Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Is Formula 1 really that bad ?

25 posts by 19 people · 15 May 1997 - 26 May 1997

Psygnosis Formula 1 PC performance disappoints

Early buyers of Psygnosis's Formula 1 on PC discussed poor performance despite marketing claims of smooth play on a P133. Some got good frame rates with the correct 3Dfx executable, but others reported stuttering, crawling track textures and weak wheel support, and many preferred Grand Prix 2. The Rendition version was said to be slower than the Voodoo one.

review/impressionshardware: PC/graphicsFormula 1

Automated summary.

Janus ya 15 May 1997#366803
Hi, I have been waiting for this game for so long. I was expecting it to be another game for voodoo-based 3d card owner. But I heard that it's not running smooth even on a P200 :( But I read it few days ago : (from PSYGNOSIS web site) ... PC game enthusiasts will be amazed at the realism and speed of Formula 1. While the game will run on a P90 machine with accelerator cards, it has been optimized as a showcase game for faster processing computers with the recommended machine being a P133 with 16 megs of RAM memory. Gamers having 3D accelerator cards in their pentiums will truly benefit. Formula 1 literally races on Diamond Monster 3D? and Orchid Righteous 3D? accelerator cards (native 3Dfx support through Glide technology) ... Have anyone seen this game running on a low-end Pentium yet ? (with Voodoo of course). Thanks.
James Dunph 17 May 1997#366985
This is a multi-part message in MIME format. ------=_NextPart_000_01BC623F.6956F720 Content-Type: text/plain; charset=ISO-8859-1 Content-Transfer-Encoding: 7bit Just got it tonight. I'm running a P90, 24MB, Diamond 3240 2MB video card. It runs so so. Not as good as GP2. But interesting!! -- Jim Dunphy My GP2 page: http://www.geocities.com/motorcity/4211/gp2.html home page: http://www.geocities.com/motorcity/4211/index.htm Racing Photos and Sims (Grand Prix 2,Nascar,Nascar 2,Indycar Racing 2) ------=_NextPart_000_01BC623F.6956F720 Content-Type: text/html; charset=ISO-8859-1 Content-Transfer-Encoding: quoted-printable <html><head></head><BODY bgcolor=3D"#E8E8E8"><p><font size=3D2 = color=3D"#000000" face=3D"Arial Narrow">Just got it tonight. I'm running = a P90, 24MB, Diamond 3240 2MB video card. It runs so so. Not as good as = GP2. But interesting!!<br>-- <br>Jim Dunphy<br><br>My GP2 page: <font = color=3D"#8080FF"><u>http://www.geocities.com/motorcity/4211/gp2.html</u>= <font color=3D"#000000"><br><br>home page: <font = color=3D"#8080FF"><u>http://www.geocities.com/motorcity/4211/index.htm</u= color=3D"#000000"><br><br>Racing Photos and Sims (Grand Prix = 2,Nascar,Nascar 2,Indycar Racing 2)<br><br><br></p> </font></font></font></font></font></font></font></body></html> ------=_NextPart_000_01BC623F.6956F720--
Nick Ridl 17 May 1997#366986
Quoted text (13 lines)>Just got it tonight. I'm running a P90, 24MB, Diamond 3240 2MB video card. >It runs so so. Not as good as GP2. But interesting!! >-- >Jim Dunphy >My GP2 page: http://www.geocities.com/motorcity/4211/gp2.html >home page: http://www.geocities.com/motorcity/4211/index.htm >Racing Photos and Sims (Grand Prix 2,Nascar,Nascar 2,Indycar Racing 2)
I disagree. Frame rate is as good as GP2 for 3dfx on a P133 (I was getting 18 fps under automatic in SVGA for GP2) and the graphics are of course a lot better. The two games are very different. Don't believe ALL the ***you're hearing about F1 though - it seems that some people are just had much higher expectations of it than others. I was not expecting Scud Racer for the PC so I wasn't disappointed. It compares favourably with the PlayStation version as far as I can see. Nick ----- Nick Ridley ----- [link lost in import]
Kris 17 May 1997#366987
I believe the people getting poor performance are running the wrong EXE file for their particular 3D card. There are three EXE's, each for a diff card and a set of drivers to load manually for rendition. The VooDoo version is called f1win.exe or something like that .. the name is deceiving. KrisPY
Rob Jame 18 May 1997#367135
Quoted text (7 lines)> I believe the people getting poor performance are running the wrong > EXE file for their particular 3D card. There are three EXE's, each for > a diff card and a set of drivers to load manually for rendition. The > VooDoo version is called f1win.exe or something like that .. the name > is deceiving. > KrisPY
Nope. I'm running f1win.exe, the 3dfx version, and while the frame-rate looks arounf 30fps it STUTTERS! It make the game unplayable :( Oh - i have a P200MMX 32MnEDO, Orchid R3D. I just played GP2 after it and I think GP2 is superior in EVERY department. The cars in GP2 are far far better looking and the track appears to ruch by you at the correct speed. In F1 the track textures sometime appear to stop and even flow backwards . F1 sucks and it needs fixing bad. Rob
BigDav 18 May 1997#367137
Quoted text (36 lines)> >Hi, > >I have been waiting for this game for so long. > >I was expecting it to be another game for voodoo-based > >3d card owner. But I heard that it's not running > >smooth even on a P200 :( > >But I read it few days ago : (from PSYGNOSIS web site) > >... > >PC game enthusiasts will be amazed at the realism and speed of > >Formula 1. While the game will run on a P90 machine with accelerator > >cards, it has been optimized as a showcase game for faster processing > >computers with the recommended machine being a P133 with 16 megs of > >RAM memory. > >Gamers having 3D accelerator cards in their pentiums will truly > >benefit. Formula 1 literally races on Diamond Monster 3D? and > >Orchid Righteous 3D? accelerator cards (native 3Dfx support > >through Glide technology) > >... > >Have anyone seen this game running on a low-end Pentium yet ? (with > >Voodoo of course). > >Thanks. > I believe the people getting poor performance are running the wrong > EXE file for their particular 3D card. There are three EXE's, each for > a diff card and a set of drivers to load manually for rendition. The > VooDoo version is called f1win.exe or something like that .. the name > is deceiving. > KrisPY
3Dfx has mentioned there may be a driver problem. I said "maybe" because I haven't confirmed it. They are supposedly working on it now.... BD
Nick Ridl 18 May 1997#367138
Quoted text (20 lines)>Are you saying 18fps is good??? (P133 w/64mb w/Monster3D) If I dont get 28+ >I dont play it. >| >|I disagree. Frame rate is as good as GP2 for 3dfx on a P133 (I was >|getting 18 fps under automatic in SVGA for GP2) and the graphics are >|of course a lot better. >| >|The two games are very different. Don't believe ALL the ***you're >|hearing about F1 though - it seems that some people are just had much >|higher expectations of it than others. I was not expecting Scud Racer >|for the PC so I wasn't disappointed. It compares favourably with the >|PlayStation version as far as I can see. >| >|Nick >| >|----- Nick Ridley ----- >|[link lost in import] >|
As someone who has forked out a load of cash on a 3dfx card too, it's fair to say that I would HOPE that any 3d accelerated game runs really quickly. Despite having a P133 I don't get frame rates of 28fps + even in GlQuake, but I still play it 'cos it looks damn good. Thus when F1 comes out and the frame rate is not arcade perfect I have an option of returning the game or playing it. I'm happy to play it because I played GP2 a lot with a similar frame rate and still enjoyed that. I played F1 on the PlayStation with worse graphics but a similar frame rate, and enjoyed that too. 18fps is not brilliant, but the it's best I can get without forking out for a faster processor. Us PC owners have been surviving with a lot less for ages. Do you bump the detail up and lose speed, or play in a tiny window and have fluidity. I was making that choice today playing Shadow Warrior. As far as I see it having a 3d card allows me to run things with all the detail on max, plus a few extra effects, for the kind of frame rate I'd have probably got in 640x480 with all the fx off. I'm not saying 18 fps is good, I'm just saying that it's been good enough for us in the past, so don't write off this game without trying it. Unaccelerated Interstate 76 anyone ? Nick ----- Nick Ridley ----- [link lost in import]
Kris 18 May 1997#367139
On Sun, 18 May 1997 19:02:24 +0100, Rob James
Quoted text (20 lines)>> I believe the people getting poor performance are running the wrong >> EXE file for their particular 3D card. There are three EXE's, each for >> a diff card and a set of drivers to load manually for rendition. The >> VooDoo version is called f1win.exe or something like that .. the name >> is deceiving. >> KrisPY >Nope. I'm running f1win.exe, the 3dfx version, and while the frame-rate >looks arounf 30fps it STUTTERS! It make the game unplayable :( >Oh - i have a P200MMX 32MnEDO, Orchid R3D. >I just played GP2 after it and I think GP2 is superior in EVERY >department. The cars in GP2 are far far better looking and the >track appears to ruch by you at the correct speed. >In F1 the track textures sometime appear to stop and even flow backwards >. F1 sucks and it needs fixing bad. >Rob
Dunno what to tell ya. I have a P200 MMX, 32 mb SDRAM, Diamond Monster. Smooth as silk and very impressive. I've not played GP2 yet, though I've got it ordered. Something is def wrong with your setup, might be something very simple. Hope you can figure it out and enjoy this game. KrisPY
Kris 18 May 1997#367140
On 18 May 1997 18:14:14 GMT, "Nancy Korkes Guerrero, M.Ed."
Quoted text (11 lines)>so there's a rendition version of this game??? >> I believe the people getting poor performance are running the wrong >> EXE file for their particular 3D card. There are three EXE's, each for >> a diff card and a set of drivers to load manually for rendition. The >> VooDoo version is called f1win.exe or something like that .. the name >> is deceiving. >> KrisPY
All the versions ship in the same package. To utilize the rendition cards it gives instructions for loading a particular set of drivers that come with the game, drivers may not be the right word, but it has particular code you must place to use rendition. The other three formats all have their own exe file. :) KrisPY
Wood 18 May 1997#367141
Are you saying 18fps is good??? (P133 w/64mb w/Monster3D) If I dont get 28+ I dont play it.
Quoted text (17 lines)| |I disagree. Frame rate is as good as GP2 for 3dfx on a P133 (I was |getting 18 fps under automatic in SVGA for GP2) and the graphics are |of course a lot better. | |The two games are very different. Don't believe ALL the ***you're |hearing about F1 though - it seems that some people are just had much |higher expectations of it than others. I was not expecting Scud Racer |for the PC so I wasn't disappointed. It compares favourably with the |PlayStation version as far as I can see. | |Nick | |----- Nick Ridley ----- |[link lost in import] |
Minh L 18 May 1997#367142
Quoted text (26 lines)> > I believe the people getting poor performance are running the > wrong > > EXE file for their particular 3D card. There are three EXE's, each > for > > a diff card and a set of drivers to load manually for rendition. The > > VooDoo version is called f1win.exe or something like that .. the > name > > is deceiving. > > KrisPY > Nope. I'm running f1win.exe, the 3dfx version, and while the > frame-rate > looks arounf 30fps it STUTTERS! It make the game unplayable :( > Oh - i have a P200MMX 32MnEDO, Orchid R3D. > I just played GP2 after it and I think GP2 is superior in EVERY > department. The cars in GP2 are far far better looking and the > track appears to ruch by you at the correct speed. > In F1 the track textures sometime appear to stop and even flow > backwards > . F1 sucks and it needs fixing bad. > Rob
I totally agree with you here. I was REALLY trying to like Formula1 but I just found all the shortcomings of this game to much to bear. The lack of "good" steering wheel support, the bad car models (GP2 really beats Formula1 in this department), and the fact that the game slows down at several "complex" points in the track resulting in this time warp effect (ala GP2). I guess the hopes of playing a good F1 simulator soon with FAST graphics will have to wait till GP3... (which is all the more reason for me to install a chryogenic chamber in my ba***t).
ari.. 19 May 1997#367279
Very Disappointing on a P200MMX using the correct drivers and running the correct .exe. I have to reduce draw distance to get a reasonable frame rate.
ccorpor 19 May 1997#367280
R: On a P133 with GLquake you should be getting 30 fps at 640x480 and 40 fps at 512x384. The majority play at 512 with the extra 10 frames. If your not in the ball park here you have a problem. R: If this is all F1 gives you then Psygnosis really is trying hard to make a crappy game. They've been working on this project for a long long time. For the longest of time it was silky smooth, but somehow the gold master musta been a copy of an early alpha version. What happened? This game is really sounding like crap. No***pit. No network. No performace. What else is left? This is a slap to Psygonosis. And no you should be doing just fine with a P133 and voodoo. Us PC owners have been surviving with a R: Hmmm.. Shadow Warrior as far as I know has absolutley now connections to a 3d accelerator. 18 frames suck. I'm sorry but it sucks. Q.B.M.
ccorpor 19 May 1997#367281
Before: After: THEREAFTER: I'm expecting some type of reply from 3dfx. Again this program was heavily totuted as being silky smooth and graphically gourgeuos at full detail to P133'ers on up. Q.B.M.
rob 19 May 1997#367282
<snip> Don't you notice the track texture ? The track appears to stop and then crawl backwards! At low speeds F1 looks great - it feels like you are driving. At higher speeds all the graphics glitches make it feel like your standing still - the crawling track texture, the wierd fence moire effects, the stuttering framerate. Don't the cars look elongated and warped to you ? Anyone with a p166 or above, get GP2 - turn off sky and wingmirror texturs set frame rate to 16 or above and play. Even at 18/19fps GP2 is much much smoother than F1, no stutter, no ugly pop-ups, no wierd track textures, poper car handling/collision great AI, great cars, great game Rob.
:On a P133 with GLquake you should be getting 30 fps at 640x480 and 40 fps at :512x384. The majority play at 512 with the extra 10 frames. If your not in the :ball park here you have a problem. Not true. Sure you get 30 fps in some places, but we were talking about _constant_ 30 fps here. On my P133, most of the time glQuake is pretty smooth in 512x384 (near 30 fps), but in places like, umm, fourth level of Mission Pack 1, or "DarkNite", I get probably less than 10 fps in many cases, and about 15 fps most of the time. I have tried all the "SET" commands to speed up the frame rate of glQuake, and I don't get even near to 40 fps. 30 fps is good enough for me though, only if it would be constant, which it isn't. My motherboard is an Intel Endeavor with a Pentium 133, 256kB PB cache, 24MB non-EDO 70 ns RAM etc. My system works fine with other games, and I even get better results in games like Virtua Fighter PC than many others on their P133 machines, so I don't think it is because of my system. If you have some easy advice to reach constant 40 fps in glQuake (say, in timedemo demo1), sure, I'm listening. So far, I've always been little under 30 fps in 512x384. Since we are talking about jerky 3dfx games, how about 3dfx Mechwarrior 2? Try the training mission on the ice planet, I get something like 5-10 fps when the battle heats up. Great game anyway, though.
Jeff Atwoo 20 May 1997#367411
Tiitus, The processor is the limiting factor at 512x384 in GLQuake... see the thread about "my Flash 3D Experience" for more info. I get 54fps TIMEDEMO DEMO2 at 512x384 in GLQUAKE on a 225MMX, while my P5-133 with 3dfx card (same settings) gets only about 43fps. Jeff >:On a P133 with GLquake you should be getting 30 fps at 640x480 and 40 fps at >:512x384. The majority play at 512 with the extra 10 frames. If your not in the
Quoted text (9 lines)>:ball park here you have a problem. >Not true. Sure you get 30 fps in some places, but we were talking about >_constant_ 30 fps here. On my P133, most of the time glQuake is pretty >smooth in 512x384 (near 30 fps), but in places like, umm, fourth >level of Mission Pack 1, or "DarkNite", I get probably less than >10 fps in many cases, and about 15 fps most of the time. >I have tried all the "SET" commands to speed up the frame rate of
glQuake,
Quoted text (16 lines)>and I don't get even near to 40 fps. 30 fps is good enough for me though, >only if it would be constant, which it isn't. >My motherboard is an Intel Endeavor with a Pentium 133, 256kB PB cache, >24MB non-EDO 70 ns RAM etc. My system works fine with other games, and I >even get better results in games like Virtua Fighter PC than many others >on their P133 machines, so I don't think it is because of my system. >If you have some easy advice to reach constant 40 fps in glQuake >(say, in timedemo demo1), sure, I'm listening. So far, I've always >been little under 30 fps in 512x384. >Since we are talking about jerky 3dfx games, how about 3dfx >Mechwarrior 2? Try the training mission on the ice planet, I get >something like 5-10 fps when the battle heats up. Great game >anyway, though.
ccorpor 20 May 1997#367412
QBM: Titanium: I meant on timedemo 1. I'm sorry but I get 40 fps on a P133 at 512 rez. I'll restate I use this mode siince there will be places the frames will drop. So when they do drop they won't fall as far as if you were in 640 mode. I feel I'll always be at least 5 frames above what 640 mode offers in the worse case scenario. Is the 4th level of Pack 1 the outside level. If so that's a whole nother problem. I don't know what to say I get 30 at 640. Let me investigate... But I'm tellin ya your not getting what you should be. I would say as a minimum a P133 in timedemo 1 should be getting 35. Q.B.M.
Has anyone played this on the Rendition yet ? Opinions please ? Cheers, Ralph
Quoted text (42 lines)> > >Hi, > > >I have been waiting for this game for so long. > > >I was expecting it to be another game for voodoo-based > > >3d card owner. But I heard that it's not running > > >smooth even on a P200 :( > > >But I read it few days ago : (from PSYGNOSIS web site) > > >... > > >PC game enthusiasts will be amazed at the realism and speed of > > >Formula 1. While the game will run on a P90 machine with accelerator > > >cards, it has been optimized as a showcase game for faster processing > > >computers with the recommended machine being a P133 with 16 megs of > > >RAM memory. > > >Gamers having 3D accelerator cards in their pentiums will truly > > >benefit. Formula 1 literally races on Diamond Monster 3D? and > > >Orchid Righteous 3D? accelerator cards (native 3Dfx support > > >through Glide technology) > > >... > > >Have anyone seen this game running on a low-end Pentium yet ? (with > > >Voodoo of course). > > >Thanks. > > I believe the people getting poor performance are running the wrong > > EXE file for their particular 3D card. There are three EXE's, each for > > a diff card and a set of drivers to load manually for rendition. The > > VooDoo version is called f1win.exe or something like that .. the name > > is deceiving. > > KrisPY > 3Dfx has mentioned there may be a driver problem. I said "maybe" > because I haven't confirmed it. They are supposedly working on it > now.... > BD
ymenard 21 May 1997#367577
> The two games are very different. Don't believe ALL the ***you're > hearing about F1 though - it seems that some people are just had much > higher expectations of it than others. I was not expecting Scud Racer > for the PC so I wasn't disappointed. It compares favourably with the > PlayStation version as far as I can see. It's normal that people had high expectations of it, they all played Gp2!! With a beta demo game like that, the first SERIOUS F1 simulator that would be out after Gp2 had to be the greatest game ever. I think it should a a big contender for #1 F1 game place, because of it's Arcade/simulator mix. It's an all-around very good game, and i would recommand it to any F1 race fan. Good race at the Brickyard, (-o-) SPEED- Cars, WC, BGN, Trucks, IROC, utilities and more... SPEED- http://www.sim-speed.com/~speed |! Go Rubens Barrichello, Jacques Villeneuve, !| |! Patrick Carpentier,Jeff Gordon and Greg Moore!!! !| |! May the force be with you, always!! !| |! Que la force soit avec toi, jamais!! !| |! Excuse me for my poor English (I'm French speaking) !| Flight Cadet Nien Numb, Gold squadron http://www.dpliv.com/dragon/Gold/index.html May the force be with you, always!!
Quoted text (9 lines)|! Official French r.a.s.s.m. Cool guy !| |! Official French r.a.s. cool guy !| |! Official Star Wars geek fan !| |! Official Anti-trekkies SW *** !| |! Official Jedi Master of NSWL !| |! Official SW Gonk religion fan !| |! #1 rec.autos.simulator post writer !| |! Best French SimRacer on the 'net !| |! Official Annoying long signature guy (thanks Eric!) !|
Mar 22 May 1997#367725
blahed: Get a more powerful cpu an remove the jerkiness - 3DFX can't do everything ! The cpu has to work out who is shooting who, who is flying throught the air in 1000 pieces etc. -- Mark. *NOTE! For replies remove *** from email address. Dman's 3D homepage:(dedicated to 3DFX's Voodoo) UK : http://www.markbz.demon.co.uk
Quoted text (10 lines)> > so there's a rendition version of this game??? > Yes. Formula 1 is the first game to use Rendition's Windows API, > Redline. > -=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=- > \`o.O' Engineering Physics, Chalmers University of Technology > =(___)= Homepage: http://www.dd.chalmers.se/~f94jowe/ > U BLIND GUARDIAN: http://www.dd.chalmers.se/~f94jowe/bg/
Any one know what the Rendition version is like ?
Bruno Amar 26 May 1997#368191
Not as good or fast as 3DFX - only advantage is that you can run 512x384 resolution to get faster framerate but it still doesn't match up to the voodoo (which is also a tad bit too slow for this game.) - tells ya something about the framerate!!!!!!!!!!! says...
Quoted text (12 lines)> > > so there's a rendition version of this game??? > > Yes. Formula 1 is the first game to use Rendition's Windows API, > > Redline. > > -=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=-=|=- > > \`o.O' Engineering Physics, Chalmers University of Technology > > =(___)= Homepage: http://www.dd.chalmers.se/~f94jowe/ > > U BLIND GUARDIAN: http://www.dd.chalmers.se/~f94jowe/bg/ > Any one know what the Rendition version is like ?

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy