Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Is RAS now an official suburb of RASf1 ?

22 posts by 14 people · 14 Sep 2000 20:53 UTC - 19 Oct 2000 04:44 UTC

Debate over real-world F1 posts on r.a.s.

David Erb complained that the group was being flooded with real-life Formula One threads that belonged in rec.autos.sport.f1. Others argued sim racers follow the real sport and that off-topic posts marked OT were acceptable, while some said RASF1 was too chaotic to post in. No consensus was reached.

community/metareal motorsport

Automated summary.

David Erb 14 Sep 2000 20:53 UTC#231699
Jeez Looweez, you people are wearing out the filter on my newsreader. In the last couple of days theres been at least 10 threads here about real life formula one and general automotive recent events. You are aware that there are 2 other newsgroups devoted to discussion of f1? In both of those groups real life f1 is considered ON Topic. In the unmoderated f1 group you can even flame each other to your hearts delight (hell, *there* flammage is nearly mandatory). Now *this* group ; the title is rec.autos. simulators. Note that last word in the title. Here we purport to discuss the various products and methods that allow us to simulate ,to a greater or lesser degree, the act of driving/racing/tuning/polishing an automobile. So: howsa 'bout a good ol' GPL sucks thread? :) David Erb (who is aware that this is a lost cause but feels better anyway)
Chris Bloom 15 Sep 2000#231541
Are Formula One drivers not simulating what it's like to drive a simulator? -- Citylab Durban www.citylab.com David Erb <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:hVaw5.63815$[email hidden]... > Jeez Looweez, you people are wearing out the filter on my newsreader. In > the last couple of days theres been at least 10 threads here about real life > formula one and general automotive recent events. > David Erb > (who is aware that this is a lost cause but feels better anyway) > >
Greg Cisko 15 Sep 2000 00:01 UTC#231734
"David Erb" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:hVaw5.63815$[email hidden]... > Jeez Looweez, you people are wearing out the filter on my newsreader.In > the last couple of days theres been at least 10 threads here about reallife > formula one and general automotive recent events. You are aware that there > are 2 other newsgroups devoted to discussion of f1? In both of thosegroups > real life f1 is considered ON Topic. In the unmoderated f1 group you can > even flame each other to your hearts delight (hell, *there* flammage is > nearly mandatory). I used to post in those goups. But I found them full of aholes that liked to correct people all the time :-) -- [email hidden] > Now *this* group ; the title is rec.autos. simulators. Note that last > word in the title. Here we purport to discuss the various products and > methods that allow us to simulate ,to a greater or lesser degree, the act of > driving/racing/tuning/polishing an automobile. > > So: howsa 'bout a good ol' GPL sucks thread? :) > > > David Erb > (who is aware that this is a lost cause but feels better anyway) > >
Robert Gravel 15 Sep 2000 01:12 UTC#231589
"David Erb" wrote in message So: howsa 'bout a good ol' GPL sucks thread? :) LOL...good one :)
Simon Brown 15 Sep 2000 01:59 UTC#231633
Try sticking ten accountants in a room together and see if they only talk about accounting :) Actually, on second thoughts, don't try that, forceful imprisonment (even of accountants) is illegal. "David Erb" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:hVaw5.63815$[email hidden]... > > Jeez Looweez, you people are wearing out the filter on my newsreader.In <snippywippy> > So: howsa 'bout a good ol' GPL sucks thread? :) > > David Erb
Zonky 15 Sep 2000 11:40 UTC#231556
David Erb <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:hVaw5.63815$[email hidden]... > Jeez Looweez, you people are wearing out the filter on my newsreader.In > the last couple of days theres been at least 10 threads here about reallife > formula one and general automotive recent events. > David Erb > (who is aware that this is a lost cause but feels better anyway) > > David, you're not alone in your thinking. Somehow in the last year or so it's suddenly become "acceptable" that you make Off topic posts ok by marking OT: Why do these people just not take it to rasf1, and in light of rasf1.moderated recentish creation, the moderated group is they want to avoid all the "rasf1 crap". Why post somewhere off topic- where you know enough to say it's off topic? Why not just go make a post in a appropiate ON Topic newsgroup? Z. Please remove my_pants when replying.
Barton Brown 15 Sep 2000 12:42 UTC#231571
Chris Bloom wrote: > > Are Formula One drivers not simulating what it's like to drive a simulator? THERE ya go! Life imitates art imitating life, the endless circle of the dharma, the Worm Ouroboros... good point! Actually, if I may be allowed my opinion, I think postings about real world F1 should be welcome here for a couple reasons: 1. We're talking about simulations of real-life spaces, objects, people, and events. I'm sure many people run, say, F12K on the same schedule as the real-world F1 championship - for one thing it's kind of a karmic affinity, for another, it acquaints one with the track and makes watching the real thing a deeper experience. 2. The only other places to post about real-world F1 are RASF1, which is an anarchistic and chaotic rathole of such depravity that it makes RAS seem like a Utopian community of love and brotherhood. The other NG, RASF1 Moderated is so anal-retentive (the opposite swing of the pendulum from RASF1, from which it broke away), that I believe one of their rules is that you have to excuse yourself if you fart while sitting at the keyboard. My feeling is that as long as off-topic posts are identified (OT) in the subject header, they should be perfectly welcome. And don't even *mention* the word "bandwidth" -- the predilection for many people here to quote massive posts in their entirety so they can tack their two-word reply on the end makes any arguments about bandwidth laughable. Just my opinion, to which everyone is entitled BB
Allan Harrison 15 Sep 2000 15:06 UTC#231399
I totally agree with you Barton, Most people like Racing Sims because they follow the sport in real life. This way when you post something on F1 most people do find it interesting and it is semi - relevent. Provided the heading suggests its off topic I can't see a problem with it Allan Harrison - [email hidden] "Barton Brown" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > Chris Bloom wrote: > > > > Are Formula One drivers not simulating what it's like to drive asimulator?
Quoted text (19 lines)> > THERE ya go! Life imitates art imitating life, the endless circle of the > dharma, the Worm Ouroboros... good point! > > Actually, if I may be allowed my opinion, I think postings about real > world F1 should be welcome here for a couple reasons: > > 1. We're talking about simulations of real-life spaces, objects, people, > and events. I'm sure many people run, say, F12K on the same schedule as > the real-world F1 championship - for one thing it's kind of a karmic > affinity, for another, it acquaints one with the track and makes > watching the real thing a deeper experience. > > 2. The only other places to post about real-world F1 are RASF1, which is > an anarchistic and chaotic rathole of such depravity that it makes RAS > seem like a Utopian community of love and brotherhood. The other NG, > RASF1 Moderated is so anal-retentive (the opposite swing of the pendulum > from RASF1, from which it broke away), that I believe one of their rules > is that you have to excuse yourself if you fart while sitting at the
keyboard.
Quoted text (10 lines)> > My feeling is that as long as off-topic posts are identified (OT) in the > subject header, they should be perfectly welcome. And don't even > *mention* the word "bandwidth" -- the predilection for many people here > to quote massive posts in their entirety so they can tack their two-word > reply on the end makes any arguments about bandwidth laughable. > > Just my opinion, to which everyone is entitled > > BB
David Erb 15 Sep 2000 23:53 UTC#231485
"Barton Brown" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > Chris Bloom wrote: > > > > Are Formula One drivers not simulating what it's like to drive asimulator? > > THERE ya go! Life imitates art imitating life, the endless circle of the > dharma, the Worm Ouroboros... good point! I feel compelled to point out that endless circles in racing,either simulated or real, do eventually come to end as the chequered flag falls and the participants acheive the Nirvana of a happy extinction of the event. However happy extinctions in the form of a drowning of signal in off topic noise are hardly a good thing for an ongoing resource such as a newsgroup. :) > Actually, if I may be allowed my opinion, I think postings about real > world F1 should be welcome here for a couple reasons: It would be a poor world without others opinions! Let the great wheel roll! > 1. We're talking about simulations of real-life spaces, objects, people, > and events. I'm sure many people run, say, F12K on the same schedule as > the real-world F1 championship - for one thing it's kind of a karmic > affinity, for another, it acquaints one with the track and makes > watching the real thing a deeper experience. No doubt many do exactly as you say. How else would there be long discussions about the correct placement of pebbles in the F1-2000 version of Silverstone as opposed to real life? However, in what manner does the discussion of the mistakes of officials or the appointment of team managers enhance your ability to navigate a F1-2000 track in a fashion that deters the AI from bouncing you off the grandstands? Do arguments about the morality of the media assist you in using the replay feature of NH? > 2. The only other places to post about real-world F1 are RASF1, which is > an anarchistic and chaotic rathole of such depravity that it makes RAS > seem like a Utopian community of love and brotherhood. The other NG, > RASF1 Moderated is so anal-retentive (the opposite swing of the pendulum > from RASF1, from which it broke away), that I believe one of their rules > is that you have to excuse yourself if you fart while sitting at thekeyboard. If RASf1 suffers from such bad karma it may well be that the nature of its subject matter tends to cause its more volatile and immoderate members to generate said bad karma. In that case the importation of the subject matter into another area of the great wheel of discussion here in RAS will surely cause the vile karma to follow. regarding RASf1 moderated: I have perused the various FAQ's,charters and announcements ther and have found no mention of the words farting,breaking wind, passing gas, underwear inflation or bath bubbles so I would have to believe you are incorrect in your assesment. I *have* found standards regarding topicality and civility that were no great burden. > My feeling is that as long as off-topic posts are identified (OT) in the > subject header, they should be perfectly welcome. And don't even > *mention* the word "bandwidth" -- the predilection for many people here > to quote massive posts in their entirety so they can tack their two-word > reply on the end makes any arguments about bandwidth laughable. I do agree that if anyone feels compelled to post off topic material in *any* newsgroup that they should be courteous and add the ever handy OT to their title. It aids in the making of an effective filter for a start. > Just my opinion, to which everyone is entitled Oh, I most definitely agree on the opinion part <--- Note: *more* than 2 words :) > BB David
"Simon Brown" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:Hnfw5.1739$[email hidden]... > Try sticking ten accountants in a room together and see if they only talk > about accounting :) If I walk into a room with the expectation of hearing about the latest *NEW*, $IMPROVED$,%CREATIVE% methods and means of accounting I would be irked if all anyone wanted to do was to rehash last nights hockey game particularly if there was a sports bar just down the hall where everyone is talking about the hockey game. Some degree of Off topic discussion is no doubt inevitable in any sort of human social context but it should not become so pervasive that the original intent of the room is lost or even obscured. > Actually, on second thoughts, don't try that, forceful imprisonment (evenof > accountants) is illegal. >I would have thought that all imprisonments would imply a degree of force or at least coercion. Perhaps not hermits, nuns or monks though.:) David
Agreed, but it's only because the last GP was so eventful and it raised some important issues. As for why those F1 posts aren't on the F1 ng, probably the posters don't use the F1 groups and don't know anyone there. It's generally more meaningful to find out what people you know (even if only a little) think on a subject. "David Erb" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:MDyw5.66676$[email hidden]... > > > If I walk into a room with the expectation of hearing about the latest > *NEW*, $IMPROVED$,%CREATIVE% methods and means of accounting I would be > irked if all anyone wanted to do was to rehash last nights hockey game > particularly if there was a sports bar just down the hall where everyoneis > talking about the hockey game. Some degree of Off topic discussion is no > doubt inevitable in any sort of human social context but it should not > become so pervasive that the original intent of the room is lost or even > obscured. > > I would have thought that all imprisonments would imply a degree of forceor > at least coercion. Perhaps not hermits, nuns or monks though.:) > > David
Michael E. Carver 16 Sep 2000 17:11 UTC#231319
On Fri, 15 Sep 2000 10:40:15 GMT Zonky <[email hidden]> wrote: % you're not alone in your thinking. Somehow in the last year or so it's % suddenly become "acceptable" that you make Off topic posts ok by marking OT: % Why do these people just not take it to rasf1, and in light of rasf1.moderated % recentish creation, the moderated group is they want to avoid all the "rasf1 % crap". % Why post somewhere off topic- where you know enough to say it's off topic? Why % not just go make a post in a appropiate ON Topic newsgroup? Not only is this group getting more than enough "OT" postings, there are a handful of posters that do nothing but post inane responses to inane responses where were inane responses to another inane reponse taking a thread that had a valid point off to never-ever-ending land. I guess they are just being cute and adorable, but it is getting real hard to find any meat anymore in r.a.s. -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. [email hidden] http://www.teleport.com/~mcarver =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Michael E. Carver 16 Sep 2000 17:13 UTC#231320
On Fri, 15 Sep 2000 12:42:33 GMT Barton Brown <[email hidden]> wrote: % Actually, if I may be allowed my opinion, I think postings about real % world F1 should be welcome here for a couple reasons: % 2. The only other places to post about real-world F1 are RASF1, which is % an anarchistic and chaotic rathole of such depravity that it makes RAS % seem like a Utopian community of love and brotherhood. The other NG, % RASF1 Moderated is so anal-retentive (the opposite swing of the pendulum % from RASF1, from which it broke away), that I believe one of their rules % is that you have to excuse yourself if you fart while sitting at the keyboard. So you want to turn r.a.s. into a little mini-me of rasf1? That's what is happening when we stray off topic and discuss topics which belong in their own newsgroup.... % My feeling is that as long as off-topic posts are identified (OT) in the % subject header, they should be perfectly welcome. And don't even % *mention* the word "bandwidth" -- the predilection for many people here % to quote massive posts in their entirety so they can tack their two-word % reply on the end makes any arguments about bandwidth laughable. Personally these types of postings are becoming more of a problem than the OT postings. :( -- **************************** Michael E. Carver ************************* Upside out, or inside down...False alarm the only game in town. [email hidden] http://www.teleport.com/~mcarver =-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=<[ /./. [- < ]>=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=-=
Barton Brown 16 Sep 2000 20:09 UTC#231256
"\"Michael E. Carver\" mcarver"@teleport.com wrote: >but it is getting real hard to find any meat anymore in r.a.s. You might want to try "alt.rec.meat"
Barton Brown 16 Sep 2000 20:11 UTC#231257
"\"Michael E. Carver\" mcarver"@teleport.com wrote: > > So you want to turn r.a.s. into a little mini-me of rasf1? Yes, that's my sinister plan as the first step towards world domination...
GTX_SlotCar 16 Sep 2000 22:55 UTC#231282
David Erb <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:LDyw5.66675$[email hidden]... > > announcements ther and have found no mention of the words farting,breaking > wind, passing gas, underwear inflation or bath bubbles so I would have to > believe you are incorrect in your assesment. You didn't look under the (excuse me) section entitiled 'Butt Trumpet'. -- Slot www.slottweak.com Tweaks & Reviews
EldredP 19 Sep 2000#230610
In article <e0nw5.8321$ly4.62930@NewsReader>, [email hidden] (Zonky) writes: >Why post somewhere off topic- where you know enough to say it's off topic? >Why >not just go make a post in a appropiate ON Topic newsgroup? > >Z. Because even though it's off-topic, there may still be many people interested IN that topic. Witness the discussions everytime "Grand Prix" is aired...<g> Eldred -- Tiger Stadium R.I.P. 1912-1999 Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett GPL hcp. +50.77 Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
m.seery 19 Sep 2000 17:25 UTC#230667
but it is getting real hard to > find any meat anymore in r.a.s. Rubbish. There was a guy offering his white virgin ass in here last week <G> MS
ymenard 20 Sep 2000 01:38 UTC#230571
"EldredP" <[email hidden]> wrote > Because even though it's off-topic, there may still be many peopleinterested > IN that topic. If they are interested, why don't they go in the appropriate newsgroup? It's just common sense gents. -- -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> -- May the Downforce be with you... -- http://www.WeRace.net -- People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world.
In article <myUx5.69$[email hidden]>, "ymenard" <[email hidden]> writes:
Quoted text (8 lines)>"EldredP" <[email hidden]> wrote >> Because even though it's off-topic, there may still be many people >interested >> IN that topic. > > >If they are interested, why don't they go in the appropriate newsgroup? It's >just common sense gents.
If it deals with racing - be it sim, real, or *imagined*, I don't have a problem with it. I guess I'm just more tolerant than others...<shrug> Eldred -- Tiger Stadium R.I.P. 1912-1999 Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett GPL hcp. +49.67 Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
In article <myUx5.69$[email hidden]>, ymenard <[email hidden]> writes
Quoted text (9 lines)>"EldredP" <[email hidden]> wrote >> Because even though it's off-topic, there may still be many people >interested >> IN that topic. > > >If they are interested, why don't they go in the appropriate newsgroup? It's >just common sense gents. >
Yes and no. You are correct on a logical level of course, but if you think about it a bit more it's not quite the same posting to an otherwise never used forum frequented by people that you've never dealt with before just to make sure that what you are saying is on topic. I would much rather discuss, within reason, subjects with this group - my peers if you like - with whom I have a history and therefore a pretty good idea of what to expect when it comes to sensible/stupid/bone- headed/comical etc comments without getting caught up with all the added baggage when viewing replies from a bunch of complete unknowns as to why they just said what they did and wondering whether they're the reasonable sort or the kind who are likely to fly off at the slightest disagreement etc. It's just more relaxed posting here because of this. Obviously I'm not suggesting that 'anything goes', but it would be nice to know that we can go OT just a little, now and again, without getting brow-beaten for doing so. A lot of us have been here long enough now to know that things aren't going to get too far off from the more appropriate topics that we generally discuss here with confidence that things are unlikely to descend into complete anarchy. -- Peter Ives - (AKA Ivington) Remove ALL_STRESS before replying No person's opinions can be said to be more correct than another's, because each is the sole judge of his or her own experience.
Chris Bloom 19 Oct 2000 04:44 UTC#225904
I've been experimenting with RASF1 the last few weeks, I find if you liberally use killfiles you can successfully rid yourself of the large proportion of posters to that newsgroup who spend there time posting messages about everything except Formula One. I don't think i miss anything of substance by ignoring these people. Chris -- Simbok Racing www.geocities.com/simbokza "Barton Brown" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > > 2. The only other places to post about real-world F1 are RASF1, which is > an anarchistic and chaotic rathole of such depravity that it makes RAS > seem like a Utopian community of love and brotherhood. The other NG, > RASF1 Moderated is so anal-retentive (the opposite swing of the pendulum > from RASF1, from which it broke away), that I believe one of their rules > is that you have to excuse yourself if you fart while sitting at the keyboard. >

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy