Here is some information and comments that many on r.a.s. will be
interested to read. It comes from a letter I received from Dean today and
should be shared with the people who helped with feedback and advice to
develop the upcoming patch for CPR. And, this is only my opinion (not
Deans), I hope it makes some others do some serious thinking in regards to
the content of their future postings.
Dean says,
Here's an update on what we have worked on:-
1) The AI is better - just how much better you'll need to tell us
2) The performance is better - 3dfx sees a 70% increase on certain configs!
3) Object Brightness is controllable and track brightness is better
4) Null zone slider for controllers makes the steering more stable
5) Pits allow you to do the driving
6) Maximum steering lock increased to 18
7) Rain tires are no longer an advantage - should give some of those fast
lap times a challenge
8) Flat-shaded mode is in for those that want to play with those graphic
settings
9) Sound in replays for those that missed it
10) Better <default> garage setups for those that didn't try the garage
11) Professional cars are faster
12) Some other bug fixes - wings etc
All of these items were added as a result of my time spent on RAS.
And here's a little background on what I was doing there ...
I didn't * have * to be on RAS at all - I'm not even a PR or support guy -
I
am the General Manager of the MS Simulations Division -
(check out the CPR credits for my actual title - and in Flight Simulator
95,
Flight Simulator 98, Monster Truck Madness ... ).
I was there to listen and learn to what this group had to say - firsthand.
I now have a good understanding of what support teams go through on the
forums - and I know what
advice I will give them next time <g>
When it became obvious I had heard from the smart/mature/knowledgable
people
and we knew where to prioritize
our efforts I then became very tired of the repetitive nonsense from those
others out to score cheap points or to slam MS.
Noone has to put up with that - whoever they are - PR guys or GM's.
Several of the critics names' came up time and again slamming many
different
games and companies - on many different forums - even in different
catgories (strategy games, flight sims ...). How old are these guys? Don't
they have lives?
They complain that "noone listens to their opinions" - someone comes to
listen - so they take the opporunity to take some cheap shots!
The Publishers all leave - eventually. And the flamers have achieved ...
absolutely nothing.
The suggestions we listened to came from those who took the trouble to be
balanced and mature in their feedback - we only wish there
were more.
And to those people I say "THANK YOU" and don't let the idiots deter you
from providing your valuable thoughts and feedback in the future.
Many were so blinded by their desire to take a cheap shot at "M$" that they
didn't realize they had a chance to actually make a difference.
So now we're gone. Like Papyrus, Microprose and all the others. Don't they
see a trend?
You may even want to share this info with those (kind) folks who were
worried I might lose my "PR job" by leaving RAS (!).
So Patch is looking good. Editors are coming. I'm fine. And my teams are
working on some great stuff for next year!
Debate over Dean's letter about the CPR patch
David Fisher shared a letter from Microsoft's Dean about the CART Precision Racing patch and those who had helped shape it. Bart Brown found its tone immature for a Microsoft simulations general manager, while others found it reasonable. Discussion moved to why the patch came so quickly and whether CPR and F1RS had avoided each other's markets at Christmas.
Automated summary.
Very good to hear. Perhaps once patched, Microsoft will actually have
the game that was advertised...
--
Eric T. Busch
http://ebusch.akorn.net
>Here's an update on what we have worked on:-
>1) The AI is better - just how much better you'll need to tell us
>2) The performance is better - 3dfx sees a 70% increase on certain
configs!
>3) Object Brightness is controllable and track brightness is better
>4) Null zone slider for controllers makes the steering more stable
>5) Pits allow you to do the driving
>6) Maximum steering lock increased to 18
>7) Rain tires are no longer an advantage - should give some of those
fast
>lap times a challenge
>8) Flat-shaded mode is in for those that want to play with those
graphic
>settings
>9) Sound in replays for those that missed it
>10) Better <default> garage setups for those that didn't try the garage
>11) Professional cars are faster
>12) Some other bug fixes - wings etc
I am NOT trying to start or rekindle another flamewar or beat a dead
horse, but honestly -- and I certainly invite feedback of any kind -- is
it just me, or does this sound rather immature from a guy who's the
General Manager of the MS Simulations Division? General Manager of a
Microsoft Division-- that's about as responsible a professional position
as it's possible to have anywhere on the planet. Now, I realize that
Dean puts his pants on one leg at a time like the rest of us, but
*really*, is this the sort of public thinking that one would consider
appropriate to such a powerful and responsible position?
Dean Lester:
"When it became obvious I had heard from the smart/mature/knowledgable
people and we knew where to prioritize our efforts I then became very
tired of the repetitive nonsense from those others out to score cheap
points or to slam MS...
They complain that "no one listens to their opinions" - someone comes to
listen - so they take the opporunity to take some cheap shots!
The Publishers all leave - eventually. And the flamers have achieved ...
absolutely nothing.
The suggestions we listened to came from those who took the trouble to
be balanced and mature in their feedback - we only wish there were
more."
I'm sorry, but "score cheap points" with whom? For what possible
purpose? "Slam MS"? First of all, slamming Microsoft is a bona fide
national pasttime (please don't misunderstand me, I'm not condoning the
*unearned* generalized trashing of MS); the tiny bit represented by this
very small appendix to the Brobdignagian giant that is Microsoft is so
insignificant as to be beneath the noise floor of general civilization.
Second, and for that very reason, why should anyone at MS care what
people in here say about them?
For pity's sake, has no one ever used a "delete" key? That's what I do
to messages that I consider "nonsense."
This is my very own personal opinion, but it seems to me that for the
General Manager of Microsoft's Simulation Division to publicly and
arbitrarily divide the subscribers to this newsgroup into
"smart/mature/knowledgable people...those who took the trouble to be
balanced and mature" on the one hand, and relegate those who criticise
the very real problems (or they wouldn't be writing a patch) with CPR as
purveyors of "repetitive nonsense...out to score cheap points or to slam
MS" and "flamers" on the other, is just not professional behavior, and
is disingenuous and divisive in the extreme. It is all too easy, and all
too common, to use the term "flamer" to dismiss those who have real
concerns, and to negate the validity of their concerns by the simple use
of this pejorative. It has ever been thus, but it has NEVER been right.
It's just an easy cop-out.
Interesting that this was a private email, but Mr. Lester chose to allow
it to be made public, with this subtly suggestive parting comment:
"You may even want to share this info with those (kind) folks who were
worried I might lose my "PR job" by leaving RAS (!)"
Am I the only person who sees it this way? I've certainly been full of
s**t before...
Bart brown
Not to me...
- Mike.
====================================================
Mike Holthouse - Indianapolis, IN
I'm sick of spam!! To e-mail me, remove the "x"...
====================================================
I don't think so. Dean is either a) still too steamed to think
straight, or b) desperately trying to spin the [mostly valid]
criticisms of CPR. Either way it's not too professional.
Joe
It doesn't sound immature at all. It sounds quite reasonable given that
Microsoft and all of the other game manufacturers could sell about 99.8% of
the amount of the titles they sell now whether anyone on this group existed,
gave a shit, complained, screamed and flamed, or whatever.
The ONLY relevant issue left, now that Dean is gone, is how will Microsoft
treat those people who bought CART 1.0 if it turns out major and annoying
patching is required to "finish" the game. If they are willing to provide
replacement CD's, then I have no complaints. Since I am still waiting for
much more minor patchwork on my ageing copy of GP2, I think I can hold out
'til next week for the CART patch.
Quoted text (63 lines)
>I am NOT trying to start or rekindle another flamewar or beat a dead >horse, but honestly -- and I certainly invite feedback of any kind -- is >it just me, or does this sound rather immature from a guy who's the >General Manager of the MS Simulations Division? General Manager of a >Microsoft Division-- that's about as responsible a professional position >as it's possible to have anywhere on the planet. Now, I realize that >Dean puts his pants on one leg at a time like the rest of us, but >*really*, is this the sort of public thinking that one would consider >appropriate to such a powerful and responsible position? >Dean Lester: >"When it became obvious I had heard from the smart/mature/knowledgable >people and we knew where to prioritize our efforts I then became very >tired of the repetitive nonsense from those others out to score cheap >points or to slam MS... >They complain that "no one listens to their opinions" - someone comes to >listen - so they take the opporunity to take some cheap shots! >The Publishers all leave - eventually. And the flamers have achieved ... >absolutely nothing. >The suggestions we listened to came from those who took the trouble to >be balanced and mature in their feedback - we only wish there were >more." >I'm sorry, but "score cheap points" with whom? For what possible >purpose? "Slam MS"? First of all, slamming Microsoft is a bona fide >national pasttime (please don't misunderstand me, I'm not condoning the >*unearned* generalized trashing of MS); the tiny bit represented by this >very small appendix to the Brobdignagian giant that is Microsoft is so >insignificant as to be beneath the noise floor of general civilization. >Second, and for that very reason, why should anyone at MS care what >people in here say about them? >For pity's sake, has no one ever used a "delete" key? That's what I do >to messages that I consider "nonsense." >This is my very own personal opinion, but it seems to me that for the >General Manager of Microsoft's Simulation Division to publicly and >arbitrarily divide the subscribers to this newsgroup into >"smart/mature/knowledgable people...those who took the trouble to be >balanced and mature" on the one hand, and relegate those who criticise >the very real problems (or they wouldn't be writing a patch) with CPR as >purveyors of "repetitive nonsense...out to score cheap points or to slam >MS" and "flamers" on the other, is just not professional behavior, and >is disingenuous and divisive in the extreme. It is all too easy, and all >too common, to use the term "flamer" to dismiss those who have real >concerns, and to negate the validity of their concerns by the simple use >of this pejorative. It has ever been thus, but it has NEVER been right. >It's just an easy cop-out. >Interesting that this was a private email, but Mr. Lester chose to allow >it to be made public, with this subtly suggestive parting comment: >"You may even want to share this info with those (kind) folks who were >worried I might lose my "PR job" by leaving RAS (!)" >Am I the only person who sees it this way? I've certainly been full of >s**t before... >Bart brownImature??? Tired of BS sounds more like it. Everybody wants the
programers to make their games perfect for that one individual. When that
doesn't happen, we as individuals raise a stink. Unfortunately, when we do
this as individuals, it hits the target more like a group reply. and keeps
comming. Types like Dean need to learn how to use the ignore command in
many newsreaders. If there are certain folks who repeatedly argue just to
hear their own voice...ignore em. Maybe send them a quck note thanking
them for the previous imput and then...zzzappp. No more malcontents. Of
course this then means that possibly a glaring error will go uncorrected.
but we bring that upon ourselves when we choose attack mode rather than
constructive dialoge mode.
dave henrie
Quoted text (63 lines)
> I am NOT trying to start or rekindle another flamewar or beat a dead > horse, but honestly -- and I certainly invite feedback of any kind -- is > it just me, or does this sound rather immature from a guy who's the > General Manager of the MS Simulations Division? General Manager of a > Microsoft Division-- that's about as responsible a professional position > as it's possible to have anywhere on the planet. Now, I realize that > Dean puts his pants on one leg at a time like the rest of us, but > *really*, is this the sort of public thinking that one would consider > appropriate to such a powerful and responsible position? > Dean Lester: > "When it became obvious I had heard from the smart/mature/knowledgable > people and we knew where to prioritize our efforts I then became very > tired of the repetitive nonsense from those others out to score cheap > points or to slam MS... > They complain that "no one listens to their opinions" - someone comes to > listen - so they take the opporunity to take some cheap shots! > The Publishers all leave - eventually. And the flamers have achieved ... > absolutely nothing. > The suggestions we listened to came from those who took the trouble to > be balanced and mature in their feedback - we only wish there were > more." > I'm sorry, but "score cheap points" with whom? For what possible > purpose? "Slam MS"? First of all, slamming Microsoft is a bona fide > national pasttime (please don't misunderstand me, I'm not condoning the > *unearned* generalized trashing of MS); the tiny bit represented by this > very small appendix to the Brobdignagian giant that is Microsoft is so > insignificant as to be beneath the noise floor of general civilization. > Second, and for that very reason, why should anyone at MS care what > people in here say about them? > For pity's sake, has no one ever used a "delete" key? That's what I do > to messages that I consider "nonsense." > This is my very own personal opinion, but it seems to me that for the > General Manager of Microsoft's Simulation Division to publicly and > arbitrarily divide the subscribers to this newsgroup into > "smart/mature/knowledgable people...those who took the trouble to be > balanced and mature" on the one hand, and relegate those who criticise > the very real problems (or they wouldn't be writing a patch) with CPR as > purveyors of "repetitive nonsense...out to score cheap points or to slam > MS" and "flamers" on the other, is just not professional behavior, and > is disingenuous and divisive in the extreme. It is all too easy, and all > too common, to use the term "flamer" to dismiss those who have real > concerns, and to negate the validity of their concerns by the simple use > of this pejorative. It has ever been thus, but it has NEVER been right. > It's just an easy cop-out. > Interesting that this was a private email, but Mr. Lester chose to allow > it to be made public, with this subtly suggestive parting comment: > "You may even want to share this info with those (kind) folks who were > worried I might lose my "PR job" by leaving RAS (!)" > Am I the only person who sees it this way? I've certainly been full of > s**t before... > Bart brownit seems odd that you expect (gratis I'm sure) a new cd. Lets see. Ever call
up GT interactive and get the final patched version of Doom or Quake?? How
about ICR2?? Well for 15 bucks you could get a new cd. I'm not sure I can
recall a company that replaced a cd with a recomplied .exe that included all
patches, especially without cost or without shipping etc included.. Not that I
would have liked a perfect game...but I hope I haven't let my expectations get
the better of me...dave henrie
> I am NOT trying to start or rekindle another flamewar or beat a dead
> horse, but honestly -- and I certainly invite feedback of any kind -- is
> it just me, or does this sound rather immature from a guy who's the
> General Manager of the MS Simulations Division? General Manager of a
> Microsoft Division-- that's about as responsible a professional position
> as it's possible to have anywhere on the planet.
Well Bart, personally I'd just as soon see this issue die but I guess
its not going to happen, MPO is that if MS/TRI no longer has a rep here
in RAS then it it us who are the losers in the end.
It doesnt really matter to Thomas Ent because we're on the beta team and
in the loop but for the rest of you guys, I'd think you'd miss Dean.
This is in no way intended as a flame, just one guys opinion.
Trev
> Imature??? Tired of BS sounds more like it.
<snippage>
Dave, point well made :) agreed 100%
Trev
Of course if we are the losers (in terms of not getting the products
we want), then by definition it also means that MS/TRI are the losers,
since they will not reap the benefit of all those sales.
I'd guess that all most people really need/want to know is that the
patch will address the issues that have been raised, and address them
satisfactorily. Given that the first version varied so wildly from
what was claimed, if Dean were here and told me tomorrow that the game
was perfect, I'd still wait and hear from someone like Randy, Joe or
Alison (or try the new demo) before I plonked my cash on the counter.
I hope that you guys on the test team can ensure that the product is
right this time before release, since if the original release wasn't a
commercial decision to go early with an unfinished product, I really
worry about the "testing" that was done vis-a-vis the way the product
was marketed.
Cheers!
John
All--
Thanks for your considerate replies.
Bart Brown
[huge snip]
Bart, I agree with a lot of what you're saying here. I also think
that, if Dean isn't a trained spin doctor / PR guy, he should have
hired one to help him with the burden of communicating with the
customers in this group. I disagree with your analysis in the
following paragraph, however.
Giving Dean the benefit of doubt (which a company rep usually
shouldn't need), I don't think it is necessary to read his comments as
"those who agree with me are thoughtful, the others are immature".
Let's face it, there are some "Beavis & Butthead" kids in this group
(and everywhere on usenet, except humanities.classics, maybe). They
*do* try "to score cheap points or to slam MS". There are also
"smart/mature/knowledgable people" who criticize in a civilized
manner, which doesn't mean that they have to say "CART PR is the
ultimate flawless sim."
I agree that, PR-wise, this is not a clever way to *publicly*
distinguish people when you're acting as a representative of a
company, but it is a valid distinction IMO.
--
Wolfgang Preiss \ E-mail copies of replies to this posting are welcome.
wopr"at"stud.uni-sb.de \ There is no "2" in my real e-mail address.
Uni des Saarlands \ Sorry for the inconvenience. You know why.
Wolfgang--
Thanks for your insightful analysis, it's much appreciated. I must,
however, disagree with your main point: "I don't think it is necessary
to read his comments as 'those who agree with me are thoughtful, the
others are immature.'" That's exactly what *I* believed (this is, after
all, only opinion) to be the thrust of his remarks -- of course, the
only one who really knows is Dean Lester. However, in support of my
opinion, it seems that Mr. Lester is having a hard time letting go of
the "abuse" he feels he suffered here. I'm sure you've seen the
following post:
<<As posted on the APEX CART Precision Racing HQ, Dean Lester of
"Regardless of the various *** theories you may read, we listened
to your feedback - and have (quickly) acted on it.">>
Obviously the man feels there is some faction bent on discrediting
him/CPR/Microsoft -- any or all of the aforementioned. I don't believe
for a moment that's what happened here at all, regardless of the Beavae
& Buttheads...in fact, I don't think anyone was slammed as hard as those
who questioned the problems with CPR, and then "caused" Mr. Lester to
leave. That there is a certain tendency towards gracelessness and blunt
words in this newsgroup and newsgroups most everywhere is beyond doubt,
but, as I've remarked ad infinitum, ad nauseam, it is the unfortunate
burden of the "professional" to act professionally: Mr. Lester did not
act professionally in his graceless exit, and he is not acting
professionally now. Labels, stereotypes -- call them what you will -- I
just think it's easier for Mr. Lester to neatly package *all* his
critics into tidy little easy-to-dismiss packages like "immature,"
"flamers," "*** theorists," than it is to answer the difficult
and, I'm sure, embarrassing questions surrounding CPR's
Not-Ready-For-Prime-Time-But-Ready-Enough-For-Christmas launch.
Thanks again
Barton Brown
<<So why hang around if the ratio of data/***was getting so low?>>
I think that question has already been answered by the presence of John
Browne.
Bart
% My take on this is not that Dean had a problem with the criticisms of
% the product - I believe the fact that a patch is coming out that
% addresses most of those criticisms (a patch that is the result, by his
% own statement, of criticisms levied here) is the data that proves he
% wanted to hear what people thought of the product and took it
% seriously enough to act on that data. What more can you want than the
% designers hearing the complaints and acting quickly to take action
% based on those complaints? (yeah, they should have got it right in the
% first place, but most software these days doesn't - including Indy II,
% NASCAR, Falcon 3, etc.)
% What I hear Dean saying is that after getting the data, the valid
% criticisms, not much more was being added outside of personal attacks
% and flaming. So why hang around if the ratio of data/***was getting
% so low?
Here's my take, and it is only my opinion. The patch sure got completed
in a short amount of time. This implies either that they were working
on the patch before CPR went gold, or that they were easy things to fix
and should have been fixed in the original release. Sure we may have
added a few items to the patch, but the whole of the patch was probably
in the works before the game went gold. If they weren't working on the
patch before the release, then they must have had some really lame beta
testers for these things to have been missed. And if they only started
on the patch after the release and feedback from r.a.s., they are some
great programmers and really should have taken care of these things
before the release (I mean 2 weeks holding back the release date of CPR
would mean no real big loss of Christmas sales). The things they are
fixing are things that were all present in ICR2 and NASCAR. Now don't
get me wrong, the latter had their problems (as did Falcon 3), but none
of these games had major problems with the AI, or had frame rates that
could be increased by 25+% in just 2 weeks of programming. Also it
would seem that either Papyrus and Spectrum Holobyte had rather inept
programmers working on the patch, or they were working on real bugs and
needed some time to track them down. We maybe talking about fruit, but
let's be careful about comparing bananas and pineapples and tomatoes.
I don't have the list handy, but most of the items being addressed with
the CPR patch are enhancements or optimizations and not bug fixes. The
problems in ICR2, NASCAR and Falcon3 were mostly bug fixes. I applaud
the CPR team for their quick response to the concerns addressed by
r.a.s. and other sim fans. But, that still doesn't excuse the fact that
the game was definately released before it was finished. Maybe I'm just
being naive. I am used to having to deal with a product that has
"bugs", but not ones that didn't quite make it through beta. Part of the
alpha and beta process isn't just to catch bugs, but to address issues
like the AI, yellow flags, some means of evaluating setup (e.g., tire
temps), control (if they had been monitoring r.a.s. during CPR's
development, they would have seen this as a major problem with other
products released -- and where are those products now?), gamma control,
frame rate, etc.
With that said, I hope the CPR team continues to "fix" their product and
continue to listen to our concerns. I certainly hope we don't have to
wait for CPR2 to get working yellow flags. That is a major ingredient
to CART racing. When we simulate racing a series, we expect to be able
to incorporate what we see when we watch a race. This includes yellow
flags and pit stratagies based on yellows. Races are won or lost based
on these kinds of decisions. Last year there were number of races that
were made or broken due to these kinds of decisions. For a program that
is attempting to push the envelope, like CPR is, to leave out key
ingredients.... Well it baffles me.
--
**************************** Michael E. Carver *************************
Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town.
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Yeah! Everything he said...
(OK, sorry, I'm really testing my newsserver which is having trouble
posting to RAS at the moment. I still mean that though. :)
Before you send me UCE, I know what you're thinking... Did he complain
to five or six postmasters last month? Now, you must ask yourself one
question: "Do I feel lucky?" Well, do you, punk?
> Unreal was pushed back most likely
> thanks to Quake2, since who in their right mind who take Quake2 on
> head-to-head in the stores.
Of course it might've been pushed back because.... it's not done yet??
Watch the *** theories.. I wouldn't want to take on Quake 2
either, even with a game from a different genre.
--
Dave Otterness
That's easy to say when you don't need to live with the consequences.
Funny how F1RS isn't being released in the US until after Christmas
and CPR isn't being released over here until after Christmas - could
it be they got the drop on each other in their respective markets?
Everyone wants to be out in time for Christmas, and no-one wants to
force the public to make a buying decision by going up against a
similar product, especially when that product is based upon a series
more popular in the target country. Unreal was pushed back most likely
thanks to Quake2, since who in their right mind who take Quake2 on
head-to-head in the stores. Far better to wait a couple of months and
release then, when people may be easing up on Quake2 and hungry for a
new challenge.
So too with CPR. Okay, by far the best is to get the game perfect and
release before Christmas, but given the prospect of*** off and
releasing after Christmas (and leaving the market for F1RS or RTI) or
going with an unfinished product, MS/TRI did the only thing that makes
financial sense. Whether we now buy it or not is up to us, and that
will to some extent influence what happens in future.
Cheers!
John
John's post pointed out a strategic theory, while yours is closer to
the *** type (no flame intended). :)
Cheers!
Marc
On Wed, 17 Dec 1997 20:25:52 -0600, David Otterness
>Of course it might've been pushed back because.... it's not done yet??
>Watch the *** theories.. I wouldn't want to take on Quake 2
>either, even with a game from a different genre.
Of course the big questions is, "How can it be a *** theory
when there's only one party involved...?".
It's speculation, nothing more and nothing less, but with an absence
of hard facts there's generally no other avenue open to us. There's
hardly likely to be a statement saying "Unreal is being pulled because
we think it would lose out to Quake2" is there? :) However, if
Unreal's delivery date is consistently going to be pre-Christmas, and
is pushed back at the same time Quake2's early Dec is announced, it
looks worthy of a bit of speculation to me!
So too with CPR and F1RS - of course I have no hard facts to support
it, if I did it would be neither theory or speculation! It does seem a
tad strange to me that they each chooses only to attack the U.S.
market or the European market at Christmas, when the games were
finished early enough to attack both. There's not too many ways you
can explain that.
Pardon me for the "*** theories", but I basically do this sort
of thing for a living, and it sort of runs on into the way I look at
the world :)
Cheers!
John
<snip>
% So too with CPR and F1RS - of course I have no hard facts to support
% it, if I did it would be neither theory or speculation! It does seem a
% tad strange to me that they each chooses only to attack the U.S.
% market or the European market at Christmas, when the games were
% finished early enough to attack both. There's not too many ways you
% can explain that.
% Pardon me for the "*** theories", but I basically do this sort
% of thing for a living, and it sort of runs on into the way I look at
% the world :)
Let me see if I understand this "theory". MS and UbiSoft made a pact to
not get in each other's way during the Christmas season? Ms says, "Hey
Ubi, we won't rain on your parade in Europe, if you give us North
America and Australia." And Ubi says, "Hey that sounds like a fair
offer, who wants to go up against MS at Christmas time". Any other
theory doesn't seem to hold water (but I'm still looking for one that
will carry scotch <G>). Too bad UbiSoft "made the pact", as it appears
they have the better product and more than likely would have done well
in the States.
--
**************************** Michael E. Carver *************************
Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town.
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
No, your interpretation really would be a *** theory! :)
I suggest no collusion between the two companies, merely that having
seen CPR was launched in the US already, and being based on a racing
formula that was more popular in the U.S. than F1 is, perhaps Ubisoft
decided it was better to hang fire and wait till people had cooled a
little on CPR before releasing a new product with which race fans
could slake their thirst. Vice versa with MS regarding the markets
outwith the US.
I have my doubts about the above, but I'm at a loss as to why else
Ubisoft would release F1 in November over here and not roll it out to
the US market in time for Christmas. Likewise MS had "a version" of
CPR available in US shops in advance of their original schedule, but
elected not to do so in Europe or elsewhere. Mind you, having seen the
fuss caused by the first release of CPR, if the above scenatio were
the case then I imagine Ubisoft were ruing their decision not to go
head-to-head with CPR in US stores in the run up to Christmas. MS may
well have been the loser there.
Cheers!
John
Under the heading of "Damned if they do, damned if they don't", Michael Carver
writes.
a short amount of time. This implies either that they were working on the
patch before CPR went gold, or that they were easy things to fix and should
have been fixed in the original release. >>
Geez man..Everyone wants them to rush out a patch to fix this stuff, and when
they do, only here on the newsgroups will you find them being ripped for doing
it TOO fast.
Randy
Randy Magruder
Staff Writer
Digital Sportspage
http://www.digitalsports.com/
% Under the heading of "Damned if they do, damned if they don't", Michael Carver
% writes.
% >> Here's my take, and it is only my opinion. The patch sure got completed in
% a short amount of time. This implies either that they were working on the
% patch before CPR went gold, or that they were easy things to fix and should
% have been fixed in the original release. >>
% Geez man..Everyone wants them to rush out a patch to fix this stuff, and when
% they do, only here on the newsgroups will you find them being ripped for doing
% it TOO fast.
I dont' wish to start another "Holy War", but I do find it extremely odd
that they were able to fix things so quickly and easily. They are not
being ripped. This was an observation. I'm still looking at the glass
and I just can't figure out rather it was half-empty or half-full.
As I see it, the observation still stands. The TRI guys are excellent
programmers one way or the other. I am just trying to figure out
whether my glass is going to get fuller or emptier. <G>
My we are touchy, when someone can't make a reasoned observation or
question something, without being accused of bashing and ripping apart a
program an it's programmers.
--
**************************** Michael E. Carver *************************
Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town.
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
that they were able to fix things so quickly and easily. >>
I work in the commercial software biz myself, and I'm not surprised at all. If
TR and MS were doing things the way these things are generally done, some bugs
or problems (assuming they were reported as such) might have been marked as
easy to fix, but they were lower priority than much worse problems (such as
crash bugs). As such someone in bug triage might have marked them as "defer"
and off the plate they go. Another factor is that some of these things might
fall under the category of suggestions (auto-control in the pits, null zone
steering adjustments) and been deferred as such. I'm not excusing it, but I
can see many ways that these could have been deferred or marked "as designed"
by people who were trying to isolate and fix frightening crash bugs and felt
that these other bugs would be easily addressed in a patch if we screamed
(which we did...undoubtedly louder than they expected!)
programmers one way or the other. I am just trying to figure out whether my
glass is going to get fuller or emptier. <G><<
If they are fixing the product and are patching it at no charge to the users,
and doing so over the Christmas holidays when they'd all rather be looking at
anything BUT CPR code, I'd say the glass is a little better than half full :)
I realize that people here will say "darn tootin...they SHOULD be there fixing
this" and that's a legitimate view from a consumer perspective, but it sure
doesn't change life much for an engineer who was rather hoping to be at home
with his family at Christmas and is told by management to stick around and some
list of problems!
something, without being accused of bashing and ripping apart a program an it's
programmers.>>
Well, its just an observation that the guys at MS/TR can't seem to do anything
that people universally think is "right".
Randy
Randy Magruder
Staff Writer
Digital Sportspage
http://www.digitalsports.com/


































