Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

CRAC - KICKED OUT.....

24 posts by 21 people · 30 May 1997 - 11 Jun 1997

Don Wilsher removed from anti-cheating group CRAC

Don Wilsher of IVGA complained that Alex Koziol had dropped him from Computer Racers Against Cheating after accusations that he cheated on Hawaii. Others pointed out that Wilsher had admitted cheating to demonstrate flaws, and debated whether teams sharing setups or extracting setups were unfair. Tom Eckel noted the news that Ed Martin had left Papyrus.

online racing/leaguescommunity/metaNASCAR Racing

Automated summary.

Don Wilshe 30 May 1997#368660
Subject: Alex Koziol of ***-Racing has just booted me out of the CRAC... Computers Racers Against Cheating. Drivers: I was just informed by ALEX KOZIOL that I have been dropped from the CRAC list because a some drivers called me a cheater. I have spent thousands of dollars trying the fix the PAPRYUS software so it would prevent cheating. If I am gonna be kicked off the CRAC list than I want to know who is calling me a cheater and what proof they have? I still believe in the justice system and I would like to face my accuser's. If any of you drivers want to step forward and explain why you think I cheat than give me your best shot and I will try and explain. All of the non-sense could of prevented if PAPYRUS would simple police HAWAII... Don Wilshe, IVGA PS. Maybe I should treat this as a status symbol. You win and you get accused of cheating..
>Subject: Alex Koziol of ***-Racing has just booted me out of the >CRAC... Computers Racers Against Cheating. >PS. Maybe I should treat this as a status symbol. You win and >you get accused of cheating.. Check out rec.autos.sport.nascar. that's what's happening to Jeff Gordon, and Earnhardt before him, and Waltrip before him, and Yarborough ..., and on, and on, ad nauseum! I don't like Gordon but have to admit he's on the best team, and has the best crew chief available today. Rich K. ******************************************************* *Anti-spam: Change the "3's" to "e's" to write to me! * *******************************************************
Ring 30 May 1997#368662
>>Subject: Alex Koziol of ***-Racing has just booted me out of the >>CRAC... Computers Racers Against Cheating. . > Check out rec.autos.sport.nascar. that's what's happening >to Jeff Gordon, >Rich K. Well he's the only Cheverolet Driver to win a race this year but his car has never been tested in the wind tunnel. The boy has to be cheating.
Guanyao Che 30 May 1997#368663
>> Check out rec.autos.sport.nascar. that's what's happening >>to Jeff Gordon, >>Rich K. >Well he's the only Cheverolet Driver to win a race this year but his >car has never been tested in the wind tunnel. The boy has to be >cheating. There is also a little something called talent... I think he wins as a combination of talent, good crew chief, good car, good crew... etc... -- Guanyao Cheng "And I personally assure you, everybody here, that http://www.uiuc.edu/ph chess, I personally guarantee you I'll /www/gcheng tear it to pieces" -- Garry Kasparov
Anonomy 30 May 1997#368664
Quoted text (33 lines)> Personally I didn't think you won that much Don :) > Higgy > -- > http://home.sprintmail.com/~higgy/ [address restored] > > Subject: Alex Koziol of ***-Racing has just booted me out of the > > CRAC... Computers Racers Against Cheating. > > Drivers: > > I was just informed by ALEX KOZIOL that I have been dropped from > > the CRAC list because a some drivers called me a cheater. I > > have spent thousands of dollars trying the fix the PAPRYUS software > > so it would prevent cheating. > > If I am gonna be kicked off the CRAC list than I want to know > > who is calling me a cheater and what proof they have? I still > > believe in the justice system and I would like to face my > > accuser's. If any of you drivers want to step forward and explain > > why you think I cheat than give me your best shot and I will > > try and explain. > > All of the non-sense could of prevented if PAPYRUS would simple police > > HAWAII... > > Don Wilshe, IVGA > > PS. Maybe I should treat this as a status symbol. You win and > > you get accused of cheating..
Well Don all i have to say you admited to cheating so therefore you are considered a Cheater.I know what you are going to say is you did it to show Papy it can be done but I take that as a Horse Sh*t excuse.How does anybody know if you are still not cheating.As far as i know fron some people who talk with Papy they are not doing anything about it except of keeping track of the people cheating and thats all so they will not boot you off the system.the penalties for it will come when and if NRO ever starts.All i can say is you have only yourself to blame.
What is racing online about? I all depends on who you ask. There are many racers out there that race online. Hawaii is more than a beta testing division, it is a community. Those that have taken part in this experience can understand what I mean. I have been racing online since april of last year. I have meet many people online that I consider my closest friends. I try to take an active part in the Hawaii Community by bringing the news and ramblings that go on, to my web site, which I update on a daily basis. It is almost a full time job. I am editor, producer, graphic designer and president. I respond to each and every e-mail I recieve. I spend 3-5 hours a day working on my site and enjoy the attention I recive. My main goal when I started *** Racing Sportscenter was to proudly report the acievments that the racers online accomplished. I then created my top 100 driver list, at the request of Don Wilshe, to honor those drivers that have showed how hard they worked in their racing career. It was a great success. I even went as far as to create bio's with complete backgrounds and pictures of these drivers. An "in the spot light" kind of feel for the sport we love. And yes it is a sport. I don't care what you say, this is real. I consider this a sport because of the level of competition there is out there. But competition has a drawback. There are people out there that thrive on this, like in real life sportsmanship. And as in real life, if you have an edge on your competition than you will excel. Is this wrong? It depends. What are you calling an edge? There are no set guidelines for this. This sport is in it's early stages. And like any sport that is just starting out, there will be people out there that look for loop-holes and any advantage they can get to become king of the mountain. I have created an organization called CRAC, *** Racers Against Cheating. There is nothing to keep us from cheating, but our honor as racers. We have decided that honor and integrity is more important than being labeled as someone that cheats. We take the game for what its worth, we do not add to it and we do not disrespect our fellow competition. The racing community can be assured that all the members of CRAC will never under any circumstance do anything that will be considered cheating. But what is cheating? Again, this brings up a totally new issue. I am not going to cite exact instances of cheating, but refer to it as a "whole". It is written in our mission statement on our CRAC web site http://www.***-racing.com/crac.html "The participants of CRAC have declared that by becoming a member of this non-profit organization that they will adhere to the following simple guidelines at all times on and off the racing circuit. We at CRAC, hold honesty as our primary objective. Under no circumstances will we use any other outside influence to increase our performance in on-track racing. We will use the racing Simulation that Papyrus has given us to the maximum ability we can as drivers. We will not attempt to gain an edge on or competition by cheating in any way. We will not intentionally use the game in any other way it was designed. We will use the tools and resources given to us by the base game and not add any other programs to increase our racing performance. Our hard work and determination is all we need to succeed. We assure you that when we race, it is in a clean and sportsmanlike manner. The secondary objective we will adhere to is treating our competition in a respectable humane manner. We will not bad mouth anyone for making a simple mistake. Be it getting into an accident or causing an accident ourselves. No one is perfect, we are all humans and we make mistakes. We realize that accidents are a part of racing and no one needs to be treated in an uncivilized manner for a mistake they made. Finally, we will show our support for CRAC to our fellow competition and urge them to become a part of this elite group of individuals that have risen above the simple philosophy that "winning has to be everything". We promise that we will not be tempted to cheat, even if that is the only way we can win. Our honor as racers is more important to us. Anyone caught for cheating will be removed from CRAC and will be labeled by their fellow races as such. This is a tight community we have here. I am happy to be part of it and will continue to show my support for my fellow racers through good times and bad times." This is definately an issue, I look forward to hearing your comments Alex Koziol President *** Racing Sportscenter http://www.***-racing.com
Gavel 30 May 1997#368667
>>Subject: Alex Koziol of ***-Racing has just booted me out of the >>CRAC... Computers Racers Against Cheating. (snip)
Quoted text (9 lines)>I was not one of the original guys that asked that they be taken off the list >because you were on it. However, I agree with Alex's decision based on the >FASTLAP 96 controversy. And from what I've read in this group + various other >forums, that is what most people are complaining about. I dont think this has >anything to do with Papyrus not policing Hawaii. As a person, you've always >seemed more than generous in regards to helping others. However, the FASTLAP 96 >controversy and others associated with IVGA have raised some question in >regards to 'grey areas' and the spirit of racing as described in the CRAC >charter.
(snip)> Having lived through the Fastlap96 controversy of extracting setup information from the fastlap program without permission, and now Mr. Wilshe ouster from a league, I think I like to add a couple of cents. 1. Is there a difference between extracting a setup under the pretense of submitting hotlaps and.... Extracting a setup from an individual under the pretense of forming a sim racing Team? Volume seems to me to be the major difference.:) It's my opinion, based on observation that Teams are a major source of setup acquisition. Oh sure, the reasons for the formation of teams is always the ...track familiarity, share the track line info variety. But imo the bottom line was the slower teammate instantly got as fast as the faster teammate. ( I'm trying to keep this light here..so :) :) :) And O.K., I realize the "without permission" seems to be a point of contention, but on the other hand... if I knew someone only wanted to be my "teammate" to acquire my quick setups, I's tell em to get lost. So in that part of the matter I'd chalk it up to diplomacy,connivery, guile or social skill, whichever your poison;teammates or fastlap96! 2. Given all of that, what of the general consensus that a setup does not make one fast; that one man's setup is anothers' backmarker? I know I've heard that over and over in this group. So now I'm confused! On one hand, the acquisition of a setup is akin to thievery. On the other, setups aren't all that important; these two thoughts from the same mouths in this forum. So, I ask, in light of the fact that teams have never been fit into the equation what is Mr. Wilshe being dunned for? The acquisition of worthless data or the method of obtaining the worthless data? Or the getting of valuable data and /or the method? Or the fact that that the data acquired wasn't done under the auspices of a team? Makes me laugh..the seriousness of it all! :)) I realize the redundancy of the subject matter and if you find it offensive, boring,etc. don't read it. There is no intent to do anything other than stimulate discussion. Regards, Greg Gavel
Pete 30 May 1997#368668
Don, it seems Alex Koziol would rather advertise rip off leagues than respond to email! At least he emails you! Pete
Quoted text (24 lines)> Subject: Alex Koziol of ***-Racing has just booted me out of the > CRAC... Computers Racers Against Cheating. > Drivers: > I was just informed by ALEX KOZIOL that I have been dropped from > the CRAC list because a some drivers called me a cheater. I > have spent thousands of dollars trying the fix the PAPRYUS software > so it would prevent cheating. > If I am gonna be kicked off the CRAC list than I want to know > who is calling me a cheater and what proof they have? I still > believe in the justice system and I would like to face my > accuser's. If any of you drivers want to step forward and explain > why you think I cheat than give me your best shot and I will > try and explain. > All of the non-sense could of prevented if PAPYRUS would simple police > HAWAII... > Don Wilshe, IVGA > PS. Maybe I should treat this as a status symbol. You win and > you get accused of cheating..
Quoted text (60 lines)> >>Subject: Alex Koziol of ***-Racing has just booted me out of the > >>CRAC... Computers Racers Against Cheating. > (snip) > >I was not one of the original guys that asked that they be taken off the list > >because you were on it. However, I agree with Alex's decision based on the > >FASTLAP 96 controversy. And from what I've read in this group + various other > >forums, that is what most people are complaining about. I dont think this has > >anything to do with Papyrus not policing Hawaii. As a person, you've always > >seemed more than generous in regards to helping others. However, the FASTLAP 96 > >controversy and others associated with IVGA have raised some question in > >regards to 'grey areas' and the spirit of racing as described in the CRAC > >charter. > (snip)> > Having lived through the Fastlap96 controversy of extracting setup > information from the fastlap program without permission, and now Mr. > Wilshe ouster from a league, I think I like to add a couple of cents. > 1. Is there a difference between extracting a setup under the > pretense of submitting hotlaps and.... > Extracting a setup from an individual under the pretense of > forming a sim racing Team? Volume seems to me to be the major > difference.:) > It's my opinion, based on observation that Teams are a major > source of setup acquisition. Oh sure, the reasons for the > formation of teams is always the ...track familiarity, share > the track line info variety. But imo the bottom line was the > slower teammate instantly got as fast as the faster teammate. > ( I'm trying to keep this light here..so :) :) :) > And O.K., I realize the "without permission" seems to be > a point of contention, but on the other hand... if I knew > someone only wanted to be my "teammate" to acquire my quick > setups, I's tell em to get lost. So in that part of the > matter I'd chalk it up to diplomacy,connivery, guile or > social skill, whichever your poison;teammates or fastlap96! > 2. Given all of that, what of the general consensus that a > setup does not make one fast; that one man's setup is > anothers' backmarker? I know I've heard that over and > over in this group. So now I'm confused! > On one hand, the acquisition of a setup is akin to thievery. > On the other, setups aren't all that important; these two > thoughts from the same mouths in this forum. > So, I ask, in light of the fact that teams have never > been fit into the equation what is Mr. Wilshe being > dunned for? The acquisition of worthless data or the > method of obtaining the worthless data? Or the getting > of valuable data and /or the method? Or the fact that > that the data acquired wasn't done under the auspices > of a team? > Makes me laugh..the seriousness of it all! :)) > I realize the redundancy of the subject matter and if you > find it offensive, boring,etc. don't read it. > There is no intent to do anything other than stimulate > discussion. > Regards, > Greg > Gavel
Well Greg, If i was to give a slower teammate a setup to help him improve it is my choice.The way i read your answer is that someone who gets help from a teammate is the same as extracting a setup with out the user's knowledge.I disagree with that for the simple reason that more than likely people who end up teaming together race against each other for a while before they team up.they will know the persons character and decide from that experience.I dont see someone racing together for a couple races then giving a slower guy a setup.Then i think you stated something to fact that not all setups work for everyone which is true but when you get a few hundred sooner or later you are going to find something that works.I cant say Don is still a cheater but once someone is recognized and admits he did cheat well then thats his own fault. Just my 2 cents, -- Paul Carillon [link lost in import] [link lost in import] [link lost in import: /~raven001/rmr/rmrframe.htm]
Tom Eckel 31 May 1997#368771
> This is definately an issue, I look forward to hearing your comments > Alex Koziol > President *** Racing Sportscenter > http://www.***-racing.com Alex.......... It's pretty slow around here this weekend with HAWAII down, so I decided to hit the R.A.S. group to see who's flamin' who<g>. Finding out that Ed Martin has left Papyrus is definitely the top story of the day, but your removal of Don Wilshe from the CRAC list is a close second. When I first heard of CRAC I was concerned that a rather large can of worms had just been opened. While I think I understand the reason for it's birth, and recent growth, I have stopped short of signing on because I had no idea how you were gonna determine who was allowed to sign on, and who was cheating, and how they were doing it. While I'll probably never be accused of being a member of the Don Wilshe Fan Club, I am concerned as to how, or what, you used to determine that Don was a "cheater", and how he got on the list in the first place (if indeed that did happen). I would rather not see us drop to the level of witch hunts and unprovable accusations.....for whatever reason. Another reason that I have not signed onto the CRAC list is simply because there are several names on that list that I am more than a little suspicious of, and none of them are named Wilshe.......I'm not gonna name names, or point fingers for the simple reason that I CANT PROVE IT. My only course of action then is to not socialize, or race, with people that possibly are hacking the system in some way. It could be that they are just better than me, that's certainly possible, and I give this short example to illustrate....... A year and a half ago under closed Beta, speeds of 183 at C***te were awesome, and at that time I was suspicious of those folks because I could only pull 181's on a good day<g>. Now jump ahead a year and a half, and literally thousands of laps later, and now I can pull low 186's in hot laps, qual at mid 185's and have a race setup that will run low 185's. The pisser is now there are guys that are running 188 laps at C***te...and I'm still suspicious of them cause I cant do it. In the last several months I havent been able to increase my times or improve on my setup in a way that allows me to go faster. So I've hit the ceiling and am wondering how these 188 boys are doing it. It could be a better computer system, better steering system, or they could be doing alittle subtle hacking...you know.....just enough to stay out there a second ahead of you, no matter how hard you try to catch 'em? I was online the other day and doing a fixed setup race with the FAST setup at C***te and all of a sudden there are a couple guys, well known in HAWAII, pulling 183's with this setup.....well I would bet money, based on my experiences in the last two years, that these boys were cheating. NO ONE up until then that I have ever raced with could do much more than low 181's with that setup, at that track. The fact that they left before qualifying added fuel to the fire of speculation. Bottom line is I cant prove anything. So my only recourse, as lame as it is, is to just not race with people that I THINK are hacking based on the fact that they're always able to stay "out there". I'm here for the competition, door to door stuff, and although its a gas to stomp the field on occasion, and win a race hands down, I gotta believe it would get old quick to just be out front all the time with no one able to catch me. So ya won.......again......whooopeee! What's the point??? So I guess my "point" in all this is to say that if I dont sign onto the CRAC list does that make me a possible cheater in everyones eyes? Does having people on the list now that I suspect of hacking the system invalidate the list for me? Do you understand what I'm asking here? You've put up a blank piece of paper, for anyone who wants to sign it to do so, for a unargueably noble cause, BUT without some kind of criteria for signing on or expulsion what validity does it carry? Again Alex, I think what you're doing is very noble, and I enjoy the hell outa yer web page 3 or 4 times a week, but I worry that the list will be used more as a weapon and less as a tool, and that would be a shame and a waste. All I can tell ya for sure is that if you race with me, you'll be raced fair and square. I'm here for the competition, and to find out how good I am compared to everyone else.....I cant find that out if I'm hacking the system just to win. I dont win enough for it to be a concern of anyones anyhow<g>.....but I wanted to make that clear. Sorry for the length of this post but I'm really missing HAWAII this weekend......and for all it's warts it's still about the most fun I have these days because of the COMPETITION. That's what it's all about guys....am I wrong or right? Send replys, good or bad, to my e-mail address.....I dont get around RAS too often. Take care everyone tom HAWAII resident since 9/19/95 1997" 8 8 8 8 Owner/Driver of the Kingsford 8888888 8888888 Charcoal Monte Carlo 8 8 8 8 Rolling Thunder Racing runs with CNSRL 8888888 8888888 [link lost in import]
Gavel 31 May 1997#368772
Hi Paul, Enjoyed your thoughtful response! I have to agree with you in general that people usually do race against each other for awhile before teaming up. So I guess it's a character judgement call there. But I think also that Teams are the way people fish for setups. I think it becomes more noticeable to me when I see one person on four or five different teams. And if ever I've asked about the reasons for forming a team, strangely, I never hear setup acquisition as being a reason. I kind of think it's the dirty little secret of teams, personally. I'm sure those deemed of good character may also have the motive of obtaining setups as well. Hmmm I guess it boils down to, other than trying to simulate a "team", you know..sort of a makebelieve thing, I see no reason for their being. At least according to the justifications I've heard. If I want to learn a fast line, I'll race with someone fast and watch the replay. So the "learn the line " reason escapes me. Since track temps and weather affect all relatively, then the comparison of diff. setups to weather is a non existent reason. I dunno, there's probably more to consider but it escapes me. I guess most are concerned with the way the setups were gotten, as I see no difference in the end result from a fastlap program or a little social grease. :) Thanks for the discussion. I've more to think about. regards, Greg Gavel
Quoted text (43 lines)> Well Greg, > >If i was to give a slower teammate a setup to help him improve it is my > >choice.The way i read your answer is that someone who gets help from a > >teammate is the same as extracting a setup with out the user's > >knowledge.I disagree with that for the simple reason that more than > >likely people who end up teaming together race against each other for a > >while before they team up.they will know the persons character and > >decide from that experience.I dont see someone racing together for a > >couple races then giving a slower guy a setup.Then i think you stated > >something to fact that not all setups work for everyone which is true > >but when you get a few hundred sooner or later you are going to find > >something that works.I cant say Don is still a cheater but once someone > >is recognized and admits he did cheat well then thats his own fault. > >Just my 2 cents, > >-- > Hi Paul, > Enjoyed your thoughtful response! I have to agree with you in general that > people usually do race against each other for awhile before teaming up. So > I guess it's a character judgement call there. But I think also that Teams are > the way people fish for setups. I think it becomes more noticeable to me > when I see one person on four or five different teams. And if ever I've > asked about the reasons for forming a team, strangely, I never hear setup > acquisition as being a reason. I kind of think it's the dirty little secret > of teams, personally. > I'm sure those deemed of good character may also have the motive of > obtaining setups as well. Hmmm I guess it boils down to, other than trying > to simulate a "team", you know..sort of a makebelieve thing, I see no > reason for their being. At least according to the justifications I've heard. > If I want to learn a fast line, I'll race with someone fast and watch > the replay. So the "learn the line " reason escapes me. > Since track temps and weather affect all relatively, then the comparison > of diff. setups to weather is a non existent reason. I dunno, there's probably > more to consider but it escapes me. > I guess most are concerned with the way the setups were gotten, as I see > no difference in the end result from a fastlap program or a little social > grease. :) > Thanks for the discussion. I've more to think about. > regards, > Greg > Gavel
Good point Greg and i will say this i Have teamed with drivers a couple Times but first starting With my Brother.It was to help in setting up the cars to go faster If you have 2 guys working on setups and then trading them for the other guy to try out you can usually pick up faster.The people I have teamed with are not always faster but a couple were.They were not faster at All tracks but some so we got together and ended up helping each other out to gain speed at tracks were lacking on plus we were able to improve on those setups with each others knowlege.I do this because i enjoy racing with the people I am associated with and would rather have a close race than being blown out.Winning is not everything to me but close competition is great.Besides it still comes down to the guys on the other side of the computer to do the driving which is were a race is won or lost. -- Paul Carillon http://members.aol.com/sschevy454 http://www2.netwide.net/n2ros/hts http://www.wf.net/~raven001/rmr/rmrframe.htm
Brad Dawso 01 Jun 1997#368866
Quoted text (100 lines)> > This is definately an issue, I look forward to hearing your comments > > Alex Koziol > > President *** Racing Sportscenter > > http://www.***-racing.com > Alex.......... > It's pretty slow around here this weekend with HAWAII down, so I > decided to hit the R.A.S. group to see who's flamin' who<g>. Finding out > that Ed Martin has left Papyrus is definitely the top story of the day, > but your removal of Don Wilshe from the CRAC list is a close second. > When I first heard of CRAC I was concerned that a rather large can > of worms had just been opened. While I think I understand the reason for > it's birth, and recent growth, I have stopped short of signing on because > I had no idea how you were gonna determine who was allowed to sign on, > and who was cheating, and how they were doing it. > While I'll probably never be accused of being a member of the Don > Wilshe Fan Club, I am concerned as to how, or what, you used to determine > that Don was a "cheater", and how he got on the list in the first place > (if indeed that did happen). I would rather not see us drop to the level > of witch hunts and unprovable accusations.....for whatever reason. > Another reason that I have not signed onto the CRAC list is simply > because there are several names on that list that I am more than a little > suspicious of, and none of them are named Wilshe.......I'm not gonna name > names, or point fingers for the simple reason that I CANT PROVE IT. My > only course of action then is to not socialize, or race, with people that > possibly are hacking the system in some way. It could be that they are > just better than me, that's certainly possible, and I give this short > example to illustrate....... > A year and a half ago under closed Beta, speeds of 183 at C***te > were awesome, and at that time I was suspicious of those folks because I > could only pull 181's on a good day<g>. Now jump ahead a year and a half, > and literally thousands of laps later, and now I can pull low 186's in > hot laps, qual at mid 185's and have a race setup that will run low > 185's. The pisser is now there are guys that are running 188 laps at > C***te...and I'm still suspicious of them cause I cant do it. In the > last several months I havent been able to increase my times or improve on > my setup in a way that allows me to go faster. So I've hit the ceiling > and am wondering how these 188 boys are doing it. It could be a better > computer system, better steering system, or they could be doing alittle > subtle hacking...you know.....just enough to stay out there a second > ahead of you, no matter how hard you try to catch 'em? > I was online the other day and doing a fixed setup race with the > FAST setup at C***te and all of a sudden there are a couple guys, well > known in HAWAII, pulling 183's with this setup.....well I would bet > money, based on my experiences in the last two years, that these boys > were cheating. NO ONE up until then that I have ever raced with could do > much more than low 181's with that setup, at that track. The fact that > they left before qualifying added fuel to the fire of speculation. > Bottom line is I cant prove anything. So my only recourse, as lame > as it is, is to just not race with people that I THINK are hacking based > on the fact that they're always able to stay "out there". I'm here for > the competition, door to door stuff, and although its a gas to stomp the > field on occasion, and win a race hands down, I gotta believe it would > get old quick to just be out front all the time with no one able to catch > me. So ya won.......again......whooopeee! What's the point??? > So I guess my "point" in all this is to say that if I dont sign > onto the CRAC list does that make me a possible cheater in everyones > eyes? Does having people on the list now that I suspect of hacking the > system invalidate the list for me? Do you understand what I'm asking > here? You've put up a blank piece of paper, for anyone who wants to sign > it to do so, for a unargueably noble cause, BUT without some kind of > criteria for signing on or expulsion what validity does it carry? > Again Alex, I think what you're doing is very noble, and I enjoy > the hell outa yer web page 3 or 4 times a week, but I worry that the list > will be used more as a weapon and less as a tool, and that would be a > shame and a waste. > All I can tell ya for sure is that if you race with me, you'll be > raced fair and square. I'm here for the competition, and to find out how > good I am compared to everyone else.....I cant find that out if I'm > hacking the system just to win. I dont win enough for it to be a concern > of anyones anyhow<g>.....but I wanted to make that clear. > Sorry for the length of this post but I'm really missing HAWAII > this weekend......and for all it's warts it's still about the most fun I > have these days because of the COMPETITION. That's what it's all about > guys....am I wrong or right? Send replys, good or bad, to my e-mail > address.....I dont get around RAS too often. > Take care everyone > tom > HAWAII resident since 9/19/95 1997" 8 8 8 8 > Owner/Driver of the Kingsford 8888888 8888888 > Charcoal Monte Carlo 8 8 8 8 > Rolling Thunder Racing runs with CNSRL 8888888 8888888 > [link lost in import]
I have many of the same concerns as you about these "Crac" heads. I consider Alex to be a good friend of mine, I would like to take him to Louden with me (Im still looking ALex) But as you know I'm also very good friends with RH and this whole Crac thing started as a kind of Anti-RH organization. Your right you just have to say your not cheating and your on the list. Well RH has said he isnt cheating but he is not allowed to join. Also from what I have seen there are already a couple of CRAC zealots who, if your not on the CRAC list then your under suspect, and if your on it then your beyond reproach. Guys I dont think this is what Alex had in mind when he started the whole thing. I wont join it because of the way people are starting to label guys as those on crac, and the rest. And the rest are all potential cheaters. I know Alex doesn't feel this way but some of the followers out there do. I'm not thrilled with cheating but descrimination is much worse IMHO. I dont think anyone thinks I cheat (lets hope Id run better if I did <g>) but I know I dont, and thats enough for me. As you said, and even the cheater haters have said, they are "cheating themselves" Guys your right, its true, if some one is cheating they are cheating themselves. One of the best races I ever had was with with Tom and KZW a 40% dega race (I know what your thinking) but it was awesome 1-4 all finished with .4 secs and it was about 3 wide across the line. With KZW myself and WIlbur Gidersleve crashing our party. This race had it all including me running a std setup and being one of the *** cars leading 19 laps. I got third and TCE was 4th and it was one blast I tell ya. Winning that race could not have made it any better, and if you ran 5 seconds ahead of everyone the whole race and then won? Not much fun there Id say. I wish this whole cheating thing would blow over already. How aout an organization wher people all get together and agree not to drive like fools, and run into each other? I' d join that in a minute <g>. Tom, hopefully I ll see you on the track.
Oldma 03 Jun 1997#369110
Quoted text (15 lines)> >> Check out rec.autos.sport.nascar. that's what's happening > >>to Jeff Gordon, > >>Rich K. > >Well he's the only Cheverolet Driver to win a race this year but his > >car has never been tested in the wind tunnel. The boy has to be > >cheating. > There is also a little something called talent... I think he wins as a > combination of talent, good crew chief, good car, good crew... etc... > -- > Guanyao Cheng "And I personally assure you, everybody here, that > http://www.uiuc.edu/ph chess, I personally guarantee you I'll > /www/gcheng tear it to pieces" -- Garry Kasparov
Not to mention, in the words of Mark Martin, "stealing a race" every now and then. Just my $0.02 worth.
Cyber Racing Sportscenter <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (8 lines)>What is racing online about? I all depends on who you ask. There are >many racers out there that race online. Hawaii is more than a beta >testing division, it is a community. Those that have taken part in this >experience can understand what I mean. I have been racing online since >april of last year. I have meet many people online that I consider my >closest friends. I try to take an active part in the Hawaii Community by >bringing the news and ramblings that go on, to my web site, which I >update on a daily basis.
News is fine. Ramblings are dangerous. Are these unbiased ramblings? Your opinions? Opinions of others? Facts? >It is almost a full time job. I am editor, >producer, graphic designer and president. You being the publisher and the editor means that there is no system of checks and balances for bias. >I respond to each and every >e-mail I recieve. You have not been responding to the e-mail from me for the past few weeks? Why not? >I spend 3-5 hours a day working on my site and enjoy >the attention I recive. I believe that. ; - ) >My main goal when I started Cyber Racing >Sportscenter was to proudly report the acievments that the racers online >accomplished. I then created my top 100 driver list, Speaking of the list.... Why do some people appear on the list when they do not appear on the closest equivalent list that David Martin's MP analyzer produces? Why do some people NOT appear on the list when they DO appear on the closest equivalent list that David Martin's MP analyzer produces? Specifically, why did you remove my name from the list? Is the list 100% based on fact or something tuned by hand and thus with potential bias?
Quoted text (14 lines)>at the request of >Don Wilshe, to honor those drivers that have showed how hard they worked >in their racing career. It was a great success. I even went as far as to >create bio's with complete backgrounds and pictures of these drivers. An >"in the spot light" kind of feel for the sport we love. And yes it is a >sport. I don't care what you say, this is real. I consider this a sport >because of the level of competition there is out there. But competition >has a drawback. There are people out there that thrive on this, like in >real life sportsmanship. And as in real life, if you have an edge on >your competition than you will excel. Is this wrong? It depends. What >are you calling an edge? There are no set guidelines for this. This >sport is in it's early stages. And like any sport that is just starting >out, there will be people out there that look for loop-holes and any >advantage they can get to become king of the mountain.
Sounds like you understand competition...
Quoted text (9 lines)>I have created an organization called CRAC, Cyber Racers Against >Cheating. There is nothing to keep us from cheating, but our honor as >racers. We have decided that honor and integrity is more important than >being labeled as someone that cheats. We take the game for what its >worth, we do not add to it and we do not disrespect our fellow >competition. The racing community can be assured that all the members of >CRAC will never under any circumstance do anything that will be >considered cheating. But what is cheating? Again, this brings up a >totally new issue.
A very complex issue. Alex, I volunteered to help CRAC with this issue. You have not responded to my e-mails. > I am not going to cite exact instances of cheating, >but refer to it as a "whole". I can almost understand why you would not want to open that can of worms, but I don't think you will get very far doing that....There is alot of gray area there. Consider: 1. Using the best processor, vga board, wheel, etc 2. Realistic setups that work well in the sim. 3. Setups that work well in the sim, but are not "realistic" 4. Bugs in the sim that allow more speed (two lap quals, ESC, etc.) 5. Using third party tools to improve performance (analyzers, etc) Sounds like CRAC would allow 1 and 2; but not 5. I am not sure about all of the territory in 3 and 4? Does everyone that has signed up for CRAC know what they have agreed not to do? Your words above are: "The racing community can be assured that all the members of CRAC will never under any circumstance do anything that will be considered cheating." "will be considered cheating" by who? By anyone? If I think someone on the list did something that I consider cheating, then you will remove that person from the list? NEVER done these things in the past? NEVER will do these things in the future? NEVER in league races, but OK in pickup races?
Quoted text (14 lines)> It is written in our mission statement on >our CRAC web site http://www.cyber-racing.com/crac.html >"The participants of CRAC have declared that by becoming a member of >this non-profit organization that they will adhere to the >following simple guidelines at all times on and off the racing circuit. >We at CRAC, hold honesty as our primary objective. Under no >circumstances will we use any other outside influence to increase our >performance in on-track racing. We will use the racing >Simulation that Papyrus has given us to the maximum ability we can as >drivers. We will not attempt to gain an edge on or competition >by cheating in any way. We will not intentionally use the game in any >other way it was designed. We will use the tools and resources >given to us by the base game and not add any other programs to increase >our racing performance.
No third party utilities? No setup organizers? (to help you find the best setup) No replay analyzers? (to help you find the best line) No telemetry? (to help you run the best line) Nothing in addition to the "base game"? >Our hard work and determination >is all we need to succeed. We assure you that when we race, it is in a >clean and sportsmanlike manner. >The secondary objective we will adhere to is treating our competition in >a respectable humane manner. I applaud your efforts here. I wish you the best of luck.
Quoted text (13 lines)>We will not bad mouth >anyone for making a simple mistake. Be it getting into an accident or >causing an accident ourselves. No one is perfect, we are all >humans and we make mistakes. We realize that accidents are a part of >racing and no one needs to be treated in an uncivilized >manner for a mistake they made. >Finally, we will show our support for CRAC to our fellow competition and >urge them to become a part of this elite group of >individuals that have risen above the simple philosophy that "winning >has to be everything". We promise that we will not be tempted >to cheat, even if that is the only way we can win. Our honor as racers >is more important to us. Anyone caught for cheating will be >removed from CRAC and will be labeled by their fellow races as such.
What about: Anyone caught for uncivil behavior will be removed from CRAC and will be labeled by their fellow races as such. Who determines who gets to join CRAC? Who determines who gets kicked out of CRAC? Who's judgement? Who is responsible for keeping this from turning into a witch hunt? Is Don Wilshe the first witch? I think what Don was saying when he started this thread was that he wants to know the answers to these questions. Your post was simply an advertisement for CRAC, and NOTa specific answer to his specific question.
Quoted text (7 lines)>This is a tight community we have here. I am happy to be part >of it and will continue to show my support for my fellow racers through >good times and bad times." >This is definately an issue, I look forward to hearing your comments >Alex Koziol >President Cyber Racing Sportscenter >http://www.cyber-racing.com
Alex, I think you have a nice web site. You do a great gob with your graphics. I wish you would stick with being the "Cyber Racing Sportscenter". This would mean unbiased reporting. Sticking with facts. This would mean avoiding the judgmental aspects of who to include or not include in the top 100 list. Or whether or not to include Don Wilshe on your CRAC list. Publish a top 100 list that David Martin's tool produced. The top 100 based on x, y, and z. Facts. I'm afraid the CRAC list is a can of worms. I apologize in advance for the length of the post. I feel like it needed to be said. I look forward to more dialog. -- Best Wishes!!! Robert Huggins Raleigh, NC [email hidden]
Brad Dawso 04 Jun 1997#369248
We take the game for what its
Quoted text (28 lines)> >worth, we do not add to it and we do not disrespect our fellow > >competition. The racing community can be assured that all the members of > >CRAC will never under any circumstance do anything that will be > >considered cheating. > Does everyone that has signed up for CRAC know what they have agreed > not to do? > Your words above are: "The racing community can be assured that all > the members of CRAC will never under any circumstance do anything that > will be considered cheating." > >Our hard work and determination > >is all we need to succeed. We assure you that when we race, it is in a > >clean and sportsmanlike manner. > >The secondary objective we will adhere to is treating our competition in > >a respectable humane manner. > I applaud your efforts here. I wish you the best of luck. > What about: > Anyone caught for uncivil behavior will be removed from CRAC and will > be labeled by their fellow races as such. > Best Wishes!!! > Robert Huggins > Raleigh, NC
A while ago I was in a Race with Mister Robert Huggins and one of the very first members of CRAC. This individual, who may have been drinking or something, Started ranting and raving at Mister Huggins. Mr Huggins was on the pole for the race with my self on the outside. I was looking forward to trying to stay with him and possibly beat him on the rare occasion it possible. The member of CRAC imediately drove through both of us on the start. He repeatedly ran in to Mr Huggins trying to "cause damage" He was even courtious enough to give me a "heads up dawson" right before he took him out again. I'm not mentioning this persons name becasue he is normaly a good guy and a good racer and he later apologized for his actions. But surely this is "cheating" Even some one appoints them self judge jury and enforcer of their own code of speed. (kind of like that new "Unofficial head of RAS" guy did, he he) What about the rest of us who were now trapped in the mini demo derby being run on the high banksd of Bristol? This was a perfect example of how people in a an organization with an agenda can get whipped up over something and start acting in a manner that is considerably worse than the original behavior the organization was formed to stop! I just read a post from a guy who said he used the button on the ECCI wheel as a pit speed limiter. I hate to think he will be "labeled as a cheater" over it. Maybe I would ask a guy like that not to use the thing in a MP race but I dont think I would "label" him. Hey how bout a list of the top 100 cleanest racers? Speed is nice but us slow guys who practice and practice all week to make it to the upper middle of the pack <g> only to wiped out in the first turn of a hundred lap race well.............. Good luck ALex and good luck RH your both great guys. I hate to sound like Rodney or anything but cant we all just get along? <g> If the WC guys can hang out after nearly loseing their lives due to someones bone head manuvers than surely we can show a little more tolerance? Best Wishes Yourself!
Quoted text (11 lines)>>>Subject: Alex Koziol of ***-Racing has just booted me out of the >>>CRAC... Computers Racers Against Cheating. >. >> Check out rec.autos.sport.nascar. that's what's happening >>to Jeff Gordon, >>Rich K. >Well he's the only Cheverolet Driver to win a race this year but his >car has never been tested in the wind tunnel. The boy has to be >cheating.
Totally unbelievable!!!!!!!!!! What a idiot.... ya ya ya ya and Michael Jordan is a cheater along with every other profesional sports figure who is better than the average Joe....Get a life!
maxwel 05 Jun 1997#369357
greg, well i can think of a couple of reasons for a team mate. 1: the guy is there to give m***support. if i am having a bad day at the track i can still count on my team mate to do well for the team. it makes me feal good to see him do well when im not. it makes me feal even better if we both do well than if i was winning alone. 2: off line testing. my team mate and i do a lot of modem and off line testing of both N1 and N2. we look for pit stragity. how long the tires will last. and fuel runs. this doubles our practice. we can learn more as a team than as a lone driver. we also learn from and teach each other stuff we could not learn running on line as a single driver. we do come up with setups but thats not the only reason for the testing. 3: having a team mate gives me someone to talk to about the race afterwards. talk about that great pass or that bone head move that i made. its fun to have him at the track with me. and 4: a team mate is also there for you in the race. that much needed drafting partner or to let you lead a lap for those 5 bonus points even if your car is off a little bit and he is faster. i will agree with you that there are some people who join a team simply to get a better setup. i am not one of them and neather is my team mate. we stand behind each other 100%. we decide what leagues to run in together. if one of us doesnt like the league then we dont join. we act as a team, we work as a team, and we race as a team. those are the best reasons of all i think. -- sam
Jan Kohl 07 Jun 1997#369661
Quoted text (12 lines)> > >> Check out rec.autos.sport.nascar. that's what's happening > > >>to Jeff Gordon, > > >>Rich K. > > >Well he's the only Cheverolet Driver to win a race this year but his > > >car has never been tested in the wind tunnel. The boy has to be > > >cheating. > > There is also a little something called talent... I think he wins as a > > combination of talent, good crew chief, good car, good crew... etc... > > -- > > Guanyao Cheng "And I personally assure you, everybody here,
that > > http://www.uiuc.edu/ph chess, I personally guarantee you I'll > > /www/gcheng tear it to pieces" -- Garry Kasparov > Not to mention, in the words of Mark Martin, "stealing a race" every now > and then. > Just my $0.02 worth. Doh! I like your thinking, Oldman...I was thinking the same thing when Mark said that. But we're not badmouthing Gordon, are we.... ;] Cheers! -- **do not reply to email address in header** ??Jan Kohl?? **The Pits Performance Team** Computer Systems Programmer USAF Air-Ground Operations School Hurlburt Field, FL Castle Graphics - http://www.castlegraphics.com/ The Pits - http://www.theuspits.com/
Bob Stanle 11 Jun 1997#370219
Greg, Yeah, your right but this time I patially agree with you. I cant speak for the *many* teams, only LSM so I can neither confirm nor deny other teams true motivations. But as for the CRAC deal, all the members of LSM are also members of CRAC and we all feel very strongly that we should'nt take advantage of some of the flaws in Hawaii. We all know they are there and we could take advantage of them but it goes against what we believe to be fair. Thats why I was very open with this newgroup in regards to setups. LSM downloads them, tests them, tweaks them, whatever we can do to advance in speed wihtout using any external program that could alter setups outside of thier intended values. That doesnt mean that we dont use excellent freeware programs such as N2HQ which helps me to basically keep things organised. We DO NOT alter setups in anyway other than via the garage in the sim. We DO share setups between members and we do post setups on our web page to help others that may have some difficulties making thier own. I'm still not sure why you think sharing setups between teammates and or friends is 'slimy'? We dont steal anything from anybody, and we give back to the community information we have found that helps us. As a matter of fact, we are going through all of the setups we have right now and working diligently to get those posted. As I said before, the guys at LSM dont even use the same setups so a setup that is posted on the LSM web page, you might download and kick my ***with it and it might even be one I developed awhile back but think I have a better one now. Anyway, there is alot more I could say about CRAC but this post is getting rather lengthly so if you're interested email me and I'll get back to you. Sorry, if I came off as preaching. All the best, Bob LightSpeed! MotorSports www.cfw.com/~aldhizer/lightspeed.html
Quoted text (16 lines)>Have you been reading the team goals on the LightSpeed! MotorSports page? <G> >You said almost verbatim what we at LSM think. I believe that most teams >that are formed in this virtual racing community are exactly as you described. >After all the help team mates provide each other in order to just keep up, its the >comaraderie shared between members thats the best part! I dont think there is >a *** little secret out there regarding setups. Its no secret, if you have 3 >guys working on setups, your chances of building a good one are that much better. >I know for a fact that none of us on LSM use the exact same setup but we >definitly tweak each others to suit our own individual tastes. Plus theres a >very friendly rivalry between us, If I turn some hot laps at Dover, my team >mates will turn faster ones quicker than you can pronounce Ymenard. Being on >a team is a blast!!!!! >Regards, >Bob >Bob_Stanley >LightSpeed! MotorSports www.cfw.com/~aldhizer/lightpseed.html
You hit the nail on the head Bob!!!! -------------- Michael Kirton

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy