Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Re: 9/25 In the High Groove article

1 post by 1 person · 26 Sep 2000 07:01 UTC - 26 Sep 2000 07:01 UTC

Tim McArthur 26 Sep 2000 07:01 UTC#229435
First things first. If you dont want to hear more about the Sears99 track of Sears Group... just stop now and move on to the next thread. warned ya! ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ Jeff Downey wrote two articles in which I disagree with. He gave me an open forum to discuss it but instead further bashed me in the artcile http://www.operationsports.com/reviewvault/articlesfull.asp?featureid=96 My emailed responce is below, but I feel I need to make a public statement as Jeff is unwilling to give me the same "air-time" as himself. 1) Your article "Tim vs Tom" was supposed to be based off the facts and you clearly state that "If you don't have all of the facts, you'll make an ass out of yourself every time." And you surely are doing that and doing your best to make an ass out of me as well. Your article wasn't based on facts, it was based on Tom Pabst's opinion regarding me and my track that I released. ***My facts were asked in an email from Jeff, but I was not able to comment on the subject at the time*** Take, in point, what proved to you that I was "a very active participant in the company". You state that you received emails forwarded from Tom Pabst that helped prove this to you. I asked you for a forward on these emails but I never received them. Hell, I can send you dozens of emails from Pabst stating that we are creating Sears99 to be released on the internet and we have SPR's approval to do it. I can even send you emails from Pabst stating that he is an alien from outter-space trying to take over the world, starting with me and my work... we can all edit an email and forward it off to another person to make our own argument look better. Forwarded emails are not facts Jeff 2) I sent you a rebuttal the day the "Tom vs Tim" article was posted. You had a rebuttal but did not post it. If you needed content, you had it Jeff. It was your choice not to use it. I guess you were doing your best not to look like that ass eh? 3) You most recent comment in today's article regarding why you didn't have last Monday's article up was just... dumb... I'm sorry, I cant find a better word for it just yet. "But, when I asked for some proof regarding his claims, I guess he decided not to speak at all." You never asked for proof, you asked for my witnesses phone numbers so you (a nobody in the real world) can personally call them to ask them some questions. That is unacceptable and I voiced that I am unwilling to do so. At that point I was fully convinced that you were not a person to even bother with. ------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------ My email to Jeff Downey sent Wed 9/13/00 1:10 PM: Jeff, May I get a forward on these emails that prove to you that I was employed by SearsGroup? I would be very interested in seeing what I had to say in those emails. A very respectable column. I wish I could have been able to give you more information, but my pending suit against Tom and SearsGroup prevents me from doing that. But, to help clear up a few points that you made: 1) First, the track that I released is not the same track that Tom and I worked on. It has been completely rebuilt from scratch to be more accurate and N3 friendly compared to the very hacked up track that Tom and I worked on. If we were to sit side by side and compare the two tracks, I can easily show hundreds of differences between the two, both in appearance and in the code itself. 2) No I was never employed by SearsGroup. In fact, SG does not exist. The name "SearsGroup" was made up by Tom Pabst to make himself appear more legit. Yes, there were plans that I would become a partner if SG did form, since my files and work is what would have started the company, but the formation of SG was left to Tom Pabst and Bob Davis, and I was to come in after the fact. Pabst and I were in negotiations on dollar amounts when we parted, but nothing ever surfaced. In fact, SG hasn't done anything since I left. 3) I never agreed (verbally or written) with SPR or SG that my work and/or files were the property of anyone other then myself. I talked with SPR yesterday, and it seems that Tom did "sell" my files to SPR without my knowledge or permission. That is called theft and I am pursuing it. 4) To the best of my knowledge, SPR had given Tom and myself permission to release Sears99 to the public. This is what I had been told up to the point that I actually released the track, and would never have spent the 5 months creating the track if I were not able to release my work. It seems Tom was playing double-agent to get my work, and to get SPR to allow us to do the work. I personally have never met Steve Page, only because Tom would not allow me to attend the meetings between him and SPR. 5) The NDA was signed in late April (Nascar testing week before the Sears Point race). That NDA was signed with the explicit understanding that any FUTURE work performed by Tom and I will be considered covered by the NDA. This is what was told to me, and that is the only reason I signed it. The papers were given to me late at night as I was leaving the track, in the dark. I was unable to read them and was told to just sign them and we would talk about it afterwards. Lesson learned I guess, but I do have 5 sworn witnesses willing to testify on my behalf regarding the NDA. The Sears99 track was built well before April of 2000 and was created with the understanding that it was being created as a hobby project to be released via the Internet. I have requested a copy of this NDA so I can bring it to my attorney, but Tom has failed to come up with it. I actually, still have no clue as to what it says in the NDA. 6) The letter from Steve Page does say not to use the track other than the purposes authorized, but I have been under the understanding that I was authorized to release the track. Again, I have never signed or seen anything that states any "authorized" or "unauthorized" uses of the Sears99 track. To the best of my knowledge, and from Tom's own words, we are/were authorized to release Seas99 once completed. 7) Actually, I have been contacted by nearly a dozen other track owners to produce their track. Birmingham is one that has already been released, and Stockton Speedway is another that I am currently working on. Tom Pabst and SearsGroup helped with Sears99 in a very small fashion� graphics only. In fact, the grass texture is about all that Tom Pabst did (I'm sure there are a few other files, but cant think of them off the top of my head). I doubt that finding a graphics person would slow me down too much from producing more tracks, and as you can see, I have released a ton since leaving Tom Pabst (BIR, Wilkes, Pocono, Daytona, Desert Winds, Desert Winds GPL, and now have Desert Winds Oval and four other tracks being released over the next few weeks� two being real-world tracks.) 8) I am now a part of 3 track editing organizations in the community. TWI, TEP, and TheUSPits team. I won't be slowing my track production at all, but I am being a lot more careful with getting written approvals from real tracks and to not team up with the wrong people. The above email was a rebutal to the artcile posted at http://www.operationsports.com/reviewvault/articlesfull.asp?featureid=94 but was not used as a rebuttal for some reason. I have contacted SPR and Steve Page has yet to return my phone calls personally. I have been requesting a clear, in writing, statement asking me to remove the likeness of SPR from my web pages. I have yet to recieve anything from SPR or Steve Page.

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy