http://forums.ubi.com/groupee/forums/a/tpc/f/561108232/m/2871061083/p/5
posted by I3thHouR
Let me start by saying I am a developer and a Webmaster of a number of
major Game related sites.
I have 25 years experience in the Business thus I make very sure that
I have fully researched what I comment about. My credentials precede
me, I do not agree with or endorse software piracy. However to play my
existing Starforce games I have had to crack them.
Issues concerning Starforce.
1. They are based in Moscow so exempt from a number of the laws that
we in the West rely upon. The 3rd Party Companies that use their copy
protection are not exempt.
2. In Windows XP Starforce gives Ring 0 (super user level access) to
Ring 3 (Standard users). In normal English this basically means that
any third party application such as Trojans or Viri are given the
ability to have full access the both software and hardware.
3. As many of you will be aware XP does have DMA/IDE issue that’s
dates back to its creation. In which if packets are lost during the
reading or writing of a disk. XP interprets this as an error and steps
the IDE speed down. Eventually it will revert to 16bit compatibility
mode rendering a CD/DVD writer virtually unusable. In some
circumstances certain drives cannot cope with this mode and it results
in physical hardware failure (Most commonly in multiformat CD/DVD
writer drives). A sure sign of this step down occurring is that the
burn speeds will get slower and slower (no matter what speed you
select to burn at). Starforce on a regular basis triggers this silent
step down. Until it reaches the latter stages most peeps do not even
realise it is happening.
Excluding the Hardware failure, the normal way to cure this is to
uninstall all the CD/DVD drivers and the Primary/Secondary IDE
controllers. (Then reboot). If you did not know about Starforce, you
can now be faced with another problem. Normally windows searches and
reinstalls the drivers. However with Starforce present this can cause
the system to either fail to find the hardware or fail to find the
drivers. Creating the illusion that the hardware has failed.
This gets even worse if you have SCSI hardware/virtual drives. SCSI
virtual printer driver (basically any SCSI hardware/Virtual drivers
present) As these may have to be removed before the other hardware
becomes visible.
4. Because Starforce are aware of these issues (Including the Trojan
Gateway) this is exempt from the EULA and could be deemed as "Gaining
access with malicious intent". Not only would starforce be liable, but
also the 3rd party company that endorsed/used that application.
Ubisoft really need to do themselves a favour and dump Starforce. They
have earned their quotas on the existing titles. So there is no reason
not to make full bypasses available in a legit format.
An example of my system using Starforce from a Ubisoft Game. My Athlon
64Bit 3200+ Clawhammer started running like its components where stuck
on treacle, My Burn proof DVD writers created more coasters than they
use at a state banquet and overall it was about as stable as a one
legged man in a hurricane.
It's not my intention to put the industry out of business (They are
achieving that under their own steam), however using so called copy
protection that is nothing more than a glorified Trojan Gateway is not
the way to stay in business.
Trojan Gateway:
I do not make such a comment lightly and I have proof of this
occurring and of exploits already using it. I have openly challenged
Starforce to prove otherwise and their response was not to comment or
to refer to the EULA (As if the EULA exempted them from installing
malicious software). Although to be fair technically Starforce is not
malicious, it just leaves the door wide open for software that is.
In my professional capacity I am aware that a number of corporations
that had been previously flexible about staff playing games during
normal breaks. Now ban the usage of any 3rd party Games in the work
place (Because of the Starforce security issues). Also a number of us
who review games are now refusing to touch any games protected by
Starforce as we are not prepared to compromise our system stability
and security anymore.
So basically if us reviewers will not handle them and the customers
are now boycotting them. How exactly do Ubisoft intend to continue to
sell games?
Starforce criticism leads to Microsoft and Linux argument
Sean Cousins reposted a developer's criticism of Starforce, and users discussed dual-boot workarounds and whether it could limit CD burning speeds. The thread shifted to claims that Windows Vista would restrict multi-booting, trusted computing, and Linux versus Windows, with Mitch_A and Uwe Schuerkamp exchanging sharp views.
industry/businessoff-topic
Automated summary.
Sean Cousins wrote:
dumb people who have no clue will buy them. There are a lot of people
who have absolutly no idea about this. They then send thier "broken"
computer out for repairs. Some guy makes a buck, and they are happy.
It's called economics( or something like that)...lol..j/k btw
Mike
mls67
Quoted text (90 lines)
> http://forums.ubi.com/groupee/forums/a/tpc/f/561108232/m/2871061083/p/5 > > posted by I3thHouR > > Let me start by saying I am a developer and a Webmaster of a number of > major Game related sites. > > I have 25 years experience in the Business thus I make very sure that > I have fully researched what I comment about. My credentials precede > me, I do not agree with or endorse software piracy. However to play my > existing Starforce games I have had to crack them. > > Issues concerning Starforce. > > 1. They are based in Moscow so exempt from a number of the laws that > we in the West rely upon. The 3rd Party Companies that use their copy > protection are not exempt. > > 2. In Windows XP Starforce gives Ring 0 (super user level access) to > Ring 3 (Standard users). In normal English this basically means that > any third party application such as Trojans or Viri are given the > ability to have full access the both software and hardware. > > 3. As many of you will be aware XP does have DMA/IDE issue that’s > dates back to its creation. In which if packets are lost during the > reading or writing of a disk. XP interprets this as an error and steps > the IDE speed down. Eventually it will revert to 16bit compatibility > mode rendering a CD/DVD writer virtually unusable. In some > circumstances certain drives cannot cope with this mode and it results > in physical hardware failure (Most commonly in multiformat CD/DVD > writer drives). A sure sign of this step down occurring is that the > burn speeds will get slower and slower (no matter what speed you > select to burn at). Starforce on a regular basis triggers this silent > step down. Until it reaches the latter stages most peeps do not even > realise it is happening. > > Excluding the Hardware failure, the normal way to cure this is to > uninstall all the CD/DVD drivers and the Primary/Secondary IDE > controllers. (Then reboot). If you did not know about Starforce, you > can now be faced with another problem. Normally windows searches and > reinstalls the drivers. However with Starforce present this can cause > the system to either fail to find the hardware or fail to find the > drivers. Creating the illusion that the hardware has failed. > > This gets even worse if you have SCSI hardware/virtual drives. SCSI > virtual printer driver (basically any SCSI hardware/Virtual drivers > present) As these may have to be removed before the other hardware > becomes visible. > > 4. Because Starforce are aware of these issues (Including the Trojan > Gateway) this is exempt from the EULA and could be deemed as "Gaining > access with malicious intent". Not only would starforce be liable, but > also the 3rd party company that endorsed/used that application. > > Ubisoft really need to do themselves a favour and dump Starforce. They > have earned their quotas on the existing titles. So there is no reason > not to make full bypasses available in a legit format. > > An example of my system using Starforce from a Ubisoft Game. My Athlon > 64Bit 3200+ Clawhammer started running like its components where stuck > on treacle, My Burn proof DVD writers created more coasters than they > use at a state banquet and overall it was about as stable as a one > legged man in a hurricane. > > It's not my intention to put the industry out of business (They are > achieving that under their own steam), however using so called copy > protection that is nothing more than a glorified Trojan Gateway is not > the way to stay in business. > > Trojan Gateway: > I do not make such a comment lightly and I have proof of this > occurring and of exploits already using it. I have openly challenged > Starforce to prove otherwise and their response was not to comment or > to refer to the EULA (As if the EULA exempted them from installing > malicious software). Although to be fair technically Starforce is not > malicious, it just leaves the door wide open for software that is. > > In my professional capacity I am aware that a number of corporations > that had been previously flexible about staff playing games during > normal breaks. Now ban the usage of any 3rd party Games in the work > place (Because of the Starforce security issues). Also a number of us > who review games are now refusing to touch any games protected by > Starforce as we are not prepared to compromise our system stability > and security anymore. > > So basically if us reviewers will not handle them and the customers > are now boycotting them. How exactly do Ubisoft intend to continue to > sell games? > >
XP/XP Dualboot with a seperate gaming/simming partition will limmit the
sideeffects of Starforce. Tripple boot would probably be best. Productivity,
gaming/simming and gaming/simming with SF. :)
Jone T.
XP/XP Dualboot with a seperate ***/simming partition will limmit the
sideeffects of Starforce. Tripple boot would probably be best. Productivity,
***/simming and ***/simming with SF. :)
Jone T.
In article <[email hidden]>, "Jone T." <jone> says...
Starting with Vista, you will no longer have the ability to boot
multiple OS's from the same hard drive (or system?) that contains Vista.
Quoted text (9 lines)
> > XP/XP Dualboot with a seperate gaming/simming partition will limmit the > sideeffects of Starforce. Tripple boot would probably be best. Productivity, > gaming/simming and gaming/simming with SF. :) > > Jone T. > > >Damn, I think I might have this problem with my cd burner. I just bought
some cd-r's from newegg and they were 48x but only would burn at 32x, could
this be the cause? GTR is the only starforce protected game I own, is there
a fix or a way to bypass it?
On Wed, 11 Jan 2006 11:30:05 GMT, John Simmons wrote:
> Starting with Vista, you will no longer have the ability to boot
> multiple OS's from the same hard drive (or system?) that contains Vista.
Hmmm, some judges might take an interest in that fact.
Cheers, uwe
--
GPG Fingerprint: 2E 13 20 22 9A 3F 63 7F 67 6F E9 B1 A8 36 A4 61
On Wed, 11 Jan 2006 14:45:18 GMT, "John Smith" <[email hidden]>
wrote:
>Damn, I think I might have this problem with my cd burner. I just bought
>some cd-r's from newegg and they were 48x but only would burn at 32x, could
>this be the cause? GTR is the only starforce protected game I own, is there
>a fix or a way to bypass it?
>Possible but can't say for sure. Could just be dodgy cdr's. If it is
Starforce you will need to find a crack for GTR, I don't know of one,
and then get the Starforce removal tool from the Starforce website.
Easy enough to test... Just remove the SF drivers from your pc (using
the Starforce Removal Tool - available on the Starforce website). Then
see if your CDs burn at 48x. I'd recommend a system boot after
uninstalling
Next time you start GTR, the Starforce drivers will be automatically
re-installed (you will know it when you are asked to reboot your
machine before GTR will play).
If you find that Starforce IS the culprit, it's up to you whether or
not GTR is worth the SF hassle(s).
Well now. That sucks.
I suspect that's a side-effect of the image-installation process it will
have.
-Larry
"John Simmons" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (14 lines)
> In article <[email hidden]>, "Jone T." <jone> says... >> >> XP/XP Dualboot with a seperate gaming/simming partition will limmit the >> sideeffects of Starforce. Tripple boot would probably be best. >> Productivity, >> gaming/simming and gaming/simming with SF. :) >> >> Jone T. >> >> >> > > Starting with Vista, you will no longer have the ability to boot > multiple OS's from the same hard drive (or system?) that contains Vista.On Wed, 11 Jan 2006 12:31:41 -0500, Larry (The Other Larry) wrote:
> Well now. That sucks.
>
> I suspect that's a side-effect of the image-installation process it will
> have.
>
I tend to agree with the "don't blame on malice what can be explained by
stupidity" viewpoint, but to me it looks like another attempt by M$ to
"own" our PC's and make it as hard as possible for the user to install
competing products on the same hardware.
Anyone remember M$ explicitly denying major hardware vendors the right
to sell multi-boot configuration machines under the threat of increasing
windows volume licensing costs to them?
All the best, uwe
--
GPG Fingerprint: 2E 13 20 22 9A 3F 63 7F 67 6F E9 B1 A8 36 A4 61
<[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
Made no difference, must be bad cd-r's.. I wonder what the Texas AG would
think of Star-force.
Quoted text (12 lines)
> Easy enough to test... Just remove the SF drivers from your pc (using > the Starforce Removal Tool - available on the Starforce website). Then > see if your CDs burn at 48x. I'd recommend a system boot after > uninstalling > > Next time you start GTR, the Starforce drivers will be automatically > re-installed (you will know it when you are asked to reboot your > machine before GTR will play). > > If you find that Starforce IS the culprit, it's up to you whether or > not GTR is worth the SF hassle(s). >On Sat, 14 Jan 2006 01:17:43 GMT, "John Smith" <[email hidden]>
wrote:
>Made no difference, must be bad cd-r's..
Maybe your drive is only capable of 32x cdr burn?
In article <[email hidden]>,
[email hidden] says...
They have identified dual-booting as a "security risk". Technically,
they are correct. You can boot into another OS and, with a sector
editor, modify system files of any other OS installed on the disk.
Granted, that's out of reach of most people nowadays, but it's possible.
Quoted text (20 lines)
> On Wed, 11 Jan 2006 12:31:41 -0500, Larry (The Other Larry) wrote: > > Well now. That sucks. > > > > I suspect that's a side-effect of the image-installation process it will > > have. > > > > I tend to agree with the "don't blame on malice what can be explained by > stupidity" viewpoint, but to me it looks like another attempt by M$ to > "own" our PC's and make it as hard as possible for the user to install > competing products on the same hardware. > > Anyone remember M$ explicitly denying major hardware vendors the right > to sell multi-boot configuration machines under the threat of increasing > windows volume licensing costs to them? > > All the best, uwe > > >On Sat, 14 Jan 2006 05:09:56 GMT, John Simmons wrote:
>
> They have identified dual-booting as a "security risk".
I guess they're on about the security of their account balance. MS
taking a stab at IT security always sounds a bit funny ;)
> Technically,
> they are correct. You can boot into another OS and, with a sector
> editor, modify system files of any other OS installed on the disk.
> Granted, that's out of reach of most people nowadays, but it's possible.
I assume they've also gotten rid of the possibility to boot off a CD /
DVD, network PROM or floppy then? Oh wait, that's a BIOS feature, I
wonder if they'll pressure BIOS makers into removing that feature in the
name of "security", too. ;-)
All the best, uwe
--
GPG Fingerprint: 2E 13 20 22 9A 3F 63 7F 67 6F E9 B1 A8 36 A4 61
>I assume they've also gotten rid of the possibility to boot off a CD /
>DVD, network PROM or floppy then? Oh wait, that's a BIOS feature, I
>wonder if they'll pressure BIOS makers into removing that feature in the
>name of "security", too. ;-)
>
>All the best, uwe
Your sarcasm is not lost on me Uwe, but your assumption is correct.
Google "trusted platform module" or "palladium BIOS". Whether any of
it becomes accepted/mainstream to the point of "their" intent remains
to be seen. But make no mistake, the intent exists, as do the efforts
to fulfill that intent.
This progresses as per some entities' plans, and Orwell could be
proven correct in "1984", save for the title.
/tinfoil hat off
...but just within reach here on my desk, along with my favorite Linux
distros. :)
Have a great day,
Brett
In article <[email hidden]>,
[email hidden] says...
Actually, Vista is supposed to allow sysadmins to set user accounts to
not allow removable storage media to be used. As for booting, I don't
think MS has an answer for that one yet.
Quoted text (21 lines)
> On Sat, 14 Jan 2006 05:09:56 GMT, John Simmons wrote: > > > > They have identified dual-booting as a "security risk". > > I guess they're on about the security of their account balance. MS > taking a stab at IT security always sounds a bit funny ;) > > > Technically, > > they are correct. You can boot into another OS and, with a sector > > editor, modify system files of any other OS installed on the disk. > > Granted, that's out of reach of most people nowadays, but it's possible. > > I assume they've also gotten rid of the possibility to boot off a CD / > DVD, network PROM or floppy then? Oh wait, that's a BIOS feature, I > wonder if they'll pressure BIOS makers into removing that feature in the > name of "security", too. ;-) > > All the best, uwe > > >In article <[email hidden]>,
[email hidden] says...
And let's not forget those talented jhackers that can download,
disassemble and modify bios images. Even palladium is vulnerable to user
whims.
Quoted text (26 lines)
> > >I assume they've also gotten rid of the possibility to boot off a CD / > >DVD, network PROM or floppy then? Oh wait, that's a BIOS feature, I > >wonder if they'll pressure BIOS makers into removing that feature in the > >name of "security", too. ;-) > > > >All the best, uwe > > Your sarcasm is not lost on me Uwe, but your assumption is correct. > Google "trusted platform module" or "palladium BIOS". Whether any of > it becomes accepted/mainstream to the point of "their" intent remains > to be seen. But make no mistake, the intent exists, as do the efforts > to fulfill that intent. > > This progresses as per some entities' plans, and Orwell could be > proven correct in "1984", save for the title. > > /tinfoil hat off > > ...but just within reach here on my desk, along with my favorite Linux > distros. :) > > Have a great day, > > Brett >Quoted text (18 lines)
>Your sarcasm is not lost on me Uwe, but your assumption is correct. >> Google "trusted platform module" or "palladium BIOS". Whether any of >> it becomes accepted/mainstream to the point of "their" intent remains >> to be seen. But make no mistake, the intent exists, as do the efforts >> to fulfill that intent. >> >> This progresses as per some entities' plans, and Orwell could be >> proven correct in "1984", save for the title. >> >> /tinfoil hat off >> >> ...but just within reach here on my desk, along with my favorite Linux >> distros. :) >> >> Have a great day, >> >> Brett >>On Sat, 14 Jan 2006 22:34:13 GMT, John Simmons wrote:
> Actually, Vista is supposed to allow sysadmins to set user accounts to
> not allow removable storage media to be used. As for booting, I don't
> think MS has an answer for that one yet.
Hi John,
goes to prove again that now computer is safe that one has physical
access to. I wonder what "they" will try to do about that? Now where did
I put that focusin bottle...?? ;)
Cheers, uwe
--
GPG Fingerprint: 2E 13 20 22 9A 3F 63 7F 67 6F E9 B1 A8 36 A4 61
"Uwe Sch�rkamp" <[email hidden]> wrote
> goes to prove again that now computer is safe that one has physical
> access to. I wonder what "they" will try to do about that? Now where did
> I put that focusin bottle...?? ;)
>
> Cheers, uwe
Focusin or Kool-Aid? Enough Uwe, we ALL know you arent able to make a
reasonable judgement on any MS products and thats fine but enough MS bashing
already.
Linux is not a consumer friendly OS know matter what SPIN you throw out.
Reality check, do you really think any of us care who makes our OS? Hell
no, I want what works best, and without a doubt in the consumer arena
Windows is far and away a superior product. When Linux looks and works like
a modern OS (not some shareware mess it currrently is) then Im convinced
everyone would migrate without a second thought.
This isnt the place for this discussion and Ive visited places that do and
they all are nothing more than a stable for the unreasonable kool-aid
drinking activists with more time than sense.
Mitch
> So at the end of the day, someone will still find a way around it.
>
> I mean no offense to the real 1%'ers, but because of 1%, 99% will get
> screwed?
1%?? Try 40-50%...
I hate MS as much as anyone and I desperately wish that Linux was a decent
alternative but it just plain isn't. Linux distros that even begin to
approach user-friendliness are 10 times slower and more bloated than Windows
has ever been. Sad but true.
What surprises me is that *anyone* at all defends Starforce and MS to
any extent.
I have nothing against MS, as long as I can select applications and turn
off the useless stuff at my choosing.
And I love linux, since it gives me the ultimate power on my own machine.
Comparing the two are comparing two non-comparative things; For one,
linux is free, MS is not. This makes it utterly useless to compare the
two in next to any context.
I don't recognize my current linux distro in any of your assessments,
since it performs magnificently well on an ancient (7 years old) P3, and
it feels like a perfectly modern OS.
Linux is most of all *different*, and attacking something because it is
*different* is the least valid of all possible imaginable arguments.
---A---
On 15.01.2006 19:22, Mitch_A wrote:
Quoted text (26 lines)
> "Uwe Sch�rkamp" <[email hidden]> wrote >> goes to prove again that now computer is safe that one has physical >> access to. I wonder what "they" will try to do about that? Now where did >> I put that focusin bottle...?? ;) >> >> Cheers, uwe > > Focusin or Kool-Aid? Enough Uwe, we ALL know you arent able to make a > reasonable judgement on any MS products and thats fine but enough MS bashing > already. > > Linux is not a consumer friendly OS know matter what SPIN you throw out. > Reality check, do you really think any of us care who makes our OS? Hell > no, I want what works best, and without a doubt in the consumer arena > Windows is far and away a superior product. When Linux looks and works like > a modern OS (not some shareware mess it currrently is) then Im convinced > everyone would migrate without a second thought. > > This isnt the place for this discussion and Ive visited places that do and > they all are nothing more than a stable for the unreasonable kool-aid > drinking activists with more time than sense. > > Mitch > > >Brett wrote:
> This progresses as per some entities' plans, and Orwell could be
> proven correct in "1984", save for the title.
F Orwell, he stole that book from Ayn Rand.
Don McCorkle
On Mon, 16 Jan 2006 07:26:44 +1000, Steve Simpson wrote:
> I hate MS as much as anyone and I desperately wish that Linux was a decent
> alternative but it just plain isn't. Linux distros that even begin to
> approach user-friendliness are 10 times slower and more bloated than Windows
> has ever been. Sad but true.
Then you haven't tried many distros. Kanotix is quite nice, as is
Knoppix, you might want to give those another try. And (K)Ubuntu, of
course... unless you define "bloated" as "providing useful applications
at no extra cost". ;)
Cheers, uwe
--
GPG Fingerprint: 2E 13 20 22 9A 3F 63 7F 67 6F E9 B1 A8 36 A4 61
It is now common knowledge that Mr. Orwell was a good old-fashioned
arsehole. :-)
---A---
On 16.01.2006 13:45, Woodie83 wrote:
Quoted text (9 lines)
> Brett wrote: > >> This progresses as per some entities' plans, and Orwell could be >> proven correct in "1984", save for the title. > > F Orwell, he stole that book from Ayn Rand. > > > Don McCorkleFirst off Im not defending anyone.
Dev's are using copy protection for a reason (Pirates). If they feel they
need it then so be it so long as it is as un-obtrusive as possible, which
Starforce is. It can and will get much worse in our lifetimes. All the
while these lunatic fringe activists are just going to drive dev's to the
consoles leaving us simmers high and dry....
Look at the reverse effect PETA is having on both the activists and the
public. The activists are getting more and more daring doing just about
anything to be heard while the general public for the most part ignores
them. The activists must then go that much farther to make the headlines
and now they are looked at as nothing more than a out of control left wing
terror group.
As far as MS goes Im just sick and tired of the activists and their
unreasonable comments. If you don;t like MS fine but why do so many feel
the need to bash MS at every single opportunity, ad nauseum... No different
than the freaks on the far left and their incessant never ending crying
about Bush or the far rights crying about Clinton.
What does L:inux being free have to do with being comparable? They are
both PC OS's and deserve to be compared to each other.
Every 6 months or so for the past decade Ive installed numerous distro's
(Suse my fav) and while they are improving the pace lags well behind Windows
releases..
You arent going to run Linux in an acceptable manner with a current desktop
manager (KDE or Gnome) on a P3 of any species... It may run but not
acceptably.
Trust me, I also want a free OS and could care less who gives it to me.
Right now Linux isnt it, free or otherwise.
You are misreading my comments if you think Im attacking Linux. I get
questions regarding Linux daily but when the end user can't even install a
printer in XP then what chance does he have with Linux? Not much and that
pretty much sums it up for me..
Mitch
"Asgeir Nesoen" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:dqfrnh$nfl$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (21 lines)
> What surprises me is that *anyone* at all defends Starforce and MS to any > extent. > > I have nothing against MS, as long as I can select applications and turn > off the useless stuff at my choosing. > > And I love linux, since it gives me the ultimate power on my own machine. > > Comparing the two are comparing two non-comparative things; For one, linux > is free, MS is not. This makes it utterly useless to compare the two in > next to any context. > > I don't recognize my current linux distro in any of your assessments, > since it performs magnificently well on an ancient (7 years old) P3, and > it feels like a perfectly modern OS. > > Linux is most of all *different*, and attacking something because it is > *different* is the least valid of all possible imaginable arguments. > > ---A--- >Quoted text (16 lines)
> ... > Every 6 months or so for the past decade Ive installed numerous distro's > (Suse my fav) and while they are improving the pace lags well behind > Windows releases.. > > You arent going to run Linux in an acceptable manner with a current > desktop manager (KDE or Gnome) on a P3 of any species... It may run but > not acceptably. > > Trust me, I also want a free OS and could care less who gives it to me. > Right now Linux isnt it, free or otherwise. > > You are misreading my comments if you think Im attacking Linux. I get > questions regarding Linux daily but when the end user can't even install a > printer in XP then what chance does he have with Linux? Not much and that > pretty much sums it up for me..Mitch,
Here's Microsoft's biggest problem...
They went from a crashy, bug-infested operating system (Windows 95 and 98)
to a relatively stable and useable operating system (Win2K and XP) but along
the way picked up so many security holes that the term swiss cheese doesn't
do it justice.
When someone like me has to spend 30-40% of their support time removing
spyware picked up via drive-by silent installs from web pages (an issue
Microsoft STILL has not addressed to this day) then, well, that's just wrong
dammit.
Microsoft deserves a lot of what they get.
-Larry
"Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:xGYyf.3380$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (68 lines)
> First off Im not defending anyone. > > Dev's are using copy protection for a reason (Pirates). If they feel they > need it then so be it so long as it is as un-obtrusive as possible, which > Starforce is. It can and will get much worse in our lifetimes. All the > while these lunatic fringe activists are just going to drive dev's to the > consoles leaving us simmers high and dry.... > > Look at the reverse effect PETA is having on both the activists and the > public. The activists are getting more and more daring doing just about > anything to be heard while the general public for the most part ignores > them. The activists must then go that much farther to make the headlines > and now they are looked at as nothing more than a out of control left wing > terror group. > > As far as MS goes Im just sick and tired of the activists and their > unreasonable comments. If you don;t like MS fine but why do so many feel > the need to bash MS at every single opportunity, ad nauseum... No > different than the freaks on the far left and their incessant never ending > crying about Bush or the far rights crying about Clinton. > > What does L:inux being free have to do with being comparable? They are > both PC OS's and deserve to be compared to each other. > > Every 6 months or so for the past decade Ive installed numerous distro's > (Suse my fav) and while they are improving the pace lags well behind > Windows releases.. > > You arent going to run Linux in an acceptable manner with a current > desktop manager (KDE or Gnome) on a P3 of any species... It may run but > not acceptably. > > Trust me, I also want a free OS and could care less who gives it to me. > Right now Linux isnt it, free or otherwise. > > You are misreading my comments if you think Im attacking Linux. I get > questions regarding Linux daily but when the end user can't even install a > printer in XP then what chance does he have with Linux? Not much and that > pretty much sums it up for me.. > > Mitch > > > "Asgeir Nesoen" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:dqfrnh$nfl$[email hidden]... >> What surprises me is that *anyone* at all defends Starforce and MS to any >> extent. >> >> I have nothing against MS, as long as I can select applications and turn >> off the useless stuff at my choosing. >> >> And I love linux, since it gives me the ultimate power on my own machine. >> >> Comparing the two are comparing two non-comparative things; For one, >> linux is free, MS is not. This makes it utterly useless to compare the >> two in next to any context. >> >> I don't recognize my current linux distro in any of your assessments, >> since it performs magnificently well on an ancient (7 years old) P3, and >> it feels like a perfectly modern OS. >> >> Linux is most of all *different*, and attacking something because it is >> *different* is the least valid of all possible imaginable arguments. >> >> ---A--- >> > >I sure NEVER said Windows is perfect. I cuss out MS daily but its still
what we have so I deal with it. Good or bad. Ill switch to anything I feed
is better. Nothing is at this point.
Blaming MS for spyware/viruses etc etc is a serious stretch of the
imagination though.
The reason for the security issues in Windows lies directly with backward
compatibility. MS (correctly I might add) put more effort into b/w
compatibility at the expense of security in the past. And they did better
than anyone else before or since.
I have an old proggy called 3d home architect originally purchased for
Windows 3.1. Just the other day I dropped the CD into my XP rig and it
worked perfectly. including printing. Just think about that for a second or
two.
Ask any Apple fan how well Apple handles OS backward compatibility ;)
Did MS wait to long to make the transition? Yes, Id say. They are
definitely heading in the right direction now and Longhorn/Vista is even
more secure. Security of any type is only as good a the PC users that use
the PC.
Had any other OS (Nix, Warp, Linux or GEO, BeOS etc etc) grabbed the holy
grail back in the 80's do you really believe they would have been immune to
these attacks? Hardly... The biggest target gets shot at the most...
My problem with MS lies in its pricing structure. When I first bought DOS
3x back in 84' it cost me (IIRC it fuzzy now) $79. The 8088 PC I was
building costed me over 5K. A pretty small percentage of the PC overall
cost.
Today I can buy a rig for $300 but Windows now costs (Home version) a
sawbuck. 25% of the PC overall cost. The scale needs adjusting IMHO. I
mean how much money is enough fo rMS? Drop the fn prices already ;)
What are you going to do when the OS is self repairing and fully secure?
I'd bet you will be wishing for some viruses to fix when they hand you your
pink slip ;)
Mitch
"Larry (The Other Larry)" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:ai7zf.115474$oG.109815@dukeread02...
Quoted text (18 lines)
> Mitch, > > Here's Microsoft's biggest problem... > > They went from a crashy, bug-infested operating system (Windows 95 and 98) > to a relatively stable and useable operating system (Win2K and XP) but > along the way picked up so many security holes that the term swiss cheese > doesn't do it justice. > > When someone like me has to spend 30-40% of their support time removing > spyware picked up via drive-by silent installs from web pages (an issue > Microsoft STILL has not addressed to this day) then, well, that's just > wrong dammit. > > Microsoft deserves a lot of what they get. > > -Larry >I don't blame them for the spyware/viruses. I blame them for leaving the
keys in the ignition.
-Larry
"Mitch_A" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:skazf.10588$[email hidden]...
> Blaming MS for spyware/viruses etc etc is a serious stretch of the
> imagination though.
>


































