On Mon 10 Jul 2000 05:24:42pm, Zonky wrote:
>Try renting films other than "hollywood history" Saving Private
>Ryan. There were other's soldiers around.
I've seen SPR, and despite the licence taken with some of the events, I
think it's a good film, and worthy of praise, as the main thrust of the
story is the human interest. If the film were being sold as a
"historical account", then that would be different. Eg "The Patriot",
which is so wildly inaccurate that I suspect when it opens in Europe it
may make the furore over "U-571" look very minor. There's an excellent
report on this on The Guardian's site at:
www.guardianunlimited.co.uk/Archive/Article/0,4273,4038697,00.html
--
David. (GPLRank handicap: +19.68)
"After all, a mere thousand yards - such a harmless little knoll,
really."
(Raymond Mays on Shelsley Walsh)
Flame warOff-topic: WWII history near Spa
Doug Gordon's tribute to his father's WWII unit near Spa turned into an argument about Saving Private Ryan, American-centred war films, and which nations fought in the Battle of the Bulge, including an obscene insult from one poster. Bruce Kennewell and others argued over whether British units fought near Spa, and several posters later apologised to Doug.
off-topic
Automated summary.
In article <8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]>, Doug Gordon <[email hidden]> wrote:
>It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in
>this area just a few years after so many American and German soldiers
>had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times...
Try renting films other than "hollywood history" Saving Private Ryan. There
were other's soldiers around.
Z.
Please remove my_pants when replying.
I was recently reading the history of my father's unit in WW-II (the
99th U.S. Infantry Div.) and their part in the Battle of the Bulge.
They held a position on Elsenborn Ridge in Belgium. When I looked at a
map that showed information on the battle lines, I was surprised when
the names of the nearby towns just leaped out at me -- Stavelot,
Malmedy, Lingueville. These were just a few miles from Elsenborn. I
wonder if he actually went through or near these towns during
his "travels" in 1944-45?
It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in
this area just a few years after so many American and German soldiers
had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times...
Doug Gordon
Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
Before you buy.
Try 20k...80k were wounded + dead + MIA.
It was a whopping 200, again you are citing wounded + dead + MIA...
This was a batlle in which Brittish, Belgian, Canadians, and French troops
also fought; sure there were much more Americans and Nazis but give credit
where credit is due! Also give credit to the citizens who lived through
that ***in those towns. Zonky may have made a harsh statement, but true
none-the-less....so calm down.
Jon
What's your problem Zonky. Cool it!
Gene
Zonky <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:8kctbq$i6n$[email hidden]...
> In article <8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]>, Doug Gordon<[email hidden]> wrote:
There
> were other's soldiers around.
>
> Z.
>
>
> Please remove my_pants when replying.
Quoted text (7 lines)
> > > >It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in > >this area just a few years after so many American and German soldiers > >had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times... > > Try renting films other than "hollywood history" Saving Private Ryan.The Battle of the Bulge was a German attack against the American 1st Army.
The Americans lost close to 80,000 men there. The British were also
involved, but to a much lesser degree, losing about 1,400 men.
So, please forgive Doug for writing about this as a German/American battle,
and fuck you.
Regards,
Gordon
Zonky <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:8kctbq$i6n$[email hidden]...
> In article <8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]>, Doug Gordon<[email hidden]> wrote:
There
> were other's soldiers around.
>
> Z.
>
>
> Please remove my_pants when replying.
Quoted text (7 lines)
> > > >It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in > >this area just a few years after so many American and German soldiers > >had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times... > > Try renting films other than "hollywood history" Saving Private Ryan.You may also like to remember the British, Canadian, Australian, Polish,
French, Belgian, Dutch and Nepalese soldiers who fought as well. Apologies
to any nation who I may have missed out.
Cheers
Phil
Doug Gordon <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (18 lines)
> I was recently reading the history of my father's unit in WW-II (the > 99th U.S. Infantry Div.) and their part in the Battle of the Bulge. > They held a position on Elsenborn Ridge in Belgium. When I looked at a > map that showed information on the battle lines, I was surprised when > the names of the nearby towns just leaped out at me -- Stavelot, > Malmedy, Lingueville. These were just a few miles from Elsenborn. I > wonder if he actually went through or near these towns during > his "travels" in 1944-45? > > It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in > this area just a few years after so many American and German soldiers > had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times... > > Doug Gordon > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > Before you buy.
Andre Warringa <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
I see your point, but personally I never assumed that the film was intended
to be an exhaustive history of the D-Day landings and aftermath. It's a
Spielberg movie after all- remember his film "1942"? Best forgotten :-) It
struck me as more of a human interest drama with a military setting,
following a small American unit wandering through American assigned zones.
The exact same story could have been done with a British unit landing on
Sword beach and searching for a lost airborne trooper around Caen and I'd
have been just as interested. And I doubt that I'd even notice any absence
of Americans unless the landing were done on Omaha or something.
Maybe the upcoming "Band of Brothers" will show a larger cross section of
participants.
Quoted text (8 lines)
> On Mon, 10 Jul 2000 12:19:36 -0500, "Gene Bonin" > <[email hidden]> wrote: > > >What's your problem Zonky. Cool it! > > Zonky said it a little bit harsh, but I know what he means. It > bothered me too that Saving Private Ryan made it seem that only > Americans were involved.On Mon, 10 Jul 2000 12:19:36 -0500, "Gene Bonin"
<[email hidden]> wrote:
>What's your problem Zonky. Cool it!
Zonky said it a little bit harsh, but I know what he means. It
bothered me too that Saving Private Ryan made it seem that only
Americans were involved.
Andre
Quoted text (22 lines)
> >Gene > >Zonky <[email hidden]> wrote in message >news:8kctbq$i6n$[email hidden]... >> In article <8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]>, Doug Gordon ><[email hidden]> wrote: >> >> >> >It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in >> >this area just a few years after so many American and German soldiers >> >had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times... >> >> Try renting films other than "hollywood history" Saving Private Ryan. >There >> were other's soldiers around. >> >> Z. >> >> >> Please remove my_pants when replying. >
"Gordon McLachlan" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:ZBna5.150$[email hidden]...
> The Battle of the Bulge was a German attack against the American 1st Army.
> The Americans lost close to 80,000 men there.
Try 20k...80k were wounded + dead + MIA.
> The British were also
> involved, but to a much lesser degree, losing about 1,400 men.
It was a whopping 200, again you are citing wounded + dead + MIA...
> So, please forgive Doug for writing about this as a German/Americanbattle,
> and fuck you.
This was a batlle in which Brittish, Belgian, Canadians, and French troops
also fought; sure there were much more Americans and Nazis but give credit
where credit is due! Also give credit to the citizens who lived through
that crap in those towns. Zonky may have made a harsh statement, but true
none-the-less....so calm down.
Jon
My comments were strictly pertaining to the 99th Division at Elsenborn
Ridge. I am fully aware of the many other nationalities who fought in the
overall battle. Sorry that my intentions were not more clear and that a
tribute to my father who was wounded in this battle turned into such a
typical R.A.S. flame war.
Doug
Zonky <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:8kctbq$i6n$[email hidden]...
> In article <8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]>, Doug Gordon<[email hidden]> wrote:
There
> were other's soldiers around.
>
> Z.
>
>
> Please remove my_pants when replying.
Quoted text (7 lines)
> > > >It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in > >this area just a few years after so many American and German soldiers > >had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times... > > Try renting films other than "hollywood history" Saving Private Ryan.
Bruce Kennewell <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
ushered
battle
> > of the bulge" until it had well and truly been decided in the allies
> favour.
> >
> > Furthermore, this was the 3rd pan-European conflict within the lifetimeof
> > most adults back then and, people had to get on with their lives. Even
> when
> > we were occupied we didn't just sit around quivering with fear from the
> > German aggressors, we had to get on with it ("we" means my parent's and
> > grandparent's generation, I wasn't around at the time). Food had to beput
jumped
Quoted text (23 lines)
> "Civilians were ushered out.....before hostilities commenced"?!!! > > Where on earth did you glean this fascinating fact from, Jan?! > Do you really believe that the protagonists went around from door-to-door, > like canvassers, advising the occupants that they should move further down > the road in case they got hurt?!!! > > If you do, and you REALLY have an interest in the history of WW II and how > it affected the individual, whether civilian or bearer-of-arms (an > irrespective of nationality) then spend several months in the depths of a > good reference library....I'm sure that Antwerp must have one. > > -- > Regards, > Bruce Kennewell, > Canberra, Australia. > --------------------------- > > Jan Verschueren <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > Doug, > > > > You have to remember WWII was not a televised war. Civilians wereQuoted text (7 lines)
> > out of the battle zone (hopefully, maybe not in this particular case, as > the > > region was thinly populated) before hostilities commenced and only let > back > > in when all was said and done. Casualties and wounded were indeed just > > statistics in the papers back then. I for one, know for sure the common > > people here to the north of Antwerp didn't learn details about "theQuoted text (14 lines)
> > on the table, rent paid etc... > > > > After the war there wasn't much time to mourn the respective casualties, > we > > had countries to rebuild, international prestige to revitalize. Any > > opportunity to show how well we had recovered from this latest conflict > (50+ > > years of peace was something most people didn't believe in, having > witnessed > > major conflicts every 15-20 years) had to be grasped, including GP's. > > > > If this seems callous in retrospect, allow me to apologize on behalf of > the > > nation. It's just after 5 years of being "in the middle of it", weQuoted text (25 lines)
> at > > the opportunity to be ourselves again. > > > > I am aware the 99th took a pasting living under atrocious conditions, so > > please don't view this message as disrespectfull towards the sacrifice > these > > units made. > > > > Jan. > > =--- > > Doug Gordon wrote... > > > <snip> > > > It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in > > > this area just a few years after so many American and German soldiers > > > had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times... > > > > > > Doug Gordon > > > > > > > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > > > Before you buy. > > > > > >At the beginning of the war the local constabulary informed both my
grandparents on my mother's and father's side the German army was advancing
and the north of Antwerp would probably fall by such and such date (indeed
on a door to door basis). Each family left one person behind to guard the
property and fled the area. My dad and his parents were passed by the
advancing army in the region of Gent and figured they could probably return
home as the "battle" was now ahead of them. My mother's parents ran all the
way to northern France before our army capitulated.
At the end of the war it somehow came to pass (I don't know how the
information was distributed this time) the Germans were going to make a
stand just to the north of where my dad lived at the time, so everyone moved
to villages which were to be "surrendered" to the advancing Canadian Army,
who in turn didn't let my grandparents anywhere near their house for the
week or so the Germans were able to hold on to their positions.
Obviously, I can't say this was the case everywhere, which I why I added
"hopefully". I don't need to go to a library to find out how WWII affected
people around here Bruce. I can ask just about anyone around me. The subject
is not gone from conversation yet. As for the soldier's point of view, my
aunt married an English soldier who saw his entire platoon wiped out in 20
seconds on D-Day, my uncle and great uncle managed to get to England and
served with the Royal Artillery and RAF respectively. 'zat good enough for
ya, or do you want to hear about the labour camps some other family members
were shipped off to?
Jan.
=---
Bruce Kennewell wrote...
Quoted text (19 lines)
> "Civilians were ushered out.....before hostilities commenced"?!!! > > Where on earth did you glean this fascinating fact from, Jan?! > Do you really believe that the protagonists went around from door-to-door, > like canvassers, advising the occupants that they should move further down > the road in case they got hurt?!!! > > If you do, and you REALLY have an interest in the history of WW II and how > it affected the individual, whether civilian or bearer-of-arms (an > irrespective of nationality) then spend several months in the depths of a > good reference library....I'm sure that Antwerp must have one. > > -- > Regards, > Bruce Kennewell, > Canberra, Australia. > --------------------------- > > <snip>Nice sentiment Doug. My apologies for jumping on the wrong wagon there.
Jan.
=---
Doug Gordon wrote...
Quoted text (18 lines)
> Jan, again what I wrote was somewhat misinterpreted. I was not saying > that there was something wrong with racing near the site of a previous > battle. To the contrary, I was marvelling at the way that the war's > wounds were so quickly healed and the reconstruction of Europe was > accomplished. Do you think that in the immediate aftermath of WW-II > that anyone in Europe could have imagined the formation of the EU by > the end of the century? I am the son of an American WW-II veteran; the > owner of a company I worked for, and a good friend of mine, is the son > of a German soldier who was killed while fighting on the Eastern Front > in the early 40's. What Europe has done in the last 50 years should be > a model for some other parts of the world that refuse to let past > history stay in the past! > > Doug Gordon > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > Before you buy.Nice sentiment Doug. My apologies for jumping on the wrong wagon there.
Jan.
=---
Doug Gordon wrote...
Quoted text (18 lines)
> Jan, again what I wrote was somewhat misinterpreted. I was not saying > that there was something wrong with racing near the site of a previous > battle. To the contrary, I was marvelling at the way that the war's > wounds were so quickly healed and the reconstruction of Europe was > accomplished. Do you think that in the immediate aftermath of WW-II > that anyone in Europe could have imagined the formation of the EU by > the end of the century? I am the son of an American WW-II veteran; the > owner of a company I worked for, and a good friend of mine, is the son > of a German soldier who was killed while fighting on the Eastern Front > in the early 40's. What Europe has done in the last 50 years should be > a model for some other parts of the world that refuse to let past > history stay in the past! > > Doug Gordon > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > Before you buy.Nice sentiment Doug. My apologies for jumping on the wrong wagon there.
Jan.
=---
Doug Gordon wrote...
Quoted text (18 lines)
> Jan, again what I wrote was somewhat misinterpreted. I was not saying > that there was something wrong with racing near the site of a previous > battle. To the contrary, I was marvelling at the way that the war's > wounds were so quickly healed and the reconstruction of Europe was > accomplished. Do you think that in the immediate aftermath of WW-II > that anyone in Europe could have imagined the formation of the EU by > the end of the century? I am the son of an American WW-II veteran; the > owner of a company I worked for, and a good friend of mine, is the son > of a German soldier who was killed while fighting on the Eastern Front > in the early 40's. What Europe has done in the last 50 years should be > a model for some other parts of the world that refuse to let past > history stay in the past! > > Doug Gordon > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > Before you buy.On Tue 11 Jul 2000 12:17:10pm, Bruce Kennewell wrote:
<snip>
Yes, OK, badly phrased. What I really meant was "carefully framed so as
to give the impression that the whole of D-Day was a US operation".
--
David. (GPLRank handicap: +19.68)
"After all, a mere thousand yards - such a harmless little knoll,
really."
(Raymond Mays on Shelsley Walsh)
Quoted text (7 lines)
>David, I am intrigued by your words "despite the licence taken with >some of the events". > >Which event (or events) in the film do you have an issue with? >(Bear in mind, of course, that the only part of the film that >portrayed a well-documented historical fact was the landing on Omaha >Beach).Major newsreader hickup here, my apologies.
Jan.
How did this empty one get here? -It's not even in my "Sent Items" folder!
Probably related to triple post further down.
My apologies,
Jan.
=---
Jan Verschueren wrote...
> <nothing ??><snip>
Doug Gordon <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:ugsa5.30983$[email hidden]...
Doug,
i apologise- however, like others, i suspect (and having just read some rather
infurating movie reviews by IMDB users) i am among a number of people who grow
increasingly angry and concerned at the current spait of revisionist american
films & other media and it's affects on perception of historical events.
Z.
(who is waiting for the movie in which Nigel Mansell was an american who won
Indy THEN F1) :P
Please remove my_pants when replying.
Quoted text (7 lines)
> My comments were strictly pertaining to the 99th Division at Elsenborn > Ridge. I am fully aware of the many other nationalities who fought in the > overall battle. Sorry that my intentions were not more clear and that a > tribute to my father who was wounded in this battle turned into such a > typical R.A.S. flame war. > > DougJan, again what I wrote was somewhat misinterpreted. I was not saying
that there was something wrong with racing near the site of a previous
battle. To the contrary, I was marvelling at the way that the war's
wounds were so quickly healed and the reconstruction of Europe was
accomplished. Do you think that in the immediate aftermath of WW-II
that anyone in Europe could have imagined the formation of the EU by
the end of the century? I am the son of an American WW-II veteran; the
owner of a company I worked for, and a good friend of mine, is the son
of a German soldier who was killed while fighting on the Eastern Front
in the early 40's. What Europe has done in the last 50 years should be
a model for some other parts of the world that refuse to let past
history stay in the past!
Doug Gordon
Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
Before you buy.
Doug,
You have to remember WWII was not a televised war. Civilians were ushered
out of the battle zone (hopefully, maybe not in this particular case, as the
region was thinly populated) before hostilities commenced and only let back
in when all was said and done. Casualties and wounded were indeed just
statistics in the papers back then. I for one, know for sure the common
people here to the north of Antwerp didn't learn details about "the battle
of the bulge" until it had well and truly been decided in the allies favour.
Furthermore, this was the 3rd pan-European conflict within the lifetime of
most adults back then and, people had to get on with their lives. Even when
we were occupied we didn't just sit around quivering with fear from the
German aggressors, we had to get on with it ("we" means my parent's and
grandparent's generation, I wasn't around at the time). Food had to be put
on the table, rent paid etc...
After the war there wasn't much time to mourn the respective casualties, we
had countries to rebuild, international prestige to revitalize. Any
opportunity to show how well we had recovered from this latest conflict (50+
years of peace was something most people didn't believe in, having witnessed
major conflicts every 15-20 years) had to be grasped, including GP's.
If this seems callous in retrospect, allow me to apologize on behalf of the
nation. It's just after 5 years of being "in the middle of it", we jumped at
the opportunity to be ourselves again.
I am aware the 99th took a pasting living under atrocious conditions, so
please don't view this message as disrespectfull towards the sacrifice these
units made.
Jan.
=---
Doug Gordon wrote...
Quoted text (10 lines)
> <snip> > It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in > this area just a few years after so many American and German soldiers > had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times... > > Doug Gordon > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > Before you buy.Fair enough Doug. I wasn't looking to start a flame war either, sorry mate.
I am grateful that people like your father came over and helped us Europeans
out.
Cheers
Phil
Doug Gordon <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:ugsa5.30983$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (29 lines)
> My comments were strictly pertaining to the 99th Division at Elsenborn > Ridge. I am fully aware of the many other nationalities who fought in the > overall battle. Sorry that my intentions were not more clear and that a > tribute to my father who was wounded in this battle turned into such a > typical R.A.S. flame war. > > Doug > > > Zonky <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:8kctbq$i6n$[email hidden]... > > In article <8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]>, Doug Gordon > <[email hidden]> wrote: > > > > > > >It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in > > >this area just a few years after so many American and German soldiers > > >had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times... > > > > Try renting films other than "hollywood history" Saving Private Ryan. > There > > were other's soldiers around. > > > > Z. > > > > > > Please remove my_pants when replying. > >Sorry Bruce, I should think more before I post. I've done some
investigation since and found this site with detals of the offensive:
http://users.skynet.be/bulgecriba/battlebul.htm
I'll have a read later and learn more about it. I hope I didn't cause any
offense.
Cheers
Phil
Bruce Kennewell <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (44 lines)
> If you can find any evidence of any of those nationalities fighting in or > around that region ("Spa") in WWII, please point me in that direction. > > -- > Regards, > Bruce Kennewell, > Canberra, Australia. > --------------------------- > > Phil Lee <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:IXma5.7019$[email hidden]... > > You may also like to remember the British, Canadian, Australian, Polish, > > French, Belgian, Dutch and Nepalese soldiers who fought as well. > Apologies > > to any nation who I may have missed out. > > > > Cheers > > > > Phil > > > > Doug Gordon <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]... > > > I was recently reading the history of my father's unit in WW-II (the > > > 99th U.S. Infantry Div.) and their part in the Battle of the Bulge. > > > They held a position on Elsenborn Ridge in Belgium. When I looked at a > > > map that showed information on the battle lines, I was surprised when > > > the names of the nearby towns just leaped out at me -- Stavelot, > > > Malmedy, Lingueville. These were just a few miles from Elsenborn. I > > > wonder if he actually went through or near these towns during > > > his "travels" in 1944-45? > > > > > > It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in > > > this area just a few years after so many American and German soldiers > > > had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times... > > > > > > Doug Gordon > > > > > > > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > > > Before you buy. > > > > > >I've just found this site, it may interest you if you haven't seen it
before:
http://users.skynet.be/bulgecriba/battlebul.htm
Cheers
Phil
Doug Gordon <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:ugsa5.30983$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (29 lines)
> My comments were strictly pertaining to the 99th Division at Elsenborn > Ridge. I am fully aware of the many other nationalities who fought in the > overall battle. Sorry that my intentions were not more clear and that a > tribute to my father who was wounded in this battle turned into such a > typical R.A.S. flame war. > > Doug > > > Zonky <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:8kctbq$i6n$[email hidden]... > > In article <8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]>, Doug Gordon > <[email hidden]> wrote: > > > > > > >It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in > > >this area just a few years after so many American and German soldiers > > >had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times... > > > > Try renting films other than "hollywood history" Saving Private Ryan. > There > > were other's soldiers around. > > > > Z. > > > > > > Please remove my_pants when replying. > >On Mon, 10 Jul 2000 14:54:35 -0400, "Gault"
<[email hidden]> wrote:
>I see your point, but personally I never assumed that the film was intended
>to be an exhaustive history of the D-Day landings and aftermath. It's a
>Spielberg movie after all- remember his film "1942"? Best forgotten :-) It
>struck me as more of a human interest drama with a military setting,
I should have added that the movie made a huge impression on me,
especially the first part, the landing at the beach. Really showed how
terrible war can be. And don't forget Spielberg's Schindler's List,
imho the best war movie ever. Now that movie really made a huge
impression on me.
Andre
Quoted text (11 lines)
>following a small American unit wandering through American assigned zones. >The exact same story could have been done with a British unit landing on >Sword beach and searching for a lost airborne trooper around Caen and I'd >have been just as interested. And I doubt that I'd even notice any absence >of Americans unless the landing were done on Omaha or something. > >Maybe the upcoming "Band of Brothers" will show a larger cross section of >participants. > > >On Tue, 11 Jul 2000 07:50:32 +1000, "Bruce Kennewell"
<[email hidden]> wrote:
You should've become a script writer Bruce :)
But, you're right. For once :)
Andre
Quoted text (10 lines)
>What's wrong with you people? > >"SPR" was a film about a group of AMERICAN soldiers looking for another >AMERICAN soldier . Those AMERICANs in Ryan's group happended to land in the >AMERICAN sector on D-Day. > >Would have been somewhat strange if the movie had been about a bunch of >Canadians, landing on the British beaches, then heading off looking for a >Nepalese Ghurka who had lost his Polish brothers whilst fighting for the >French, don't you think?From a man who fought in the war...
http://www.mm.com/user/jpk/battle.htm
Jon
"Bruce Kennewell" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (44 lines)
> If you can find any evidence of any of those nationalities fighting in or > around that region ("Spa") in WWII, please point me in that direction. > > -- > Regards, > Bruce Kennewell, > Canberra, Australia. > --------------------------- > > Phil Lee <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:IXma5.7019$[email hidden]... > > You may also like to remember the British, Canadian, Australian, Polish, > > French, Belgian, Dutch and Nepalese soldiers who fought as well. > Apologies > > to any nation who I may have missed out. > > > > Cheers > > > > Phil > > > > Doug Gordon <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]... > > > I was recently reading the history of my father's unit in WW-II (the > > > 99th U.S. Infantry Div.) and their part in the Battle of the Bulge. > > > They held a position on Elsenborn Ridge in Belgium. When I looked at a > > > map that showed information on the battle lines, I was surprised when > > > the names of the nearby towns just leaped out at me -- Stavelot, > > > Malmedy, Lingueville. These were just a few miles from Elsenborn. I > > > wonder if he actually went through or near these towns during > > > his "travels" in 1944-45? > > > > > > It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in > > > this area just a few years after so many American and German soldiers > > > had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times... > > > > > > Doug Gordon > > > > > > > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > > > Before you buy. > > > > > >And?
I stand by my original question...show me evidence of any unit other than
American which fought in the Spa area.
Unless it was a British platoon that became detached from the main British
force and horribly lost, there were no units other than American (and
German, of course) in that area.
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
> From a man who fought in the war...
> http://www.mm.com/user/jpk/battle.htm
> Jon
> > If you can find any evidence of any of those nationalities fighting in
or
> > around that region ("Spa") in WWII, please point me in that direction.
> > --
> > Regards,
> > Bruce Kennewell,
> > Canberra, Australia.
> > ---------------------------
> > > You may also like to remember the British, Canadian, Australian,
Polish,
> > > French, Belgian, Dutch and Nepalese soldiers who fought as well.
> > Apologies
> > > to any nation who I may have missed out.
> > > Cheers
> > > Phil
> > > > I was recently reading the history of my father's unit in WW-II (the
> > > > 99th U.S. Infantry Div.) and their part in the Battle of the Bulge.
> > > > They held a position on Elsenborn Ridge in Belgium. When I looked at
a
> > > > map that showed information on the battle lines, I was surprised
when
> > > > the names of the nearby towns just leaped out at me -- Stavelot,
> > > > Malmedy, Lingueville. These were just a few miles from Elsenborn. I
> > > > wonder if he actually went through or near these towns during
> > > > his "travels" in 1944-45?
> > > > It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in
> > > > this area just a few years after so many American and German
soldiers
> > > > had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times...
> > > > Doug Gordon
> > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
> > > > Before you buy.
Major newsreader hickup here, my apologies.
Jan.
Read it again for the first time!
Jon
(the
> > > > > 99th U.S. Infantry Div.) and their part in the Battle of the Bulge.
> > > > > They held a position on Elsenborn Ridge in Belgium. When I looked at
> a
> > > > > map that showed information on the battle lines, I was surprised
> when
> > > > > the names of the nearby towns just leaped out at me -- Stavelot,
> > > > > Malmedy, Lingueville. These were just a few miles from Elsenborn. I
> > > > > wonder if he actually went through or near these towns during
> > > > > his "travels" in 1944-45?
> > > > > It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in
Quoted text (51 lines)
> And? > I stand by my original question...show me evidence of any unit other than > American which fought in the Spa area. > Unless it was a British platoon that became detached from the main British > force and horribly lost, there were no units other than American (and > German, of course) in that area. > -- > Regards, > Bruce Kennewell, > Canberra, Australia. > --------------------------- > > From a man who fought in the war... > > http://www.mm.com/user/jpk/battle.htm > > Jon > > > If you can find any evidence of any of those nationalities fighting in > or > > > around that region ("Spa") in WWII, please point me in that direction. > > > -- > > > Regards, > > > Bruce Kennewell, > > > Canberra, Australia. > > > --------------------------- > > > > You may also like to remember the British, Canadian, Australian, > Polish, > > > > French, Belgian, Dutch and Nepalese soldiers who fought as well. > > > Apologies > > > > to any nation who I may have missed out. > > > > Cheers > > > > Phil > > > > > I was recently reading the history of my father's unit in WW-IIQuoted text (8 lines)
> > > > > this area just a few years after so many American and German > soldiers > > > > > had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times... > > > > > Doug Gordon > > > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > > > > > Before you buy.Hey Zonk.....read your history pertaining to that area during WWII,
particularly those items concerning the units which fought in that zone.
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
Zonky <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:8kctbq$i6n$[email hidden]...
> In article <8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]>, Doug Gordon
<[email hidden]> wrote:
>
>
> >It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in
> >this area just a few years after so many American and German soldiers
> >had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times...
>
> Try renting films other than "hollywood history" Saving Private Ryan.
There
> were other's soldiers around.
>
> Z.
>
>
> Please remove my_pants when replying.
If you can find any evidence of any of those nationalities fighting in or
around that region ("Spa") in WWII, please point me in that direction.
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
Phil Lee <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:IXma5.7019$[email hidden]...
> You may also like to remember the British, Canadian, Australian, Polish,
> French, Belgian, Dutch and Nepalese soldiers who fought as well.
Apologies
> to any nation who I may have missed out.
>
> Cheers
>
> Phil
>
> Doug Gordon <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> news:8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]...
> > I was recently reading the history of my father's unit in WW-II (the
> > 99th U.S. Infantry Div.) and their part in the Battle of the Bulge.
> > They held a position on Elsenborn Ridge in Belgium. When I looked at a
> > map that showed information on the battle lines, I was surprised when
> > the names of the nearby towns just leaped out at me -- Stavelot,
> > Malmedy, Lingueville. These were just a few miles from Elsenborn. I
> > wonder if he actually went through or near these towns during
> > his "travels" in 1944-45?
> >
> > It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in
> > this area just a few years after so many American and German soldiers
> > had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times...
> >
> > Doug Gordon
> >
> >
> > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
> > Before you buy.
>
>
What's wrong with you people?
"SPR" was a film about a group of AMERICAN soldiers looking for another
AMERICAN soldier . Those AMERICANs in Ryan's group happended to land in the
AMERICAN sector on D-Day.
Would have been somewhat strange if the movie had been about a bunch of
Canadians, landing on the British beaches, then heading off looking for a
Nepalese Ghurka who had lost his Polish brothers whilst fighting for the
French, don't you think?
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
Andre Warringa <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> On Mon, 10 Jul 2000 12:19:36 -0500, "Gene Bonin"
> <[email hidden]> wrote:
>
> >What's your problem Zonky. Cool it!
>
> Zonky said it a little bit harsh, but I know what he means. It
> bothered me too that Saving Private Ryan made it seem that only
> Americans were involved.
>
> Andre
>
> >
> >Gene
> >
> >Zonky <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> >news:8kctbq$i6n$[email hidden]...
> >> In article <8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]>, Doug Gordon
> ><[email hidden]> wrote:
> >>
> >>
> >> >It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in
> >> >this area just a few years after so many American and German soldiers
> >> >had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times...
> >>
> >> Try renting films other than "hollywood history" Saving Private Ryan.
> >There
> >> were other's soldiers around.
> >>
> >> Z.
> >>
> >>
> >> Please remove my_pants when replying.
> >
>
In article <[email hidden]>, "Bruce Kennewell" <[email hidden]> wrote:
BATTLE FACTS
The coldest, snowiest weather �in memory� in the Ardennes Forest on the
German/Belgium border.
Over a million men, 500,000 Germans, 600,000 Americans (more than fought on
both sides at Gettysburg) and 55,000 British.
3 German armies, 10 corps, the equivalent of 29 divisions.
3 American armies, 6 corps, the equivalent of 31 divisions.
The equivalent of 3 British divisions as well as contingents of Belgian,
Canadian and French troops.
Is that clear enough?
Z.
Please remove my_pants when replying.
Quoted text (7 lines)
>And? >I stand by my original question...show me evidence of any unit other than >American which fought in the Spa area. > >Unless it was a British platoon that became detached from the main British >force and horribly lost, there were no units other than American (and >German, of course) in that area.Getting a bit off topic here aint we mr Z <G>
MS
"Zonky" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:CAGa5.15639$Hm2.27869@NewsReader...
> In article <[email hidden]>, "Bruce Kennewell"<[email hidden]> wrote:
>
> >And?
> >I stand by my original question...show me evidence of any unit other than
> >American which fought in the Spa area.
> >
> >Unless it was a British platoon that became detached from the mainBritish
on
Quoted text (8 lines)
> >force and horribly lost, there were no units other than American (and > >German, of course) in that area. > > BATTLE FACTS > > The coldest, snowiest weather "in memory" in the Ardennes Forest on the > German/Belgium border. > Over a million men, 500,000 Germans, 600,000 Americans (more than foughtQuoted text (12 lines)
> both sides at Gettysburg) and 55,000 British. > 3 German armies, 10 corps, the equivalent of 29 divisions. > 3 American armies, 6 corps, the equivalent of 31 divisions. > The equivalent of 3 British divisions as well as contingents of Belgian, > Canadian and French troops. > > Is that clear enough? > > Z. > > > Please remove my_pants when replying.Jan Verschueren wrote:
>
> How did this empty one get here? -It's not even in my "Sent Items" folder!
> Probably related to triple post further down.
>
> My apologies,
Outbreak Express strikes again! :-))
--
Chuck Kandler
A man is no less a Slave just because he is
allowed to choose a new Master every four years.
Read it again for the first time!
Jon
"Bruce Kennewell" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
(the
> > > > > 99th U.S. Infantry Div.) and their part in the Battle of theBulge.
> > > > > They held a position on Elsenborn Ridge in Belgium. When I lookedat
> a
> > > > > map that showed information on the battle lines, I was surprised
> when
> > > > > the names of the nearby towns just leaped out at me -- Stavelot,
> > > > > Malmedy, Lingueville. These were just a few miles from Elsenborn.I
> > > > > wonder if he actually went through or near these towns during
> > > > > his "travels" in 1944-45?
> > > > >
> > > > > It's strange to ponder that they were holding international racesin
Quoted text (48 lines)
> And? > I stand by my original question...show me evidence of any unit other than > American which fought in the Spa area. > > Unless it was a British platoon that became detached from the main British > force and horribly lost, there were no units other than American (and > German, of course) in that area. > -- > Regards, > Bruce Kennewell, > Canberra, Australia. > --------------------------- > > Jon Van Ginneken <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:SAva5.196$[email hidden]... > > From a man who fought in the war... > > http://www.mm.com/user/jpk/battle.htm > > > > Jon > > > > > > "Bruce Kennewell" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:[email hidden]... > > > If you can find any evidence of any of those nationalities fighting in > or > > > around that region ("Spa") in WWII, please point me in that direction. > > > > > > -- > > > Regards, > > > Bruce Kennewell, > > > Canberra, Australia. > > > --------------------------- > > > > > > Phil Lee <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > > news:IXma5.7019$[email hidden]... > > > > You may also like to remember the British, Canadian, Australian, > Polish, > > > > French, Belgian, Dutch and Nepalese soldiers who fought as well. > > > Apologies > > > > to any nation who I may have missed out. > > > > > > > > Cheers > > > > > > > > Phil > > > > > > > > Doug Gordon <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > > > news:8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]... > > > > > I was recently reading the history of my father's unit in WW-IIQuoted text (17 lines)
> > > > > this area just a few years after so many American and German > soldiers > > > > > had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times... > > > > > > > > > > Doug Gordon > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > > > > > Before you buy. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > >
David Buttery <[email hidden]> wrote in
message news:[email hidden]...
How so? A small American infantry unit lands on an American assigned beach.
This film did little to give an impression of the WHOLE of D-Day, either US
or Allied. Following your line of thinking here, one could also claim that
the various Allied navies, air forces, intelligence officers, and many
others crucial to the event were overlooked in this depiction. And
overlooked they were, but the thrust of the film isn't toward a documentary.
Maybe you were expecting something along the lines of an updated and vastly
improved "The Longest Day", which SPR is not.
Quoted text (13 lines)
> On Tue 11 Jul 2000 12:17:10pm, Bruce Kennewell wrote: > > >David, I am intrigued by your words "despite the licence taken with > >some of the events". > > > >Which event (or events) in the film do you have an issue with? > >(Bear in mind, of course, that the only part of the film that > >portrayed a well-documented historical fact was the landing on Omaha > >Beach). > <snip> > > Yes, OK, badly phrased. What I really meant was "carefully framed so as > to give the impression that the whole of D-Day was a US operation".why are you jumping all over "zonky"and insulting him?
he is right in what he said, and didn't insult anybody....
Sudesh
Gordon McLachlan wrote:
Quoted text (29 lines)
> > The Battle of the Bulge was a German attack against the American 1st Army. > The Americans lost close to 80,000 men there. The British were also > involved, but to a much lesser degree, losing about 1,400 men. > > So, please forgive Doug for writing about this as a German/American battle, > and fuck you. > > Regards, > Gordon > > Zonky <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:8kctbq$i6n$[email hidden]... > > In article <8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]>, Doug Gordon > <[email hidden]> wrote: > > > > > > >It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in > > >this area just a few years after so many American and German soldiers > > >had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times... > > > > Try renting films other than "hollywood history" Saving Private Ryan. > There > > were other's soldiers around. > > > > Z. > > > > > > Please remove my_pants when replying.Well, "enjoy" is not the word I would have chosen but thank you for the
reference, Jon.
As the note at the bottom of that page states, there *were* British forces
involved (about 2,000). Now I shall spend some time in finding out
something about them.
Thanks again.
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
Jon Van Ginneken <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:dUQa5.5$[email hidden]...
> http://www.heartofeurope.com/bulgeinc.html
> Enjoy...
>
> Jon
>
>
> "Bruce Kennewell" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> news:[email hidden]...
> > I have, Jon and can only assume that you are directing my attention to
the
> > "within a few miles of" phrase?
> > --
> > Regards,
> > Bruce Kennewell,
> > Canberra, Australia.
> > ---------------------------
> >
> > Jon Van Ginneken <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> > news:9wIa5.233$[email hidden]...
> > > Read it again for the first time!
> > >
> > > Jon
> > >
> > > "Bruce Kennewell" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> > > news:[email hidden]...
> > > > And?
> > > > I stand by my original question...show me evidence of any unit other
> > than
> > > > American which fought in the Spa area.
> > > >
> > > > Unless it was a British platoon that became detached from the main
> > British
> > > > force and horribly lost, there were no units other than American
(and
> > > > German, of course) in that area.
> > > > --
> > > > Regards,
> > > > Bruce Kennewell,
> > > > Canberra, Australia.
> > > > ---------------------------
> > > >
> > > > Jon Van Ginneken <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> > > > news:SAva5.196$[email hidden]...
> > > > > From a man who fought in the war...
> > > > > http://www.mm.com/user/jpk/battle.htm
> > > > >
> > > > > Jon
> > > > >
> > > > >
> > > > > "Bruce Kennewell" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> > > > > news:[email hidden]...
> > > > > > If you can find any evidence of any of those nationalities
> fighting
> > in
> > > > or
> > > > > > around that region ("Spa") in WWII, please point me in that
> > direction.
> > > > > >
> > > > > > --
> > > > > > Regards,
> > > > > > Bruce Kennewell,
> > > > > > Canberra, Australia.
> > > > > > ---------------------------
> > > > > >
> > > > > > Phil Lee <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> > > > > > news:IXma5.7019$[email hidden]...
> > > > > > > You may also like to remember the British, Canadian,
Australian,
> > > > Polish,
> > > > > > > French, Belgian, Dutch and Nepalese soldiers who fought as
well.
> > > > > > Apologies
> > > > > > > to any nation who I may have missed out.
> > > > > > >
> > > > > > > Cheers
> > > > > > >
> > > > > > > Phil
> > > > > > >
> > > > > > > Doug Gordon <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> > > > > > > news:8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]...
> > > > > > > > I was recently reading the history of my father's unit in
> WW-II
> > > (the
> > > > > > > > 99th U.S. Infantry Div.) and their part in the Battle of the
> > > Bulge.
> > > > > > > > They held a position on Elsenborn Ridge in Belgium. When I
> > looked
> > > at
> > > > a
> > > > > > > > map that showed information on the battle lines, I was
> surprised
> > > > when
> > > > > > > > the names of the nearby towns just leaped out at me --
> Stavelot,
> > > > > > > > Malmedy, Lingueville. These were just a few miles from
> > Elsenborn.
> > > I
> > > > > > > > wonder if he actually went through or near these towns
during
> > > > > > > > his "travels" in 1944-45?
> > > > > > > >
> > > > > > > > It's strange to ponder that they were holding international
> > races
> > > in
> > > > > > > > this area just a few years after so many American and German
> > > > soldiers
> > > > > > > > had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those
times...
> > > > > > > >
> > > > > > > > Doug Gordon
> > > > > > > >
> > > > > > > >
> > > > > > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
> > > > > > > > Before you buy.
> > > > > > >
> > > > > > >
> > > > > >
> > > > > >
> > > > >
> > > > >
> > > >
> > > >
> > >
> > >
> >
> >
>
>
On Tue 11 Jul 2000 10:32:27pm, Bruce Kennewell wrote:
>Only one *major* movie depicts the Normandy landings on D-Day as a
>combined-nations operation.....and that is "The Longest Day".
Excellent film. OK, I conced defeat here. I'd mis-remembered some of
the details. Tut, tut, David - posted without checking facts. Do 500
lines!
--
David. (GPLRank handicap: +19.68)
"After all, a mere thousand yards - such a harmless little knoll,
really."
(Raymond Mays on Shelsley Walsh)
"Bruce Kennewell" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> Merci, Andre.
> --
> Regards,
> Bruce Kennewell,
> Canberra, Australia.
> ---------------------------
Ah, you're just prejudiced because you're an.......ummmmm .....Aussie. Or
somthing.
Nevermind.
Merci, Andre.
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
Andre Warringa <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> On Tue, 11 Jul 2000 07:50:32 +1000, "Bruce Kennewell"
> <[email hidden]> wrote:
>
> >What's wrong with you people?
> >
> >"SPR" was a film about a group of AMERICAN soldiers looking for another
> >AMERICAN soldier . Those AMERICANs in Ryan's group happended to land in
the
> >AMERICAN sector on D-Day.
> >
> >Would have been somewhat strange if the movie had been about a bunch of
> >Canadians, landing on the British beaches, then heading off looking for a
> >Nepalese Ghurka who had lost his Polish brothers whilst fighting for the
> >French, don't you think?
>
> You should've become a script writer Bruce :)
> But, you're right. For once :)
>
> Andre
Doug, you have nothing to apologise for in what you said.
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
Doug Gordon <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:ugsa5.30983$[email hidden]...
> My comments were strictly pertaining to the 99th Division at Elsenborn
> Ridge. I am fully aware of the many other nationalities who fought in the
> overall battle. Sorry that my intentions were not more clear and that a
> tribute to my father who was wounded in this battle turned into such a
> typical R.A.S. flame war.
>
> Doug
"Civilians were ushered out.....before hostilities commenced"?!!!
Where on earth did you glean this fascinating fact from, Jan?!
Do you really believe that the protagonists went around from door-to-door,
like canvassers, advising the occupants that they should move further down
the road in case they got hurt?!!!
If you do, and you REALLY have an interest in the history of WW II and how
it affected the individual, whether civilian or bearer-of-arms (an
irrespective of nationality) then spend several months in the depths of a
good reference library....I'm sure that Antwerp must have one.
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
Jan Verschueren <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> Doug,
>
> You have to remember WWII was not a televised war. Civilians were ushered
> out of the battle zone (hopefully, maybe not in this particular case, as
the
> region was thinly populated) before hostilities commenced and only let
back
> in when all was said and done. Casualties and wounded were indeed just
> statistics in the papers back then. I for one, know for sure the common
> people here to the north of Antwerp didn't learn details about "the battle
> of the bulge" until it had well and truly been decided in the allies
favour.
>
> Furthermore, this was the 3rd pan-European conflict within the lifetime of
> most adults back then and, people had to get on with their lives. Even
when
> we were occupied we didn't just sit around quivering with fear from the
> German aggressors, we had to get on with it ("we" means my parent's and
> grandparent's generation, I wasn't around at the time). Food had to be put
> on the table, rent paid etc...
>
> After the war there wasn't much time to mourn the respective casualties,
we
> had countries to rebuild, international prestige to revitalize. Any
> opportunity to show how well we had recovered from this latest conflict
(50+
> years of peace was something most people didn't believe in, having
witnessed
> major conflicts every 15-20 years) had to be grasped, including GP's.
>
> If this seems callous in retrospect, allow me to apologize on behalf of
the
> nation. It's just after 5 years of being "in the middle of it", we jumped
at
> the opportunity to be ourselves again.
>
> I am aware the 99th took a pasting living under atrocious conditions, so
> please don't view this message as disrespectfull towards the sacrifice
these
> units made.
>
> Jan.
> =---
> Doug Gordon wrote...
> > <snip>
> > It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in
> > this area just a few years after so many American and German soldiers
> > had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times...
> >
> > Doug Gordon
> >
> >
> > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
> > Before you buy.
>
>
Phil, you didn't cause *ME* any offense and I therefore accept your apology
without hesitation.
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
Phil Lee <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:CSsa5.7643$[email hidden]...
> Sorry Bruce, I should think more before I post. I've done some
> investigation since and found this site with detals of the offensive:
>
> http://users.skynet.be/bulgecriba/battlebul.htm
>
> I'll have a read later and learn more about it. I hope I didn't cause any
> offense.
>
> Cheers
>
> Phil
>
> Bruce Kennewell <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> news:[email hidden]...
> > If you can find any evidence of any of those nationalities fighting in
or
> > around that region ("Spa") in WWII, please point me in that direction.
> >
> > --
> > Regards,
> > Bruce Kennewell,
> > Canberra, Australia.
> > ---------------------------
> >
> > Phil Lee <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> > news:IXma5.7019$[email hidden]...
> > > You may also like to remember the British, Canadian, Australian,
Polish,
> > > French, Belgian, Dutch and Nepalese soldiers who fought as well.
> > Apologies
> > > to any nation who I may have missed out.
> > >
> > > Cheers
> > >
> > > Phil
> > >
> > > Doug Gordon <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> > > news:8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]...
> > > > I was recently reading the history of my father's unit in WW-II (the
> > > > 99th U.S. Infantry Div.) and their part in the Battle of the Bulge.
> > > > They held a position on Elsenborn Ridge in Belgium. When I looked at
a
> > > > map that showed information on the battle lines, I was surprised
when
> > > > the names of the nearby towns just leaped out at me -- Stavelot,
> > > > Malmedy, Lingueville. These were just a few miles from Elsenborn. I
> > > > wonder if he actually went through or near these towns during
> > > > his "travels" in 1944-45?
> > > >
> > > > It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in
> > > > this area just a few years after so many American and German
soldiers
> > > > had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times...
> > > >
> > > > Doug Gordon
> > > >
> > > >
> > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
> > > > Before you buy.
> > >
> > >
> >
> >
>
>
David, I am intrigued by your words "despite the licence taken with some of
the events".
Which event (or events) in the film do you have an issue with? (Bear in
mind, of course, that the only part of the film that portrayed a
well-documented historical fact was the landing on Omaha Beach).
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
David Buttery <[email hidden]> wrote in
message news:[email hidden]...
> On Mon 10 Jul 2000 05:24:42pm, Zonky wrote:
>
> >Try renting films other than "hollywood history" Saving Private
> >Ryan. There were other's soldiers around.
>
> I've seen SPR, and despite the licence taken with some of the events, I
> think it's a good film, and worthy of praise, as the main thrust of the
> story is the human interest. If the film were being sold as a
> "historical account", then that would be different. Eg "The Patriot",
> which is so wildly inaccurate that I suspect when it opens in Europe it
> may make the furore over "U-571" look very minor. There's an excellent
> report on this on The Guardian's site at:
>
> www.guardianunlimited.co.uk/Archive/Article/0,4273,4038697,00.html
>
> --
> David. (GPLRank handicap: +19.68)
> "After all, a mere thousand yards - such a harmless little knoll,
> really."
> (Raymond Mays on Shelsley Walsh)
And?
I stand by my original question...show me evidence of any unit other than
American which fought in the Spa area.
Unless it was a British platoon that became detached from the main British
force and horribly lost, there were no units other than American (and
German, of course) in that area.
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
Jon Van Ginneken <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:SAva5.196$[email hidden]...
> From a man who fought in the war...
> http://www.mm.com/user/jpk/battle.htm
>
> Jon
>
>
> "Bruce Kennewell" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> news:[email hidden]...
> > If you can find any evidence of any of those nationalities fighting in
or
> > around that region ("Spa") in WWII, please point me in that direction.
> >
> > --
> > Regards,
> > Bruce Kennewell,
> > Canberra, Australia.
> > ---------------------------
> >
> > Phil Lee <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> > news:IXma5.7019$[email hidden]...
> > > You may also like to remember the British, Canadian, Australian,
Polish,
> > > French, Belgian, Dutch and Nepalese soldiers who fought as well.
> > Apologies
> > > to any nation who I may have missed out.
> > >
> > > Cheers
> > >
> > > Phil
> > >
> > > Doug Gordon <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> > > news:8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]...
> > > > I was recently reading the history of my father's unit in WW-II (the
> > > > 99th U.S. Infantry Div.) and their part in the Battle of the Bulge.
> > > > They held a position on Elsenborn Ridge in Belgium. When I looked at
a
> > > > map that showed information on the battle lines, I was surprised
when
> > > > the names of the nearby towns just leaped out at me -- Stavelot,
> > > > Malmedy, Lingueville. These were just a few miles from Elsenborn. I
> > > > wonder if he actually went through or near these towns during
> > > > his "travels" in 1944-45?
> > > >
> > > > It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in
> > > > this area just a few years after so many American and German
soldiers
> > > > had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times...
> > > >
> > > > Doug Gordon
> > > >
> > > >
> > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
> > > > Before you buy.
> > >
> > >
> >
> >
>
>
http://www.heartofeurope.com/bulgeinc.html
Enjoy...
Jon
"Bruce Kennewell" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
fighting
WW-II
surprised
> > > when
> > > > > > > the names of the nearby towns just leaped out at me --Stavelot,
Quoted text (42 lines)
> I have, Jon and can only assume that you are directing my attention to the > "within a few miles of" phrase? > -- > Regards, > Bruce Kennewell, > Canberra, Australia. > --------------------------- > > Jon Van Ginneken <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:9wIa5.233$[email hidden]... > > Read it again for the first time! > > > > Jon > > > > "Bruce Kennewell" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:[email hidden]... > > > And? > > > I stand by my original question...show me evidence of any unit other > than > > > American which fought in the Spa area. > > > > > > Unless it was a British platoon that became detached from the main > British > > > force and horribly lost, there were no units other than American (and > > > German, of course) in that area. > > > -- > > > Regards, > > > Bruce Kennewell, > > > Canberra, Australia. > > > --------------------------- > > > > > > Jon Van Ginneken <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > > news:SAva5.196$[email hidden]... > > > > From a man who fought in the war... > > > > http://www.mm.com/user/jpk/battle.htm > > > > > > > > Jon > > > > > > > > > > > > "Bruce Kennewell" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > > > news:[email hidden]... > > > > > If you can find any evidence of any of those nationalitiesQuoted text (26 lines)
> in > > > or > > > > > around that region ("Spa") in WWII, please point me in that > direction. > > > > > > > > > > -- > > > > > Regards, > > > > > Bruce Kennewell, > > > > > Canberra, Australia. > > > > > --------------------------- > > > > > > > > > > Phil Lee <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > > > > news:IXma5.7019$[email hidden]... > > > > > > You may also like to remember the British, Canadian, Australian, > > > Polish, > > > > > > French, Belgian, Dutch and Nepalese soldiers who fought as well. > > > > > Apologies > > > > > > to any nation who I may have missed out. > > > > > > > > > > > > Cheers > > > > > > > > > > > > Phil > > > > > > > > > > > > Doug Gordon <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > > > > > news:8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]... > > > > > > > I was recently reading the history of my father's unit inQuoted text (8 lines)
> > (the > > > > > > > 99th U.S. Infantry Div.) and their part in the Battle of the > > Bulge. > > > > > > > They held a position on Elsenborn Ridge in Belgium. When I > looked > > at > > > a > > > > > > > map that showed information on the battle lines, I wasQuoted text (30 lines)
> > > > > > > Malmedy, Lingueville. These were just a few miles from > Elsenborn. > > I > > > > > > > wonder if he actually went through or near these towns during > > > > > > > his "travels" in 1944-45? > > > > > > > > > > > > > > It's strange to ponder that they were holding international > races > > in > > > > > > > this area just a few years after so many American and German > > > soldiers > > > > > > > had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times... > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Doug Gordon > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > > > > > > > Before you buy. > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > >Well, "enjoy" is not the word I would have chosen but thank you for the
reference, Jon.
As the note at the bottom of that page states, there *were* British forces
involved (about 2,000). Now I shall spend some time in finding out
something about them.
Thanks again.
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
> http://www.heartofeurope.com/bulgeinc.html
> Enjoy...
> Jon
> > I have, Jon and can only assume that you are directing my attention to
the
> > "within a few miles of" phrase?
> > --
> > Regards,
> > Bruce Kennewell,
> > Canberra, Australia.
> > ---------------------------
> > > Read it again for the first time!
> > > Jon
> > > > And?
> > > > I stand by my original question...show me evidence of any unit other
> > than
> > > > American which fought in the Spa area.
> > > > Unless it was a British platoon that became detached from the main
> > British
> > > > force and horribly lost, there were no units other than American
(and
> > > > German, of course) in that area.
> > > > --
> > > > Regards,
> > > > Bruce Kennewell,
> > > > Canberra, Australia.
> > > > ---------------------------
> > > > > From a man who fought in the war...
> > > > > http://www.mm.com/user/jpk/battle.htm
> > > > > Jon
> > > > > > If you can find any evidence of any of those nationalities
> fighting
> > in
> > > > or
> > > > > > around that region ("Spa") in WWII, please point me in that
> > direction.
> > > > > > --
> > > > > > Regards,
> > > > > > Bruce Kennewell,
> > > > > > Canberra, Australia.
> > > > > > ---------------------------
> > > > > > > You may also like to remember the British, Canadian,
Australian,
> > > > Polish,
> > > > > > > French, Belgian, Dutch and Nepalese soldiers who fought as
well.
> > > > > > Apologies
> > > > > > > to any nation who I may have missed out.
> > > > > > > Cheers
> > > > > > > Phil
> > > > > > > > I was recently reading the history of my father's unit in
> WW-II
> > > (the
> > > > > > > > 99th U.S. Infantry Div.) and their part in the Battle of the
> > > Bulge.
> > > > > > > > They held a position on Elsenborn Ridge in Belgium. When I
> > looked
> > > at
> > > > a
> > > > > > > > map that showed information on the battle lines, I was
> surprised
> > > > when
> > > > > > > > the names of the nearby towns just leaped out at me --
> Stavelot,
> > > > > > > > Malmedy, Lingueville. These were just a few miles from
> > Elsenborn.
> > > I
> > > > > > > > wonder if he actually went through or near these towns
during
> > > > > > > > his "travels" in 1944-45?
> > > > > > > > It's strange to ponder that they were holding international
> > races
> > > in
> > > > > > > > this area just a few years after so many American and German
> > > > soldiers
> > > > > > > > had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those
times...
> > > > > > > > Doug Gordon
> > > > > > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
> > > > > > > > Before you buy.
No, Zonk, it's not.
I'm referring to the SPA-FRANCORCHAMPS area.
Which British troops fought within the area that includes the villages in
Doug's original post....Malmedy, Stavelot etc.?
I cannot find any indication in my reference material to any unit
designations other than American and German that were within a stone's throw
of what we now think of as the Spa circuit.
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
Zonky <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:CAGa5.15639$Hm2.27869@NewsReader...
> In article <[email hidden]>, "Bruce Kennewell"
<[email hidden]> wrote:
>
> >And?
> >I stand by my original question...show me evidence of any unit other than
> >American which fought in the Spa area.
> >
> >Unless it was a British platoon that became detached from the main
British
> >force and horribly lost, there were no units other than American (and
> >German, of course) in that area.
>
> BATTLE FACTS
>
> The coldest, snowiest weather "in memory" in the Ardennes Forest on the
> German/Belgium border.
> Over a million men, 500,000 Germans, 600,000 Americans (more than fought
on
> both sides at Gettysburg) and 55,000 British.
> 3 German armies, 10 corps, the equivalent of 29 divisions.
> 3 American armies, 6 corps, the equivalent of 31 divisions.
> The equivalent of 3 British divisions as well as contingents of Belgian,
> Canadian and French troops.
>
> Is that clear enough?
>
> Z.
>
>
> Please remove my_pants when replying.
Only one *major* movie depicts the Normandy landings on D-Day as a
combined-nations operation.....and that is "The Longest Day".
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
David Buttery <[email hidden]> wrote in
message news:[email hidden]...
> On Tue 11 Jul 2000 12:17:10pm, Bruce Kennewell wrote:
>
> >David, I am intrigued by your words "despite the licence taken with
> >some of the events".
> >
> >Which event (or events) in the film do you have an issue with?
> >(Bear in mind, of course, that the only part of the film that
> >portrayed a well-documented historical fact was the landing on Omaha
> >Beach).
> <snip>
>
> Yes, OK, badly phrased. What I really meant was "carefully framed so as
> to give the impression that the whole of D-Day was a US operation".
>
> --
> David. (GPLRank handicap: +19.68)
> "After all, a mere thousand yards - such a harmless little knoll,
> really."
> (Raymond Mays on Shelsley Walsh)
Ah! The local constabulary....NOT representatives of the Axis or Allied
forces. Fair enough. I misinterpreted your statement.....sorry about that.
And no, there is no need for you to give details regarding either relatives
sent to forced labour camps or those who served. Although Australia is a
zillion miles from Europe we also have one or two people here who are
related to those Aussies who fought, and in some cases died, in the towns
and countryside of Europe, not to mention the Pacific, Asia and Middle East.
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
Jan Verschueren <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> At the beginning of the war the local constabulary informed both my
> grandparents on my mother's and father's side the German army was
advancing
> and the north of Antwerp would probably fall by such and such date (indeed
> on a door to door basis). Each family left one person behind to guard the
> property and fled the area. My dad and his parents were passed by the
> advancing army in the region of Gent and figured they could probably
return
> home as the "battle" was now ahead of them. My mother's parents ran all
the
> way to northern France before our army capitulated.
>
> At the end of the war it somehow came to pass (I don't know how the
> information was distributed this time) the Germans were going to make a
> stand just to the north of where my dad lived at the time, so everyone
moved
> to villages which were to be "surrendered" to the advancing Canadian Army,
> who in turn didn't let my grandparents anywhere near their house for the
> week or so the Germans were able to hold on to their positions.
>
> Obviously, I can't say this was the case everywhere, which I why I added
> "hopefully". I don't need to go to a library to find out how WWII affected
> people around here Bruce. I can ask just about anyone around me. The
subject
> is not gone from conversation yet. As for the soldier's point of view, my
> aunt married an English soldier who saw his entire platoon wiped out in 20
> seconds on D-Day, my uncle and great uncle managed to get to England and
> served with the Royal Artillery and RAF respectively. 'zat good enough for
> ya, or do you want to hear about the labour camps some other family
members
> were shipped off to?
>
> Jan.
> =---
> Bruce Kennewell wrote...
> > "Civilians were ushered out.....before hostilities commenced"?!!!
> >
> > Where on earth did you glean this fascinating fact from, Jan?!
> > Do you really believe that the protagonists went around from
door-to-door,
> > like canvassers, advising the occupants that they should move further
down
> > the road in case they got hurt?!!!
> >
> > If you do, and you REALLY have an interest in the history of WW II and
how
> > it affected the individual, whether civilian or bearer-of-arms (an
> > irrespective of nationality) then spend several months in the depths of
a
> > good reference library....I'm sure that Antwerp must have one.
> >
> > --
> > Regards,
> > Bruce Kennewell,
> > Canberra, Australia.
> > ---------------------------
> >
> > <snip>
>
>
I have, Jon and can only assume that you are directing my attention to the
"within a few miles of" phrase?
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
Jon Van Ginneken <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:9wIa5.233$[email hidden]...
> Read it again for the first time!
>
> Jon
>
> "Bruce Kennewell" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> news:[email hidden]...
> > And?
> > I stand by my original question...show me evidence of any unit other
than
> > American which fought in the Spa area.
> >
> > Unless it was a British platoon that became detached from the main
British
> > force and horribly lost, there were no units other than American (and
> > German, of course) in that area.
> > --
> > Regards,
> > Bruce Kennewell,
> > Canberra, Australia.
> > ---------------------------
> >
> > Jon Van Ginneken <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> > news:SAva5.196$[email hidden]...
> > > From a man who fought in the war...
> > > http://www.mm.com/user/jpk/battle.htm
> > >
> > > Jon
> > >
> > >
> > > "Bruce Kennewell" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> > > news:[email hidden]...
> > > > If you can find any evidence of any of those nationalities fighting
in
> > or
> > > > around that region ("Spa") in WWII, please point me in that
direction.
> > > >
> > > > --
> > > > Regards,
> > > > Bruce Kennewell,
> > > > Canberra, Australia.
> > > > ---------------------------
> > > >
> > > > Phil Lee <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> > > > news:IXma5.7019$[email hidden]...
> > > > > You may also like to remember the British, Canadian, Australian,
> > Polish,
> > > > > French, Belgian, Dutch and Nepalese soldiers who fought as well.
> > > > Apologies
> > > > > to any nation who I may have missed out.
> > > > >
> > > > > Cheers
> > > > >
> > > > > Phil
> > > > >
> > > > > Doug Gordon <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> > > > > news:8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]...
> > > > > > I was recently reading the history of my father's unit in WW-II
> (the
> > > > > > 99th U.S. Infantry Div.) and their part in the Battle of the
> Bulge.
> > > > > > They held a position on Elsenborn Ridge in Belgium. When I
looked
> at
> > a
> > > > > > map that showed information on the battle lines, I was surprised
> > when
> > > > > > the names of the nearby towns just leaped out at me -- Stavelot,
> > > > > > Malmedy, Lingueville. These were just a few miles from
Elsenborn.
> I
> > > > > > wonder if he actually went through or near these towns during
> > > > > > his "travels" in 1944-45?
> > > > > >
> > > > > > It's strange to ponder that they were holding international
races
> in
> > > > > > this area just a few years after so many American and German
> > soldiers
> > > > > > had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times...
> > > > > >
> > > > > > Doug Gordon
> > > > > >
> > > > > >
> > > > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
> > > > > > Before you buy.
> > > > >
> > > > >
> > > >
> > > >
> > >
> > >
> >
> >
>
>
"amos-opus" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> why are you jumping all over "zonky"and insulting him?
> he is right in what he said, and didn't insult anybody....
Because the guy makes a full time occupation of fanning the flames, getting
into wars of semantics. and generally causing bad feeling whilst self
contradicting himself on many occasions.
He was the guy who used to make trouble every time an off- topic post
appeared in this forum so why is he now indulging in this argument?
MS
That's very interesting Doug. I bet there were quiet a few pondering just
that thought on that first race there after the war.
I was wondering where you got your information on your Dads particular unit
from? I would like to find out some info about my Dad as well and where his
unit went.
I know he landed on Omaha beach on his birthday as a tank commander and got
his tracks blown off which put him back a couple days. I know he was among
those who first ran upon and liberated one of the consentration camps. I
have some very disturbing photos he took. I also know he married the first
German war bride of WWII (my Mom still has the newspaper clipping) But I
don't know too much more except that he won a bronze star. He didn't like to
talk about it much from what I understand. He died when I was only 8 yrs
old. He was forced to take a shower(s?) in DDT in the war. And also to go
though other chemical chambers. I'm not exactly sure why he had to do this,
but my Mom had to prove these things in court after he died from 13
different cancers to be able to get some of his pension. I still get the
chance to hear stories from my Mom though. What it was like growing up as a
poor German girl in Nuremberg. Living though the bombings, losing a brother
on the Eastern front, another in a JU87, another (still alive now) who was
captured.
Makes you sure feel lucky, almost to the point of guilt that we didn't have
to live or fight in that war.
Jim D.
Doug Gordon wrote in message <8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]>...
Quoted text (18 lines)
>I was recently reading the history of my father's unit in WW-II (the >99th U.S. Infantry Div.) and their part in the Battle of the Bulge. >They held a position on Elsenborn Ridge in Belgium. When I looked at a >map that showed information on the battle lines, I was surprised when >the names of the nearby towns just leaped out at me -- Stavelot, >Malmedy, Lingueville. These were just a few miles from Elsenborn. I >wonder if he actually went through or near these towns during >his "travels" in 1944-45? > >It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in >this area just a few years after so many American and German soldiers >had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times... > > Doug Gordon > > >Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ >Before you buy.Jim...you will probably find this address most helpful:-
http://members.aol.com/dadswar/index.htm
--
Regards,
Bruce Kennewell,
Canberra, Australia.
---------------------------
Jim Dombrowski <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:pMnb5.44738$[email hidden]...
> That's very interesting Doug. I bet there were quiet a few pondering just
> that thought on that first race there after the war.
> I was wondering where you got your information on your Dads particular
unit
> from? I would like to find out some info about my Dad as well and where
his
> unit went.
> I know he landed on Omaha beach on his birthday as a tank commander and
got
> his tracks blown off which put him back a couple days. I know he was among
> those who first ran upon and liberated one of the consentration camps. I
> have some very disturbing photos he took. I also know he married the
first
> German war bride of WWII (my Mom still has the newspaper clipping) But I
> don't know too much more except that he won a bronze star. He didn't like
to
> talk about it much from what I understand. He died when I was only 8 yrs
> old. He was forced to take a shower(s?) in DDT in the war. And also to go
> though other chemical chambers. I'm not exactly sure why he had to do
this,
> but my Mom had to prove these things in court after he died from 13
> different cancers to be able to get some of his pension. I still get the
> chance to hear stories from my Mom though. What it was like growing up as
a
> poor German girl in Nuremberg. Living though the bombings, losing a
brother
> on the Eastern front, another in a JU87, another (still alive now) who was
> captured.
> Makes you sure feel lucky, almost to the point of guilt that we didn't
have
> to live or fight in that war.
>
> Jim D.
>
>
> Doug Gordon wrote in message <8kcq03$otu$[email hidden]>...
> >I was recently reading the history of my father's unit in WW-II (the
> >99th U.S. Infantry Div.) and their part in the Battle of the Bulge.
> >They held a position on Elsenborn Ridge in Belgium. When I looked at a
> >map that showed information on the battle lines, I was surprised when
> >the names of the nearby towns just leaped out at me -- Stavelot,
> >Malmedy, Lingueville. These were just a few miles from Elsenborn. I
> >wonder if he actually went through or near these towns during
> >his "travels" in 1944-45?
> >
> >It's strange to ponder that they were holding international races in
> >this area just a few years after so many American and German soldiers
> >had lost their lives in the fierce fighting of those times...
> >
> > Doug Gordon
> >
> >
> >Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
> >Before you buy.
>
>


































