Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Re: GPL brake lock-ups

24 posts by 17 people · 12 May 2000 - 22 May 2000 18:19 UTC

Does locking the brakes in GPL stop you faster?

GraDee found that locking the brakes in GPL seemed to slow the car faster than threshold braking, which he thought unrealistic. Others explained that peak braking happens at slight slip, not full lock-up, and suggested tests and brake-bias changes, though some agreed GPL's lock-up behaviour seemed odd.

physics/realism debatesetup/driving techniqueGrand Prix Legends

Automated summary.

Sjon Stigter <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:8fhgtf$4m$[email hidden]... > yeah, you are so right... everybody is complaining about the brakes... > > Maybe you should download the brakes patch, this corrects alot... > Which begs the question: what brake patch and from where can it be downloaded? S.
GraDee 12 May 2000 17:50 UTC#270804
I've been spending some time around Monza lately to get a bit of my times. I've discovered something tough, maybe because of a few corners being very slow from 6th gear straight. I've found mainly that locking the brakes seems very in-accurate in GPL. Of course, why "feel" of looking the brakes is right, you can't steer, the wheels stop and the smoke fly's, yes, if looks very real, however: As we all know to get maximum braking you need to brake as hard as possible, but once you lock the brakes you distance is greater. Now, maybe this is just my problem I don't know but..... When trying not to lock the brakes it's fairly easy t do with lots of practice. However in an effort to reduce braking distances slightly to lesmo 1 and Parabolica like the AI were doing I tried to brake harder, sure enough It worked and the brakes still didn't lock. Next, the back fishtails and ......wipe out! Now, almost throwing my hat at hit as I came to parabolic for a 100th time It seemed I just slammed the brakes on. Brakes locked but that was ok, I wasn't trying to trailbrake. Since the fronts were locked straight the car could jink left or right any little bit, yet the braking distance dropped unbelievably. Now, my question is, if it were the case that the braking as unrealistic surely I wouldn't be the first to notice!?!?! Why is it that locking the brakes makes you slow much quicker than not braking fully? The easy answer is because the brake is to the floor, but if the wheels are locked the braking distance should be greater...... why am I noticing this?
Sjon Stigter 12 May 2000 18:01 UTC#270807
yeah, you are so right... everybody is complaining about the brakes... Maybe you should download the brakes patch, this corrects alot... -- Sjon GraDee <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:8fhg9e$m0v$[email hidden]... > I've been spending some time around Monza lately to get a bit of my times. > > I've discovered something tough, maybe because of a few corners being very > slow from 6th gear straight. > > I've found mainly that locking the brakes seems very in-accurate in GPL.Of > course, why "feel" of looking the brakes is right, you can't steer, the > wheels stop and the smoke fly's, yes, if looks very real, however: > > As we all know to get maximum braking you need to brake as hard aspossible, > but once you lock the brakes you distance is greater. > > Now, maybe this is just my problem I don't know but..... > When trying not to lock the brakes it's fairly easy t do with lots of > practice. However in an effort to reduce braking distances slightly tolesmo > 1 and Parabolica like the AI were doing I tried to brake harder, sureenough
Quoted text (14 lines)> It worked and the brakes still didn't lock. Next, the back fishtails and > ......wipe out! > > Now, almost throwing my hat at hit as I came to parabolic for a 100th time > It seemed I just slammed the brakes on. Brakes locked but that was ok, I > wasn't trying to trailbrake. > Since the fronts were locked straight the car could jink left or right any > little bit, yet the braking distance dropped unbelievably. > > Now, my question is, if it were the case that the braking as unrealistic > surely I wouldn't be the first to notice!?!?! > Why is it that locking the brakes makes you slow much quicker than not > braking fully? > The easy answer is because the brake is to the floor, but if the wheels
are > locked the braking distance should be greater...... why am I noticingthis? > >
Joe Murphy 12 May 2000 23:36 UTC#270744
First you need to adjust the handbrake? Steven Dickson <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:8fhki6$am2gc$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (14 lines)> > Sjon Stigter <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:8fhgtf$4m$[email hidden]... > > yeah, you are so right... everybody is complaining about the brakes... > > > > Maybe you should download the brakes patch, this corrects alot... > > > > Which begs the question: what brake patch and from where can it be > downloaded? > S. > > >
On 13 May 2000 14:48:33 +0200, Mats Lofkvist <[email hidden]> wrote in message <[email hidden]> : >Nope, locking the wheels will get you less than optimum deceleration. >This is because tires give the most grip when just slightly sliding It is worthwhile noting though that with the wheels fully locked many drivers will still find greater deceleration than with their normal braking. Optimum deceleration is easier said than done ;-) Cheers, Richard
What brake bias do you use ? i use 53 and when i drive on the edge and i lock my brakes i miss the corner. _ Jarno GraDee wrote:
Quoted text (31 lines)> I've been spending some time around Monza lately to get a bit of my times. > > I've discovered something tough, maybe because of a few corners being very > slow from 6th gear straight. > > I've found mainly that locking the brakes seems very in-accurate in GPL. Of > course, why "feel" of looking the brakes is right, you can't steer, the > wheels stop and the smoke fly's, yes, if looks very real, however: > > As we all know to get maximum braking you need to brake as hard as possible, > but once you lock the brakes you distance is greater. > > Now, maybe this is just my problem I don't know but..... > When trying not to lock the brakes it's fairly easy t do with lots of > practice. However in an effort to reduce braking distances slightly to lesmo > 1 and Parabolica like the AI were doing I tried to brake harder, sure enough > It worked and the brakes still didn't lock. Next, the back fishtails and > ......wipe out! > > Now, almost throwing my hat at hit as I came to parabolic for a 100th time > It seemed I just slammed the brakes on. Brakes locked but that was ok, I > wasn't trying to trailbrake. > Since the fronts were locked straight the car could jink left or right any > little bit, yet the braking distance dropped unbelievably. > > Now, my question is, if it were the case that the braking as unrealistic > surely I wouldn't be the first to notice!?!?! > Why is it that locking the brakes makes you slow much quicker than not > braking fully? > The easy answer is because the brake is to the floor, but if the wheels are > locked the braking distance should be greater...... why am I noticing this?
Colin 13 May 2000#270631
No. You will get optimum braking when your tires are on the threshold of locking up. When tires are skidding you get nowhere near full braking force. It's an absolute myth that you get maximum braking by standing on the brakes and skidding along. Cheers, ...Colin "Simon Brown" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:0J9T4.4832$[email hidden]... > Surely if the brakes are locked and the wheels aren't spinning at all you > will get maximum deceleration. > The main reason to avoid locking brakes is that it can make you spin andyou > lose the ability to control the cars direction. > >
Matthew V. Jessick 13 May 2000 03:50 UTC#270648
Have you played around with the brake bias? Less front braking (more presure to the rear) will give you more overall braking capability... until the rear tires start locking first. If you seem to get more braking after front lockup, perhaps you weren't at threshold in the previous test. If I lock the fronts going braking deep into Parabolica, I end up picking sand out of my teeth ;) (Definitely less deceleration after front lockup for me.) GraDee wrote:
Quoted text (31 lines)> I've been spending some time around Monza lately to get a bit of my times. > > I've discovered something tough, maybe because of a few corners being very > slow from 6th gear straight. > > I've found mainly that locking the brakes seems very in-accurate in GPL. Of > course, why "feel" of looking the brakes is right, you can't steer, the > wheels stop and the smoke fly's, yes, if looks very real, however: > > As we all know to get maximum braking you need to brake as hard as possible, > but once you lock the brakes you distance is greater. > > Now, maybe this is just my problem I don't know but..... > When trying not to lock the brakes it's fairly easy t do with lots of > practice. However in an effort to reduce braking distances slightly to lesmo > 1 and Parabolica like the AI were doing I tried to brake harder, sure enough > It worked and the brakes still didn't lock. Next, the back fishtails and > ......wipe out! > > Now, almost throwing my hat at hit as I came to parabolic for a 100th time > It seemed I just slammed the brakes on. Brakes locked but that was ok, I > wasn't trying to trailbrake. > Since the fronts were locked straight the car could jink left or right any > little bit, yet the braking distance dropped unbelievably. > > Now, my question is, if it were the case that the braking as unrealistic > surely I wouldn't be the first to notice!?!?! > Why is it that locking the brakes makes you slow much quicker than not > braking fully? > The easy answer is because the brake is to the floor, but if the wheels are > locked the braking distance should be greater...... why am I noticing this?
GraDee 13 May 2000 10:56 UTC#270587
> Surely if the brakes are locked and the wheels aren't spinning at all you > will get maximum deceleration. > The main reason to avoid locking brakes is that it can make you spin andyou > lose the ability to control the cars direction. No no no Simon, If you lock the brakes while turning in you'll spin, If you lock the brakes while holding a straight line you'll be fine, which again is a flaw, even in a straight line, persistent locked brakes should eventually put you in circles. I find that if you brake hard the car goes out of control but if you stamp on the brakes before it ahs time the brakes lock straight on and you decelerate all the better. Locking the brakes even if you do manage to hold the car straight in real life greatly extends braking distance, even sims like MGPRS2 and F1 2000 model this. I won't go into the physics of it all but when the wheel is rotating it means it is gripping the tarmac. when you slow the wheel rotation down by braking, as long as the wheel is still rotation it is gripping the tarmac and slowing the car down with it. If the brakes lock however, there is no rotation of the wheels. The means no grip and the wheels are just skidding over the ground. The ONLY force in this case that should make the car slow down is that fact that there is nothing driving the car forward as you are not accelerating, I essentially like coming off the throttle and letting the car slow that way. This really runs the game for me after learning this, it's not in the least bit realistic. Physically the cars in GPL lock there brakes but they seems to maintain the impact of: the Lower the pedal the quicker you stop which is incorrect when locking the brakes up.
Simon Brown 13 May 2000 11:00 UTC#270681
Surely if the brakes are locked and the wheels aren't spinning at all you will get maximum deceleration. The main reason to avoid locking brakes is that it can make you spin and you lose the ability to control the cars direction.
Mats Lofkvist 13 May 2000 12:48 UTC#270598
"Simon Brown" <[email hidden]> writes: > Surely if the brakes are locked and the wheels aren't spinning at > all you will get maximum deceleration. Nope, locking the wheels will get you less than optimum deceleration. This is because tires give the most grip when just slightly sliding (compare acceleration, it is easy to demonstrate that full throttle acceleration with wildly spinning wheels is far from optimal :-) > The main reason to avoid locking brakes is that it can make you spin > and you lose the ability to control the cars direction. Even with the loss of deceleration, this is still correct imo. _ Mats Lofkvist [email hidden]
Alan Orton 13 May 2000 20:13 UTC#270575
I'm not sure if it's true but I read that you'll lose 30% of your braking power or grip with the tires locked. So your braking distance will be 30% farther. For the optimum braking grip the tire will be sliping around 10%. So really the tires are skiding but not locked. The 30% and 10% is probably different with each type of tire. Richard Walker wrote:
Quoted text (13 lines)> > On 13 May 2000 14:48:33 +0200, Mats Lofkvist <[email hidden]> wrote > in message <[email hidden]> : > > >Nope, locking the wheels will get you less than optimum deceleration. > >This is because tires give the most grip when just slightly sliding > > It is worthwhile noting though that with the wheels fully locked many > drivers will still find greater deceleration than with their normal > braking. Optimum deceleration is easier said than done ;-) > > Cheers, > Richard
wheetos 14 May 2000#270308
You certainly should be able to stop shorter un-locked !!! Are you sure you really are braking as well as possible un-locked up. I find braking gently at first followed by steadily increasing pressure gives maximum retardation. It's certainly better than locking up - especially if I'm braking round a bend - eg. that left hander at Rouen before the hairpin - what a bitch that is ! Regards , Bog GraDee <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:8fhg9e$m0v$[email hidden]... > I've been spending some time around Monza lately to get a bit of my times. > > I've discovered something tough, maybe because of a few corners being very > slow from 6th gear straight. > > I've found mainly that locking the brakes seems very in-accurate in GPL.Of > course, why "feel" of looking the brakes is right, you can't steer, the > wheels stop and the smoke fly's, yes, if looks very real, however: > > As we all know to get maximum braking you need to brake as hard aspossible, > but once you lock the brakes you distance is greater. > > Now, maybe this is just my problem I don't know but..... > When trying not to lock the brakes it's fairly easy t do with lots of > practice. However in an effort to reduce braking distances slightly tolesmo > 1 and Parabolica like the AI were doing I tried to brake harder, sureenough
Quoted text (14 lines)> It worked and the brakes still didn't lock. Next, the back fishtails and > ......wipe out! > > Now, almost throwing my hat at hit as I came to parabolic for a 100th time > It seemed I just slammed the brakes on. Brakes locked but that was ok, I > wasn't trying to trailbrake. > Since the fronts were locked straight the car could jink left or right any > little bit, yet the braking distance dropped unbelievably. > > Now, my question is, if it were the case that the braking as unrealistic > surely I wouldn't be the first to notice!?!?! > Why is it that locking the brakes makes you slow much quicker than not > braking fully? > The easy answer is because the brake is to the floor, but if the wheels
are > locked the braking distance should be greater...... why am I noticingthis? > >
Simon Brown 14 May 2000 01:18 UTC#270400
Thanks for taking the time to explain that. It doesn't exactly ruin the game for me, but it's a disapointment. It's tempting when playing to GPL to imagine that it's nearly perfect.
Alan Orton 14 May 2000 02:01 UTC#270403
Your braking distance will be longer in gpl if you lock up the brakes. Try this test. Put 100% front brake bias. Then goto monza and move down the front straight then turn around and accelerate to redline in second gear. When you hit the start finish line nail the brakes and lock up the wheels. *With out downshifting and in standard not auto shifting* Notice where you stopped. Then reset your car to get new tires and fuel. Now Try the same thing but this time try modulating the brakes. With 100% front brake it's hard to not lock them up so you have to be very smooth and if you do it right I'm sure you'll see a BIG difference in distance, it's good practice to help make you more smooth too. :) *With out downshifting and in standard not auto shifting*. The reason why you put the brake bias to 100% forward is to make it fair. With brake bias around 52-57 your engine braking can screw up you bias if not set properly. It can reduce your braking capabilities. You can try this same test with you racing setup with brake bias in the 52-7 area. If your locking of the brakes is stopping you quicker with your race setup then you're bias isn't set properly or your not at the maximum braking power. Don't forget engine braking and downshifting can really mess up your brake bias. GraDee wrote:
Quoted text (36 lines)> > > Surely if the brakes are locked and the wheels aren't spinning at all you > > will get maximum deceleration. > > The main reason to avoid locking brakes is that it can make you spin and > you > > lose the ability to control the cars direction. > > No no no Simon, > If you lock the brakes while turning in you'll spin, > If you lock the brakes while holding a straight line you'll be fine, which > again is a flaw, even in a straight line, persistent locked brakes should > eventually put you in circles. > > I find that if you brake hard the car goes out of control but if you stamp > on the brakes before it ahs time the brakes lock straight on and you > decelerate all the better. > > Locking the brakes even if you do manage to hold the car straight in real > life greatly extends braking distance, even sims like MGPRS2 and F1 2000 > model this. > > I won't go into the physics of it all but when the wheel is rotating it > means it is gripping the tarmac. when you slow the wheel rotation down by > braking, as long as the wheel is still rotation it is gripping the tarmac > and slowing the car down with it. > If the brakes lock however, there is no rotation of the wheels. The means no > grip and the wheels are just skidding over the ground. The ONLY force in > this case that should make the car slow down is that fact that there is > nothing driving the car forward as you are not accelerating, I essentially > like coming off the throttle and letting the car slow that way. > > This really runs the game for me after learning this, it's not in the least > bit realistic. Physically the cars in GPL lock there brakes but they seems > to maintain the impact of: > the Lower the pedal the quicker you stop which is incorrect when locking the > brakes up.
m.seery 14 May 2000 11:18 UTC#270466
"Colin" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:8fjrpm$1fv$[email hidden]... > No. You will get optimum braking when your tires are on the threshold of > locking up. Quite right. You will get maximum braking when the wheels are partially locked. That is to say, when they are revolving at a slower rate than roadspeed would normally dictate, but not locked into a static, non revolving state. MS.
Quoted text (10 lines)> When tires are skidding you get nowhere near full braking > force. It's an absolute myth that you get maximum braking by standing on > the brakes and skidding along. > > Cheers, > ...Colin > > "Simon Brown" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:0J9T4.4832$[email hidden]... > > Surely if the brakes are locked and the wheels aren't spinning at all
you
Quoted text (8 lines)> > will get maximum deceleration. > > The main reason to avoid locking brakes is that it can make you spin and > you > > lose the ability to control the cars direction. > > > > > >
GraDee 14 May 2000 21:20 UTC#270327
> You certainly should be able to stop shorter un-locked !!! > Are you sure you really are braking as well as possible un-locked up. Ifind > braking gently at first followed by steadily increasing pressure gives > maximum retardation. It's certainly better than locking up - especially if > I'm braking round a bend - eg. that left hander at Rouen before the > hairpin - what a bitch that is ! Yes, of course of a curve I cannot lock the brakes, this doesn't help at all. But in a situation like Parabolica or most first corners which have a long straight behind them. If you try to balance it on the fine line of heavy braking and locking you will be very slow to slow down. Another bit harder and the back goes out. If you just stomp on the brakes the back end hasn't time to snap out from behind stand the front hold it steady which itself is unrealistic I feel.
EldredP 15 May 2000#270058
In article <8fn5ap$nsi$[email hidden]>, "GraDee" <[email hidden]> writes:
Quoted text (11 lines)>Yes, of course of a curve I cannot lock the brakes, this doesn't help at >all. > >But in a situation like Parabolica or most first corners which have a long >straight behind them. If you try to balance it on the fine line of heavy >braking and locking you will be very slow to slow down. Another bit harder >and the back goes out. > >If you just stomp on the brakes the back end hasn't time to snap out from >behind stand the front hold it steady which itself is unrealistic I feel. >
Have you ever locked up your brakes on ice? If you were going perfectly straight, the car will SLIDE straight. GPL sounds realistic to *me*...<g> Eldred -- Tiger Stadium R.I.P. 1912-1999 Own Grand Prix Legends? Goto http://gpl.gamestats.com/vroc Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
GraDee 15 May 2000 20:50 UTC#270066
> Have you ever locked up your brakes on ice? If you were going perfectly > straight, the car will SLIDE straight. GPL sounds realistic to *me*...<g> Perhaps but you know GPL man, your never going perfectly straight, the damn thing shakes all over the place. Anway the main point was the braking distance, this is weird to me.
Olav K. Malmin 15 May 2000 20:56 UTC#270067
"GraDee" <[email hidden]> writes: > > Have you ever locked up your brakes on ice? If you were going perfectly > > straight, the car will SLIDE straight. GPL sounds realistic to *me*...<g> I drive on snow and ice 5 months a year, and while if I lock the brakes, the car is having a straight line of motion, but turns to one of the sides due to uneven brake pressure. :) > Perhaps but you know GPL man, your never going perfectly straight, the damn > thing shakes all over the place. LOL > > Anway the main point was the braking distance, this is weird to me. > > -- Olav K. Malmin remove spam when replying
Matthew V. Jessick 17 May 2000 02:25 UTC#269714
Alan Orton wrote: > I'm not sure if it's true but I read that you'll lose 30% of your > braking power or grip with the tires locked. So your braking distance > will be 30% farther. If you were to lose 30% of the deceleration, you would skid (1 divided by 0.7) times as far ... or 43% farther. (This is why trajectory analysts don't get repeat invites to parties! ;) - Matt
Michael E. Carver 17 May 2000 16:04 UTC#269614
On Wed, 17 May 2000 02:25:23 GMT Matthew V. Jessick <[email hidden]> wrote: % Alan Orton wrote: % > I'm not sure if it's true but I read that you'll lose 30% of your % > braking power or grip with the tires locked. So your braking distance % > will be 30% farther. % If you were to lose 30% of the deceleration, you would skid % (1 divided by 0.7) times as far ... or 43% farther. % (This is why trajectory analysts don't get repeat invites to parties! ;) Matt, bring the latest version of your new sim and you would be welcome at my party. ;-) -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. [email hidden] http://www.teleport.com/~mcarver =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Brett C. Cammack 17 May 2000 18:05 UTC#269544
On Fri, 12 May 2000 18:48:04 +0100, "GraDee" <[email hidden]> wrote: >Now, almost throwing my hat at hit as I came to parabolic for a 100th time >It seemed I just slammed the brakes on. Brakes locked but that was ok, I >wasn't trying to trailbrake. >Since the fronts were locked straight the car could jink left or right any >little bit, yet the braking distance dropped unbelievably. I discovered this, too, but I try to avoid capitalizing on it. I will resort to it in those "oh shit" situations where I have had a massive brain-fade and missed my brake points horribly. <g> I've also found that, if not going too fast, I lose the tail of the car entering a corner, I can hammer the brakes and stop the spin. I lose time, but not wheels, etc. None of this is good technique, but I do consider them to be useful survival skills... <g> Regards, Brett C. Cammack That's Racing! Motorsports Pompano Beach, FL
Alan Orton 22 May 2000 18:19 UTC#268743
Thanks, Matt. That's why I don't work for Boeing or everything would fly off the runways. ;) Matthew V. Jessick wrote:
Quoted text (13 lines)> > Alan Orton wrote: > > > I'm not sure if it's true but I read that you'll lose 30% of your > > braking power or grip with the tires locked. So your braking distance > > will be 30% farther. > > If you were to lose 30% of the deceleration, you would skid > (1 divided by 0.7) times as far ... or 43% farther. > > (This is why trajectory analysts don't get repeat invites to parties! ;) > > - Matt

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy