Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

So which FF wheel should I buy?

22 posts by 12 people · 22 Dec 1999 21:07 UTC - 31 Jan 2000

Choosing a force-feedback wheel for precision in GPL

Karl Zosel asked which force-feedback wheel offers the most precision for GPL. Shumi said the Logitech had the best positioning resolution, with Act Labs close behind, and explained that USB wheels digitise their potentiometer signals. Scott Husted urged owners to ask Papyrus to support the Act Labs RS shifter, which worked only in sequential legacy mode.

hardware: wheels/pedalsGrand Prix Legends

Automated summary.

Karl Zosel 22 Dec 1999 21:07 UTC#290799
Guillemot? Logitech? Microsoft? Which ones are DIGITAL controllers? Which ones analogue? Whats the difference? Tell me I wanna race GPL most of all but precision is MOST important to me.
Shumi 22 Dec 1999 22:06 UTC#290809
Precision wise.... the best you'll get is from the Logitech at approximately 128 positioning resolution. Act Labs does however have a positioning resolution only slightly lower (and far better than Microsoft or Guillemot), and also supports the Shifter (which I use in GPL with great pleasure). As far as I'm concerned.... these are the ONLY 2 wheels worth considering at the present moment. You will still get exponentially more precise control from an analog controller and the PDPI gameport. The best in that field is the Act Labs RS, and the PDPI Gamecard/cartridge. It boasts the most stable reporting, the positioning resolution is rock solid at 256 (all axis), and there is NO taxation on the CPU (unless you consider 0.18% CPU usage taxation... compared to 50% on the standard gameport with some wheels). All FF USB wheels are "digital" (all USB wheels for that matter), and don't be tricked into thinking that the Microsoft Wheel and it's Electro-optic positioning mechanisms are more accurate... they aren't after you cut into the positioning resolution to combat the enormous amount of mechanical jitter that accompanies such internals. Not to mention the brutal rachety feeling to it. Hope that helps :) Cheers, Shumi http://www.rs2league.com Karl Zosel <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:83rej9$eos$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (11 lines)> Guillemot? > Logitech? > Microsoft? > > Which ones are DIGITAL controllers? Which ones analogue? > Whats the difference? > Tell me > > I wanna race GPL most of all but precision is MOST important to me. > >
Zeke Varg 22 Dec 1999 23:58 UTC#290818
Are the Logitech pedals any good? I have read that they are the bad part! Shumi <[email hidden]> skrev i diskussionsgruppsmeddelandet:yXb84.69097$[email hidden]... > Precision wise.... the best you'll get is from the Logitech atapproximately > 128 positioning resolution. > > Act Labs does however have a positioning resolution only slightly lower(and > far better than Microsoft or Guillemot), and also supports the Shifter > (which I use in GPL with great pleasure). > > As far as I'm concerned.... these are the ONLY 2 wheels worth consideringat > the present moment. You will still get exponentially more precise control > from an analog controller and the PDPI gameport. The best in that field is > the Act Labs RS, and the PDPI Gamecard/cartridge. It boasts the moststable > reporting, the positioning resolution is rock solid at 256 (all axis), and > there is NO taxation on the CPU (unless you consider 0.18% CPU usage > taxation... compared to 50% on the standard gameport with some wheels). > > All FF USB wheels are "digital" (all USB wheels for that matter), anddon't
Quoted text (29 lines)> be tricked into thinking that the Microsoft Wheel and it's Electro-optic > positioning mechanisms are more accurate... they aren't after you cut into > the positioning resolution to combat the enormous amount of mechanical > jitter that accompanies such internals. Not to mention the brutal rachety > feeling to it. > > Hope that helps :) > > Cheers, > > Shumi > http://www.rs2league.com > > > Karl Zosel <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:83rej9$eos$[email hidden]... > > Guillemot? > > Logitech? > > Microsoft? > > > > Which ones are DIGITAL controllers? Which ones analogue? > > Whats the difference? > > Tell me > > > > I wanna race GPL most of all but precision is MOST important to me. > > > > > >
speedracer 23 Dec 1999 04:42 UTC#290832
Personally, I originally tried the thrustmaster, I left it hooked up for a total of two hours before I hooked my old nascar pro back up. The force feedback implementation completley ruined the design of the wheel, which was pretty good. It was way way way to clunky for me, and I had lots of hardware glitches after the install. I bought the Wingman Formula Force about 2 months later, and it has been heaven. I think I've had it about 6 months now, with absolutely zero problems, and it plugs into the USB port besides, so I have no hardware conflicts. I couldn't ask for a better wheel. It is very smooth, and the software for adjusting the effects is easy to use, and it is easy to dial in just the right amount of force.(you can go from overdoing the force, to none at all, with lots of room inbetween.) Karl Zosel <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:83rej9$eos$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (11 lines)> Guillemot? > Logitech? > Microsoft? > > Which ones are DIGITAL controllers? Which ones analogue? > Whats the difference? > Tell me > > I wanna race GPL most of all but precision is MOST important to me. > >
Jalo 23 Dec 1999#510164
Correct me if I'm wrong, but I know the Logitech and the "Ferrari" wheel are anolog, they use standard pots. I'm not so sure about the Microsoft, it might be digital. I own the Logitech FF, and it's great. I'm not sure about all that resolution stuff your talking about, but the logitech is very accurate.
Jalo 23 Dec 1999#510165
The pedals on the Logitech do require awhile to get used to. But I actaully prefer them now that I've gotten used to them. They seem to be better suited for people who drive with only one foot.
Well I have owned a V4 Force Feedback Interact Wheel since last Christmas, recently I decided to purchase the Act Labs Force RS wheel. I thought the USB and shifter additions looked interesting. When I received them I immediately removed the InterAct V4 and installed the Act Labs Force RS with Shifter through the USB port. I was highly dissappointed in the feedback "feel" compared to the Act Labs wheel. Other than that the fit and finish of the Act Labs RS is superb. The shifter worked superb. The gas and brake pedals are superb. I feel the InterAct V4 software interface is much better and easier to program. After keeping the Act Labs Force RS for about a week and dealing with their superb tech support I was forced to return their Force RS wheel. I really wanted to keep it just because of the USB and Shifter features, But the InterAct V4 beats it hands down in actual game play enjoyment The bumps (rough roads) feel like bumps. The slides like slides, Crashes like crashes, engine rumble like an engine rumbling ect. ect. I was ready to trade off the Interact V4 for the new RS Force but I couldn't do it. The InterAct V4 wheel has spoiled me. Until a wheel comes along that has at least equal to performance in force feedback I have to remain satisfied with this simple but very gratifying wheel.
Shumi 23 Dec 1999#510167
Just because wheels use potentiometers does not make them "analog". The USB chip will have an A->D (analog to digital) conversion onboard the design (in the chip itself, or separatly). Therefor the signal coming out of the wheel is digital. This is the case with all USB since you are sending digital only signals through there. So I guess the m***of the story is: The mechanical method of determining the position of the wheel has little to do with whether it's digital. It's the method in which you report the information to the computer that counts. It's when you send analog signals to the computer to "comprehend" for you, that you run into taxation on the system, and the fact that the Standard Gameport is time-based only increases that taxation exponentially. You save a lot of time and taxation by translating the signals to digital onboard the controller itself (hence why every controller manufacturer is desperatly converting their product lines to USB... including Microsoft and their "digital technology"...) It's a common error, and don't feel bad for thinking pots = analog. FYI, Shumi
You say you are using the RS Shifter with GPL. Im assuming you mean you are using it in legacy mode? If not, I would love to know how you got GPL to support the free shifting. Scott PA-Scott Powersims.com -- Scott B. Husted ICQ# 4395450
Shumi 23 Dec 1999#510169
Yes Scott, I use the Shifter in Legacy mode until Papy realizes it is an idea peripheral for the game. Most racing nowadays uses sequential shifting, but the shifter offers a nice "immersiveness" in most, since most dio not employ paddle shifters, but rather a legacy style shifter. Still not sure what Papy is waiting for personally. It's too easy to implement into the game, and is an ideal addition for GPL particularly. Cheers, Shumi http://www.rs2league.com
Shumi, I tried starting a 'campaign' for RS Shifter support in GPL at Powersims.com <VBG> So I ask again... Anyone who owns a Force RS Wheel and RS Shifter combination to email Sierra/Papy and ask for support of the RS Shifter. Hell, even if you DON'T own this combo.. email them anyways! <VBG> Scott PA-Scott Powersims.com -- Scott B. Husted ICQ# 4395450
Ian Parker 23 Dec 1999#510171
Potentiometers, by definition are analogue devices, this is then converted to a digital signal for USB devices. This is fine when the pots are in good condition but when they start wearing out (as all devices that rely on moving contacts will) the signal to the A > D converter will be unstable therefore the outgoing signal will also be unstable. As for the optical sensors in the MSFF wheel they do not rely on contact of moving parts, therefore will not wear and will always give a stable signal to the gameport (maybe USB when they get around to it) As for going on about positioning resolution, it has plenty for what I require plus has no vagueness in its positioning as an analogue pot will have (Analogue pots are affected by heat dust etc...) The MSFF may have a higher CPU usage than many analogue wheels but I really don't notice it in the real world. So when you are looking for pots for your Logitech (or whatever wheel you have that uses analogue pots) I'll still be racing with optical sensor accuracy using my Microsoft wheel ;) -- Ian Parker UKGPL League [link lost in import] [link lost in import] -- > Just because wheels use potentiometers does not make them "analog". The USB > chip will have an A->D (analog to digital) conversion onboard the design (in > the chip itself, or separatly). Therefor the signal coming out of the wheel > is digital. This is the case with all USB since you are sending digital only > signals through there. > So I guess the m***of the story is: The mechanical method of determining > the position of the wheel has little to do with whether it's digital. It's > the method in which you report the information to the computer that counts. > It's when you send analog signals to the computer to "comprehend" for you, > that you run into taxation on the system, and the fact that the Standard > Gameport is time-based only increases that taxation exponentially. You save > a lot of time and taxation by translating the signals to digital onboard the > controller itself (hence why every controller manufacturer is desperatly > converting their product lines to USB... including Microsoft and their > "digital technology"...) > It's a common error, and don't feel bad for thinking pots = analog. > FYI, > Shumi > > > All FF USB wheels are "digital" (all USB wheels for that matter), and > > don't > > > be tricked into thinking that the Microsoft Wheel and it's Electro-optic > > > positioning mechanisms are more accurate... they aren't after you cut > into > > > the positioning resolution to combat the enormous amount of mechanical > > > jitter that accompanies such internals. Not to mention the brutal > rachety > > > feeling to it. > > Correct me if I'm wrong, but I know the Logitech and the "Ferrari" wheel > are > > anolog, they use standard pots. > > I'm not so sure about the Microsoft, it might be digital. > > I own the Logitech FF, and it's great. I'm not sure about all that > > resolution stuff your talking about, but the logitech is very accurate.
Shumi 23 Dec 1999#510172
If only this were the case. Unfortunately the Electro-optical sensors are susceptible to dust interference etc. that will also interrupt the positioning information. This is just a fact of life. True they will not "wear" like potentiometers do (another fact of life), but I emplore you to ask Microsoft why they have 9 bits of information coming into their processor, and only 6 bits coming out the other end to the computer. This is because they have to due to the enormous amount of "mechanical jitter" these electro-optical sensors produce. The time it takes the USB chip or separate A->D converters to translate the analog signal into digital information is considerably shorter than the amount of positioning data the computer is requesting. Therefor... there is absolutely NOTHING wrong with using analog pots and translating the information into digital bits. In fact... the potentiometers are accompanied by substantially less mechanical jitter than electro-optical sensors, making potentiometers a better solution at this point in time. You have to remember... JITTERING is the enemy! It's how you deal with the jitter that governs the performance of the wheel/joystick overall. I am sure that you are very happy with your MS wheel, and I am glad this is the case. However, I cannot allow others to recommend the MS wheel based on it's technical short comings. I used to think my Nascar Pro wheel was Da Bomb for the longest time.... until I tried the Act Labs RS w/PDPI gameport.... then I realized what I had been mising all along. Full 256 positioning resolution (every degree of turn accounted for), no jitters whatsoever (the PDPI filtering algorithm is brilliant), and I knocked full seconds off my lap times as a result. To say that the MS wheel functions great is very subjective and opinion, but it's technical merits are fact, and fall very short of the competition in ALL areas. There ARE better out there... I suggest the Logi or the Act Labs F-RS based on their technical merits and overall pleasure of driving (in my experience). Just my 2 cents (which is worth 1 in 2 years). Cheers, Shumi http://www.rs2league.com > Potentiometers, by definition are analogue devices, this is then converted > to a digital signal for USB devices. This is fine when the pots are in good > condition but when they start wearing out (as all devices that rely on > moving contacts will) the signal to the A > D converter will be unstable > therefore the outgoing signal will also be unstable. > As for the optical sensors in the MSFF wheel they do not rely on contact of > moving parts, therefore will not wear and will always give a stable signal > to the gameport (maybe USB when they get around to it) > As for going on about positioning resolution, it has plenty for what I > require plus has no vagueness in its positioning as an analogue pot will > have (Analogue pots are affected by heat dust etc...) > The MSFF may have a higher CPU usage than many analogue wheels but I really
Quoted text (25 lines)> don't notice it in the real world. > So when you are looking for pots for your Logitech (or whatever wheel you > have that uses analogue pots) I'll still be racing with optical sensor > accuracy using my Microsoft wheel ;) > -- > Ian Parker > UKGPL League > [link lost in import] > [link lost in import] > -- > > Just because wheels use potentiometers does not make them "analog". The > USB > > chip will have an A->D (analog to digital) conversion onboard the design > (in > > the chip itself, or separatly). Therefor the signal coming out of the > wheel > > is digital. This is the case with all USB since you are sending digital > only > > signals through there. > > So I guess the m***of the story is: The mechanical method of
determining > > the position of the wheel has little to do with whether it's digital. It's > > the method in which you report the information to the computer that > counts. > > It's when you send analog signals to the computer to "comprehend" for you,
Quoted text (19 lines)> > that you run into taxation on the system, and the fact that the Standard > > Gameport is time-based only increases that taxation exponentially. You > save > > a lot of time and taxation by translating the signals to digital onboard > the > > controller itself (hence why every controller manufacturer is desperatly > > converting their product lines to USB... including Microsoft and their > > "digital technology"...) > > It's a common error, and don't feel bad for thinking pots = analog. > > FYI, > > Shumi > > > > All FF USB wheels are "digital" (all USB wheels for that matter),
and > > > don't > > > > be tricked into thinking that the Microsoft Wheel and it's > Electro-optic > > > > positioning mechanisms are more accurate... they aren't after you cut > > into > > > > the positioning resolution to combat the enormous amount of mechanical > > > > jitter that accompanies such internals. Not to mention the brutal > > rachety > > > > feeling to it. > > > Correct me if I'm wrong, but I know the Logitech and the "Ferrari" wheel > > are > > > anolog, they use standard pots. > > > I'm not so sure about the Microsoft, it might be digital. > > > I own the Logitech FF, and it's great. I'm not sure about all that > > > resolution stuff your talking about, but the logitech is very accurate.
Shumi 24 Dec 1999#510365
Hehe..... don't forget to send Act Labs your consulting fee invoice after it's done ;) Kiddin of course... but it would be pretty neat to have full support in GPL... Cheers, Shumi http://www.rs2league.com P.S. Scott.... what ever happened to posting my link on your site?
No brutal rachety feel to the MSFF I own.. very smooth and precise feeling. Also no framerate hit either, actually since moving over to DirectX 7.0a my framerates have improved over those I was getting when using my old non-ff wheel. There seem to be so many different opinions on the various wheels out there that I think it really is a case of trying as many of them as you can and keeping the one that works best for you. Regards Peter Hooper > Precision wise.... the best you'll get is from the Logitech at approximately > 128 positioning resolution. > Act Labs does however have a positioning resolution only slightly lower (and > far better than Microsoft or Guillemot), and also supports the Shifter > (which I use in GPL with great pleasure). > As far as I'm concerned.... these are the ONLY 2 wheels worth considering at > the present moment. You will still get exponentially more precise control > from an analog controller and the PDPI gameport. The best in that field is > the Act Labs RS, and the PDPI Gamecard/cartridge. It boasts the most stable > reporting, the positioning resolution is rock solid at 256 (all axis), and > there is NO taxation on the CPU (unless you consider 0.18% CPU usage > taxation... compared to 50% on the standard gameport with some wheels). > All FF USB wheels are "digital" (all USB wheels for that matter), and don't
Quoted text (25 lines)> be tricked into thinking that the Microsoft Wheel and it's Electro-optic > positioning mechanisms are more accurate... they aren't after you cut into > the positioning resolution to combat the enormous amount of mechanical > jitter that accompanies such internals. Not to mention the brutal rachety > feeling to it. > Hope that helps :) > Cheers, > Shumi > http://www.rs2league.com > > Guillemot? > > Logitech? > > Microsoft? > > Which ones are DIGITAL controllers? Which ones analogue? > > Whats the difference? > > Tell me > > I wanna race GPL most of all but precision is MOST important to me.
ronli.. 25 Dec 1999#510513
I just got my 4 year old the V4, plus Monster Truck Madness 2. Does anyone know where I can get a config file for the V4 & MTM2? Thanks...Ron... > Well I have owned a V4 Force Feedback Interact Wheel since last Christmas, > recently > I decided to purchase the Act Labs Force RS wheel. I thought the USB and > shifter additions looked interesting. > When I received them I immediately removed the InterAct V4 and installed the > Act Labs Force RS with Shifter through the USB port. > I was highly dissappointed in the feedback "feel" compared to the Act Labs > wheel. Other than that the fit and finish of the Act Labs RS is superb. The > shifter worked superb. The gas and brake pedals are superb. I feel the > InterAct V4 software interface is much better and easier to program. After > keeping the Act Labs Force RS for about a week and dealing with their superb > tech support I was forced to return their Force RS wheel. I really wanted to > keep it just because of the USB and Shifter features, But the InterAct V4 > beats it hands down in actual game play enjoyment The bumps (rough roads) > feel like bumps. The slides like slides, Crashes like crashes, engine rumble > like an engine rumbling ect. ect. > I was ready to trade off the Interact V4 for the new RS Force but I couldn't > do it. The InterAct V4 wheel has spoiled me. Until a wheel comes along that
Quoted text (13 lines)> has at least equal to performance in force feedback I have to remain > satisfied with this simple but very gratifying wheel. > > Guillemot? > > Logitech? > > Microsoft? > > Which ones are DIGITAL controllers? Which ones analogue? > > Whats the difference? > > Tell me > > I wanna race GPL most of all but precision is MOST important to me.
Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
Karl Zosel 26 Dec 1999#510674
What do you mean with LEGACY MODE? And what are the consequences? Karl
Shumi 26 Dec 1999#510675
Hi again Karl, Legacy mode simply means that you can only sift sequentially. The RS-Shifter comes with a "Hi-Low" plate that allows you instant support for every game made to date. Meaning of course that you shift forwards for down, and back for up (in gears).... just like paddles. There are no disadvantages to the system since the Shifter simply assumes button controls from the wheel. By default the 3 and 4th gear assume the paddle shifter functions. So the game always just assumes the shifter as the mode of shifting correctly sequentially (and you lose the functionability of the paddles in the process since the Shifter "assumes" their control). Should the game support it... you can assign certain Shifter positions for certain gears in a game... So theoretically... you could assign 1st and 2nd as those exact gears... but assign 5th & 6th as 3rd and 4th. It nakes NASCAR and GPL support very interesting and admittedly exciting as fasr as "Full Immersiveness" goes since you could theoretically have ultimate control on Gear placement. I know that racing with RC2K with full support to customize gears made it interesting and even a bit ***ive considering the game sucked as a whole in many areas. I use it a lot, even though I am adimittedly a bit slower with it. But I have more fun and my times are prety close to real world times which brings me back to realism as a whole. It simply feels more real as a whole. Cheers, Shumi [link lost in import] (and another one soon ;])
GTX_SlotCar 27 Dec 1999#510832
Ron, MTM2 has support for 8 buttons. You probably don't need a config file for it. Slot
Quoted text (55 lines)> I just got my 4 year old the V4, plus Monster Truck Madness 2. Does > anyone know where I can get a config file for the V4 & MTM2? > Thanks...Ron... > > Well I have owned a V4 Force Feedback Interact Wheel since last > Christmas, > > recently > > I decided to purchase the Act Labs Force RS wheel. I thought the USB > and > > shifter additions looked interesting. > > When I received them I immediately removed the InterAct V4 and > installed the > > Act Labs Force RS with Shifter through the USB port. > > I was highly dissappointed in the feedback "feel" compared to the Act > Labs > > wheel. Other than that the fit and finish of the Act Labs RS is > superb. The > > shifter worked superb. The gas and brake pedals are superb. I feel the > > InterAct V4 software interface is much better and easier to program. > After > > keeping the Act Labs Force RS for about a week and dealing with their > superb > > tech support I was forced to return their Force RS wheel. I really > wanted to > > keep it just because of the USB and Shifter features, But the > InterAct V4 > > beats it hands down in actual game play enjoyment The bumps (rough > roads) > > feel like bumps. The slides like slides, Crashes like crashes, engine > rumble > > like an engine rumbling ect. ect. > > I was ready to trade off the Interact V4 for the new RS Force but I > couldn't > > do it. The InterAct V4 wheel has spoiled me. Until a wheel comes > along that > > has at least equal to performance in force feedback I have to remain > > satisfied with this simple but very gratifying wheel. > > > Guillemot? > > > Logitech? > > > Microsoft? > > > Which ones are DIGITAL controllers? Which ones analogue? > > > Whats the difference? > > > Tell me > > > I wanna race GPL most of all but precision is MOST important to me. > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > Before you buy.
Scott it would greatly help if you included a link to email Pappy, thx, JeremyDeal
I completely agree with the above. Act-Labs have the FF wheel technology down as far as im concerned. I have heard too many negative reports from the MSFF users (these are people who have had different wheels), too many negatives to even consider recommending one to a friend. However the only bad reports I have ever heard about the Act-Labs RS is that it doesnt translate only the very lightest of FF signals due to its tight belt. However to be fair, all have said this gets problems gets much better if not dissapearing with time as the belt starts to set into its natural stretching (which is why it comes so tight from the factory in the first place). Also Act-Labs has the most powerfull motor so if you want the wheel to jerk outta your hand when you hit the wall go ahead, however I dont quite like it that high. Good thing is you can always turn-down the force if its too much - but you will never be able to turn up other wheels to match its power. Even without mentioning that you can add a kick-***shifter that blows the balls off everything else in its price range (it even comes with different plates, ie: You want a six speed? Just change the plate!, You want a 2-speed? 5-speed, etc? Just change the plate again) id HIGHLY recommend a Act-Labs RS FF wheel. Even without mentioning that it has separate "Engines" you can switch out to use the wheel with your Play Station, N64, yadda yadda, or even to convert the wheel to USB for all you USB-happy folk..... Without either the shifter OR the separate engine feature, id recommend this wheel. The fact that you can add the fore-mentioned just goes to show that that ACT-LABS has done their homework & this wheel isnt just another "Gimmick", but rather the best wheel out there. > >As for the optical sensors in the MSFF wheel they do not rely on contact of > > moving parts, therefore will not wear and will always give a stable signal
Quoted text (8 lines)> > to the gameport (maybe USB when they get around to it) > If only this were the case. Unfortunately the Electro-optical sensors are > susceptible to dust interference etc. that will also interrupt the > positioning information. This is just a fact of life. True they will not > "wear" like potentiometers do (another fact of life), but I emplore you to > ask Microsoft why they have 9 bits of information coming into their > processor, and only 6 bits coming out the other end to the computer. This
is > because they have to due to the enormous amount of "mechanical jitter" these > electro-optical sensors produce. > The time it takes the USB chip or separate A->D converters to translate the > analog signal into digital information is considerably shorter than the > amount of positioning data the computer is requesting. Therefor... there is > absolutely NOTHING wrong with using analog pots and translating the > information into digital bits. In fact... the potentiometers are accompanied > by substantially less mechanical jitter than electro-optical sensors, making > potentiometers a better solution at this point in time. You have to > remember... JITTERING is the enemy! It's how you deal with the jitter that > governs the performance of the wheel/joystick overall. > I am sure that you are very happy with your MS wheel, and I am glad this is > the case. However, I cannot allow others to recommend the MS wheel based on
Quoted text (8 lines)> it's technical short comings. I used to think my Nascar Pro wheel was Da > Bomb for the longest time.... until I tried the Act Labs RS w/PDPI > gameport.... then I realized what I had been mising all along. Full 256 > positioning resolution (every degree of turn accounted for), no jitters > whatsoever (the PDPI filtering algorithm is brilliant), and I knocked full > seconds off my lap times as a result. > To say that the MS wheel functions great is very subjective and opinion,
but > it's technical merits are fact, and fall very short of the competition in > ALL areas. There ARE better out there... I suggest the Logi or the Act Labs > F-RS based on their technical merits and overall pleasure of driving (in my
Quoted text (13 lines)> experience). > Just my 2 cents (which is worth 1 in 2 years). > Cheers, > Shumi > [link lost in import] > > Potentiometers, by definition are analogue devices, this is then
converted
Quoted text (8 lines)> > to a digital signal for USB devices. This is fine when the pots are in > good > > condition but when they start wearing out (as all devices that rely on > > moving contacts will) the signal to the A > D converter will be unstable > > therefore the outgoing signal will also be unstable. > > As for the optical sensors in the MSFF wheel they do not rely on contact > of > > moving parts, therefore will not wear and will always give a stable
signal
Quoted text (8 lines)> > to the gameport (maybe USB when they get around to it) > > As for going on about positioning resolution, it has plenty for what I > > require plus has no vagueness in its positioning as an analogue pot will > > have (Analogue pots are affected by heat dust etc...) > > The MSFF may have a higher CPU usage than many analogue wheels but I > really > > don't notice it in the real world. > > So when you are looking for pots for your Logitech (or whatever wheel
you
Quoted text (13 lines)> > have that uses analogue pots) I'll still be racing with optical sensor > > accuracy using my Microsoft wheel ;) > > -- > > Ian Parker > > UKGPL League > > [link lost in import] > > [link lost in import] > > -- > > > Just because wheels use potentiometers does not make them "analog".
The > > USB > > > chip will have an A->D (analog to digital) conversion onboard the design > > (in > > > the chip itself, or separatly). Therefor the signal coming out of the > > wheel > > > is digital. This is the case with all USB since you are sending digital
Quoted text (13 lines)> > only > > > signals through there. > > > So I guess the m***of the story is: The mechanical method of > determining > > > the position of the wheel has little to do with whether it's digital. > It's > > > the method in which you report the information to the computer that > > counts. > > > It's when you send analog signals to the computer to "comprehend" for > you, > > > that you run into taxation on the system, and the fact that the
Standard > > > Gameport is time-based only increases that taxation exponentially. You > > save > > > a lot of time and taxation by translating the signals to digital onboard > > the > > > controller itself (hence why every controller manufacturer is desperatly
Quoted text (34 lines)> > > converting their product lines to USB... including Microsoft and their > > > "digital technology"...) > > > It's a common error, and don't feel bad for thinking pots = analog. > > > FYI, > > > Shumi > > > > > All FF USB wheels are "digital" (all USB wheels for that matter), > and > > > > don't > > > > > be tricked into thinking that the Microsoft Wheel and it's > > Electro-optic > > > > > positioning mechanisms are more accurate... they aren't after you > cut > > > into > > > > > the positioning resolution to combat the enormous amount of > mechanical > > > > > jitter that accompanies such internals. Not to mention the brutal > > > rachety > > > > > feeling to it. > > > > Correct me if I'm wrong, but I know the Logitech and the "Ferrari" > wheel > > > are > > > > anolog, they use standard pots. > > > > I'm not so sure about the Microsoft, it might be digital. > > > > I own the Logitech FF, and it's great. I'm not sure about all that > > > > resolution stuff your talking about, but the logitech is very > accurate.
GTX_SlotCar 31 Jan 2000#517230
The Ferrari wheel is digital, not analog. Use of pots has no bearing on this. Slot >> All FF USB wheels are "digital" (all USB wheels for that matter), and >don't >> be tricked into thinking that the Microsoft Wheel and it's Electro-optic >> positioning mechanisms are more accurate... they aren't after you cut into >> the positioning resolution to combat the enormous amount of mechanical >> jitter that accompanies such internals. Not to mention the brutal rachety >> feeling to it. >Correct me if I'm wrong, but I know the Logitech and the "Ferrari" wheel are >anolog, they use standard pots. >I'm not so sure about the Microsoft, it might be digital. >I own the Logitech FF, and it's great. I'm not sure about all that >resolution stuff your talking about, but the logitech is very accurate.

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy