Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

EXTREME COMPETITION CDS5000 info released!

20 posts by 15 people · 15 Apr 1997 - 29 Apr 1997

Extreme Competition Controls announces $1,395 CDS 5000 wheel

Extreme Competition Controls announced its top-end CDS 5000 wheel and pedal system, with fluid-damped steering and a MOMO wheel. Many thought the price absurd compared with a Thrustmaster T2, and John Wallace said his tests found the cheaper ECCI CDS roughly equal to the TSW wheel. ECCI owners defended the build quality and reliability.

hardware: wheels/pedalsrelease/news

Automated summary.

ACers 15 Apr 1997#363056
Extreme Competition Controls Inc. has just released new information on the new top of the line driving controls system, the CDS 5000. New info and many photos are available on our website at: HTTP://OURWORLD.COMPUSERVE.COM/HOMEPAGES/EXTREME This new system has many never-seen-before features such as fluid damped steering, a genuine MOMO indycar-spec wheel, adjustable pressure resistance braking, and a new standard of machining artistry... just take a look! We are only a few weeks away from shipping the first units to customers. The CDS5000 is limited in availability so seriously interested parties should contact us soon. Andy Cers Extreme Competition Controls Inc.
brand.. 16 Apr 1997#363182
Quoted text (22 lines)>>Extreme Competition Controls Inc. has just released new information on the >>new top of the line driving controls system, the CDS 5000. New info and >>many photos are available on our website at: >>HTTP://OURWORLD.COMPUSERVE.COM/HOMEPAGES/EXTREME >>This new system has many never-seen-before features such as fluid damped >>steering, a genuine MOMO indycar-spec wheel, adjustable pressure >>resistance braking, and a new standard of machining artistry... just take >>a look! We are only a few weeks away from shipping the first units to >>customers. The CDS5000 is limited in availability so seriously interested >>parties should contact us soon. >$1395... HAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAHAH!!!!!! I'm not saying it isn't worth it, but I'd >rather spend the money on upgrades to my PC. Besides, 95% of the time I'm >playing, I look at the screen, not the wheel. Otherwise, I'd crash. :-O >Seriously, this company should look into making a line that gets rid of the >flash and keeps most of the mechanics for a lower price. >Alex >ps. A happy TSW owner!
Well, they have the base model CDS2, which is $549, and for performance per penny, way above the TSW. I guess you would like Ferrari to start making a Geo?
Tom Pole 16 Apr 1997#363183
For $1,395, I could could a beat up used car (preferably an El Camino), get drunk, and speed around a schoolyard yelling "Damn that Jeff Gordon," and have alot more fun than I would with $1,395 sterring wheel. I'll stick to my T2 - I don't see value in the additional $1,295. Tom
"WAY" above the perfomance of a TSW? I tested all of the wheels and found the ECCI to be "the equal" of the TSW and at a much higher price. The TSW did some things better, the ECCI others - overall they were pretty much the same.
Shawn Wi 18 Apr 1997#363401
>Well, they have the base model CDS2, which is $549, and for >performance per penny, way above the TSW. I guess you would like >Ferrari to start making a Geo? From what basis do you come to this conclusion? I have a TSW, and have tried the ECCI. I'm glad that my money went to Thomas Enterprises. I'm not knocking the ECCI, it's a nice piece of equipment. But, after giving it a try, IMO the only difference in the two is some flashyness and price. Personally, I didn't like having to shift from the steering wheel. This forced me to drive with two hands which I _really_ didn't like. Although, my sim of choice is Nascar. If I really got into the other racing sims, I may have a different opinion on the wheel shifter issue. But, even then if I had need for wheel shifting, I'd buy the TSW with the paddle shifters. There were several different things that I didn't like about the more expensive wheel. It is one BULKY unit. For my particular desk setup, it would be impossible to see my moniter. Anyway, I'd like to know what your "price per penny" means. What great mechanical ability and precision does your unit have that the TSW does not? The TSW has a _lifetime_ warranty on it's equipment, does yours? IMO your statement should've read "glamour per penny". And for the record.....I'm not flaming the ECCI, or it's owners, it is a nice wheel. Shawn Wise
Mike Ostro 18 Apr 1997#363402
> equipment. But, after giving it a try, IMO the only difference in the > two is some flashyness and price. Shawn, My main reason for getting the ECCI was one thing Reliability. Of all the spring pedals that have been broken on T2's, I knew I didn't want that happening to me in the middle of a points hunt<G> Ah comeon, you can learn to type on the keyboard when its on your far right<G> -- Mike Ostrow Miral - #99 Spotted Owl/Three Wide Racing
brand.. 18 Apr 1997#363403
Quoted text (18 lines)>Absolutely not! The point I was trying to make is that you can only go so far >in making a computer racing simulation realistic to your senses. Thing doesn't >even offer force feedback. For another $600, one could buy a used racing kart >and get into real racing. >The difference between a T2 and a TSW is quite noticable in feel and precision. >I could care less about the looks of the thing. After reading the review, of >the CDS at SIMRACING and comparing to others, I stand by my opinion that the >TSW is better price/performance wise. If one is really a stickler for looks and >has money to burn, then by all means buy a CDS5000 or CDS2, whatever. If you >have an extra $1400 to burn, buy me one. :^) I wouldn't mind trying a CDS unit >and compare it to my TSW to see if the difference in feel and performance >actually warrants an extra $250-$1000, but I'm not about to pay $550-$1300 to >do so. >BTW, what wheel/pedal unit do you own? >Alex
I have the wheel/pedal unit that came with the CDS2! I have compared, and believe me, the CDS2 is better. The review at SIMRACING is out of date, done on the original. It is not only pretty(which I don't care about either), but it does make the sim even more realistic. Can you change the amount of wheel resistance on your TSW? Can you change the wheel lock with the turn of a knob? I drive all the sims, and changing from a road course to an oval without changing these things is pure torture now that I have the ability. I gave my T2 away to a buddy, and when I go to his house to help him with a sim, I can't drive near as well as I can on the CDS2. I can't believe I used that thing for so long! I am not saying you don't have a fine wheel(10x better than T2), but just because it is out of your price range, you don't have to bash it.
Prove what you say before you slam an excellent quality, hand built and reasonably priced control set that ordinary people can afford. BTW where is the 100% lifetime warranty? Trevor
Warranty??? Why do you need a warranty if you build a perfect product<G> Extremely<G> satisfied and proud owner of an ECCI<G> > Prove what you say before you slam an excellent quality, hand built and > reasonably priced control set that ordinary people can afford. BTW where > is the 100% lifetime warranty? > Trevor
I agree, that would be fun. But that's not really the point is it? Sure, I could buy a Mad Catz, but it's comforting to know that others are making the "Ferrari" of driving wheels available. If it were not for Extreme Competition and others pushing the envelope, what would Thrustmaster have to compare themselves against?
brand.. 19 Apr 1997#363496
>Prove what you say before you slam an excellent quality, hand built and >reasonably priced control set that ordinary people can afford. BTW where >is the 100% lifetime warranty? >Trevor Slam? If you can find a sentence I wrote that slammed your product then sue me. I quote myself " I am not saying you don't have a fine wheel(10x better than T2)." And are you calling me out of the ordinary? I am a single 26 year old hetero*** male who does NOT live with his mommy, and I make less than 30k a year. I spend maybe 5-10 hours a week driving sims, and I don't appreciate the fact that you sent me an e-mail apologizing for your reply, but do not post it here for all to see. From now on, I will read the ng's before my mail! Brandon
ymenard 20 Apr 1997#363597
Quoted text (13 lines)> > For $1,395, I could could a beat up used car (preferably an El Camino), > get > > drunk, and speed around a schoolyard yelling "Damn that Jeff Gordon," and > > have alot more fun than I would with $1,395 sterring wheel. I'll stick to > > my T2 - I don't see value in the additional $1,295. > > Tom > I agree, that would be fun. But that's not really the point is it? Sure, > I could buy a Mad Catz, but it's comforting to know that others are making > the "Ferrari" of driving wheels available. If it were not for Extreme > Competition and others pushing the envelope, what would Thrustmaster have > to compare themselves against?
Well for the price of a MadCatz (which I think is a great whell FOR it's price) do you get a real difference in laps for all the money spent on the ECC wheel? If I could run 10mph more than with a Madcatz, that would be a good wheel. But for the confort and the 0.1 mph that you can do faster, it's not worth 1200$ more. I'm not telling it's not a great wheel (I think it's one of the best, with the HyperStimulator). It's just that (and per exemple) if you take the Madcatz, for 1200$ less you can have 75% of what the ECC does. And it's not 75% of the ECC price!!! Good race at the Brickyard, (Old'Indytrack guy in rec.autos.simulators) ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ =ymenard now!!! SPEED- http://www.nascarnet.com/~speed [===] Go Rubens Barrichello, Jacques Villeneuve, | ! | And all you that thinks that Jacques Villeneuve is |!| from Canada, your right!! He's from St-Jean sur le |o| Richelieu, 30 minutes from Montreal, Quebec, Canada. [--I--] v Fran?ois Mnard "Wasupe LeGrand" May the force be with you, always!! Que la force soit avec toi, jamais!(for you French people) Excuse me for my poor English(I'm French speaking)
brand.. 21 Apr 1997#363725
>Well for the price of a MadCatz (which I think is a great whell FOR it's >price) do you get a real difference in laps for all the money spent on >the ECC wheel? Yes, actually I do. I also have had a MadCatz, a T2, and the opportunity to use a TSW. Comparing the TSW to the ECC is understandable, but please, untill you have used one, do not compare an ECC unit to a plastic, massed produced unit. Like I said in the previous post, the CDS2 is more than half the price of the CDS5000. And again, untill you try one, don't say it is not worth it. It will last longer than 10 Madcatz's, and then how much would you have spent?
Rich McCab 22 Apr 1997#363852
Boy you guys are being pretty tough on the extreme wheel. Keep in mind this is not the only wheel that Extreme sells. This is a "special order" only wheel that is for teh guy that want to out do his neighbor. His other wheels are half the cost, which is still expensive. I own an extreme wheel that I bought about a year ago. And I guarantee it will outlast me. There is NO wheel built with higher quality, fit and finish than the extreme. Sure it is expensive, but so are Ferrari's. To much money ??? buy a T-1.... > > > For $1,395, I could could a beat up used car (preferably an El Camino), > > get > > > drunk, and speed around a schoolyard yelling "Damn that Jeff Gordon," and > > > have alot more fun than I would with $1,395 sterring wheel. I'll stick to > > > my T2 - I don't see value in the additional $1,295. > > > Tom > > I agree, that would be fun. But that's not really the point is it? Sure, > > I could buy a Mad Catz, but it's comforting to know that others are making > > the "Ferrari" of driving wheels available. If it were not for Extreme > > Competition and others pushing the envelope, what would Thrustmaster have
Quoted text (26 lines)> > to compare themselves against? > Well for the price of a MadCatz (which I think is a great whell FOR it's > price) do you get a real difference in laps for all the money spent on > the ECC wheel? If I could run 10mph more than with a Madcatz, that > would be a good wheel. But for the confort and the 0.1 mph that you can > do faster, it's not worth 1200$ more. I'm not telling it's not a great > wheel (I think it's one of the best, with the HyperStimulator). It's > just that (and per exemple) if you take the Madcatz, for 1200$ less you > can have 75% of what the ECC does. And it's not 75% of the ECC price!!! > Good race at the Brickyard, (Old'Indytrack guy in rec.autos.simulators) > ^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^^ =ymenard now!!! > SPEED- http://www.nascarnet.com/~speed > [===] Go Rubens Barrichello, Jacques Villeneuve, > | ! | And all you that thinks that Jacques Villeneuve is > |!| from Canada, your right!! He's from St-Jean sur le > |o| Richelieu, 30 minutes from Montreal, Quebec, Canada. > [--I--] > v > Fran?ois Mnard "Wasupe LeGrand" > May the force be with you, always!! > Que la force soit avec toi, jamais!(for you French people) > Excuse me for my poor English(I'm French speaking)
SimRaci 22 Apr 1997#363853
SRN ran a test of the available wheels last summer, and the ECCI won hands-down. There is no better product (at any price), and one which I would recommend to anyone. I would wager that if the ECCI product line was put toe-to-toe against the competition today, it would come out on top...again. Best Regards, Marc Marc J. Nelson Sim Racing News / The Sim Project / iRACE
: Is their a website where I can find out more about this Extreme : Competition wheel? This and many more useful URL's can be found the Welcoming r.a.s. faq posted weekly to this newsgroup. http://ourworld.compuserve.com/homepages/extreme -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
brand.. 26 Apr 1997#364557
On Thu, 17 Apr 1997 12:27:50 GMT, "John Wallace"
Quoted text (9 lines)>> Well, they have the base model CDS2, which is $549, and for >> performance per penny, way above the TSW. I guess you would like >> Ferrari to start making a Geo? >"WAY" above the perfomance of a TSW? >I tested all of the wheels and found the ECCI to be "the equal" of the TSW >and at a much higher price. The TSW did some things better, the ECCI others >- overall they were pretty much the same.
Well, I tested them all also, and all I have to say is Opinions are like ***s......everyone has one.
Hmmm, that's not quite how I would describe it. The ECCI-CDS and TSW were considered pretty equal given price. The ECCI-CDS was "nicer" cosmetically (looks etc), but you couldn't really discern a difference in _racing_ quality. Cheers! John

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy