Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Speeding in the pits in IRC2 - Message for Rick Genter

26 posts by 17 people · 20 Apr 1996 - 30 Apr 1996

Black flags for pit-lane speeding in ICR2 and NASCAR

Players complained that IndyCar Racing II and NASCAR Racing black-flagged them for exceeding the pit speed limit by 1 mph for an instant. They suggested a pit limiter or a tolerance like the 5 mph grace reportedly used in real IndyCar racing. Posters debated average versus instantaneous speed checks, and Rick Genter confirmed that in NASCAR going over 55 mph in the pits means a black flag.

With Rick Genter (Papyrus)

setup/driving techniquereal motorsportIndyCar Racing IINASCAR Racing

Automated summary.

David Lyde 20 Apr 1996#316264
Don't Indycars have a speed regulating governor in the car, where the driver would hold down a button and his speed would be capped at 80 mph? Can't this be added in the patch for IRC2? I have been black flagged for hitting 81 mph for a fraction of a second. Something like a governor button would really help.
> Don't Indycars have a speed regulating governor in the car, where the > driver would hold down a button and his speed would be capped at 80 mph? > Can't this be added in the patch for IRC2? I have been black flagged for > hitting 81 mph for a fraction of a second. Something like a governor > button would really help. Further to this... During the race at Long Beach I heard one of the ABC commentators mention that there was a 5 mph grace zone. One of the drivers went 67 in the pit when the limit was 60, and was hit with a penalty, whereas they said if had done 65, the officials would have given him a bly. Just a random output JAC
: Don't Indycars have a speed regulating governor in the car, where the : driver would hold down a button and his speed would be capped at 80 mph? : Can't this be added in the patch for IRC2? I have been black flagged for : hitting 81 mph for a fraction of a second. Something like a governor : button would really help. Reach up to your dashboard (read keyboard) and flick the regulator on (read ALT/B). Soon as you clear the pit exit, your car will begin to accelerate. Flick off the regulator (read ALT/B) and go racing. -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Remco Moedt 20 Apr 1996#316267
>Don't Indycars have a speed regulating governor in the car, where the >driver would hold down a button and his speed would be capped at 80 mph? >Can't this be added in the patch for IRC2? I have been black flagged for >hitting 81 mph for a fraction of a second. Something like a governor >button would really help. Rick Genter already stated the possibility of Alt - B (Auto Brake) This will do the trick Remco <<Ring ... Ring ... Allo? Tuut ... Tuut .. Tuut ...>>
Jo 20 Apr 1996#316268
Ya, I heard that too. A simple solution in ICR2 would be to set it up so you can't be over 80 for more than 2 (or 1, if you like) seconds in a speeding incident. That would be the equivelent to having a 5 MPH boundary zone, and would add a little give-and-take to the process of getting in/out of the pits. Of course, you could also at the same time make it so anyone going over 85 would be black flagged immediately. Putting both of these in would make it very realistic, I think. Nothing sucks worse than to be coming up to speed and then hitting 81 for a 1/4 of a second, and it is all over. Adding this above mentioned feature would make leaving the pits a little more about the driving and not about watching the damn speedometer.
Gregory Fu 21 Apr 1996#316327
>> Don't Indycars have a speed regulating governor in the car, where the >> driver would hold down a button and his speed would be capped at 80 mph? >> Can't this be added in the patch for IRC2? I have been black flagged for >> hitting 81 mph for a fraction of a second. Something like a governor >> button would really help. If you FOLLOW this newsgroup, check back to Josh Beaulieu's response to the same question a few days ago. Gregory Fung Vancouver, B.C., Canada IICC3 Ground Effects/Rebel Alliance Lola-Ford-Firestone
David Spark 22 Apr 1996#316381
>Don't Indycars have a speed regulating governor in the car, where the >driver would hold down a button and his speed would be capped at 80 mph? >Can't this be added in the patch for IRC2? I have been black flagged for >hitting 81 mph for a fraction of a second. Something like a governor >button would really help. In the Long Beach broadcast on ABC, Danny Sullivan mentioned that the officials don't penalize a driver unless he's going at least 5 mph over pit speed. Also, I'm pretty sure that it's based on average speed rather than instantaneous speed. It would be nice if Papyrus allowed us just a little more leeway on the pit speed. Dave
Jo 23 Apr 1996#316462
>In the Long Beach broadcast on ABC, Danny Sullivan mentioned that the >officials don't penalize a driver unless he's going at least 5 mph over pit >speed. Also, I'm pretty sure that it's based on average speed rather than >instantaneous speed. It would be nice if Papyrus allowed us just a little >more leeway on the pit speed. My idea was to make the program only flag you if you maintain over 80 (or is it 70? I forget) for a full second stretch; seems easy to build in, and would make the whole pit thing more interesting, and apparently (by Danny Sullivan's comment) more realistic. Average speed would be good too, but that is hard to get a grasp on while driving- what happens to the running average when you are actually pitted (speed 0), for example- sort of scwrews up the equation.
Mike Manthe 23 Apr 1996#316463
=========================================== It's all in your perspective.... In the last "real" Long Beach race, they lowered the pit speed limit, (I forgot what it was lowered to...) so the speed limit is not a constant.. So, why not just call the pit speed limit... say.... 75 MPH? That will give you the 5 MPH "buffer" you're looking for! It's also not based on average speed, as was suggested. A speed limit in the pits is a speed limit. ..just as a highway speed limit is a limit. You couldn't get out of a speeding ticket by explaining that your average speed was actually only 65 MPH.... :-( I wish! To ask that Papyrus write a patch to fix something that's not broke..... well, it's a little much to ask. It's a great simulator. Use it for what it does, find a work-around for what doesn't, and above all, play! ** To all - I'm not trying to pick on those I just replied to :-) ** Just an observation, but it seems too many people buy a program before they know if it will suit their needs, then claim "foul" when they find something they don't like. This applies to much more than just games. Let the same caution you use buying a used car apply to software. If it's not going to work for you, don't buy it. Lighten up, my fellow gamers. This is supposed to be fun! Have fun Be flexible Mike
Quoted text (8 lines)>: Don't Indycars have a speed regulating governor in the car, where the >: driver would hold down a button and his speed would be capped at 80 mph? >: Can't this be added in the patch for IRC2? I have been black flagged for >: hitting 81 mph for a fraction of a second. Something like a governor >: button would really help. >Reach up to your dashboard (read keyboard) and flick the regulator on >(read ALT/B). Soon as you clear the pit exit, your car will begin to >accelerate. Flick off the regulator (read ALT/B) and go racing.
Try this at Michigan and the car gets up to 81mph for a fraction of a second before dropping to 80. Still gives a black flag. Chris >-- >**************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* > Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. >=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Wade Tschi 24 Apr 1996#316571
Mike, You have just been nominated as THE voice of "The Silent Majority". Thank You. I'm sure you'll serve your Tenure well. Happy Lappin' Wade Tschida #49 DB Motorsports
David Spark 25 Apr 1996#316714
>It's also not based on average speed, as was suggested. A speed limit >in the pits is a speed limit. ..just as a highway speed limit is a >limit. You couldn't get out of a speeding ticket by explaining that your >average speed was actually only 65 MPH.... :-( I wish! No cop would ever write a ticket for going 1 mph over the speed limit, even for a radar ticket. It's not reasonable to expect a speedometer to be that accurate. As far as pit speed limit, it really depends on the race. I don't know CART rules, but in NASCAR, there are some tracks where it is based on average speed. There are white lines on the pit lane, and the scorer simply clocks the amount of time it takes to get from the first white line in front of your pit to the last line on pit road. Does anyone one know how CART enforces the rules? Do they use a radar gun? Dave
an.. 25 Apr 1996#316715
Well, them using a stopwatch and timing cars would be the same thing as using a radar gun. Beings Winston Cup cars don't have speedometers the go by RPM to guage their speed on pit road. Go to any race and a some point <usually the last "Happy Hour"> the pace car will lead the pack down Pit road at the regulated speed and each driver will set his/her tachometer accordingly. I have watched Winston Cup racing for over 10 yrs. and since they <NASCAR> cracked down on pit road speeds I've never herd of them using "average speed". I unfortunatly don't recall the exact track last season, but ask Kyle Petty about Pit road speed. They called him back in at least 4 times in a ROW! for exceeding Pit road speed. Looked like he was ok to me on the TV so I think that would pretty much wipe out any doubt on the way the NASCAR officials handle it. Take it Easy. Andy A
Mike Manthe 25 Apr 1996#316716
> Mike, > You have just been nominated as THE voice of "The Silent Majority". Thank You. > I'm sure you'll serve your Tenure well. > Happy Lappin' > Wade Tschida ==================== Gee.... uh.... thanks.... I think. I try to keep quiet, but sometimes... Mike (still one lap down.) :-)
David Spark 26 Apr 1996#316832
>Well, them using a stopwatch and timing cars would be the same thing >as using a radar gun. Beings Winston Cup cars don't have speedometers >the go by RPM to guage their speed on pit road. Go to any race and a >some point <usually the last "Happy Hour"> the pace car will lead the Sorry, a radar gun, for all practical purposes gives you instantaneous speed. It is NOT the average speed in the pits. Dave
an.. 26 Apr 1996#316833
That wasn't the point, what I'm saying is the process of the two is to acheive the same end result correct?. And I believe NASCAR has excelled past using measurment of speed from two white lines and a stopwatch to yes, a radar gun. What this boils down to is Yeah maybe your local cop as was mentioned in the original post would cut you some slack. But thats mixing apples with oranges. A cop cutting someone on the street a break and Pit speed in NASCAR or any other Sanctioning body are two different things right? NASCAR sets a particular speed for pit road PERIOD! The Simulator should therefor reflect the same rules as best it can be. No doubt Nascar by Papyrus defualts the tracks to 55mph. But that is far better than having a Sim. without accuracy. Who's knows maybe we'll get to see a few added changes in the next version. Regards, Andy A
Banfi Fol 26 Apr 1996#316834
Rick? Can you tell us if the current version of NASCAR Racing (the one that is in use for Hawaii) was modified to eliminate this (very small) problem? Thanks Folco
Mike Manthe 26 Apr 1996#316835
> No cop would ever write a ticket for going 1 mph over the speed limit, even > for a radar ticket. It's not reasonable to expect a speedometer to be that > accurate. > <lines snipped> > Dave True enough, Dave, (except for here, in Colorado). But as you and I both know, all it would take is a couple of quick test to see just exactly what speed is too much, and then we would always push it. So what's the use? If you won't get a black flag until 58 mph, then you will be driving "on the edge" at 57 anyway. Then we would call 57 mph our "new" speed limit. ???? Am I missing something? (Use the force, Luke. You will see this to be true... :-)) Would you then complain that you always get a black flag at 58 MPH??? HA! Look at the options! Here's a scary thought: Would you rather have them randomly giving black flags at anything between 55 and 70? Think of the complaints!! "Gee, I was always able to go 61 in the pits, but today, I was in first place and got flagged at 59!" That would make it more "realistic", but does anyone really want the guy waving the black flag to have an ATTITUED PROBLEM? This is a "computer" simulation, we have the capability of being *accurate* AND FAIR. Mike's Handy Tip #3: Use a piece of black electrical tape & cover up your speed indicator for a more realistic sim. Mike's Handy Thought #412: -after looking at some alternatives, we sometimes realize that what we have is really not that bad. Mike -"still one lap down"
David Spark 27 Apr 1996#316961
Quoted text (11 lines)>True enough, Dave, (except for here, in Colorado). But as you and I both >know, all it >would take is a couple of quick test to see just exactly what speed is too >much, and >then we would always push it. So what's the use? If you won't get a >black flag >until 58 mph, then you will be driving "on the edge" at 57 anyway. Then we >would call >57 mph our "new" speed limit. ???? Am I missing something? (Use the >force, Luke. >You will see this to be true... :-))
The AI drivers always drive right at 55, they never get black-flagged. If I try to keep that same pace, at least 1 time in 5, I will go 56 for a split second and get a black flag. So I end up losing a couple more spots. I suppose you could argue that this is just one more way to even the odds for the AI drivers. However, at a track like N. Wilkesboro, one or two spots hurts a lot. Also, as someone has pointed out, Indy cars have rev limiters that keep the car under the speed limit (if you remember to push the button). But this doesn't always work in ICR2, I've been black-flagged more than once. In multi-player, I don't care, because we all have to play by the same rules. It's been an interesting discussion, but in the scheme of things, I'd much rather see other things changed. Like the yellow flag problems in ICR2, double file restarts in NASCAR, cars exiting the pit have to wait for the end of the caution line, better AI, seeing the tach jump and hearing the engine race when the wheels start slipping, being able to get out of the pits before repairs are complete in NASCAR to avoid being lapped, spotters, I could go on... Dave
Karl Rau 27 Apr 1996#316962
And then we'd all be doing 65 and complaining that we're still getting black flagged. It's not that hard to keep under the limit. Just keep it in first all the time and you'll get used to it.
RickGent 27 Apr 1996#316963
problem? As far as I know, no, if you go over 55, you get black flagged, period. Rick Genter Technical Lead, IndyCar Racing II Sierra On-Line, Inc.
Craig Hopki 28 Apr 1996#317080
Quoted text (9 lines)>>Well, them using a stopwatch and timing cars would be the same thing >>as using a radar gun. Beings Winston Cup cars don't have speedometers >>the go by RPM to guage their speed on pit road. Go to any race and a >>some point <usually the last "Happy Hour"> the pace car will lead the >Sorry, a radar gun, for all practical purposes gives you instantaneous >speed. It is NOT the average speed in the pits. >Dave
But it is the average speed for that instant! :-)))
Gary Godso 29 Apr 1996#317167
Quoted text (41 lines)> > >Can't this be added in the patch for IRC2? I have been black flagged for > > >hitting 81 mph for a fraction of a second. Something like a governor > > >button would really help. > > In the Long Beach broadcast on ABC, Danny Sullivan mentioned that the > > officials don't penalize a driver unless he's going at least 5 mph over pit > > speed. Also, I'm pretty sure that it's based on average speed rather than > > instantaneous speed. It would be nice if Papyrus allowed us just a little > > more leeway on the pit speed. > =========================================== > It's all in your perspective.... > In the last "real" Long Beach race, they lowered the pit speed limit, (I > forgot what it was lowered to...) so the speed limit is not a > constant.. > So, why not just call the pit speed limit... say.... 75 MPH? > That will give you the 5 MPH "buffer" you're looking for! > It's also not based on average speed, as was suggested. A speed limit > in the pits is a speed limit. ..just as a highway speed limit is a > limit. You couldn't get out of a speeding ticket by explaining that your > average speed was actually only 65 MPH.... :-( I wish! > To ask that Papyrus write a patch to fix something that's not broke..... > well, it's a little much to ask. It's a great simulator. Use it for > what it does, find a work-around for what doesn't, and above all, play! > ** To all - I'm not trying to pick on those I just replied to :-) ** > Just an observation, but it seems too many people buy a program before > they know if it will suit their needs, then claim "foul" when they find > something they don't like. This applies to much more than just games. > Let the same caution you use buying a used car apply to software. If > it's not going to work for you, don't buy it. > Lighten up, my fellow gamers. This is supposed to be fun! > Have fun > Be flexible > Mike
Get this. I'm in the lead at Phoneix, right? I go for my final stop, right? And then--WHAM! Black Flag. I know how it goes!! I think I might have found a way to beat the flag thing. Call me an unnaturaliist, but I still use a joystick. I pull back on the stick (which is my reverse) and it prevents me from going over the limit. Like the present day govenors so to speak. I have only tried it a couple of times, so don't hold me to it!! It is worth a shot!
EldredP 29 Apr 1996#317168
>Mike's Handy Tip #3: Use a piece of black electrical tape & cover up your speed >indicator for a more realistic sim. >Mike's Handy Thought #412: -after looking at some alternatives, we sometimes realize >that what we have is really not that bad. >Mike -"still one lap down" Mike, you've got too much time to THINK<g> ...and I'm TWO laps down... Eldred Pickett I am NOT paranoid. And why are you always watching me?!?
David Spark 29 Apr 1996#317169
Quoted text (8 lines)>>Sorry, a radar gun, for all practical purposes gives you instantaneous >>speed. It is NOT the average speed in the pits. >>Dave >But it is the average speed for that instant! >:-)))
Arghh! I want my Richmond setup back! <g> Dave
Mike Manthe 30 Apr 1996#317330
> Mike, you've got too much time to THINK<g> > ...and I'm TWO laps down... > Eldred Pickett Naw, once the price of Hawaii comes down, I'll be racing. Right now, I'm dreaming.... Mike -one lap down, in the pits, black flagged for speeding. :-)

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy