Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Why TOCA so slow, POD so fast?

10 posts by 8 people · 05 Dec 1997 - 16 Dec 1997

24479 05 Dec 1997#385791
How come some games (e.g. GP2, POD, Manx TT) are perfectly playable in SVGA on my reasonably powerful system (e.g. 166MHz MMX) without 3Dfx wheras some (e.g. Sega Rally, TOCA) can barely manage to run in VGA. The difference in performance between Manx and TOCA is particularly stunning. They're both recent releases, they both run under windows - why the big difference? Is it just down to sloppy programming, or is it something to do with being optimised for 3D? I heard that TOCA is unbelievable if you have 3Dfx.
Nama 05 Dec 1997#385793
Thats funny cause I also have a 166Mhz non mmx and I run TOCA in SVGA in low detail level and am very happy with framerates. Do you use DX5? Naman . >It's unbelievable alright! In poor D3D!
: How come some games (e.g. GP2, POD, Manx TT) are perfectly playable in SVGA : on my reasonably powerful system (e.g. 166MHz MMX) without 3Dfx wheras some : (e.g. Sega Rally, TOCA) can barely manage to run in VGA. Manx TT has much simplier physics model. Most of the power was used for graphics. ManxTT is arcade quality smooth in 3Dfx and playable in hi-res non-accelerated. TOCA is very CPU intensive. Even with a 3Dfx, a fast CPU is required. Or the framerate will be very unstable - sometimes 30fps, sometimes 10fps. : The difference in performance between Manx and TOCA is particularly : stunning. They're both recent releases, they both run under windows - why : the big difference? From my observation, TOCA hi-res full detail with software rendering is actually a slow slide show in most machines. It is actually at least 10 times slower than ManxTT. However, TOCA is not that bad with 3Dfx. The difference is much closer between both games with 3Dfx than without. Actually, I suspect that ManxTT was done by quite a lot of pure assembly code which aims at the general market. TOCA is much more dependent on the 3D hardware as it saids it was designed for 3D accelerators. : Is it just down to sloppy programming, or is it something to do with being : optimised for 3D? I heard that TOCA is unbelievable if you have 3Dfx. I think TOCA is not badly programmed. It performs reasonably with 3Dfx. It is just ManxTT did exceptionally good. Someone with PPro and 3Dfx says TOCA is great in his system. In my P133 + voodoo rush, I can say it is playable, beautiful and should be worth buying. But if you don't have 3Dfx, even P233MMX helps a little. Bernard Shum
Redr 10 Dec 1997#386653
On 10 Dec 1997 17:15:02 GMT, Shum Chun Pong Bernard
Quoted text (9 lines)>: How come some games (e.g. GP2, POD, Manx TT) are perfectly playable in SVGA >: on my reasonably powerful system (e.g. 166MHz MMX) without 3Dfx wheras some >: (e.g. Sega Rally, TOCA) can barely manage to run in VGA. >Manx TT has much simplier physics model. Most of the power was used for >graphics. ManxTT is arcade quality smooth in 3Dfx and playable in hi-res >non-accelerated. TOCA is very CPU intensive. Even with a 3Dfx, a fast CPU >is required. Or the framerate will be very unstable - sometimes 30fps, >sometimes 10fps.
I read a very interesting commentary in some flight-sim magazine a few months ago. It was from the main programmer of A10 Cuba, the game often claimed to have the most realistic physics model among all PC flight-sims (possibly excluding SU27). In the commentary, he said that his game spends 90% of CPU time on the graphics and 10% on everything else. And what is the graphics in A10 Cuba like? It's non-textured all simple polygon drawn graphics. This should stop the myth: complex AI/physics means low frame rate. If we base our argument on that programmer's opinion, it means that TOCA programmers were simply incompetent when it came to the graphics. Ubisoft released F1RS after they released POD and F1RS is slower. Howerver, Ubisoft said this is because F1RS uses much more polygons, but they didn't say it is because F1RS has more complex physics or AI. This is not to mean that creating complex physics model or AI is easy. But it means that complex physics model should not slow the game down.
Joe McGinn 10 Dec 1997#386654
It's barely apparent, Manx TT is ugly as sin on a 3dfx. Joe
Joe McGinn 10 Dec 1997#386655
>Ubisoft released F1RS after they released POD and F1RS is slower. >Howerver, Ubisoft said this is because F1RS uses much more polygons, Just as I predicted six months ago. All the PODnicks went ape-shit of course ("No WAY does POD have a low polygon count," they yelled in unison, "Ubisoft programmers havejust figured out the Magic 3D Forumla (tm), that's all"). Joe
Doug Bur 11 Dec 1997#386955
ManxTT did an exceptionally good job? On what? This is one of the lamer releases of the year. It has NOTHING over MotoRacer ... 2 tracks ??? come on... Doug
Yes, it is clear in GP2 which relies entirely on processor that the driving code takes very little resource. Switching all the graphic detail off would still provide the same level of driving realism and you could run it on a 486 (but it would look like GP1!). An even better example is Interplay's Virtual Pool. That has an incredibly real physics model which takes very little time. There is a training mode which uses lines to tell you where every ball on the table will go if you hit the white with the current direction and power settings. The game works out in an instant every single ball movement, collision and change of direction allowing for spin etc.. Hit the shot and you watch in real time the balls realistically move exactly as was indicated. This almost instant calculation even happens on a 486, but when it goes to play the shot, it will look jerky with a slow framerate. Calculating the graphics is way more intensive than the complex simulation of the real world the game is actually making. - Gwyn.
: On 10 Dec 1997 17:15:02 GMT, Shum Chun Pong Bernard : I read a very interesting commentary in some flight-sim magazine a few : months ago. It was from the main programmer of A10 Cuba, the game : often claimed to have the most realistic physics model among all PC : flight-sims (possibly excluding SU27). In the commentary, he said : that his game spends 90% of CPU time on the graphics and 10% on : everything else. And what is the graphics in A10 Cuba like? It's : non-textured all simple polygon drawn graphics. : This should stop the myth: complex AI/physics means low frame rate. : If we base our argument on that programmer's opinion, it means that : TOCA programmers were simply incompetent when it came to the graphics. : Ubisoft released F1RS after they released POD and F1RS is slower. : Howerver, Ubisoft said this is because F1RS uses much more polygons, : but they didn't say it is because F1RS has more complex physics or AI. : This is not to mean that creating complex physics model or AI is easy. : But it means that complex physics model should not slow the game down. Have you seen the ManxTT actually?? It is virtually no physics model. The motorcycle turns instanteously. The radius of turning nearly independent of speed. When the physics model is say 5 times more complex, then the CPU usage will become 9:5 = 64% on graphics and 36% on Physics.(Graphics similar). Then 90% vs 64% case will be significant. Say originally you have 30fps.(silky smooth) When applied that physics model, you will get only 30 x 64/90 = 21 fps. (notably jerky, especially considering you are running with 3Dfx, 21 fps was considered quite jerky). 5 times more complex than ManxTT is a reasonable prediction because TOCA really keep track of the traction on 4 wheels. Also, it keep track of all the opponent cars instead of ManxTT's pop-up opponent on your back. It calculate the rate of damage to the car on various speed instead of 'god mode' in ManxTT. Not to say that even the graphics engine is slightly more complex.(You can see the red lights of the car on the ground in rain condition, the tyre smoke and back red light effect is really nice) Even NFS2SE cannot did so well on the above two things. Bernard Shum

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy