Could you please let me know where you bought GP3 from so you could
make this in depth comparison.
Regards Mike
On Mon, 05 Jun 2000 16:43:18 GMT, [email hidden] (Attila) wrote:
GP3 versus F1 2000 graphics screenshots
A poster compared a GP3 screenshot unfavourably with F1 2000, while others found GP3 nearly photo-realistic or warned against judging before release. This led to a debate over whether Geoff Crammond had proven 3D credentials, with his record from Revs and The Sentinel to F1GP and GP2 cited, and over whether ICR2 or GP2 shipped first. The thread ended with nostalgia for Stunt Car Racer.
Automated summary.
"Simon Brown" <[email hidden]> schreef in bericht
news:EIT_4.7963$[email hidden]...
were
> finished. And as for those two screenshots, the GP3 shot wins by a mile.
> Can't you see how artificial F1 2000 looks? Those cars on that shot look
> terrible, just look at that Ferrari, it looks nothing like the real sport.
> All those criticisms of GP3 are totally peripheral to what make a goodsim.
> The most important thing is the physics model, and Geoff Crammond's track
> record is proven here. Also you need a good 3d engine, again GC is a top3d
Top 3d programmer? Can you name 3d games he made???
> programmer, which compares very favourably with the awfully slow engine in
> F1 2000.
>
>
Quoted text (7 lines)
> You've got to be kidding. I played F1 2000 for about 3 hours before > un-installing it. I've never seen such messy grahpics and sloppy engine. > Just look at the game from the replay views and ask yourself - "does this > look anything like F1?". Track layouts wrong (utterly unforgiveable), > colour schemes all wrong, stupid AI drivers that spin out on the formation > lap (!!!) and hit each other and you all the time. > Another example of EA forcing the developer to release way before they"Brian V. Balgobind" <[email hidden]> wrote:
F1GP
The Sentinel
Stunt Car Racer
GP2
GP3
That's 5.
JoH
------- The best way to accelerate a Mac is 9.81 m/s2 --------
--------------------------------------------------------------
Quoted text (21 lines)
> >"Simon Brown" <[email hidden]> schreef in bericht >news:EIT_4.7963$[email hidden]... >> You've got to be kidding. I played F1 2000 for about 3 hours before >> un-installing it. I've never seen such messy grahpics and sloppy engine. >> Just look at the game from the replay views and ask yourself - "does this >> look anything like F1?". Track layouts wrong (utterly unforgiveable), >> colour schemes all wrong, stupid AI drivers that spin out on the formation >> lap (!!!) and hit each other and you all the time. >> Another example of EA forcing the developer to release way before they >were >> finished. And as for those two screenshots, the GP3 shot wins by a mile. >> Can't you see how artificial F1 2000 looks? Those cars on that shot look >> terrible, just look at that Ferrari, it looks nothing like the real sport. >> All those criticisms of GP3 are totally peripheral to what make a good >sim. >> The most important thing is the physics model, and Geoff Crammond's track >> record is proven here. Also you need a good 3d engine, again GC is a top >3d > >Top 3d programmer? Can you name 3d games he made???Quoted text (7 lines)
> > The most important thing is the physics model, and Geoff Crammond's > > track > > record is proven here. Also you need a good 3d engine, again GC is > > a top > 3d > > Top 3d programmer? Can you name 3d games he made???> I must say I'm really disappointed... The colours in F12000 are much
> more vivid, and have much better contrast. Does GP3 really use 3D
> hardware or is this just another "early" software shot?
????
The graphics in GP3 are absolutely fantastic. They are almost
photo-realistic!!!
F1 2000 is an excellent game IMHO but it needs a LOT of work in the graphics
department!!!
> I must say I'm really disappointed... The colours in F12000 are much
> more vivid, and have much better contrast. Does GP3 really use 3D
> hardware or is this just another "early" software shot?
Are you being sarcastic? I can't really tell, but you seem quite serious
to me. Maybe you got the two screenshots muddled up by mistake?
OTOH, I am worried (by the looks of that screenshot) that they have spent
too much time on graphics and not enough on physics. I would much rather
have a lesser graphically correct game with amazing physics than one with
photo realistic graphics and arcade gameplay.
Also, I hope it will run smoothly on my P2-400, or else this copy of GP3
I'm going to buy will become very expensive.
Scott
The "great" GP3 against EA's decent F12000, graphics-wise:
http://www.alphaf1.com/gp3/pics/hung15.jpg
http://speed.pcarena.com/f12000/pic9.html
I must say I'm really disappointed... The colours in F12000 are much
more vivid, and have much better contrast. Does GP3 really use 3D
hardware or is this just another "early" software shot?
Also, GP3 seems to lack fences. Now, which F1 track doesn't have
fences, for God's sake!!!
F12000 has a drivingline. Where's the GP3 drivingline?
The trees are supposed to look photo-realistic, but they jump too much
out of the entire image for my taste. Ruines the effect.
The heads don't seem to move like they do in F12000 either. Now this
really is something that would add to the realistic looks. (wasn't it
in GP2?)
Then I'm not even talking about how all the carshapes are identical...
Not seen a Ferrari or McLaren though, so there may still be hope.
http://speed.pcarena.com/f12000/pic3.html
http://www.alphaf1.com/gp3/pics/hung19.jpg
Microprose didn't bother much about the cockpit informaton either.
Still the same limited info, compared to F12K. Is it that difficult to
add essential information? At least with F12K you always know exactly
where you are relative to the opposition. MPS still went for a
bitmapped cockpit as well.
A nice little touch is the flags carried by the public in F12K. GP3
fans are much flatter. Hell, they look like muesli or something! :-)
Let's hope the physics engine, AI and online play will be something
special, or Microprose will quickly fall behind... They still have GP4
up their sleeve, but it probably will have to compete against F12002,
so...
Attila
You've got to be kidding. I played F1 2000 for about 3 hours before
un-installing it. I've never seen such messy grahpics and sloppy engine.
Just look at the game from the replay views and ask yourself - "does this
look anything like F1?". Track layouts wrong (utterly unforgiveable),
colour schemes all wrong, stupid AI drivers that spin out on the formation
lap (!!!) and hit each other and you all the time.
Another example of EA forcing the developer to release way before they were
finished. And as for those two screenshots, the GP3 shot wins by a mile.
Can't you see how artificial F1 2000 looks? Those cars on that shot look
terrible, just look at that Ferrari, it looks nothing like the real sport.
All those criticisms of GP3 are totally peripheral to what make a good sim.
The most important thing is the physics model, and Geoff Crammond's track
record is proven here. Also you need a good 3d engine, again GC is a top 3d
programmer, which compares very favourably with the awfully slow engine in
F1 2000.
Why don't we wait til gp3 is out before we begin comparing the
two sims. Otherwise I'll have to bring CART3 into the mix and let
everyone be the...OOPS my BS meter just went off...sorry..no CART3!
Just wait til gp3 is out before getting too into the small stuff
comparisons.
dave henrie
Attila wrote:
Quoted text (44 lines)
> > The "great" GP3 against EA's decent F12000, graphics-wise: > > http://www.alphaf1.com/gp3/pics/hung15.jpg > http://speed.pcarena.com/f12000/pic9.html > > I must say I'm really disappointed... The colours in F12000 are much > more vivid, and have much better contrast. Does GP3 really use 3D > hardware or is this just another "early" software shot? > > Also, GP3 seems to lack fences. Now, which F1 track doesn't have > fences, for God's sake!!! > > F12000 has a drivingline. Where's the GP3 drivingline? > > The trees are supposed to look photo-realistic, but they jump too much > out of the entire image for my taste. Ruines the effect. > > The heads don't seem to move like they do in F12000 either. Now this > really is something that would add to the realistic looks. (wasn't it > in GP2?) > > Then I'm not even talking about how all the carshapes are identical... > Not seen a Ferrari or McLaren though, so there may still be hope. > > http://speed.pcarena.com/f12000/pic3.html > http://www.alphaf1.com/gp3/pics/hung19.jpg > > Microprose didn't bother much about the cockpit informaton either. > Still the same limited info, compared to F12K. Is it that difficult to > add essential information? At least with F12K you always know exactly > where you are relative to the opposition. MPS still went for a > bitmapped cockpit as well. > > A nice little touch is the flags carried by the public in F12K. GP3 > fans are much flatter. Hell, they look like muesli or something! :-) > > Let's hope the physics engine, AI and online play will be something > special, or Microprose will quickly fall behind... They still have GP4 > up their sleeve, but it probably will have to compete against F12002, > so... > > Attila > I think we are getting into a grey area there. He has made games
that appear to have a 3d look but then so did DOOM, and we all should
know how really flat that game was. GP3 will be the
first product that uses 3d acceleration and so I think we can truthfully
say he is an unknown quantity right now concerning 3d issues.
dave henrie
Jo Helsen wrote:
Quoted text (37 lines)
> > "Brian V. Balgobind" <[email hidden]> wrote: > > > > >"Simon Brown" <[email hidden]> schreef in bericht > >news:EIT_4.7963$[email hidden]... > >> You've got to be kidding. I played F1 2000 for about 3 hours before > >> un-installing it. I've never seen such messy grahpics and sloppy engine. > >> Just look at the game from the replay views and ask yourself - "does this > >> look anything like F1?". Track layouts wrong (utterly unforgiveable), > >> colour schemes all wrong, stupid AI drivers that spin out on the formation > >> lap (!!!) and hit each other and you all the time. > >> Another example of EA forcing the developer to release way before they > >were > >> finished. And as for those two screenshots, the GP3 shot wins by a mile. > >> Can't you see how artificial F1 2000 looks? Those cars on that shot look > >> terrible, just look at that Ferrari, it looks nothing like the real sport. > >> All those criticisms of GP3 are totally peripheral to what make a good > >sim. > >> The most important thing is the physics model, and Geoff Crammond's track > >> record is proven here. Also you need a good 3d engine, again GC is a top > >3d > > > >Top 3d programmer? Can you name 3d games he made??? > > F1GP > The Sentinel > Stunt Car Racer > GP2 > GP3 > > That's 5. > > JoH > > ------- The best way to accelerate a Mac is 9.81 m/s2 -------- > --------------------------------------------------------------ICR2 and Nascar 1 had extensive texture mapping before GP2. Granted, GP2
looked nicer, but it still used bitmap wheels (whereas the Papy sims used
textured polys) so neither was perfect.
Stephen
Simon Brown <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:3fX_4.8356$[email hidden]...
> Revs, Revs+, Sentinel (one of the greatest concepts for a game ever, and
> superbly executed, in full 3d on the C64!), Stunt Car Racer, F1GP (first
> serious F1 sim ever), GP2 (first racing game to feature full texturemapping
> and still considered the top F1 game even today by some people) . All
> classic games without a shadow of a doubt, every one scored over 90%.
>
>
<[email hidden]> schreef in bericht
news:8hh8qq$d9e$[email hidden]...
Well he is comparing the 3d engine of F1 2000 with GP3...that off F1 2000 is
3d hardware accelerated. But according to his message he says GC already has
proven on that area...and i say no..he hasn't proven that yet cause GP3 will
be his first.
> But of course, GP3 will change all that....
>
> 8-)
>
> *Peter* - http://www.cix.co.uk/~peterpc/home.html
Quoted text (21 lines)
> > > The most important thing is the physics model, and Geoff Crammond's > > > track > > > record is proven here. Also you need a good 3d engine, again GC is > > > a top > > 3d > > > > Top 3d programmer? Can you name 3d games he made??? > > GC is a master of 3D, have you never heard of: > > Stunt Car Racer > > F1GP > > Sentinel > > F1GP2 > > All these programs use 3D. They do not use 3D hardware acceleration (3D > graphics cards) because it was not around when they were produced. >Revs, Revs+, Sentinel (one of the greatest concepts for a game ever, and
superbly executed, in full 3d on the C64!), Stunt Car Racer, F1GP (first
serious F1 sim ever), GP2 (first racing game to feature full texture mapping
and still considered the top F1 game even today by some people) . All
classic games without a shadow of a doubt, every one scored over 90%.
Doom wasn't a proper 3d game at all, but F1GP, GP2, Revs, Revs+, The
Sentinel and Stunt Car Racer all were. Revs, Revs+, F1GP, and GP2 all used
some sprites (like for the wheels in GP2) but the vast majority of what you
saw in the game was true 3d. Even F1RS used sprites. The difference with a
game like Doom is that Doom didn't have a "proper" 3d engine at all, so not
even the corridors were generated in 3d.
And Stunt Car Racer and The Sentinel were 100% all in 3d. Geoff Crammond
was writing true 3d games when John Carmack was still working out
raycasting.
Theres a common misconception that because GP2 had only just recently been
able to run 25fps in 640*480 that it's a slow engine, which is just rubbish.
The same people who say such things should try running Quake in 640*480 in
software mode and see how slow it is, and Quake has nothing like the draw
distance of GP2 and no physics to run.
That's not what I said at all. Geoff Crammond is a proven creator of
excellent 3d engines. Every game he has written has had a 3d engine. It's
still called a 3d engine whether it supports 3d accelerator cards or not.
Even The Sentinel on the C64 had a full 3d engine. I never commented on
Geoff's ability to get the maximum speed out of a 3d accelerator cards.
Also the code overlap between a software and hardware engine is about 95%.
Chech your eye glasses! They just might belong to your grandfather :-)
Borut
"Scott Boham" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:8hgqia$1d6$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (18 lines)
> > I must say I'm really disappointed... The colours in F12000 are much > > more vivid, and have much better contrast. Does GP3 really use 3D > > hardware or is this just another "early" software shot? > > Are you being sarcastic? I can't really tell, but you seem quite serious > to me. Maybe you got the two screenshots muddled up by mistake? > > OTOH, I am worried (by the looks of that screenshot) that they have spent > too much time on graphics and not enough on physics. I would much rather > have a lesser graphically correct game with amazing physics than one with > photo realistic graphics and arcade gameplay. > > Also, I hope it will run smoothly on my P2-400, or else this copy of GP3 > I'm going to buy will become very expensive. > > Scott > >Well, not everything was texture mapped in Nascar Racing, and Indycar 2 was
out well after GP2.
Er no
ICR2 was released over 6 months before GP2.
Although ICR2 was released AFTER GP2 was DUE to be released :-)
Tony
"Simon Brown" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:MZ5%4.9085$[email hidden]...
> Well, not everything was texture mapped in Nascar Racing, and Indycar 2was
> out well after GP2.
>
>
Well, maybe ICR2 had a different release date in Europe and the USA, and
probably the same for GP2 (it would certainly fit with the current release
policies of the two companies). Anyway, the point I was making is that
Geoff Crammond has always been known as a top notch 3d programmer. Whereas
some people seemed to think he'd never done a 3d game before!
You're probably right, although the release date for ICR2 in europe may have
been later, since the same thing has happened with all subsequent Papy
games. Also GP2 was probably released ealier in europe than in the US. I
just seem to remember GP2 being earlier, but both CD's are copyright 1995 so
you are probably right.
Anyway, the point I was trying to make is that Geoff Crammond is well known
for being an excellent 3d programmer.
Simon Brown wrote:
> And Stunt Car Racer and The Sentinel were 100% all in 3d. Geoff Crammond
> was writing true 3d games when John Carmack was still working out
> raycasting.
Speaking of Stunt Car Racer, I read in an interview quite some time ago
that Goeff was perhaps interested in making a new version of that
classic game. Of course he'll have to finish GP3 first.
I used to play SCR all the time on my old Atari ST, but I wonder, was
there ever a VGA version made for PC? I've seen some screenshots of a
monochromatic PC version but never something with more than 16 colors.
Was duch a version ever made?
--
Kotta
In article <[email hidden]>, Kotta <[email hidden]> wrote:
If you're feeling slightly naughty, you candownload the game and an appropiate
emulator to run it on your PC
Please remove my_pants when replying.


































