am just a corn fed whiteboy from the USA so please excuse me. All I am saying is Byron adds nothing to this NG but negative posts and re-hashes the same points over and over it borders on MS bashing ....What a bore P.S. He has even started to bash MTM2. (Another MS product) Has it been released out of beta yet? ummmmm NO!! It is not a sim like CPR claimed it would be but believe me the beta has far less problems then CPR has to this day.
Perhaps I was a nats harsh - more insulting I should have said, but the two generally amount to much the same thing :-) Well, it could be argued that people continually bringing up the good points of CPR at nothing to the newsgroup, since it inevitably requires someone to point out that theirs is not entirely an unchalleneged position - live and let live. MTM2 looks rather cool, and if it improves on the original (which I heartily recommend and enjoyed very much) then I will be more than happy. If only CPR's AI had been as talented as those Monster Truckers eh!? :-) Cheers! John
<gsand.. 25 Mar 1998#401215
>>BTW I even have my Pedal travel reduced by 1.5 inches or so and I can still >>threshold and Trail brake CPR? Took me about 10 mins to get used to it. >I don't think the effects of trail braking are modeled in CPR. The car >doesn't seem to turn in when trail braking or lifting the throttle. Several >others have commented on this also. Well the effects might not be exact to par but I can trail brake while turning, Isnt that what trail braking is??? I guess I am the only one that has the touch? You must be very gentle though! I never said the brakes were perfect. I agree that they need to be fixed and I have said this from the start. But until they are I CAN ADJUST! I'll tell
<gsand.. 25 Mar 1998#401216
Quoted text (17 lines)>> > Look out Randy! George is one of the people who advised MS as to what >> >they should do to fix CPR ie traction, heheheheheh. Looks like they paid >> >him for that and to do a little CPR defending on various forums! >> I've raced George on the Zone and he's a fine driver in CPR. I'm glad >> he's doing so well with CPR. However, his experience is not the same >> as most other people. I've found that I can get used to the problems >> with CPR and drive it reasonably well, but it wrecks my ability to >> drive any other sim, because of the poor brake pedal travel and >> massive high speed oversteer. >> Randy > Ditto. George is a great driver who's dominated with ICR2 and is >sick of it. He desperately wants/wanted CPR to be its replacement. I >just don't understand why he and others are so defensive about CPR >though.
I first want to thank both Byron and Randy for the comments on my driving ability, that means alot to me as I take great pride in my driving ability! And yes Byron I do want CPR to be the replacement for ICR2 as my phone bill is so much lower now not having to make long distance phone calls to have human competition. Now as for me defending CPR, I am not defending CPR as much as you bash it, I have and still feel there is things that need to be fixed and am hopefull that they all are. I just dont think you should be posting stuff about a product that you havent even tried! Please Byron, Go out and buy CPR and then try it with some current setups avail and before the 30 days are up you can get your money back. Then you can post your experiences that you have had good or bad. You know Byron, I can really imagine simulator manufactures coming here just to see what you, the expert says so they know what to fix. hehehe I bet they all have filtered you out of the newsgroup Dont you think that Microsoft can fix this and is capable of making CPR one of the best Sims avail? Well lets give them until after there vacation from MTM2 and see what happens! Wait, before you reply about the above sentence, let me recap for you. First you *** cause they release it to fast. then you *** cause they dont patch it fast enough. then you *** cause the patch didnt fix all the things that you think they should fix. Now you *** cause they are taking a break after MTM2 before deciding what to do for CPR. I know for a fact that you want CPR cause you told me that the other day when we chatted for about an hour. There was a lot of things in the full version you never experienced since you only tried the Demo. Remember your comments when I told you about how the car would get real light as you approched Thunder Valley. You were getting very e***d. I think you also want CPR to replace ICR2 for you too, huh Byron? Be honest now Byron. The Sims Gods are watching! One last thing Byron, You keep mentioning the same fixes for CPR. Steering, Braking and the AI over and over again, If you had ever really tried it you would realize that there are other important thinks that need to be fixed also: Tire Temps so we can actually see whats happening with our setups. Realistic Engine failures due to overreving and abusing the engine. Brakes should fade after hard and long abuse. There are quite a few others but I dont want to list them all cause you will only include these in your future posts as if you knew about them from experience. One last thing: I hope you have been practicing for our modem race in ICR2. You know Byron, I think i'll give you a break. We can race at your home track in Australia but we will use a full field using Realistic Damage. and we can use a very strong AI strength and we can both start from the rear of the pack, and we will then see if you can stay on the lead lap with me! You just let me know when you are ready ok? Later George
> Thats pretty original. Yes CPR sucks. That is the truth. Who > doesnt know that by now? Since you are doing everyone a service why dont > you focus your anger towards CPR and MS on something constructive like > saying what games are worth the money. It gets a little old saying the > same boring thing about CPR over and over for months doesnt it? Keep on > flaming Byron you do it well Thankyou. I will. Hopefully I'll have better things to do when GPL arrives. That should make us all happy!
> Less eloquent huh? Well I have never been so insulted in all my life. : ) I am > just a corn fed whiteboy from the USA so please excuse me. All I am saying is > Byron adds nothing to this NG but negative posts and re-hashes the same points > over and over it borders on MS bashing ....What a bore Bullshit. Anyway, it seems MS needs a little bashing. The corn fed whiteboy? Govt of the U.S.A. thinks so too. To get to the Zone one needs IE4 so that they can waist their time trying to get CPR happening and so IE4 can take over, and in many cases, stuff up peoples systems. Some of you people take this way too seriously. I made one or two references to MTM2 after it was reveiled CPR had been shafted in favour of getting MTM2 on the shelves. Big deal. I don't give a hoot about MTM2 - not my cuppa tea.
> Please Byron, Go out and buy CPR and then try it with some current setups > avail and before the 30 days are up you can get your money back. Then you > can post your experiences that you have had good or bad. Buy CPR? Now I know your trying to hurt me George! Btw, there is no 30 day deal here in Aus :( Their loss. Obviously they can! The question is will they and when! Well, seems I and others have been doing a lot of ?"***ing"? As your above paragraph points out, so we should be *"complaining"*. Thunder Valley? Very e***d, hehehehehe? Luckily, I must have forgotten this. Of course I do/did. That's exactly what I'm so pissed off about! Gee, thanks George. Your strongest track and one I have never even raced on - not even for fun (shame on me). I think I'll forfiet. You win! Next! Actually, I would think Vancouver would be very interesting since you so generously (though accidently, hehehehe) gave me your then world record setup there. I think Australia would be a waist of your money unless you'd like to wait till after I run it at IEC, Oct 18 or CCCC, Oct 25. LOL. Unfortunately I fear lag is gunna be a shocka, especially with a big field. Just us 2 on the track would be fun I reckon!
% Bullshit. Anyway, it seems MS needs a little bashing. The corn fed % whiteboy? Govt of the U.S.A. thinks so too. To get to the Zone one needs % IE4 so that they can waist their time trying to get CPR happening and so % IE4 can take over, and in many cases, stuff up peoples systems. I read that MS should make the Zone usuable with other browsers, but the release date I heard of this switch was next spring. I think this is in reaction to the pressure MS has been getting from the Justice Department. I just find it odd that it will take a whole year to undo this coupling of IE4 and The Zone. But, by then everyone will have made the jump to Win98 which is an OS embedded even deeper into IE4 than the Zone. -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Pat Dotson 25 Mar 1998#401221
> I think you also want CPR to replace ICR2 for you too, huh Byron? Be honest > now Byron. The Sims Gods are watching! That would be great but it's a long way from happening. There is nothing more we can do to make it happen - it's up to MS. The other things like brake fade and engine damage are relatively _very_ minor. They could be lived with, but ineffective steering and brain- dead AI will completely ruin CARTPR. Tire temps are necessary to be effectice with any of the setup adjustments. The lack of a tire temp readout clearly shows the inattention to detail that went into CARTPR. I did finally manage to get the steering to work fairly well - well enough to try racing against the AI. After wasting a couple of hours with the AI, I gave up on CARTPR altogether and haven't touched it again for a month or two. I hope they get it right someday. -- Pat Dotson IMPACT Motorsports
>Dont you think that Microsoft can fix this and is capable of making CPR one >of the best Sims avail? Well lets give them until after there vacation from >MTM2 and see what happens! To be honest no, I honestly don't think MS (or indeed anyone else) could patch this product to be one of the best sims available. Technically it is imporbable given the amount of things so obviously needing attention, and commercially it makes no sense whatsoever. I suspect you may see these things addressed for "CPR2" should such a beast ever appear. By then of course GPL will have been around for some time and N3 and quite possible Papy's new CART sim will be on the market, and the bar will have been raised to a level that the engine MS are using for CPR and MTM2 just cannot come close to. I'd like to see MS do well and produce great sims, and if they can beat Papyrus, Ubisoft, GC and the like then it's good for all of us. Frankly speaking it will take a _lot_ more than they have at the moment, not only from the physics and game engine side but also in understanding the sport and the needs of the market. Accepting CPR as a good sim without offering constructive criticism will not help one iota (although mindlessly bashing their efforts will admittedly achieve a darn sight less). The sole item of ***ing that needs attention is that CPR, as a product, is not up to the standard required to be a top class sim. Now if it makes money and that is the intention of it then it has been a succesful product - if the intention is to be the best sim ever then it most assuredly has not. If it's "raison d'etre" is to be a first step on the road to that "best sim" position then feedback is obviously needed. Agreed, but I would be happy even with steering and braking - that would allow me to hotlap. Good CCs would allow me to race, and anything beyond that would simply be improving on what would by that time be a pretty good product. Thanks for the comments, and a reasoned outlook on CPR. Cheers! John
> % Bullshit. Anyway, it seems MS needs a little bashing. The corn fed > % whiteboy? Govt of the U.S.A. thinks so too. To get to the Zone one needs > % IE4 so that they can waist their time trying to get CPR happening and so
Quoted text (9 lines)> % IE4 can take over, and in many cases, stuff up peoples systems. > I read that MS should make the Zone usuable with other browsers, but the > release date I heard of this switch was next spring. I think this is in > reaction to the pressure MS has been getting from the Justice > Department. I just find it odd that it will take a whole year to undo > this coupling of IE4 and The Zone. But, by then everyone will have made > the jump to Win98 which is an OS embedded even deeper into IE4 than the > Zone.
I have never had and probably never will have IE4 but I use the Zone?
<gsand.. 25 Mar 1998#401224
>> Less eloquent huh? Well I have never been so insulted in all my life. : ) I am >> just a corn fed whiteboy from the USA so please excuse me. All I am saying is >> Byron adds nothing to this NG but negative posts and re-hashes the same points >> over and over it borders on MS bashing ....What a bore > Bullshit. Anyway, it seems MS needs a little bashing. The corn fed >whiteboy? Govt of the U.S.A. thinks so too. To get to the Zone one needs >IE4 so that they can waist their time trying to get CPR happening and so >IE4 can take over, and in many cases, stuff up peoples systems. Well if you knew anything about what you are talking about you would know that the zone is working on Netscape availabilty to the zone now! but as usuall you wouldnt have noticed it cause it wasnt in a message about CPR, MTM2 or Microsoft! G
<gsand.. 25 Mar 1998#401225
>> Please Byron, Go out and buy CPR and then try it with some current setups >> avail and before the 30 days are up you can get your money back. Then you >> can post your experiences that you have had good or bad. > Buy CPR? Now I know your trying to hurt me George! Btw, there is no >30 day deal here in Aus :( >> You know Byron, I can really imagine simulator manufactures coming here just >> to see what you, the expert says so they know what to fix. hehehe I bet >> they all have filtered you out of the newsgroup > Their loss. >> Dont you think that Microsoft can fix this and is capable of making CPR one >> of the best Sims avail? Well lets give them until after there vacation from >> MTM2 and see what happens! > Obviously they can! The question is will they and when! >> Wait, before you reply about the above sentence, let me recap for you. First >> you *** cause they release it to fast. then you *** cause they dont >> patch it fast enough. then you *** cause the patch didnt fix all the >> things that you think they should fix. Now you *** cause they are taking a
Quoted text (8 lines)>> break after MTM2 before deciding what to do for CPR. > Well, seems I and others have been doing a lot of ?"***ing"? As >your above paragraph points out, so we should be *"complaining"*. >> I know for a fact that you want CPR cause you told me that the other day >> when we chatted for about an hour. There was a lot of things in the full >> version you never experienced since you only tried the Demo. Remember
your
Quoted text (7 lines)>> comments when I told you about how the car would get real light as you >> approched Thunder Valley. You were getting very e***d. > Thunder Valley? Very e***d, hehehehehe? Luckily, I must have >forgotten this. >> I think you also want CPR to replace ICR2 for you too, huh Byron? Be
honest
Quoted text (8 lines)>> now Byron. The Sims Gods are watching! > Of course I do/did. That's exactly what I'm so pissed off about! >> One last thing: >> I hope you have been practicing for our modem race in ICR2. >> You know Byron, I think i'll give you a break. We can race at your home >> track in Australia but we will use a full field using Realistic Damage.
and >> we can use a very strong AI strength and we can both start from the rear of >> the pack, and we will then see if you can stay on the lead lap with me! You
Quoted text (11 lines)>> just let me know when you are ready ok? > Gee, thanks George. Your strongest track and one I have never even >raced on - not even for fun (shame on me). I think I'll forfiet. You >win! Next! Actually, I would think Vancouver would be very interesting >since you so generously (though accidently, hehehehe) gave me your then >world record setup there. I think Australia would be a waist of your >money unless you'd like to wait till after I run it at IEC, Oct 18 or >CCCC, Oct 25. LOL. Unfortunately I fear lag is gunna be a shocka, >especially with a big field. Just us 2 on the track would be fun I >reckon!
Vancouver is fine too Byron. No problem. Lets do it! George
<gsand.. 25 Mar 1998#401226
>> I think you also want CPR to replace ICR2 for you too, huh Byron? Be honest
Quoted text (7 lines)>> now Byron. The Sims Gods are watching! >That would be great but it's a long way from happening. There is >nothing more >we can do to make it happen - it's up to MS. >> One last thing Byron, You keep mentioning the same fixes for CPR.
Steering, >> Braking and the AI over and over again, If you had ever really tried it you
Quoted text (20 lines)>> would realize that there are other important thinks that need to be fixed >> also: >The other things like brake fade and engine damage are relatively _very_ >minor. They could be lived with, but ineffective steering and brain- >dead AI will completely ruin CARTPR. Tire temps are necessary to be >effectice with any of the setup adjustments. The lack of a tire temp >readout clearly shows the inattention to detail that went into CARTPR. >I did finally manage to get the steering to work fairly well - well >enough >to try racing against the AI. After wasting a couple of hours with the >AI, I gave up on CARTPR altogether and haven't touched it again for a >month or two. >I hope they get it right someday. >-- >Pat Dotson >IMPACT Motorsports
Well Pat I wouldnt know about the AI cause I dont race them I race Humans. George
Kevin 25 Mar 1998#401227
>Well the effects might not be exact to par but I can trail brake while >turning, Isnt that what trail braking is??? I guess I am the only one that >has the touch? You must be very gentle though! I wasn't talking about slowing down while braking and turning. I'm talking about the effects the weight transfer has on steering and car balance. Specifically, the car should turn in better when trail braking. I haven't seen this effect in CPR compared to other sims like F1RS. It's not just the brakes that are a problem in this sim. I can care less when there are several minor problems in a sim, but the sum of the major problems in CPR lead me to delete it and race exclusively in F1RS. I was once a fan of CPR, hoping that future patches would improve it. They haven't delivered, and I doubt that they ever will. -- Kevin (Remove the "x-" prefix from my address in order to reply via email)
> Well if you knew anything about what you are talking about you would know > that the zone is working on Netscape availabilty to the zone now! > but as usuall you wouldnt have noticed it cause it wasnt in a message about > CPR, MTM2 or Microsoft! I read the other day that MS will be making Netscape compatible with the Zone in 2 months. But are you trying to say that this has not been a deliberate ploy by MS. How hopeless are MS either way? They iether can't program properly or a plain dishonest. Take your pick!
snip > Well if you knew anything about what you are talking about you would know > that the zone is working on Netscape availabilty to the zone now! Yeah, and I'm sure it's one (1) guy working 2 hours per month on it! "What, you finished it? Go back and start from scratch!" l8er ronny -- |\ _,,,---,,_ I want to die like my Grandfather, ZZZzz /,`.-'`' -. ;-;;,_ in his sleep. |,4- ) )-,_. ,\ ( `'-' Not like the people in his car, '---''(_/--' `-'\_) screaming their heads off!
Pat Dotson 26 Mar 1998#401403
Quoted text (7 lines)> >to try racing against the AI. After wasting a couple of hours with the > >AI, I gave up on CARTPR altogether and haven't touched it again for a > >month or two. > Well Pat I wouldnt know about the AI cause I dont race them I race Humans. > George
Well George, I do too - on NROS. That wouldn't excuse Papyrus if the AI in N2 was lame, and it doesn't excuse Microsoft either. MS's blatant attempt to force IE on me is even more lame than their AI. -- Pat Dotson IMPACT Motorsports
Joe McGinn 26 Mar 1998#401404
Quoted text (7 lines)>>P.S. He has even started to bash MTM2. (Another MS product) Has it been >>released out of beta yet? ummmmm NO!! It is not a sim like CPR claimed it would >>be but believe me the beta has far less problems then CPR has to this day. >MTM2 looks rather cool, and if it improves on the original (which I >heartily recommend and enjoyed very much) then I will be more than >happy. If only CPR's AI had been as talented as those Monster Truckers >eh!? :-)
And the claim that Byron is bashing MTM2 is PURE bullshit - he wrote a very positive an accurate preview posted on the web the other day. Joe
URL? As I would really like to see a " positive & accurate " anything from Byron regarding an MS product. Really I would :-)
Safe-T-Lit 26 Mar 1998#401406
Give me an address please. I read a few post from Mr Negative on this NG bashing MTM2 and that aint no BS
Quoted text (13 lines)> >>P.S. He has even started to bash MTM2. (Another MS product) Has it been > >>released out of beta yet? ummmmm NO!! It is not a sim like CPR claimed it would > >>be but believe me the beta has far less problems then CPR has to this day. > >MTM2 looks rather cool, and if it improves on the original (which I > >heartily recommend and enjoyed very much) then I will be more than > >happy. If only CPR's AI had been as talented as those Monster Truckers > >eh!? :-) > And the claim that Byron is bashing MTM2 is PURE bullshit - he wrote a > very positive an accurate preview posted on the web the other day. > Joe
Safe-T-Lit 26 Mar 1998#401407
Oh yeah, Joe take a look a few posts down from Mr Negative. No wait I will help you. Here is one quote from Byron (a.k.a Mr. Negative) about MTM2 Some of you people take this way too seriously. I made one or two references to MTM2 after it was reveiled CPR had been shafted in favour of getting MTM2 on the shelves. Big deal. I don't give a hoot about MTM2 - not my cuppa tea. That aint no BS either
Quoted text (13 lines)> >>P.S. He has even started to bash MTM2. (Another MS product) Has it been > >>released out of beta yet? ummmmm NO!! It is not a sim like CPR claimed it would > >>be but believe me the beta has far less problems then CPR has to this day. > >MTM2 looks rather cool, and if it improves on the original (which I > >heartily recommend and enjoyed very much) then I will be more than > >happy. If only CPR's AI had been as talented as those Monster Truckers > >eh!? :-) > And the claim that Byron is bashing MTM2 is PURE bullshit - he wrote a > very positive an accurate preview posted on the web the other day. > Joe
<gsand.. 26 Mar 1998#401408
>>Well if you had seem the Elk replay I was talking about Randy and did the >>same in CPR I guarentee you will spin like crazy. I suggest you check it out
Quoted text (9 lines)>>if you have ICR2!! >Fine. I know that this happens a lot in ICR2 and I know that in ICR2 >its relatively easy to cut corners for big time savings. Cleveland >was so bad many leagues had to adopt some special replay rules to >ensure people weren't mowing the grass too much. >>I agree that the travel wasnt what I was used to in ICR2,GP2 or other sims >>burt you really think that CART drivers move there pedal 4 inches.
hehehehe
Quoted text (16 lines)>>Come on Randy, You of all people should know that there braking is set up >>with little travel, >Yes, little travel but HIGH PRESSURE. I've never seen a brake system >for a PC which accurately simulates the fact that brakes are PRESSURE >devices, not deflection devices. The ideal brake would be on with >almost no travel, because you'd press harder and harder rather than >get more pedal deflection. A real car can have little brake pedal >deflection because its truly a pressure device. Since we don't have >that with almost every set of PC pedals out there, it has to be made >up for with travel, and the fact of the matter is that CPR doesn't >have enough travel, nor does there appear to be any difference in >travel-to-lockup at high speeds vs. low speeds. This isn't really a >debatable issue. If you want realistic travel for CPR, you're going >to have to tell me how I can come by pressure-sensitive brakes that >make that deflection worthwhile and realistic.
Hmmm, Maybe we all need to spend the big bucks and get the CDS5000 Wheel/Pedal system??? Maybe someday, huh? I have a feeling my wife would take that CDS5000 and hit me upside the head with it :) I have an Pi Analysis that I am E-Mailing you that shows between 50 % and 70 % braking depending on the location and speed. Maybe not as much diff as Reality?? I dont know. I have never seen an analysis of a Indycar, but I am assuming you have, or know what it should be, so let me know the diff between mine. The PI Analysis I am sending you also shows Trail Braking into Turn 2, and before the corkscrew. I think the lap that I am talking about is listed as 1:09.76 at Laguna. Didnt run to many but if you need more proof I will run some more. Oh BTW, I made sure in that lap to put a tire off in Turn 4 just like the CART guys do (as you have stated) also Randy I would have been right behind you last year if you were in Turn 4 grandstands as I was halfway up the hill behind you btwn the grandstands you were in and Turn 5. If you go this year let me know and we can meet somewhere and do a little bench racing :) First of all I am not trying to insult you but I feel I am the one that is being insulted, cause I have shown proof of my statements as shown in my PI Analysis. Now maybe this is not exactly the same as an actual Indycar would show? I wouldnt know, as I have never driven one yet! (Maybe someday! Well, I can dream cant I?) Now the only thing I really dont see is the ability to see threshold braking. I had smoke on but is not shown in the replay. Is there a way for me to also verify this? You will see in my replay that i do back off a hair on the brakes as I reach the Threshold. And at no time in this replay did I completely lock the brakes up! Now, I have never heard of the term "strawman argument", but if this is an insult of my intelligence, I want you to know that all throughout my school years I was consistently in accelerated classes, (MGM, we called this Mentally Gifted Monkeys :) and in the Top 2 percentile. I currently have a IQ of 150. I graduated a year early from High School with Honors. I have an AA in Electronics and am currently working on my BA in Engineering. So I just want you to know I am no stupid little kid arguing for arguments sake. I have stated points which I believe are true, and I feel they are proven in the PI Analysis. No one wants to not emulate lock-up, but You had to know how easily the points you made were going to I really dont think they are refuted Randy, as I have shown that my steering is Stable, and I can Threshold and Trail Brake just as I have stated, and this is shown in the PI Analysis. BTW if anyone else would like to see the PI Analysis E-Mail me and I would be glad to send it to you! Later George
Joe McGinn 26 Mar 1998#401409
>> And the claim that Byron is bashing MTM2 is PURE bullshit - he wrote a >> very positive an accurate preview posted on the web the other day. > URL? As I would really like to see a " positive & accurate " anything >from Byron regarding an MS product. Really I would :-) Here you go: http://www.activeguide.com/previews/prev/mtm2.html Although I think we're talking about two different Byrons actually - this is by Byron Hinson. Sorry bout that. Joe
<gsand.. 26 Mar 1998#401411
>>Dont you think that Microsoft can fix this and is capable of making CPR one >>of the best Sims avail? Well lets give them until after there vacation from
Quoted text (20 lines)>>MTM2 and see what happens! >To be honest no, I honestly don't think MS (or indeed anyone else) >could patch this product to be one of the best sims available. >Technically it is imporbable given the amount of things so obviously >needing attention, and commercially it makes no sense whatsoever. I >suspect you may see these things addressed for "CPR2" should such a >beast ever appear. By then of course GPL will have been around for >some time and N3 and quite possible Papy's new CART sim will be on the >market, and the bar will have been raised to a level that the engine >MS are using for CPR and MTM2 just cannot come close to. >I'd like to see MS do well and produce great sims, and if they can >beat Papyrus, Ubisoft, GC and the like then it's good for all of us. >Frankly speaking it will take a _lot_ more than they have at the >moment, not only from the physics and game engine side but also in >understanding the sport and the needs of the market. Accepting CPR as >a good sim without offering constructive criticism will not help one >iota (although mindlessly bashing their efforts will admittedly >achieve a darn sight less).
I agree John that constructive criticism is necessary, but what I see is alot of mindless bashing going on.
Hey George, I would love to see it. Not to dispute it as I am sure you know. But just to see how well it can be done. Everytime we have raced I never get to see your driving as I am too far behind :-) thanks, Mike
Quoted text (14 lines)> >> And the claim that Byron is bashing MTM2 is PURE bullshit - he wrote a > >> very positive an accurate preview posted on the web the other day. > > URL? As I would really like to see a " positive & accurate " anything > >from Byron regarding an MS product. Really I would :-) > Here you go: > http://www.activeguide.com/previews/prev/mtm2.html > Although I think we're talking about two different Byrons actually - > this is by Byron Hinson. Sorry bout that. > Joe
Hehe I am sorry too Joe :-) See now I really wonder as I am sure the flack you have been taking is actually due to this misunderstanding of which Byron you meant. But didn't you notice the title of this thread? Cya, Mike
Quoted text (14 lines)> >> And the claim that Byron is bashing MTM2 is PURE bullshit - he wrote a > >> very positive an accurate preview posted on the web the other day. > > URL? As I would really like to see a " positive & accurate " anything > >from Byron regarding an MS product. Really I would :-) > Here you go: > http://www.activeguide.com/previews/prev/mtm2.html > Although I think we're talking about two different Byrons actually - > this is by Byron Hinson. Sorry bout that. > Joe
LOL. Man, did you have me going or what. I thought I must have got up in my sleep and done it or something. I was shuddering at the thought I may have given it game of the year. LOL.
Quoted text (9 lines)> Oh yeah, Joe take a look a few posts down from Mr Negative. No wait I will help you. > Here is one quote from Byron (a.k.a Mr. Negative) about MTM2 > Some of you people take this way too seriously. I made one or two > references to MTM2 after it was reveiled CPR had been shafted in favour > of getting MTM2 on the shelves. Big deal. I don't give a hoot about MTM2 > - not my cuppa tea. > That aint no BS either
Hey buddy, what's your name? And where's the negative bit? (Folks, maybe I see everything so negatively that this looks quite normal to me - or is it that it's just normal like me?). Go away kid!
>Hmmm, Maybe we all need to spend the big bucks and get the CDS5000 >Wheel/Pedal system??? Maybe someday, huh? I have a feeling my wife would >take that CDS5000 and hit me upside the head with it :) Some people would probably say its still worth it <G> And how do you know you're at thresshold braking the entire time? You might just not be braking as much in one corner as you possibly could? Either way, it takes only a small amount of brake pedal travel to generate 50% braking, way too little to be able to modulate as well as you can with some other sims. Yes you can definitely put a tire off. Never said you couldn't... Okay, will do. You have and you haven't. First of all, I never claimed you couldn't trail brake in CPR. I've done it myself and know its doable. The issue is whether the pedal-travel-to-braking force ratio is all out of whack for all but a tiny percentage of PC pedals. And the fact that such little travel means its incredibly difficult for most people to do even a reasonable job at braking without locking 'em up all the time. Not really. You'd need wheelspin values to see you locking wheels up for the tiniest amounts of time when they locked & released. Since CPR doesn't track wheelspin its hard to tell. The best thing you can do is go down a long straight and brake to a stop as quickly as you can without locking up the tires, and look at the Pi traces to see what your braking % was to get to the limit. If you are going 150+ mph and you can lock 'em up with only 50% braking, something is wrong. Your downforce should allow more braking than that! Now perhaps under 100 mph 50% might lock 'em up. Lets throw ice water on this fight before it gets out of control. I took it personally because your comments seemed to imply that I wanted ICR2 anti-lock brakes and wanted to be able to just slam the brakes to the stops and hold it there. No such thing was ever suggested...by anyone. So for you to try to prop that puppy up and knock it down seemed to me like you were getting extreme in your arguments. I never called you stupid. But neither did I appreciate it you acting like I thought ICR2 braking was perfectly wonderful either. You've demonstrated you can TRAIL brake, not threshhold brake, since you yourself admit you have no Pi trace that shows the wheelspin necessary to show you actually touched the limit of braking. Randy Randy Magruder Contributing Reviewer Digital Sportspage http://www.digitalsports.com
OK - I've decided. All the shit I posted was real stupid on my part. I apologize to the news group. BF
<gsand.. 28 Mar 1998#401607
>> >to try racing against the AI. After wasting a couple of hours with the >> >AI, I gave up on CARTPR altogether and haven't touched it again for a >> >month or two. >> Well Pat I wouldnt know about the AI cause I dont race them I race Humans.
Quoted text (9 lines)>> George >Well George, I do too - on NROS. That wouldn't excuse Papyrus if the >AI in N2 was lame, and it doesn't excuse Microsoft either. MS's >blatant attempt to force IE on me is even more lame than their AI. >-- >Pat Dotson >IMPACT Motorsports
hmm I have heard that NROS has a lot of competitors on it. I never realy got into Nascar. Just wish there was something as big as that for open wheel cars. but I rem when N2 came out, all you guys did was complain how bad the AI was. Wasnt there some people out there that fixed the AI? I dont remember Papyrus doing it for you! Well CPR is a MS game played in a MS zone why should they make it work with other browsers first? George
<gsand.. 28 Mar 1998#401608
Quoted text (24 lines)>>Well the effects might not be exact to par but I can trail brake while >>turning, Isnt that what trail braking is??? I guess I am the only one that >>has the touch? You must be very gentle though! >I wasn't talking about slowing down while braking and turning. I'm talking >about the effects the weight transfer has on steering and car balance. >Specifically, the car should turn in better when trail braking. I haven't >seen this effect in CPR compared to other sims like F1RS. >>I never said the brakes were perfect. I agree that they need to be fixed >and >>I have said this from the start. But until they are I CAN ADJUST! >It's not just the brakes that are a problem in this sim. I can care less >when there are several minor problems in a sim, but the sum of the major >problems in CPR lead me to delete it and race exclusively in F1RS. I was >once a fan of CPR, hoping that future patches would improve it. They >haven't delivered, and I doubt that they ever will. >-- >Kevin >(Remove the "x-" prefix from my address in order to reply via email) >Well Kevin, F1RS is not on the shelves here yet so I wouldnt know about
that. In a few more days I guess is what I hear and I will go buy it and try it out. I would assume that it must be the perfect Simulator since it has had 8 patches so far! George
<gsand.. 28 Mar 1998#401609
Quoted text (15 lines)>> BTW if anyone else would like to see the PI Analysis E-Mail me and I >would >> be glad to send it to you! >> Later >> George >Hey George, > I would love to see it. Not to dispute it as I am sure >you know. >But just to see how well it can be done. Everytime we have raced I never >get to see >your driving as I am too far behind :-) >thanks, Mike
Sure thing Mike its on its way! George
Scott White 28 Mar 1998#401610
hehehe I noticed the e-mail address was diffrent too. I knew you wouldnt actually apologize to this NG. You have to admit tho, its pretty funny
Quoted text (11 lines)> > OK - I've decided. All the shit I posted was real stupid on my part. > > I apologize to the news group. > > BF > Now this I MUST have posted in my sleep. And on someone elses > computer considering the email address. To whoever posted this all I can > say to you is what you say about yourself is entirely true and well > demonstrated by the fact you forgot to change your email address. I have > recorded your email address and if you attempt to do this again be > assured a complaint to your ISP will follow promptly!
> > Well CPR is a MS game played in a MS zone why should they make it work with > > other browsers first? > Why not at the same time? Are they hopeless or are they scum? Why does HBO not make their movies available on free cable? Are they hopeless or scum? Why didn't the VCR guys make it to run VHS, Beta Max & PAL? Are they hopeless or scum? Why didn't all game developers make their games for both D3D & 3Dfx? Are they hopeless or scum? Why? Ever hear of free enterprise? You have an idea? You want to sell it? But the best part is this IT WAS ALWAYS FREE SEE? I.E 4.0 was never required as I never had it. I.E 3.02 is free smaller in size and better than NS IMO. So? I have both no problem right? But this is really not about any of the things your complaining about right? Its just some folks will always see something as half empty instead of half full. Even if it is totally free for the taking. Are they hopeless? IMHO yes
> > I would assume that it must be the perfect Simulator since it has had 8 > > patches so far! > Yeah, but it was 100 times more finished than CPR without any. In fact, it's still 100 times more finished than CPR with two, and quite likely always will be. Anybody care to wager that there will EVER be another patch to CPR, or even a (pay twice, get one sim) version 2? I'll be truly shocked and amazed if we ever hear another official peep from Microsoft about CPR. Bart Brown
> OK - I've decided. All the shit I posted was real stupid on my part. > I apologize to the news group. > BF Now this I MUST have posted in my sleep. And on someone elses computer considering the email address. To whoever posted this all I can say to you is what you say about yourself is entirely true and well demonstrated by the fact you forgot to change your email address. I have recorded your email address and if you attempt to do this again be assured a complaint to your ISP will follow promptly!
> Randy, Stuff about how much better ICR2 has be implied since CPR first came > out. I dont agree that ICR2 is any better. I agree that the travel feels to > little but maybe we have all gotten use to to much travel in previous Sims? > I will see the diff when I get F1RS next week but I think Ubi has been > around here and all the complaining might have something to do with them > releasing 8 patches befere releasing it in the States? GP2 has the best braking model I know of so far. I would think the optimum way to sim brakes would be for the brakes to lock up just before full travel when the car has max downforce (unless it was the case that even real F1/CART drivers cannot even lock the brakes under such circumstances - dunno?) and at about 1/3 travel with min downforce ie very slow speeds. It seems this is pretty much what GP2 does.
> Well CPR is a MS game played in a MS zone why should they make it work with > other browsers first? Why not at the same time? Are they hopeless or are they scum?
> I would assume that it must be the perfect Simulator since it has had 8 > patches so far! Yeah, but it was 100 times more finished than CPR without any.
Quoted text (8 lines)> > > Well CPR is a MS game played in a MS zone why should they make it work > with > > > other browsers first? > > Why not at the same time? Are they hopeless or are they scum? > Why does HBO not make their movies available on free cable? Are they > hopeless or scum?
To compare a privatly owned cable network to the Internet is so brain dead, do you really want an answer? MS is trying to achive domination, just so I don't use the word monopoly. If MS wants to operate in the Internet, they should live with competition and grant us the possibility to choose the tools used for accessing it... l8er ronny -- |\ _,,,---,,_ I want to die like my Grandfather, ZZZzz /,`.-'`' -. ;-;;,_ in his sleep. |,4- ) )-,_. ,\ ( `'-' Not like the people in his car, '---''(_/--' `-'\_) screaming their heads off!
From an interview with CMP's "Net Insider": Is Microsoft sorry? Bob Herbold, Microsoft' chief operating officer, says the company is trying to learn from the aggressiveness that has made it not only a success, but a vilified target. "Yeah, at times we say things we probably wish we hadn't said," Herbold admits. "We are working at that, to try to be a bit more aware of the implications of those things. They are not in the best interests of our users, or us, or the third party."
> hehehe I noticed the e-mail address was diffrent too. I knew you wouldnt > actually apologize to this NG. You have to admit tho, its pretty funny Yes, I did think it was pretty funny. But probably for a different reason than you.
Quoted text (22 lines)> > > Well CPR is a MS game played in a MS zone why should they make it work > with > > > other browsers first? > > Why not at the same time? Are they hopeless or are they scum? > Why does HBO not make their movies available on free cable? Are they > hopeless or scum? > Why didn't the VCR guys make it to run VHS, Beta Max & PAL? Are they > hopeless or scum? > Why didn't all game developers make their games for both D3D & 3Dfx? Are > they hopeless or scum? > Why? Ever hear of free enterprise? You have an idea? You want to sell it? > But the best part is this > IT WAS ALWAYS FREE SEE? I.E 4.0 was never required as I never had it. I.E > 3.02 is free smaller > in size and better than NS IMO. So? I have both no problem right? But this > is really not about any > of the things your complaining about right? Its just some folks will always > see something as half empty > instead of half full. Even if it is totally free for the taking. Are they > hopeless? IMHO yes
Ok Mike, I admit it. Your head is half full.
Same old stuff eh? Who compared HBO to the internet only you? The thread "was" about a site not the net. So who is brain dead? So I guess your saying NROS / Ten is doing the same then? Think 1st flame later Mike
Quoted text (15 lines)> > To compare a privatly owned cable network to the Internet is so brain > > dead, > > do you really want an answer? MS is trying to achive domination, just so > > I > > don't use the word monopoly. > > If MS wants to operate in the Internet, they should live with > > competition > > and grant us the possibility to choose the tools used for accessing > > it... > Same old stuff eh? Who compared HBO to the internet only you? > The thread "was" about a site not the net. So who is brain dead? > So I guess your saying NROS / Ten is doing the same then? > Think 1st flame later
Did you read my last sentence? They should let the user decide which tools to use for access! Support monopoly, flame later... ;^) l8er ronny -- Toys'R'Us '99: "So, would you like a hand gun with that action figure, kiddo?" |\ _,,,---,,_ I want to die like my Grandfather, ZZZzz /,`.-'`' -. ;-;;,_ in his sleep. |,4- ) )-,_. ,\ ( `'-' Not like the people in his car, '---''(_/--' `-'\_) screaming their heads off!
Pat Dotson 30 Mar 1998#401803
> hmm I have heard that NROS has a lot of competitors on it. I never realy > got into Nascar. Just wish there was something as big as that for open wheel > cars. There are about 4000 people who have been on NROS - or so I've heard. On any given night, there are about 500 people online. Lots of competition! I wish there was something available that was more road course oriented, but good road course sim drivers are few and far between. It's tough to get a good field of drivers at Sears Point. Maybe GPL will be added to TEN? :) I don't remember any big problems with the original N2 AI. Racing off line was and is OK _and_ it had yellow flags. The new AI enhancements from Nim and others are just improvements to an already functional product. Maybe because the AI doesn't work? You claim that worthless AI is irrelevant because online racing is available. It's only available if the browser MS wants you to use is installed. Is it too much to ask to be able to practice racing off line? I can't say I blame MS for trying to leverage their strength to make people use IE, but the way they are doing it is definitely coercive. -- Pat Dotson IMPACT Motorsports
Jim Sokolo 30 Mar 1998#401804
So, we can now expect them to be a bit more careful about what they *say*. What they do will likely not change much at all, eh? --Jim
> So, we can now expect them to be a bit more careful about what they > *say*. What they do will likely not change much at all, eh? > --Jim They're hewing to a pretty steady line of stonewalling so far! In fact, "stonewalling" is a bit TOO generous, as it implies *some* sort of response... The entire interview with Herbold is an absolute hoot -- the questioner wasn't exactly gentle... Bart
Quoted text (33 lines)> > hmm I have heard that NROS has a lot of competitors on it. I never realy > > got into Nascar. Just wish there was something as big as that for open wheel > > cars. > There are about 4000 people who have been on NROS - or so I've heard. > On > any given night, there are about 500 people online. Lots of competition! > I wish there was something available that was more road course oriented, > but good road course sim drivers are few and far between. It's tough > to get a good field of drivers at Sears Point. Maybe GPL will be > added to TEN? :) > > but I rem when N2 came out, all you guys did was complain how bad the AI > > was. Wasnt there some people out there that fixed the AI? I dont remember > > Papyrus doing it for you! > I don't remember any big problems with the original N2 AI. Racing off > line > was and is OK _and_ it had yellow flags. The new AI enhancements from > Nim and > others are just improvements to an already functional product. > > Well CPR is a MS game played in a MS zone why should they make it work with > > other browsers first? > Maybe because the AI doesn't work? You claim that worthless AI is > irrelevant because online racing is available. It's only available > if the browser MS wants you to use is installed. Is it too much > to ask to be able to practice racing off line? > I can't say I blame MS for trying to leverage their strength to make > people use IE, but the way they are doing it is definitely coercive.
I can't say I'd blame someone for puting a bullet in the head of all those involved with the waist of time CPR is!
Everyone has to draw their own personal line somewhere, and I don't feel quite able to justify that to myself. Exaggerating for effect may be okay, but a cold shower followed by a lie down in a darkened room may be necessary :-) Cheers! John
Goy Larsen 01 Apr 1998#402155
I use MS explorer for playing Age of Empire on the Zone (and only for that), and TEN`s software to play N2 on NROS, the difference is...... ? And before any of you ask, I use Netscape as my regular browser :-) Beers and cheers (uncle) Goy Unclegoy on TEN
Quoted text (10 lines)> > I can't say I'd blame someone for puting a bullet in the head of all > >those involved with the waist of time CPR is! > Everyone has to draw their own personal line somewhere, and I don't > feel quite able to justify that to myself. Exaggerating for effect may > be okay, but a cold shower followed by a lie down in a darkened room > may be necessary :-) > Cheers! > John
Hehehehehehe. Good point about lines drawn. It's just a matter of where is it drawn. The open field (ie the land of no rules/gentlemans agreements) is a very wild place and IMO thats the field MS is on as far as CPR goes. There's no tellin' what can happen to those in the open field!

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy