Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

TOCA - Sim/Arcade?

17 posts by 13 people · 29 Dec 1997 - 15 Jan 1998

Juan Vasque 29 Dec 1997#389496
I was in England last week and saw this TOCA PC game. Is it a simulation or an arcade game? JV
Doug Bur 29 Dec 1997#389497
> I was in England last week and saw this TOCA PC game. Is it a simulation or > an arcade game? JV It is an ARCADE racer in the sense that there is NO setups for the cars -- it is more of a SIMULATION in the respect of the car handling model. Much more realisitc than most ARCADE racers in that category. Graphics are OK on a 3dfx.
Lomceva 29 Dec 1997#389498
Definitely arcade, since there are no setups, telemetry, real damage, mirrors etc, but borders on the sim genre in realism. The AI races very rough and heavy and there are `yellow card' as there are in real life. The cars look fabulous and can look very battered (but really aren't). You can spin upside down like 4 times in a row (even gives me enough time to swap to***pit). You only have two circuits at the beginning and you must get good results to get the rest of the circuits (although some have already found their way around this...). Certain flaws : even on low sentivity, it is very twitchy. I tried lowered the keyboard repeat rate thru W95, but even then, winning at Brands Hatch was unbelivably dicey. And I can't use my CH pedals either. Stanley > I was in England last week and saw this TOCA PC game. Is it a > simulation or > an arcade game? JV
Nick 05 Jan 1998#390416
My personal opinion is that it sits between sim and arcade but it is more sim than arcade simply because the driving experience "feels" right. I've been on a couple of tracks depicted (albeit on a bike, not in a car) and the reproduction of the tracks and the way that you drive them seems spot on. With an analog controller, the progressive brake/throttle and steering is very nice to use although steering is twitchy even on the low sensitivity. I've been running NASCAR2 as my promary driving sim for a while but I'm swtiching to TOCA for a while, it's a blast. Nick
I'm sorry but I think I must be loosing my mind. Every review I've read about TOCA seems to praise it's realistic handling...they don't handle like any car I've driven. Has anyone else noticed that the cars seem to bounce down the straights, like they've got square wheels. People I speak to say its just settling on its springs, but it's more than that, the track isn't smooth, it seems to be made of lots of straight bits knocked together to make curves. You can see the lumps approaching as you drive along and then leap over them. Definitely arcade in my view. Plus it's got to be the ugliest 3Dfx game ever made. Am I the only one to think like this?
Quoted text (16 lines)>My personal opinion is that it sits between sim and arcade but it is more >sim than arcade simply because the driving experience "feels" right. I've >been on a couple of tracks depicted (albeit on a bike, not in a car) and >the reproduction of the tracks and the way that you drive them seems spot >on. >With an analog controller, the progressive brake/throttle and steering is >very nice to use although steering is twitchy even on the low >sensitivity. >I've been running NASCAR2 as my promary driving sim for a while but I'm >swtiching to TOCA for a while, it's a blast. >Nick >> I was in England last week and saw this TOCA PC game. Is it a simulation
or >> an arcade game? JV
Nope. I deleted it off the HD and took it back to the shop. It's a pile of steaming toss, I said to the bloke when he asked what was wrong with it. If you ever sell me such rubbish again I shall make your assistant shove it up your[NO CARRIER]
Nick 09 Jan 1998#391145
I would guess that Touring cars probably DO handle unlike anything you've ever driven unless you're lucky enough to have cut some laps in a TCC car. Last time I rode at Brands Hatch it WASN'T smooth and that was on a road bike with soft suspension. I guess in a stiffly setup Touring car, you would bounce around a fair bit but I do agree that the effect seems to be a bit accentuated in TOCA. Yeah, I gotta agree with you on that but I rarely notice itwhen I'm running at race speed. The tarmac textures are the only thing that really grate on me, apart from that the graphics seem OK rather than brilliant. I agree that TOCA is lightweight for a sim but I would also contend that it appears realistic enough not to get slagged off as just another arcade racer. That's just a personal opinion and I can see that others would not agree with me ! Later, nick
leo 09 Jan 1998#391146
On Wed, 7 Jan 1998 21:51:37 -0000, "Tim Harrison"
Quoted text (9 lines)>I'm sorry but I think I must be loosing my mind. Every review I've read >about TOCA seems to praise it's realistic handling...they don't handle like >any car I've driven. Has anyone else noticed that the cars seem to bounce >down the straights, like they've got square wheels. People I speak to say >its just settling on its springs, but it's more than that, the track isn't >smooth, it seems to be made of lots of straight bits knocked together to >make curves. You can see the lumps approaching as you drive along and then >leap over them. Definitely arcade in my view. Plus it's got to be the >ugliest 3Dfx game ever made. Am I the only one to think like this?
I have a little bit of experience in karts and did some FF1600 tests at Ledenon, in France....and I have driven a few laps of Donington too.......I don't know what sort of cars you've driven ;-) , but I wouldn't even think about comparing the handling of any road car with one that is set up for racing....the springing is usually so stiff that you'll feel every single bump, and get shaken about a fair bit....plus there is all the vibration to think about.. The tracks the Touring Cars race on are (with the exception of Silverstone) are not billiard table smooth by any means....and I know from my limited experience that Donington has a fair few lumpy bits <ggg>..... FastPants :)
TOP BLOKE !!! >> I'm sorry but I think I must be loosing my mind. Every review I've read >> about TOCA seems to praise it's realistic handling...they don't handle like >> any car I've driven. Has anyone else noticed that the cars seem to bounce >> down the straights, like they've got square wheels. People I speak to say >> its just settling on its springs, but it's more than that, the track isn't >> smooth, it seems to be made of lots of straight bits knocked together to >> make curves. You can see the lumps approaching as you drive along and then
Quoted text (7 lines)>> leap over them. Definitely arcade in my view. Plus it's got to be the >> ugliest 3Dfx game ever made. Am I the only one to think like this? >Nope. I deleted it off the HD and took it back to the shop. It's a pile >of steaming toss, I said to the bloke when he asked what was wrong with >it. If you ever sell me such rubbish again I shall make your assistant >shove it up your[NO CARRIER]
Oi! First I find Papa Doc and Io here, now you. Get back in that Flanker *immediately* ;-) Either that or we start a ground support team. Anyone know any good Russian lorry sims? Icarus
Yes, I understand your point, but there is a difference between bumps and a car (like in TOCA) leaping around a foot in the air, which I see it do several times a lap. I've been to many races TOCA , GP's, F3 etc over the years and I've even had the chance ride round Oulton Park with John Cleland strapped into his Cavalier, and never seen it happen like it does in this game. It seems the programmers were unable to create a smooth track surface and just tiled sections together and the simulated cars are leaping over the ridges where these tiles join. Sounds like I'm barking mad but that's what it feels like to me.
ajh.. 09 Jan 1998#391150
Quoted text (14 lines)>> I'm sorry but I think I must be loosing my mind. Every review I've read >> about TOCA seems to praise it's realistic handling...they don't handle like >> any car I've driven. Has anyone else noticed that the cars seem to bounce >> down the straights, like they've got square wheels. People I speak to say >> its just settling on its springs, but it's more than that, the track isn't >> smooth, it seems to be made of lots of straight bits knocked together to >> make curves. You can see the lumps approaching as you drive along and then >> leap over them. Definitely arcade in my view. Plus it's got to be the >> ugliest 3Dfx game ever made. Am I the only one to think like this? >Nope. I deleted it off the HD and took it back to the shop. It's a pile >of steaming toss, I said to the bloke when he asked what was wrong with >it. If you ever sell me such rubbish again I shall make your assistant >shove it up your[NO CARRIER]
Agreed. With a 166mmx and Pure 3d card I had to turn off a lot of stuff to get a decent frame rate and it still ran choppy. Very poor looking for a current 3d game. I wanted to love this game but after trying the demo I would not waste my money on it. A real shame. Don Scurlock Vancouver, B.C.
J. Perkin 09 Jan 1998#391151
> Yes, I understand your point, but there is a difference between bumps and a > car (like in TOCA) leaping around a foot in the air, which I see it do > several times a lap...It seems the programmers were unable to create a > smooth track surface and just tiled sections together and the simulated > cars are leaping over the ridges where these tiles join. Hmm. I just got this game (takes a little longer here in the states) and played pretty extensively over the last two days, and I don't see this at all, or at least not to the extent that it seems you do. I do get the occasional bounce, but it happens to the computer cars as well, and seems to be an attempt to model an actual bump in the track (from what I can tell, I have only seen the tracks on TV, and briefly at that). I wonder if it has something to do with system speed, or some other variable? No idea, but personally I think its a great game, and I'm having a blast trying to win the championship. Can't wait for it to get released over here so I can try and find some net competition. J. Perkins -- The AutoSim World Records Site NFS, S2, Rally Championship, SODA, Stunts! http://www.twogoons.com/aswrs/
Nick 10 Jan 1998#391366
How much RAM do you have on your machine? I'm running 64MB on a P166 (not MMX) and Orchid 3D abd it runs smooth on full detail levels. Nick
parr 10 Jan 1998#391367
I am running a p150 with a stealth II and works fine with full graphics. Only a bit gerky when its raining.
I don't know guys, I can only try the demo, but I thought that the AI was superb compared to 99% of the sims out there. And when you throw it into a turn, you can still control it and power slide somewhat. I don't know of any games I can go out and buy that give you the control that this game does.
MDWS 15 Jan 1998#392326
AT LAST!! I have found someone who agrees that TOCA is really quite crap!! I race cars in the UK and I can quite clearly say that it is inbelieveably unrealistic. The car handling is awful. THis would be acceptable if Grand Prix II never existed, but GP 2 is very very very good. (With a wheel and pedals). That is a proper race simulator. TOCA is just a ***arcade game. I've come very close to snapping the CD in Half!! Matt -- Please remove the exclamation mark from my email address if replying by email

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy