Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Shootout between the Voodoo 5 and the Geforce 2...

26 posts by 10 people · 27 Jul 2000 04:32 UTC - 01 Aug 2000 15:25 UTC

Pierre Legrand's Voodoo5 versus GeForce2 benchmark shootout

Pierre Legrand published a benchmark comparison of the Voodoo5 and GeForce2 across eight games and two processors. Magnus Svensson argued newer Nvidia drivers greatly improved GeForce2 full-screen anti-aliasing, which led Nos to insult him. Others noted that Quake 3 benchmarks say little about racing sims.

hardware: PC/graphics

Automated summary.

Pierre Legrand 27 Jul 2000 04:32 UTC#249790
My humble efforts at enlightening you heathens is at another milestone...THE FREAKING MOTHER OF ALL VIDEO CARD SHOOT OUTS IS DONE...thanks be to ALLAH I can get back to playing again...thank you lord, thank you Jesus. http://www.papadoc.net/Voodoo_vs_Geforce2.htm 8 games benchmarked...two different speed processors...geeez up the wazoo with choices. Only me you heathens....you ALL owe me a drink. Naturally I expect that both camps will be pissed off given my abilities at pissing off people...if that happens I will have been successful. <VBG> PAPA DOC Pierre PAPA DOC Legrand Flanker Target Grand Prix Legends Crash Test Dummy Aim-120 Propellent Addict Infamous Pink Flamingo Pilot...<VBG> Rants, Bullshit and Help Guides availible at www.papadoc.net
Nos 27 Jul 2000 05:19 UTC#249806
On Thu, 27 Jul 2000 04:32:59 GMT, [email hidden] (Pierre Legrand) thus spoke: >My humble efforts at enlightening you heathens is at another >milestone...THE FREAKING MOTHER OF ALL VIDEO CARD SHOOT OUTS IS >DONE...thanks be to ALLAH I can get back to playing again...thank you >lord, thank you Jesus. Oooh...on my way now. I already know the outcome though. -- Nos
Magnus Svensson 27 Jul 2000 06:29 UTC#249817
On Thu, 27 Jul 2000 04:32:59 GMT, [email hidden] (Pierre Legrand) wrote: [snip] You really, REALLY should consider using 5.32 drivers to test the FSAA on the GF2, instead of 5.22. The D3D FSAA performance is *considerably* better in 5.30 and above. /Magnus
N.. 27 Jul 2000#527107
thus spoke: Oooh...on my way now. I already know the outcome though. -- Nos
N.. 27 Jul 2000#527108
On Thu, 27 Jul 2000 16:13:56 +0200, Magnus Svensson You missed his point completely. Ignore this *** PD. He's one of those zealots from the video card news group. One of Petey's pals. -- Nos
Pierre Legrand 27 Jul 2000 13:11 UTC#249696
Yea I was gonna wait till the 6.42's....then a little birdy told me that the 7.33's were really gonna rock...course the review has to end sooner or later eh. It was a comparison between two cards...the 3dfx ran with what came in the box...I see no reason not to expect the Nvidia to do the same. But like I said in the article the Nvidia plainly would not run with what came in the box so I gave it some slack and used the Non Beta 5.22's. Btw I did benchmark the 5.30 drivers...its in the article... PAPA DOC >You really, REALLY should consider using 5.32 drivers to test the FSAA >on the GF2, instead of 5.22. The D3D FSAA performance is >*considerably* better in 5.30 and above. > > >/Magnus Pierre PAPA DOC Legrand Flanker Target Grand Prix Legends Crash Test Dummy Aim-120 Propellent Addict Infamous Pink Flamingo Pilot...<VBG> Rants, Bullshit and Help Guides availible at www.papadoc.net
Magnus Svensson 27 Jul 2000 14:13 UTC#249641
On Thu, 27 Jul 2000 13:11:00 GMT, [email hidden] (Pierre Legrand) wrote: >Yea I was gonna wait till the 6.42's....then a little birdy told me >that the 7.33's were really gonna rock...course the review has to end >sooner or later eh. Hardiharhar. :) But seriously, the 5.32s has been out for a 4 weeks. >It was a comparison between two cards...the 3dfx ran with what came in >the box...I see no reason not to expect the Nvidia to do the same. But >like I said in the article the Nvidia plainly would not run with what >came in the box so I gave it some slack and used the Non Beta 5.22's. > >Btw I did benchmark the 5.30 drivers...its in the article... Ok, didn't look too closely it appears, but if you're putting that much emphasis on FSAA, it's pretty unnecessary sticking with 5.22, just because it's "non-beta". The D3D FSAA in 5.22 is "alpha" at best, IMHO. http://firingsquad.gamers.com/hardware/detonator530/default.asp /Magnus
Simon Brown 27 Jul 2000 15:20 UTC#249643
I've heard great thing about the 12.4's. And I shouldn't mention this but the 23.2's will really kick ass! ;) (it's a joke dammit!)
Nos 27 Jul 2000 18:10 UTC#249562
On Thu, 27 Jul 2000 16:13:56 +0200, Magnus Svensson <[email hidden]> thus spoke: >Hardiharhar. :) > >But seriously, the 5.32s has been out for a 4 weeks. You missed his point completely. Ignore this twat PD. He's one of those zealots from the video card news group. One of Petey's pals. -- Nos
Pierre Legrand 27 Jul 2000 23:38 UTC#249486
Nvidia released this card early to answer the shot across the bow of 3dfx with the release of Voodoo 5. Nvidia I truly believe had no intention of releasing the Geforce 2 early but they were forced to by the overwhelming response to FSAA by most of the press. This forced them to release early to stem the possible loss of mindshare that a Non contested Voodoo 5 would have caused. So they released early and just let the consumer suffer thru multiple drivers while they sorted out their FSAA which no matter what tricks they pull wont be as good looking as the FSAA in the Voodoo 5...simply will not happen. From my standpoint releasing a card then expecting the consumer to sort thru your drivers trying to find ones that work is not good. Especially when you consider what a chore it is for most people to change drivers...especially when you see some of the extreme measures that some drivers (both 3dfx and Nvidia are guilty here) require the user to go thru to make sure the new drivers are installed correctly. PAPA DOC >The D3D FSAA in 5.22 is "alpha" at best, IMHO. > >http://firingsquad.gamers.com/hardware/detonator530/default.asp > > >/Magnus Pierre PAPA DOC Legrand Flanker Target GPL Crash Dummy Video Card Wizard www.papadoc.net FALCON 4 Benchmarks Rants, Bullshit and Reviews
[email hidden] wrote:
Quoted text (14 lines)> > On Fri, 28 Jul 2000 05:05:04 +0200, Magnus Svensson > <[email hidden]> thus spoke: > > >Phueewh, Nos. Bust open the valium can or something. > > I'm all out. Gotta see the doc. > > >I was talking about *D3D FSAA*, and if you look well enough, lo and > >behold, there *are* D3D FSAA scores there. Compared to the 5.22 there > >are in some cases 200-250% improvement. > > I had the Geforce2 and returned it for the V5. I made the right > choice. 'Nuff said.
Oh come on, admit that you just didn't want to be the sheep of the flightsim group any longer! Giving in to peer pressure... ;^) -- l8er ronny Your mouse has moved. Windows must be restarted for the change to take effect. Reboot now? |\ _,,,---,,_ I want to die like my Grandfather, ZZZzz /,`.-'`' -. ;-;;,_ in his sleep. |,4- ) )-,_. ,\ ( `'-' Not like the people in his car, '---''(_/--' `-'\_) screaming their heads off!
Mark Gums 28 Jul 2000 00:10 UTC#249487
First, THANK YOU. I have been looking for an article not beating me over the head with techincal jargon. I really am not that concerned with 'extreme' fps, as I don't play frag-a-thons, or, am impressed with techinal jargon, Can spout it with the best of 'em. Pierre PAPA DOC Legrand <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (9 lines)> Nvidia released this card early to answer the shot across the bow of > 3dfx with the release of Voodoo 5. Nvidia I truly believe had no > intention of releasing the Geforce 2 early but they were forced to by > the overwhelming response to FSAA by most of the press. This forced > them to release early to stem the possible loss of mindshare that a > Non contested Voodoo 5 would have caused. So they released early and > just let the consumer suffer thru multiple drivers while they sorted > out their FSAA which no matter what tricks they pull wont be as good > looking as the FSAA in the Voodoo 5...simply will not happen.
On this, I completely agree. I am really tired of being the beta tester for hardware and software just because the company is so desperate to get it to market. I don't have the time or patience to mess with crap like that anymore. Spent too many months continuously updating my rendition based card to keep it funtional. I really want one that goes good right out of the box, on multiple pieces of software. > From my standpoint releasing a card then expecting the consumer to > sort thru your drivers trying to find ones that work is not good. > Especially when you consider what a chore it is for most people to > change drivers...especially when you see some of the extreme measures > that some drivers (both 3dfx and Nvidia are guilty here) require the > user to go thru to make sure the new drivers are installed correctly. You're completely correct here. Although, it was only some flavors of the Voodoo2 drivers that had problems letting go. I put a Diamond V2 in mine when the price dropped to get some more compatibiltiy(glide), and wound up wiping the system to make the V3 work right. Oh well. It has worked right ever since with the drivers right off the CD. Now, your review has the one thing that almost none of the reviews paid attention to, much less actually went into detail about, actually installing both onto a system. Some just gave a brief snippet, or a rating, but none actually went step by step to see how painless/painful the hookup was. And you gave multiple tests on multiple game types. Those were the two things I wanted to hear. NOT winmark/stone/bench/whatever numbers. Those are totally meaningless to me. Again, I appreciate the info from the real world. Later. -Mark Gums
Pierre Legrand 28 Jul 2000 01:28 UTC#249411
Thank you very much for the kind words..I did this exactly for people like you and me... who just want results not the promise. Pierre PAPA DOC Legrand
Quoted text (7 lines)>Those were the two things I wanted to hear. NOT >winmark/stone/bench/whatever numbers. Those are >totally meaningless to me. Again, I appreciate the info >from the real world. >Later. -Mark Gums > >
Pierre PAPA DOC Legrand Flanker Target GPL Crash Dummy Video Card Wizard www.papadoc.net FALCON 4 Benchmarks Rants, Bullshit and Reviews
Magnus Svensson 28 Jul 2000 02:24 UTC#249431
On Thu, 27 Jul 2000 18:10:21 GMT, [email hidden] wrote: >>Hardiharhar. :) >> >>But seriously, the 5.32s has been out for a 4 weeks. > >You missed his point completely. Ignore this twat PD. He's one of >those zealots from the video card news group. One of Petey's pals. Whatever, Nos. I just pointed out that the GF2 had much better FSAA performance with newer drivers and thus I'm a twat. Now who's the zealot. /Magnus
Nos 28 Jul 2000 02:27 UTC#249429
On Thu, 27 Jul 2000 23:38:16 GMT, [email hidden] (Pierre PAPA DOC Legrand) thus spoke: >>http://firingsquad.gamers.com/hardware/detonator530/default.asp Notice they use Quake3 once again as a benchmark. Q3 takes advantage of the GPU on the GTS. Just how is that relevant to people who play GPL, Nascar3 etc.? These review sites like the above need to take their heads out of their asses. -- Nos
Magnus Svensson 28 Jul 2000 02:57 UTC#249437
On Thu, 27 Jul 2000 23:38:16 GMT, [email hidden] (Pierre PAPA DOC Legrand) wrote: >Nvidia released this card early to answer the shot across the bow of >3dfx with the release of Voodoo 5. Nvidia I truly believe had no >intention of releasing the Geforce 2 early but they were forced to by >the overwhelming response to FSAA by most of the press. Nah, I don't think so. The GF2 is extremely similar to a GF1. You do know that the GF1 does FSAA exactly the same way? The FSAA in the GeForce1/2 is hardly new. It's a pretty simple approach and even the TNT had it way back(albeit horrendously slow, so it got removed). The problem has always been compatibility, and I don't think we will ever see full D3D compatibility because of the way 2D graphics is handled. The D3D compatibility seems to only get better on a handcrafted per-title basis. That they reopened the FSAA-file just now is of course because they can take a little wind out of 3dfx's sails, no argument about that. >From my standpoint releasing a card then expecting the consumer to >sort thru your drivers trying to find ones that work is not good. As true as that is, well, for better or worse I'm afraid that is something one have to live with when using a GeForce card. But at least they update their drivers, unlike other companies(listening S3, ATI?) :) >Especially when you consider what a chore it is for most people to >change drivers...especially when you see some of the extreme measures >that some drivers (both 3dfx and Nvidia are guilty here) require the >user to go thru to make sure the new drivers are installed correctly. Yup, that can certainly be made smoother, agreed. /Magnus P.S. Sheesh, all I did was pointing out that the newer drivers had better performance and compatibility, and already I'm a technofiliac elitist, a twat and a zealot. ;) Phew. D.S.
Magnus Svensson 28 Jul 2000 03:04 UTC#249239
On Fri, 28 Jul 2000 02:27:05 GMT, [email hidden] wrote: >>>http://firingsquad.gamers.com/hardware/detonator530/default.asp > >Notice they use Quake3 once again as a benchmark. Q3 takes advantage >of the GPU on the GTS. Just how is that relevant to people who play >GPL, Nascar3 etc.? These review sites like the above need to take >their heads out of their asses. Phueewh, Nos. Bust open the valium can or something. I was talking about *D3D FSAA*, and if you look well enough, lo and behold, there *are* D3D FSAA scores there. Compared to the 5.22 there are in some cases 200-250% improvement. /Magnus
Nos 28 Jul 2000 04:43 UTC#249276
On Fri, 28 Jul 2000 05:05:04 +0200, Magnus Svensson <[email hidden]> thus spoke: >Phueewh, Nos. Bust open the valium can or something. I'm all out. Gotta see the doc. >I was talking about *D3D FSAA*, and if you look well enough, lo and >behold, there *are* D3D FSAA scores there. Compared to the 5.22 there >are in some cases 200-250% improvement. I had the Geforce2 and returned it for the V5. I made the right choice. 'Nuff said. -- Nos
Nos 28 Jul 2000 04:54 UTC#249280
On Fri, 28 Jul 2000 05:05:04 +0200, Magnus Svensson <[email hidden]> thus spoke: >Phueewh, How do you pronounce that? Is it fueeeee of few? -- Nos
N.. 28 Jul 2000#527171
On Fri, 28 Jul 2000 05:05:04 +0200, Magnus Svensson I'm all out. Gotta see the doc. I had the Geforce2 and returned it for the V5. I made the right choice. 'Nuff said. -- Nos
N.. 28 Jul 2000#527172
On Fri, 28 Jul 2000 05:05:04 +0200, Magnus Svensson How do you pronounce that? Is it fueeeee of few? -- Nos
sennafan 28 Jul 2000 14:53 UTC#249082
You know, I might care about Voodoo5 vs. GeForce if all I did was gaming, but since I also run professional graphics programs on my machine and the Voodoo series is basically USELESS for those, the choice is academic. Let's see, since there's only one video chip manufacturer that supports high-end gaming, *and* high-end professional graphics (that is, a well-written, FULL OpenGL ICD), 3dfx will not be seeing any of my money any time soon. ----------------------------------------------------------- Got questions? Get answers over the phone at Keen.com. Up to 100 minutes free! http://www.keen.com
Pierre Legrand 28 Jul 2000 15:20 UTC#249123
hehe...Nos goes for the throat...<VBG> > >Nah, I don't think so. The GF2 is extremely similar to a GF1. You do >know that the GF1 does FSAA exactly the same way? Absolutely but notice they didnt want to advertise the fact that it did for several reasons. One main one...GF1 didnt have the fill rate to do it. Second main reason the drivers sucked (they pretty much still do)....and the results werent that great.
Quoted text (7 lines)> >The FSAA in the GeForce1/2 is hardly new. It's a pretty simple >approach and even the TNT had it way back(albeit horrendously slow, so >it got removed). The problem has always been compatibility, and I >don't think we will ever see full D3D compatibility because of the way >2D graphics is handled. The D3D compatibility seems to only get better >on a handcrafted per-title basis.
Thats strange the compatibility on the 3dfx is pretty much outstanding. But I agree that using FSAA on the Geforce 2 was not a fun experience.... > >That they reopened the FSAA-file just now is of course because they >can take a little wind out of 3dfx's sails, no argument about that. Thats an understatment..all their statements and efforts have been to diminish the effect of stunning effects of 3dfx FSAA. One very clever way is to use their card as an example of FSAA and say see it doesnt look that good...clever indeed. Another good way is to have uneducated sites like Anandtech make silly comparisons of screenshots showing edges as if thats the Big Ass deal about FSAA. It IS the big ass deal about Nvidia's FSAA but its NOT the big ASS deal about 3dfx's FSAA which does a much better job of eliminating the Creepy Crawly Textures, swimming textures and popping pixels...eliminating THAT is the big ass deal about FSAA. Scenes the 3dfx do not move around as much as they do with the Geforce and thats the big deal. Anand is making a fool of himself by comparing edges alone.
Quoted text (8 lines)> >>From my standpoint releasing a card then expecting the consumer to >>sort thru your drivers trying to find ones that work is not good. > >As true as that is, well, for better or worse I'm afraid that is >something one have to live with when using a GeForce card. But at >least they update their drivers, unlike other companies(listening S3, >ATI?) :)
The sole reason that this release isnt as good a release as the Geforce 1 is they panicked by the reactions to 3dfx's FSAA by the press. Losing mindshare is not an option. Its the main thing that cost 3dfx so much and the main reason why putting useless features in a card might be a good idea in the future...dont even have to work just have to say that the card does it.
Quoted text (7 lines)> >>Especially when you consider what a chore it is for most people to >>change drivers...especially when you see some of the extreme measures >>that some drivers (both 3dfx and Nvidia are guilty here) require the >>user to go thru to make sure the new drivers are installed correctly. > >Yup, that can certainly be made smoother, agreed.
Thats the big puzzle to me. I mean has anyone at either of these companies read "Inmates are running the asylum"...? Do they honest believe its a good idea to release cards that will require driver updates then require that shenanigans like editing the registry be done by the normal user. LIke the teacher said if you are gonna do drugs then bring enough for everyone. PAPA DOC
Quoted text (7 lines)> > >/Magnus >P.S. Sheesh, all I did was pointing out that the newer drivers had >better performance and compatibility, and already I'm a technofiliac >elitist, a twat and a zealot. ;) Phew. D.S. >
Pierre PAPA DOC Legrand Flanker Target Grand Prix Legends Crash Test Dummy Aim-120 Propellent Addict Infamous Pink Flamingo Pilot...<VBG> Rants, Bullshit and Help Guides availible at www.papadoc.net
Nos 29 Jul 2000 09:03 UTC#248571
On Fri, 28 Jul 2000 18:58:19 +0200, Ronald Stoehr <[email hidden]> thus spoke: >Oh come on, admit that you just didn't want to be the sheep of >the flightsim group any longer! > >Giving in to peer pressure... ;^) I've been a 3DFX fanboy since day one. I believe I was the *first* person in the flight-sim group with a 3DFX card. I used to troll this group with my 3dFX rantings quite often because they were all using those crap Rendition cards (just ask PD or Greg Cisko for proof). I just had a momentary lapse of insanity, but I'm ok now. -- Nos
Greg Cisko 29 Jul 2000 13:57 UTC#248473
<[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (14 lines)> On Fri, 28 Jul 2000 18:58:19 +0200, Ronald Stoehr > <[email hidden]> thus spoke: > > > >Oh come on, admit that you just didn't want to be the sheep of > >the flightsim group any longer! > > > >Giving in to peer pressure... ;^) > > I've been a 3DFX fanboy since day one. I believe I was the *first* > person in the flight-sim group with a 3DFX card. I used to troll this > group with my 3dFX rantings quite often because they were all using > those crap Rendition cards (just ask PD or Greg Cisko for proof). I > just had a momentary lapse of insanity, but I'm ok now.
That is right. As I recall you made a bigger stink than I have, simply by calling the entire RAS NG a bunch of pussies. I would never stoop so low as to do such a thing :-) -- [email hidden] > -- > Nos
Goy Larsen 01 Aug 2000 15:25 UTC#246819
Greg Cisko wrote:
Quoted text (22 lines)> > <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > On Fri, 28 Jul 2000 18:58:19 +0200, Ronald Stoehr > > <[email hidden]> thus spoke: > > > > > > >Oh come on, admit that you just didn't want to be the sheep of > > >the flightsim group any longer! > > > > > >Giving in to peer pressure... ;^) > > > > I've been a 3DFX fanboy since day one. I believe I was the *first* > > person in the flight-sim group with a 3DFX card. I used to troll this > > group with my 3dFX rantings quite often because they were all using > > those crap Rendition cards (just ask PD or Greg Cisko for proof). I > > just had a momentary lapse of insanity, but I'm ok now. > > That is right. As I recall you made a bigger stink than I have, > simply by calling the entire RAS NG a bunch of pussies. > > I would never stoop so low as to do such a thing :-)
I'll take a bet on this one, anyone ? :-) Beers and cheers (uncle) Goy "Team Mirage" http://www.teammirage.com/ "The Pits" http://www.theuspits.com/ * Spam is for losers who can't get business any other way * "Spamkiller" http://www.spamkiller.com

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy