Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

P6 and Verite DMA problems...an explanation

7 posts by 7 people · 19 Dec 1996 - 24 Dec 1996

Quoted text (7 lines)> >>Subject: RE: P6SNE bad Verite DMA performance? > >>Hello Christopher, > >> The Pentium Pro processor has extremely poor I/O performance. This is > >>one of the reasons SCSI is always recommended. The memory functions > >>are optimize at the sacrifice of the I/O sub-systems. There is not > >>work about with this issue.
I'm having a hard time accepting this. I can't believe that Intel Engineers would be so stupid as to even cripple I/O performance in favor of memory performance. Also, the above statement seems to me as a contradiction. If I/O performanace is so poor, why do they recommend a SCSI card? It itself is an I/O subsystem with some cards being able to do DMA transfers, ie. bus masters. Is there another way to test DMA transfer speeds besides DMADIAG? Alex
dangr.. 19 Dec 1996#349348
Quoted text (35 lines)>On Thu, 19 Dec 1996 09:53:33 -0500, Alex Fernandez >>> >>Subject: RE: P6SNE bad Verite DMA performance? >>> >>Hello Christopher, >>> >> The Pentium Pro processor has extremely poor I/O performance. This is >>> >>one of the reasons SCSI is always recommended. The memory functions >>> >>are optimize at the sacrifice of the I/O sub-systems. There is not >>> >>work about with this issue. >>I'm having a hard time accepting this. I can't believe that Intel >>Engineers >>would be so stupid as to even cripple I/O performance in favor of memory >>performance. Also, the above statement seems to me as a contradiction. >>If >>I/O performanace is so poor, why do they recommend a SCSI card? It >>itself >>is an I/O subsystem with some cards being able to do DMA transfers, ie. >>bus >>masters. >>Is there another way to test DMA transfer speeds besides DMADIAG? >>Alex > SCSI devices require much less internention from the CPU. For >instance some EIDE CD drives may consume as much as 50 % of your cpu's >time. Not good. SCSI on the other hand uses much less. Can't remember >the exact figures. > I think the reference to SCSI has nothing to do with the Reactor >card. He was just refering to what is suggested for general I/O >performance if you buy a PRO.
Now I'm confused doesn't SCSI use DMA so that it can release the CPU? Isn't DMA performance the question. I know that someone here can explain this a little better. It don't matter what you call a dog with no legs. He won't come.
> I'm having a hard time accepting this. I can't believe that Intel > Engineers > would be so stupid as to even cripple I/O performance in favor of memory > performance. Also, the above statement seems to me as a contradiction.I've got the impression that the PPro has a poor PCI-Performance, because it has a primary bus called GTL+, which is supposed to be good at multiprocessing. It seems to be difficult to have both good multiprocessing and PCI performance at once, and intel went for the first. Besides, the _main_ memory performance isn't that great, compared to current Pentium chipsets (~40-46 MB/s both). The on-chip 2nd-level-cache is the thing that's really fast. -- Ride on... Boris Woerner
On Thu, 19 Dec 1996 09:53:33 -0500, Alex Fernandez
Quoted text (22 lines)>> >>Subject: RE: P6SNE bad Verite DMA performance? >> >>Hello Christopher, >> >> The Pentium Pro processor has extremely poor I/O performance. This is >> >>one of the reasons SCSI is always recommended. The memory functions >> >>are optimize at the sacrifice of the I/O sub-systems. There is not >> >>work about with this issue. >I'm having a hard time accepting this. I can't believe that Intel >Engineers >would be so stupid as to even cripple I/O performance in favor of memory >performance. Also, the above statement seems to me as a contradiction. >If >I/O performanace is so poor, why do they recommend a SCSI card? It >itself >is an I/O subsystem with some cards being able to do DMA transfers, ie. >bus >masters. >Is there another way to test DMA transfer speeds besides DMADIAG? >Alex
SCSI devices require much less internention from the CPU. For instance some EIDE CD drives may consume as much as 50 % of your cpu's time. Not good. SCSI on the other hand uses much less. Can't remember the exact figures. I think the reference to SCSI has nothing to do with the Reactor card. He was just refering to what is suggested for general I/O performance if you buy a PRO. Vincent Aldridge Been playing games on PC's since 1980 I be the DOOM GOD .... Bow to me....!!
Tom Hansen 20 Dec 1996#349490
SCSI cards will use bus-mastering to transfer data - the CPU does not need to do I/O for data transfer. IDE requires the CPU to read the data via I/O from the IDE controller. /THansen
Quoted text (44 lines)> On Thu, 19 Dec 1996 09:53:33 -0500, Alex Fernandez > >> >>Subject: RE: P6SNE bad Verite DMA performance? > >> >>Hello Christopher, > >> >> The Pentium Pro processor has extremely poor I/O performance. This is > >> >>one of the reasons SCSI is always recommended. The memory functions > >> >>are optimize at the sacrifice of the I/O sub-systems. There is not > >> >>work about with this issue. > >I'm having a hard time accepting this. I can't believe that Intel > >Engineers > >would be so stupid as to even cripple I/O performance in favor of memory > >performance. Also, the above statement seems to me as a contradiction. > >If > >I/O performanace is so poor, why do they recommend a SCSI card? It > >itself > >is an I/O subsystem with some cards being able to do DMA transfers, ie. > >bus > >masters. > >Is there another way to test DMA transfer speeds besides DMADIAG? > >Alex > SCSI devices require much less internention from the CPU. For > instance some EIDE CD drives may consume as much as 50 % of your cpu's > time. Not good. SCSI on the other hand uses much less. Can't remember > the exact figures. > I think the reference to SCSI has nothing to do with the Reactor > card. He was just refering to what is suggested for general I/O > performance if you buy a PRO. > Vincent Aldridge > Been playing games on PC's since 1980 > I be the DOOM GOD .... Bow to me....!!
[ RESPONSE.TXT 2K ]
Quoted text (44 lines)> On Thu, 19 Dec 1996 09:53:33 -0500, Alex Fernandez > >> >>Subject: RE: P6SNE bad Verite DMA performance? > >> >>Hello Christopher, > >> >> The Pentium Pro processor has extremely poor I/O performance. This is > >> >>one of the reasons SCSI is always recommended. The memory functions > >> >>are optimize at the sacrifice of the I/O sub-systems. There is not > >> >>work about with this issue. > >I'm having a hard time accepting this. I can't believe that Intel > >Engineers > >would be so stupid as to even cripple I/O performance in favor of memory > >performance. Also, the above statement seems to me as a contradiction. > >If > >I/O performanace is so poor, why do they recommend a SCSI card? It > >itself > >is an I/O subsystem with some cards being able to do DMA transfers, ie. > >bus > >masters. > >Is there another way to test DMA transfer speeds besides DMADIAG? > >Alex > SCSI devices require much less internention from the CPU. For > instance some EIDE CD drives may consume as much as 50 % of your cpu's > time. Not good. SCSI on the other hand uses much less. Can't remember > the exact figures. > I think the reference to SCSI has nothing to do with the Reactor > card. He was just refering to what is suggested for general I/O > performance if you buy a PRO. > Vincent Aldridge > Been playing games on PC's since 1980 > I be the DOOM GOD .... Bow to me....!!
My first forays with a HACK dungeon were in a VAX750 on a REGENT 200 but I digress . . . I am planning on a Dual Pentium Pro implementation for a desk top P6DNF. Doesn't this allow one processor to deal with I/O while the other taunts me at the monitor? This is of course is under NT. SCSI peripherals are so much more costly than IDE. Is it worth the $s and/or the hassle. I digress again.
Quoted text (11 lines)|I am Vwariff the knight of mirror . . . | |I bow to no one that doth bow to me. If Ye come seeking drink & droll |belly up to the bar. If Ye come seeking war -- there be virtual war if |and only if you ask for it. Ye need only make the dreaded system call |vwariff().
AHH for an old fashioned 2 meg VAX with a dungeon full of gamers and an Amulet of Yendor for the taking -- the Hell Hound hits! Commercial systems aren't nearly the fun of good academic BSD source code site. The above tag has been out of circ since '86. At that time I was Vwariff :-}
Kevin? 24 Dec 1996#350041
On Mon, 23 Dec 1996 23:26:10 -0800, Keith & Cathy Bancroft >My first forays with a HACK dungeon were in a VAX750 on a REGENT 200 but >I digress . . . >AHH for an old fashioned 2 meg VAX with a dungeon full of gamers and an >Amulet of Yendor for the taking -- the Hell Hound hits! >Vwariff :-} YES!!......wasn't that a great game?!?! I played it for nearly 4 years! Still start it up ocassionally >|-) kev

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy