Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

N2: AI pitting bug

7 posts by 3 people · 29 Nov 1997 - 30 Nov 1997

While we are working on enhancing the AI for Papyrus' NASCAR Racing 2, we are spending alot of time at the track. I am running across a pitting bug that I know I have seen before and has been reported here in r.a.s., in the past. I have tried and tried to find a solution, but it has eluded me. I think it's something that Papyrus should look into and fix for all of us. The problem is most apparent at short tracks (tracks with pits on the front and back stretch), though I've seen it on occasion at other tracks. The AI car comes into the pit under green, but doesn't get down low enough. As it approaches the pit wall between the pits and the track, it smacks the car's nose on the end of the pit wall and then 1) slides down the outside of the pit wall until it "materializes" through the wall and slides into its pit stall. 2) Veers maddly across the race track to the outside wall and then slides back to the pit wall to "materialize" to its pit stall. After analyzing many replays of these buggy pit attempts, I have come to the conclusion that the trigger for the event is that the AI was not "pulled" into the pitting groove for its approach to the pits. Whenever a car successfully slides down to the pitting groove, they successfully make a correct pit entrance. But, 99.99999% of the time when the car doesn't get down low for the pitting groove, but instead follows the inside groove to the pit entrance, it smacks the wall and wrecks havoc. This happens at an extremely high rate at Martinsville. To test it out, edit the mrtnsvil.txt file and change the pit window to 6 and 9 (SPDWY 0 6 9). Don't qualify so you will be at the rear of the field. When the green flag drops pull off the track and park your car on the inside wall about 4-5 car lengths before your pit stall. Change to the 2nd outside view (F10) and sit and wait. Once the cars starting pitting you should see this happen by 14 laps. This also happens on the back stretch and the spotter will call out "car stopped low on the back straight". Check the replays and you will see it all unfold. I am beginning to think this is "tied" to the problem with the Atlanta yellow flag pit bug. Besides yanking a few lines from the atlanta.txt file, it looks like Papyrus fixed the track.dat file for Atlanta. No wonder they haven't fixed it for other tracks. It was just more blatant at Atlanta cuz it happened on every yellow flag pit situation. But, one would assume that they know how to fix the problem. Since we have a long wait until N3, it would be nice if Papyrus decided to fix N2 until then. -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Snowd 29 Nov 1997#384689
%While we are working on enhancing the AI for Papyrus' NASCAR Racing %2, we are spending alot of time at the track. I am running across a %pitting bug that I know I have seen before and has been reported here %in r.a.s., in the past. I have tried and tried to find a solution, %but it has eluded me. I think it's something that Papyrus should l%ook into and fix for all of us. % Wait, what? You mean you *aren't* totally biased toward Papy products, and you *do* find fault with them??? Imagine that :) What are you, some sort of level headed fruitcake or something!? If so, you certainly don't belong in here! -Rob (papyrus, PLEASE look into this... It really is the least you could do.)
Tom Hansen 29 Nov 1997#384690
I have experienced the same while working on AI and during racing. I would also like to point out that I have tried many times to plead for fix for the AI poor pit decisions under caution - which typically leads to many of the lead lap cars going down a lap and the lead pack of cars getting seperated. I have forwarded 'C' code to Papy which implements a very simple pit under yellow algorythm in an effort to show that this should be a very simple problem to fix. I do understand that fixing existing product revisions does not yield profit to Sierra/Papyrus - however some of these fixes will also appy to future sims (e.g. NASCAR 3) and some will help keep the customers satisfied until the next release (which they most certainly will buy). /TomH
Snowd 29 Nov 1997#384691
%% I have forwarded 'C' code to Papy which implements a very %simple pit under yellow algorythm in an effort to show that this %should be a very simple problem to fix. Hi Tom, I, for one, am glad this is finally public knowledge (the fact that you actually wrote and sent them code that could be adapted to N2). Now everyone can see exactly how hard it is for us to work with Papyrus, as well as how customers going above and beyond the call of 'duty' goes completly ignored by them.. Personally, I thought Tony Johns getting a job there was in our favor, but I haven't seen anything to prove me right. Maybe he doesn't have the power to actaully get it done, but obviously they respect him enough to hire him and move him and his family back east, so I'd imagine he atleast has a voice louder than most of us. I hate to put anyone on the spot, but Tony please go to bat for us! The game is *not* finished... Nor are 100% races handeld realistically due to the pitting under yellow problems.. N1 did not have this problem, ICR2 did, and now N2 does. Believe me, we'd fix it ourselves if we could (ie. the LP's that have been created) and not utter a harsh word toward Papy, but we can't fix this. Please take a small amount of time and fix this glaring error.. If for nothing else than to show some respect for the sim racers who allowed your company to get to it's present financial state! We put quality food on your tables, now return some quality products to our HD's.. Please! If not for those that bought ICR1/N1/ICR2/N2 there would be no GPL, N3, etc... And life *may* not be so grand for you guys to live the dream. Here's hoping.. -Rob
% I have experienced the same while working on AI and during racing. I would % also like to point out that I have tried many times to plead for fix for % the AI poor pit decisions under caution - which typically leads to many of % the lead lap cars going down a lap and the lead pack of cars getting % seperated. I have forwarded 'C' code to Papy which implements a very % simple pit under yellow algorythm in an effort to show that this should be % a very simple problem to fix. I do understand that fixing existing product % revisions does not yield profit to Sierra/Papyrus - however some of these % fixes will also appy to future sims (e.g. NASCAR 3) and some will help keep % the customers satisfied until the next release (which they most certainly % will buy). /TomH Tom, that's been one of my biggest gripes with Papyrus. Once they have put out a couple of patches to fix the glaring errors, they stop "fixing" things that are sill broken. And since each progressive sim has some components from the previous engines these bugs seem to get carried from one product to the next (sorta like a virus). One would think that it would make sense to find out what's broken in the current release to insure it doesn't flare up in the next release. For instance the HOG bug from N1 to ICR2. Well, they did work to find that bug and guess what, it didn't show up in N2. While the yellow pitting situation you point out isn't really a bug as much as a bad programming decision, it's one that has plagued their sims for quite some time. Okay, so maybe they won't "re-program" the sim to make it "smarter", but damn it, I think they should sqaush them bugs. And while they were at it, it would be nice if they fixed the pitting under yellow algorythm. <g> -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
% I have experienced the same while working on AI and during racing. I would % also like to point out that I have tried many times to plead for fix for % the AI poor pit decisions under caution - which typically leads to many of % the lead lap cars going down a lap and the lead pack of cars getting % seperated. I have forwarded 'C' code to Papy which implements a very % simple pit under yellow algorythm in an effort to show that this should be % a very simple problem to fix. I do understand that fixing existing product % revisions does not yield profit to Sierra/Papyrus - however some of these % fixes will also appy to future sims (e.g. NASCAR 3) and some will help keep % the customers satisfied until the next release (which they most certainly % will buy). /TomH Well while attempting to fix the pitting problems with the cars bouncing across the track, I discovered another bug in yellow pitting. On the short tracks the cars that pit on the back get to sneak into their pits before the leaders on the front stretch. Since they are back towards the rear they can get into their pits when the "pits are open" signal is given. They are then out on the track and behind the pace car before those who pit on the front stretch. So the leaders get pushed to the back of the pack. -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Tom Hansen 30 Nov 1997#384841
I'll fix it. Where's the non-disclosure ?? /TomH ps. By the way - I do understand the business case for not fixing everything that Papy customers ask for. This one just happens to ruin a perfect racing experience for me (boo-hoo).

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy