Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

GP2 vs ICR2...The envelope please...

7 posts by 7 people · 30 Jul 1996 - 03 Aug 1996

Greetings from a first time poster/long-time reader. I've played GP2 for many, many hours now since Thursday, (better go back to work soon) ;) It may be a little early for a final decision between GP2 and ICR2, but here are my thoughts. Speed: Whenever I go back and play ICR2, I notice how incredibly smooth it is on my P133/16MB ram. Roughly 21 FPS for ICR2 in full SVGA detail vs 15 FPS for GP2 in partial SVGA detail. ---> Winner ICR2 Sound: Hmmm, tough one. LOVE the in car sound of GP2, but there's something about the Beehive buzz of being in a pack of indycars. ---> Winner, don't know yet Graphics: The day I can run full SVGA detail with 20+ FPS in GP2, the winner will be obvious. For now it is very much a toss-up. I've always thought the ICR2 graphics were stunning, but GP2 does look great even with partial detail. ---> Winner, (flips coin) Hmmm, who was tails? User Interface: GP2: A FEW MORE MENU'S PLEASE GEOFF!!!!! (Sarcasm intended). Although could we please have mouse support in ICR3 Papyrus! Way to many mouse clicks necessary to do the simplest of things in GP2. ---> Winner, ICR2 hands down Realism: Car damage in GP2 (at least on Semi-Pro) is a complete joke. 'Nuff said. Air born effects are very cool. (GP2) Tire spinning is cool. (GP2) Brake lock-up is cool. (GP2) ---> Winner, GP2 Opponent AI: Seen some very aggressive moves in GP2, I need to get much better. The jury's still out but... ---> Winner, GP2 Customer support/service/public relations: No this has nothing to do with game play, but a VERY important category. Papyrus hands down. Thank you Rick & Ed for your patience/support/feedback. Gabriel, you have your work cut out for you if you want to be competitive in this category. ---> Winner, ICR2 (Although I did wait a LONG TIME for that patch!) Enough miscellaneous ramblings for now, no winner yet. Gotta go race SPA, no Elkhart Lake, I mean Portugal, err... Later cats,
Quoted text (62 lines)> Greetings from a first time poster/long-time reader. > I've played GP2 for many, many hours now since Thursday, (better go back to work soon) ;) It may > be a little early for a final decision between GP2 and ICR2, but here are my thoughts. > Speed: > Whenever I go back and play ICR2, I notice how incredibly smooth it is on my P133/16MB ram. > Roughly 21 FPS for ICR2 in full SVGA detail vs 15 FPS for GP2 in partial SVGA detail. > ---> Winner ICR2 > Sound: > Hmmm, tough one. LOVE the in car sound of GP2, but there's something about the Beehive buzz of > being in a pack of indycars. > ---> Winner, don't know yet > Graphics: > The day I can run full SVGA detail with 20+ FPS in GP2, the winner will be obvious. For now it > is very much a toss-up. I've always thought the ICR2 graphics were stunning, but GP2 does look > great even with partial detail. > ---> Winner, (flips coin) Hmmm, who was tails? > User Interface: > GP2: A FEW MORE MENU'S PLEASE GEOFF!!!!! (Sarcasm intended). Although could we please have > mouse support in ICR3 Papyrus! Way to many mouse clicks necessary to do the simplest of things > in GP2. > ---> Winner, ICR2 hands down > Realism: > Car damage in GP2 (at least on Semi-Pro) is a complete joke. 'Nuff said. > Air born effects are very cool. (GP2) > Tire spinning is cool. (GP2) > Brake lock-up is cool. (GP2) > ---> Winner, GP2 > Opponent AI: > Seen some very aggressive moves in GP2, I need to get much better. The jury's still out but... > ---> Winner, GP2 > Customer support/service/public relations: > No this has nothing to do with game play, but a VERY important category. Papyrus hands down. > Thank you Rick & Ed for your patience/support/feedback. Gabriel, you have your work cut out for > you if you want to be competitive in this category. > ---> Winner, ICR2 (Although I did wait a LONG TIME for that patch!) > Enough miscellaneous ramblings for now, no winner yet. > Gotta go race SPA, no Elkhart Lake, I mean Portugal, err... > Later cats,
have u ever drive kart or formula ford ??? ( monoplace ) Well, i think Indycar is more realistick than gp2 however gp2 have more realist sounds and gfx effects. Have a nice Grand prix -- ================================================ * Magic_Fr - stixier - Sebastien Tixier * * Etudiant en Maitrise Informatique * * Universite Claude Bernard Lyon1 * * Stagiaire au LIP a l'ENS sur DOSMOS * * url : http://www.ens-lyon.fr/~stixier * * ou : http://www710.univ-lyon1.fr/~milu61 * ================================================
papa.. 31 Jul 1996#330663
I have and I think that its a toss up..But more to the point so what. The most important item for me is which one is more fun....GP2. I love ICR but hehehe no SPA, SILVERSTONE, MONOCO..... Pierre PAPA DOC Legrand
Quoted text (14 lines)>have u ever drive kart or formula ford ??? ( monoplace ) >Well, i think Indycar is more realistick than gp2 however gp2 >have more realist sounds and gfx effects. >Have a nice Grand prix >-- >================================================ >* Magic_Fr - stixier - Sebastien Tixier * >* Etudiant en Maitrise Informatique * >* Universite Claude Bernard Lyon1 * >* Stagiaire au LIP a l'ENS sur DOSMOS * >* url : http://www.ens-lyon.fr/~stixier * >* ou : http://www710.univ-lyon1.fr/~milu61 * >================================================
JEB 31 Jul 1996#330664
> I have and I think that its a toss up..But more to the point so what. > The most important item for me is which one is more fun....GP2. > I love ICR but hehehe no SPA, SILVERSTONE, MONOCO..... > Pierre PAPA DOC Legrand We have two computers in our house and we do a lot of direct connect stuff. We've had ICR2 and NASCAR on both computers for a long time, and we have the cable connected at all times. I have both NASCAR and ICR2 setup on the desktop of both machines. My two sons (10 and 14) know how to setup the T1 and the T2 (we have one of each, one for each machine) and I have two Joyswitches one on each machine. Anyway, the "boyz" have each been shown how to load up ICR2 and NASCAR and I have raced them both in both sims. Neither one, nor any of their several friends has EVER loaded up NASCAR or ICR2 and run them. Now along comes GP2. I have it installed from/in DOS on both machines. I have separate configs and auto.bats written for GP2 on both machines so it requires that you exit to dos mode on the 133, and restart the machine and hit F4 on the P6. Then you have to run a "setGP2" type .bat file and then RE-boot again. My boyz will, and do, everyday reboot both machine, go through all that dos command line stuff like "d:" and "cd\gp2" and load up GP2 on both machines and race it constantly. I actually have to chase them off the machine when I get home from work so I can use "my" computer. I find it very interesting and somewhat telling that the boyz will go through all that to run GP2, where they would NEVER do a simple click of the mouse and run NASCAR or ICR2. What am I getting at? Don't know, but I think it means that GP2 is a lot more fun. JEB in Vegas
Altough I am not a Kart World champion, I have driven my fare share of 100CC two stroke Karts and for me without a doubt GP2's driving model is superior. Are you driving with a steering wheel, with all aids disconnected? In IndyII, I never has the feeling the car could be kept on the right line by giving little pushes on the accelerator... Maybe it is because I don't like ovals. JFD
Paul Gra 01 Aug 1996#330931
On Wed, 31 Jul 1996 09:19:06 +0200, Jean-Francois De Rudder >disconnected? In IndyII, I never has the feeling the car could be kept >on the right line by giving little pushes on the accelerator... Maybe it >is because I don't like ovals. ICR2 is a great game, but it`s far too unforgiving, I wanted to play with realistic damage but I could, I would be out within 2 laps even at arcade level it`s still dificult.
markm.. 03 Aug 1996#331413
ICR2 has to develop that *sliding* feeling that GP2 has. I agree with what your saying re:damage on/off. In GP2 you can catch the car and get sideways, ->->->->Mark Mann->->->->http://www.netrunner.net/~markmann ************************************** ...Stupid TV....Be More Funny ! - Homer Simpson ************************************** Go Jacques Villeneuve - #6 Williams-Renault Go Greg Moore - #99 Player's/Forsythe-Reynard-Mercedes

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy