Bruce Kennewell <[email hidden]> wrote:
: Observations? Racing human drivers introduces a high level of
: unpredictability and naturally, after racing AI for 18 months, this provides
: a freshness to the sim.
: However, another form of unpredictability I can do without: wondering where
: in God's name a car in front of or behind me is going to be every
: split-second as it dances it's way across the track, warping left-right and
: centre. I can certainly do without disconnections too.
This is because you're racing with a 600ms ping - that's going to
cause loads of warping and disconnects. (Think about it - how difficult
would real racing be if you could only see a prediction of where the
other guy "might be in 1/2 a seconds time"). I imagine it's pretty
hard to find a good low ping race to connect to down there
in oz - especially with a lot of cars entered. It's worth it
when you do... A very different expereince to racing the AI - you
_know_ the AI will brake in the same place 9 laps in 10 and you _know_
that the AI will avoid you 9 times in 10 if you cut inside forcefully
enough.
--
Richard G. Clegg Only the mind is waving
Networks and Non-Linear Dynamics Group
Dept. of Mathematics, Uni. of York
www: http://manor.york.ac.uk/top.html
Does a high ping ruin online GPL racing?
Bruce Kennewell's first online GPL races prompted debate about latency. Ron Ayton insisted pings up to 600 ms work fine with stable connections, while Phillip McNelley said such pings were usually hopeless from Australia. Papyrus's Grant Reeve said high latency causes warping rather than disconnects, and others advised limiting modems to V.34.
With Grant Reeve (Papyrus)
Automated summary.
Oh, the ping was fine....one of the hosts I visited incurred a ping of
around 750 but the Q and S bars were rock steady and any warping was
minimal. Don't worry, Ron....I understand the "ping" aspect. I have
"played" on-line before....just not with GPL. :-)
I must admit to not touching the DUN settings so perhaps I should look at
tweaking that area. Modem is 56k.
Thanks for the advice, Ron. Much appreciated.
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
Ron Ayton <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:01bf7bf4$7466e400$0100007f@ronayton...
> Hi Bruce,
>
> I just wanted to tell you that what Phillip is saying here, regarding a
> 600 ping would be hopeless, is total, total rubbbish.
> (no offence meant Phillip)
> I am a proud member of the GMSS GPL league, which is based in the USA
> and has been in operation ever since GPL was released.
> Our host's locations vary across America, even as far up as Canada, and
> my connections and quality of racing on-line from Australia has always
> been excellent with pings from .400 up to and including .650 or so...
>
> There is so much false information being blasted around on RAS and
> other places, about what ping will work with GPL and 99.9% of it is
> totally wrong..
> Let me first say, that a lower ping is better, that is obvious, but a
> ping of up to .600 can be absolutely PERFECT in GPL for the F2 or F3
> cars, IF you have a good quality connection..
> In actuality, pings of up to .750 can produce good racing in F3, but it
> is not generally desirable to have pings over .600
> In F1, i have found that pings of up to .550 will work reasonably well
> as long as quality is good.
> Regarding quality, my quality to the hosts in the GMSS league, is
> usually around the .990 to .999 mark and i DO connect and race with the
> GMSS league every week, with pings around the .450 to .600 area, with
> hardly ever a warp of a problem, as i have been doing for the last 2
> years.
> The biggest problem is discoes, not warping...
> That is not brought about by a latency of .600, but is usually the
> result of packets being lost through bad routers, or having your
> packets re-routed through different servers and GPL doesn't like the
> delay or the lost packets that are introduced as the routers change or
> go bad.
>
> If any members of the GMSS league read this post Bruce, i am sure they
> will confirm what i am saying here.
> I would say that 99.9% of the time when i connect to one of our hosts
> in the GMSS, that i DO NOT warp at all, in fact i will go as far to say
> that my connection, as far as not warping and being solid on the track,
> is usually as good as the guys in our league that have sub 100 pings.
> In F1, i used to have occasional warping problems with pings of up to
> .600, but these days i don't run F1 anyway, so the ping times (latency)
> from Australia to USA are absolutely perfect for F2 & F3 racing, which
> is where my love with GPL lies anyway.
>
> One thought Bruce, what speed are you connecting at, and do you have
> error correction and data compression turned off. ?
> I am with BigPond, i have restricted my 56k modem speed to 26400 and i
> have error correction and data compression turned off, so give that a
> try before you give up in disgust. :)
>
> Finally, don't EVER believe any crap you hear about how pings of up to
> 600 will not work with GPL, because it is simply not true.
> Quality is far more important than latency in GPL on-line.
> The GPL team at Papy have done an excellent job with the on-line code
> and how well GPL handles latencys of up to .600.
> If you need a hand or want more info, get in touch with me Bruce.
>
> Regards,
> Ron Ayton
> Melbourne, Australia
>
>
>
> Phillip McNelley <[email hidden]> wrote in article
> <[email hidden]>...
> > >Well.....I've had my first tastes of racing against human opponents
> and
> > >cannot say that I was overly impressed by the experience. ...
> >
> > The .600 ping would be hopeless. You're lucky to even get connected
> at
> > that ping as many servers would be set up to reject you at once.
> >
> > See the ASRG at http://www.powerup.com.au/~philmak/ASRG.htm for sim
> > racing online in Australia.
> >
> > We have a GPL comp coming up in Mid-March.
> >
> > Unfortunaly you've caught us between servers. Our previous high
> > bandwidth servers are offline and the new ones dont come online til
> > March. But even so, you'll find a few ofthe members hosting on good
> > servers from time to time in the intrim.
> >
> > Phillip McNelley
> >
-----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==----------
http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World!
------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----
On Sun, 20 Feb 2000 15:05:37 +1100, "Bruce Kennewell"
<[email hidden]> wrote:
I started online racing not so long ago and for the first few weeks I
never managed to have a decent race due to a number of different
problems. But slowly but surely I found which times of the day I can
get a better connection, and I can tell you that with less latency,
and no packet loss, is a completely different experience.
The one problem that I can't seem to be able to even minimize is
being disconnected, in my view that is the most frustrating aspect of
online racing. I have been disconnect countless times and most of them
right at the beginning of the race or on the last lap, seems there is
a pattern here.
But apart from that I have had the best races ever online, and some of
them I was lucky enough not to be disconnect as soon as I cross the
finish line, enabling me to record it for later viewing.
I have a 56k modem and will be getting an ISDN in the next few months,
and wonder if i would still experience such disconnections problems,
which seem to me are a GPL bug.
Mauricio.
Quoted text (43 lines)
>Well.....I've had my first tastes of racing against human opponents and >cannot say that I was overly impressed by the experience. >First adventure was Osterreichring; full-on GP cars and there were five >starters, which dropped to three when the flag dropped. I was last on the >grid and made sure that I kept my start to a gentle lift-off rather than a >full-on shuttle launch: I didn't want to risk stuffing anyone into the >wall. > >Everything was fine...the guy in the lead shot away into the distance and I >tailed the second-stringer for a lap, seeing what effect the latency (~ 600) >had on him. Apart from some odd "weaving" it was okay but when I tried to >pass him into turn one he slowed so much that I braked heavily, lost it and >ended up on the grass! No matter....I then enjoyed the chase, caught and >passed him (and he deliberately pulled to the left to leave room to >overtake.....nicely done) and I then got disconnected on he last lap!! > >No problems.......next attempt was Zandvoort (I LOVE this track!) in F2 >cars. Fifteen laps and there were five or six starters. Again I was last on >the grid. Flag drops and once again I kept clear of any start-line >shenanigans and headed into the first turn tailing the field. Suddenly I've >moved up a place as a car goes off, then another place is taken as another >car warps all over the place. At the end of lap one I'm in second place and >at the end of lap two the lead car pulls into the pits and I'm leading, with >a fifteen-second lead!! Slow and steady becomes the pattern for the rest of >the event. >After 12 laps I have a 6 second lead over second place and >suddenly.....ZAP!....disconnected! > >Observations? Racing human drivers introduces a high level of >unpredictability and naturally, after racing AI for 18 months, this provides >a freshness to the sim. >However, another form of unpredictability I can do without: wondering where >in God's name a car in front of or behind me is going to be every >split-second as it dances it's way across the track, warping left-right and >centre. I can certainly do without disconnections too. > >However, those gripes aside, I enjoyed the experience but I cannot say that >it (racing on the Internet) is better than sex. > >But having said that, I would like to have a LAN setup (and this has been >mooted by a group of acquaintances) with 20 drivers in the one room. A full >weekend of racing......Two one-hour practice sessions each morning with the >full, GP length race, each afternoon. Now that WOULD be something!I agree. You better have a .600 ping and no packetloss than a fluctuating
.300 connection with 15% packetloss. Less warping, and less chance of
disconnections.
Ron Ayton <[email hidden]> schreef in artikel
<01bf7bf4$7466e400$0100007f@ronayton>...
Quoted text (12 lines)
> Hi Bruce, > > I just wanted to tell you that what Phillip is saying here, regarding a > 600 ping would be hopeless, is total, total rubbbish. > (no offence meant Phillip) > I am a proud member of the GMSS GPL league, which is based in the USA > and has been in operation ever since GPL was released. > Our host's locations vary across America, even as far up as Canada, and > my connections and quality of racing on-line from Australia has always > been excellent with pings from .400 up to and including .650 or so... > > There is so much false information being blasted around on RAS andI had great raced at 700 ping and horrible warping at 350 ping.
ping isn't the only thing what makes a decent connection.
Jens
On Sun, 20 Feb 2000 16:46:51 GMT, [email hidden] (Phillip McNelley)
wrote:
>The .600 ping would be hopeless. You're lucky to even get connected at
>that ping as many servers would be set up to reject you at once.<snip>
---------------------------------------------
[email hidden]
Remove "NOSPAM" before using my email-address
Visit my webpage at http://members.xoom.com/JensSchu/ for some serious stuff concerning:
Radio controlled airplanes
Racing simulation, esp. GPL
Classic cars, esp. Morris Minor
>Well.....I've had my first tastes of racing against human opponents and
>cannot say that I was overly impressed by the experience. ...
The .600 ping would be hopeless. You're lucky to even get connected at
that ping as many servers would be set up to reject you at once.
See the ASRG at http://www.powerup.com.au/~philmak/ASRG.htm for sim
racing online in Australia.
We have a GPL comp coming up in Mid-March.
Unfortunaly you've caught us between servers. Our previous high
bandwidth servers are offline and the new ones dont come online til
March. But even so, you'll find a few ofthe members hosting on good
servers from time to time in the intrim.
Phillip McNelley
Ron Ayton <[email hidden]> wrote:
: Hi Bruce,
: I just wanted to tell you that what Phillip is saying here, regarding a
: 600 ping would be hopeless, is total, total rubbbish.
: (no offence meant Phillip)
Well, the fact is that Bruce complained about warping... Your mileage
may vary but my experience, having spent an age tweaking everything I
can about my modem, is that racing with pings over 300 is a less
enjoyable experience.
Certainly you are correct that quality of connection is as or more
important than ping time but I fully stand by the statement that,
generally speaking, if I see a ping time above 400 I experience
considerable warping and occasional disconnects.
Bruce complained that his racing was spoiled by continual warping
and occasional disconnects. Draw your own conclusions.
--
Richard G. Clegg Only the mind is waving
Networks and Non-Linear Dynamics Group
Dept. of Mathematics, Uni. of York
www: http://manor.york.ac.uk/top.html
Thanks Kurt, a friend of mine also has big connection problems with
his 56k6 modem, I'll forward this message to him.
Andre
Hi Ron,
Yes what I said was a simplistic explanationn - but it is a general
rule of thumb as far as connecting to a high ping server from here in
Australia to the other side ofthe world.
Ususaly, from here, the reason you have a high ping is that you are
going through a lot of hops to the server. Every hop is a potential
weak point. True its not just the ping but a combination of things.
But from here, the same reason you are getting a high ping is also
likely to be the reason that the other parts of the equation are less
than optimal also.
You can have OK races with pings of up to 500 as long as the quality
is good and as long as you allow a bit for the lag. But having a 500
ping race with 7 hops and good quality is altobeather another thing
than a 500 ping race with 20 hops and occasional drops. The problem
with us is that nearly all connects to outside of Oz have more hops
than is usualy helpful.
My expierance with 500+ OS ping races is that they may be ok for a
period or short races but sooner or later you get the clock smashes
and/or warps and/or disconnects. There are just one or two ( or three
) exceptions to this with certian OS servers that must have
exceptionaly stable setups.
Not only this, but just connecting to a server at those pings can
lower the quality for everyone else on the server - which is exact;y
why many servers are ping # set to reject anyone over a more aceptable
figure. That's what the facility is there for.
Total rubbish ? This implies there is no truth in the concept at all.
I still stand by what I said. An OS 600 ping, for a varity or reasons,
will most likey be completely uesless unless you are happy to have
reatively short periods of OK racing dispursed with a lot of
irratating and frustration interuptions.
( If what you said is anything less than 100% perfect truth in every
respect can I call it total rubbish ? )
Cheers
Phillip McNelley
> This is because you're racing with a 600ms ping - that's going to
> cause loads of warping and disconnects.
I used to race GPL online back in late '98 from back in New Zealand,
I had 600-700ms latency usually, but I had a very stable connection,
and got booted much less rarely than a lot of other people with much
lower latency connections. High latency doesn't mean more disconnects,
it just means icky warping. I used to follow people around and wait
for them to fall off to make a pass, because due to warping their
cars would be taking up about 4 carwidths on the track :)
Bruce, you might want to check into websites and stuff that cover
ways of tweaking your modem online connection for *** play, there's
a lot of stuff you can do and combined altogether it will help your
latency and connection reliability.
Grant.
On Mon, 21 Feb 2000 21:06:40 +1100, "Bruce Kennewell"
Definitely do so, Bruce. A V.34 connection is far more
robust/stable than 56K. GPL only needs around 21k for a client, so
any speed above that is sufficient. Listen to Ron, he mostly knows
what he's talking about (lower ping is better, but high ping in itself
can be compensted for, for the most part).
"But in a way, fear is a big part of racing, because if there was
nothing to be frightened of, and no limit, any fool could get into
a motor car and racing would not exist as a sport." -- Jim Clark
Quoted text (7 lines)
>Oh, the ping was fine....one of the hosts I visited incurred a ping of >around 750 but the Q and S bars were rock steady and any warping was >minimal. Don't worry, Ron....I understand the "ping" aspect. I have >"played" on-line before....just not with GPL. :-) >I must admit to not touching the DUN settings so perhaps I should look at >tweaking that area. Modem is 56k.>Thanks Kurt, a friend of mine also has big connection problems with
>his 56k6 modem, I'll forward this message to him.
>Andre
yes, much appreciated- thanks
> Definitely do so, Bruce. A V.34 connection is far more
>robust/stable than 56K. GPL only needs around 21k for a client, so
>any speed above that is sufficient. Listen to Ron, he mostly knows
>what he's talking about (lower ping is better, but high ping in itself
>can be compensted for, for the most part).
This cannot be emphasized too much: *DO NOT* use a V.90 (56K)
connection ! The constant retrains will quite often mess up the
client-server synchronisation and get you booted from the server.
Configure a "second modem" in Windows with the init strings to
limit it to V.34 (33.6k) and use that to connect when playing GPL.
Richard.
--
Richard Bellavance Enter-Net Inc.
Phone: (450) 652-7189 #16
Systems Administrator/ (514) 990-1683 #16
Analyst-Programmer Fax: (450) 652-6973
What i said was 100% true Phillip..
Like i said, people can believe what they want, it's just that there is
too many connections problems related to latency, when in truth, bad
connections in GPL are caused by poor quality, bad routers, overtaxing
the cpu, the client not tuning his DUN settings, the host attempting to
allow too many on his server etc etc..
Believe what you like, but i have done extensive testing with GPL
on-line ever since it was released with hosts located all around the
world, and pings of up to .600 in F2 and F3 are absolutely perfect in
every way for GPL on-line, as long as quality is good.
There is no need to compensate for ping at .600 in F2 or F3, as i have
had literally hundreds of races, inches apart from clients in the USA
at pings of up to .600 in F2 and have done the same in F3 with pings of
up to .700
Also, the only way a poorly set up client can downgrade the performance
of other clients in a race, is if he is warping in and out of the field
of cars and making a hazard of himself.
I think you will find anyone that is doing that will disconnect
themselves through decency, or they will be disconnected anyway, if
their connections are that bad.
They cannot effect the other clients in any other way at all..
Like i said Phillip, you are totally wrong on the concept of thinking a
.600 ping is useless, but that is your opinion, i just hope that other
on-line enthusiasts are not discouraged by this false assumption you
have made.
I will agree with you that in F1, pings over .550 are not real good,
but before you actually disagree with me again, take a F2 or F3 car to
a high ping server and you will see what i mean.
I have seen these comments about pings a few times, and it is always
from the guys that do not have a good connection, or have not taken the
time to set up their DUN's properly.
Try a F2 or F3 race with a ping of around .550 to .650 sometime, and as
long as your quality is good, you will be surprised at the performance.
Personally i feel sorry for anyone who believes that a ping of up to
.600 is bad news for GPL, as it explains why there is not a lot more
Australian sim racers in overseas leagues.
False assumptions are bad news for GPL on-line. :)
Cheers,
Ron
Hi Richard,
Like i just replied to Phillip, you are welcome to come to any decision
you like when it comes to personal opinions, but as far as pings over
.400 in GPL being less than desirable for racing, that simply isn't
true.
That isn't just my opinion, by the way, but we have proven that pings
of up to .600 are perfect in F2 & F3 and likewise for pings of up to
550 in F1.
I am not going to try and dissuade you from what you believe Richard,
but if you are having problems at pings over .400, then there is still
something not setup right on your computer, or the hosts you were
connecting to were overtaxing their cpu's.
If you want help or information on tuning your DUN or improving your
connection for on-line racing, drop me a line and i will help you sort
it out a bit better.
Cheers,
Ron
Hi Kurt,
No problems at all about you re-posting that info..
If we can improve the quality and connections of drivers in on-line
GPL and educate a few on the problems that can be encountered and how
to fix them, then we are miles in front.
Like i said earlier, if anyone is having problems with warping or
generally would like help in setting up their connections, you are
welcome to drop me a line and i will try to help you sort it out.
I will add, that since i wrote that article, GPL 1.2 has been released,
so in general you will find the new Synch method works fine now with
GPL, so there should be no need to alter the Synch method.
Synch method 1 (the new method) works almost perfectly now, but i will
add that if you find you are having a lot of disco problems, even
though your quality and ping seem good, try using the old Synch method
"0" with a clock delay of 12.
I have found that with a couple of the servers i connect to on a
regular bassis in the states, that the old Synch method still works
better for me, but usually i leave it at the new method of 1.
Cheers,
Ron
> >: Hi Bruce,
> >: I just wanted to tell you that what Phillip is saying here, regarding a
> >: 600 ping would be hopeless, is total, total rubbbish.
> >: (no offence meant Phillip)
> > Well, the fact is that Bruce complained about warping... Your mileage
> >may vary but my experience, having spent an age tweaking everything I
Messrs.
> Pickett and Ayton). Since, like Bruce, I am starting to make more serious
> forays into on-line racing, I hauled it out.
** snip **
Quoted text (22 lines)
> >can about my modem, is that racing with pings over 300 is a less > >enjoyable experience. > > Certainly you are correct that quality of connection is as or more > >important than ping time but I fully stand by the statement that, > >generally speaking, if I see a ping time above 400 I experience > >considerable warping and occasional disconnects. > > Bruce complained that his racing was spoiled by continual warping > >and occasional disconnects. Draw your own conclusions. > >-- > >Richard G. Clegg Only the mind is waving > > Networks and Non-Linear Dynamics Group > > Dept. of Mathematics, Uni. of York > > www: http://manor.york.ac.uk/top.html > Hello, all -- > Since modems, pings, latency and so forth have come up again ... > Quite a while ago, I saved the mail pasted below (contributions from
Richard G Clegg wrote in message <88r7b7$4ka$[email hidden]>...
Hello, all --
Since modems, pings, latency and so forth have come up again ...
Quite a while ago, I saved the mail pasted below (contributions from Messrs.
Pickett and Ayton). Since, like Bruce, I am starting to make more serious
forays into on-line racing, I hauled it out.
Can I assume that going through the process below is still relevant and
helpful with GPL 1.2? (Sorry if that's an incredibly obvious questions, but
je ne parle pas "dun.")
Regards,
Kurt
All of the following snipped from earlier post ..........
Are you sick of those LPB (Low Ping Bastards :-) who keep braggin about
getting less than 100 ping???
Well.. don't dispair... :-)
I have been racing ONline since GPL came out.. and have found it pretty good
up until now.. BUT.. I have just found a way to make it better.. for me
I'm no ISP Trouble Shooter.. and don't know THAT much about networking and
Dial connections.. but his is what i have learned and discovered from GPL
online racing...
(for all those who have found this.. plz excuse.. I have just discovered
it.. and other need to know it too)
PING / Latency DOESN'T necessarily make for warp free racing.. My
understanding and experience is that you require a STABLE connection.. not
a "FAST" connection..
Most connection seem to be "suped-up" for bandwidth.. and not stable
throughput.. which is what GPL ( and probably other online games)
require.... This seems to make them more prone to Errors and fluctuations
in Flow...
Sooooo.. by decreasing the connection speed.. you lessen the chance of
such things.. and therefore make the connection more stable... A
connection that is more stable. .can take full advantage of the "prediction"
that is built into GPL
Take note of the QUALITY in the ALT + L function.. PING is NOT THAT
important... lower is better.. but QUALITY is the most important...
With my 56k V90 US Robotics modem.. I was getting about 177 Lat /Ping (same
thing) @ 967 Quality to the best server here in Australia (THANK YOU
TROY!!!! :-). Connection seemed quite good...
Then I took the advice of friends and tried different connection speeds..
It took a lot of mucking around with differnt strings.. but I eventually
got the following
26,400 bps conecction and got 23j0-240 Lat @ 1.000 - 995 Quality
The latency has gone up by about 50ping.. but the cars are now VERY
smooth.. (not far off LAN speed) The main differnce is the Quality....
The following is a post that Ron Ayton put here a few weeks ago (Hope you
don't mind Ron .. BTw.. thanx for your help..... it cover basically all
this..
==========================================================
Firstly, the DUN you use for the Internet is NOT suitable for on-line
gaming. It most likely would be using Data Compression, Error
Correction, Maximum FIFO Buffers and probably going as hard as your
poor little modem can peddle, or harder if i believe half of the tales
i hear about....
All of the above is VERY bad news for on-line gaming.
You should make up another DUN for on-line gaming, with Data
Compression and Error Correction turned OFF. Also, turn down the
maximum connect speed of your modem to 24000, 26400 or 28800 at a
maximum.
The quality of the lines in your area, will dictate the best speed for
you.
This can be done in the Modem Properties tab of your DUN for the
designated Modem. Read the booklet that comes with your modem for the
initialization strings you need.
NOTE:
Some people are under the mistaken belief that a slower connect speed
will take longer to get to the host, resulting in higher latencys
(pings) etc. This is totally false.!!!
The connection speed of your modem, is a false analogy, as the
connection speed only refers to how much bandwidth the modem is capable
of sending at any given time, NOT how fast it can send it.
Hence, the ammount of data that a GPL host requires from a client will
get to the host at exactly the same time, whether the client is using
26400 baud or 56000 baud, and 99.9% of the time, the 26400 baud rate
from the client will have a lot less errors and be more stable than
the 56000 baud's best effort, unless you are lucky enough to live in a
area where optical fibre abounds, all the way from you to the host,
which is very unlikely. :)
I only ever use a maximum of 26400 on-line with GPL, as the lines in my
area, leave a bit to be desired, but with my normal internet dun, i use
33 to 56k baud, and let the error correction fix any problems i
encounter, which is fine for surfing and general internet use etc.
(error correction is a definite no-no for gPL)
To make more than one DUN with different modem initialization strings,
you will need to go to the MODEMS in the control panel and ADD another
modem. This will not overwrite your present modem settings, but will
add another modem to the modems you have listed in the modem list. As
you add more modems to the list, Windows will simply add a #2 #3 #4
etc etc to the end of the modem name. That way you can set up as many
DUN's as you have modem names, each one with different initialization
strings.
Once you have your on-line DUNS and modem set up correctly, you will
actually find that disco's, error filled connections and high latency's
will simply become a bad memory...
NOTE:
The FIFO buffers should be set no higher than the 2nd mark from
the left, unfortunately these are global settings, so if you set them
at the 2nd setting from the left, that is where they will remain
regardless of which DUN you are using. I have not noticed any lesser
performance in surfing or downloading with the buffers set there
anyway, so i just leave them there all the time.
Make sure you turn Error Correction off, also turn off the Data
Compression and select Hardware Flow Control in you modem's properties
tab for the On-Line gaming DUN. If you are a paranoid type, as i am,
you could also add those commands to the extra settings in the modem
initialization string, just in case you don't trust windows to carry
out your wishes and let's face it, who trusts windows to do anything
right when it comes to gaming anyway..
I have included the following line for my US Robotics modem in my
On-Line Gaming DUN..
&F1&K0&M0&U10&N13
&F1 Resets modem to standard, in case windows messed it up.
&K0 Disables Data Compression, in case windows forgot.
&M0 Disables Error Correction, as per above scenario..
&U10 Sets the floor connect speed to 19200.
&N13 Sets the ceiling connect speed to 26400.
The above is an example for the US Robotics modem, different modems
will vary slightly in the initialization strings, so read your manual
for further details to achieve similiar results.
Secondly.. Windows in it's infinite wisdom sets up the Port settings
on the extra conservative side by default.
This needs to be changed manually.
To do this:
Go to the Control Panel, go to System, go to Device Manager, go to
Ports (com & lpt).
Select Com1 , go to Port Settings, and adjust the following to read as
follows:
Bits per second 115200
Data 8
Parity none
Stop Bits 1
Flow Control Hardware
Go to Advanced and adjust the FIFO Buffers so they are 1 mark from
the left side.
Do the same for Com Port 2.
The following topics, are relevant to the new CORE.INI file, that ships
with GPL 1.1
NOTE:
This file is called: COREINI.SAMPLE and must be re-named to: CORE.INI
before GPL 1.1 can make use of it.
It is located in the: SIERRA\GPL\ folder, after the GPL 1.1 patch has
been installed...
A couple of slight adjustments are needed to get the best out of the
new CORE.INI file.
Following, is a brief example of a couple of changes i made to my
CORE.INI file, to suit on-line play on VROC.
The parts you need to alter from the CORE.INI that ships with GPL1.1
are the two lines concerned with band width:
net_mdm_client_send =2 & net_mdm_server_send_every =2
Change both of those to 3, like below in the pasted example.
net_mdm_client_send_every = 3 ; Client packet freq on dialup
net_mdm_client_send_size = 84 ; Client packet size on dialup
net_mdm_server_send_every = 3 ; Server packet freq on dialup
net_mdm_server_send_size = 84 ; Server packet size on dialup
That is the standardized band settings that VROC uses, for clients
and hosts, and everyone running on VROC, should alter the relevant
lines to match the above criteria.
Also, for me, the new Synch method does not work well...
The best way to tell if the new synch method is working for you, is to
race on-line, and if you are noticing a lot of slow motion & speed-up
effects, then the new synch method is not working well for you.
The new synch method does not use the: clock_adj_delay = 4
line either, as that is disabled when the synch_method is set to 1.
I have changed the line:
synch_method =1 to synch_method = 0
(which re-enables the old version of synchronization)
By altering that line back to 0, GPL 1.1, uses the following line:
clock_adj_delay = 4 ; How often may client adjust clock?
The number of 4, did not work for me at all, so after much
experimenting with different values, both locally here in Australia,
and to overseas hosts, i settled for a value of: 16
eg: clock_adj_delay = 16 ; How often may client adjust clock?
That cured all my slow-mo problems, and 99 % of my warping problems.
Anything under 14, began to give me frame stuttering, so i left it at
16, which seems strange, as before with version 1.000 of GPL, the
default delay setting of 12, and even 10 seemd to work best.
However, with the new GPL 1.1, a clock setting of 16 seems to be much
more stable and stutter/warp free.
You may need to experiment with this line, to suit your own local and
overseas conditions, but generally, if you have good low pings to your
regular hosts, a value of 8 to 10, seems to work well.
If latency is an issue, then a higher value of 12 14 or 16, seems to do
a better job of keeping the client's computer in synchronization with
the hosting computer.
NOTE:
This line does not affect the hosting computer, or the other clients,
it is simply a localized client based instruction set.
The only way this line could affect the other clients and host, is if
you alter this value to some ridiculous ammount, which causes your own
computer to fall out of synchronization with the hosting computer at a
much larger rate, and then, the other clients would notice your car
disappearing (warping) around more than usual, however, this does not
affect the other clients in any other way.
NOTE:
Things may change for the better, when the patch for the patch is
released, in regards to what synch method we will end up using, but for
the moment, the older (original) version of: snych_method = 0 seems to
work best for the majority of us.
Hopefully when the patch for the patch is released, we can go back to
the new method: synch_method = 1 which should allow for a more
seamless adjustment of the timing, between the hosting and client's
computer.
NOTE:
GSB2 & VROC2, allows the setting up and use of the old synchronization
method in the joining screen, if you would rather do it from there,
than make the designated changes in your CORE.INI file...
Another line you may want to change is the line that says:
disable_modem = 0 ; Don't look for/use modems
If you change that line to:
disable_modem = 1 ; Don't look for/use modems
By disabling modem lookup, GPL 1.1, will start up a lot quicker..
This only affects the modem to modem dial-up playing between two
players, and will not affect GPL's Internet play....
The only other line you might need to alter, is the line:
alternate_ip_addr_lookup = 0 ; Find IP addresses another way
If GPL cannot find your ip address, to enable you to join on-line
races, change that line to 1..
eg:
alternate_ip_addr_lookup = 1 ; Find IP addresses another way
Finally, why do people insist on having to run at 1024x768 with all the
eye candy on for on-line racing. Frame rates DO matter as far as
warping and good on-line play go.
If you are not seeing 36fps in on-line play, then your CPU is being
taxed. Give your CPU a rest and turn down the resolution a bit, turn
off some eye candy untill you are seeing 36 fps or as close to it as
you can. You might be surprised at the difference it makes.
Amother thing to keep in mind as well is to not have back ground
programs running when you intend to play on-line.
Just to finish this novel off, Windows 98 is superior to Windows 95
when it comes to Networking, Serial Control, Internet functionability
DUN protocols and on-line gaming, so if all else fails, consider that
much dreaded upgrade. It may just make that final difference to having
a good connection or a so so connection..
If anyone who is having problems, would like any help in setting up
their duns, or modems etc for on-line play in GPL, then drop me a line
and i will try to offer assistance.
Cheers,
Ron
===================================================
Like I said.. this is common knowledge for some.. but for others this could
be a "Heaven sent" :-)
The Initialisation string I am using ATM is:
AT&F1&U10&N13&K0s32=98
It is for a US Robotics Sportster Flash (V90 upgraded) Modem.. I can't
garantee it will work with anything else. but has made my racnig much
better.
Also cars dissapearing has become a thing of the past.. every car is now
ROCK stable..
FANTASTIC!!!! :-)
WOW.. tha is long. if your interested.. print it out.. and try it.. it is
worth it...
Good luck.. and c u on the track :-)
James Pickard,
Melbourne,
AUSTRALIA
DUN racing is ALIVE And well!!!!!! (now :-)
Quoted text (25 lines)
>Ron Ayton <[email hidden]> wrote: >: Hi Bruce, > >: I just wanted to tell you that what Phillip is saying here, regarding a >: 600 ping would be hopeless, is total, total rubbbish. >: (no offence meant Phillip) > > Well, the fact is that Bruce complained about warping... Your mileage >may vary but my experience, having spent an age tweaking everything I >can about my modem, is that racing with pings over 300 is a less >enjoyable experience. > > Certainly you are correct that quality of connection is as or more >important than ping time but I fully stand by the statement that, >generally speaking, if I see a ping time above 400 I experience >considerable warping and occasional disconnects. > > Bruce complained that his racing was spoiled by continual warping >and occasional disconnects. Draw your own conclusions. > >-- >Richard G. Clegg Only the mind is waving > Networks and Non-Linear Dynamics Group > Dept. of Mathematics, Uni. of York > www: http://manor.york.ac.uk/top.htmlHi Bruce,
I just wanted to tell you that what Phillip is saying here, regarding a
600 ping would be hopeless, is total, total rubbbish.
(no offence meant Phillip)
I am a proud member of the GMSS GPL league, which is based in the USA
and has been in operation ever since GPL was released.
Our host's locations vary across America, even as far up as Canada, and
my connections and quality of racing on-line from Australia has always
been excellent with pings from .400 up to and including .650 or so...
There is so much false information being blasted around on RAS and
other places, about what ping will work with GPL and 99.9% of it is
totally wrong..
Let me first say, that a lower ping is better, that is obvious, but a
ping of up to .600 can be absolutely PERFECT in GPL for the F2 or F3
cars, IF you have a good quality connection..
In actuality, pings of up to .750 can produce good racing in F3, but it
is not generally desirable to have pings over .600
In F1, i have found that pings of up to .550 will work reasonably well
as long as quality is good.
Regarding quality, my quality to the hosts in the GMSS league, is
usually around the .990 to .999 mark and i DO connect and race with the
GMSS league every week, with pings around the .450 to .600 area, with
hardly ever a warp of a problem, as i have been doing for the last 2
years.
The biggest problem is discoes, not warping...
That is not brought about by a latency of .600, but is usually the
result of packets being lost through bad routers, or having your
packets re-routed through different servers and GPL doesn't like the
delay or the lost packets that are introduced as the routers change or
go bad.
If any members of the GMSS league read this post Bruce, i am sure they
will confirm what i am saying here.
I would say that 99.9% of the time when i connect to one of our hosts
in the GMSS, that i DO NOT warp at all, in fact i will go as far to say
that my connection, as far as not warping and being solid on the track,
is usually as good as the guys in our league that have sub 100 pings.
In F1, i used to have occasional warping problems with pings of up to
.600, but these days i don't run F1 anyway, so the ping times (latency)
from Australia to USA are absolutely perfect for F2 & F3 racing, which
is where my love with GPL lies anyway.
One thought Bruce, what speed are you connecting at, and do you have
error correction and data compression turned off. ?
I am with BigPond, i have restricted my 56k modem speed to 26400 and i
have error correction and data compression turned off, so give that a
try before you give up in disgust. :)
Finally, don't EVER believe any crap you hear about how pings of up to
600 will not work with GPL, because it is simply not true.
Quality is far more important than latency in GPL on-line.
The GPL team at Papy have done an excellent job with the on-line code
and how well GPL handles latencys of up to .600.
If you need a hand or want more info, get in touch with me Bruce.
Regards,
Ron Ayton
Melbourne, Australia
Phillip McNelley <[email hidden]> wrote in article
<[email hidden]>...
> >Well.....I've had my first tastes of racing against human opponentsand
> >cannot say that I was overly impressed by the experience. ...
>
> The .600 ping would be hopeless. You're lucky to even get connectedat
Quoted text (14 lines)
> that ping as many servers would be set up to reject you at once. > > See the ASRG at http://www.powerup.com.au/~philmak/ASRG.htm for sim > racing online in Australia. > > We have a GPL comp coming up in Mid-March. > > Unfortunaly you've caught us between servers. Our previous high > bandwidth servers are offline and the new ones dont come online til > March. But even so, you'll find a few ofthe members hosting on good > servers from time to time in the intrim. > > Phillip McNelley >Hi Bruce,
I just wanted to tell you that what Phillip is saying here, regarding a
600 ping would be hopeless, is total, total rubbbish.
(no offence meant Phillip)
I am a proud member of the GMSS GPL league, which is based in the USA
and has been in operation ever since GPL was released.
Our host's locations vary across America, even as far up as Canada, and
my connections and quality of racing on-line from Australia has always
been excellent with pings from .400 up to and including .650 or so...
There is so much false information being blasted around on RAS and
other places, about what ping will work with GPL and 99.9% of it is
totally wrong..
Let me first say, that a lower ping is better, that is obvious, but a
ping of up to .600 can be absolutely PERFECT in GPL for the F2 or F3
cars, IF you have a good quality connection..
In actuality, pings of up to .750 can produce good racing in F3, but it
is not generally desirable to have pings over .600
In F1, i have found that pings of up to .550 will work reasonably well
as long as quality is good.
Regarding quality, my quality to the hosts in the GMSS league, is
usually around the .990 to .999 mark and i DO connect and race with the
GMSS league every week, with pings around the .450 to .600 area, with
hardly ever a warp of a problem, as i have been doing for the last 2
years.
The biggest problem is discoes, not warping...
That is not brought about by a latency of .600, but is usually the
result of packets being lost through bad routers, or having your
packets re-routed through different servers and GPL doesn't like the
delay or the lost packets that are introduced as the routers change or
go bad.
If any members of the GMSS league read this post Bruce, i am sure they
will confirm what i am saying here.
I would say that 99.9% of the time when i connect to one of our hosts
in the GMSS, that i DO NOT warp at all, in fact i will go as far to say
that my connection, as far as not warping and being solid on the track,
is usually as good as the guys in our league that have sub 100 pings.
In F1, i used to have occasional warping problems with pings of up to
..600, but these days i don't run F1 anyway, so the ping times
(latency) from Australia to USA are absolutely perfect for F2 & F3
racing, which is where my love with GPL lies anyway.
One thought Bruce, what speed are you connecting at, and do you have
error correction and data compression turned off. ?
I am with BigPond, i have restricted my 56k modem speed to 26400 and i
have error correction and data compression turned off, so give that a
try before you give up in disgust. :)
Finally, don't EVER believe any crap you hear about how pings of up to
600 will not work with GPL, because it is simply not true.
Quality is far more important than latency in GPL on-line.
The GPL team at Papy have done an excellent job with the on-line code
and how well GPL handles latencys of up to .600.
If you need a hand or want more info, get in touch with me Bruce.
Regards,
Ron Ayton
Melbourne, Australia
Phillip McNelley <[email hidden]> wrote in article
<[email hidden]>...
> >Well.....I've had my first tastes of racing against human opponentsand
> >cannot say that I was overly impressed by the experience. ...
>
> The .600 ping would be hopeless. You're lucky to even get connectedat
Quoted text (14 lines)
> that ping as many servers would be set up to reject you at once. > > See the ASRG at http://www.powerup.com.au/~philmak/ASRG.htm for sim > racing online in Australia. > > We have a GPL comp coming up in Mid-March. > > Unfortunaly you've caught us between servers. Our previous high > bandwidth servers are offline and the new ones dont come online til > March. But even so, you'll find a few ofthe members hosting on good > servers from time to time in the intrim. > > Phillip McNelley >I disagree. Try a lesser figure. You have generalised. You've taken a
story that may apply to some circumstances and implied that it is
always the case.
What I have said is based not only on my own personal expenses, but
those of numerous people who do a lot more OS racing at the highest
levels than I do or have done.
Which of course, in fairness, must also apply to you.
All things being equal, and expecting nothing more than the usual mode
of status with the misc servers one finds, a 600 ping from Australia
to OS is in 98% of cases bad news. As I say, there are a few notable
exceptions where the connection quality is unusually stable for
whatever reasons.
If there are bad routers then you are more likely to get one with a 20
hop connection than a 7 hop connection.
No one is saying that latency alone is the cause of all ills. But as
has already been said - the reason you get a high latency in OS
connections from here is also likely to encompass the related reasons
why the various other factors will also be on the poor side -
resulting in an overall less than attractive experience.
My comments relate to F1 races. And they are not just my comments but
those opinions that have been expressed to me by others - who have
simply told me exactly what I have repeated here.
Some have gone further to explain that it is a pain to race in
overseas races because of the lag problems - even when they are not
warping or clock smashing - in that they can't do the wheel to wheel
racing they expect or even to try an overtaking attempt that they
would have made otherwise.
I believe that if you got 100 people in Oz, set them up and let them
connect to 100 OS racers on 100 OS servers with pings of 600 or more,
and then asked them what they thought of the racing experience they
had just had, you would get an overwhelming number saying that it was
useless.
My comments are for the general rule. Yours are for specific isolated
and unusual cases. It is more truthful , imho, to tell people what
they are most likely to encounter rather than what they might
encounter in a few special cases if they are lucky. It is more false
to use the best case scenario as a description to inform others of the
norm.
I, like many others I might add, have zero interest in F2 or F3 cars.
If others enjoy them then fine. But its defiantly not my cup of tea.
How on earth can you say that you personally know the DUN settings and
other factors involved on the systems of other racers you see who
happen to be having a bad connection time ? Do you simply see someone
with a bad connection and then assume that they must have certain
settings. Be advised, that there are many who have done all the DUN
settings etc that are commonly recommended and who can still not get a
decent OS race at 600 or greater pings. You assume too much.
I feel just as sorry for those who have connected with 600 OS pings
expecting to be able to race - and then simply find they spend one
frustrating hour after another and then give up as seeing the whole
thing as useless. Better to give them the proper scoop in the first
place and get them racing in an arena where they can experience the
kind of racing that most closely meets their expectations and hopes.
Do you honestly think that the bulk of Australian sim racers refrain
from OS races because someone has said the pings are too high? You
sound rather nieve. You could say all you want but the great many
people will go and try it for themslves anyway. The more likely reason
that more Australias do no run in OS races is that they have probably
all tried to do so on many occasions and have finally come to their
own conclusions that its not worth the bother.
Even over the last few weeks when we have been having problems
providing servers here in Oz, and where there has been no Australian
alternative, you still do not see many Aussies doing OS races at 600
ping or more - even when some are desperate for some racing. Many of
these people have been racing online with GPL since it first came out
and know which way is up. Proper DUN settings etc is not news to them.
Do you think that they are all refraining because someone has said the
pings are too high ? They know better I suggest.
False and misleading information is always undesirable in any area. I
don't know that you are squeaky clean in this matter.
Best Regards
Phillip McNelley
I'm using a cable modem and usually see pings ranging from 60 to 300,
yet I seem to get as much warping and discos as people using dialup
modems. Any basic suggestions for tweaking cable modems ? Thanks.
--
Don Scurlock
Vancouver,B.C.
Hi,
I am not going to debate this anymore, as it appears to be a waste of
time trying to get the truth across to you..
Obviously you feel you are right, so i am not going to carry this on
any further.
I do know for a fact that good to excellent on-line races to overseas
is possible from Australia quite easily with .600 ping connections
using a dial up modem in GPL, so if you want to be negative about
this, that is fine by me.
I am not generalizing either, as any connection in Australia, or world
wide, for that matter, can achieve exactly the same results i have, if
they care to to be educated and open their eyes a bit...
Enjoy you on-line experiences...
Cheers,
Ron
**snipo **
Thanks Grant, for your feedback.
I'm not really enthusiastic enough about on-line to worry about chasing the
best setup.......I simply use it for fun and if on-line is either too
glitchy or too expensive or too difficult to set up then that's okay.
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
> > This is because you're racing with a 600ms ping - that's going to
> > cause loads of warping and disconnects.
> I used to race GPL online back in late '98 from back in New Zealand,
> I had 600-700ms latency usually, but I had a very stable connection,
> and got booted much less rarely than a lot of other people with much
> lower latency connections. High latency doesn't mean more disconnects,
> it just means icky warping. I used to follow people around and wait
> for them to fall off to make a pass, because due to warping their
> cars would be taking up about 4 carwidths on the track :)
> Bruce, you might want to check into websites and stuff that cover
> ways of tweaking your modem online connection for *** play, there's
> a lot of stuff you can do and combined altogether it will help your
> latency and connection reliability.
> Grant.
-----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==----------
http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World!
------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----
Thanks for the tip, Jeff.
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
> On Mon, 21 Feb 2000 21:06:40 +1100, "Bruce Kennewell"
> Definitely do so, Bruce. A V.34 connection is far more
> robust/stable than 56K. GPL only needs around 21k for a client, so
> any speed above that is sufficient. Listen to Ron, he mostly knows
> what he's talking about (lower ping is better, but high ping in itself
> can be compensted for, for the most part).
-----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==----------
http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World!
------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----
Thanks for that advice, Richard, but there's no ***y way I'm buying a
second modem just to set up for playing GPL on-line!! LOL!!
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
> > Definitely do so, Bruce. A V.34 connection is far more
> >robust/stable than 56K. GPL only needs around 21k for a client, so
> >any speed above that is sufficient. Listen to Ron, he mostly knows
> >what he's talking about (lower ping is better, but high ping in itself
> >can be compensted for, for the most part).
> This cannot be emphasized too much: *DO NOT* use a V.90 (56K)
> connection ! The constant retrains will quite often mess up the
> client-server synchronisation and get you booted from the server.
> Configure a "second modem" in Windows with the init strings to
> limit it to V.34 (33.6k) and use that to connect when playing GPL.
> Richard.
> --
> Richard Bellavance Enter-Net Inc.
> Phone: (450) 652-7189 #16
> Systems Administrator/ (514) 990-1683 #16
> Analyst-Programmer Fax: (450) 652-6973
-----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==----------
http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World!
------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----
Hey Bruce,
you wanna get ya ***up to Sydney on Sat. 26th. A GPL,Nascar3 LAN day.
:-)
Your being there might even get #33 out of his house. Tim is coming.
:-)
--
Todd Norbury
Norbury Technologies
Quoted text (37 lines)
> Thanks for that advice, Richard, but there's no ***y way I'm buying a > second modem just to set up for playing GPL on-line!! LOL!! > -- > Regards, > Bruce Kennewell, > Canberra, Australia. > --------------------------- > > > Definitely do so, Bruce. A V.34 connection is far more > > >robust/stable than 56K. GPL only needs around 21k for a client, so > > >any speed above that is sufficient. Listen to Ron, he mostly knows > > >what he's talking about (lower ping is better, but high ping in itself > > >can be compensted for, for the most part). > > This cannot be emphasized too much: *DO NOT* use a V.90 (56K) > > connection ! The constant retrains will quite often mess up the > > client-server synchronisation and get you booted from the server. > > Configure a "second modem" in Windows with the init strings to > > limit it to V.34 (33.6k) and use that to connect when playing GPL. > > Richard. > > -- > > Richard Bellavance Enter-Net Inc. > > Phone: (450) 652-7189 #16 > > Systems Administrator/ (514) 990-1683 #16 > > Analyst-Programmer Fax: (450) 652-6973 > -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==---------- > http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World! > ------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----It is not a wate of time getting the "truth" accross to anyone. Your
"truth" and mine seems to be at odds though.
For what its worth, from here on in I am more likey to tell people
that in my expierence an OS 600+ ping has almost always been a waste
of time BUT some have found such to be OK. I still think that
untimately everyone will try it for themselves and make up their own
minds regardless of what anyone tells them.
There is an old saying. When the truth seems to confict with
expeirience then go with experience.
In any case, with high bandwith connects soon to be available to many
at an affordable price in Australia perhaps these kind of discussions
will be irrelavant in due course.
I don't call relating the truth of my expieience over the last year or
more as being negative. I simply feel its better to tell people what
they are most likly to expierience - based on my understanding and
expieience.
If I say to somone avoid this but go for that because that will
utimatly give you the best expieience then I feel that's a way of
being possitive and helping them to not have a negative expierence.
Whatever.
Best Regards
Phillip McNelley
: Hi Richard,
: Like i just replied to Phillip, you are welcome to come to any decision
: you like when it comes to personal opinions, but as far as pings over
: .400 in GPL being less than desirable for racing, that simply isn't
: true.
: That isn't just my opinion, by the way, but we have proven that pings
: of up to .600 are perfect in F2 & F3 and likewise for pings of up to
: 550 in F1.
Most people race in F1. I wouldn't claim to be able to comment on F2
& F3 ping connections. The reason I assume is that an F1 car simply
moves further in the .3 seconds taken to get info back from the server
if your pings are poor.
: I am not going to try and dissuade you from what you believe Richard,
: but if you are having problems at pings over .400, then there is still
: something not setup right on your computer, or the hosts you were
: connecting to were overtaxing their cpu's.
: If you want help or information on tuning your DUN or improving your
: connection for on-line racing, drop me a line and i will help you sort
: it out a bit better.
Fine thank you - I actually do internet stuff as part of my
regular research work. Specifically relating to router and TCP/IP
efficiency. Higher pings in GPL are likely to lead to more disconnects
simply because (here in Europe at least) higher ping is often a sign
that there are more routers between you and the host - which means that
you are likely to have lower quality. As I said, quality is as
important - but also harder to measure before you join a server.
If Bruce can find himself < .4 ms ping sites then he's also likely to
get a higher quality connection.
--
Richard G. Clegg Only the mind is waving
Networks and Non-Linear Dynamics Group
Dept. of Mathematics, Uni. of York
www: http://manor.york.ac.uk/top.html
: Thanks for that advice, Richard, but there's no ***y way I'm buying a
: second modem just to set up for playing GPL on-line!! LOL!!
Bruce,
he wasn't talking about buying a second modem - he was talking
about adding three or four characters into your modems configuration
which will improve the GPL performance by making it act like a slower
modem when you need it to. It's pretty easy to do and does enhance the
online experience.
--
Richard G. Clegg Only the mind is waving
Networks and Non-Linear Dynamics Group
Dept. of Mathematics, Uni. of York
www: http://manor.york.ac.uk/top.html
And as you seem unable to notice that serveral variables are mentioned
i can'y say that I'm impressed with your ability to read and take
notice of what's being said.
Cheers
PM
Oh and by the way ...
You seem to be happy to make wide unsubstantated assumtions like your
friend. It happens that the above is not the case.
But even if it were, are you happy to assume it applys to my case
alone and other parties are exempt from the same assumtion ? Nice
sense of fairness you have.
Of course. This is not even being debated or contested by anyone. I
think we are all in agreance on this.
"No one is saying that latency alone is the cause of all ills. ...
.. related reasons why the various other factors ... ...are
going through a lot of hops to the server. Every hop is a potential
weak point. True its not just the ping but a combination of things.
.. ... the other parts of the equation are less than optimal also.
.. ... You can have OK races with pings of up to 500 as long as the
quality is good ... ...and as long as you allow a bit for the lag. But
having a 500 ping race with 7 hops and good quality is altobeather
another thing than a 500 ping race with 20 hops and occasional drops.
The problem with us is that nearly all connects to outside of Oz have
more hops than is usualy helpful. ... ... clock smashes and/or warps
and/or disconnects. ... "
Only 1 variable mentioned ??? HAve you actually read all the threads
or just one parragraph from one thread before you respnded ?
Cheers
PM
I agree with Ron, I've had lots of races with the servers in Australia, with
drivers from Australia USA and UK with very little warping problems.
--
Ian Parker
UKGPL League http://members.xoom.com/ukgpl
==
> Hi Bruce,
> I just wanted to tell you that what Phillip is saying here, regarding a
> 600 ping would be hopeless, is total, total rubbbish.
> (no offence meant Phillip)
> I am a proud member of the GMSS GPL league, which is based in the USA
> and has been in operation ever since GPL was released.
> Our host's locations vary across America, even as far up as Canada, and
> my connections and quality of racing on-line from Australia has always
> been excellent with pings from .400 up to and including .650 or so...
> There is so much false information being blasted around on RAS and
> other places, about what ping will work with GPL and 99.9% of it is
> totally wrong..
> Let me first say, that a lower ping is better, that is obvious, but a
> ping of up to .600 can be absolutely PERFECT in GPL for the F2 or F3
> cars, IF you have a good quality connection..
> In actuality, pings of up to .750 can produce good racing in F3, but it
> is not generally desirable to have pings over .600
> In F1, i have found that pings of up to .550 will work reasonably well
> as long as quality is good.
> Regarding quality, my quality to the hosts in the GMSS league, is
> usually around the .990 to .999 mark and i DO connect and race with the
> GMSS league every week, with pings around the .450 to .600 area, with
> hardly ever a warp of a problem, as i have been doing for the last 2
> years.
> The biggest problem is discoes, not warping...
> That is not brought about by a latency of .600, but is usually the
> result of packets being lost through bad routers, or having your
> packets re-routed through different servers and GPL doesn't like the
> delay or the lost packets that are introduced as the routers change or
> go bad.
> If any members of the GMSS league read this post Bruce, i am sure they
> will confirm what i am saying here.
> I would say that 99.9% of the time when i connect to one of our hosts
> in the GMSS, that i DO NOT warp at all, in fact i will go as far to say
> that my connection, as far as not warping and being solid on the track,
> is usually as good as the guys in our league that have sub 100 pings.
> In F1, i used to have occasional warping problems with pings of up to
> .600, but these days i don't run F1 anyway, so the ping times (latency)
> from Australia to USA are absolutely perfect for F2 & F3 racing, which
> is where my love with GPL lies anyway.
> One thought Bruce, what speed are you connecting at, and do you have
> error correction and data compression turned off. ?
> I am with BigPond, i have restricted my 56k modem speed to 26400 and i
> have error correction and data compression turned off, so give that a
> try before you give up in disgust. :)
> Finally, don't EVER believe any ***you hear about how pings of up to
> 600 will not work with GPL, because it is simply not true.
> Quality is far more important than latency in GPL on-line.
> The GPL team at Papy have done an excellent job with the on-line code
> and how well GPL handles latencys of up to .600.
> If you need a hand or want more info, get in touch with me Bruce.
> Regards,
> Ron Ayton
> Melbourne, Australia
> > >Well.....I've had my first tastes of racing against human opponents
> and
> > >cannot say that I was overly impressed by the experience. ...
> > The .600 ping would be hopeless. You're lucky to even get connected
> at
> > that ping as many servers would be set up to reject you at once.
> > See the ASRG at http://www.powerup.com.au/~philmak/ASRG.htm for sim
> > racing online in Australia.
> > We have a GPL comp coming up in Mid-March.
> > Unfortunaly you've caught us between servers. Our previous high
> > bandwidth servers are offline and the new ones dont come online til
> > March. But even so, you'll find a few ofthe members hosting on good
> > servers from time to time in the intrim.
> > Phillip McNelley
>Thanks for that advice, Richard, but there's no ***y way I'm buying a
>second modem just to set up for playing GPL on-line!! LOL!!
Thankfully, You don't need to buy another physical modem :-)
Just go into the Windows control panel, click "Modems", and add your
modem (same model, COM port etc.) a 2nd time. It will appear in the
list as "name of your modem#2". You can then tweak the settings of
this modem especially for online play, separately from your regular
dialup connection.
You'll also need to setup a 2nd "Dial-up networking" entry to use
this 2nd, "virtual", modem. I've been using such a setup for over
a year, on both Win95 and 98, without any problem.
Richard.
--
Richard Bellavance Enter-Net Inc.
Phone: (450) 652-7189 #16
Systems Administrator/ (514) 990-1683 #16
Analyst-Programmer Fax: (450) 652-6973
Bruce. In addition to what has been posted here, I have to add this. Ron
forgot to mention the fact that he has, on occasion, connected to Europe
with a ping of around the 900 - 1.0 region. Whilst not an ideal, situation,
we have had many a ding dong F3 battle into the early hours (his or ours).
He is quite correct in that it would not be recommended to try this in a F1
race though. Obviously, A f1 car goes much further in 1/2 a second at 190mph
than a F3 does at 120.
MS
Quoted text (83 lines)
> Hi Bruce, > I just wanted to tell you that what Phillip is saying here, regarding a > 600 ping would be hopeless, is total, total rubbbish. > (no offence meant Phillip) > I am a proud member of the GMSS GPL league, which is based in the USA > and has been in operation ever since GPL was released. > Our host's locations vary across America, even as far up as Canada, and > my connections and quality of racing on-line from Australia has always > been excellent with pings from .400 up to and including .650 or so... > There is so much false information being blasted around on RAS and > other places, about what ping will work with GPL and 99.9% of it is > totally wrong.. > Let me first say, that a lower ping is better, that is obvious, but a > ping of up to .600 can be absolutely PERFECT in GPL for the F2 or F3 > cars, IF you have a good quality connection.. > In actuality, pings of up to .750 can produce good racing in F3, but it > is not generally desirable to have pings over .600 > In F1, i have found that pings of up to .550 will work reasonably well > as long as quality is good. > Regarding quality, my quality to the hosts in the GMSS league, is > usually around the .990 to .999 mark and i DO connect and race with the > GMSS league every week, with pings around the .450 to .600 area, with > hardly ever a warp of a problem, as i have been doing for the last 2 > years. > The biggest problem is discoes, not warping... > That is not brought about by a latency of .600, but is usually the > result of packets being lost through bad routers, or having your > packets re-routed through different servers and GPL doesn't like the > delay or the lost packets that are introduced as the routers change or > go bad. > If any members of the GMSS league read this post Bruce, i am sure they > will confirm what i am saying here. > I would say that 99.9% of the time when i connect to one of our hosts > in the GMSS, that i DO NOT warp at all, in fact i will go as far to say > that my connection, as far as not warping and being solid on the track, > is usually as good as the guys in our league that have sub 100 pings. > In F1, i used to have occasional warping problems with pings of up to > .600, but these days i don't run F1 anyway, so the ping times (latency) > from Australia to USA are absolutely perfect for F2 & F3 racing, which > is where my love with GPL lies anyway. > One thought Bruce, what speed are you connecting at, and do you have > error correction and data compression turned off. ? > I am with BigPond, i have restricted my 56k modem speed to 26400 and i > have error correction and data compression turned off, so give that a > try before you give up in disgust. :) > Finally, don't EVER believe any ***you hear about how pings of up to > 600 will not work with GPL, because it is simply not true. > Quality is far more important than latency in GPL on-line. > The GPL team at Papy have done an excellent job with the on-line code > and how well GPL handles latencys of up to .600. > If you need a hand or want more info, get in touch with me Bruce. > Regards, > Ron Ayton > Melbourne, Australia > > >Well.....I've had my first tastes of racing against human opponents > and > > >cannot say that I was overly impressed by the experience. ... > > The .600 ping would be hopeless. You're lucky to even get connected > at > > that ping as many servers would be set up to reject you at once. > > See the ASRG at http://www.powerup.com.au/~philmak/ASRG.htm for sim > > racing online in Australia. > > We have a GPL comp coming up in Mid-March. > > Unfortunaly you've caught us between servers. Our previous high > > bandwidth servers are offline and the new ones dont come online til > > March. But even so, you'll find a few ofthe members hosting on good > > servers from time to time in the intrim. > > Phillip McNelley<Snip>
Funny thing is, the only "real" experience you can have is your
own connection. You don't really know the values of other's
connections.
In the end, I'll prefer racing people with a 50 ms/100% quality
connection, of course. But I also prefer a 600ms/100% q connection
above a 50 ms/70% q connection.
Since you keep talking about only 1 variable as being an indication of
the racing experience, I'm afraid I can't say that I'm impressed by
your statement....
Remco
"For what its worth, from here on in I am more likey to tell people
that in my expierence an OS 600+ ping has almost always been a waste
of time BUT some have found such to be OK. I still think that
untimately everyone will try it for themselves and make up their own
minds regardless of what anyone tells them."
Hmmm, I see only 1 variable here.....
Remco
Quoted text (11 lines)
>>Since you keep talking about only 1 variable as being an indication of >>the racing experience, I'm afraid I can't say that I'm impressed by >>your statement.... >And as you seem unable to notice that serveral variables are mentioned >i can'y say that I'm impressed with your ability to read and take >notice of what's being said. >Cheers >PMOh jeez, Todd! Don't tempt me. driving 600 kays is a bit much though,
mate. How many people are you expecting? (Say hello to Tim for me too).
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
> Hey Bruce,
> you wanna get ya ***up to Sydney on Sat. 26th. A GPL,Nascar3 LAN day.
> :-)
> Your being there might even get #33 out of his house. Tim is coming.
> :-)
> > Thanks for that advice, Richard, but there's no ***y way I'm buying a
> > second modem just to set up for playing GPL on-line!! LOL!!
> > --
> > Regards,
> > Bruce Kennewell,
> > Canberra, Australia.
> > ---------------------------
> > > > Definitely do so, Bruce. A V.34 connection is far more
> > > >robust/stable than 56K. GPL only needs around 21k for a client, so
> > > >any speed above that is sufficient. Listen to Ron, he mostly knows
> > > >what he's talking about (lower ping is better, but high ping in
itself
> > > >can be compensted for, for the most part).
> > > This cannot be emphasized too much: *DO NOT* use a V.90 (56K)
> > > connection ! The constant retrains will quite often mess up the
> > > client-server synchronisation and get you booted from the server.
> > > Configure a "second modem" in Windows with the init strings to
> > > limit it to V.34 (33.6k) and use that to connect when playing GPL.
> > > Richard.
> > > --
> > > Richard Bellavance Enter-Net Inc.
> > > Phone: (450) 652-7189 #16
> > > Systems Administrator/ (514) 990-1683 #16
> > > Analyst-Programmer Fax: (450) 652-6973
> > -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News
==----------
> > http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the
World!
> > ------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers
==-----
> --
> Todd Norbury
> Norbury Technologies
-----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==----------
http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World!
------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----
Ah, don't know at the moment. Maybe 10.
--
Todd Norbury
Norbury Technologies
Quoted text (75 lines)
> Oh jeez, Todd! Don't tempt me. driving 600 kays is a bit much though, > mate. How many people are you expecting? (Say hello to Tim for me too). > -- > Regards, > Bruce Kennewell, > Canberra, Australia. > --------------------------- > > Hey Bruce, > > you wanna get ya ***up to Sydney on Sat. 26th. A GPL,Nascar3 LAN day. > > :-) > > Your being there might even get #33 out of his house. Tim is coming. > > :-) > > > Thanks for that advice, Richard, but there's no ***y way I'm buying a > > > second modem just to set up for playing GPL on-line!! LOL!! > > > -- > > > Regards, > > > Bruce Kennewell, > > > Canberra, Australia. > > > --------------------------- > > > > > Definitely do so, Bruce. A V.34 connection is far more > > > > >robust/stable than 56K. GPL only needs around 21k for a client, so > > > > >any speed above that is sufficient. Listen to Ron, he mostly knows > > > > >what he's talking about (lower ping is better, but high ping in > itself > > > > >can be compensted for, for the most part). > > > > This cannot be emphasized too much: *DO NOT* use a V.90 (56K) > > > > connection ! The constant retrains will quite often mess up the > > > > client-server synchronisation and get you booted from the server. > > > > Configure a "second modem" in Windows with the init strings to > > > > limit it to V.34 (33.6k) and use that to connect when playing GPL. > > > > Richard. > > > > -- > > > > Richard Bellavance Enter-Net Inc. > > > > Phone: (450) 652-7189 #16 > > > > Systems Administrator/ (514) 990-1683 #16 > > > > Analyst-Programmer Fax: (450) 652-6973 > > > -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News > ==---------- > > > http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the > World! > > > ------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers > ==----- > > -- > > Todd Norbury > > Norbury Technologies > -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==---------- > http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World! > ------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----Depending on where the server is an Oz connection can have fewer hops than a
connection on the same continent. If my memory serves me correctly Ron had
fewer hops to a server we used to use on the West Coast of Canada than I did
and I was/am only 500 miles from there.
--
Michael Horton
http://www.bus.nait.ab.ca/staff/mikeh/gpl
F2/F3 Hotlaps and Other Downloadables
If you read the previous posts that lead up to any particular
statement you are more likely to get the gest of what has been
discussed. See other reply.
I had no idea that ping times etc was such a religious topic here. (
btw "etc" in this case stands for, quality, bandwidth, DUN setups,
type of connection, and surrounding relevant issues - before I'm
accused of referring to only 1 variable )
If it were a discussion on ***, Irish religion, the Vietnam war,
etc, I would have expected that some would have very firm viewpoints
as articles of faith.
But I though a discussion about online experiences as they relate to
connection qualities and ping times would be open for anyone to
express what their experiences have been. Seems that if you dare to
mention that, even with all the usual DUN fine tuning etc, your
experience differs form another's, you stand to be condemned as a
heretic - because your experiences don't line up with what another's
definition of connection "absolute and unquestionable truth" happens
to be.
I'm not sure that one can extrapolate the North America to Europe
situation to the Australia to North America one with perfect
comparative baselines.
Eg. From things I have read and heard I take it that there are
physical fibre optic cables across the Atlantic. In our case I believe
its all satellites. Who knows what obscure fine differences this
distinction may introduce.
I mention this because from analysis that I have done in the past the
biggest and most unreliable hop is from Sydney to San Fransico across
the pacific.
If you set up a connection testing software across the Pacific, and
set it for say 40 mins ( the time that should allow for pro-long races
) at the time of day the Ozzies might be online, and log the results
over that period some of the problems show up.
The thing is this ...
Even when the quality is high initially or usually, regardless of the
ping, over a period of time of say 40 mins, there are almost always
several periods of high packet loss and extended ping times. They
might only last for 30 or 60 seconds at a time, or even less, but
that's enough to ruin a race with clock smashes, warps, and
disconnects. This can be against a background of otherwise good
figures in all other respects. And this usually happens over the
Sydney to San-Fransico hop - for whattever reasons.
And, like it or not or accept it or not, when the ping is high it is
more often than not an indication that the other variables are less
than optimal too - from here to North America at least. Your
experience across the Atlantic may be entirely different on the
different hardware in place there.
I tried some high ping races last night just to see if things have
changed - but the old problems were still there it seems to me.
Although I must say not to the same extent I believe.
They were The other cars dance around so that passing is a real hit
and miss affair. Instead of wheel to wheel battles you have to wait
until the ahead driver has made a major error to chance a pass. On a
background of what appears to be a solid stable connection of
excellent quality you suddenly and for no apparent reason get very bad
quality, for a short period at least, with clock smashes, warps, and
disappearing other cars. This has been the problem for a long time and
still appears to be the case.
There is hope on the horizon though. Our 2nd largest Internet carrier
is going to establish its own backbone across the pacific I
understand, and may have already done so by this time, instead of
buying time from the owner of the only current link. This should then
free up the current link more as well as provide an entirely new 2nd
link which may turn out to be better quality than the existing one.
Also high bandwidth ISP services at affordable prices are about to hit
Australia. So perhaps in the next few months we will see trans pacific
races more useful to Australians.
You may then see me on the track with you and you can always crash
into me to "underline the emotional strength of your opinions" if you
like :-)
Cheers
PM
Maybe this is the basic reason why our expierneces seem so widely
differnet. I tried some high ping races last night just to see how it
was. A connection to a Canadian server took 26 hops. Needless to say
the expience was less than optimal.
As far as I know, there is little one can do to control the number of
hops it takes to get somewhere.
Regards
PM
Aha! Yes....thanks Richard. I've since discovered that was indeed the
message. :-)
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
> : Thanks for that advice, Richard, but there's no ***y way I'm buying a
> : second modem just to set up for playing GPL on-line!! LOL!!
> Bruce,
> he wasn't talking about buying a second modem - he was talking
> about adding three or four characters into your modems configuration
> which will improve the GPL performance by making it act like a slower
> modem when you need it to. It's pretty easy to do and does enhance the
> online experience.
> --
> Richard G. Clegg Only the mind is waving
> Networks and Non-Linear Dynamics Group
> Dept. of Mathematics, Uni. of York
> www: [link lost in import]
-----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==----------
http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World!
------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----
Thanks Richard....all understood.
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
> >Thanks for that advice, Richard, but there's no ***y way I'm buying a
> >second modem just to set up for playing GPL on-line!! LOL!!
> Thankfully, You don't need to buy another physical modem :-)
> Just go into the Windows control panel, click "Modems", and add your
> modem (same model, COM port etc.) a 2nd time. It will appear in the
> list as "name of your modem#2". You can then tweak the settings of
> this modem especially for online play, separately from your regular
> dialup connection.
> You'll also need to setup a 2nd "Dial-up networking" entry to use
> this 2nd, "virtual", modem. I've been using such a setup for over
> a year, on both Win95 and 98, without any problem.
> Richard.
> --
> Richard Bellavance Enter-Net Inc.
> Phone: (450) 652-7189 #16
> Systems Administrator/ (514) 990-1683 #16
> Analyst-Programmer Fax: (450) 652-6973
-----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==----------
http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World!
------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----
Fine mate. I must admit to having formed a preference for the "F2" cars
over the past year (although tend to think of them as representative of the
1.5 litre GP cars).
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
> Bruce. In addition to what has been posted here, I have to add this. Ron
> forgot to mention the fact that he has, on occasion, connected to Europe
> with a ping of around the 900 - 1.0 region. Whilst not an ideal,
situation,
> we have had many a ding dong F3 battle into the early hours (his or
ours).
> He is quite correct in that it would not be recommended to try this in a
F1
> race though. Obviously, A f1 car goes much further in 1/2 a second at
190mph
> than a F3 does at 120.
> MS
> > Hi Bruce,
> > I just wanted to tell you that what Phillip is saying here, regarding a
> > 600 ping would be hopeless, is total, total rubbbish.
> > (no offence meant Phillip)
> > I am a proud member of the GMSS GPL league, which is based in the USA
> > and has been in operation ever since GPL was released.
> > Our host's locations vary across America, even as far up as Canada, and
> > my connections and quality of racing on-line from Australia has always
> > been excellent with pings from .400 up to and including .650 or so...
> > There is so much false information being blasted around on RAS and
> > other places, about what ping will work with GPL and 99.9% of it is
> > totally wrong..
> > Let me first say, that a lower ping is better, that is obvious, but a
> > ping of up to .600 can be absolutely PERFECT in GPL for the F2 or F3
> > cars, IF you have a good quality connection..
> > In actuality, pings of up to .750 can produce good racing in F3, but it
> > is not generally desirable to have pings over .600
> > In F1, i have found that pings of up to .550 will work reasonably well
> > as long as quality is good.
> > Regarding quality, my quality to the hosts in the GMSS league, is
> > usually around the .990 to .999 mark and i DO connect and race with the
> > GMSS league every week, with pings around the .450 to .600 area, with
> > hardly ever a warp of a problem, as i have been doing for the last 2
> > years.
> > The biggest problem is discoes, not warping...
> > That is not brought about by a latency of .600, but is usually the
> > result of packets being lost through bad routers, or having your
> > packets re-routed through different servers and GPL doesn't like the
> > delay or the lost packets that are introduced as the routers change or
> > go bad.
> > If any members of the GMSS league read this post Bruce, i am sure they
> > will confirm what i am saying here.
> > I would say that 99.9% of the time when i connect to one of our hosts
> > in the GMSS, that i DO NOT warp at all, in fact i will go as far to say
> > that my connection, as far as not warping and being solid on the track,
> > is usually as good as the guys in our league that have sub 100 pings.
> > In F1, i used to have occasional warping problems with pings of up to
> > .600, but these days i don't run F1 anyway, so the ping times (latency)
> > from Australia to USA are absolutely perfect for F2 & F3 racing, which
> > is where my love with GPL lies anyway.
> > One thought Bruce, what speed are you connecting at, and do you have
> > error correction and data compression turned off. ?
> > I am with BigPond, i have restricted my 56k modem speed to 26400 and i
> > have error correction and data compression turned off, so give that a
> > try before you give up in disgust. :)
> > Finally, don't EVER believe any ***you hear about how pings of up to
> > 600 will not work with GPL, because it is simply not true.
> > Quality is far more important than latency in GPL on-line.
> > The GPL team at Papy have done an excellent job with the on-line code
> > and how well GPL handles latencys of up to .600.
> > If you need a hand or want more info, get in touch with me Bruce.
> > Regards,
> > Ron Ayton
> > Melbourne, Australia
> > > >Well.....I've had my first tastes of racing against human opponents
> > and
> > > >cannot say that I was overly impressed by the experience. ...
> > > The .600 ping would be hopeless. You're lucky to even get connected
> > at
> > > that ping as many servers would be set up to reject you at once.
> > > See the ASRG at http://www.powerup.com.au/~philmak/ASRG.htm for sim
> > > racing online in Australia.
> > > We have a GPL comp coming up in Mid-March.
> > > Unfortunaly you've caught us between servers. Our previous high
> > > bandwidth servers are offline and the new ones dont come online til
> > > March. But even so, you'll find a few ofthe members hosting on good
> > > servers from time to time in the intrim.
> > > Phillip McNelley
-----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==----------
http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World!
------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----
Now that would be a great group but something here in Canberra would be
preferable for me.
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
> Ah, don't know at the moment. Maybe 10.
> > Oh jeez, Todd! Don't tempt me. driving 600 kays is a bit much though,
> > mate. How many people are you expecting? (Say hello to Tim for me too).
> > --
> > Regards,
> > Bruce Kennewell,
> > Canberra, Australia.
> > ---------------------------
> > > Hey Bruce,
> > > you wanna get ya ***up to Sydney on Sat. 26th. A GPL,Nascar3 LAN
day.
> > > :-)
> > > Your being there might even get #33 out of his house. Tim is coming.
> > > :-)
> > > > Thanks for that advice, Richard, but there's no ***y way I'm
buying a
> > > > second modem just to set up for playing GPL on-line!! LOL!!
> > > > --
> > > > Regards,
> > > > Bruce Kennewell,
> > > > Canberra, Australia.
> > > > ---------------------------
> > > > > On Mon, 21 Feb 2000 18:16:56 GMT, Jeff Vincent
> > > > > > Definitely do so, Bruce. A V.34 connection is far more
> > > > > >robust/stable than 56K. GPL only needs around 21k for a client,
so
> > > > > >any speed above that is sufficient. Listen to Ron, he mostly
knows
> > > > > >what he's talking about (lower ping is better, but high ping in
> > itself
> > > > > >can be compensted for, for the most part).
> > > > > This cannot be emphasized too much: *DO NOT* use a V.90 (56K)
> > > > > connection ! The constant retrains will quite often mess up the
> > > > > client-server synchronisation and get you booted from the server.
> > > > > Configure a "second modem" in Windows with the init strings to
> > > > > limit it to V.34 (33.6k) and use that to connect when playing GPL.
> > > > > Richard.
> > > > > --
> > > > > Richard Bellavance Enter-Net Inc.
> > > > > Phone: (450) 652-7189 #16
> > > > > Systems Administrator/ (514) 990-1683 #16
> > > > > Analyst-Programmer Fax: (450) 652-6973
> > > > -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News
> > ==----------
> > > > http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the
> > World!
> > > > ------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries
Servers
> > ==-----
> > > --
> > > Todd Norbury
> > > Norbury Technologies
> > -----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News
==----------
> > http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the
World!
> > ------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers
==-----
> --
> Todd Norbury
> Norbury Technologies
-----------== Posted via Newsfeeds.Com, Uncensored Usenet News ==----------
http://www.newsfeeds.com The Largest Usenet Servers in the World!
------== Over 73,000 Newsgroups - Including Dedicated Binaries Servers ==-----
: My excuses that I wasn't clear in my first reply. What I meant to say
: was, after the discussion you had with others, you still would keep
: telling people that in your experience racing with a ping of 650 ms is
: not doable. (Yes, you also said others don't agree with you)
OK - a possible reason for all this...
In general, higher ping times mean higher numbers of hops which means
lower quality. Even with 100% quality, 600ms ping is going to affect
you badly.
However, thinking about the situation with australia, it's wholly
possible that they have single hops which themselves have long ping
times therefore, for traffic to/from australia a 600ms ping time may
have much better quality than a 600ms ping time across europe or from
europe to america.
This might well explain why people are saying "I'm in Europe/America
and I find 600ms unusable" and "I'm in Australia and I find 600ms fine
for F2/F3"... 600ms from Australia could be indicating a good
connection for a long journey whereas between the US and Europe it
indicates a dreadful connection for a not-so-long journey.
--
Richard G. Clegg Only the mind is waving
Networks and Non-Linear Dynamics Group
Dept. of Mathematics, Uni. of York
www: http://manor.york.ac.uk/top.html
Hi Richard,
I just wanted to say that what you are suggesting here is certainly a
major contributing factor to why some people find .600 and above pings
bad, where as others find them good to excellent.
I race on-line to the USA, where my on-line league is based, from
Australia every day and have done so ever since the very first day that
GPL was released.
The guys and myself in the GMSS league have done extensive testing with
GPL connection issues, and quite often, as Mike said earlier in this
thread, my jumps nearly always go through less routers than the guys
who live 500 miles away from the host.
As far as warping goes, i very rarely, if ever warp at all, but i do
suffer discoes slightly more than some of the guys based in the USA,
not all of them, but that is probably the most frustrating factor for
me in GPL on-line, as warping has never been an issue for me at all,
except for the first few times i was on-line, and that soon made me
attempt to start tuning DUNS and experimenting with different ISP
providers, and since then, apart form obviously bad net days, i have
never had a warping problem with any host that has a reasonable idea on
how to set up a hosting server..
I know with the testing i did myself personally in Australia that the
ISP provider is a major factor for Australians wanting to run overseas
races, with BigPond winning the race by a huge margin in providing
quality and warp free races in GPL to overseas hosts.
Hoepfully, as Phillip said, that will change for the better soon with
broadband connections soon to be affordable and available for the city
slickers here in Australia (no such luck for us bush boys though) so
hopefully the guys that do not have good ISP providers, or seem to
suffer more problems than others will soon be able to enjoy the quality
of overseas racing in GPL that some of us already do enjoy..
Incidentally, it works both ways, as after we managed to sort our
connections out, i tried hosting 3 clients from the USA on my 56k
modem, capped at 26400 baud on numerous occasions over the following
year or so with only very occasional warping, and usually none at all.
The guys pings that joined my test sessions were usually in the .500 to
.650 area as well, so it is possible to have fun, even with a dial-up
connection..
Finally, i will comment on this piece i cut from your post.. :)
From my experiences with GPL on-line, this is not a factor at all.
I am not just disagreeing with you for the sake of disagreeing :) but
honestly, speaking from my own personal experience with .600 and higher
pings, i know that it is totally possible to have excellent warp free
races at those ping levels, with absolutely no bad effects at all....
I know it goes against all we have learned and all we have read, but
pings for me of up to .600 are absolutely perfect, warp free racing in
F2 & F3 (where even higher pings can be just as good) and i have had
numerous races in F1 with pings up to and slightly higher then .600 in
the GMSS F1 league, where i have raced entire league races with pings
of around .625 in F1 without a single warp, spatial displacement or any
untoward behaviour at all, and that is racing in very close proximity
to other members of our league, without having to allow for lag in any
way.
The reason i am replying to you Richard, is to let you know that it is
possible to race with pings of up to .600 in F1 and even a lot higher
in F2/F3 without a single problem, so it is possible...
Also, like i said earlier, the lower the ping the better, you will
never get an argument with me there, but GPL does an excellent job of
latency calculation with .660 pings with a good quality connection,
just a damn shame that N3/NL wasn't as good in the on-line department
as GPL is, because in N3 i have had a few good races at pings of up to
.350, but usually i find that pings over .300 in N3/NL are next to
useless for close, warp free racing, anyway i transgress..
Like i said, i think you are on the right track with the ammount of
jumps verses quality of connection at high ping levels, as each and
every router our signal goes through is a potential trouble spot, so
lets just enjoy what we have at the moment and make the most of it..
Cheers,
Ron Ayton
Melbourne, Australia
>> ... Hmmm, I see only 1 variable here.....
>If you read the previous posts that lead up to any particular
>statement you are more likely to get the gest of what has been
>discussed. See other reply.
I did read them...
My excuses that I wasn't clear in my first reply. What I meant to say
was, after the discussion you had with others, you still would keep
telling people that in your experience racing with a ping of 650 ms is
not doable. (Yes, you also said others don't agree with you)
I would expect, after you clearly showed you know your stuff, that you
would tell this people the real story, like you did in your last post,
which is a very fine explanation about the matter. Tell people the
facts, and let them decide...don't spoonfeed them with your experience
alone.
It is ok to express your experience...
So, not the high latency is the reason of your bad experience, but a
certain router?
I've raced on Austalian servers, with pings lower then 500ms....those
races were fine.
I hope this will work out for you, but don't forget that the demand is
rising faster as they can add bandwidth :-(
Looking forward to it... <g>
Remco


































