Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Re: GP3 short take

8 posts by 7 people · 22 Jul 2000 - 25 Jul 2000 00:31 UTC

On Sat, 22 Jul 2000 00:29:42 GMT, "L_NiN0" <[email hidden]> wrote: >The game also suffers from lackluster >damage effects. Some body damage and a flying tire or two but I did not >witness anything as spectacular as the end over end flaming car of GPL. You did something wrong then, I made quite some "contacts" that left nothing but the drivers safety cell. Of the other guys car of course. :-) Blaze
tweety 22 Jul 2000 00:09 UTC↳ reply to L_NiN0#253094
Hi, Off course all have their opinion but for me as far as physics is concerned they're not fighting the #2 behind GPL... F12000 beats GP3 a good deal in this area. I've written this somewhere else aswell but to me the way the car feels in GP3 is completly dead...same as in GP2. GP2 ruled 4 years ago but it's obsolete...and since GP3 is basically GP2...sigh... I agree on where you say in GP3 the cars stick to the track allmost to well.....way to well is my feeling. I've written this somewhere else aswell but to me the way the car feels in GP3 is completly dead...same as in GP2. Compared to GPL it's obvious cause those are cars where aerodynamics don't play such a big role...but GP3's 'carfeel' is also completly dead compared to F12000. I wrote this in the other post: " I think the canned spins are still there aswell as far as i can tell(saw someone else's comment he thought they were gone) Yes..you can catch the back when it starts sliding but the window is *extremly* small. Very unlike GPL and F12000 where you really can have a major back brakeout of which the in-spin behaviour is influenced by what you do with the throtlle and go 'owwww...i just catched it' In GPL and to a lesser extend in F12k it's allmost an art to catch the back..in GP3 it seems to be just a case of immediatly release the throttle completly and you'll be fine....there seems to be no counter responce of the car from doing that except the back twitching back nicely to 'center'...no nice smooth slight back sliding powering out of a corner " Before the argument gets brought up..yes..i know a F1 car is 'glued' to the ground due to the aerodynamics. However it's a mute argument to say the real F1 cars don't slide. If you watch F1 races there's definatly sliding in there...very subtle drifting...and i think if someone asked an F1 driver to go out there and do some real sliding we'de see quite a show but since it does bad things to the lap times so we don't see it much. Back to the point...in F12000 there is a lot of subtlety...if it's all 100% correct i don't know, but it does feel alive and it does feel quite realistic...you can do powerslides...nicely power out of a corner with the back slightly braking out...you can get one rear wheel 'stuck' on the edge of a curbe....etc..etc As far as i can tell by driving a few hours(with all aids including steeringhelp turned off), this is totally absent in GP3... Oh well, there's GPL...and the hope N4 and WSC will be as good or better. On Sat, 22 Jul 2000 00:29:42 GMT, "L_NiN0" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (14 lines)>-PHYSICS ( **** ) >Well, its not GPL but it does beat everything else out there. However, GPL >wins by a lap and a half while F1 2000 and GP3 fight it out for a distant >second. Followed in 4th by MGPRS2 while F1WGP is retired. (ICR2 was not >include but would have given them all a run for the money) > >Two of the biggest physics issues with GP3 that I can see are that the cars >stick to the track almost too well (but, Ive never driven a car like this so >maybe that is realistic - it just doesn't have that loose seat-of-your-pants >feel of GPL) and secondly the game appears to incorporate a canned 180 spin >if you get to far out of control. Maybe its not and maybe I just think I >should be able to partially catch myself on some of the spinouts but you are >always left facing the opposite direction. >
L_NiN0 22 Jul 2000 00:29 UTC#253175
Ok...first let me start off by saying I have never played or even seen GP2 so this review will be very unbiased in the respect. Prior to playing GP3 my favorite F1 game was Ubisoft's MGPRS2. I have played almost every other race game arcade and sim...just not GP before. I have only played the 'demo' version of GP3 for about an hour or so but here is a quick take on it. For those of you who think that this version won't represent the final...well, I would beg to differ because even if it is beta Im sure the only things being worked out are a few bugs and minor tweaks - not a complete makeover of a fully playable game. That out of the way - on to the details. -GRAPHICS ( ***1/2 out of 5 ) Dated but well done. Some items (ie barrels) are very pixilated up close and some track side objects (sand traps and grass) are very bland, however the overall look is fairly crisp and sharp. The road is very easy to distinguish from the surroundings which was something I though F1 2000 did not accomplish. The display features can be adjusted to suite almost any system and my GeForce SDR, 128MB 600E system had no problem pushing out the 26fps limit. Yes, the game appears to be tied to some frame limiter like GPL but with a much lower limit that does affect the sense of speed. -PHYSICS ( **** ) Well, its not GPL but it does beat everything else out there. However, GPL wins by a lap and a half while F1 2000 and GP3 fight it out for a distant second. Followed in 4th by MGPRS2 while F1WGP is retired. (ICR2 was not include but would have given them all a run for the money) Two of the biggest physics issues with GP3 that I can see are that the cars stick to the track almost too well (but, Ive never driven a car like this so maybe that is realistic - it just doesn't have that loose seat-of-your-pants feel of GPL) and secondly the game appears to incorporate a canned 180 spin if you get to far out of control. Maybe its not and maybe I just think I should be able to partially catch myself on some of the spinouts but you are always left facing the opposite direction. On the positive side the controls are very responsive and there are some nice affects when going of the track or getting stuck in the sand. -SOUND ( ** ) I found this to be one of the games weakest points, moreso than the outdated graphics. There are almost no sound other than your engine. You do not hear other cars as they come by you. Your engine sounds ok but downshifts and braking are very distracting. Skids and bumps are nicely placed but all in all this game does better without sound or at least the engine turned way down. -INTERFACE ( ****) The user interface is very complete but I found it hard to access the garage once the race weekend had started (I have no instructions). There are many options to select from in respect to driving aids and car setup. The driving aids are very annoying and make it even harder to drive if you ask me. I do not get a lot into the garage setup but I will confirm one rumor : no tire pressure option. You can also select between all sorts of different damage options and, yes, you can turn on engine failures. There are several driver levels (rookie to ace) which basically take away more aids and add more penalties and failures. However, you can modify them to some extent in the different levels. -SPECIAL EFFECT ( **1/2 ) GP3 has very nice weather effects on the track but I still tend to like the look of the water splash in MGPRS2. GP3 has a moderate amount of moderately produced flash but it is clear the developers did not put a lot of concern into this side of the game - other than the almost overly used brake smoke. The game does do a nice job with capturing the feel of acceleration and braking from the cockpit but never gets up to top speed leaving you feeling as if your driving in slow motion. The game also suffers from lackluster damage effects. Some body damage and a flying tire or two but I did not witness anything as spectacular as the end over end flaming car of GPL. In my view GP3 barley manages to accomplish the effects MGPRS2 did a few years back. -DIFFICULTY ( **** ) Here is were GP3 appears to distances itself from the others. Top notch physics is not all its made out to be as we saw with F1 2000, because the best physics can be hampered by bad AI. GP3 from what I have seem has some very nice AI. They appear aggressive and have a very good sense of their surroundings. You can set them to run equal or based on 98 stats. Running 98 stats I found Schumacher to act very lifelike as he would take your line away and force you to change your path in order to avoid hitting. Other drivers are much calmer and will hang back and wait for bigger openings to pass. All in all the AI seems very good however I did not provide much of a challenge for them so I will leave this topic open. -OVERALL ( ***1/2 ) GP3 is no GPL killer and those of you looking for this will have to wait for another challenger (MGPRS3?). The game is very good though and I would rank it as the best of the rest, however, as I said earlier, I have not played GP2. From some other reviews Ive read this game is nothing more than GP2.5 which may very well be true. For those of us who have not played GP2 though, this may just be the modern F1 we are looking for. Or possible a nice update for those GP2 fans...just don't expect GP3 to shake the tree too much because all of the current F1 games seem to be very weak in respect to GPL. GP3 does nudge out the current crop bit it is starting to looks like GPL is the McLaren/Farrari of sims while everyone else is striving to be Williams. Feel free to post your questions and Ill answer the best I can, however, I will not respond to anyone wanting to know where I got the 'demo'.
"rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > On Sat, 22 Jul 2000 00:29:42 GMT, "L_NiN0" <[email hidden]> wrote: > > > For those of you who think that this version > >won't represent the final...well, I would beg to differ because even ifit > >is beta Im sure the only things being worked out are a few bugs and minor > >tweaks - not a complete makeover of a fully playable game. > > ... and you know this how, 'buttwad'? Well I would believe it because I have been a beta tester for other games. I know how these things go. -- [email hidden] >
"rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > And, who the hell are you anyway? > > :) I am the one that asked you the tough question about whether you used warez F1 2000 or not. Don't think I am pissed though. :-) -- [email hidden]
Mrv 22 Jul 2000 16:51 UTC↳ reply to L_NiN0#252640
Well I am not sure who to believe. I was chatting with a fellow who knows a few of the guys from Class ( The Warez group that ripped the game) and he was telling me that this is the gold version of the game that is going on sale next week. I hope he is wrong but even so , how much of a difference will this release be from the Retail. Not much. If it is 7 weeks old you can't just change the entire engine of the game. Anyway you have to give it a chance for awhile. At first I was totally dissapointed but I am starting to enjoy it more and more. People are right, it does remind me of Gp2. It even has the same animation when you are out of the race. The guy pushes your vehicle from behind and all of the sudden your car rises and goes to heaven. Gee don't they believe in Cranes? Another thing I noticed is that if you are in a wet race and driving at 300km and slam on the brakes the car stops and doesn't spin. Not really sure if real F1 cars can do this. I doubt that very much you would think that the car would go into a violent spin. Another thing I noticed is that, going over the kerbs is quite easy. I never lose control of the car. In other F1 games if the car is not setup right the car has problems going over them and you spin out. This game is not very difficult to master and it is quite easy driving around all circuits. Still hoping for a miracle for next week but I really doubt it. rrevved wrote:
Quoted text (25 lines)> On Sat, 22 Jul 2000 10:06:39 -0500, "Greg Cisko" <[email hidden]> wrote: > > >"rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > >news:[email hidden]... > >> On Sat, 22 Jul 2000 00:29:42 GMT, "L_NiN0" <[email hidden]> wrote: > >> > >> > For those of you who think that this version > >> >won't represent the final...well, I would beg to differ because even if > >it > >> >is beta Im sure the only things being worked out are a few bugs and minor > >> >tweaks - not a complete makeover of a fully playable game. > >> > >> ... and you know this how, 'buttwad'? > > > >Well I would believe it because I have been a beta tester > >for other games. I know how these things go. > > Greg, AFAIK, he doesn't know what build of GP3 is available as the > warez version. Whether it's months, weeks, or days old versus the retail, > could make a lot of difference in what the state of the code is. > IMO, of course. > > And, who the hell are you anyway? > > :)
On Sat, 22 Jul 2000 10:14:39 -0500, rrevved <[email hidden]> wrote: >Greg, AFAIK, he doesn't know what build of GP3 is available as the >warez version. Whether it's months, weeks, or days old versus the retail, >could make a lot of difference in what the state of the code is. >IMO, of course. I read elsewhere that the credits state "V1.0" - is that true? If so it sounds rather finished... John
SKurj 25 Jul 2000 00:31 UTC↳ reply to L_NiN0#251245
I've spun after gettin too heavy on the throttle while catching the curb at Montreal... Martyn_D Mrv wrote:
Quoted text (46 lines)> Well I am not sure who to believe. I was chatting with a fellow who knows a few > of the guys from Class ( The Warez group that ripped the game) and he was > telling me that this is the gold version of the game that is going on sale next > week. I hope he is wrong but even so , how much of a difference will this > release be from the Retail. Not much. If it is 7 weeks old you can't just > change the entire engine of the game. Anyway you have to give it a chance for > awhile. At first I was totally dissapointed but I am starting to enjoy it more > and more. People are right, it does remind me of Gp2. It even has the same > animation when you are out of the race. The guy pushes your vehicle from behind > and all of the sudden your car rises and goes to heaven. Gee don't they believe > in Cranes? Another thing I noticed is that if you are in a wet race and driving > at 300km and slam on the brakes the car stops and doesn't spin. Not really sure > if real F1 cars can do this. I doubt that very much you would think that the > car would go into a violent spin. Another thing I noticed is that, going over > the kerbs is quite easy. I never lose control of the car. In other F1 games if > the car is not setup right the car has problems going over them and you spin > out. This game is not very difficult to master and it is quite easy driving > around all circuits. Still hoping for a miracle for next week but I really doubt > it. > rrevved wrote: > > > On Sat, 22 Jul 2000 10:06:39 -0500, "Greg Cisko" <[email hidden]> wrote: > > > > >"rrevved" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > >news:[email hidden]... > > >> On Sat, 22 Jul 2000 00:29:42 GMT, "L_NiN0" <[email hidden]> wrote: > > >> > > >> > For those of you who think that this version > > >> >won't represent the final...well, I would beg to differ because even if > > >it > > >> >is beta Im sure the only things being worked out are a few bugs and minor > > >> >tweaks - not a complete makeover of a fully playable game. > > >> > > >> ... and you know this how, 'buttwad'? > > > > > >Well I would believe it because I have been a beta tester > > >for other games. I know how these things go. > > > > Greg, AFAIK, he doesn't know what build of GP3 is available as the > > warez version. Whether it's months, weeks, or days old versus the retail, > > could make a lot of difference in what the state of the code is. > > IMO, of course. > > > > And, who the hell are you anyway? > > > > :)

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy