Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

GTR: First Look Review

22 posts by 12 people · 29 Oct 2004 10:45 UTC - 02 Nov 2004 19:37 UTC

Early GTR review highlights multiplayer features

Steve Simpson linked an early ESL review of GTR that described its multiplayer features, including server options to block joins during sessions. Posters noted the German release was imminent but possibly German-language only, with a wider release rumoured for early 2005, and AutoBild had praised its accuracy. Debate followed on whether GTR's claimed warp-free collisions would beat Papyrus's netcode.

review/impressionsonline racing/leaguesrumour/speculationGTR

Automated summary.

Steve Simpson <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > Here's the first mini review for GTR that I've come across....mentions the > multiplayer capabilities of the game. > > http://www.esl-europe.net/eu/news/8662/ > Thanks. The mp news sounds promising.........but, have to see what actually happens when run in league format, the preferred method for myself.
Quoted text (10 lines)>> Here's the first mini review for GTR that I've come across....mentions >> the >> multiplayer capabilities of the game. >> >> http://www.esl-europe.net/eu/news/8662/ >> > > Thanks. The mp news sounds promising.........but, have to see what > actually happens when run in league format, the preferred method for > myself.
Yeah, us road racers have been starved of a decent sim for league racing for a long time. There hasn't been anything good since GPL and it's been feeling very dated the last few years despite some excellent mods.
Steve Simpson <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (12 lines)> >> Here's the first mini review for GTR that I've come across....mentions > >> the > >> multiplayer capabilities of the game. > >> > >> http://www.esl-europe.net/eu/news/8662/ > >> > > > > Thanks. The mp news sounds promising.........but, have to see what > > actually happens when run in league format, the preferred method for > > myself. > > Yeah, us road racers have been starved of a decent sim for league racing
for > a long time. There hasn't been anything good since GPL and it's been > feeling very dated the last few years despite some excellent mods. Exactly. > >
Chad Rogers 29 Oct 2004 17:29 UTC↳ reply to JP#29966
I am very excited about this one. Adding weight to cars should make it good fun for evening the fields each week for leagues as well. Now I just need to figure out how to read German before my copy arrives. "JP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:U0vgd.16$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (27 lines)> > Steve Simpson <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... >> >> Here's the first mini review for GTR that I've come across....mentions >> >> the >> >> multiplayer capabilities of the game. >> >> >> >> http://www.esl-europe.net/eu/news/8662/ >> >> >> > >> > Thanks. The mp news sounds promising.........but, have to see what >> > actually happens when run in league format, the preferred method for >> > myself. >> >> Yeah, us road racers have been starved of a decent sim for league racing > for >> a long time. There hasn't been anything good since GPL and it's been >> feeling very dated the last few years despite some excellent mods. > > > Exactly. > > >> >> > >
Chad Rogers 29 Oct 2004 17:29 UTC#532092
I am very e***d about this one. Adding weight to cars should make it good fun for evening the fields each week for leagues as well. Now I just need to figure out how to read German before my copy arrives.
Quoted text (16 lines)>> >> Here's the first mini review for GTR that I've come across....mentions >> >> the >> >> multiplayer capabilities of the game. >> >> http://www.esl-europe.net/eu/news/8662/ >> > Thanks. The mp news sounds promising.........but, have to see what >> > actually happens when run in league format, the preferred method for >> > myself. >> Yeah, us road racers have been starved of a decent sim for league racing > for >> a long time. There hasn't been anything good since GPL and it's been >> feeling very dated the last few years despite some excellent mods. > Exactly.
"Steve Simpson" <[email hidden]> kirjoitti viestiss�:[email hidden]... > Here's the first mini review for GTR that I've come across....mentions the > multiplayer capabilities of the game. > > http://www.esl-europe.net/eu/news/8662/ That awful lag when people join and leave the server, basically ruined GTR2002 leagues and in lesser extend, F1C league, at least here in Finland. When person X crashed in race and then quit, the lag caused a somebody else or number of people to crash too, which then caused... Doesn't look too bright on that part :( Looks like F1C netcode really hasn't been changed by Simbin that much, if at all. -- Mika Takala
Whats in German? The screenshots (from Steve's post) all showed English menu's. The Docs arent real important to me as I can just come here and ask Uwe :) If thats all thats in German Im going to place an order very soon. I sure like the sound of the warp free collision detection. No more cars flying off the track with a slight touch :-) Thats one thing I sure wont miss from Papy multi. itch "Chad Rogers" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... >I am very excited about this one. Adding weight to cars should make it >good fun for evening the fields each week for leagues as well. Now I just >need to figure out how to read German before my copy arrives.
Andi Cole 29 Oct 2004 22:07 UTC↳ reply to BRH#29978
Global release is currently being rumoured as Q1 2005, February has been talked about. Nothing definite though. Andi. -- Remove only one zero to reply "BRH @comcast.net>" <"bhoenig<no-spam> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > So, when will it be released in the US? > > Steve Simpson wrote: > > > Here's the first mini review for GTR that I've come across....mentions the > > multiplayer capabilities of the game. > > > > http://www.esl-europe.net/eu/news/8662/ >
> Doesn't look too bright on that part :( Looks like F1C netcode really > hasn't been changed by Simbin that much, if at all. Well, I didn't play much F1C online due mainly to the crappy netcode but the pause when people joined wasn't really a big deal. It certainly didn't happen when people quit. Like the article says, you can set the server to disallow people from joining during qualifying and the race which pretty much solves the problem. You could do the same in F1C. How bad the pause is depends on the speed of the server - if you've got a real beast of a dedicated server with RAID etc the pause when the server loads the new car textures etc is barely noticeable. I'm sure there must have been a lot of people hosting F1C races on laptops with 64MB of RAM at times! Simbin delayed the game several times because they weren't satisfied with the netcode. I doubt they would release it in a sloppy state knowing that it's going to be one of the game's main selling points - especially since they're talking about hosting their own online competitions etc. We live in hope....
Mitch, The release next week is the German version which is rumored to be exclusively in German, menus, garage, crew etc. Might be a challenge, but I am not willing to wait 3-4 months for a copy. Chad "Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:6axgd.2230$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (19 lines)> Whats in German? The screenshots (from Steve's post) all showed English > menu's. The Docs arent real important to me as I can just come here and > ask Uwe :) If thats all thats in German Im going to place an order very > soon. > > I sure like the sound of the warp free collision detection. No more cars > flying off the track with a slight touch :-) Thats one thing I sure wont > miss from Papy multi. > > itch > > > "Chad Rogers" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... >>I am very excited about this one. Adding weight to cars should make it >>good fun for evening the fields each week for leagues as well. Now I just >>need to figure out how to read German before my copy arrives. > >
Id have to wait. I can barely understand English :-) Mitch "Chad Rogers" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (32 lines)> Mitch, > > The release next week is the German version which is rumored to be > exclusively in German, menus, garage, crew etc. Might be a challenge, but > I am not willing to wait 3-4 months for a copy. > > Chad > > > "Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:6axgd.2230$[email hidden]... >> Whats in German? The screenshots (from Steve's post) all showed English >> menu's. The Docs arent real important to me as I can just come here and >> ask Uwe :) If thats all thats in German Im going to place an order very >> soon. >> >> I sure like the sound of the warp free collision detection. No more cars >> flying off the track with a slight touch :-) Thats one thing I sure >> wont miss from Papy multi. >> >> itch >> >> >> "Chad Rogers" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >> news:[email hidden]... >>>I am very excited about this one. Adding weight to cars should make it >>>good fun for evening the fields each week for leagues as well. Now I >>>just need to figure out how to read German before my copy arrives. >> >> > >
Speaking of German, AutoBild (popular car magazine in Germany) had a two page article on GTR, praising it for its accuracy. They had a few GTR drivers testing it out. Of course, not all car magazine writers are as good as our Mr. Smith at separating the wheat from the chaff, but I find it promising that it is getting this kind of media attention. Stephen p.s. they also praised "modest" system requirements
On Fri, 29 Oct 2004 23:07:23 +0100, "Andi Cole" <[email hidden]> wrote something like: >Global release is currently being rumoured as Q1 2005, February has been >talked about. Nothing definite though. Global publisher has not been announced yet, thus no date has been given for global release. Scandinavian release is planned for 1Q/2005, but I'm a bit sceptical as the scandinavian release was originally supposed to be october 29th... -- - Jussi Koukku -
ymenard 02 Nov 2004 05:29 UTC↳ reply to Mitch_A#29762
>"Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote > I sure like the sound of the warp free collision detection. No more cars > flying off the track with a slight touch :-) Thats one thing I sure wont > miss from Papy multi. I don't see why you hated it for Papy, as what they wrote is *exactly* the same thing as what Papy does. "Warp free collision detection" = eliminated the zig-zagging with a prediction code. Prediction coding smoothes everything but adds an element where cars can for an instant turn inside each other if they reappear correctly and create impossible physical collisions. No prediction coding simply make for something else... WARP. Perhaps in a perfect network with unlimited bandwidth it's possible (ex : a LAN type system which btw even isn't perfect and still needs a prediction code), but on the Internet you have to have a prediction code. It's the basis that makes any simracing community live. Without this, multiplayer racing will never be good even if there's a good set of community tools. Without it, when the server loses a fraction of where somebody is or misses a fraction of the relay of somebody else, the cars will be shown erratically (warping). Prediction code, smoothes everything out and eliminated extreme warping. You often see that in GPL as they increase the bandwidth requirement. Cars zig-zag around the corners, they turn in a very "stairway" style. -- -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> -- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez Corporation - helping America into the New World...
Well stated, Fran�ois! "ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:LWEhd.1440$[email hidden]... > >"Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote > > I sure like the sound of the warp free collision detection. No morecars > > flying off the track with a slight touch :-) Thats one thing I surewont > > miss from Papy multi. > > > I don't see why you hated it for Papy, as what they wrote is *exactly* the > same thing as what Papy does. "Warp free collision detection" =eliminated
Quoted text (9 lines)> the zig-zagging with a prediction code. Prediction coding smoothes > everything but adds an element where cars can for an instant turn inside > each other if they reappear correctly and create impossible physical > collisions. > > > No prediction coding simply make for something else... WARP. Perhaps in a > perfect network with unlimited bandwidth it's possible (ex : a LAN type > system which btw even isn't perfect and still needs a prediction code),
but
Quoted text (21 lines)> on the Internet you have to have a prediction code. > > > It's the basis that makes any simracing community live. Without this, > multiplayer racing will never be good even if there's a good set of > community tools. Without it, when the server loses a fraction of where > somebody is or misses a fraction of the relay of somebody else, the cars > will be shown erratically (warping). Prediction code, smoothes everything > out and eliminated extreme warping. You often see that in GPL as they > increase the bandwidth requirement. Cars zig-zag around the corners, they > turn in a very "stairway" style. > > > > > -- > -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> > -- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez > Corporation - helping America into the New World... > >
From what I'm told, the reactions to warp induced collisions are handled a fair bit better in GTR than N2003. Netkar & LFS are also better than N2003 in that respect.
Mitch_A 02 Nov 2004 16:59 UTC↳ reply to ymenard#29789
You missed my point completely, or I missed yours but to say Papy is the same is the opposite of what Ive seen. Slight touch and you opponent goes flying off the track and the magic cars that blend with each other quite happily till collision detection catches up then whaaaammmm. Off you both go spinning round and round. On the other hand GTR sounds like when the cars rub they actually do rub and not blend with each other then the resulting crash. Mitch "ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:LWEhd.1440$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (38 lines)> >"Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote >> I sure like the sound of the warp free collision detection. No more cars >> flying off the track with a slight touch :-) Thats one thing I sure >> wont miss from Papy multi. > > > I don't see why you hated it for Papy, as what they wrote is *exactly* the > same thing as what Papy does. "Warp free collision detection" = > eliminated the zig-zagging with a prediction code. Prediction coding > smoothes everything but adds an element where cars can for an instant turn > inside each other if they reappear correctly and create impossible > physical collisions. > > > No prediction coding simply make for something else... WARP. Perhaps in a > perfect network with unlimited bandwidth it's possible (ex : a LAN type > system which btw even isn't perfect and still needs a prediction code), > but on the Internet you have to have a prediction code. > > > It's the basis that makes any simracing community live. Without this, > multiplayer racing will never be good even if there's a good set of > community tools. Without it, when the server loses a fraction of where > somebody is or misses a fraction of the relay of somebody else, the cars > will be shown erratically (warping). Prediction code, smoothes everything > out and eliminated extreme warping. You often see that in GPL as they > increase the bandwidth requirement. Cars zig-zag around the corners, they > turn in a very "stairway" style. > > > > > -- > -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> > -- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez > Corporation - helping America into the New World... > >
JP 02 Nov 2004 19:36 UTC↳ reply to Mitch_A#29797
Anything would be an improvement over that flaw in the Papy net code. They had the best around (so far), but that part stinks. Other games don't/didn't do it, so something is messed up besides just warp. Mitch_A <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:02Phd.37756$[email hidden]... > You missed my point completely, or I missed yours but to say Papy is the > same is the opposite of what Ive seen. > > Slight touch and you opponent goes flying off the track and the magic cars > that blend with each other quite happily till collision detection catchesup > then whaaaammmm. Off you both go spinning round and round. > > On the other hand GTR sounds like when the cars rub they actually do ruband
Quoted text (9 lines)> not blend with each other then the resulting crash. > > Mitch > > > "ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:LWEhd.1440$[email hidden]... > > >"Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote > >> I sure like the sound of the warp free collision detection. No more
cars > >> flying off the track with a slight touch :-) Thats one thing I sure > >> wont miss from Papy multi. > > > > > > I don't see why you hated it for Papy, as what they wrote is *exactly*the > > same thing as what Papy does. "Warp free collision detection" = > > eliminated the zig-zagging with a prediction code. Prediction coding > > smoothes everything but adds an element where cars can for an instantturn > > inside each other if they reappear correctly and create impossible > > physical collisions. > > > > > > No prediction coding simply make for something else... WARP. Perhaps ina
Quoted text (10 lines)> > perfect network with unlimited bandwidth it's possible (ex : a LAN type > > system which btw even isn't perfect and still needs a prediction code), > > but on the Internet you have to have a prediction code. > > > > > > It's the basis that makes any simracing community live. Without this, > > multiplayer racing will never be good even if there's a good set of > > community tools. Without it, when the server loses a fraction of where > > somebody is or misses a fraction of the relay of somebody else, the cars > > will be shown erratically (warping). Prediction code, smoothes
everything > > out and eliminated extreme warping. You often see that in GPL as they > > increase the bandwidth requirement. Cars zig-zag around the corners,they
Quoted text (13 lines)> > turn in a very "stairway" style. > > > > > > > > > > -- > > -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> > > -- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez > > Corporation - helping America into the New World... > > > > > >
JP 02 Nov 2004 19:37 UTC↳ reply to ymenard#29798
ymenard <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:LWEhd.1440$[email hidden]... > >"Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote > > I sure like the sound of the warp free collision detection. No morecars > > flying off the track with a slight touch :-) Thats one thing I surewont > > miss from Papy multi. > > > I don't see why you hated it for Papy, as what they wrote is *exactly* the > same thing as what Papy does. "Warp free collision detection" =eliminated
Quoted text (9 lines)> the zig-zagging with a prediction code. Prediction coding smoothes > everything but adds an element where cars can for an instant turn inside > each other if they reappear correctly and create impossible physical > collisions. > > > No prediction coding simply make for something else... WARP. Perhaps in a > perfect network with unlimited bandwidth it's possible (ex : a LAN type > system which btw even isn't perfect and still needs a prediction code),
but
Quoted text (19 lines)> on the Internet you have to have a prediction code. > > > It's the basis that makes any simracing community live. Without this, > multiplayer racing will never be good even if there's a good set of > community tools. Without it, when the server loses a fraction of where > somebody is or misses a fraction of the relay of somebody else, the cars > will be shown erratically (warping). Prediction code, smoothes everything > out and eliminated extreme warping. You often see that in GPL as they > increase the bandwidth requirement. Cars zig-zag around the corners, they > turn in a very "stairway" style. > > > > > -- > -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> > -- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimago-Dominguez > Corporation - helping America into the New World...
Other games handled this better (Heat, i.e.) so Papy should have been able to you'd think. > >

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy