Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Re: F1-2000 --> Why I won't buy it on Day One.

29 posts by 19 people · 18 Mar 2000 - 23 Mar 2000 09:23 UTC

Critical review of F1 2000 physics, brakes and sound

rrevved posted a critical review of F1 2000 after trying it, citing brakes that locked too easily, elevation changes, poor tyre sounds and other shortcomings. Some agreed and called it a disappointment, while others liked it and suggested adjusting the brake bias. The thread also included complaints about the newsgroup's falling civility and the influx of warez users.

review/impressionsphysics/realism debateF1 2000

Automated summary.

Alan Orton <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > Just curious but have you guy's even tried adjusting the bias? I know in > gpl if the bias is set 70% to the front you get the same effect. > It's not nearly as bad with the bias at around 48/52 F/R. The only thing I really don' tlike is that the brakes don't seem to release when you let up on the pedal- it's about a necessity to use the ABS option.
Quoted text (11 lines)> AndrewS wrote: > > > > > EA/ISI: > > > > > > Why is there only about a 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel prior to full > > > braking? I use a TSW wheel/pedals and I don't have this problem > > > in any other sim. What's up with F1-2000 that it will go full > > > brakes with 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel? I have over 2" of pedal > > > travel in my pedals and you only let me use 1/4-1/2" of the 2". > > > > I've read F1 drivers say that people don't understand the brakes in an
F1 > > car. It's not how far you push the pedal, it's how hard you push it.There > > is very little pedal travel. So by your admission, ISI has modeled this > > dead on. Whether it's a suitable for computer simulations is left up tothe > > user.
rrevved 18 Mar 2000#286710
F1-2000 - Why I won't buy it on Day One. Well folks, I am glad I tried this thing out prior to buying it. If you don't want to read a major whining rant, you might want to move on to another post. First off, I want to say that I am VERY grateful for developers who take a chance on creating hardcore sims, and at it's maximum realism settings, F1-2000 is pretty damned hardcore. If it's so hardcore, then I guess you might wonder why I won't be snapping it up the millisecond it hits the shelves. Here are a few of the reasons. These are my impressions from the MYTH (Final Retail) version of F1-2000, not the earlier CLASS-released BETA version. * REASON #1 - Why I absolutely won't buy F1-2000 on Day One EA/ISI: What's up with the frigging TIRE SQUEAL? Have you ever witnessed an F1 race? Have you attended ANY type of race? If not, then here is some info you may be interested in. When there are 25, or so, F1 cars in a clump at a venue like Monaco, it is VERY damned difficult to hear the tiniest squeal from anyone's tires. F1 cars are really, really noisy . 'K? Why didn't you actually -listen- to what you have created here, or at least have someone that actually goes to races, (of any type) listen to it? To group: This particular developer, ISI, while having a good handle on the physics of the cars is not.. err.. sound savvy. Just like their previous title, SCGT, there are nearly NO ways to control the sounds that are dished out to us, the user. If I set the sound effects slider to 10%, I will hear no crashes, etc., but my damned tires will continue to holler at the *slightest* provocation. I *can't stand* the continuous squealing, so I will pass on this one, until editors are made by 3rd parties, as was done to fix the ludicrous sound situation in SCGT. With SCGT, I rushed out and bought it, and lived with the crap sound for a while until someone finally made an editor to rip the sounds. At that time, I changed the engine and other sounds and my SCGT sounds are on GTINSIDER, and other sites etc.. The sounds that I and others created made SCGT much more likeable. Again, this will have to be done to fixed the f**ked-up F1-2000 TIRE SQUEAL, of all things. I simply can't bear to listen to it, and I won't be paying for F1-2000 until it is fixed. Don't worry, I won't be sitting here at home secretly using this warez copy of F1-2000. It is off my drive. I will wait and see if there are any editors released and what the user comments are, prior to running it again. If it is fixed, I will buy it that day. Not before. I HATE the squealing sound!!!!!!! ;) * OTHER REASONS I would be irritated even if the SQUEALING problems were fixed. EA/ISI: Why is there only about a 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel prior to full braking? I use a TSW wheel/pedals and I don't have this problem in any other sim. What's up with F1-2000 that it will go full brakes with 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel? I have over 2" of pedal travel in my pedals and you only let me use 1/4-1/2" of the 2". It really, really makes it difficult to modulate the brakes, EA/ISI, when you design your simulator this way. Care to tell us why it is like that? Is there a way that the users can do yet more hacking to fix this problem? Will you help them hack it? Also, EA/ISI, why is it that even with SMOKE detail at LOW that every car, including mine, emits powerful plumes of SMOKE at nearly EVERY corner? The first time I saw it, I thought the entire field had blown their engines.. LOL. I had to turn off the smoke in order to see where I was going, when following the AI. What's up with that, EA/ISI, and will you help 3rd parties hack it to act like real racecars do? EA/ISI, why does the run down to Eau Rouge, one of the most famous and recognizable sections of race track in the WORLD, have only a -very- slight slope, not a dramatic drop, like in real life? Same with Monaco.. Why are the elevations made MUCH less dramatic than in real life? You may remember that you did the -same- thing in SCGT with Road Atlanta and with Laguna Seca. Didn't user comments affect you when you created this new title. Do you at ISI have a TV or VCR so you could actually LOOK at an F1 race and see that the elevation changes in F1-2000 are FAR too understated? [sigh] * Note to newsgroup: I have some other irritants that bother me with this title, including the POOR graphics performance. I won't belabor those, since I can simply reduce major amounts of detail, view distances, cars viewed, etc. I can crank down the res to 640x480 on my PIII-600/256mb/V3-3000. Silly crap like graphics beauty shouldn't bother me, cos' after all, I'm hard core, right? I have to do this majorly reduced detail thing to maintain a *consistently* decent framerate in *races* with F1-2000. After my ranting, some of you may wonder who pissed in my Cheerios. Well, I guess my expectations pissed in my Cheerios. I thought this was gonna be a nice sim, and in many areas it is VERY nice. Physics modeling, for example, is very impressive. FWIW, there is more to enjoyable sim racing, for me, than simply the physics modeling. EA/ISI: What's up with the engine sound? Why does it make those little frequency jumps as it revs up? This is most noticeable in the external replay. It's as if you take a sound loop and change it's frequency in steps. You do something like: 8000,8300,8600,8900, etc. The jumps are very noticeable and sound silly. It would be much better if the jumps were MUCH smaller, like 8000,8025,8050,8075,8100 .. etc. This is not a biggie, I'm just wondering if there is some way to [sigh] 'hack' it to make it sound like a real racecar, and not some cheap FOR..NEXT loop in an 80's BASIC program. [shrug] O.K, enough whining, I am gonna go do something else and try to make my ears stop squealing, and put a few drops of Visine in my eyes to clear out the tire smoke. :) There is a -nice- sim under all of the incredibly bad elevation and sound detail, and I will buy F1-2000 immediately when it is *fixed*, by either the developer (unlikely) or by 3rd parties. Not before. For now, I am going to sit back and watch people post that this can't be the 'final retail' version, and that all will be well in the REAL store-bought version, that my controller and system is crap, that I should support 'hardcore' developers by buying it anyway, that I am a pirate slimeball, (even though I have an unfixed PURCHASED Nascar Revolution on my shelf)... Blah, Blah, Blah. I guess when it actually hits the store shelves all of these questions will be answered by the posts here in this newsgroup. You heard it here first .. . :) Let the flames commence. Next .. -- * rrev at mindspring dot com * unit.26 - s.p.u.t.u.m. * http://www.cabal.net
On Sat, 18 Mar 2000 17:02:14 GMT, "Tim Vanhee" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (12 lines)>>Why are the elevations made MUCH less dramatic than in real life? >>You may remember that you did the -same- thing in SCGT with >>Road Atlanta and with Laguna Seca. Didn't user comments affect >>you when you created this new title. Do you at ISI have a TV or >>VCR so you could actually LOOK at an F1 race and see that the >>elevation changes in F1-2000 are FAR too understated? > >Errrrr.... What did you say? Less dramatic??? I agree in most points of your >post but I totally disagree on this one. The elevations are extremely >overdone IMO. There are elevations where there should be none or very high >elevation changes where in real life there are just small bumps. (check >Monza)
Tim, surely you don't think that the elevation is steep enough in the run down to Eau Rouge, at Spa, or down from Casino Square at Monaco, through the 2 or 3 turns leading to the hairpin... Those are -minor- hills in F1-2000. They aren't like that in real life. Just my opinion. ;) -- * rrev at mindspring dot com * unit.26 - s.p.u.t.u.m. * http://www.cabal.net
On 18 Mar 2000 18:00:19 GMT, "Alexander Marx" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (13 lines)>> Let the flames commence. Next .. > >Agree with everything you said, track accuracy is horrible (as I've already >posted it earler) I'm incredibly disappointed by F12k, especially after the >hype created in this newsgroup. I just installed the final to give it >another chance, but my opinion hasn't changed - have you tried to lose the >car under braking ? it won'T happen, you can'T even provoke it! Ridiculous. >If any F1 car would be that easy to drive at the limit then count me in for >next season ;-) > >Already wearing my Flame-proof suit :) >Alex >
I can definitely lose the car under braking. It will push (understeer) into the sandtrap. I think that part is pretty realistic. Are you driving with all of the driving aids off? -- * rrev at mindspring dot com * unit.26 - s.p.u.t.u.m. * http://www.cabal.net
> I can definitely lose the car under braking. It will push (understeer) > into the sandtrap. I think that part is pretty realistic. Are you > driving with all of the driving aids off? I was thinking of the opposite effect, try turning in too early while braking, I can't seem to provoke snap oversteer. It seems like braking is simply a question of whether you are locking or not locking the brakes - no weight transfer effects modelled. And yes, all possible aids are off. Looking at the replay you'll see that the suspension movement is very much exaggerated. And if you still aren't convinced that this sim is *not THAT great* <g> then fire up a 100% GP and watch it as a spectator.... ROFLMAO this is so ridiculous it's funny.
On Sat, 18 Mar 2000 20:42:54 GMT, "Marc Collins" <[email hidden]> wrote: >Does this newsgroup seem a lot less....civilised of late? Is this what the >warez crowd brings? Good sarcastic reply rrevved, but really, what's >happening? > >Marc. >Marc, I hate to be considered as part of the 'warez' crowd, but in this case I will have to plead guilty.. ;) I had no qualms whatsoever in finding out if F1-2000 was just another EA Sports money grab, like Nascar Revolution. I bought and kept NR based on EA's promise to fix it. I haunted the NR forum on the EA site for several months only to ultimately watch as they simply removed the forum, leaving all of the posters with nowhere to turn. I haven't a twinge of guilt in finding out how I would like F1-2000 prior to purchasing it. Had there been a demo, I certainly would have never downloaded the full version twice on my 56k dialup modem. ( 2 x 50 parts x 2.88mb per part) = 288mb Thats the biggest thing I have ever downloaded, by far. I would have simply downloaded the ~20mb demo and decided if F1-2000 was for me. Like I said, I have no intention of using it anymore without buying it and I will only buy it when assured the problems are resolved. A 'plan' to resolve the problems (like NR had) ain't gonna cut it.. ;) Well, that was longer than I intended, but maybe you catch my drift. ;)
Quoted text (207 lines)>"rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >news:[email hidden]... >> On Sat, 18 Mar 2000 20:10:02 GMT, [email hidden] (benh) wrote: >> >> >You're just a fuckin' whiner, i didn't even notice the tire sounds, >> >any chance you have a piece of shit soundcard that only handles a >> >couple channels at a time? >> >> Yah, I got one of them Turtle Beach Montego A3D 2.0 pieces of shit. >> >> LOL >> >> >because the sounds were great on my machine >> >with and SBLive and FPS2000 speakers. >> >> Well, I got some of them USB Altec Lansing Dolby Prologic >> Surround speakers. Are they any good, soundmeister? >> >> LOL >> >> > I also liked the default sounds >> >in SCGT way more than all the overdone ones by other people, >> >> So, in SCGT, you liked it when you couldn't hear your car at >> the start since it was drowned out by the others cars 'cos >> they were all using their internal cockpit sounds and they were >> just as loud as yours and there were 20 cars trying to drown >> you out? >> >> KeWl >> >> LOL >> >> > i still >> >use the defaults with it as well, i think the problem many people have >> >with sounds comes from the fact they have shitless sound >> >cards/speakers etc.. >> > >> >> Well, my sound card hasn't shit yet. Does that make it 'shitless'? >> >> > >> >On Sat, 18 Mar 2000 10:45:47 -0600, rrevved <[email hidden]> >> >wrote: >> > >> >> >> >>F1-2000 - Why I won't buy it on Day One. >> >> >> >>Well folks, I am glad I tried this thing out prior to buying it. >> >>If you don't want to read a major whining rant, you might >> >>want to move on to another post. >> >> >> >>First off, I want to say that I am VERY grateful for developers >> >>who take a chance on creating hardcore sims, and at it's maximum >> >>realism settings, F1-2000 is pretty damned hardcore. If it's >> >>so hardcore, then I guess you might wonder why I won't be snapping >> >>it up the millisecond it hits the shelves. >> >> >> >>Here are a few of the reasons. >> >> >> >>These are my impressions from the MYTH (Final Retail) version of >> >>F1-2000, not the earlier CLASS-released BETA version. >> >> >> >>* REASON #1 - Why I absolutely won't buy F1-2000 on Day One >> >> >> >>EA/ISI: >> >> >> >>What's up with the frigging TIRE SQUEAL? Have you ever witnessed >> >>an F1 race? Have you attended ANY type of race? >> >> >> >>If not, then here is some info you may be interested in. When there >> >>are 25, or so, F1 cars in a clump at a venue like Monaco, it is VERY >> >>damned difficult to hear the tiniest squeal from anyone's tires. >> >>F1 cars are really, really noisy . 'K? >> >> >> >>Why didn't you actually -listen- to what you have created here, >> >>or at least have someone that actually goes to races, (of any type) >> >>listen to it? >> >> >> >>To group: This particular developer, ISI, while having a good >> >>handle on the physics of the cars is not.. err.. sound savvy. Just >> >>like their previous title, SCGT, there are nearly NO ways to >> >>control the sounds that are dished out to us, the user. If I set >> >>the sound effects slider to 10%, I will hear no crashes, etc., >> >>but my damned tires will continue to holler at the *slightest* >> >>provocation. I *can't stand* the continuous squealing, so I >> >>will pass on this one, until editors are made by 3rd parties, >> >>as was done to fix the ludicrous sound situation in SCGT. >> >> >> >>With SCGT, I rushed out and bought it, and lived with the crap >> >>sound for a while until someone finally made an editor to rip >> >>the sounds. At that time, I changed the engine and other sounds >> >>and my SCGT sounds are on GTINSIDER, and other sites etc.. >> >>The sounds that I and others created made SCGT much more >> >>likeable. Again, this will have to be done to fixed the f**ked-up >> >>F1-2000 TIRE SQUEAL, of all things. >> >> >> >>I simply can't bear to listen to it, and I won't be paying for >> >>F1-2000 until it is fixed. Don't worry, I won't be sitting here at >> >>home secretly using this warez copy of F1-2000. It is off my drive. >> >>I will wait and see if there are any editors released and what the >> >>user comments are, prior to running it again. If it is fixed, I will >> >>buy it that day. Not before. >> >> >> >>I HATE the squealing sound!!!!!!! ;) >> >> >> >>* OTHER REASONS I would be irritated even if the SQUEALING >> >>problems were fixed. >> >> >> >>EA/ISI: >> >> >> >>Why is there only about a 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel prior to full >> >>braking? I use a TSW wheel/pedals and I don't have this problem >> >>in any other sim. What's up with F1-2000 that it will go full >> >>brakes with 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel? I have over 2" of pedal >> >>travel in my pedals and you only let me use 1/4-1/2" of the 2". >> >> >> >>It really, really makes it difficult to modulate the brakes, >> >>EA/ISI, when you design your simulator this way. Care to >> >>tell us why it is like that? Is there a way that the users can >> >>do yet more hacking to fix this problem? Will you help them hack it? >> >> >> >>Also, EA/ISI, why is it that even with SMOKE detail at LOW >> >>that every car, including mine, emits powerful plumes of SMOKE >> >>at nearly EVERY corner? The first time I saw it, I thought the >> >>entire field had blown their engines.. LOL. I had to turn off the >> >>smoke in order to see where I was going, when following the AI. >> >>What's up with that, EA/ISI, and will you help 3rd parties hack >> >>it to act like real racecars do? >> >> >> >>EA/ISI, why does the run down to Eau Rouge, one of the most >> >>famous and recognizable sections of race track in the WORLD, >> >>have only a -very- slight slope, not a dramatic drop, like in real >life? >> >>Same with Monaco.. >> >> >> >>Why are the elevations made MUCH less dramatic than in real life? >> >>You may remember that you did the -same- thing in SCGT with >> >>Road Atlanta and with Laguna Seca. Didn't user comments affect >> >>you when you created this new title. Do you at ISI have a TV or >> >>VCR so you could actually LOOK at an F1 race and see that the >> >>elevation changes in F1-2000 are FAR too understated? >> >> >> >>[sigh] >> >> >> >>* Note to newsgroup: I have some other irritants that bother me >> >>with this title, including the POOR graphics performance. I won't >> >>belabor those, since I can simply reduce major amounts of detail, >> >>view distances, cars viewed, etc. I can crank down the res to >> >>640x480 on my PIII-600/256mb/V3-3000. Silly crap like graphics >> >>beauty shouldn't bother me, cos' after all, I'm hard core, right? >> >> >> >>I have to do this majorly reduced detail thing to maintain a >> >>*consistently* decent framerate in *races* with F1-2000. >> >> >> >>After my ranting, some of you may wonder who pissed in my Cheerios. >> >>Well, I guess my expectations pissed in my Cheerios. I thought >> >>this was gonna be a nice sim, and in many areas it is VERY nice. >> >>Physics modeling, for example, is very impressive. FWIW, there >> >>is more to enjoyable sim racing, for me, than simply the physics >> >>modeling. >> >> >> >>EA/ISI: >> >> >> >>What's up with the engine sound? Why does it make >> >>those little frequency jumps as it revs up? This is most >> >>noticeable in the external replay. It's as if you take a sound >> >>loop and change it's frequency in steps. You do something >> >>like: 8000,8300,8600,8900, etc. The jumps are very noticeable >> >>and sound silly. It would be much better if the jumps were >> >>MUCH smaller, like 8000,8025,8050,8075,8100 .. etc. >> >> >> >>This is not a biggie, I'm just wondering if there is some >> >>way to [sigh] 'hack' it to make it sound like a real racecar, and >> >>not some cheap FOR..NEXT loop in an 80's BASIC program. >> >> >> >>[shrug] >> >> >> >>O.K, enough whining, I am gonna go do something else and try to >> >>make my ears stop squealing, and put a few drops of Visine in my >> >>eyes to clear out the tire smoke. :) >> >> >> >>There is a -nice- sim under all of the incredibly bad elevation >> >>and sound detail, and I will buy F1-2000 immediately when it >> >>is *fixed*, by either the developer (unlikely) or by 3rd parties. >> >> >> >>Not before. >> >> >> >>For now, I am going to sit back and watch people post that this >> >>can't be the 'final retail' version, and that all will be well in the >> >>REAL store-bought version, that my controller and system is crap, >> >>that I should support 'hardcore' developers by buying it anyway, >> >>that I am a pirate slimeball, (even though I have an unfixed >> >>PURCHASED Nascar Revolution on my shelf)... Blah, Blah, Blah. >> >> >> >>I guess when it actually hits the store shelves all of these questions >> >>will be answered by the posts here in this newsgroup. >> >> >> >>You heard it here first .. . :) >> >> >> >>Let the flames commence. Next .. >> >> -- >> * rrev at mindspring dot com >> * unit.26 - s.p.u.t.u.m. >> * http://www.cabal.net >
-- * rrev at mindspring dot com * unit.26 - s.p.u.t.u.m. * http://www.cabal.net
On Sat, 18 Mar 2000 17:55:09 -0500, "AndrewS" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (10 lines)>> EA/ISI: >> >> Why is there only about a 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel prior to full >> braking? I use a TSW wheel/pedals and I don't have this problem >> in any other sim. What's up with F1-2000 that it will go full >> brakes with 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel? I have over 2" of pedal >> travel in my pedals and you only let me use 1/4-1/2" of the 2". > >I've read F1 drivers say that people don't understand the brakes in an F1 >car. It's not how far you push the pedal, it's how hard you push it.
Thats the way it is in a normal car as well... ;) >There is very little pedal travel. Yep, I wouldn't want my real-life Taurus brake pedal to go to the floor.. ;) >So by your admission, ISI has modeled this >dead on. Whether it's a suitable for computer simulations is left up to the >user. Agreed. We don't have hydraulic brake pressure to push against, in our normal sim pedals. To model something that makes it more difficult to control than real-life is not making a simulation any better, in my opinion. -- * rrev at mindspring dot com * unit.26 - s.p.u.t.u.m. * http://www.cabal.net
On Sat, 18 Mar 2000 20:10:02 GMT, [email hidden] (benh) wrote: >You're just a fuckin' whiner, i didn't even notice the tire sounds, >any chance you have a piece of shit soundcard that only handles a >couple channels at a time? Yah, I got one of them Turtle Beach Montego A3D 2.0 pieces of shit. LOL >because the sounds were great on my machine >with and SBLive and FPS2000 speakers. Well, I got some of them USB Altec Lansing Dolby Prologic Surround speakers. Are they any good, soundmeister? LOL > I also liked the default sounds >in SCGT way more than all the overdone ones by other people, So, in SCGT, you liked it when you couldn't hear your car at the start since it was drowned out by the others cars 'cos they were all using their internal cockpit sounds and they were just as loud as yours and there were 20 cars trying to drown you out? KeWl LOL > i still >use the defaults with it as well, i think the problem many people have >with sounds comes from the fact they have shitless sound >cards/speakers etc.. > Well, my sound card hasn't shit yet. Does that make it 'shitless'?
Quoted text (159 lines)> >On Sat, 18 Mar 2000 10:45:47 -0600, rrevved <[email hidden]> >wrote: > >> >>F1-2000 - Why I won't buy it on Day One. >> >>Well folks, I am glad I tried this thing out prior to buying it. >>If you don't want to read a major whining rant, you might >>want to move on to another post. >> >>First off, I want to say that I am VERY grateful for developers >>who take a chance on creating hardcore sims, and at it's maximum >>realism settings, F1-2000 is pretty damned hardcore. If it's >>so hardcore, then I guess you might wonder why I won't be snapping >>it up the millisecond it hits the shelves. >> >>Here are a few of the reasons. >> >>These are my impressions from the MYTH (Final Retail) version of >>F1-2000, not the earlier CLASS-released BETA version. >> >>* REASON #1 - Why I absolutely won't buy F1-2000 on Day One >> >>EA/ISI: >> >>What's up with the frigging TIRE SQUEAL? Have you ever witnessed >>an F1 race? Have you attended ANY type of race? >> >>If not, then here is some info you may be interested in. When there >>are 25, or so, F1 cars in a clump at a venue like Monaco, it is VERY >>damned difficult to hear the tiniest squeal from anyone's tires. >>F1 cars are really, really noisy . 'K? >> >>Why didn't you actually -listen- to what you have created here, >>or at least have someone that actually goes to races, (of any type) >>listen to it? >> >>To group: This particular developer, ISI, while having a good >>handle on the physics of the cars is not.. err.. sound savvy. Just >>like their previous title, SCGT, there are nearly NO ways to >>control the sounds that are dished out to us, the user. If I set >>the sound effects slider to 10%, I will hear no crashes, etc., >>but my damned tires will continue to holler at the *slightest* >>provocation. I *can't stand* the continuous squealing, so I >>will pass on this one, until editors are made by 3rd parties, >>as was done to fix the ludicrous sound situation in SCGT. >> >>With SCGT, I rushed out and bought it, and lived with the crap >>sound for a while until someone finally made an editor to rip >>the sounds. At that time, I changed the engine and other sounds >>and my SCGT sounds are on GTINSIDER, and other sites etc.. >>The sounds that I and others created made SCGT much more >>likeable. Again, this will have to be done to fixed the f**ked-up >>F1-2000 TIRE SQUEAL, of all things. >> >>I simply can't bear to listen to it, and I won't be paying for >>F1-2000 until it is fixed. Don't worry, I won't be sitting here at >>home secretly using this warez copy of F1-2000. It is off my drive. >>I will wait and see if there are any editors released and what the >>user comments are, prior to running it again. If it is fixed, I will >>buy it that day. Not before. >> >>I HATE the squealing sound!!!!!!! ;) >> >>* OTHER REASONS I would be irritated even if the SQUEALING >>problems were fixed. >> >>EA/ISI: >> >>Why is there only about a 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel prior to full >>braking? I use a TSW wheel/pedals and I don't have this problem >>in any other sim. What's up with F1-2000 that it will go full >>brakes with 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel? I have over 2" of pedal >>travel in my pedals and you only let me use 1/4-1/2" of the 2". >> >>It really, really makes it difficult to modulate the brakes, >>EA/ISI, when you design your simulator this way. Care to >>tell us why it is like that? Is there a way that the users can >>do yet more hacking to fix this problem? Will you help them hack it? >> >>Also, EA/ISI, why is it that even with SMOKE detail at LOW >>that every car, including mine, emits powerful plumes of SMOKE >>at nearly EVERY corner? The first time I saw it, I thought the >>entire field had blown their engines.. LOL. I had to turn off the >>smoke in order to see where I was going, when following the AI. >>What's up with that, EA/ISI, and will you help 3rd parties hack >>it to act like real racecars do? >> >>EA/ISI, why does the run down to Eau Rouge, one of the most >>famous and recognizable sections of race track in the WORLD, >>have only a -very- slight slope, not a dramatic drop, like in real life? >>Same with Monaco.. >> >>Why are the elevations made MUCH less dramatic than in real life? >>You may remember that you did the -same- thing in SCGT with >>Road Atlanta and with Laguna Seca. Didn't user comments affect >>you when you created this new title. Do you at ISI have a TV or >>VCR so you could actually LOOK at an F1 race and see that the >>elevation changes in F1-2000 are FAR too understated? >> >>[sigh] >> >>* Note to newsgroup: I have some other irritants that bother me >>with this title, including the POOR graphics performance. I won't >>belabor those, since I can simply reduce major amounts of detail, >>view distances, cars viewed, etc. I can crank down the res to >>640x480 on my PIII-600/256mb/V3-3000. Silly crap like graphics >>beauty shouldn't bother me, cos' after all, I'm hard core, right? >> >>I have to do this majorly reduced detail thing to maintain a >>*consistently* decent framerate in *races* with F1-2000. >> >>After my ranting, some of you may wonder who pissed in my Cheerios. >>Well, I guess my expectations pissed in my Cheerios. I thought >>this was gonna be a nice sim, and in many areas it is VERY nice. >>Physics modeling, for example, is very impressive. FWIW, there >>is more to enjoyable sim racing, for me, than simply the physics >>modeling. >> >>EA/ISI: >> >>What's up with the engine sound? Why does it make >>those little frequency jumps as it revs up? This is most >>noticeable in the external replay. It's as if you take a sound >>loop and change it's frequency in steps. You do something >>like: 8000,8300,8600,8900, etc. The jumps are very noticeable >>and sound silly. It would be much better if the jumps were >>MUCH smaller, like 8000,8025,8050,8075,8100 .. etc. >> >>This is not a biggie, I'm just wondering if there is some >>way to [sigh] 'hack' it to make it sound like a real racecar, and >>not some cheap FOR..NEXT loop in an 80's BASIC program. >> >>[shrug] >> >>O.K, enough whining, I am gonna go do something else and try to >>make my ears stop squealing, and put a few drops of Visine in my >>eyes to clear out the tire smoke. :) >> >>There is a -nice- sim under all of the incredibly bad elevation >>and sound detail, and I will buy F1-2000 immediately when it >>is *fixed*, by either the developer (unlikely) or by 3rd parties. >> >>Not before. >> >>For now, I am going to sit back and watch people post that this >>can't be the 'final retail' version, and that all will be well in the >>REAL store-bought version, that my controller and system is crap, >>that I should support 'hardcore' developers by buying it anyway, >>that I am a pirate slimeball, (even though I have an unfixed >>PURCHASED Nascar Revolution on my shelf)... Blah, Blah, Blah. >> >>I guess when it actually hits the store shelves all of these questions >>will be answered by the posts here in this newsgroup. >> >>You heard it here first .. . :) >> >>Let the flames commence. Next ..
-- * rrev at mindspring dot com * unit.26 - s.p.u.t.u.m. * http://www.cabal.net
rrevved 18 Mar 2000#523464
>You're just a ***in' whiner, i didn't even notice the tire sounds, >any chance you have a piece of shit soundcard that only handles a >couple channels at a time? Yah, I got one of them Turtle Beach Montego A3D 2.0 pieces of shit. LOL Well, I got some of them USB Altec Lansing Dolby Prologic Surround speakers. Are they any good, soundmeister? LOL So, in SCGT, you liked it when you couldn't hear your car at the start since it was drowned out by the others cars 'cos they were all using their internal***pit sounds and they were just as loud as yours and there were 20 cars trying to drown you out? KeWl LOL Well, my sound card hasn't shit yet. Does that make it 'shitless'?
Quoted text (154 lines)>>F1-2000 - Why I won't buy it on Day One. >>Well folks, I am glad I tried this thing out prior to buying it. >>If you don't want to read a major whining rant, you might >>want to move on to another post. >>First off, I want to say that I am VERY grateful for developers >>who take a chance on creating *** sims, and at it's maximum >>realism settings, F1-2000 is pretty damned ***. If it's >>so ***, then I guess you might wonder why I won't be snapping >>it up the millisecond it hits the shelves. >>Here are a few of the reasons. >>These are my impressions from the MYTH (Final Retail) version of >>F1-2000, not the earlier CLASS-released BETA version. >>* REASON #1 - Why I absolutely won't buy F1-2000 on Day One >>EA/ISI: >>What's up with the frigging TIRE SQUEAL? Have you ever witnessed >>an F1 race? Have you attended ANY type of race? >>If not, then here is some info you may be interested in. When there >>are 25, or so, F1 cars in a clump at a venue like Monaco, it is VERY >>damned difficult to hear the tiniest squeal from anyone's tires. >>F1 cars are really, really noisy . 'K? >>Why didn't you actually -listen- to what you have created here, >>or at least have someone that actually goes to races, (of any type) >>listen to it? >>To group: This particular developer, ISI, while having a good >>handle on the physics of the cars is not.. err.. sound savvy. Just >>like their previous title, SCGT, there are nearly NO ways to >>control the sounds that are dished out to us, the user. If I set >>the sound effects slider to 10%, I will hear no crashes, etc., >>but my damned tires will continue to holler at the *slightest* >>provocation. I *can't stand* the continuous squealing, so I >>will pass on this one, until editors are made by 3rd parties, >>as was done to fix the ludicrous sound situation in SCGT. >>With SCGT, I rushed out and bought it, and lived with the *** >>sound for a while until someone finally made an editor to rip >>the sounds. At that time, I changed the engine and other sounds >>and my SCGT sounds are on GTINSIDER, and other sites etc.. >>The sounds that I and others created made SCGT much more >>likeable. Again, this will have to be done to fixed the f**ked-up >>F1-2000 TIRE SQUEAL, of all things. >>I simply can't bear to listen to it, and I won't be paying for >>F1-2000 until it is fixed. Don't worry, I won't be sitting here at >>home secretly using this warez copy of F1-2000. It is off my drive. >>I will wait and see if there are any editors released and what the >>user comments are, prior to running it again. If it is fixed, I will >>buy it that day. Not before. >>I HATE the squealing sound!!!!!!! ;) >>* OTHER REASONS I would be irritated even if the SQUEALING >>problems were fixed. >>EA/ISI: >>Why is there only about a 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel prior to full >>braking? I use a TSW wheel/pedals and I don't have this problem >>in any other sim. What's up with F1-2000 that it will go full >>brakes with 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel? I have over 2" of pedal >>travel in my pedals and you only let me use 1/4-1/2" of the 2". >>It really, really makes it difficult to modulate the brakes, >>EA/ISI, when you design your simulator this way. Care to >>tell us why it is like that? Is there a way that the users can >>do yet more hacking to fix this problem? Will you help them hack it? >>Also, EA/ISI, why is it that even with SMOKE detail at LOW >>that every car, including mine, emits powerful plumes of SMOKE >>at nearly EVERY corner? The first time I saw it, I thought the >>entire field had blown their engines.. LOL. I had to turn off the >>smoke in order to see where I was going, when following the AI. >>What's up with that, EA/ISI, and will you help 3rd parties hack >>it to act like real racecars do? >>EA/ISI, why does the run down to Eau Rouge, one of the most >>famous and recognizable sections of race track in the WORLD, >>have only a -very- slight slope, not a dramatic drop, like in real life? >>Same with Monaco.. >>Why are the elevations made MUCH less dramatic than in real life? >>You may remember that you did the -same- thing in SCGT with >>Road Atlanta and with Laguna Seca. Didn't user comments affect >>you when you created this new title. Do you at ISI have a TV or >>VCR so you could actually LOOK at an F1 race and see that the >>elevation changes in F1-2000 are FAR too understated? >>[sigh] >>* Note to newsgroup: I have some other irritants that bother me >>with this title, including the POOR graphics performance. I won't >>belabor those, since I can simply reduce major amounts of detail, >>view distances, cars viewed, etc. I can crank down the res to >>640x480 on my PIII-600/256mb/V3-3000. Silly ***like graphics >>beauty shouldn't bother me, cos' after all, I'm hard core, right? >>I have to do this majorly reduced detail thing to maintain a >>*consistently* decent framerate in *races* with F1-2000. >>After my ranting, some of you may wonder who pissed in my Cheerios. >>Well, I guess my expectations pissed in my Cheerios. I thought >>this was gonna be a nice sim, and in many areas it is VERY nice. >>Physics modeling, for example, is very impressive. FWIW, there >>is more to enjoyable sim racing, for me, than simply the physics >>modeling. >>EA/ISI: >>What's up with the engine sound? Why does it make >>those little frequency jumps as it revs up? This is most >>noticeable in the external replay. It's as if you take a sound >>loop and change it's frequency in steps. You do something >>like: 8000,8300,8600,8900, etc. The jumps are very noticeable >>and sound silly. It would be much better if the jumps were >>MUCH smaller, like 8000,8025,8050,8075,8100 .. etc. >>This is not a biggie, I'm just wondering if there is some >>way to [sigh] 'hack' it to make it sound like a real racecar, and >>not some cheap FOR..NEXT loop in an 80's BASIC program. >>[shrug] >>O.K, enough whining, I am gonna go do something else and try to >>make my ears stop squealing, and put a few drops of Visine in my >>eyes to clear out the tire smoke. :) >>There is a -nice- sim under all of the incredibly bad elevation >>and sound detail, and I will buy F1-2000 immediately when it >>is *fixed*, by either the developer (unlikely) or by 3rd parties. >>Not before. >>For now, I am going to sit back and watch people post that this >>can't be the 'final retail' version, and that all will be well in the >>REAL store-bought version, that my controller and system is crap, >>that I should support '***' developers by buying it anyway, >>that I am a pirate slimeball, (even though I have an unfixed >>PURCHASED Nascar Revolution on my shelf)... Blah, Blah, Blah. >>I guess when it actually hits the store shelves all of these questions >>will be answered by the posts here in this newsgroup. >>You heard it here first .. . :) >>Let the flames commence. Next ..
-- * rrev at mindspring dot com * unit.26 - s.p.u.t.u.m. * http://www.cabal.net
>Why are the elevations made MUCH less dramatic than in real life? >You may remember that you did the -same- thing in SCGT with >Road Atlanta and with Laguna Seca. Didn't user comments affect >you when you created this new title. Do you at ISI have a TV or >VCR so you could actually LOOK at an F1 race and see that the >elevation changes in F1-2000 are FAR too understated? Errrrr.... What did you say? Less dramatic??? I agree in most points of your post but I totally disagree on this one. The elevations are extremely overdone IMO. There are elevations where there should be none or very high elevation changes where in real life there are just small bumps. (check Monza) Now everyone is shouting what a great sim F1 2000 is but it'll change. The first time I played it I hated it, and gave GP2 another run. I thought it would get better, that I'd have to get used to it, but after several hours of forcing myself to love it I still hate it. I wanted it to be good but it isn't.
Alexander Marx wrote:
Quoted text (12 lines)> > Let the flames commence. Next .. > > Agree with everything you said, track accuracy is horrible (as I've already > posted it earler) I'm incredibly disappointed by F12k, especially after the > hype created in this newsgroup. I just installed the final to give it > another chance, but my opinion hasn't changed - have you tried to lose the > car under braking ? it won'T happen, you can'T even provoke it! Ridiculous. > If any F1 car would be that easy to drive at the limit then count me in for > next season ;-) > > Already wearing my Flame-proof suit :) > Alex
What !!! Are you crazy ??? this is the best sim since GPL have you disabled all the driving helps ? no alex just kidding i too agree with the above post, some people started a hype these persons which i THOUGHT where true simmers (as in gplers) made me curious and i too downloaded it This game is a piece of shit just like most of the other games and i feel sorry for fortunecity.de for wasting their 150mb of bandwith, this was the first warez game i've downloaded and also the last, i have not deleted this TRASH yet because a friend has already preordered it and i'm sure when he plays this game he is not going to buy it _ Jarno
Some real good points, rrevvved. The smoke at all the corners is, I assume, from tires locking up. A real education for me as I didn't realize real F1 drivers locked their tires at every turn. I get about 1" of brake travel before full lock on the Ferrari wheel. Haven't tried the modified Act Labs yet. Guys running the old 'squash ball under the pedal' trick better go out and buy a basketball and try to fit it in. I don't know, maybe I could get used to it in a few days (weeks or months). Then there's always (sigh) anti-lock brakes. Having a TSW you wouldn't notice the FF. At least SCGT has SOME road feel. This is a step backwards. Can't even get wheel damping without using default spring. I'm afraid we'll never see another driving sim with GPL's ff qualities. The future looks like washboard running, sign crunching, cobblestone chattering, NFS force feedback. Ah well, endeavor to persevere. Slot "rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (160 lines)> > F1-2000 - Why I won't buy it on Day One. > > Well folks, I am glad I tried this thing out prior to buying it. > If you don't want to read a major whining rant, you might > want to move on to another post. > > First off, I want to say that I am VERY grateful for developers > who take a chance on creating hardcore sims, and at it's maximum > realism settings, F1-2000 is pretty damned hardcore. If it's > so hardcore, then I guess you might wonder why I won't be snapping > it up the millisecond it hits the shelves. > > Here are a few of the reasons. > > These are my impressions from the MYTH (Final Retail) version of > F1-2000, not the earlier CLASS-released BETA version. > > * REASON #1 - Why I absolutely won't buy F1-2000 on Day One > > EA/ISI: > > What's up with the frigging TIRE SQUEAL? Have you ever witnessed > an F1 race? Have you attended ANY type of race? > > If not, then here is some info you may be interested in. When there > are 25, or so, F1 cars in a clump at a venue like Monaco, it is VERY > damned difficult to hear the tiniest squeal from anyone's tires. > F1 cars are really, really noisy . 'K? > > Why didn't you actually -listen- to what you have created here, > or at least have someone that actually goes to races, (of any type) > listen to it? > > To group: This particular developer, ISI, while having a good > handle on the physics of the cars is not.. err.. sound savvy. Just > like their previous title, SCGT, there are nearly NO ways to > control the sounds that are dished out to us, the user. If I set > the sound effects slider to 10%, I will hear no crashes, etc., > but my damned tires will continue to holler at the *slightest* > provocation. I *can't stand* the continuous squealing, so I > will pass on this one, until editors are made by 3rd parties, > as was done to fix the ludicrous sound situation in SCGT. > > With SCGT, I rushed out and bought it, and lived with the crap > sound for a while until someone finally made an editor to rip > the sounds. At that time, I changed the engine and other sounds > and my SCGT sounds are on GTINSIDER, and other sites etc.. > The sounds that I and others created made SCGT much more > likeable. Again, this will have to be done to fixed the f**ked-up > F1-2000 TIRE SQUEAL, of all things. > > I simply can't bear to listen to it, and I won't be paying for > F1-2000 until it is fixed. Don't worry, I won't be sitting here at > home secretly using this warez copy of F1-2000. It is off my drive. > I will wait and see if there are any editors released and what the > user comments are, prior to running it again. If it is fixed, I will > buy it that day. Not before. > > I HATE the squealing sound!!!!!!! ;) > > * OTHER REASONS I would be irritated even if the SQUEALING > problems were fixed. > > EA/ISI: > > Why is there only about a 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel prior to full > braking? I use a TSW wheel/pedals and I don't have this problem > in any other sim. What's up with F1-2000 that it will go full > brakes with 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel? I have over 2" of pedal > travel in my pedals and you only let me use 1/4-1/2" of the 2". > > It really, really makes it difficult to modulate the brakes, > EA/ISI, when you design your simulator this way. Care to > tell us why it is like that? Is there a way that the users can > do yet more hacking to fix this problem? Will you help them hack it? > > Also, EA/ISI, why is it that even with SMOKE detail at LOW > that every car, including mine, emits powerful plumes of SMOKE > at nearly EVERY corner? The first time I saw it, I thought the > entire field had blown their engines.. LOL. I had to turn off the > smoke in order to see where I was going, when following the AI. > What's up with that, EA/ISI, and will you help 3rd parties hack > it to act like real racecars do? > > EA/ISI, why does the run down to Eau Rouge, one of the most > famous and recognizable sections of race track in the WORLD, > have only a -very- slight slope, not a dramatic drop, like in real life? > Same with Monaco.. > > Why are the elevations made MUCH less dramatic than in real life? > You may remember that you did the -same- thing in SCGT with > Road Atlanta and with Laguna Seca. Didn't user comments affect > you when you created this new title. Do you at ISI have a TV or > VCR so you could actually LOOK at an F1 race and see that the > elevation changes in F1-2000 are FAR too understated? > > [sigh] > > * Note to newsgroup: I have some other irritants that bother me > with this title, including the POOR graphics performance. I won't > belabor those, since I can simply reduce major amounts of detail, > view distances, cars viewed, etc. I can crank down the res to > 640x480 on my PIII-600/256mb/V3-3000. Silly crap like graphics > beauty shouldn't bother me, cos' after all, I'm hard core, right? > > I have to do this majorly reduced detail thing to maintain a > *consistently* decent framerate in *races* with F1-2000. > > After my ranting, some of you may wonder who pissed in my Cheerios. > Well, I guess my expectations pissed in my Cheerios. I thought > this was gonna be a nice sim, and in many areas it is VERY nice. > Physics modeling, for example, is very impressive. FWIW, there > is more to enjoyable sim racing, for me, than simply the physics > modeling. > > EA/ISI: > > What's up with the engine sound? Why does it make > those little frequency jumps as it revs up? This is most > noticeable in the external replay. It's as if you take a sound > loop and change it's frequency in steps. You do something > like: 8000,8300,8600,8900, etc. The jumps are very noticeable > and sound silly. It would be much better if the jumps were > MUCH smaller, like 8000,8025,8050,8075,8100 .. etc. > > This is not a biggie, I'm just wondering if there is some > way to [sigh] 'hack' it to make it sound like a real racecar, and > not some cheap FOR..NEXT loop in an 80's BASIC program. > > [shrug] > > O.K, enough whining, I am gonna go do something else and try to > make my ears stop squealing, and put a few drops of Visine in my > eyes to clear out the tire smoke. :) > > There is a -nice- sim under all of the incredibly bad elevation > and sound detail, and I will buy F1-2000 immediately when it > is *fixed*, by either the developer (unlikely) or by 3rd parties. > > Not before. > > For now, I am going to sit back and watch people post that this > can't be the 'final retail' version, and that all will be well in the > REAL store-bought version, that my controller and system is crap, > that I should support 'hardcore' developers by buying it anyway, > that I am a pirate slimeball, (even though I have an unfixed > PURCHASED Nascar Revolution on my shelf)... Blah, Blah, Blah. > > I guess when it actually hits the store shelves all of these questions > will be answered by the posts here in this newsgroup. > > You heard it here first .. . :) > > Let the flames commence. Next .. > > -- > * rrev at mindspring dot com > * unit.26 - s.p.u.t.u.m. > * http://www.cabal.net
benh 18 Mar 2000 20:10 UTC↳ reply to rrevved#286820
You're just a fuckin' whiner, i didn't even notice the tire sounds, any chance you have a piece of shit soundcard that only handles a couple channels at a time? because the sounds were great on my machine with and SBLive and FPS2000 speakers. I also liked the default sounds in SCGT way more than all the overdone ones by other people, i still use the defaults with it as well, i think the problem many people have with sounds comes from the fact they have shitless sound cards/speakers etc.. On Sat, 18 Mar 2000 10:45:47 -0600, rrevved <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (155 lines)> >F1-2000 - Why I won't buy it on Day One. > >Well folks, I am glad I tried this thing out prior to buying it. >If you don't want to read a major whining rant, you might >want to move on to another post. > >First off, I want to say that I am VERY grateful for developers >who take a chance on creating hardcore sims, and at it's maximum >realism settings, F1-2000 is pretty damned hardcore. If it's >so hardcore, then I guess you might wonder why I won't be snapping >it up the millisecond it hits the shelves. > >Here are a few of the reasons. > >These are my impressions from the MYTH (Final Retail) version of >F1-2000, not the earlier CLASS-released BETA version. > >* REASON #1 - Why I absolutely won't buy F1-2000 on Day One > >EA/ISI: > >What's up with the frigging TIRE SQUEAL? Have you ever witnessed >an F1 race? Have you attended ANY type of race? > >If not, then here is some info you may be interested in. When there >are 25, or so, F1 cars in a clump at a venue like Monaco, it is VERY >damned difficult to hear the tiniest squeal from anyone's tires. >F1 cars are really, really noisy . 'K? > >Why didn't you actually -listen- to what you have created here, >or at least have someone that actually goes to races, (of any type) >listen to it? > >To group: This particular developer, ISI, while having a good >handle on the physics of the cars is not.. err.. sound savvy. Just >like their previous title, SCGT, there are nearly NO ways to >control the sounds that are dished out to us, the user. If I set >the sound effects slider to 10%, I will hear no crashes, etc., >but my damned tires will continue to holler at the *slightest* >provocation. I *can't stand* the continuous squealing, so I >will pass on this one, until editors are made by 3rd parties, >as was done to fix the ludicrous sound situation in SCGT. > >With SCGT, I rushed out and bought it, and lived with the crap >sound for a while until someone finally made an editor to rip >the sounds. At that time, I changed the engine and other sounds >and my SCGT sounds are on GTINSIDER, and other sites etc.. >The sounds that I and others created made SCGT much more >likeable. Again, this will have to be done to fixed the f**ked-up >F1-2000 TIRE SQUEAL, of all things. > >I simply can't bear to listen to it, and I won't be paying for >F1-2000 until it is fixed. Don't worry, I won't be sitting here at >home secretly using this warez copy of F1-2000. It is off my drive. >I will wait and see if there are any editors released and what the >user comments are, prior to running it again. If it is fixed, I will >buy it that day. Not before. > >I HATE the squealing sound!!!!!!! ;) > >* OTHER REASONS I would be irritated even if the SQUEALING >problems were fixed. > >EA/ISI: > >Why is there only about a 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel prior to full >braking? I use a TSW wheel/pedals and I don't have this problem >in any other sim. What's up with F1-2000 that it will go full >brakes with 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel? I have over 2" of pedal >travel in my pedals and you only let me use 1/4-1/2" of the 2". > >It really, really makes it difficult to modulate the brakes, >EA/ISI, when you design your simulator this way. Care to >tell us why it is like that? Is there a way that the users can >do yet more hacking to fix this problem? Will you help them hack it? > >Also, EA/ISI, why is it that even with SMOKE detail at LOW >that every car, including mine, emits powerful plumes of SMOKE >at nearly EVERY corner? The first time I saw it, I thought the >entire field had blown their engines.. LOL. I had to turn off the >smoke in order to see where I was going, when following the AI. >What's up with that, EA/ISI, and will you help 3rd parties hack >it to act like real racecars do? > >EA/ISI, why does the run down to Eau Rouge, one of the most >famous and recognizable sections of race track in the WORLD, >have only a -very- slight slope, not a dramatic drop, like in real life? >Same with Monaco.. > >Why are the elevations made MUCH less dramatic than in real life? >You may remember that you did the -same- thing in SCGT with >Road Atlanta and with Laguna Seca. Didn't user comments affect >you when you created this new title. Do you at ISI have a TV or >VCR so you could actually LOOK at an F1 race and see that the >elevation changes in F1-2000 are FAR too understated? > >[sigh] > >* Note to newsgroup: I have some other irritants that bother me >with this title, including the POOR graphics performance. I won't >belabor those, since I can simply reduce major amounts of detail, >view distances, cars viewed, etc. I can crank down the res to >640x480 on my PIII-600/256mb/V3-3000. Silly crap like graphics >beauty shouldn't bother me, cos' after all, I'm hard core, right? > >I have to do this majorly reduced detail thing to maintain a >*consistently* decent framerate in *races* with F1-2000. > >After my ranting, some of you may wonder who pissed in my Cheerios. >Well, I guess my expectations pissed in my Cheerios. I thought >this was gonna be a nice sim, and in many areas it is VERY nice. >Physics modeling, for example, is very impressive. FWIW, there >is more to enjoyable sim racing, for me, than simply the physics >modeling. > >EA/ISI: > >What's up with the engine sound? Why does it make >those little frequency jumps as it revs up? This is most >noticeable in the external replay. It's as if you take a sound >loop and change it's frequency in steps. You do something >like: 8000,8300,8600,8900, etc. The jumps are very noticeable >and sound silly. It would be much better if the jumps were >MUCH smaller, like 8000,8025,8050,8075,8100 .. etc. > >This is not a biggie, I'm just wondering if there is some >way to [sigh] 'hack' it to make it sound like a real racecar, and >not some cheap FOR..NEXT loop in an 80's BASIC program. > >[shrug] > >O.K, enough whining, I am gonna go do something else and try to >make my ears stop squealing, and put a few drops of Visine in my >eyes to clear out the tire smoke. :) > >There is a -nice- sim under all of the incredibly bad elevation >and sound detail, and I will buy F1-2000 immediately when it >is *fixed*, by either the developer (unlikely) or by 3rd parties. > >Not before. > >For now, I am going to sit back and watch people post that this >can't be the 'final retail' version, and that all will be well in the >REAL store-bought version, that my controller and system is crap, >that I should support 'hardcore' developers by buying it anyway, >that I am a pirate slimeball, (even though I have an unfixed >PURCHASED Nascar Revolution on my shelf)... Blah, Blah, Blah. > >I guess when it actually hits the store shelves all of these questions >will be answered by the posts here in this newsgroup. > >You heard it here first .. . :) > >Let the flames commence. Next ..
Does this newsgroup seem a lot less....civilised of late? Is this what the warez crowd brings? Good sarcastic reply rrevved, but really, what's happening? Marc. "rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (131 lines)> On Sat, 18 Mar 2000 20:10:02 GMT, [email hidden] (benh) wrote: > > >You're just a fuckin' whiner, i didn't even notice the tire sounds, > >any chance you have a piece of shit soundcard that only handles a > >couple channels at a time? > > Yah, I got one of them Turtle Beach Montego A3D 2.0 pieces of shit. > > LOL > > >because the sounds were great on my machine > >with and SBLive and FPS2000 speakers. > > Well, I got some of them USB Altec Lansing Dolby Prologic > Surround speakers. Are they any good, soundmeister? > > LOL > > > I also liked the default sounds > >in SCGT way more than all the overdone ones by other people, > > So, in SCGT, you liked it when you couldn't hear your car at > the start since it was drowned out by the others cars 'cos > they were all using their internal cockpit sounds and they were > just as loud as yours and there were 20 cars trying to drown > you out? > > KeWl > > LOL > > > i still > >use the defaults with it as well, i think the problem many people have > >with sounds comes from the fact they have shitless sound > >cards/speakers etc.. > > > > Well, my sound card hasn't shit yet. Does that make it 'shitless'? > > > > >On Sat, 18 Mar 2000 10:45:47 -0600, rrevved <[email hidden]> > >wrote: > > > >> > >>F1-2000 - Why I won't buy it on Day One. > >> > >>Well folks, I am glad I tried this thing out prior to buying it. > >>If you don't want to read a major whining rant, you might > >>want to move on to another post. > >> > >>First off, I want to say that I am VERY grateful for developers > >>who take a chance on creating hardcore sims, and at it's maximum > >>realism settings, F1-2000 is pretty damned hardcore. If it's > >>so hardcore, then I guess you might wonder why I won't be snapping > >>it up the millisecond it hits the shelves. > >> > >>Here are a few of the reasons. > >> > >>These are my impressions from the MYTH (Final Retail) version of > >>F1-2000, not the earlier CLASS-released BETA version. > >> > >>* REASON #1 - Why I absolutely won't buy F1-2000 on Day One > >> > >>EA/ISI: > >> > >>What's up with the frigging TIRE SQUEAL? Have you ever witnessed > >>an F1 race? Have you attended ANY type of race? > >> > >>If not, then here is some info you may be interested in. When there > >>are 25, or so, F1 cars in a clump at a venue like Monaco, it is VERY > >>damned difficult to hear the tiniest squeal from anyone's tires. > >>F1 cars are really, really noisy . 'K? > >> > >>Why didn't you actually -listen- to what you have created here, > >>or at least have someone that actually goes to races, (of any type) > >>listen to it? > >> > >>To group: This particular developer, ISI, while having a good > >>handle on the physics of the cars is not.. err.. sound savvy. Just > >>like their previous title, SCGT, there are nearly NO ways to > >>control the sounds that are dished out to us, the user. If I set > >>the sound effects slider to 10%, I will hear no crashes, etc., > >>but my damned tires will continue to holler at the *slightest* > >>provocation. I *can't stand* the continuous squealing, so I > >>will pass on this one, until editors are made by 3rd parties, > >>as was done to fix the ludicrous sound situation in SCGT. > >> > >>With SCGT, I rushed out and bought it, and lived with the crap > >>sound for a while until someone finally made an editor to rip > >>the sounds. At that time, I changed the engine and other sounds > >>and my SCGT sounds are on GTINSIDER, and other sites etc.. > >>The sounds that I and others created made SCGT much more > >>likeable. Again, this will have to be done to fixed the f**ked-up > >>F1-2000 TIRE SQUEAL, of all things. > >> > >>I simply can't bear to listen to it, and I won't be paying for > >>F1-2000 until it is fixed. Don't worry, I won't be sitting here at > >>home secretly using this warez copy of F1-2000. It is off my drive. > >>I will wait and see if there are any editors released and what the > >>user comments are, prior to running it again. If it is fixed, I will > >>buy it that day. Not before. > >> > >>I HATE the squealing sound!!!!!!! ;) > >> > >>* OTHER REASONS I would be irritated even if the SQUEALING > >>problems were fixed. > >> > >>EA/ISI: > >> > >>Why is there only about a 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel prior to full > >>braking? I use a TSW wheel/pedals and I don't have this problem > >>in any other sim. What's up with F1-2000 that it will go full > >>brakes with 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel? I have over 2" of pedal > >>travel in my pedals and you only let me use 1/4-1/2" of the 2". > >> > >>It really, really makes it difficult to modulate the brakes, > >>EA/ISI, when you design your simulator this way. Care to > >>tell us why it is like that? Is there a way that the users can > >>do yet more hacking to fix this problem? Will you help them hack it? > >> > >>Also, EA/ISI, why is it that even with SMOKE detail at LOW > >>that every car, including mine, emits powerful plumes of SMOKE > >>at nearly EVERY corner? The first time I saw it, I thought the > >>entire field had blown their engines.. LOL. I had to turn off the > >>smoke in order to see where I was going, when following the AI. > >>What's up with that, EA/ISI, and will you help 3rd parties hack > >>it to act like real racecars do? > >> > >>EA/ISI, why does the run down to Eau Rouge, one of the most > >>famous and recognizable sections of race track in the WORLD, > >>have only a -very- slight slope, not a dramatic drop, like in real
life?
Quoted text (72 lines)> >>Same with Monaco.. > >> > >>Why are the elevations made MUCH less dramatic than in real life? > >>You may remember that you did the -same- thing in SCGT with > >>Road Atlanta and with Laguna Seca. Didn't user comments affect > >>you when you created this new title. Do you at ISI have a TV or > >>VCR so you could actually LOOK at an F1 race and see that the > >>elevation changes in F1-2000 are FAR too understated? > >> > >>[sigh] > >> > >>* Note to newsgroup: I have some other irritants that bother me > >>with this title, including the POOR graphics performance. I won't > >>belabor those, since I can simply reduce major amounts of detail, > >>view distances, cars viewed, etc. I can crank down the res to > >>640x480 on my PIII-600/256mb/V3-3000. Silly crap like graphics > >>beauty shouldn't bother me, cos' after all, I'm hard core, right? > >> > >>I have to do this majorly reduced detail thing to maintain a > >>*consistently* decent framerate in *races* with F1-2000. > >> > >>After my ranting, some of you may wonder who pissed in my Cheerios. > >>Well, I guess my expectations pissed in my Cheerios. I thought > >>this was gonna be a nice sim, and in many areas it is VERY nice. > >>Physics modeling, for example, is very impressive. FWIW, there > >>is more to enjoyable sim racing, for me, than simply the physics > >>modeling. > >> > >>EA/ISI: > >> > >>What's up with the engine sound? Why does it make > >>those little frequency jumps as it revs up? This is most > >>noticeable in the external replay. It's as if you take a sound > >>loop and change it's frequency in steps. You do something > >>like: 8000,8300,8600,8900, etc. The jumps are very noticeable > >>and sound silly. It would be much better if the jumps were > >>MUCH smaller, like 8000,8025,8050,8075,8100 .. etc. > >> > >>This is not a biggie, I'm just wondering if there is some > >>way to [sigh] 'hack' it to make it sound like a real racecar, and > >>not some cheap FOR..NEXT loop in an 80's BASIC program. > >> > >>[shrug] > >> > >>O.K, enough whining, I am gonna go do something else and try to > >>make my ears stop squealing, and put a few drops of Visine in my > >>eyes to clear out the tire smoke. :) > >> > >>There is a -nice- sim under all of the incredibly bad elevation > >>and sound detail, and I will buy F1-2000 immediately when it > >>is *fixed*, by either the developer (unlikely) or by 3rd parties. > >> > >>Not before. > >> > >>For now, I am going to sit back and watch people post that this > >>can't be the 'final retail' version, and that all will be well in the > >>REAL store-bought version, that my controller and system is crap, > >>that I should support 'hardcore' developers by buying it anyway, > >>that I am a pirate slimeball, (even though I have an unfixed > >>PURCHASED Nascar Revolution on my shelf)... Blah, Blah, Blah. > >> > >>I guess when it actually hits the store shelves all of these questions > >>will be answered by the posts here in this newsgroup. > >> > >>You heard it here first .. . :) > >> > >>Let the flames commence. Next .. > > -- > * rrev at mindspring dot com > * unit.26 - s.p.u.t.u.m. > * http://www.cabal.net
"Marc Collins" <[email hidden]> wrote > Does this newsgroup seem a lot less....civilised of late? Is this whatthe > warez crowd brings? Good sarcastic reply rrevved, but really, what's > happening? I know... what's happening with this NG? Is it "the invasion of the dumb warez crowd" movie shooting? People ask dumb questions like "kewl wear cani dload the gamez". What's next? People start to actually love the Test Drive series? Teehee ;) -- -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> -- May the Downforce be with you... -- http://www.WeRace.net -- People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world.
Quoted text (7 lines)> EA/ISI: > > Why is there only about a 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel prior to full > braking? I use a TSW wheel/pedals and I don't have this problem > in any other sim. What's up with F1-2000 that it will go full > brakes with 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel? I have over 2" of pedal > travel in my pedals and you only let me use 1/4-1/2" of the 2".
I've read F1 drivers say that people don't understand the brakes in an F1 car. It's not how far you push the pedal, it's how hard you push it. There is very little pedal travel. So by your admission, ISI has modeled this dead on. Whether it's a suitable for computer simulations is left up to the user.
Hypocritical asshole.................. "ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:QHTA4.80147$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (9 lines)> "Marc Collins" <[email hidden]> wrote > > Does this newsgroup seem a lot less....civilised of late? Is this what > the > > warez crowd brings? Good sarcastic reply rrevved, but really, what's > > happening? > > I know... what's happening with this NG? > > Is it "the invasion of the dumb warez crowd" movie shooting? People ask
dumb > questions like "kewl wear cani dload the gamez". What's next? Peoplestart
Quoted text (9 lines)> to actually love the Test Drive series? Teehee ;) > > > > -- > -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> > -- May the Downforce be with you... > -- http://www.WeRace.net > -- People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't
realise > how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world. > > >
RC2000 RULEZ! --DK "ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:QHTA4.80147$[email hidden]... > > I know... what's happening with this NG? > > Is it "the invasion of the dumb warez crowd" movie shooting? People askdumb > questions like "kewl wear cani dload the gamez". What's next? Peoplestart > to actually love the Test Drive series? Teehee ;)
Just learned some words with more than one syllable, have we?. -- Regards, Bruce Kennewell, Canberra, Australia. --------------------------- benh <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:38d4e220.5627632@news... > You're just a fuckin' whiner, i didn't even notice the tire sounds, > any chance you have a piece of shit soundcard that only handles a > couple channels at a time? because the sounds were great on my machine > with and SBLive and FPS2000 speakers. I also liked the default sounds > in SCGT way more than all the overdone ones by other people, i still > use the defaults with it as well, i think the problem many people have > with sounds comes from the fact they have shitless sound > cards/speakers etc..
(snip) > I've read F1 drivers say that people don't understand the brakes in an F1 > car. It's not how far you push the pedal, it's how hard you push it.(unsnip) I thought that applied to *ALL* cars? I know mine all comply (thank God!) -- Regards, Bruce Kennewell, Canberra, Australia. --------------------------- AndrewS <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:YVTA4.11042$[email hidden]...
DAVE'S 1:04 AT WATKINS GLEN RULEZ! Tell us more about it please. David G Fisher David Karr" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:8b12j7$flp$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (18 lines)> RC2000 RULEZ! > > --DK > > "ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:QHTA4.80147$[email hidden]... > > > > > I know... what's happening with this NG? > > > > Is it "the invasion of the dumb warez crowd" movie shooting? People ask > dumb > > questions like "kewl wear cani dload the gamez". What's next? People > start > > to actually love the Test Drive series? Teehee ;) > > >
Unshoulder that chip! As for the 1:04--alas, it has not happened again . . .to date. --DK "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:JJVA4.3443$[email hidden]... > DAVE'S 1:04 AT WATKINS GLEN RULEZ! > > Tell us more about it please. > > David G Fisher
Hey, what did you expect, something like GPL? :) Just drove 2 hours at Australia, certainly all the mentioned shortcomings are true, graphics and sound stuff, but I really, really like this game. Sorry... :) Andre On 18 Mar 2000 18:19:48 GMT, "Alexander Marx" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (9 lines)>I was thinking of the opposite effect, try turning in too early while >braking, I can't seem to provoke snap oversteer. It seems like braking is >simply a question of whether you are locking or not locking the brakes - no >weight transfer effects modelled. And yes, all possible aids are off. >Looking at the replay you'll see that the suspension movement is very much >exaggerated. And if you still aren't convinced that this sim is *not THAT >great* <g> then fire up a 100% GP and watch it as a spectator.... ROFLMAO >this is so ridiculous it's funny. >
In article <QHTA4.80147$[email hidden]>, [email hidden] wrote... > Is it "the invasion of the dumb warez crowd" movie shooting? People ask dumb > questions like "kewl wear cani dload the gamez". What's next? People start > to actually love the Test Drive series? Teehee ;) No - you have to do it like this: "kEwL cAnI dLoAd tHe gAmEz" - something like that anyways :P --David Cook
Just curious but have you guy's even tried adjusting the bias? I know in gpl if the bias is set 70% to the front you get the same effect. AndrewS wrote:
Quoted text (14 lines)> > > EA/ISI: > > > > Why is there only about a 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel prior to full > > braking? I use a TSW wheel/pedals and I don't have this problem > > in any other sim. What's up with F1-2000 that it will go full > > brakes with 1/4"-1/2" of pedal travel? I have over 2" of pedal > > travel in my pedals and you only let me use 1/4-1/2" of the 2". > > I've read F1 drivers say that people don't understand the brakes in an F1 > car. It's not how far you push the pedal, it's how hard you push it. There > is very little pedal travel. So by your admission, ISI has modeled this > dead on. Whether it's a suitable for computer simulations is left up to the > user.
No flames here...EA doesn't give a bloody sh*t about their customers...that's because their concerned about the nasdaq now...... What Molyneux does with games, they do with customers ;) Bart rrevved wrote: > > F1-2000 - Why I won't buy it on Day One.[snip] > Let the flames commence. Next ..
Alex try this, reduce brake ratio under 45%(front) / 55%(rear), at preciselly 44/56 snap oversteer will start :) Eric (don't tell anyone I tried the MYTH) wich I hope IS A BETA in disguise....) Alexander Marx wrote:
Quoted text (12 lines)> > I can definitely lose the car under braking. It will push (understeer) > > into the sandtrap. I think that part is pretty realistic. Are you > > driving with all of the driving aids off? > > I was thinking of the opposite effect, try turning in too early while > braking, I can't seem to provoke snap oversteer. It seems like braking is > simply a question of whether you are locking or not locking the brakes - no > weight transfer effects modelled. And yes, all possible aids are off. > Looking at the replay you'll see that the suspension movement is very much > exaggerated. And if you still aren't convinced that this sim is *not THAT > great* <g> then fire up a 100% GP and watch it as a spectator.... ROFLMAO > this is so ridiculous it's funny.
I read somewhere yesterday that the ISO (full cd version) had a better fps than the Myth version. Spent 4 hours downloading the ISO, but unfortunately it's exactly the same as Myth's version... Andre On Wed, 22 Mar 2000 19:34:30 -0500, Eric Cote <[email hidden]> wrote: >Alex try this, reduce brake ratio under 45%(front) / 55%(rear), at preciselly >44/56 snap oversteer will start :) > >Eric > >(don't tell anyone I tried the MYTH) wich I hope IS A BETA in disguise....)

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy