Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

GP2 Opinion (long)

14 posts by 14 people · 25 Jul 1996 - 01 Aug 1996

Nick Flyn 25 Jul 1996#329010
I got GP2 last night. The following is all based on 6 hours of fooling around with it - taking practice laps at various circuits (mostly Monza, but also Monaco, Hockenheim, Brazil and some others). A little backround - I have a P133, 16 megs, 2 meg video card, sound card. I have had ICR2 for several months and have really enjoyed it, despite playing with the keyboard (I'm too cheap to get a T2 just yet). In ICR2, I use SVGA, min frame rate 28, all cars ahead drawn, most of the textures on auto (except track). I consistently get frame rates in the 27-30 range and only see trackside objects begin to turn off in heavy traffic. On to GP2. I spent about 2 hours fooling with the graphics settings and driving around. First of all, with everything turned on, the game is undeniably beautiful. The tracks are rendered very realistically and there are many enjoyable details. However, the choices made in the rendering engine seem to detract from the game significantly. The only way to get near a decent frame rate is to turn most of the features off, as I refuse to run in VGA (which looks terrible, IMHO). Even with most everything turned off, I can only get a framerate in the mid 20s, which would be acceptable, except for the other quirk of the game. The whole processor occupancy concept seems to me to be ass-backwards. The game slows the "game time" down versus real time to allow the frames to be rendered, thereby destroying the sense of speed. This choice makes little sense to me at all - the game is supposed to be a sim. If I want to look at pictures of F1 tracks, I'll get a coffee table book. When the processor occupancy goes above 100%, the illusion of speed goes right out the window. After fooling around with this for a long time, I turned off enough detail that I am able to run consistently below 100% and thus stay in real-time. However, at this setting, the game's much vaunted graphics don't look even close to as good as ICR2. Another thing I noticed is that when there is enough detail on to raise occupancy rates above 100, the game actually gets easier to play because time is slowed. This reminds me of turning off the turbo button on an old XT to beat a game. Cheesy. I suppose I could go out and get a P6-200 or something, but come on. My machine is not exactly a dinosaur. I think the details in the game are fantastic and I certainly am going to get lots of enjoyment from it, but its performance vis-a-vis ICR2 is not very impressive. Before everyone starts ***ing about every little thing that they want in the game (whether it be weather, IPX support, updated car sets, etc..), I think that this issue of graphics performance is the most critical. If it remains as it is, I doubt this game will go on to be the same kind of classic as the original was. Enough on that. Lest anyone think I am resolutely negative about the whole thing, let me point out some of the features I like a lot: - Sound is really nice, especially stuff like hitting the curbs - The data logging and analysis stuff is a dream come true - It is quite easy to get up and running with the various drivers aids available - much easier than ICR2 - Curbs are cool. - Lots of attention to detail and options (like choice of KMH/MPH) Note that I haven't tried running a race yet, so I can't comment on the AI or anything like that, which I gather is superb. Further complaints (just in case you thought I'd gone soft): No way to configure the keyboard, at least that I could find. For all the 10 minutes of programming this would have taken, it seems rather obnoxious - I would like to use the same pattern I do in ICR2 for throttle, brake and turning. Also, another keyboard problem - you can't turn off features like steering help when you use the keyboard for control. Or am I wrong about this? (Yes, I know - get a wheel!) The replays are a joke compared to the system in ICR2. I don't know whether this is just a flaw with the keyboard controls or the steering help, but the car just doesn't feel as realistic as it does in ICR2. Car setups lack camber, toe, tire pressure. There is no access to tire temperature data. This stuff is pretty basic and the game's choice of other features to include seems pretty idiosyncratic. The tire temperature is one of the most basic diagnostics. There is no***pit adjustable brake balance or roll bars. Both these features are present on F1 cars. It is nice to have all the various damper settings and stuff, but I think some basic stuff has been left out. Alright, I'm done. I may be wrong about some of this - I'm sure I will have that pointed out to me in Usenet style (oh, boy). While I think this is a nice game, I doubt it is the definitive single seater sim. If the graphics speed was brought up to par with ICR2, perhaps then it would be, but for now...
[snip -- most of which I agree with] : I don't know whether this is just a flaw with the keyboard controls : or the steering help, but the car just doesn't feel as realistic as it : does in ICR2. I am really curious about this to. I think some of the feel of handling characterics in GP2 are masked/heightened by the slow down of time. I can't quite put my finger on it. I think it would be very interesting to have Christian Fittipaldi, Alessandro (Alex) Zanardi, and Mark Blundell test drive GP2 & ICR2. Then we can ask them which one models the feel of the car the best. Why did I choose these drivers? Well they all drove F1 in 1994 and now drive Indycar. Since I've never driven real F1 or Indy cars I can't really judge, but the GP2 cars seems way too easy to steer and control (as long as I stay off the curbs). However, I really like the feel of GP2 with the traction help off. Putting the power down too fast coming out of the corners and going over a curb is frightening. Maybe I just don't have a fast enough machine for GP2, but the cars seem less nimble and light. There's something too "solid" about them compared to ICR2 cars. I am also bothered by the lack of "extra" cues to aid in driving in a 2D environment in GP2. No other car sounds. Another car can be right beside you and you have no clue (except for maybe when your rear view mirror is suddenly and totally filled by a huge black object -- a tire!). I also agree about the missing "setup" tools, tire temps, roll-bar adjustments, etc. However, all of the above aside both sims come from 2 different camps and have different goals and "artistic" style. Besides, how can I knock GP2 and still expect to show my face in r.a.s.? :-) (I know, we could split it up -- "that's a joke son, it's a joke" Foghorn Leghorn). -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
> Also, why can you 'see' better in VGA on GP2 than in ICR2? I don't know, but > I'm convinced. > However, while I get about 28-30 fps almost always on SVGA in ICR2 (w/o track > & grass textures), I can only get, IMHO, slide shows in GP2. I'm sorry, buy > 20fps is NOT playable. 20fps is not playable. I respected your IMHO, but I have to say I would be very happy if I can have all detials and textures on then got 20fps. In the ideal world we would all like to this for even 25fps(is there a real difference between 25fps - 30fps in the human eye?). But we can't, if you think 20fps is not playable, then those poor flight sim fans is in the hell most of the time, becuase they usually be very happy if the frame rate is at 15fps.
Julian Lov 26 Jul 1996#329377
> After fooling around with this for a long time, I > turned off enough detail that I am able to run consistently below 100% > and thus stay in real-time. However, at this setting, the game's much > vaunted graphics don't look even close to as good as ICR2. I too have a P133 and can get good performance with most textures on. The trick is to set the ajustable framrate to about 2 lower than the estimated framerate. With this I can have all textures except sky on in the front view, and untextures track, smoke, and verges on in the mirros and get 15fps. I know 15fps sounds slow, but it actually seems smoother than 22 fps just beacause the game moves at the correct speed. Try this and you will not be disappointed. With these settings my occupancy only goes above 100% at the start, or when there is a lot of smoke on screen. It's absolutely fine for every track except Monaco. Julian _____________________________________________________________________ University of Oxford
>Since I've never driven real F1 or Indy cars I can't really judge, but >the GP2 cars seems way too easy to steer and control (as long as I stay >off the curbs). Are you driving with the provided setup or are you clocking in laps that compete with the actual track records? My impression was the same as yours until I dropped the rear wing from 10 to 1 and did a similar fix on the front wing, then adjusted the gearing for higher top speeds. Now at Monza I can finally go over 200 mph on the straights, whereas in the stock setup you can't get much over 185. The car is also now more difficult to control, especially in the curbs, and I go into oversteer a lot. Randy
Clark Arch 26 Jul 1996#329379
Quoted text (17 lines)> > >>Alright, I'm done. I may be wrong about some of this - I'm sure I will >>have that pointed out to me in Usenet style (oh, boy). While I think >>this is a nice game, I doubt it is the definitive single seater sim. If >>the graphics speed was brought up to par with ICR2, perhaps then it >>would be, but for now... > >I totally agree and I hope SH and Geoff or somebody is listening. >Could a "patch" be done to solve some of the graphics speed probs? >Lets hope so, or its going to be a flat, untextured polygon world for >most users....or,_the horror_ , a VGA one. > >"You know how dumb the average person is? Well, by definition, > half of 'em are dumber than THAT." - J.R. "Bob" Dobbs > > [link lost in import: /~flashboy]
Well, I'm currently running my GP2 in VGA. And you know, I don't think the graphics are that far behind ICR2 in SVGA. In fact, I'd go so far as to say that the graphics in GP2 are better in VGA than ICR2 offers in SVGA. And here's why: cars have CURVED body work in GP2 light sourcing! track texture sky texture curbs real sponsors (except for tobacco; wow, GP2 has *** sponsors; sorry, but I don't see why *** and not cigarettes?!?!?!?!; you would think, both or neither; BTW, anyone else notice the Marlboro sign trackside during the British Grand Prix; why trackside and not on the cars?!?) Also, why can you 'see' better in VGA on GP2 than in ICR2? I don't know, but I'm convinced. However, while I get about 28-30 fps almost always on SVGA in ICR2 (w/o track & grass textures), I can only get, IMHO, slide shows in GP2. I'm sorry, buy 20fps is NOT playable. Have you seen those bumper stickers that say "Visualize World Peace"? Well, how about this: "Visualize P7/500". BTW, my setup: P5/166, Matrox MGA Millenium/4MBWRAM,64MB/60ns/EDO Wow, time to upgrade processors AGAIN. Why oh why are games just about the only reason I ever have to upgrade!? Clark Archer Speed Tribe IVGA #3920 1996 Lola Honda Firestone
Quoted text (9 lines)> No way to configure the keyboard, at least that I could find. For all >the 10 minutes of programming this would have taken, it seems rather >obnoxious - I would like to use the same pattern I do in ICR2 for >throttle, brake and turning. > Also, another keyboard problem - you can't turn off features like >steering help when you use the keyboard for control. Or am I wrong >about this? > (Yes, I know - get a wheel!)
Try going to control method and selecting one of the not used buttons. I dont think you can alter the keys but you might be able to switch the helps off. (I haven`t actually tried this but it worked for multi buttoned sticks.) Try turning off the help options ; ) Point taken but would you be able to get tyre temps from the***pit? Mark _________________________________ "..every lap I think `Oh bollocks! This is dreadful..`" Damon Hill __________________________________
A J Samue 27 Jul 1996#329631
Quoted text (7 lines)> Car setups lack camber, toe, tire pressure. There is no access to >tire temperature data. This stuff is pretty basic and the game's choice >of other features to include seems pretty idiosyncratic. The tire >temperature is one of the most basic diagnostics. There is no***pit >adjustable brake balance or roll bars. Both these features are present >on F1 cars. It is nice to have all the various damper settings and >stuff, but I think some basic stuff has been left out.
Cockpit-adjustable anti-roll bars have been banned in F1 since the beginning of 1994, so it could be said to be 'realistic' to leave these out, however brake balance adjustment is still allowed as far as I know. AJ -------------------------------------------------------------------- AA AA JJ "It's not a question of whose habitat it is, AAAAAAA JJ JJ it's a question of how hard you hit it!" AA AA JJJJJ (Arthur Dent) --------------------------------------------------------------------
Quoted text (14 lines)>>Since I've never driven real F1 or Indy cars I can't really judge, but >>the GP2 cars seems way too easy to steer and control (as long as I stay >>off the curbs). >Are you driving with the provided setup or are you clocking in laps >that compete with the actual track records? My impression was the >same as yours until I dropped the rear wing from 10 to 1 and did a >similar fix on the front wing, then adjusted the gearing for higher >top speeds. Now at Monza I can finally go over 200 mph on the >straights, whereas in the stock setup you can't get much over 185. >The car is also now more difficult to control, especially in the >curbs, and I go into oversteer a lot. >Randy
I agree with Randy, I too thought the cars had a LOT of grip until I started messing with the setup a bit. This is with no steering or traction/opposite lock aids on. By reducing both the front wing and rear wing considerably, I am finally able to get the car up to about 203mph on the straights at Monza, but that has made those corners really scary now. With absolute concentration I can pull away from the field and build a gap, but more often I will lose it in a corner and fall back. I personally love the driving model, it feels much more realistic to me, even bouncing off the curbs pushes the car in the right directions like it does on TV in the F1 coverage. Also I am able to run over the curbs on the chicanes if I keep my foot out of the gas until the rear traction settles back down. I think the driving model alone is years ahead of what ICR2 had, in GP2 I can feel when the car is about to lose grip and get off the gas enough to try and control it, in ICR2 every turn felt like a gamble either I made a perfect turn or, the car would go into an unrecoverable spin. I think the default setups are set with too much down force, great for learning the track, but really much too slow for competing with the higher oponent levels, in order to set the car up to the speeds required, you have to give up some downforce and make the car much more nervous. I feel like Gerhart Berger, at the beginning of this season at Benneton trying to come to terms with the twichy handling and smacking the wall a couple of times. Great game so far, last night played for 7.5 hours straight. Cheers. --John -- ------------------- John (Joao) Silva http://weber.u.washington.edu/~jsilva Seattle, Washington USA.
How about fuel/air mixture? Is that still adjustable in today's F1?? Yves
Ke 28 Jul 1996#329823
I too was having problems with the car being "twitchy" and "nervous" after lowering the wings at Imola. I remedied this by softening the suspension up on all four wheels. This seems to have made my car much easier to pilot now....
Ken Nicols 28 Jul 1996#329824
:>***pit-adjustable anti-roll bars have been banned in F1 since the :> beginning of 1994, so it could be said to be 'realistic' to leave :> these out, however brake balance adjustment is still allowed as far :> as I know. : :How about fuel/air mixture? Is that still adjustable in today's F1?? In the real GP, Hill got a pit board signal "FUEL MIXT 4", so I would guess so! : :Yves Ken
Richard Sob 28 Jul 1996#329825
Quoted text (7 lines)>>However, while I get about 28-30 fps almost always on SVGA in ICR2 (w/o track >>& grass textures), I can only get, IMHO, slide shows in GP2. I'm sorry, buy >>20fps is NOT playable. >20fps is playable. Just lower your actual frame rate down to >15~18fps. >The graphics in GP2 are far superior to ICR2, IMHO. >--KCI
Oh yeah - so if you lowered your actual frame rate to 15~18fps, you think you would get smoother graphics? I don't think so. If you set the frame rate at 15, the game will run at 15fps - no matter what (assuming the processor occupancy doesn't rise above 100%). And personnaly, I agree with Clark - I tried playing at - I think it was either 18 or 21.3 fps - and it was horrible. I mean - I couldn't stand it. I turned it off straight away. I don't know even why people settle for 15fps - what are they like??? I run GP2 (on a P120/16Mb/PCI graphics etc) in SVGA, none but one detail, and NO textures whatsoever. It still looks absolutely stunning (at least compared to GP1!!). And I get 23fps. ------------- Richard Sobey
Jo 01 Aug 1996#331091
<...snipped stuff...> I know just what you are saying. But I tend to think that is ICR2's extreme jitteryness and not GP2's overly solid-ness. I could be totally wrong, but I would say that GP2 "feels" just like F1 cars "look" when you see the***pit views- they are amazingly solid on the track- even though just a tiny overacceleration out of a curve will easily spin you. I think that with ICR2, we have all gotten very used to a ridiculously unstable model- and I believe a lot of that could have been changed in some approach a little more sophisticated that "Linear" or Non-Linear Steering." Maybe I am wrong. But that is my honest assesment (if a program I cherish, bugs and all). When I watch Andretti from the***pit, it looks a lot more "solid" than what we have. Maybe I'm just witnessing the "genius of Andretti?" I'm already used to it, but I sure was used to hearing a competitor in ICR2 before I had to really worry about him, Now I just sort of see a blur in my mirror, then nothing, then WHAM! on the inside of the turn, I'm out of the race! Andretti wasn't racing in F1 '94, was he? Just kidding! I actually like the guy a lot, and second half of the season he has been a real pro- maybe a little messy in Toronto. I don't know who is hitting me, I need some sort of replay that I haven't discovered yet in GP2. I propose that CART buy (save) Papy's ICR2 from Sierra, put 2 or 3 million dollars (nothing in racing money!) in to making the next generation, and give NASCAR and F1 a run for their money! Let's face it, these sims are good enough now that they are as engaging as Doom or Descent ever were. These sims can MAKE fans of racing. F1 apparently realized this with their incredibly major endor***t of GP2- maybe they noticed NASCAR leap out at them. It is big not only in the south of the US (like when I was a kid), but now there are fans in Finland, Germany, Norway, Australia... and I think that is because of Papy's NASCAR being such a mega-hit. And all this time F1 was afraid of IndyCar! Even in the US, IndyCar is 3rd (after NASCAR then Drag Racing, if I understand correctly). Too bad major promo didn't go in to ICR2 abroad- it's similarities to F1 make it a natural for F1 fans. >-- >**************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* > Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. >=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy