Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Re: Why GP3's steering feels YUCKY

7 posts by 6 people · 27 Aug 2000 - 28 Aug 2000 04:28 UTC

Hell I'm confused now. I had the steering help set to 0% and the steering felt like it was on a spring, forever trying to get me back to dead centre. So I changed it to 100% after seeing one of the above posts and it seems much better. Which way around does this thing work? Hang on, maybe its in the manual, or maybe its all a crock of sh*t? Steve :-( Marki000 wrote in message <[email hidden]>... >Set the steerhelp to 0% and for me this works fine.
Loosay2 27 Aug 2000#236659
Quoted text (32 lines)>Ok, day 3 with GP3 now. And I just noticed something. I've been fiddling >with the controller config a lot trying to get that same silky smooth feel >to the controls that I had with GP2, or even with GPL, and I haven't been >able to do it. I think I just figured out why. > >There's a small "latency" in the controls. It feels like the steering >collumn is made of rubber. I'm pretty certain this is actually >intentionally hard-coded into the sim. It's easiest to see in the >controller calibration screen. Wiggle the wheel from side to side, and >notice how the little silver ball on the screen lags behind. This isn't a >problem with my system. Let me explain. > >For one thing, I don't have this problem with any other game. And I also >noticed that when you make a sudden movement on the wheel, the little silver >ball *gradually* moves to the new position. Press the throttle down and >realease it with a 'snap' and you'll see what I mean. It looks to me like >this is something they programmed into the game in order to smooth things >out for people with spikey controllers, dirty pots or whatever. Well, my >pots aren't dirty, and I don't like it. > >This sim seems really cool so far, but this controller "feature" really >pretty much ruins the game. I think the physics model is actually very >good, certainly improved over GP2, but you cant get the most out of it with >this shitty latency. It gives the whole sim a weird disconnected feeling, >and I think it makes it difficult to time your entry into fast corners. >Maybe it's something you can "get used to" to some extent, but no amount of >practice will make up for your lost reaction time. > >What a bummer. I hope someone figures out how to hack this thing and kill >it. What really troubles me is that this dopey little feature will probably >appear in GP4, GP5, etc. as well. What a waste of a perfectly good sim. >
Have you tried adjusting the "steering Help" feature under advanced control options? I have not really noticed the effect you are talking about, but I have the steering help adjustment set to the default 100%, and it feels fine to me.
Aubrey 27 Aug 2000 07:12 UTC#236653
Ok, day 3 with GP3 now. And I just noticed something. I've been fiddling with the controller config a lot trying to get that same silky smooth feel to the controls that I had with GP2, or even with GPL, and I haven't been able to do it. I think I just figured out why. There's a small "latency" in the controls. It feels like the steering collumn is made of rubber. I'm pretty certain this is actually intentionally hard-coded into the sim. It's easiest to see in the controller calibration screen. Wiggle the wheel from side to side, and notice how the little silver ball on the screen lags behind. This isn't a problem with my system. Let me explain. For one thing, I don't have this problem with any other game. And I also noticed that when you make a sudden movement on the wheel, the little silver ball *gradually* moves to the new position. Press the throttle down and realease it with a 'snap' and you'll see what I mean. It looks to me like this is something they programmed into the game in order to smooth things out for people with spikey controllers, dirty pots or whatever. Well, my pots aren't dirty, and I don't like it. This sim seems really cool so far, but this controller "feature" really pretty much ruins the game. I think the physics model is actually very good, certainly improved over GP2, but you cant get the most out of it with this shitty latency. It gives the whole sim a weird disconnected feeling, and I think it makes it difficult to time your entry into fast corners. Maybe it's something you can "get used to" to some extent, but no amount of practice will make up for your lost reaction time. What a bummer. I hope someone figures out how to hack this thing and kill it. What really troubles me is that this dopey little feature will probably appear in GP4, GP5, etc. as well. What a waste of a perfectly good sim. -A
Marki000 27 Aug 2000 15:40 UTC#236776
Set the steerhelp to 0% and for me this works fine. Aubrey wrote:
Quoted text (33 lines)> Ok, day 3 with GP3 now. And I just noticed something. I've been fiddling > with the controller config a lot trying to get that same silky smooth feel > to the controls that I had with GP2, or even with GPL, and I haven't been > able to do it. I think I just figured out why. > > There's a small "latency" in the controls. It feels like the steering > collumn is made of rubber. I'm pretty certain this is actually > intentionally hard-coded into the sim. It's easiest to see in the > controller calibration screen. Wiggle the wheel from side to side, and > notice how the little silver ball on the screen lags behind. This isn't a > problem with my system. Let me explain. > > For one thing, I don't have this problem with any other game. And I also > noticed that when you make a sudden movement on the wheel, the little silver > ball *gradually* moves to the new position. Press the throttle down and > realease it with a 'snap' and you'll see what I mean. It looks to me like > this is something they programmed into the game in order to smooth things > out for people with spikey controllers, dirty pots or whatever. Well, my > pots aren't dirty, and I don't like it. > > This sim seems really cool so far, but this controller "feature" really > pretty much ruins the game. I think the physics model is actually very > good, certainly improved over GP2, but you cant get the most out of it with > this shitty latency. It gives the whole sim a weird disconnected feeling, > and I think it makes it difficult to time your entry into fast corners. > Maybe it's something you can "get used to" to some extent, but no amount of > practice will make up for your lost reaction time. > > What a bummer. I hope someone figures out how to hack this thing and kill > it. What really troubles me is that this dopey little feature will probably > appear in GP4, GP5, etc. as well. What a waste of a perfectly good sim. > > -A
Thomas JS Brown 27 Aug 2000 18:06 UTC#236585
Yes...latency is a bad thing, but by the same token so are nasty spikes that come with too little latency. I think this may be the reason FF almost didn't make it into GP3. TJSB James Pickard wrote:
Quoted text (61 lines)> > It's not a steering help problem.... > > It's a latency issue. Whether it is hardware or the software / drivers,it's > hard to say. > > This is an area of sim racing that is 'untapped'. Latency is a bad thing, > the less there is, the faster you will go... > > James > > Loosay2 <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > >Ok, day 3 with GP3 now. And I just noticed something. I've been > fiddling > > >with the controller config a lot trying to get that same silky smooth > feel > > >to the controls that I had with GP2, or even with GPL, and I haven't been > > >able to do it. I think I just figured out why. > > > > > >There's a small "latency" in the controls. It feels like the steering > > >collumn is made of rubber. I'm pretty certain this is actually > > >intentionally hard-coded into the sim. It's easiest to see in the > > >controller calibration screen. Wiggle the wheel from side to side, and > > >notice how the little silver ball on the screen lags behind. This isn't > a > > >problem with my system. Let me explain. > > > > > >For one thing, I don't have this problem with any other game. And I also > > >noticed that when you make a sudden movement on the wheel, the little > silver > > >ball *gradually* moves to the new position. Press the throttle down and > > >realease it with a 'snap' and you'll see what I mean. It looks to me > like > > >this is something they programmed into the game in order to smooth things > > >out for people with spikey controllers, dirty pots or whatever. Well, my > > >pots aren't dirty, and I don't like it. > > > > > >This sim seems really cool so far, but this controller "feature" really > > >pretty much ruins the game. I think the physics model is actually very > > >good, certainly improved over GP2, but you cant get the most out of it > with > > >this shitty latency. It gives the whole sim a weird disconnected > feeling, > > >and I think it makes it difficult to time your entry into fast corners. > > >Maybe it's something you can "get used to" to some extent, but no amount > of > > >practice will make up for your lost reaction time. > > > > > >What a bummer. I hope someone figures out how to hack this thing and > kill > > >it. What really troubles me is that this dopey little feature will > probably > > >appear in GP4, GP5, etc. as well. What a waste of a perfectly good sim. > > > > > > > Have you tried adjusting the "steering Help" feature under advanced > control > > options? > > I have not really noticed the effect you are talking about, but I have the > > steering help adjustment set to the default 100%, and it feels fine to me.
Aubrey 27 Aug 2000 18:06 UTC#236586
"James Pickard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:BH8q5.19876$[email hidden]... > It's not a steering help problem.... > > > It's a latency issue. Whether it is hardware or the software /drivers,it's > hard to say. > > This is an area of sim racing that is 'untapped'. Latency is a bad thing, > the less there is, the faster you will go... Let me clarify a couple of things here. It's not just latency that I'm seeing. There's a certain "springiness" to it that doesn't seem like ordinary hardware or driver problems. If it were just latency, a sudden movement on the wheel would produce a sudden movement in the sim. There would be a delay, but after the delay, the movement would be just as quick as your input. That's not what happens. Go to the calibration screen, press the throttle down, and take your foot off it suddenly. Then you'll see what I'm talking about. The little silver ball will move to its new location much slower then you moved your foot. That's why I'm so convinced it's programmed into the game, and not a problem with my system. I think it's meant to filter out spikes in the controls. It takes a few moments for the game to realize the input is genuine, rather than a spike. I wouldn't mind it if it just slowed me down, but this completely ruins the feel of the game. BTW, I'm using 0% steering help. Maybe I'll fiddle with that as an experiment. But I sure don't want to have it on all the time.
James Pickard 28 Aug 2000 04:28 UTC#236629
It's not a steering help problem.... It's a latency issue. Whether it is hardware or the software / drivers,it's hard to say. This is an area of sim racing that is 'untapped'. Latency is a bad thing, the less there is, the faster you will go... James Loosay2 <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > >Ok, day 3 with GP3 now. And I just noticed something. I've beenfiddling > >with the controller config a lot trying to get that same silky smoothfeel
Quoted text (8 lines)> >to the controls that I had with GP2, or even with GPL, and I haven't been > >able to do it. I think I just figured out why. > > > >There's a small "latency" in the controls. It feels like the steering > >collumn is made of rubber. I'm pretty certain this is actually > >intentionally hard-coded into the sim. It's easiest to see in the > >controller calibration screen. Wiggle the wheel from side to side, and > >notice how the little silver ball on the screen lags behind. This isn't
a > >problem with my system. Let me explain. > > > >For one thing, I don't have this problem with any other game. And I also > >noticed that when you make a sudden movement on the wheel, the littlesilver > >ball *gradually* moves to the new position. Press the throttle down and > >realease it with a 'snap' and you'll see what I mean. It looks to melike
Quoted text (7 lines)> >this is something they programmed into the game in order to smooth things > >out for people with spikey controllers, dirty pots or whatever. Well, my > >pots aren't dirty, and I don't like it. > > > >This sim seems really cool so far, but this controller "feature" really > >pretty much ruins the game. I think the physics model is actually very > >good, certainly improved over GP2, but you cant get the most out of it
with > >this shitty latency. It gives the whole sim a weird disconnectedfeeling, > >and I think it makes it difficult to time your entry into fast corners. > >Maybe it's something you can "get used to" to some extent, but no amountof > >practice will make up for your lost reaction time. > > > >What a bummer. I hope someone figures out how to hack this thing andkill > >it. What really troubles me is that this dopey little feature willprobably > >appear in GP4, GP5, etc. as well. What a waste of a perfectly good sim. > > > > Have you tried adjusting the "steering Help" feature under advancedcontrol > options? > I have not really noticed the effect you are talking about, but I have the > steering help adjustment set to the default 100%, and it feels fine to me.

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy