Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Re: GP3 after 4 hours

3 posts by 3 people · 28 Jul 2000 - 28 Jul 2000 13:19 UTC

Douglas, thanks for your honest appraisal. Now on with the debate. :) On Fri, 28 Jul 2000 12:09:44 +0100, "Douglas Ellison" <[email hidden]> wrote: >OK - it's here, I've driven it for a while...and, well, umm...it's alright. <highly selective editing> >So - I'm happy - it's what I wanted, and what I expected. Mediocrity makes many a best-seller. And if that's all you want and all you expect, that's exactly what you'll get. :( >So - I'm happy - it's what I wanted, and what I expected. I do think, >however - that Hasbro & Microprose must realise that the code now needs to >be canned, and to start GP4 with a clean sheet. Retaining the old code >would be a mistake now. Software mode needs to be droped, sound imroved, >packaging dept fired. The trouble is, this *is* the starting point for future versions. If it took x years (x being a hotly-debated number between 0.5 and 4) to do "GP2.5", HTF do you expect Geoff to come up with a totally new GP4 by next year? The thing that everyone needs to understand (and it becomes more apparent with time) is that Geoff has *reached his vision*. He thinks a GP simulator should be done a particular way and *he's there now* (he was with GP2, except the PCs of the time weren't fast enough for the graphics and weather, and GP3 has fixed that). Anyone expecting something radically new from Geoff is going to have a long, loooong wait. As time goes by and PCs become more capable, we see developers like Geoff plateauing as they reach their vision, while others like Kaemmer (I500, ICR, NASCAR, ICR2-3D, GPL, N4) just keep pushing the limits of computer-simulated reality (be it physics or graphics or multiplayer). GP3 will be a very good game, but it doesn't do much to advance the start of the art of simulations. It has great playability and will be very accessible to the masses (as per Geoff's vision). But for those of us who are striving for something better, we have to look to other developers for that vision, as it isn't part of Geoff's. >Oh, and I've just un-installed GPL. I hadn't played it for a few weeks, and >felt no need to subject myself to the continued ritual of spin, spin, spin, >spin. Get's boring after 10 mins. GP2 still interests me 4 years later, and >the same will happen with GP3. I understand that some people don't have the time for some sims. But, Douglas, what worthwhile achievement in your life have you ever achieved by devoting the odd 10 minutes a day to it? Some of us (yup, us fanatics :), think that achievement has its own rewards. "But in a way, fear is a big part of racing, because if there was nothing to be frightened of, and no limit, any fool could get into a motor car and racing would not exist as a sport." -- Jim Clark
OK - it's here, I've driven it for a while...and, well, umm...it's alright. It's certainly not ground-breaking. It's GP2 with an overhaul. Graphics still have a GP2 feel about them, but brush up quite well at 800x600 or above. . (note to G.Cram DROP THE OLD CODE - it's holding back the quality of graphics...start afresh with Direct 3D Accel only..software mode isn't necessary anymore) Physics is basicaly the same as GP2 - perhaps a little more catchable in a slide - which I like! Not too difficult - none too easy neither - just nice. Don't like the moving steering wheel - doesn't feel right somehow - perhaps have it's movement turn on & offable!?! The Data-logging side is improved a little - with trace print outs being an AWESOME addition - they look great - just like the pros use!! Menu system improved a great deal, and the bgnd music is really very nice. Wet weather is outstanding - no-one has ever done it that well. Sound is pretty much the same as GP2 - perhaps the samples are a little bit better - but fundamentally the same - disapointing...(note to G.Cram. MUST DO BETTER HERE!) AI - havn't toyed around enough yet - had a nasty crash and they managed to get out my way, and ran 3 abrest down into Eau Rouge, and ran out of track without getting barged off. The MANUAL IS CRAP...the same as the GP2 manual, which was the same as the GP1 manual. Full of errors, most of the track maps have missing or wrongly placed pit lanes, and the Box quotes rec. spec '..AMD Anthlon' what's an Anthlon....athlon perhaps? No wonder Hasbro are advertising for a manual writer on their website. So - I'm happy - it's what I wanted, and what I expected. I do think, however - that Hasbro & Microprose must realise that the code now needs to be canned, and to start GP4 with a clean sheet. Retaining the old code would be a mistake now. Software mode needs to be droped, sound imroved, packaging dept fired. I'm looking forward to seeing people edit this till it bleeds though - because the scope is there (in the same way GP2 code has been retained) for the old editing programs to be re-jigged to work for GP3 (track editor out TOMORROW!!!) so, damnit, get me gp3jam!!! Oh, and I've just un-installed GPL. I hadn't played it for a few weeks, and felt no need to subject myself to the continued ritual of spin, spin, spin, spin. Get's boring after 10 mins. GP2 still interests me 4 years later, and the same will happen with GP3. So there you go... Not the best game ever, certainly not a driving simulator, but a damn good F1 game that I'll be enjoying for a while. Doug
Daniel Lichtenberger 28 Jul 2000 13:19 UTC#249158
On Fri, 28 Jul 2000 12:09:44 +0100, "Douglas Ellison" <[email hidden]> wrote: >[...] >So there you go... Not the best game ever, certainly not a driving >simulator, but a damn good F1 game that I'll be enjoying for a while. After some hours of driving (mainly at Hockenheim), I agree with most of your points. Graphics are ok, the unfiltered textures and some cars look really bad, but on the other hand the virtual cockpit and the rain effects are great. Sound is disappointing (mainly because you can't hear other cars), and controls seriously need a fast patch (known problem with 3 axis-wheels, and FF doesn't work right on my R4 FF). Imo, physics are very good, the car feels more 'real' than in GP2, perhaps only because you can see your tires. Cars also feel more loose, especially when accelerating you have to react very quickly when your rear loses traction. Curbs feel a bit odd, as in GP2. I *love* the weather effects, I never noticed how much I missed them in GPL (or GP2) until today. Driving in the wet is pretty challenging, as you have wheelspin up to the 4th gear (at least). In summary, the car doesn't always feel the way I'd like it to do, but as far as I can judge from various in-car video coverage of current F1 races, physics seem to be very accurate, especially when driving on the limit. I think I'll spend a lot of hours with GP3 :) Daniel -- ICQ UIN: 30333508 http://www.topofgames.de || http://danielshome.cjb.net

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy