Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

IndyCar-II Woes

23 posts by 18 people · 25 Mar 1996 - 11 Apr 1996

Why IndyCar Racing II feels slipperier than the original

A player found ICR2's cars much looser than ICR1's. Others explained that the game modelled the 1995 rules, which cut downforce, and recommended practice and setup work. The discussion moved on to shift points and tyre temperatures. Rick Genter of Papyrus confirmed that the physics model redlined the Cosworth and Mercedes engines at 13,000 RPM and the Honda at 13,500 RPM.

With Rick Genter (Papyrus)

setup/driving techniquephysics/realism debateIndyCar Racing II

Automated summary.

StormPt 25 Mar 1996#314604
I recently began playing ICR2. I did ICR-1 and Nascar extensively. The tracks in ICR2 seem much slipperier. Michigan with the Ace setup seems like glass. You can't seem to go full out all around like you used to in the old version. Anyone have any comments on this? Bug? Feature? Real? Fake? Need more practice?
(StormPtrl)25 Mar 1996 02:42:39 -0500 writes: :> :>I recently began playing ICR2. I did ICR-1 and Nascar extensively. The :>tracks in ICR2 seem much slipperier. Michigan with the Ace setup seems :>like glass. You can't seem to go full out all around like you used to in :>the old version. Anyone have any comments on this? Bug? Feature? Real? :> Fake? Need more practice? Same here. I just thought I sucked at this game! I'm playing on a 486-66 and was wondering if a Pentium would suffer the same problems? When I was playing ICRI extensively, I could beat the competition at any level. In ICR2, I feel lucky to go two laps without spinning out. It doesn't seem as bad when surrounded by traffic though(too bad they lose me when I spin). If you find a solution, please e-mail me. WARP'n across the 'Net
Tim Olso 25 Mar 1996#314606
>I recently began playing ICR2. I did ICR-1 and Nascar extensively. The >tracks in ICR2 seem much slipperier. Michigan with the Ace setup seems >like glass. You can't seem to go full out all around like you used to in >the old version. Anyone have any comments on this? Bug? Feature? Real? > Fake? Need more practice? No, contrary to popular belief, this is not a bug. Real 95 IndyCars behave like this. I know that it looks very easy to drive an IndyCar when you watch a race on TV or go to one, but this is the same stuff real IndyCar drivers have to put up with. It doesn't seem like it, but then again, these guys are pros. All you can do about it is get a good setup and lots of practice. Tim
Lo 26 Mar 1996#314659
Only in that you'll get better frame rate with more detail. All things being equal between two machines, including framerate, it just plain helps to get more detail. I've got a p90 and a P133. (my roomamte and I race all the time). I just swapped out my P75 for a P133 and it made a hgus difference, (17" monitor too). You just see more of the track and it feels like you can anticipate and react a little better. (course we also have a T2 and an ECCI CDS. ;->) Re: SVGA ICR2 vs ICR, it seems that ICR has a better VGA look. my friend swapped out ICR for ICR2 on his 486/66, and has a tougher time dealing w/ VGA on ICR2. Los Los
>I recently began playing ICR2. I did ICR-1 and Nascar extensively. The >tracks in ICR2 seem much slipperier. Michigan with the Ace setup seems >like glass. You can't seem to go full out all around like you used to in >the old version. Anyone have any comments on this? Bug? Feature? Real? > Fake? Need more practice? Real. ICR2 uses 1995-spec cars, which have 40% less downforce than 1993-spec cars, which is what ICR1 has. I suspect that, in addition, icr2 is more realistic. If you work on the setup, you CAN go around Michigan without lifting. That's how you can run 242+ mph... I don't think it's possible to go around without lifting some with full tanks. If it is, I sure haven't hit THAT setup yet. -- Brian Wong Systems Engineering Group (Servers)
John Sil 26 Mar 1996#314661
Quoted text (21 lines)>(StormPtrl)25 Mar 1996 02:42:39 -0500 writes: >:> >:>I recently began playing ICR2. I did ICR-1 and Nascar extensively. >The >:>tracks in ICR2 seem much slipperier. Michigan with the Ace setup >seems >:>like glass. You can't seem to go full out all around like you used >to in >:>the old version. Anyone have any comments on this? Bug? Feature? >Real? >:> Fake? Need more practice? >Same here. I just thought I sucked at this game! I'm playing on a >486-66 and was wondering if a Pentium would suffer the same problems? >When I was playing ICRI extensively, I could beat the competition at >any level. In ICR2, I feel lucky to go two laps without spinning out. > It doesn't seem as bad when surrounded by traffic though(too bad they >lose me when I spin). >If you find a solution, please e-mail me.
In ICR2 Papyrus modeled the reduced downforce rules for the 1995 season, that is why the track feels a lot more slippery. After a bit of practice though eventually you will become used to it and start giving the computer opponents some real competition. The upgrade in the computer AI really improves the gameplay in ICR2 for me, I could not go back and play ICR1 with it's dumber opponents. -- John -- ----------------------------- http://www.wolfe.net/~kludger
Quoted text (25 lines)> (StormPtrl)25 Mar 1996 02:42:39 -0500 writes: > :> > :>I recently began playing ICR2. I did ICR-1 and Nascar extensively. > The > :>tracks in ICR2 seem much slipperier. Michigan with the Ace setup > seems > :>like glass. You can't seem to go full out all around like you used > to in > :>the old version. Anyone have any comments on this? Bug? Feature? > Real? > :> Fake? Need more practice? > Same here. I just thought I sucked at this game! I'm playing on a > 486-66 and was wondering if a Pentium would suffer the same problems? > When I was playing ICRI extensively, I could beat the competition at > any level. In ICR2, I feel lucky to go two laps without spinning out. > It doesn't seem as bad when surrounded by traffic though(too bad they > lose me when I spin). > If you find a solution, please e-mail me. > WARP'n across the 'NetIn the past few years since the first ICR was released many rules changes
were made to the cars. The downforce was reduced by as much as 25-35% as I've heard. Though the teams have gained some of that back they still are down by a lot.
said...
Quoted text (8 lines)>>In ICR2 Papyrus modeled the reduced downforce rules for the 1995 season, >>that is why the track feels a lot more slippery. >Why don't they make important settings like this configurable by the >user? I understand going for realism in a simulation, but that doesn't >mean you shouldn't have adjustments for different skill levels (i.e., >this is not the same as being able to adjust the oponnents strength - >that does nothing about the difficulty of driving your own car).
Nonsense. Lower opponent strength to 85%; then you can set your boost setting at 1 to reduce the amount of braking you need to make for the turns. Also, you can brake earlier at the lower speed, so you shouldn't have problems negotiating the turns. At the same time as driving around the course carefully, you won't lose time on the other cars. There's nothing that makes me spin off the track more than a faster car putting pressure on me from behind. I guess professional racing is not the job for me. :-) -- +------------------------+---------------------------------+ | G. Warren Abao | BBL AFC Central Standings | +------------------------+Provo 13 1 0 434 115| | Owner/GM/Head Coach |Pittsburgh 10 4 0 617 387| | Jacksonville Jaguars |JAGUARS 7 7 0 363 345| | Black and Blue League |Texas State 1 13 0 143 563| +------------------------+-------------+-------------------+ | Official BBL Jaguars Website: | SPOOOOOOOOOOON!!! | | http://www.jaxnet.com/~wabao/jax.htm +-------------------+ +--------------------------------------+
Joe McGinn 30 Mar 1996#314947
>In ICR2 Papyrus modeled the reduced downforce rules for the 1995 season, >that is why the track feels a lot more slippery. >After a bit of practice though eventually you will become used to it and >start giving the computer opponents some real competition. The upgrade in >the computer AI really improves the gameplay in ICR2 for me, I could not >go back and play ICR1 with it's dumber opponents. Why don't they make important settings like this configurable by the user? I understand going for realism in a simulation, but that doesn't mean you shouldn't have adjustments for different skill levels (i.e., this is not the same as being able to adjust the oponnents strength - that does nothing about the difficulty of driving your own car). I have ICR II, Nascar, and just about every other PC racing and driving game, and to be honest ICR II is the only one I don't play. Every now and then I go back to try it again, and I rarely last five minutes before I get bored of spinning out and go back to Nascar or some other game. I'm not a bad driver or inexperienced gamer, and I've seen a lot of other people with the same complaint about ICR II. Is an adjustable skill level really such heresy in a simulation that they can't provide it for people who are trying to learn the game? Joe
BOsteen3 30 Mar 1996#314948
My car got very loose at Road America but after adjusting the Joystick settings everything returned to normal. It does take a lot of practice to get good at ICR2. I've been playing Nascar since it came out and the better I get the more I like it. I hope ICR2 will be the same. Preston
Josh 01 Apr 1996#315021
Quoted text (20 lines)>>In ICR2 Papyrus modeled the reduced downforce rules for the 1995 season, >>that is why the track feels a lot more slippery. >>After a bit of practice though eventually you will become used to it and >>start giving the computer opponents some real competition. The upgrade in >>the computer AI really improves the gameplay in ICR2 for me, I could not >>go back and play ICR1 with it's dumber opponents. >Why don't they make important settings like this configurable by the >user? I understand going for realism in a simulation, but that doesn't >mean you shouldn't have adjustments for different skill levels (i.e., >this is not the same as being able to adjust the oponnents strength - >that does nothing about the difficulty of driving your own car). >I have ICR II, Nascar, and just about every other PC racing and >driving game, and to be honest ICR II is the only one I don't play. >Every now and then I go back to try it again, and I rarely last five >minutes before I get bored of spinning out and go back to Nascar or >some other game. I'm not a bad driver or inexperienced gamer, and I've >seen a lot of other people with the same complaint about ICR II. Is an >adjustable skill level really such heresy in a simulation that they >can't provide it for people who are trying to learn the game? >Joe
I hope you arent as bad as you say, No problems at all!!! Just learn to drive first Joshua (Rally driver) Joshua, If there is a GOD Show Me!! And I will believe!!!
Joe McGinn 01 Apr 1996#315022
>I hope you arent as bad as you say, As I said, I'm not a bad driver. I have no problems with Nascar or other driving games (or driving in real life for that matter). I'm far from the first person who's complained that ICR2 is too hard to control when you're learning it. But hey, if Papyrus is too closed minded too listen to their customers complaints I don't mind, I'll just take my business elsewhere. I suspect, for example, that F1GP2 will have adjustable skill settings like most computer games do. Joe
drunk 01 Apr 1996#315023
Quoted text (12 lines)> Abao) writes: > >>Why don't they make important settings like this configurable by the > >>user? I understand going for realism in a simulation, but that doesn't > >>mean you shouldn't have adjustments for different skill levels (i.e., > >>this is not the same as being able to adjust the oponnents strength - > >>that does nothing about the difficulty of driving your own car). > My car got very loose at Road America but after adjusting the Joystick > settings everything returned to normal. It does take a lot of practice to > get good at ICR2. I've been playing Nascar since it came out and the > better I get the more I like it. I hope ICR2 will be the same.
i also found at first that ICR2 was a lot more frustrating than ICR1, but now, i simply love it.. lots of lots of practice.. easy on the braking.. get a good joystick or wheel.. and most of all, ADJUST your car setup to your *style*.. HUGE difference.. i found that all, (easy, fast & ace) setups were so badly out of whack, and after using up most of my march breaks perfecting setups from ground up, i love the game now.. im having faster lap times than ICR1, faster than real life times, and race at 97%-102% .. great game papyrus! keep it up!
EldredP 03 Apr 1996#315146
Quoted text (27 lines)>Subject: Re: IndyCar-II Woes >Date: Mon, 01 Apr 1996 18:26:14 -0800 >> Abao) writes: >> >>Why don't they make important settings like this configurable by the >> >>user? I understand going for realism in a simulation, but that doesn't >> >>mean you shouldn't have adjustments for different skill levels (i.e., >> >>this is not the same as being able to adjust the oponnents strength - >> >>that does nothing about the difficulty of driving your own car). >> My car got very loose at Road America but after adjusting the Joystick >> settings everything returned to normal. It does take a lot of practice to >> get good at ICR2. I've been playing Nascar since it came out and the >> better I get the more I like it. I hope ICR2 will be the same. >i also found at first that ICR2 was a lot more frustrating than ICR1, but >now, i simply love it.. lots of lots of practice.. easy on the braking.. >get a good joystick or wheel.. and most of all, ADJUST your car setup to >your *style*.. HUGE difference.. i found that all, (easy, fast & ace) >setups were so badly out of whack, and after using up most of my march >breaks perfecting setups from ground up, i love the game now.. im having >faster lap times than ICR1, faster than real life times, and race at >97%-102% .. great game papyrus! keep it up!
this is only a test I am NOT paranoid. And why are you always watching me?!? Eldred Pickett
EldredP 03 Apr 1996#315147
>Subject: Re: IndyCar-II Woes >Date: Mon, 01 Apr 1996 18:26:14 -0800 [snip] Well, *I* don't like it more than ICR1...I can't drive it on SEVERAL tracks. Detroit:the walls blend in, and I can't tell where the turns are. Phoenix:the manual LIED, you can't go flat out thru 3/4. Cleveland:the turns blend in with the ground. Now some of my problems may be because my machine is too slow(486/50 & p90) to run the detail I need, my setup skills are poor, or my driving skills are poor.(or all of the above). I can't do anything about the first, and I've turned a LOT of practice laps with no improvement. No matter WHAT I read,study, whatever, I have NO IDEA how to setup a car for my driving style. I'm actually sorry I spent money on the thing... I am NOT paranoid. And why are you always watching me?!? Eldred Pickett
Jo 05 Apr 1996#315291
> Well, *I* don't like it more than ICR1...I can't drive it on SEVERAL tracks. > Detroit:the walls blend in, and I can't tell where the turns are. Phoenix:the > manual LIED, you can't go flat out thru 3/4. Cleveland:the turns blend in > with the ground. > Now some of my problems may be because my machine is too slow(486/50 & p90) to > run the detail I need, my setup skills are poor, or my driving skills are > poor.(or all of the above). I can't do anything about the first, and I've > turned a LOT of practice laps with no improvement. No matter WHAT I > read,study, whatever, I have NO IDEA how to setup a car for my driving style. > I'm actually sorry I spent money on the thing... How long have you had it? Took me about... 4 months to finally not be pissed off at it all the time. I like it now. But I do think that the manual is very, very incomplete- doesn't even tell you what the optimal temp for the tires is or what RPMs to shift at. I spent months thinking I was gaining something by revving way up past 14k. I'm still not sure if tire wear is a gradual degredation of the tires over time or a sudden "tires are no good now" sort of thing... Papyrus really needed to go in to more detail on how their simulation works, because even tho it is a great simulator, there are lots of things which are simply beyond the range of a PC simulator (mostly because we can't feel the road physically), and we need to know what Papyrus is doing on them. Like, do we pick up dirt going off the track, messing up traction? Does the engine degrade if you rev it at 14k for an hour, or does it just go catastrophic? Do tires get damaged from wall scrapes or tangles with other cars? These are subtle things that are pretty hard to figure out just by watching your monitor and hearing the revs, I think. I am also a bit skeptical about how Papyrus is dealing with spins- sometimes it seems to me like if you exceed some threshold, you do a "pre-packaged" spin. It would be nice to know if that is true or not. It is clear that after an hour of racing on worn tires I can't run a lap as fast as my qual, even with almost no gas, but I keep wondering if that is just me being tired. And has anybody actually noticed drafting of any kind in ICR2?! I realize it's not going to be as important as in NASCAR, obviously, but I also don't seem able to draft anybody, even when the other car only has 1 or 2 MPH over me. Setup info is very poor too, a few "rules of thumb", but not enough (particularly with shocks and torsion-bar info) to know what is going on when modifying a setup. Oh- and the elementary replay functions... let's face it, we need some way to do a "random access" of the replays, rewinding the way they are now is *way* beyond tedious. Thank god for EDITRPY (Thanks, Mr. Corrigan!)! After all that, hey, I love the sim, and don't really know any other game with such a gradual, challenging learning curve. I think Papyrus needs to hire out another set of programmers for the interface. They clearly know what they are doing in the sim, but the interface needs a cosmetic overhaul (less tedium) and some more user-defined params. And I know everyone else seems to get somebody at their tech support, but I have *never* gotten a reply on the 5 or more things I've asked them. What is up with that!?
John Buc 08 Apr 1996#315428
based on the first manual, it recommends max. 240 (i think) for soft compound, up to 260 (??) for hard compound. in ICR2, i found its good to keep the tires a little above 200 F, but at 220 they begin to get slippery. i THINK its more powerful & more fuel wasteful to shift at 14,000, i do it only when overpassing a tough opponent (shift down to 5th, gun it to 14,500, and then shift to 6th after i passed him) check F5 (the tire data) and the green bar gets thinner, then turns yellow, then red (thats your gradual degredation). if one tire wears out way too fast, fix it. dirt has no effect on your car once your back on the road. and there are no *marbles* on outside of turns (thank GOD for that!), but when i rev up to 14k, the engine SOUNDS like its wimpering (pop-off valve sound f/x?) and i believe it increases your chances at a car breakdown. if its under REALISTIC damages, a little scrape against the wall leads to front wing damage affecting the car handling (but i once managed to counter it in a race by adjusting my front-anti-roll bar :) yeah, drafting is tough.. it only helps you get speed and swerve around the car in a turn, and saves gas. like in the real thing. few cars just FLING past a competitor just coz they are behind them. they should have made a DUMMY option that makes it drive like ICR1.. not everyone is as skilled as me :)
Josh Beauli 09 Apr 1996#315484
>Subject: Re: ICRII woes >Date: Mon, 08 Apr 1996 16:04:10 -0700 >... i THINK its more powerful & more fuel wasteful to shift at >14,000, i do it only when overpassing a tough opponent (shift down to >5th, gun it to 14,500, and then shift to 6th after i passed him) Wrong! I have done some testing and have found that the optimum RPM (cosworth) is 12800-13000. After 13000 you start losing speed that you would be gaining if you upshifted. BTW tires in ICR2work the best at 235-255, depending on the compound.
John Buc 10 Apr 1996#315557
maybe you're right with the RPMs thing, but i'm pretty sure running at a lower gear and high rpm is better than higher gear and low rpm besides, 13000 is high enough. doesnt it give a warning by then? for the tires, i beg to differ. 220 tops. anything more and the car feels like its on ice.
Quoted text (11 lines)> > >... i THINK its more powerful & more fuel wasteful to shift at > > >14,000, i do it only when overpassing a tough opponent (shift down to > > >5th, gun it to 14,500, and then shift to 6th after i passed him) > > Wrong! I have done some testing and have found that the optimum RPM > > (cosworth) is 12800-13000. After 13000 you start losing speed that you > > be gaining if you upshifted. BTW tires in ICR2work the best at 235-255, > > depending on the compound. > maybe you're right with the RPMs thing, but i'm pretty sure running at a > lower gear and high rpm is better than higher gear and low rpm
Yes, of course but once you exceed ~13000 rpm that isn't true any longer. Press F10. Check the rev counter when you cross 13125. It turns red. One problem, though, it's the same for all engines. The Honda should be good for ~14000. Papyrus has ***ed up again I presume. The optimum seems to be around 215 - 230. It depends on the compound. Soft is around 215-220. -- --- Terje Wold Johansen --- http://www.ifi.uio.no/~terjjo/ --- "I am your inferior superior." O.W.
RickGent 11 Apr 1996#315633
Press F10. Check the rev counter when you cross 13125. It turns red. One problem, though, it's the same for all engines. The Honda should be good for ~14000. Papyrus has ***ed up again I presume. <<< According to our physics model, the Cosworth and Mercedes engines redline at 13000 RPM, the Honda at 13500 RPM. If you have a reference work that indicates otherwise for the engines used in the 1995 season, I'd be interested in hearing about it. Rick Genter Technical Lead, IndyCar Racing II Papyrus Design Group, Inc.
Jo 11 Apr 1996#315634
Thanks, John, Josh, and Terje, and Rick for the discussion, it was informative. So I think I can be pretty sure that tire wear is a three-step degredation. That helps, because when testing, I might just start doing pitstops for 4 gallons and no tires- instead of putting new tires on and going through the pain of heating them up again. I'm 1/10 of a second off Long Beach's "Track Record" (Andretti, 52.4...), and I'd like to beat it before sundays race! Just for the hell of it.
Quoted text (7 lines)>According to our physics model, the Cosworth and Mercedes engines redline >at 13000 RPM, the Honda at 13500 RPM. If you have a reference work that >indicates otherwise for the engines used in the 1995 season, I'd be >interested in hearing about it. >Rick Genter >Technical Lead, IndyCar Racing II >Papyrus Design Group, Inc.
Rick, maybe you can enlighten us as to what optimum tire temps are for both kinds of tires. There is a whole lot of speculation up here about it, the range people are saying spreads from 200 on up to 255- clearly most of us are wrong! And it is fair to say that at "redline" the engine is putting out the most horsepower? Great game, keep up the good work

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy