Don't you find it frustrating that most sims on the market today generally lack
the grip of the real thing. The car just slices around like ice skating.
Do racing sims lack realistic tyre grip?
A poster complained that sims feel like ice skating compared with real cars. Replies argued that grip is often about right or even too high, and that the real problem is the lack of physical feedback and g-forces, with developers sometimes reducing grip or power to keep lap times realistic. The discussion moved to motion simulators, including Silicon Motor Speedway, and why tilting cockpits cause simulator sickness and cannot reproduce sustained lateral g.
Automated summary.
I don't find it frustrating, because I think that it is actually realistic.
If you could feel the g-forces of the car in the simulator, I think that the
tire grip would be quite realistic, and that you would probably be scared
shitless by how fast you are going and the unbelievable forces involved. If
you could actually feel how fast you are accelerating and turning, like in a
real car, then the grip would seem realistic. It's hard to discern the
forces involved when you're sitting in front of a desk watching computer
pixels flash by. I think the frustrating thing is just that -- that there
is no g-force simulation so unless it's a good sim (gpl :-) ), or until we
get g-force simulation, it's hard to tell just when you're going to lose
grip.
Brook
GUCCIPHILE <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> Don't you find it frustrating that most sims on the market today generallylack
> the grip of the real thing. The car just slices around like ice skating.
yes but in that car you can feel when the tires are going to lose grip.
That's my point. lifelike feedback. Not like computers, no real feedback.
Happy racing!
Brook
SKurj <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> Hmm my brother's 5 liter mustang was very tail happy, with an overexuberant
> stomp on the gas pedal. I'd imagine race cars with better power to weight
> ratio's would be even more so. However I have no experience in real racecars
>If you could feel the g-forces of the car in the simulator, I think that the
>tire grip would be quite realistic, and that you would probably be scared
>shitless by how fast you are going and the unbelievable forces involved.
Hehehe a while ago i was talking to my friend and we were talking about the
ring. And how the cars dont go high much. He said fear factor. And i had a
wierd though about a simulator cockpit. and tunr you feel the gs' and if you do
barrle rolls on GPL the cockpit sim would start doing barrle rolls at that
volocity. And you would be ejected. :-)
Hmm my brother's 5 liter mustang was very tail happy, with an over exuberant
stomp on the gas pedal. I'd imagine race cars with better power to weight
ratio's would be even more so. However I have no experience in real race cars
Martyn_D
Brook Halvorson wrote:
Quoted text (19 lines)
> I don't find it frustrating, because I think that it is actually realistic. > If you could feel the g-forces of the car in the simulator, I think that the > tire grip would be quite realistic, and that you would probably be scared > shitless by how fast you are going and the unbelievable forces involved. If > you could actually feel how fast you are accelerating and turning, like in a > real car, then the grip would seem realistic. It's hard to discern the > forces involved when you're sitting in front of a desk watching computer > pixels flash by. I think the frustrating thing is just that -- that there > is no g-force simulation so unless it's a good sim (gpl :-) ), or until we > get g-force simulation, it's hard to tell just when you're going to lose > grip. > > Brook > > GUCCIPHILE <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > Don't you find it frustrating that most sims on the market today generally > lack > > the grip of the real thing. The car just slices around like ice skating.well true..
forcefeedback i guess is yer answer, dunno if there are any seats that can help
in the feedback area either
Martyn_D
Brook Halvorson wrote:
Quoted text (13 lines)
> yes but in that car you can feel when the tires are going to lose grip. > That's my point. lifelike feedback. Not like computers, no real feedback. > Happy racing! > > Brook > > SKurj <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > Hmm my brother's 5 liter mustang was very tail happy, with an over > exuberant > > stomp on the gas pedal. I'd imagine race cars with better power to weight > > ratio's would be even more so. However I have no experience in real race > cars"Jan Verschueren" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> There is the crux I guess. If developers would put in the "right" sort of
> grip, people would start doing unrealisticly fast times, just because the
> physics are by definition an approximation and the fear of damage/injuryis
> not present. So I guess grip is the easiest thing to fudge to keep thingsin
> check.
I have a hard time believing that this is true for anything resembling a
"real" champion. It would shatter my preconceptions to learn that they
bravely force themselves from the safety of their trailers with nagging
doubts about their abilities to control the car, let alone control it well
enough better than the next guy in order to win. In the back of my simple
mind, I was certain that they are where they are not because they are more
brave and more foolhardy than I, but because they have a keener sense of a
car's grip at the limit.
Also, by way of anecdotal proof, some of my PB's were made in a race --
where the concern of wiping out weighs very heavily -- not hotlapping alone
in practice, where I care only about riding the limit at the next corner. We
can theorize all we want, and we might even find that you're right, but I
have a difficult time accepting your reasoning.
Michael.
>I don't think that's true. If there wasn't enough grip, laptimes would be
>unrealistically high. Most sims seem to have laptimes that are too low- for
>the best drivers, anyway.
I tried the demo version of Monaco Racing Simulation. The graphics look nice
but the car just slices around the track that doesn't feel real.
Quoted text (14 lines)
>"GUCCIPHILE" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >news:[email hidden]... >> Don't you find it frustrating that most sims on the market today generally >lack >> the grip of the real thing. The car just slices around like ice skating. >> > > > > > > > >There is the crux I guess. If developers would put in the "right" sort of
grip, people would start doing unrealisticly fast times, just because the
physics are by definition an approximation and the fear of damage/injury is
not present. So I guess grip is the easiest thing to fudge to keep things in
check.
Jan.
=---
Aubrey wrote...
> I don't think that's true. If there wasn't enough grip, laptimes would be
> unrealistically high. Most sims seem to have laptimes that are too low-for
> the best drivers, anyway.
> <Snip>
I disagree... there's plenty of grip to be had in MGPRS2. My main gripe with
the game is the AI having traction control.
On the other hand I agree with Frank MGPRS2 does not represent the state of
the art in racing simulations, far from it.
Jan.
=---
GUCCIPHILE wrote...
> ><snip>
> I tried the demo version of Monaco Racing Simulation. The graphics looknice
> but the car just slices around the track that doesn't feel real.
>
>
I think that the grip in most sims is higher than in real life. But the problem
seems to be that it's a bit of all or nothing even at relatively low speeds.
There is too little warning before the tires completely let go in a low to
moderate speed turn. I could understand this happening in a hispeed turn at 150
MPH +, things would tend to happen rather quickly. But , in most sims,
including GPL, the tires let go sometimes completely, without even a squeal
even at moderate speeds ( i.e. less than 60 MPH )
in a turn which at least visually does not feel dangerous at that speed.
Admittedly you dont have any sense of the g-forces for feedback, but it still
does not feel quite right sometimes, and the visuals should be made to match up
with your visual perception of speed relative to reality, and they sometimes
dont. You learn to adjust to it, but I think that there needs to be some
tweaking done to insure that what you see on the screen mimics what you
experience in real life. Cars are routinely made to slide under control in real
racing, in fact I can more easily powerslide my ATV or Go cart on asphalt than
I can any of the cars in any sims. There is a definite lack of tire adhesion
progressiveness in sims. It does feel like you are sliding on ice sometimes
even when you are not
pushing to your personal limit. We all judge a sims accuracy subjectively,
based upon whether it "feels" like what we would expect to happen in real
life,extrapolating from our personal experiences with actual cars. Sometimes It
seems that we are too willing to assume that a demanding sim must be accurate
because it is difficult, but I have played alot of arcadish racers that I could
barely exceed 30 MPH on a straightaway without crashing ( i.e. Gran Prix Racing
for the Nintendo 64). And yet those people who love that game claim that it is
hard to steer the cars because it is so realistic. Sometimes, even in the best
of sims, the shortcoming lies in the game and not with the player. It is quite
possible to make a sim that is more demanding than reality.
I don't think that's true. If there wasn't enough grip, laptimes would be
unrealistically high. Most sims seem to have laptimes that are too low- for
the best drivers, anyway.
"GUCCIPHILE" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> Don't you find it frustrating that most sims on the market today generallylack
> the grip of the real thing. The car just slices around like ice skating.
>
I recently started driving a Late Model stock car and feel that GPL is very
close to the real thing if you make the gears a little taller to reduce the
power and engine braking. I've also used the converter for N2 tracks to GPL
so I could run ovals, Hickory being my favorite 'cause that's similar to the
local track I drive at. Late Models don't run radial tires and slide around
kind'a easily. I've also driven a WC car at one of those driver experiance
programs a few times and they have a lot of grip and power but seem to be
less forgiving when it breaks loose. It's all kind'a like ice skating. The
closer you get to the edge, the more it slides around. Hopefully NASCAR4
will do a good job of modeling the grip.
"GUCCIPHILE" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> Don't you find it frustrating that most sims on the market today generallylack
> the grip of the real thing. The car just slices around like ice skating.
"GUCCIPHILE" <[email hidden]> wrote
> I tried the demo version of Monaco Racing Simulation. The graphics looknice
> but the car just slices around the track that doesn't feel real.
Please don't say "most sims" by only including MGPRS2. It's clearly not
representative of modern F1 racing. So what are the other ones?
--
-- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard>
-- May the Downforce be with you...
-- http://www.WeRace.net
-- People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise
how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world.
Just based on how fast you can get around a track in GPL, I think the
simulation is pretty accurate.
I find that I drive the best in the sim, when I am focused on the scene so
much that I almost forget that its a simulation. If your hardware gets you
to the higher resolutions and performs well that helps too of course.
Jim
"GUCCIPHILE" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> Don't you find it frustrating that most sims on the market today generallylack
> the grip of the real thing. The car just slices around like ice skating.
gucciphile wrote;
>Don't you find it frustrating that most sims on the market today generally
>lack
>the grip of the real thing. The car just slices around like ice skating.
>
Get F1 2000 or SCGT. You can adjust the car physics files to give
yourself all the grip you want. You might be disapointed , as
more grip != more fun, or even more realistic.
Tom
In article <8ko48b$[email hidden]>,
"Brook Halvorson" <[email hidden]> wrote:
>I think the frustrating thing is just that -- that there
> is no g-force simulation so unless it's a good sim (gpl :-) ),
> or until we get g-force simulation, it's hard to tell just
> when you're going to lose grip.
You know, I've had this idea for a g-force race-car simulator.
There's obviously no way (that we know of yet) to simulate the
real forces involved in racing a real car, but I think you
could get a good approximation by building a small roll-cage
with a seat, pedals, wheel, and shifter, then making it so
that the whole thing can rock forward and backward to simulate
accellerating and braking, and also rock side-to-side to
simulate the lateral g-forces you get when going around a turn.
Add force-feedback to the wheel and pedals, and something to
generate vibrations from the engine and various road
conditions, and I think you could have a simulator that would
impress even real race-car drivers.
You could then mount some kind of projection screen on the
front that would move with the car, or even better, come up
with some kind of head-mounted display.
Rainer Weitz
[email hidden]
Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
Before you buy.
Actually it's not a theory, the two most common choices that sim
designers make are either reduce grip or reduce horsepower.
Quoted text (17 lines)
> > I have a hard time believing that this is true for anything resembling a > "real" champion. It would shatter my preconceptions to learn that they > bravely force themselves from the safety of their trailers with nagging > doubts about their abilities to control the car, let alone control it well > enough better than the next guy in order to win. In the back of my simple > mind, I was certain that they are where they are not because they are more > brave and more foolhardy than I, but because they have a keener sense of a > car's grip at the limit. > > Also, by way of anecdotal proof, some of my PB's were made in a race -- > where the concern of wiping out weighs very heavily -- not hotlapping alone > in practice, where I care only about riding the limit at the next corner. We > can theorize all we want, and we might even find that you're right, but I > have a difficult time accepting your reasoning. > > Michael.In article <8kveda$s4$[email hidden]>, [email hidden] says...
I can imagine the NASCAR version of this supposed simulator - the seat
would be permanently leaning to the right...!
--
s i m a g e r y @ h o t m a i l . c o m
Quoted text (10 lines)
> > > I have thought about doing something like this myself. The thing is, > one could probably spend the same amount of money as it would take to > develop and build something like this and instead buy a real race car. > > Seriously though, it would be the coolest thing since sliced bread to > have something like what you are talking about. Perhaps one could buy > a used DaytonaUSA arcade game and figure out a way to interface it with > some kind of game controller....
I have thought about doing something like this myself. The thing is,
one could probably spend the same amount of money as it would take to
develop and build something like this and instead buy a real race car.
Seriously though, it would be the coolest thing since sliced bread to
have something like what you are talking about. Perhaps one could buy
a used DaytonaUSA arcade game and figure out a way to interface it with
some kind of game controller. That would at least save some of the
hardware costs.
Then all you would need is somebody to write a custom patch to your
favorite game for you... BUT, you might get "close enough" simply by
interpreting steering wheel and throttle/brake positions... I dunno.
BTW, what is the PowerBall up to this week?
In article <8ktgfh$kp0$[email hidden]>,
[email hidden] wrote:
Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
Before you buy.
Quoted text (22 lines)
> You know, I've had this idea for a g-force race-car simulator. > There's obviously no way (that we know of yet) to simulate the > real forces involved in racing a real car, but I think you > could get a good approximation by building a small roll-cage > with a seat, pedals, wheel, and shifter, then making it so > that the whole thing can rock forward and backward to simulate > accellerating and braking, and also rock side-to-side to > simulate the lateral g-forces you get when going around a turn. > Add force-feedback to the wheel and pedals, and something to > generate vibrations from the engine and various road > conditions, and I think you could have a simulator that would > impress even real race-car drivers. > You could then mount some kind of projection screen on the > front that would move with the car, or even better, come up > with some kind of head-mounted display. > > Rainer Weitz > [email hidden] > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > Before you buy. >In article <[email hidden]>,
"Matthew V. Jessick" <[email hidden]> wrote:
That looks interesting, but the nearest one to me is over 500
miles away. Besides, it doesn't look they have what I was
talking about. I think to get a realistic driving experience
you need to be able to tip the simulator up to 45 degrees, or
more.
For example: Picture a car making a sharp turn on a level road,
such that the car is experiencing 1 gee of lateral force. If you
have 1 gee downward force from gravity, and 1 gee of centripedal
force pointing horizontally, then the net force experienced by
the driver is approximately 1.4 gee's at an angle of 45 degrees
downward and to the side.
So if you're in a simulator, and you make a sharp turn to the
left, and the simulator tips 45 degrees to the right, you will
feel as if you are pulling a 1-gee turn. The force won't be
quite as strong (only 1 gee, instead of 1.4 gee's) but the
vector of force would be in right direction. When you straighten
out the wheel, the simulator would roll back up to the level
position, and you would no longer feel like you were in a turn.
In the same way, tipping forward and back would simulate the
forces involved in accelerating and braking. Tipping forward
would give you the feeling that you were slowing down, while
tipping back would give you the sensation of accelerating.
As long as the user's frame of reference (the screen) is telling
him that he is level, he will feel like he's swerving back and
forth, accellerating and braking, when he's actually sitting in
one spot, tipping back and forth, and side to side.
Rainer Weitz
Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
Before you buy.
Quoted text (7 lines)
> You should try out the Silicon Motor Speedway stores > in several cities around the country. > see: http://www.smsonline.com/ > > They use motion base simulators with multiple monitors, > force feedback, etc. for mutliple cars in the same NASCAR race. > It's fun, and a great experience.
Matt -- Thanks for the plug, saved me the typing!!
SMS does use pretty realistic tire data.
-- Doug Milliken
ps. looks like you skipped ahead one day...
On Mon, 17 Jul 2000, Matthew V. Jessick wrote:
Quoted text (43 lines)
> You should try out the Silicon Motor Speedway stores > in several cities around the country. > see: http://www.smsonline.com/ > > They use motion base simulators with multiple monitors, > force feedback, etc. for mutliple cars in the same NASCAR race. > It's fun, and a great experience. > > - Matt > > [email hidden] wrote: > > > In article <8ko48b$[email hidden]>, > > "Brook Halvorson" <[email hidden]> wrote: > > >I think the frustrating thing is just that -- that there > > > is no g-force simulation so unless it's a good sim (gpl :-) ), > > > or until we get g-force simulation, it's hard to tell just > > > when you're going to lose grip. > > > > You know, I've had this idea for a g-force race-car simulator. > > There's obviously no way (that we know of yet) to simulate the > > real forces involved in racing a real car, but I think you > > could get a good approximation by building a small roll-cage > > with a seat, pedals, wheel, and shifter, then making it so > > that the whole thing can rock forward and backward to simulate > > accellerating and braking, and also rock side-to-side to > > simulate the lateral g-forces you get when going around a turn. > > Add force-feedback to the wheel and pedals, and something to > > generate vibrations from the engine and various road > > conditions, and I think you could have a simulator that would > > impress even real race-car drivers. > > You could then mount some kind of projection screen on the > > front that would move with the car, or even better, come up > > with some kind of head-mounted display. > > > > Rainer Weitz > > [email hidden] > > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > > Before you buy. > > >You should try out the Silicon Motor Speedway stores
in several cities around the country.
see: http://www.smsonline.com/
They use motion base simulators with multiple monitors,
force feedback, etc. for mutliple cars in the same NASCAR race.
It's fun, and a great experience.
- Matt
[email hidden] wrote:
Quoted text (28 lines)
> In article <8ko48b$[email hidden]>, > "Brook Halvorson" <[email hidden]> wrote: > >I think the frustrating thing is just that -- that there > > is no g-force simulation so unless it's a good sim (gpl :-) ), > > or until we get g-force simulation, it's hard to tell just > > when you're going to lose grip. > > You know, I've had this idea for a g-force race-car simulator. > There's obviously no way (that we know of yet) to simulate the > real forces involved in racing a real car, but I think you > could get a good approximation by building a small roll-cage > with a seat, pedals, wheel, and shifter, then making it so > that the whole thing can rock forward and backward to simulate > accellerating and braking, and also rock side-to-side to > simulate the lateral g-forces you get when going around a turn. > Add force-feedback to the wheel and pedals, and something to > generate vibrations from the engine and various road > conditions, and I think you could have a simulator that would > impress even real race-car drivers. > You could then mount some kind of projection screen on the > front that would move with the car, or even better, come up > with some kind of head-mounted display. > > Rainer Weitz > [email hidden] > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > Before you buy.Now, now. Winston Cup does do a few road courses every season...
In article <[email hidden]>,
BriGuy <[email hidden]> wrote:
> I can imagine the NASCAR version of this supposed simulator - the
> seat would be permanently leaning to the right...!
>
Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/
Before you buy.
"Matthew V. Jessick" wrote:
> There was someone at a WarBirds convention (online flight sim)
> a couple years ago with just a chair that tilted. Nifty gadget.
> It used a small single cylinder hydraulic system, probably rather
> slower acting than what SMS uses.
At the giant Mall of America in Minneapolis, Minnesota, USA, they have a
plane "simulator" that does complete rolls. You can select various
planes (I chose a P51 Mustang). Unfortunately, you don't get to control
the thing, it just goes on a pre-programmed flight. Also, it played
some lame soundtrack rather than letting you hear the actual sounds,
which diluted the effect. It was pretty fun nonetheless. It was quite
an odd feeling when you were completely inverted, just hanging by your
shoulder harness. Warning - be sure to empty your pockets of all loose
change!
Dave Ewing
--
*****************************************************
David A. Ewing
Xilinx Boulder [email hidden]
*****************************************************
On Mon, 17 Jul 2000 [email hidden] wrote:
I suggest some web research on "simulator sickness". Based on what little
I know, large amounts of tilting seem to upset the inner ear (due to the
unnatural rotation), so it's probably not reasonable to use large roll and
pitch angles to simulate lateral and longitudinal acceleration. VW tried
it with their research driving simulator many years ago and, in simulated-
limit-maneuvers, the drivers almost all got motion-sick. My father was one
of the few that actually drove that VW simulator hard (simulating limit
maneuvers) and didn't get sick in a few minutes...
There were other concerns with SMS also -- you have to be careful
when designing anything that will be used by the general public...
<snip>
> As long as the user's frame of reference (the screen) is telling
> him that he is level, he will feel like he's swerving back and
> forth, accellerating and braking, when he's actually sitting in
> one spot, tipping back and forth, and side to side.
Actually, a lot of research has been done on this and I believe
that most of it contradicts your scenerio...
The new big research simulators (DaimlerChrysler and others) have X-Y
tracks so that by moving back and forth, they can actually subject the
simulator to true linear accelerations (of a limited duration). Often this
is combined with pitch and roll (phased in cleverly) to let them maintain
some constant acceleration as well.
-- Doug
Douglas Milliken <[email hidden]>
Milliken Research Associates Inc.
Quoted text (14 lines)
> In article <[email hidden]>, > "Matthew V. Jessick" <[email hidden]> wrote: > > You should try out the Silicon Motor Speedway stores > > see: http://www.smsonline.com/ > > > > They use motion base simulators with multiple monitors, > > force feedback, etc. for mutliple cars in the same NASCAR race. > > It's fun, and a great experience. > > That looks interesting, but the nearest one to me is over 500 > miles away. Besides, it doesn't look they have what I was > talking about. I think to get a realistic driving experience > you need to be able to tip the simulator up to 45 degrees, or > more.In article <8ku5mm$30a$[email hidden]>, [email hidden] says...
The problem is that the simulator has to roll quite rapidly to achieve
the necessary angle of tilt. This rotational acceleration is quite
unnatural (unless you're barrel-rolling!), and can upset the inner ear
and induce motion sickness.
- Michael Powell
Quoted text (8 lines)
> So if you're in a simulator, and you make a sharp turn to the > left, and the simulator tips 45 degrees to the right, you will > feel as if you are pulling a 1-gee turn. The force won't be > quite as strong (only 1 gee, instead of 1.4 gee's) but the > vector of force would be in right direction. When you straighten > out the wheel, the simulator would roll back up to the level > position, and you would no longer feel like you were in a turn. >
[email hidden] wrote:
It doesn't take a lot of of motion to help to fool the senses.
There was someone at a WarBirds convention (online flight sim)
a couple years ago with just a chair that tilted. Nifty gadget.
It used a small single cylinder hydraulic system, probably rather
slower acting than what SMS uses.
The ultimate might have been a NASA simulator that moved
up/down and laterally along a large wall, or the docking simulator
that (so I've heard) was hung in a dark room from an overhead
crane. The trainees were presumably ordered to ignore the extra
1 G. ;) Still, given the confusing way proximity operations
work it was probably useful.
- Matt
Quoted text (13 lines)
> When you straighten > out the wheel, the simulator would roll back up to the level > position, and you would no longer feel like you were in a turn. > In the same way, tipping forward and back would simulate the > forces involved in accelerating and braking. Tipping forward > would give you the feeling that you were slowing down, while > tipping back would give you the sensation of accelerating. > As long as the user's frame of reference (the screen) is telling > him that he is level, he will feel like he's swerving back and > forth, accellerating and braking, when he's actually sitting in > one spot, tipping back and forth, and side to side. >>So if you're in a simulator, and you make a sharp turn to the
>left, and the simulator tips 45 degrees to the right, you will
>feel as if you are pulling a 1-gee turn.
At a 45 degree angle of rotation, we'll feel .707 G's laterally, if I'm not
mistaken. The only way to get 1g from a rotation-only setup is to pop us all
the way sideways to 90 degrees. Of course then, we don't have any acceleration
pushing us down in the seat now, so we'll feel like we're making a 1g turn with
no gravity.
I'd love to feel the accelerations in a racing sim as much as anybody else,
but this approach has some problems. If we're going straight ahead without
turning, then flick the wheel left and enter a 1g turn, the cockpit rotates 90
degrees to the right to simulate this. Aside from having just lost gravity
entirely, what happens if we want to turn back to the right for the next 1g
corner? If it takes 2 seconds to transition from 1g left to 1g right, the
cockpit will spin us from 90 degrees on our right side to 90 degrees on our
left in 2 seconds! Barf city, and way too disorienting for me to drive.
But there's got to be a way.... :-)
Todd Wasson


































