Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Re: Schumacher turns in before he brakes!!

21 posts by 14 people · 25 Mar 2000 - 26 Mar 2000 21:54 UTC

Schumacher turning in before braking at Melbourne

James Pickard reported seeing Schumacher turn into Turn 1 at Melbourne before braking on a qualifying lap. This drew scepticism and a debate on trail braking and aero drag. ymenard argued that F1 2000 made such techniques too easy. Jan Verschueren distinguished between sims that emulate real skills and sims that recreate the experience.

real motorsportphysics/realism debatesetup/driving techniqueF1 2000

Automated summary.

> turned into turn one before he hit the brakes!!!! well you've been there and I've not been there but I still don't believe you ;-)... it sounds so incredible, those cars are doing 300 kph at the main straight - please tell me at least that he lifted earlier otherwise: impossible. P.S. On the TV it looked to me like they brake at about 70-80 meters before T1 cheers, Alex
James Pickard <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:1F5D4.3694$[email hidden]... > > And Schumacher was the only one I could see doing this.. Everyone seemedto > brake later than the 50 meter board, but Michael was the only one who > actualy turned in before he hit the brakes.. > No, no, no! You can't do that. Our resident expert in the newsgroup has told us repeatedly that, with modern F1 cars, the sequence is brake, let off, *then* turn in. This is the *only* way that it can be done with modern F1 cars. Don't believe your eyes, because we have it from a higher authority. :-) Stephen
rrevved 25 Mar 2000#284033
On Sat, 25 Mar 2000 18:51:56 GMT, "ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (11 lines)>"Stephen Ferguson" <[email hidden]> wrote >> No, no, no! You can't do that. Our resident expert in the newsgroup has >> told us repeatedly that, with modern F1 cars, the sequence is brake, let >> off, *then* turn in. This is the *only* way that it can be done with >modern >> F1 cars. Don't believe your eyes, because we have it from a higher >> authority. :-) > >You failed to notice what those person wrote after, saying that only few >drivers, like Michael Schumacher are able to do that. Clearly not the >average human racecar driver like a good portion of gamers are...
Yawn.. -- * rrev at mindspring dot com *
BK 25 Mar 2000 18:49 UTC#284000
Maybe he was using engine braking there`s no way he would be in 6th gear just before a turn.
ymenard 25 Mar 2000 18:51 UTC#284001
"Stephen Ferguson" <[email hidden]> wrote > No, no, no! You can't do that. Our resident expert in the newsgroup has > told us repeatedly that, with modern F1 cars, the sequence is brake, let > off, *then* turn in. This is the *only* way that it can be done withmodern > F1 cars. Don't believe your eyes, because we have it from a higher > authority. :-) You failed to notice what those person wrote after, saying that only few drivers, like Michael Schumacher are able to do that. Clearly not the average human racecar driver like a good portion of gamers are... -- -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> -- May the Downforce be with you... -- http://www.WeRace.net -- People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world.
ymenard 25 Mar 2000 18:53 UTC#284002
"James Pickard" <[email hidden]> wrote > And Schumacher was the only one I could see doing this.. Everyone seemedto > brake later than the 50 meter board, but Michael was the only one who > actualy turned in before he hit the brakes.. Yet, F1 2000 shows us that the common human can do this constantly without any problem lap after lap... (thanks for proving my point). That was still incredible driving by those F1 drivers today. -- -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> -- May the Downforce be with you... -- http://www.WeRace.net -- People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world.
David Masten 25 Mar 2000 20:38 UTC#283896
In article <01bf968a$c8ed2060$2949a8c2@default>, "BK" <[email hidden]> wrote: > >Maybe he was using engine braking >there`s no way he would be in 6th gear >just before a turn. I've read that indy cars aero-brake at more than 1G just be lifting off at about 200 mph. And it is easy to calculate that this is about right. Throw in more wing for a road track and I'd bet even a higher G level. Still, my instructor would have said that you should either be on the gas or on the brake, no coasting allowed :-) Sorry, don't remember exactly where they were braking when I was a Montreal at the hairpin two years back. Off topic, I find it disturbing in F1 sims where I see cars constantly shifting down to first gear on turns like T1-T3 at Monza. From what I've read, 1st gear is used to start, and come out of the pits, and that's about it (maybe Monaco??). Can't they get this right??
Stefan Magnusson 25 Mar 2000 20:47 UTC#284020
There is an article in the Feb/Mar issue of the Race Tech magazine, discussing linear vs. digressive (nosey) damping and how this possibly allows Schumi to be able to turn in earlier than the opposition. The article doesn't mention anything about braking before or after turn in, but it is interesting reading nevertheless. Stefan James Pickard wrote:
Quoted text (33 lines)> > I just thought I would repeat what I posted a little further down.... > > I was at the Australian Grand Prix a few weeks ago. I have watched F1 cars > for a long time... but one thing stuck in my mind that showed me how > amazing these guys and cars are.... > > I was lucky enough to get myself into the Jaguar corporate suite (by > accident!), I just wandered in.... and before I knew it, there was green > furniture and fittings all around me!! woops.. oh welll :-) > > I then went up stair and stood about 20 feet above the GP teams (saw all > the drivers and managers etc..) I had a great view of the front straight > and the entrance to turn one. > > I watched the practise session and then the qualifying session. Now these > cars are fast.. but I knew that. > > What TOTALLY blew me away was the way these cars brake and stop. Watching > all the cars drive down into turn 1. they drove past the 150 meter board, > past the 100 meter board, past the 50 meter board (!!!) .. TURN IN!!! and > then you hear them down shift!!!! > > This was Michael Schumacher on his final qualifying attempt. He actually > turned into turn one before he hit the brakes!!!! > > Absolutely AMAZING!! > > And Schumacher was the only one I could see doing this.. Everyone seemed to > brake later than the 50 meter board, but Michael was the only one who > actualy turned in before he hit the brakes.. > > James Pickard
Remco Moedt 25 Mar 2000 22:56 UTC#283849
"James Pickard" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (7 lines)>What TOTALLY blew me away was the way these cars brake and stop. Watching >all the cars drive down into turn 1. they drove past the 150 meter board, >past the 100 meter board, past the 50 meter board (!!!) .. TURN IN!!! and >then you hear them down shift!!!! > >This was Michael Schumacher on his final qualifying attempt. He actually >turned into turn one before he hit the brakes!!!!
How do you know he didn't hit the brake before? He had brakelights? <g> Some while ago the story was that Schumacher doesn't lift the throttle when he does his turns (well, in certain turns), to keep the revs in the powerband, like they did in the turbo era, then to keep the boost high. Maybe this was the case? Remco
ymenard 25 Mar 2000 23:55 UTC#283879
"Jan Verschueren" <[email hidden]> wrote
Quoted text (7 lines)> IMO there's two sides to simming in general: one is about recreating the > situation as accurately as possible, allowing for people to attempt to > emulate the skills of their real world counterparts on their computer. The > other is to recreate the "experience" as accurately as possible for the > "average" gamer. > > Ideally every sim should offer both, but I'm quite happy if a sim manges
to > pull off either. This is why I like F1 2000: an easy enough sim so I canget > my mates to race me instead of fragging me at our LAN meetings (hey, Ilike > winning too <g>). True, but this is where helps and driving aid come in place. With quality helps and aids, you can model both the recreation and the emulation. Taking all of them out, you shouldn't be able to be able to do such things like in F1-2000. If gaming developpers understood that, everybody would be happy. People that like your above point (I know the majority are them) can enjoy the title, and at the same time people who want full realism are able to. Even GPL, to some extent, doesn't necessary show what those cars were REALLY. -- -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> -- May the Downforce be with you... -- http://www.WeRace.net -- People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world.
<[email hidden]> wrote in message news:8bj83v$74p4$[email hidden]... > In article <01bf968a$c8ed2060$2949a8c2@default>, "BK"<[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (7 lines)> > > >Maybe he was using engine braking > >there`s no way he would be in 6th gear > >just before a turn. > > I've read that indy cars aero-brake at more than 1G just be lifting off at > about 200 mph. And it is easy to calculate that this is about right.
Throw > in more wing for a road track and I'd bet even a higher G level. Still,my > instructor would have said that you should either be on the gas or on the > brake, no coasting allowed :-) > > Sorry, don't remember exactly where they were braking when I was aMontreal at > the hairpin two years back. > > Off topic, I find it disturbing in F1 sims where I see cars constantly > shifting down to first gear on turns like T1-T3 at Monza. From what I've > read, 1st gear is used to start, and come out of the pits, and that'sabout it > (maybe Monaco??). Can't they get this right?? > Just change your gears. It's not so disturbing. Stephen
Chris 26 Mar 2000#283810
It's called trail braking and is about the fastest way of getting round a corner, but only works when you get the line just right and manage to slow down before the apex. Try in Viper Racing and see how fast the back comes away... Chris -- -------------------------------------------------- http://www.the.saints.btinternet.co.uk Alexander Marx wrote in message <8bitv9$556hi$[email hidden]>... | |> turned into turn one before he hit the brakes!!!! | |well you've been there and I've not been there but I still don't believe you |;-)... it sounds so incredible, those cars are doing 300 kph at the main |straight - please tell me at least that he lifted earlier otherwise: |impossible. | |P.S. On the TV it looked to me like they brake at about 70-80 meters before |T1 | |cheers, |Alex | |
Jan Verschueren 26 Mar 2000 00:51 UTC#283874
That's not nescessarily a bad thing. IMO there's two sides to simming in general: one is about recreating the situation as accurately as possible, allowing for people to attempt to emulate the skills of their real world counterparts on their computer. The other is to recreate the "experience" as accurately as possible for the "average" gamer. Ideally every sim should offer both, but I'm quite happy if a sim manges to pull off either. This is why I like F1 2000: an easy enough sim so I can get my mates to race me instead of fragging me at our LAN meetings (hey, I like winning too <g>). Jan. =--- ymenard wrote in message... > <snip> > Yet, F1 2000 shows us that the common human can do this constantly without > any problem lap after lap... (thanks for proving my point). That wasstill > incredible driving by those F1 drivers today.
Lorne Glustein 26 Mar 2000 01:12 UTC#283816
Jan, thats exactly the way I feel and thats why I`m having fun with F1-2000. I like to race online in a car I really enjoy driving and F1-2000 offers me that (fun is fun). Fran�ois, I know exactly where you are coming from as well and I also agree with you... I`ve also been waiting for something that can be called a "true modern F1 >SIM<" and other than GP2 (in it`s time) I dont think any company has come close to making one.... they all seem to have major shortcomings in on area or another. They call these things "sims" but usually they dont come close to living up to what that title [should] represent. The job of making a "perfect sim" is no doubt a hard one.... but it`s amazing to me how many totaly stupid mistakes are made in most sim`s.... some mistakes are nothing but oversites that should never have happend. Other mistakes are probably the result of budget and\or rushing to ship the product. In any case, I look forward to the day someone gets it right in all areas (maybe GP3?). But until then I can only deal with the shortcomings and spend time with the F1 sim I have the most fun with.... right now thats F1-2000 All the best, Lorne
Jan Verschueren 26 Mar 2000 01:39 UTC#283812
ymenard wrote in message... > <snip> > True, but this is where helps and driving aid come in place. With quality > helps and aids, you can model both the recreation and the emulation.Taking > all of them out, you shouldn't be able to be able to do such things likein > F1-2000. If gaming developpers understood that, everybody would be happy. > People that like your above point (I know the majority are them) can enjoy > the title, and at the same time people who want full realism are able to. > Even GPL, to some extent, doesn't necessary show what those cars were > REALLY. Exactly, my real enjoyment comes from the emulation part, but on the other hand I'm realist enough to know "our" (sorry people ;-)) market is too small to support development of ever better sims on it's own. Hence the recreation part; -the aides and so forth. I'm happy when a sim gets "at least" the last part right as sales = money = new games. Without funding there isn't even a chance of getting a better sim next time. EA may not have struck the balance right this time, but it's not that bad either. GP2 had it pretty much nailed for its time, which is probably why it clung on so long after it got technically surpassed. Jan. =---
James Pickard 26 Mar 2000 07:18 UTC#284084
I just thought I would repeat what I posted a little further down.... I was at the Australian Grand Prix a few weeks ago. I have watched F1 cars for a long time... but one thing stuck in my mind that showed me how amazing these guys and cars are.... I was lucky enough to get myself into the Jaguar corporate suite (by accident!), I just wandered in.... and before I knew it, there was green furniture and fittings all around me!! woops.. oh welll :-) I then went up stair and stood about 20 feet above the GP teams (saw all the drivers and managers etc..) I had a great view of the front straight and the entrance to turn one. I watched the practise session and then the qualifying session. Now these cars are fast.. but I knew that. What TOTALLY blew me away was the way these cars brake and stop. Watching all the cars drive down into turn 1. they drove past the 150 meter board, past the 100 meter board, past the 50 meter board (!!!) .. TURN IN!!! and then you hear them down shift!!!! This was Michael Schumacher on his final qualifying attempt. He actually turned into turn one before he hit the brakes!!!! Absolutely AMAZING!! And Schumacher was the only one I could see doing this.. Everyone seemed to brake later than the 50 meter board, but Michael was the only one who actualy turned in before he hit the brakes.. James Pickard
Bruce Kennewell 26 Mar 2000 12:54 UTC#283733
Shouldn't the Subject be "Schumacher turns in before he *breaks*"?!! (Sorry...couldn't resist in light of his "offs" in the past). -- Regards, Bruce Kennewell, Canberra, Australia. --------------------------- rrevved <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > On Sat, 25 Mar 2000 18:51:56 GMT, "ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote: > > >"Stephen Ferguson" <[email hidden]> wrote > >> No, no, no! You can't do that. Our resident expert in the newsgroup has > >> told us repeatedly that, with modern F1 cars, the sequence is brake, let > >> off, *then* turn in. This is the *only* way that it can be done with > >modern > >> F1 cars. Don't believe your eyes, because we have it from a higher > >> authority. :-) > > > >You failed to notice what those person wrote after, saying that only few > >drivers, like Michael Schumacher are able to do that. Clearly not the > >average human racecar driver like a good portion of gamers are... > > Yawn.. > > -- > * rrev at mindspring dot com *
Marc Collins 26 Mar 2000 16:19 UTC#283545
You mean 7th gear.... Marc. "BK" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:01bf968a$c8ed2060$2949a8c2@default... > > Maybe he was using engine braking > there`s no way he would be in 6th gear > just before a turn. >
James Pickard 26 Mar 2000 17:01 UTC#283825
To answer your questions. Schumacher was the ONLY driver to do this.. and he only did it once. It was on his final qualifying lap where he probably would have got pole. He probably had litterally 2 laps of fuel left, perfect tires.. and yes.. I saw it with my own eyes. He turned into the corner before he slowed down (ie braked). But he was the only one to do this and it was only on one lap where his car was setup perfectly. I just was "gob smacked".. I couldn't believe it, but I definately saw it... So now the series of events is... Lights Red.. lights out... accelerate.. up shift... drive past the 150... past the 100.... past the 50.... turn in... apex.. BRAKE!!!! :-) J/K.. James Pickard James Pickard <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:1F5D4.3694$[email hidden]... > I just thought I would repeat what I posted a little further down.... > > I was at the Australian Grand Prix a few weeks ago. I have watched F1cars
Quoted text (15 lines)> for a long time... but one thing stuck in my mind that showed me how > amazing these guys and cars are.... > > I was lucky enough to get myself into the Jaguar corporate suite (by > accident!), I just wandered in.... and before I knew it, there was green > furniture and fittings all around me!! woops.. oh welll :-) > > I then went up stair and stood about 20 feet above the GP teams (saw all > the drivers and managers etc..) I had a great view of the front straight > and the entrance to turn one. > > I watched the practise session and then the qualifying session. Now these > cars are fast.. but I knew that. > > What TOTALLY blew me away was the way these cars brake and stop.
Watching > all the cars drive down into turn 1. they drove past the 150 meter board, > past the 100 meter board, past the 50 meter board (!!!) .. TURN IN!!!and
Quoted text (9 lines)> then you hear them down shift!!!! > > This was Michael Schumacher on his final qualifying attempt. He actually > turned into turn one before he hit the brakes!!!! > > Absolutely AMAZING!! > > > And Schumacher was the only one I could see doing this.. Everyone seemed
to
Quoted text (7 lines)> brake later than the 50 meter board, but Michael was the only one who > actualy turned in before he hit the brakes.. > > > James Pickard > >
David Masten 26 Mar 2000 21:54 UTC#283504
In article <8bkrg3$575o3$[email hidden]>, "Stephen Ferguson" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (8 lines)>> Off topic, I find it disturbing in F1 sims where I see cars constantly >> shifting down to first gear on turns like T1-T3 at Monza. From what I've >> read, 1st gear is used to start, and come out of the pits, and that's >about it >> (maybe Monaco??). Can't they get this right?? >> > >Just change your gears. It's not so disturbing.
You misunderstand me. I mean the AI drivers. I always do my own shifting (sims and reality). To me, it detracts from the suspension of disbelief when the AI is doing something that just isn't so. Then again, the manual for F12K shows a lot of 1st gear turns. Truth or fiction?

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy