Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Thrustmaster Nascar Pro Racing Wheel

25 posts by 13 people · 24 Sep 1997 - 06 Oct 1997

Mixed first reports on Thrustmaster NASCAR Pro wheel

Greg Cisko returned a new Thrustmaster NASCAR Pro wheel within an hour, calling it cheap-looking with a faulty throttle, while others suggested he had misset the pedal switch. Other owners found it smoother than the T2 with much better pedals. Posters discussed whether Papyrus sims use separate gas and brake axes.

hardware: wheels/pedals

Automated summary.

Da 24 Sep 1997#378137
Hi I understand Thrustmaster started shipping this a few weeks ago. Has anyone got one? If so what is it like? A comparison to the T2 would be ideal! Please e-mail Daniel.
Greg Cisko 28 Sep 1997#378441
OK here it is. I have had a T2 for about 11 months and have had no problems with it at all. But I am always looking for something better. Purchased a Thrustmaster Nascar Pro Racing Wheel at 13:07 at Circuit City for $129. Get home at 13:45 open box. When I opened the box & notice that the wheel looks rather cheap. In my opinion it looks nothing like what the picture on the box looks like. All of a sudden I am not so sure it is better than my T2. Thankfully the throttle did not work. When I pushed the throttle to calibrate, nothing happened. Everything else worked OK though. The base *DID* mount to my desk much better, but that alone is not worth the $129 cost. I got my money back at 14:57. At one time I really liked TM, but this one is a turkey IMHO. So get one at your own risk. You have been warned :-) -- Header address intentionally scrambled to ward off the spamming hordes.
Eric Busch 28 Sep 1997#378442
Hmm... the picture on my box looks exactly like the real wheel. As far as the throttle not working, are you sure you had the switch set properly on the pedals? -- http://ebusch.akorn.net Greg Cisko wrote in article
Dave Bowers 28 Sep 1997#378443
Say it ain't so! Are there any other people who've tried this wheel, and could give a little insight. I'm hoping this is a one-off case! -- Dave Bowers
Greg Cisko 29 Sep 1997#378529
You mean set to seperate like the instructions say? Besides, the brake is the same axis as the gas and the brake worked.
Quoted text (16 lines)>-- >http://ebusch.akorn.net >Greg Cisko wrote in article >>Purchased a Thrustmaster Nascar Pro Racing Wheel at 13:07 at Circuit >>City for $129. Get home at 13:45 open box. When I opened the box & >>notice that the wheel looks rather cheap. In my opinion it looks nothing >>like what the picture on the box looks like. All of a sudden I am not so >>sure it is better than my T2. Thankfully the throttle did not work. When >>I pushed the throttle to calibrate, nothing happened. Everything else >>worked OK though. The base *DID* mount to my desk much better, but >>that alone is not worth the $129 cost. I got my money back at 14:57. At >>one time I really liked TM, but this one is a turkey IMHO.
% >Hmm... the picture on my box looks exactly like the real wheel. As far as % >the throttle not working, are you sure you had the switch set properly on % >the pedals? % You mean set to seperate like the instructions say? Besides, the brake % is the same axis as the gas and the brake worked. You may have picked up a wheel that slipped through the Quality tests or had a wire get knocked loose in shipment. But if the switch was set to separate, then the brake and gas are not on the same axis. In fact, they are not even on the same joystick. I really like this feature. I can now come screaming up to my pit stall and hit the brakes at a certain spot and always hit the mark. Before with the pedals on the same axis, this was always a dicey situation. -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Paul Sander 30 Sep 1997#378606
This brings up an interesting question..... Does ICR2, Nascar 2 and GP2 take advantage of two joystick axes for brake and gas when available????? The Thrustmaster T1/2 had the brake and gas on the same axis. The CH Pro Pedals had the brake and gas on two axes. Now the new TM wheel provides two axes support. Is this all moot??? Do Microprose and Papyrus program their sims to take advantage of two axes or do they add some code to convert the two axes into an equivalent single axis????? In other words, you're entering turn 1 of your favorite sim. Which is better, lifting off the throttle without braking, or keeping the throttle floored and left foot braking? Does the sim make a programmatic distinction between the two when you have a separate axes for brake and gas??? If you are using the T1 or T2 pedals, the answer is no. I'm curious about the CH Pro and the TM Pro pedals. -Paul > On Mon, 29 Sep 1997 10:12:26 -0500 Greg Cisko > % >Hmm... the picture on my box looks exactly like the real wheel. As far as > % >the throttle not working, are you sure you had the switch set properly on
Quoted text (17 lines)> % >the pedals? > % You mean set to seperate like the instructions say? Besides, the brake > % is the same axis as the gas and the brake worked. > You may have picked up a wheel that slipped through the Quality tests or > had a wire get knocked loose in shipment. But if the switch was set to > separate, then the brake and gas are not on the same axis. In fact, they > are not even on the same joystick. I really like this feature. I can > now come screaming up to my pit stall and hit the brakes at a certain > spot and always hit the mark. Before with the pedals on the same axis, > this was always a dicey situation. > -- > **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* > Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. > =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Dave Henrie 30 Sep 1997#378607
I really like this feature. I can
Quoted text (8 lines)>now come screaming up to my pit stall and hit the brakes at a certain >spot and always hit the mark. Before with the pedals on the same axis, >this was always a dicey situation. >-- >**************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* > Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. >=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Mike...just curious...as to the performance enhancemnent you seem to derive from SCREAMING?? Now I have screamed from time to time after whacking a wall ....but screaming to produce speed??? :) Dave Henrie #99 The Pits Touring Car Championship
% I really like this feature. I can % >now come screaming up to my pit stall and hit the brakes at a certain % >spot and always hit the mark. Before with the pedals on the same axis, % >this was always a dicey situation. % Mike...just curious...as to the performance enhancemnent you seem to % derive from SCREAMING?? Now I have screamed from time to time after % whacking a wall ....but screaming to produce speed??? :) I'm screaming to let my pit crew know that I headed their way. They've asked that I warn them since in the past I used to run 2 or 3 over every other time I came into the pits. Besides coming into the pits at some of the tracks is just like Mr. Toad's Wild Ride cranked up 1000X's. If that don't make you scream, I don't know what will. Why do people scream on roller coaster rides and other thrill rides? Actually I'm Jeff Gordon'ing (well, I don't whine too much since I set up my own car <g>), but he is the master at coming up to the pit entrance hot and heavy and then braking at he very last moment to come down to pit speed. -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Greg Cisko 30 Sep 1997#378610
Well since you can do this maneuver with a T2 is is moot :-) I do it all the time. It somewhat simulated the "balancing" that some F1 drivers do. Seriously though. I really like TM stuff in general. Heck I even was a beta tester for them at one point. I seriously thought the Nascar Pro rig was cheap looking. Sorry. I really did not think it was a reasonable upgrade to a 10 month old T2. -- Header address intentionally scrambled to ward off the spamming hordes. > > On Mon, 29 Sep 1997 10:12:26 -0500 Greg Cisko > > % >Hmm... the picture on my box looks exactly like the real wheel. As > far as > > % >the throttle not working, are you sure you had the switch set properly > on > > % >the pedals? > > % You mean set to seperate like the instructions say? Besides, the brake > > % is the same axis as the gas and the brake worked. > > You may have picked up a wheel that slipped through the Quality tests or > > had a wire get knocked loose in shipment. But if the switch was set to > > separate, then the brake and gas are not on the same axis. In fact, they > > are not even on the same joystick. I really like this feature. I can > > now come screaming up to my pit stall and hit the brakes at a certain > > spot and always hit the mark. Before with the pedals on the same axis, > > this was always a dicey situation. > > -- > > **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* > > Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. > > =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
N2 does support seprate control. You put any of the controls on any any axis, button or key. Timothy D. Lenz
% Does this new wheel have force-feedback and if not, why not? No. Because that will be another product altogether, but I understand that the developement of their force-feedback wheel has been delayed. For mor information go to http://www.thrustmaster.com -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Dirtb 01 Oct 1997#378718
Hi Michael. I looked for the info on Thrustmasters site, and couldn't find it... Maybe I just missed it somehow. An article in the press releases from June says they're working with Immersion Technology, but no info on the delay. I looked in a few other places, including the product page for the MotorSport GP wheel, which is the FF wheel that was originally slated for summer release. --
% > This brings up an interesting question..... % > % > Does ICR2, Nascar 2 and GP2 take advantage of two joystick axes for brake % > and gas when available????? The Thrustmaster T1/2 had the brake and gas on % > the same axis. The CH Pro Pedals had the brake and gas on two axes. Now % > the new TM wheel provides two axes support. Is this all moot??? Do % > Microprose and Papyrus program their sims to take advantage of two axes or % > do they add some code to convert the two axes into an equivalent single % > axis????? In other words, you're entering turn 1 of your favorite sim. % > Which is better, lifting off the throttle without braking, or keeping the % > throttle floored and left foot braking? Does the sim make a programmatic % Well since you can do this maneuver with a T2 is is moot :-) I do it % all the time. % It somewhat simulated the "balancing" that some F1 drivers do. While it can be done with combined axis for the pedals, the results in Papyrus sims when on separate axis is more accurately modeled. Thus providing a more accurate and precise reaction to such actions as trail-braking. However, Papyrus sims does not accurately model this 100% (see earlier post in this thread). % Seriously though. I really like TM stuff in general. Heck I even was a beta % tester for them at one point. I seriously thought the Nascar Pro rig was % cheap % looking. Sorry. I really did not think it was a reasonable upgrade to a 10 % month old T2. While I can agree with your accessment of the NASCAR Pro not being a reasonable upgrade to a 10 month old T2, I am somewhat confused by your statements saying that the "NASCAR Pro rig was cheap looking". I don't know, not having seen the beta version, but would assume that the most beta versions where not "housed" in the final production housing. I fin the construction and design of the NASCAR Pro to be an improvement over the T1/T2. While the earlier T1's (limited editions) where in metal housings, I still find the overall design of the NASCAR Pro to be more solid and yes even "less cheap". The NASCAR Pro is housed in "thick" and solid modeled hi-impact plastics. The construction and design of the wheel (while smaller than the stock T1/2 series), is more solid and much more comfortable. While its size is similar to the GP1 wheel, I think the construction is more solid and I really appreciate the "molded" grips and the cushion. The wheel is more in design to a CART/PPG car's wheel than a Winston Cup car's. The design of the stick shift is an marked improvement over the T1/2 series. The pedal base and pedal mechanisms are a vast improvement over the T1/2 design and construction. If the construction of the NASCAR Pro seemed cheap to you and it is the same construction as the final product, it may be that you are just adverse to "plastic". Take a look at today's modern fighter planes or CART/F1 cars. While they may not be "plastic" they sure see cheap compared to the planes and cars that were pure metal. ;-) To quote a line from "Twin Peaks", "wrapped in plastic". -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
% This brings up an interesting question..... % Does ICR2, Nascar 2 and GP2 take advantage of two joystick axes for brake % and gas when available????? The Thrustmaster T1/2 had the brake and gas on % the same axis. The CH Pro Pedals had the brake and gas on two axes. Now % the new TM wheel provides two axes support. Is this all moot??? Do % Microprose and Papyrus program their sims to take advantage of two axes or % do they add some code to convert the two axes into an equivalent single % axis????? In other words, you're entering turn 1 of your favorite sim. % Which is better, lifting off the throttle without braking, or keeping the % throttle floored and left foot braking? Does the sim make a programmatic % distinction between the two when you have a separate axes for brake and % gas??? If you are using the T1 or T2 pedals, the answer is no. I'm % curious about the CH Pro and the TM Pro pedals. Yes. I am not sure exactly how well GP2 models this, but one can select a different axis or even joystick for the gas and brake in GP2. I do find that the control of the car is much better with separate axis in GP2. Especially noticable in trail-braking, slightly touching the brakes while under throttle to shift the weigh towards the front wheels for steering purposes. As to Papyrus sims, I tested this out in N2. With combined pedals (all on the same axis) with both throttle and brake fully depressed -- Nothing, no revs not movement. With the pedals on separate axis and both pedals fully depressed -- max revs and no movement -- the car just sits there and spins the rear wheels. While not an accurate re-creation of reality, it does show that the modeling is different with separate axis. On the track there is a noticable difference. Braking is much more precise. I can easily keep on the throttle and use the brake to slow down and when I let off the brake acceleration is quicker to respond. (Note: Please follow this thread to for more information) -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
% My understanding is that the Papyrus sims do not model the gas and brake % separately. When you step on the brake, it overrides the gas pedal, even if % they are on separate axes. (Note: for news servers that don't honor supersedes or cancels this is an enhanced post). While Papyrus sims does not "accurately" model separate axis for brake and throttle, there is a marked difference in how the program reacts between combined and separate axis. There is an advantage to having the inputs on separate axis, however, it is not exactly the same as in real life. Here is Jim Sokoloff's explanation from the an older r.a.s. post: ubject: Re: How do pedals / wheels work? Date: 1997/04/26 Newsgroups: rec.autos.simulators >> If the pedals are both wired to the same axis (the usual case), then >> applying the brake is (electrically) the same as letting off the >> throttle. If the brake and throttle are on separate axes, then it is >> up to the game software what happens. >> In Papyrus sims released to date, applying the brakes at all overrides
Quoted text (9 lines)>> the throttle input, causing something which is not what you describe >> you want... >> ---Jim >So let me get this stright. If I'm running at Pocono and I have the >Throttle all the way down heading into turn 1 I don't have to lift the >foot off? I can just press on the brake and it overrides the throttle? >So in a race, I can leave my foot on the throttle the whole time?
No. I wasn't clear. In pedal sets with gas and brake wired together, the computer can only read one value. (Think of it as Value = Throttle - Brakes.) If you keep your foot on the throttle, and press the brakes 10%, the computer will read (in percentages for simplicity:) Value = 100% - 10% (+ 90% or 90% throttle, 0% brakes) If you get off the throttle and 50% on the brakes, you'll get: Value = 0% - 50% (-50% or 0% throttle, 50% brakes) If you have 30% throttle and 50% brakes, the computer sees -20%, which is 0% throttle, 20% brakes. In the case of split axes (gas and brake not electrically connected), the game reads the true value for brakes and throttle, and uses logic similar to: /* Account for noise in brake value reading */ If (brakes > 5%) { throttle = 0% Maybe that's clearer. Sorry for the earlier confusion. ---Jim -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
% Greg Cisko wrote in article % >Purchased a Thrustmaster Nascar Pro Racing Wheel at 13:07 at Circuit % >City for $129. Get home at 13:45 open box. When I opened the box & % >notice that the wheel looks rather cheap. In my opinion it looks nothing % >like what the picture on the box looks like. All of a sudden I am not so % >sure it is better than my T2. Thankfully the throttle did not work. When % >I pushed the throttle to calibrate, nothing happened. Everything else % >worked OK though. The base *DID* mount to my desk much better, but % >that alone is not worth the $129 cost. I got my money back at 14:57. At % >one time I really liked TM, but this one is a turkey IMHO. I don't know where you had trouble calibrating the throttle. However, I have discovered that Papyrus sims are a little whacky when it comes to setting up their Sims with a different controller than the current setup/calibration. While I was testing the differences today between combined and separate pedal axis, I ran into similar problems. The answer is to delete the calib.val and control.cfg files from you Papyrus sim directory and start from scratch in calibration and configuration. For some reason their sims don't recognize the fact that a different controller configuration may be plugged in and refuses to listen to the new controller. BTW: I see you really gave the NASCAR Pro a good solid evaluation. Unless you lived right next door to Circuit City and they refunded your money the second you walked in the door, you couldn't have spent more than a 1/2 hour to 45 minutes max with the setup. Just an observation... -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Greg Cisko 01 Oct 1997#378723
I haven't seen the beta version either. I said I used to beta test for them (I signed an NDA a couple of years ago). You seem to think that means I beta tested this rig or something. I did not. And I really have no relationship with them anymore. This I agree with. The new pedals certainly are an improvement. Too bad they didn't work :-) I am sure it was something *I* was doing wrong though. The plastic (carbon fiber) in F1 and CART cars have no similarity to the plastic used in the NASCAR Pro wheel. Nice try :-) -- Header address intentionally scrambled to ward off the spamming hordes. > -- > **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* > Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. > =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Eric Busch 01 Oct 1997#378724
There's no need to get defensive, as no one is accusing you. Michael and I both made simple the observation that if the pedal switch was set to separate, then the gas and brake would have been on separate joysticks which can cause problems with some versions of Win95's joystick control panel as well as some games. There's always the possibility that a wire came loose during shipping (I've seen UPS guys basically kicking packages around), but the switch would have been the first thing I would have checked. You obviously didn't care for the wheel, so you returned it without looking into the problem very much. It's really not a big deal. -- http://ebusch.akorn.net
Paul Hoffma 01 Oct 1997#378725
Quoted text (14 lines)> > BTW: I see you really gave the NASCAR Pro a good solid evaluation. > > Unless you lived right next door to Circuit City and they refunded your > > money the second you walked in the door, you couldn't have spent more > > than a 1/2 hour to 45 minutes max with the setup. Just an > > observation... > A correct observation. I know a turkey when I see it. I don't need > much more than 1/2 hour to 45 minutes. > > -- > > **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* > > Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. > > =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Turkeys must be in the eye of the beholder. I just got the nascar pro last week and find it a major improvement over the t2. It is much smoother to drive. I find it much easier to turn consistent laps. The pedals are also a big improvment. I couldn't use the t2 pedals.(used ch pedals instead) but really like the new ones. IMHO well worth the price($129--circuit city) and for me was a definite upgrade from the t2. -- Paul #18 Alpha Omega Motorsports Chevolet truck #18 Alpha Omega Motorsports Pontiac GrandPrix Rom 10:13 "Whoever will call upon the name of the Lord will be saved"
Greg Cisko 01 Oct 1997#378726
A correct observation. I know a turkey when I see it. I don't need much more than 1/2 hour to 45 minutes. > -- > **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* > Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. > =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
SmallTal 06 Oct 1997#379089
> % This brings up an interesting question..... > % Does ICR2, Nascar 2 and GP2 take advantage of two joystick axes for brake > % and gas when available????? The Thrustmaster T1/2 had the brake and gas on > % the same axis. If you are using the T1 or T2 pedals, the answer is no. I'm
Quoted text (21 lines)> % curious about the CH Pro and the TM Pro pedals. > Yes. I am not sure exactly how well GP2 models this, but one can select > a different axis or even joystick for the gas and brake in GP2. I do > find that the control of the car is much better with separate axis in > GP2. Especially noticable in trail-braking, slightly touching the > brakes while under throttle to shift the weigh towards the front wheels > for steering purposes. > As to Papyrus sims, I tested this out in N2. With combined pedals (all > on the same axis) with both throttle and brake fully depressed -- > Nothing, no revs not movement. With the pedals on separate axis and > both pedals fully depressed -- max revs and no movement -- the car just > sits there and spins the rear wheels. While not an accurate re-creation > of reality, it does show that the modeling is different with separate > axis. On the track there is a noticable difference. Braking is much > more precise. I can easily keep on the throttle and use the brake to > slow down and when I let off the brake acceleration is quicker to > respond. > (Note: Please follow this thread to for more information)
Just a related note to all of this. I finally decided I was going to figure out how to fix up my T2 so I could separate the axes of the brake and gas, and went looking for some more information. I found what I needed to know at http://www.oz.net/~wottenad/wheel.htm. There he has a diagram to set up switches so you can configure your home-built pedals to conform to whatever you wish by just switching them. So I opened up the T2 and worked out all the wiring, figured out the pin assignments.. bought the switches, a project box to house them, used some handy phone wire (4 conductors, perfect for the switched arrangement) to replace the 2 wire cable that ran into the pedals... and Voil, separate axes.. and I no longer need the Thrustmaster adapter. I haven't used it in a race yet, I have just been practicing, as the feel IS a bit different.. however it is a Michael says... its a different feel... holding down the brakes and gas you can more or less do a wheel stand... I think I will very much prefer it for feel as I get more used to it. Here is where the plans for the switches are: http://www.oz.net/~wottenad/switches.htm. BTW I don't know if I would do this to a new T2... I have had mine for quite some time (I think I got the first one they made lol) and felt comfortable with changing it without worrying about voiding a warranty. If anyone has any questions I can help out some but Wally's World had all the information I needed, I just needed to take my time and do a lot of checking with my multi-meter. It was worth it though! SmallTalk

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy