Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Racing sims and expectations.

6 posts by 3 people · 28 Jul 2000 12:23 UTC - 30 Jul 2000

GPL freak 28 Jul 2000 12:23 UTC#248998
Too many racing sim developers hide their heads in the sand and don't want to or are too afraid to see what the opposition does to develope something better because it really takes an effort to come up with something revolutionary! I won't name any other titles than the one below (because I want to stay positive :) but I think we all know the short comings of sim releases that have come out after-98. I think the only game that has really satisfied me in the final release is GPL and that was 2 years ago! It wasn't/isn't perfect but it was more than I expected in the year of -98! Hell, I even played the demo more than any other game I had installed on my system! With the patches introducing FF and better online play I'm safe to say it's the best racing sim around and a lot of its long time appeal is not alone due to its excellent driving model but also because of its online capabilities. No other racing game since the release of GPL has in my eyes been a sim because it really raised the benchmark of what a racing a sim is about. It not only made us expect quality but also demand it. To make it short: - So I'm not really too surprised about the comments about the F1 sims released this year.. <g> GPLfreak
Tracey A Miller 28 Jul 2000 18:29 UTC#248846
"GPL freak" wrote > Too many racing sim developers hide their heads in the sand and don't want > to or are too afraid to see what the opposition does to develope something > better because it really takes an effort to come up with something > revolutionary! The goal of a developer is to make money, not do "something revolutionary". GPL was revolutionary, and it lost money for Sierra. Do you really think other developers are going to look at what Sierra/Papyrus did with GPL as a model for producing software? Sierra could publish a book on the subject of "How to publish a great simulation and lose a ton of money in the process". They could also tell the world "How to publish the same game five times in five years and make money every year just by improving the graphics" based on their NASCAR series' success. Don't blame the other developers for not trying to emulate GPL's "success". Blame Sierra for causing other publishers to steer clear of anything remotely resembling "the most realistic driving experience on a PC".
GPL freak 29 Jul 2000 02:59 UTC#248589
Do you really think that GP3 would have sold any less (than it prpbably will) if it would have been more of a new game than a facelift to GP2? With it's many driving aids it still would have been easy for beginners and challenging for hardcore simmers. I just feel it's sad that for example Crammond totally ignores what the opposition does! I do understand that the business is a bout making $$$ and lots of it but too many times we see mediocre crap coming out sometimes because of ignoring what's happening in the outside world and sometimes because being hurried out to make a certain release date! Sounds like legally ripping of people of their money! With more quality games with good manuals etc. (and a demo before release damn it :) I'm sure that more people would be willing to pay for the full product! IT seems to be more of a standard nowdays to expect that the FINAL game is something that we will have to patch many times before it even works and still not be happy with it. Thank god for developers having the courage to try and do something new! How are we supposed to get any better sims if the developers don't try to raise the bar? And it's easier to do a better product if you don't just improve your own results but raise their quality above others too. GP3 brought us great weather, lets hope the next sim we get also has that and more in it. :) GPLfreak Tracey Miller <[email hidden]> kirjoitti viestiss�:pikg5.293$[email hidden]... > "GPL freak" wrote > > Too many racing sim developers hide their heads in the sand and don'twant > > to or are too afraid to see what the opposition does to developesomething > > better because it really takes an effort to come up with something > > revolutionary! > > The goal of a developer is to make money, not do "somethingrevolutionary". > GPL was revolutionary, and it lost money for Sierra. Do you really think > other developers are going to look at what Sierra/Papyrus did with GPL asa > model for producing software? > > Sierra could publish a book on the subject of "How to publish a great > simulation and lose a ton of money in the process". They could also tellthe > world "How to publish the same game five times in five years and makemoney > every year just by improving the graphics" based on their NASCAR series' > success. > > Don't blame the other developers for not trying to emulate GPL's"success". > Blame Sierra for causing other publishers to steer clear of anything > remotely resembling "the most realistic driving experience on a PC". > > >
GPL freak 29 Jul 2000 06:44 UTC#248542
Yes, and sometimes it's seems that the beta versions aren't even beta tested before release... <g> GPLfreak wert <[email hidden]> kirjoitti viestiss�:[email hidden]... > any game that has to be patched, should have never been released, > thats why they make beta versions.
GPL freak 29 Jul 2000 06:44 UTC#248541
> Facelift? Like N1, N2 and N3 ? >Yep, those are in the same category but I think N3 was even more of a face lift than GP3 to GP2 ! Dunno about Nascar1 though as it was the 1st of the papy Nascar series. :) NLegends included too in the facelifts.. more like a car addon. I really hope N4 will be more as it will have an improved(!) gpl physics engine. Lets hope it's true. F1 2000 wasn't a facelift but it sure needs one! ;o) ...and a lot of optimization of the code. It has potential but it was hurried out by EA as a very buggy test version <g>. Ubisoft products.. err.. Actually I like GP3 as a game when playing offline and it has some very good (as well as some annoying) features but it doesn't have what it takes to really want me to spend a lot of time with it in the long run. I do however have fun with it atm but I doubth it will last long. I think if it had working internet multiplay I would forgive some of it's short comings more. The dual axis bug makes me wonder if they actually beta tested the thing with anyone actually having a dual axis setup? 4 years of development and they don't get dual axis to work??? It's just that I did expect a bit more of the 2 latest F1 sim attempts in the year of 2000. If GP3 would have been released on it's original announced release date sometime in -98 ( ? :) when the expectations weren't as high as today I think it would have got less bad feedback. GP2 and ICR2 were both good sims when they were 1st released but if something like that came out now I don't think it would satisfy todays simmers because their expectations are higher. GPLfreak
EldredP 30 Jul 2000#247708
In article <[email hidden]>, wert <[email hidden]> writes: >any game that has to be patched, should have never been released, >thats why they make beta versions. But is it realistically possible to catch *every* bug? I don't think so. There are too many different combinations(hardware/OS) for that to happen. Eldred -- Tiger Stadium R.I.P. 1912-1999 Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett GPL hcp. +60.31 Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy