uuummm......anyone play NASCAR 2000 by EA??? pretty bad you say? PAPYRUS
RULES!!!!
GP3 omits driver personalities, frustrating fans
Quotes from GP3's senior producer that individual driver behaviour would be left out disappointed fans, who compared it unfavourably with GPL's configurable AI drivers. Some suspected licensing worries or a rushed release by Hasbro, others pointed to reports that features were being held back for a GP4, and the thread drifted into EA's sports titles.
Automated summary.
In article <[email hidden]>,
"Bruce Kennewell" <[email hidden]> wrote:
> (snip)
> but they've left the
> door wide open for another company to take the F1 crown.
> (unsnip)
>
> I seem to have seen this type of comment here before now. Severaltimes
> over the past 8 years, in fact!! :-)
:) - Yeah, as it stands GP3 will still be the best modern F1 sim when it
comes out, I'd say. It just could have been head-and-shoulders above
anything else now and in the near future.
All this speculation is pretty pointless until GP3 is released anyway,
so I'll shut up now ;).
Kendt
Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
Before you buy.
yeah, but in the days when anyone will sue for any pathetic reason, a modern
day celebrity (which F1 drivers are) will care about their image, or at
least their people, or their people's people will.
I think it's just a legal safeguard.
David C
Borut Srebotnik <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:8QcU4.3422$[email hidden]...
> I didn't hear anything about Surtees getting rich on behalf of Papy's
> presentation of his caracter in GPL;-) I mean, seriously, Schumachertaking
Quoted text (30 lines)
> legal actions against Hasbro for killing him over and over again at > Silverstone in GP3! C'mon!!!! Not even in U.S.! > > Borut > > "David Cane" <david.cane(spam-off)@btinternet.com> wrote in message > news:8fr01o$fk4$[email hidden]... > > > > > * Induvidial driver style will not be included in Grand Prix 3 as it > > > may annoy people. > > > > > I don't think he means the people like us, the players. I think he means > the > > actual real life dirvers. There's gotta be all sorts of legal problems > with > > putting what is effectively a driver's personality into the game. > Afterall, > > if a driver is programmed to block excessively and do other things that > are > > considered 'controversial' in real life, that real life driver may get > > pissed off and be sending "deformation of Character" lawsuits towards > > Hasbro. > > > > It's a shame though > > > > David C > > > > > >Anyone catch the latest quotes from GP3's senior producer?
From Sim Racing News:
* Grand Prix 3's physics engine is based on 12 years of work by Geoff
Crammond, and that Grand Prix 3 is the final product of that work.
<Yeah, OK, but what are the actual improvements over GP2?>
* In later games it will be possible to start as a test driver and work
your way up through the rankings.
<Fine, cool - but does he mean GP4+?>
* Induvidial driver style will not be included in Grand Prix 3 as it
may annoy people.
<WTF?! This isn't a damn arcade game - sounds like an excuse to me>
* There are no radio messages currently added to Grand Prix 3, but they
are not ruled out of the final version. If they were included, they
would not be very often as that is how realistic it is in real life.
<Well, hell - GP2 already had the radio messages in the sound files,
and they *still* don't have them implemented?>
* No pit animation because the driver would just change to the camera
view and not concentrate on the actual driving.
<sounds like another excuse to leave out an enhancement>
I really don't like to complain, but it sounds like Geoff is doing the
bare minimum to get GP3 out. If it's just GP2 with improved physics
and 3D graphics, I'll still definitely buy it, but they've left the
door wide open for another company to take the F1 crown.
EA F1-2001? MGPRS3 (anyone seen this yet)?
Kendt
Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
Before you buy.
> * Induvidial driver style will not be included in Grand Prix 3 as it
> may annoy people.
>I don't think he means the people like us, the players. I think he means the
actual real life dirvers. There's gotta be all sorts of legal problems with
putting what is effectively a driver's personality into the game. Afterall,
if a driver is programmed to block excessively and do other things that are
considered 'controversial' in real life, that real life driver may get
pissed off and be sending "deformation of Character" lawsuits towards
Hasbro.
It's a shame though
David C
In article <8fr01o$fk4$[email hidden]>,
"David Cane" <david.cane(spam-off)@btinternet.com> wrote:
>
> > * Induvidial driver style will not be included in Grand Prix 3 as it
> > may annoy people.
> >
> I don't think he means the people like us, the players. I think hemeans the
> actual real life dirvers. There's gotta be all sorts of legal problems[snip]
I see the point - but I worry that there's still a core limitation in
the GP3 engine that will prevent even a 3rd party from programming
driver profiles. Not to beat a dead horse, but I think GPL really does
it right with all the settable driver variables.
Kendt
Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
Before you buy.
yeah, I do actually reckon the drivers are the people that would be annoyed.
I can't see any reason why the players would be annoyed with it, afterall if
that was a concern you'd just put an option in a menu to switch off the
individual driving styles.
It would enhance the simulation no-end, so that's gotta be the reason.
Remember, it was promised as a feature for GP2, but the reasons for it's
absence was never given......
David C
Jo Helsen <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
the
> >actual real life dirvers. There's gotta be all sorts of legal problemswith
> >putting what is effectively a driver's personality into the game.Afterall,
> >if a driver is programmed to block excessively and do other things thatare
Quoted text (8 lines)
> On Tue, 16 May 2000 09:15:44 +0100, "David Cane" > <david.cane(spam-off)@btinternet.com> wrote: > > > > >> * Induvidial driver style will not be included in Grand Prix 3 as it > >> may annoy people. > >> > >I don't think he means the people like us, the players. I think he meansQuoted text (14 lines)
> >considered 'controversial' in real life, that real life driver may get > >pissed off and be sending "deformation of Character" lawsuits towards > >Hasbro. > > Do you really think? > > I guess it's just that different people can have very different ideas > about this or that driver. Just visit one of the F1 groups and you'll > probably find a huge percentage of threads discussing the merits and > "personalities" of certain drivers. > > So it's not such a far shot that it could upset people... > > JoHOn Tue, 16 May 2000 04:38:37 GMT, [email hidden] thus spoke:
>EA F1-2001? MGPRS3 (anyone seen this yet)?
>Kendt
If EA keeps putting out F1 versions like they do with their NHL, FIFA
and other sports series I think they will definatley take the crown.
You just have to realize that you will have to buy a new version every
year to get the fixes instead of expecting any major patches.
--
Nos
Doesn't work with regular videoboards drivers.....
Doesn't work with force feedback.
NO support (they just don't answer the mails regarding these issues....)
What kind of company is this ? Oh yes, EA
Well, then Surtees should sue PAPYRUS for his GPL character !!!!
David Cane <david.cane(spam-off)@btinternet.com> a �crit dans le message :
8fr01o$fk4$[email hidden]...
>
> > * Induvidial driver style will not be included in Grand Prix 3 as it
> > may annoy people.
> >
> I don't think he means the people like us, the players. I think he meansthe
> actual real life dirvers. There's gotta be all sorts of legal problemswith
> putting what is effectively a driver's personality into the game.Afterall,
> if a driver is programmed to block excessively and do other things thatare
Quoted text (9 lines)
> considered 'controversial' in real life, that real life driver may get > pissed off and be sending "deformation of Character" lawsuits towards > Hasbro. > > It's a shame though > > David C > >Yeah, but how many goes have they had a doing a decent football game and yet
they've still utterly failed. I would rather play Kick Off 2 than FIFA
2000.
On Tue, 16 May 2000 09:15:44 +0100, "David Cane"
<david.cane(spam-off)@btinternet.com> wrote:
Do you really think?
I guess it's just that different people can have very different ideas
about this or that driver. Just visit one of the F1 groups and you'll
probably find a huge percentage of threads discussing the merits and
"personalities" of certain drivers.
So it's not such a far shot that it could upset people...
JoH
Quoted text (11 lines)
> >> * Induvidial driver style will not be included in Grand Prix 3 as it >> may annoy people. >> >I don't think he means the people like us, the players. I think he means the >actual real life dirvers. There's gotta be all sorts of legal problems with >putting what is effectively a driver's personality into the game. Afterall, >if a driver is programmed to block excessively and do other things that are >considered 'controversial' in real life, that real life driver may get >pissed off and be sending "deformation of Character" lawsuits towards >Hasbro.I don't think he means the people like us, the players. I think he means the
actual real life dirvers. There's gotta be all sorts of legal problems with
putting what is effectively a driver's personality into the game. Afterall,
if a driver is programmed to block excessively and do other things that are
considered 'controversial' in real life, that real life driver may get
pissed off and be sending "deformation of Character" lawsuits towards
Hasbro.
It's a shame though
David C
You obviously have not played FIFA 2000. This is the best soccer game out
there hands down and Madden 2000 was also the best Football game on the
market. Just to get back on topic though, EA sports' first foray into f1
racing wasn't all that bad. I would never buy it since I already have the
best f1 sim on the planet (GPL) but with the frequency EA puts out products
they will easily take over the modern f1 crown. It looks like GP3 is cutting
allot of corners and leaving out allot of stuff just to get the product out.
This leads me to believe the system requirements to make it run will be so
steep that f12000 will look a little better.
Vintook
"Simon Brown" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:6V8U4.2049$[email hidden]...
> Yeah, but how many goes have they had a doing a decent football game andyet
> they've still utterly failed. I would rather play Kick Off 2 than FIFA
> 2000.
>
>
I didn't hear anything about Surtees getting rich on behalf of Papy's
presentation of his caracter in GPL;-) I mean, seriously, Schumacher taking
legal actions against Hasbro for killing him over and over again at
Silverstone in GP3! C'mon!!!! Not even in U.S.!
Borut
"David Cane" <david.cane(spam-off)@btinternet.com> wrote in message
news:8fr01o$fk4$[email hidden]...
>
> > * Induvidial driver style will not be included in Grand Prix 3 as it
> > may annoy people.
> >
> I don't think he means the people like us, the players. I think he meansthe
> actual real life dirvers. There's gotta be all sorts of legal problemswith
> putting what is effectively a driver's personality into the game.Afterall,
> if a driver is programmed to block excessively and do other things thatare
Quoted text (9 lines)
> considered 'controversial' in real life, that real life driver may get > pissed off and be sending "deformation of Character" lawsuits towards > Hasbro. > > It's a shame though > > David C > >Uhhh, i just contributed to this thread and then i discover that somebody
already brought the Surtees out :-( Shit!
Borut
"LL" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:8fr58m$7l0$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (28 lines)
> Well, then Surtees should sue PAPYRUS for his GPL character !!!! > > > David Cane <david.cane(spam-off)@btinternet.com> a �crit dans le message : > 8fr01o$fk4$[email hidden]... > > > > > * Induvidial driver style will not be included in Grand Prix 3 as it > > > may annoy people. > > > > > I don't think he means the people like us, the players. I think he means > the > > actual real life dirvers. There's gotta be all sorts of legal problems > with > > putting what is effectively a driver's personality into the game. > Afterall, > > if a driver is programmed to block excessively and do other things that > are > > considered 'controversial' in real life, that real life driver may get > > pissed off and be sending "deformation of Character" lawsuits towards > > Hasbro. > > > > It's a shame though > > > > David C > > > > > >GP4 isn't gonna be an add on pack, probably everything that should of been
put in the upcoming GP3 to begin with. Make that money!!
http://f1gaming.com/f1/news/958484659x61657x.html
jj
<[email hidden]> wrote in message news:8fru63$h0l$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (23 lines)
> In article <[email hidden]>, > "Bruce Kennewell" <[email hidden]> wrote: > > (snip) > > but they've left the > > door wide open for another company to take the F1 crown. > > (unsnip) > > > > I seem to have seen this type of comment here before now. Several > times > > over the past 8 years, in fact!! :-) > > :) - Yeah, as it stands GP3 will still be the best modern F1 sim when it > comes out, I'd say. It just could have been head-and-shoulders above > anything else now and in the near future. > > All this speculation is pretty pointless until GP3 is released anyway, > so I'll shut up now ;). > > Kendt > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > Before you buy.(snip)
but they've left the
door wide open for another company to take the F1 crown.
(unsnip)
I seem to have seen this type of comment here before now. Several times
over the past 8 years, in fact!! :-)
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
<[email hidden]> wrote in message news:8fqjcc$11p$[email hidden]...
> Anyone catch the latest quotes from GP3's senior producer?
>
> From Sim Racing News:
> * Grand Prix 3's physics engine is based on 12 years of work by Geoff
> Crammond, and that Grand Prix 3 is the final product of that work.
>
> <Yeah, OK, but what are the actual improvements over GP2?>
>
> * In later games it will be possible to start as a test driver and work
> your way up through the rankings.
>
> <Fine, cool - but does he mean GP4+?>
>
> * Induvidial driver style will not be included in Grand Prix 3 as it
> may annoy people.
>
> <WTF?! This isn't a damn arcade game - sounds like an excuse to me>
>
> * There are no radio messages currently added to Grand Prix 3, but they
> are not ruled out of the final version. If they were included, they
> would not be very often as that is how realistic it is in real life.
>
> <Well, hell - GP2 already had the radio messages in the sound files,
> and they *still* don't have them implemented?>
>
> * No pit animation because the driver would just change to the camera
> view and not concentrate on the actual driving.
>
> <sounds like another excuse to leave out an enhancement>
>
> I really don't like to complain, but it sounds like Geoff is doing the
> bare minimum to get GP3 out. If it's just GP2 with improved physics
> and 3D graphics, I'll still definitely buy it, but they've left the
> door wide open for another company to take the F1 crown.
>
> EA F1-2001? MGPRS3 (anyone seen this yet)?
> Kendt
>
>
> Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
> Before you buy.
On Tue, 16 May 2000 18:04:35 +0100 David Cane <david.cane(spam-off)@btinternet.com> wrote:
% yeah, but in the days when anyone will sue for any pathetic reason, a modern
% day celebrity (which F1 drivers are) will care about their image, or at
% least their people, or their people's people will.
% I think it's just a legal safeguard.
From what I have heard of what is being left out, it sounds more like
either Geoff dictates or can't be bothered to program.
pit communicaton
decent net and lan play
come to mind....
--
**************************** Michael E. Carver *************************
Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town.
[email hidden] http://www.teleport.com/~mcarver
=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
What bothers me is they try to play it off as something they do to enhance
the game for us, the players. "It would detract from the experience", is an
often abused sentence.
I say: put it in there you lazy bastards and let us decide whether it
bothers us or not. Assuming there's a way to not use the feature, of course.
Cheers,
Jan.
=---
Michael E. Carver <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:8gzU4.504$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (16 lines)
> <snip> > From what I have heard of what is being left out, it sounds more like > either Geoff dictates or can't be bothered to program. > > pit communicaton > > decent net and lan play > > come to mind.... > > > -- > **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* > Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. > [email hidden] http://www.teleport.com/~mcarver > =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=On Wed, 17 May 2000 15:53:40 GMT, "Michael E. Carver"
[email hidden] thus spoke:
Or Hasbro is trying to force another half baked product out the door.
Don't expect much support from Hasbro either. I will bet my money on
EA and future versions that enhance and fix problems.
--
Nos
Quoted text (8 lines)
>From what I have heard of what is being left out, it sounds more like >either Geoff dictates or can't be bothered to program. > >pit communicaton > >decent net and lan play > >come to mind....On Tue, 16 May 2000 09:54:10 GMT, "Simon Brown"
<[email hidden]> thus spoke:
>Yeah, but how many goes have they had a doing a decent football game and yet
>they've still utterly failed. I would rather play Kick Off 2 than FIFA
>2000.
>
>
Never played Kick Off 2. Who does it? Anyway, I like the EA Football
games, as do many other people. It's been good since WC '98.
--
Nos
On 16 May 2000 20:36:36 GMT, [email hidden] (Ray127611) thus spoke:
>uuummm......anyone play NASCAR 2000 by EA??? pretty bad you say? PAPYRUS
>RULES!!!!
Was Nascar 2000 developed by Image Space like F1 2000 and SCGT? Nope.
--
Nos
Seems like they are getting into Papy's habit of add on packs.
I just got Unreal Tornament and after I installed it, I checked
for any updates or patches. It was quite refreshing to find
that epic games have made a FREE add on pack, including several
new maps, for downloading.
Like Microsoft with their flight sims, Epic also actively
encourage third party add-ons. Maybe the sim-racing
manufacturers should have a look outside their own genre
sometimes to see whats going on?
Chris
In article <8frvlg$hp5$[email hidden]>, "J.
Janasov" <[email hidden]> wrote:
>GP4 isn't gonna be an add on pack, probably everything thatshould of been
>put in the upcoming GP3 to begin with. Make that money!!
>
>http://f1gaming.com/f1/news/958484659x61657x.html
>jj
>
><[email hidden]> wrote in message news:8fru63$h0l$[email hidden]...
Several
>> times
>> > over the past 8 years, in fact!! :-)
>>
>> :) - Yeah, as it stands GP3 will still be the best modern F1sim when it
>> comes out, I'd say. It just could have been head-and-shoulders above
>> anything else now and in the near future.
>>
>> All this speculation is pretty pointless until GP3 isreleased anyway,
* Sent from RemarQ http://www.remarq.com The Internet's Discussion Network *
The fastest and easiest way to search and participate in Usenet - Free!


































