On Fri, 24 Mar 2000 03:26:05 GMT, "ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote:
..and they are?
--
* rrev at mindspring dot com *
Buying F1 2000 at release and the ethics of public plonks
Some posters announced they were buying F1 2000 at release as the best F1 sim to date, while ymenard and Mrv called it below average. The thread turned into a meta-argument about whether announcing killfile plonks publicly was useful, and Jo Helsen asked the feuding parties to take it elsewhere.
Automated summary.
On Thu, 23 Mar 2000 23:43:07 GMT, "Snake" <[email hidden]> wrote:
I like it too.
I will probably go to EB tomorrow and get it.
--
* rrev at mindspring dot com *
Quoted text (17 lines)
>Reserved it today and will pick it tomorrow, and I will then own the best >F1 racing sim released to date. Flaws or no flaws it will still beat the >previous games by miles, and I`m sure people will discover ways of tweaking >the game and then theres the possible add ons and patches to come. >From what I`ve learnt in this group this game will be able to be improved >substancially. I raced CPR at the Zone another game people seem to slate >easily but it was very enjoyable to play online and from what I`ve heard the >online code is good, so I hope to enjoy this game alot. >Yes I played the warez version and yes I will purchase the game the first >day of its release. >Interested to hear somone post earlier they got the game from Dixons in >London today, I phoned my local EB and they told me it would be tomorrow and >kindly reserved me a copy. >Look forward to discussing the game further with those who buy it. > >Adrian. >On Fri, 24 Mar 2000 01:55:44 GMT, "ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote:
So what do you play, Frank... GPL and Quake3?
--
* rrev at mindspring dot com *
Quoted text (13 lines)
>"Snake" <[email hidden]> wrote >> Reserved it today and will pick it tomorrow, and I will then own the best >> F1 racing sim released to date. > >I don't understand the logic. > >All curent Formula 1 titles are either 1) outdated 2) not realistic or 3) >simply arcade. So when a below-average titles gets released, even if higher >rated than the others, it's a GOOD thing and we should all buy it, since >under your logic it's the best and you own it? > >I would rather spend time on better quality titles than owning a bad, even >if the "best of the bad" Formula 1 title.Reserved it today and will pick it tomorrow, and I will then own the best
F1 racing sim released to date. Flaws or no flaws it will still beat the
previous games by miles, and I`m sure people will discover ways of tweaking
the game and then theres the possible add ons and patches to come.
From what I`ve learnt in this group this game will be able to be improved
substancially. I raced CPR at the Zone another game people seem to slate
easily but it was very enjoyable to play online and from what I`ve heard the
online code is good, so I hope to enjoy this game alot.
Yes I played the warez version and yes I will purchase the game the first
day of its release.
Interested to hear somone post earlier they got the game from Dixons in
London today, I phoned my local EB and they told me it would be tomorrow and
kindly reserved me a copy.
Look forward to discussing the game further with those who buy it.
Adrian.
On Fri, 24 Mar 2000 23:14:28 +0100, Ronald Stoehr <[email hidden]> wrote:
So, I guess you don't understand the reasoning behind making a
plonk public?
Here, I'll help you:
You see, Roland, if a plonk is not made public, then the plonkee can
falsely accuse the plonker of something or can continue to make
comments about said plonker, which, after killfiling the plonkee,
will obviously go unchallenged by the plonker. This makes the plonker
appear to the other posters here, to either agree with the plonkee,
or to think that the plonker must be thick as a post for not responding
to even more bullshit from the plonkee, which he obviously can't,
since he sees no more of the plonkee's posts.
Now, Roland, your brain is full.
*p-l-o-
--
* rrev at mindspring dot com *
Quoted text (15 lines)
>Stephen Ferguson wrote: >> >> rrevved <[email hidden]> wrote in message >snip >> > >> > Why not just killfile them if you don't like it? >> > >> >> I neither killfile nor do I get too upset at having to wade through the >> flamewars, as it is usually obvious within the first few words what the post >> is about. The only problem with the killfile is that *occasionally* some > >But then you're not able to post cute little messages containing just >one word, that being "plonk". Oh, you could killfile people >without telling everybody that you did? I didn't know that...On the following date: Fri, 24 Mar 2000 14:45:45 GMT, said person(s)
Studs Ramrod <[email hidden]> stated:
>OK, there are problems with it, namely processor hungry graphics,
>circuit realism, crap AI and sound etc, but I dont find these a big
>enough problem to dissuade me from buying it.
Ok.. just WHAT would qualify as a reason NOT to buy it then?
- James "Gunslinger" Wohlever
[email hidden]
Techware Computer Services
http://techware.gtinsider.com
Send ATTACHMENTS (Files) to:
[email hidden]
Stephen Ferguson wrote:
>
> rrevved <[email hidden]> wrote in messagesnip
But then you're not able to post cute little messages containing just
one word, that being "plonk". Oh, you could killfile people
without telling everybody that you did? I didn't know that...
--
l8er
ronny
Your mouse has moved. Windows must be restarted for the change
to take effect. Reboot now?
|\ _,,,---,,_ I want to die like my Grandfather,
ZZZzz /,`.-'`' -. ;-;;,_ in his sleep.
|,4- ) )-,_. ,\ ( `'-' Not like the people in his car,
'---''(_/--' `-'\_) screaming their heads off!
Quoted text (7 lines)
> > > > Why not just killfile them if you don't like it? > > > > I neither killfile nor do I get too upset at having to wade through the > flamewars, as it is usually obvious within the first few words what the post > is about. The only problem with the killfile is that *occasionally* some
I too have gone out and bought it this morning, after playing the Myth
(supposedly final?) ISO release, and look forward to participating in
some healthy chat and seeing fan sites spring up about F12000.
(by the way I'm at work just now, and taking part in a karting event
tonight, so I wont be able to give any info on final retail release
until I install it tomorrow)
OK, there are problems with it, namely processor hungry graphics,
circuit realism, crap AI and sound etc, but I dont find these a big
enough problem to dissuade me from buying it.
For you info, my system is a Pentium II 333, 128 Mb RAM and Voodoo3 2000
card. Initially, I could only run at a good fps in practice, but after
reading some posts in here and High Gear forum about hot to edit the
.cfg file to alter the number of cars on the grid (I changed this to 10
for my PC) it run smooth as silk.
Then, a couple of days later, there was the post about altering the
mipmap entry in the .cfg from a "0" to a "1" - again a drastic
improvement in frame rate, and I now run a full grid with no mirrors (I
have my LWFF configured with a button to look behind, just as good),
medium settings for car detail, bitmap detail etc and the game runs fine
with me now.
The sound will no doubt be patched by some bright coder out there, I can
hot lap or race in multiplay and not bother about AI and although the
circuits may not be perfect...big deal....its a circuit and your racing
on it....is that not what its all about?
I own many driving sims (GP2, GPL, F1RS, MGPRS, Rally2000, NFS 3 & 4,
Colin McRae, GP500, Superbikes 2000 etc) although my favourites are
definately F1 sims - I have been a morotcycle owner for 20 years but
beautiful as these games are looking now, I just never get the feeling
of driving a bike in them. Until some company brings out a set of FF
handlebars with working throttle, clutch etc I dont think they ever
will.
I'm absolutely gagging on GP3 coming out in July, but F12000 will keep
me happy until then, I definately consider it the best of the current
crop of F1 games available, and I'm sure fans will beging to release
addons for tobacco sponsored cars, new sounds etc, and I am still
hopefull that EA will supoort this sim with patches etc.
Simple rule - if you enjoy it buy it, if you hate it save your money.
Look forward to you comments.
Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
Before you buy.
rrevved <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> On Fri, 24 Mar 2000 13:50:57 GMT, [email hidden] (Jo Helsen)wrote:
I neither killfile nor do I get too upset at having to wade through the
flamewars, as it is usually obvious within the first few words what the post
is about. The only problem with the killfile is that *occasionally* some
pearls of wisdom might be dropped by one of these two, although I suppose
eventually those can be culled via replies to such posts.
Stephen
Quoted text (11 lines)
> > >Could the two of you please launch seperate threads for your personal > >wars? Or at least start messages with "don't bother". > > > >Thanks. > > > >JoH > > > > Why not just killfile them if you don't like it? >On Fri, 24 Mar 2000 13:50:57 GMT, [email hidden] (Jo Helsen) wrote:
Why not just killfile them if you don't like it?
--
* rrev at mindspring dot com *
Quoted text (7 lines)
>Could the two of you please launch seperate threads for your personal >wars? Or at least start messages with "don't bother". > >Thanks. > >JoH >Quoted text (10 lines)
>On Fri, 24 Mar 2000 13:01:56 GMT, Barton Brown <[email hidden]> >wrote: > >>Finally, something I can wholeheartedly agree with. >> >>BB >> >>ymenard wrote: >>> >>> I don't understand the logic.
ymenard <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:AWzC4.8611$[email hidden]...
> "Snake" <[email hidden]> wrote
> > Reserved it today and will pick it tomorrow, and I will then own thebest
> > F1 racing sim released to date.
>
> I don't understand the logic.
>
The logic is fairly simple. It's fun, they enjoy it, they are going to buy
it. It's only 30 or 40 bucks after all.
Stephen
Jan Verschueren wrote in message ...
>Same here... won't be able to pick it up until next week tho' (will be at
>shop, but no time).
>
>Jan.
I`m self employed so its easy for me to make the time. Just give myself an
hour off (which is handy).
Look forward to everyones reations to the official release.
Same here... won't be able to pick it up until next week tho' (will be at
shop, but no time).
Jan.
=---
Snake <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:f_xC4.4443$[email hidden]...
> Reserved it today and will pick it tomorrow, and I will then own the best
> <snip>
"Snake" <[email hidden]> wrote
> Reserved it today and will pick it tomorrow, and I will then own the best
> F1 racing sim released to date.
I don't understand the logic.
All curent Formula 1 titles are either 1) outdated 2) not realistic or 3)
simply arcade. So when a below-average titles gets released, even if higher
rated than the others, it's a GOOD thing and we should all buy it, since
under your logic it's the best and you own it?
I would rather spend time on better quality titles than owning a bad, even
if the "best of the bad" Formula 1 title.
--
-- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard>
-- May the Downforce be with you...
-- http://www.WeRace.net
-- People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world.
You must be joking. This game is outright trash. Nothing can fix this other
than a new release for 2001 and that might not be enough. Gp3 hurry up!!!
Snake wrote:
Quoted text (16 lines)
> Reserved it today and will pick it tomorrow, and I will then own the best > F1 racing sim released to date. Flaws or no flaws it will still beat the > previous games by miles, and I`m sure people will discover ways of tweaking > the game and then theres the possible add ons and patches to come. > From what I`ve learnt in this group this game will be able to be improved > substancially. I raced CPR at the Zone another game people seem to slate > easily but it was very enjoyable to play online and from what I`ve heard the > online code is good, so I hope to enjoy this game alot. > Yes I played the warez version and yes I will purchase the game the first > day of its release. > Interested to hear somone post earlier they got the game from Dixons in > London today, I phoned my local EB and they told me it would be tomorrow and > kindly reserved me a copy. > Look forward to discussing the game further with those who buy it. > > Adrian."rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote
> >I would rather spend time on better quality titles than owning a bad,even
> >if the "best of the bad" Formula 1 title.
>
> So what do you play, Frank... GPL and Quake3?
I unfortunately have no time for non-racing games. Wish a day had more than
24hours, as there is great gems in other game categories that are
incredible. My rotation of frequent racing games is around 5 presently.
The last non-racing games I tried were X-Wing Alliance, Fighter Ace, Links
LS and Roller Coaster Tycoon. I go back to almost a year with XWA, so you
can see how much time I have
--
-- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard>
-- May the Downforce be with you...
-- http://www.WeRace.net
-- People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world.
"rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote
> >I unfortunately have no time for non-racing games. Wish a day had morethan
> >24hours, as there is great gems in other game categories that are
> >incredible. My rotation of frequent racing games is around 5 presently.
>
> ..and they are?
Hmm let's see... This month they are :
Grand Prix Legends
Nascar Racing 3
Rally Championship 2000
Grand Prix World
SBK 2000
Everything else (DTR, Driver, Gp2, MGPRS2, AMA SBK, Icr2, Viper, Soda,
Toca2, etc..) is raced when I have time, willing, want to try new things or
want to change my idea. My game opinion can vary alot with time.
--
-- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard>
-- May the Downforce be with you...
-- http://www.WeRace.net
-- People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world.
On the following date: Fri, 24 Mar 2000 14:45:45 GMT, said person(s)
Ok.. just WHAT would qualify as a reason NOT to buy it then?
- James "Gunslinger" Wohlever
Techware Computer Services
http://techware.gtinsider.com
Send ATTACHMENTS (Files) to:
Finally, something I can wholeheartedly agree with.
BB
ymenard wrote:
>
> I don't understand the logic.
Could the two of you please launch seperate threads for your personal
wars? Or at least start messages with "don't bother".
Thanks.
JoH
On Fri, 24 Mar 2000 13:01:56 GMT, Barton Brown <[email hidden]>
wrote:
Quoted text (7 lines)
>Finally, something I can wholeheartedly agree with. > >BB > >ymenard wrote: >> >> I don't understand the logic.Great post Studs,
I really enjoyed reading it......feel free to drop into my thread called:
F1-2000 - Thoughts - Lap times - Lets race online :)
I cant wait to hear what changes are in the "real" full version (I pray the
AI is better).
I would also like to know when the full ver will be in Canada.....anyone
know ?
All the best,
Lorne
Studs Ramrod <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:8bfv2l$otj$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (51 lines)
> > > I too have gone out and bought it this morning, after playing the Myth > (supposedly final?) ISO release, and look forward to participating in > some healthy chat and seeing fan sites spring up about F12000. > (by the way I'm at work just now, and taking part in a karting event > tonight, so I wont be able to give any info on final retail release > until I install it tomorrow) > > OK, there are problems with it, namely processor hungry graphics, > circuit realism, crap AI and sound etc, but I dont find these a big > enough problem to dissuade me from buying it. > > For you info, my system is a Pentium II 333, 128 Mb RAM and Voodoo3 2000 > card. Initially, I could only run at a good fps in practice, but after > reading some posts in here and High Gear forum about hot to edit the > .cfg file to alter the number of cars on the grid (I changed this to 10 > for my PC) it run smooth as silk. > Then, a couple of days later, there was the post about altering the > mipmap entry in the .cfg from a "0" to a "1" - again a drastic > improvement in frame rate, and I now run a full grid with no mirrors (I > have my LWFF configured with a button to look behind, just as good), > medium settings for car detail, bitmap detail etc and the game runs fine > with me now. > The sound will no doubt be patched by some bright coder out there, I can > hot lap or race in multiplay and not bother about AI and although the > circuits may not be perfect...big deal....its a circuit and your racing > on it....is that not what its all about? > > I own many driving sims (GP2, GPL, F1RS, MGPRS, Rally2000, NFS 3 & 4, > Colin McRae, GP500, Superbikes 2000 etc) although my favourites are > definately F1 sims - I have been a morotcycle owner for 20 years but > beautiful as these games are looking now, I just never get the feeling > of driving a bike in them. Until some company brings out a set of FF > handlebars with working throttle, clutch etc I dont think they ever > will. > > I'm absolutely gagging on GP3 coming out in July, but F12000 will keep > me happy until then, I definately consider it the best of the current > crop of F1 games available, and I'm sure fans will beging to release > addons for tobacco sponsored cars, new sounds etc, and I am still > hopefull that EA will supoort this sim with patches etc. > > Simple rule - if you enjoy it buy it, if you hate it save your money. > > Look forward to you comments. > > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > Before you buy.On Fri, 24 Mar 2000 08:09:33 -0600, rrevved <[email hidden]>
wrote:
There are flamewar groups around. No need to use rec.autos.simulators
for it.
Hey, maybe ask them to forward their "proze" to your email address if
you enjoy it so much? <G>
JoH
Quoted text (11 lines)
>On Fri, 24 Mar 2000 13:50:57 GMT, [email hidden] (Jo Helsen) wrote: > >>Could the two of you please launch seperate threads for your personal >>wars? Or at least start messages with "don't bother". >> >>Thanks. >> >>JoH >> > >Why not just killfile them if you don't like it?"don't bother" sounds nice.
Jo Helsen wrote:
Quoted text (7 lines)
> > Could the two of you please launch seperate threads for your personal > wars? Or at least start messages with "don't bother". > > Thanks. > > JoH
rrevved <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> On Fri, 24 Mar 2000 23:14:28 +0100, Ronald Stoehr <[email hidden]>wrote:
post
> >> is about. The only problem with the killfile is that *occasionally*some
Roland has a point. Hang around a newsgroup for a while and you develop a
feel for who generally posts level-headed posts, and who posts drivel. For
example, if (through some strange set of circumstances) a Richard Clegg
happened to stir up a flamer, and then failed to respond to the flames, my
opinion of Richard Clegg would not change. I don't need him to tell me that
he is formally cutting any further communication with this particular
half-wit, because it is implicitly obvious. At the same time, I do not
develop doubts about Richard's character, that he has failed to respond to
the challenge. It is a non-issue.
My take on it is that the whole business of letting people know that they
have been dropped into a killfile is simply a matter of having the last
word, then severing the communication. It's like saying "you're wrong" then
sticking your fingers in your ears and singing "nyah nyah nyah, I can't hear
you".
Stephen
Quoted text (11 lines)
> > >Stephen Ferguson wrote: > >> > >> rrevved <[email hidden]> wrote in message > >snip > >> > > >> > Why not just killfile them if you don't like it? > >> > > >> > >> I neither killfile nor do I get too upset at having to wade through the > >> flamewars, as it is usually obvious within the first few words what theQuoted text (24 lines)
> > > >But then you're not able to post cute little messages containing just > >one word, that being "plonk". Oh, you could killfile people > >without telling everybody that you did? I didn't know that... > > So, I guess you don't understand the reasoning behind making a > plonk public? > > Here, I'll help you: > > You see, Roland, if a plonk is not made public, then the plonkee can > falsely accuse the plonker of something or can continue to make > comments about said plonker, which, after killfiling the plonkee, > will obviously go unchallenged by the plonker. This makes the plonker > appear to the other posters here, to either agree with the plonkee, > or to think that the plonker must be thick as a post for not responding > to even more bullshit from the plonkee, which he obviously can't, > since he sees no more of the plonkee's posts. > > Now, Roland, your brain is full. > > *p-l-o- > > --On Sat, 25 Mar 2000 18:59:51 +0100, "Stephen Ferguson" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Hmm, I don't see it that way at all, as I explained in
excruciating detail. All I can say is that if you don't
like my posts, feel free to drop me in your killfile.
Publicly or privately.
--
* rrev at mindspring dot com *
Quoted text (62 lines)
> >rrevved <[email hidden]> wrote in message >news:[email hidden]... >> On Fri, 24 Mar 2000 23:14:28 +0100, Ronald Stoehr <[email hidden]> >wrote: >> >> >Stephen Ferguson wrote: >> >> >> >> rrevved <[email hidden]> wrote in message >> >snip >> >> > >> >> > Why not just killfile them if you don't like it? >> >> > >> >> >> >> I neither killfile nor do I get too upset at having to wade through the >> >> flamewars, as it is usually obvious within the first few words what the >post >> >> is about. The only problem with the killfile is that *occasionally* >some >> > >> >But then you're not able to post cute little messages containing just >> >one word, that being "plonk". Oh, you could killfile people >> >without telling everybody that you did? I didn't know that... >> >> So, I guess you don't understand the reasoning behind making a >> plonk public? >> >> Here, I'll help you: >> >> You see, Roland, if a plonk is not made public, then the plonkee can >> falsely accuse the plonker of something or can continue to make >> comments about said plonker, which, after killfiling the plonkee, >> will obviously go unchallenged by the plonker. This makes the plonker >> appear to the other posters here, to either agree with the plonkee, >> or to think that the plonker must be thick as a post for not responding >> to even more bullshit from the plonkee, which he obviously can't, >> since he sees no more of the plonkee's posts. >> >> Now, Roland, your brain is full. >> >> *p-l-o- >> >> -- > >Roland has a point. Hang around a newsgroup for a while and you develop a >feel for who generally posts level-headed posts, and who posts drivel. For >example, if (through some strange set of circumstances) a Richard Clegg >happened to stir up a flamer, and then failed to respond to the flames, my >opinion of Richard Clegg would not change. I don't need him to tell me that >he is formally cutting any further communication with this particular >half-wit, because it is implicitly obvious. At the same time, I do not >develop doubts about Richard's character, that he has failed to respond to >the challenge. It is a non-issue. > >My take on it is that the whole business of letting people know that they >have been dropped into a killfile is simply a matter of having the last >word, then severing the communication. It's like saying "you're wrong" then >sticking your fingers in your ears and singing "nyah nyah nyah, I can't hear >you". > >Stephen >rrevved wrote:
>
> On Fri, 24 Mar 2000 23:14:28 +0100, Ronald Stoehr <[email hidden]> wrote:snip
Well, rreeved, you must have cleared your killfile, as you respond to
my little post.
Man, did you ever try just ignoring a guy worth plonking. Most of the
other guys know implicitely which guy needs to be ignored without
responding. I'm just waiting for you to plonk a spammer, that'd be the
maximum of useless "plonkmania".
BTW, you really think your little drivel could fill my brain? Funny.
Now, did I get a 3/4 plonk this time? What's the "*", a wildcard plonk?
You ARE a strange person...
--
l8er
ronny
Your mouse has moved. Windows must be restarted for the change
to take effect. Reboot now?
|\ _,,,---,,_ I want to die like my Grandfather,
ZZZzz /,`.-'`' -. ;-;;,_ in his sleep.
|,4- ) )-,_. ,\ ( `'-' Not like the people in his car,
'---''(_/--' `-'\_) screaming their heads off!
Quoted text (21 lines)
> >But then you're not able to post cute little messages containing just > >one word, that being "plonk". Oh, you could killfile people > >without telling everybody that you did? I didn't know that... > > So, I guess you don't understand the reasoning behind making a > plonk public? > > Here, I'll help you: > > You see, Roland, if a plonk is not made public, then the plonkee can > falsely accuse the plonker of something or can continue to make > comments about said plonker, which, after killfiling the plonkee, > will obviously go unchallenged by the plonker. This makes the plonker > appear to the other posters here, to either agree with the plonkee, > or to think that the plonker must be thick as a post for not responding > to even more bullshit from the plonkee, which he obviously can't, > since he sees no more of the plonkee's posts. > > Now, Roland, your brain is full. > > *p-l-o-I just want to express my delight that the words "plonker" and "plonkee"
have entered my vocabulary. I love 'em, truly!
no doubt verging on plonkability himself,
--DK
"rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> On Fri, 24 Mar 2000 23:14:28 +0100, Ronald Stoehr <[email hidden]>wrote:
Quoted text (15 lines)
> You see, Roland, if a plonk is not made public, then the plonkee can > falsely accuse the plonker of something or can continue to make > comments about said plonker, which, after killfiling the plonkee, > will obviously go unchallenged by the plonker. This makes the plonker > appear to the other posters here, to either agree with the plonkee, > or to think that the plonker must be thick as a post for not responding > to even more bullshit from the plonkee, which he obviously can't, > since he sees no more of the plonkee's posts. > > Now, Roland, your brain is full. > > *p-l-o- > > -- > * rrev at mindspring dot com *Maybe there could be a newsgroup "rec.plonk.everybody"--but I imagine it'd
be a bit weird after a bit. . .
--DK
"Ronald Stoehr" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
[snip] useless "plonkmania"
> --
> l8er
> ronny
David Karr wrote:
>
> Maybe there could be a newsgroup "rec.plonk.everybody"--but I imagine it'd
> be a bit weird after a bit. . .
>
> --DK
There is: it's called alt.flame. If you think THIS place is nuts....
BB
On Sun, 26 Mar 2000 12:58:00 +0200, "Stephen Ferguson" <[email hidden]> wrote:
>You are
>concerned about the false impression others may have when they read the
>subsequent one-sided messages from the "plonkee" only, as you would not be
>able to respond, having no access to those posts. My point was it doesn't
>really matter.
It matters to -me- Steve.
'nuf sed.
--
* rrev at mindspring dot com *
rrevved <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> On Sat, 25 Mar 2000 18:59:51 +0100, "Stephen Ferguson"<[email hidden]> wrote:
the
> >> >> flamewars, as it is usually obvious within the first few words whatthe
a
> >feel for who generally posts level-headed posts, and who posts drivel.For
> >example, if (through some strange set of circumstances) a Richard Clegg
> >happened to stir up a flamer, and then failed to respond to the flames,my
> >opinion of Richard Clegg would not change. I don't need him to tell methat
> >he is formally cutting any further communication with this particular
> >half-wit, because it is implicitly obvious. At the same time, I do not
> >develop doubts about Richard's character, that he has failed to respondto
> >the challenge. It is a non-issue.
> >
> >My take on it is that the whole business of letting people know that they
> >have been dropped into a killfile is simply a matter of having the last
> >word, then severing the communication. It's like saying "you're wrong"then
> >sticking your fingers in your ears and singing "nyah nyah nyah, I can'thear
My first paragraph addresses the concerns you have which lead you to
publicly state that you have dropped someone into a killfile. You are
concerned about the false impression others may have when they read the
subsequent one-sided messages from the "plonkee" only, as you would not be
able to respond, having no access to those posts. My point was it doesn't
really matter. We know most of the regulars here. We certainly know your
opinions, rrevved, so there is little chance we would be lead to believe
that you implicitly agree with the "plonkee" when you suddenly fall silent
in a thread. Anyway, my response is just an opinion, which is what the
dialogue in these groups is about. It wasn't a question of liking your
posts of not.


































