Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

iRacing - Hardware

44 posts by 17 people · 12 Oct 2008 20:14 UTC - 24 Oct 2008 05:58 UTC

Hardware needed for iRacing, and is it a sport?

Returning simmer Dirt asked whether modest hardware could run iRacing, and replies said a dual-core CPU and mid-range graphics card would do, as anything that ran NR2003 well would cope. Older posters shared why they still sim race, and Mario Petrinovic and Ronald Stoehr argued over whether iRacing's laser-scanned tracks and sanctioning body made it more than a game. Dirt later joined using an Xbox 360 wheel and reported a smooth install.

hardware: PC/graphicsonline racing/leaguesgame comparisoniRacingrFactor

Automated summary.

Dirt 12 Oct 2008 20:14 UTC#2217
So, I just found out about iRacing and it has me thinking about coming back to sim racing after quite a while. What sort of hardware can you really get away with? Are the minimums listed at iRacing.com realistic, or is that really scraping the bottom of the barrel? -Dirt-
[email hidden] (Dirt) wrote: > So, I just found out about iRacing and it has me thinking about > coming back to sim racing after quite a while. Even with my many frustrations with iRacing, it is the kind of code which gets you back in the driving seat, one way or another! I've done more laps in more sims since starting my trial month in iRacing than I've done in the last two years. Hardware-wise, I think the biggest factor I've seen is whether you have a dual core processor. iRacing really seems to benefit significantly from that. As for graphics, it seems remarkably flexible if you have a relatively modern card. Exactly how modern though, I'm not sure. I started with what is now a relatively dated (in enthusiast terms anyway!) 8800GTS 320Mb and it coped very well with the shadows turned down to basic settings. An E6600 processor running at 3GHz probably helps a lot though for throwing the physics around. I really do wish iRacing would open up parts of their forums to the general public. It would help greatly with queries like yours. But the minimum specs look pretty realistic to me, if you can live with a few compromises. Andrew McP
Thanks. My current processor is a dual core 2.33GHz and my graphics card has an NVidia 7300 series chip (name unknown) and 512M. Not sure if this quite meets the bill, though, as its now two years old. I certainly won't be buying a new computer for iRacing, which why I'm hoping my current setup could be made to work. -Dirt-
Remco Moedt 13 Oct 2008 09:49 UTC↳ reply to Dirt#2222
On Sun, 12 Oct 2008 23:29:35 -0700 (PDT), Dirt <[email hidden]> wrote: >Thanks. My current processor is a dual core 2.33GHz and my graphics >card has an NVidia 7300 series chip (name unknown) and 512M. Not sure >if this quite meets the bill, though, as its now two years old. I >certainly won't be buying a new computer for iRacing, which why I'm >hoping my current setup could be made to work. I've an AMD 3500+ and a nVidia 6800 ultra. Granted, I had to cut down a lot, up to class 5, but then I had an fps of 50, and not the feeling I was missing out too much regarding graphics. Cheers! Remco
[email hidden] (Dirt) wrote: > NVidia 7300 series chip (name unknown) and 512M I take it that;s the RAM on the video card, not the pain PC? The 7300 chipset was initially a bit more of a concern, but I've just set iRacing up on this PC, which has an AMD x2 3800 @ 2.4GHz,2GB RAM, and an old ATI X800 graphics card. iRacing configured the video setting automatically, and it runs well. Nowhere near the setting on my main games box, but acceptable for racing rather than staring at the scenery. :-) The RAM footprint is harder to judge, but it looks to me (using the ctrl ALT DELETE Task Manager) that iRacing is using about 445k. So as long as you have 1Gb+ of system RAM you should be fine. It may even run ok with 512Mb, only with longer pauses when entering & exiting. Andrew McP
On Oct 13, 11:03 am, [email hidden] (Andrew MacPherson) wrote: > I take it that;s the RAM on the video card, not the pain PC? Yes, that is the video RAM. System RAM is 1G.
Dirt 13 Oct 2008 10:32 UTC↳ reply to Remco Moedt#2225
On Oct 13, 10:49 am, no@email (Remco Moedt) wrote: > > I've an AMD 3500+ and a nVidia 6800 ultra. Granted, I had to cut down > a lot, up to class 5, but then I had an fps of 50, and not the feeling > I was missing out too much regarding graphics. I haven't simmed since GPL, so I'm used to 30 fps! -Dirt-
Larry 13 Oct 2008 12:42 UTC↳ reply to Dirt#2226
If you could run NR2003 full tilt, you can run iRacing. However a bump in processor and graphics capability would NOT hurt. -Larry "Dirt" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > So, I just found out about iRacing and it has me thinking about coming > back to sim racing after quite a while. What sort of hardware can you > really get away with? Are the minimums listed at iRacing.com > realistic, or is that really scraping the bottom of the barrel? > > -Dirt-
Plowboy 14 Oct 2008 01:42 UTC↳ reply to Larry#2227
Processor is fine, GPU (vid) will make things nicer the 7300 is pretty much like my 8600 I believe, I like it fine. I have an 8800gt and it runs better on that card overall (but the card has a flaw and is on its way back with an RMA>.. "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:KmHIk.216$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (14 lines)> If you could run NR2003 full tilt, you can run iRacing. However a bump in > processor and graphics capability would NOT hurt. > > -Larry > > "Dirt" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... >> So, I just found out about iRacing and it has me thinking about coming >> back to sim racing after quite a while. What sort of hardware can you >> really get away with? Are the minimums listed at iRacing.com >> realistic, or is that really scraping the bottom of the barrel? >> >> -Dirt- >
Dirt 14 Oct 2008 06:38 UTC↳ reply to Plowboy#2228
Thanks, all, for the answers. Sounds like my current setup will be adequate. Now on to a different question. I still have my Thomas Super Wheel but it has a serial port interface. Is there any way to make XPPro recognize a serial interface properly? I tried once a year or two ago when I put away my Win98 GPL machine but was never successful in getting it calibrated properly. I contacted TSW but they essentially suggest a complete rewire to their USB connection. My other option if the TSW can't be made to work is the wireless PC control adapter and my XBox360 wireless FFB wheel. Anybody use this wheel for iRacing? The TSW is a brick and I love it, but FFB might be nice. My only experience with FFB is on Forza Motorsports on the 360. I'm not convinced yet. -Dirt- PS: Any of you approaching 40 like me and wondering just what the hell you're still doing thinking about sim racing all the time? ;)
GaryR 14 Oct 2008 16:11 UTC↳ reply to Dirt#2229
Come back in 13 years and ask that.. ;-) >On Mon, 13 Oct 2008 23:38:28 -0700 (PDT), Dirt <[email hidden]> wrote: >PS: Any of you approaching 40 like me and wondering just what the >hell you're still doing thinking about sim racing all the time? ;)
Ed Medlin 14 Oct 2008 17:10 UTC↳ reply to Dirt#2230
"Dirt" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (20 lines)> Thanks, all, for the answers. Sounds like my current setup will be > adequate. > > Now on to a different question. I still have my Thomas Super Wheel > but it has a serial port interface. Is there any way to make XPPro > recognize a serial interface properly? I tried once a year or two ago > when I put away my Win98 GPL machine but was never successful in > getting it calibrated properly. I contacted TSW but they essentially > suggest a complete rewire to their USB connection. My other option if > the TSW can't be made to work is the wireless PC control adapter and > my XBox360 wireless FFB wheel. Anybody use this wheel for iRacing? > The TSW is a brick and I love it, but FFB might be nice. My only > experience with FFB is on Forza Motorsports on the 360. I'm not > convinced yet. > > -Dirt- > > PS: Any of you approaching 40 like me and wondering just what the > hell you're still doing thinking about sim racing all the time? ;) >
You are a young pup.......:-). There are lots of folks on iRacing in their 50s and 60s. Ed
speedmd 15 Oct 2008 03:21 UTC↳ reply to Dirt#2231
I'm 45 an I sim race for a living, so to speak. As far as XP is concerned, I installed my trusty Turtle Beach Santa Cruz sound card into my home built box, and the joystick port works just fine. speedmd
Larry 15 Oct 2008 13:14 UTC↳ reply to speedmd#2232
Most trouble-free sound card ever made. It's a shame they didn't continue the family :( -Larry "speedmd" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (7 lines)> I'm 45 an I sim race for a living, so to speak. > > As far as XP is concerned, I installed my trusty Turtle Beach Santa > Cruz sound card into my home built box, and the joystick port works > just fine. > > speedmd
Bob Simpson 15 Oct 2008 13:55 UTC↳ reply to Dirt#2233
On Oct 14, 2:38 am, Dirt <[email hidden]> wrote: > PS:  Any of you approaching 40 like me and wondering just what the > hell you're still doing thinking about sim racing all the time? ;) Eight years ago at 52, I discovered Simming with GPL. It was like a dream come true for me. These Sims that we're talking about aren't games, but a fairly realistic racing experience - especially when you factor in a good wheel, pedals and shifter. Now at 60, I don't see this stopping ever. The "gaming" aspect just isn't there in iRacing, GPL and the other fairly realistic Sims/Mods, although there is a time and place to play games for recreation. I can see that when I explain my hobby to others, they assume that it's a game, but staying at it happliy for 8 years and more, they must realize that it's a serious activity.
On Wed, 15 Oct 2008 06:55:37 -0700 (PDT), Bob Simpson wrote: > On Oct 14, 2:38ᅵam, Dirt <[email hidden]> wrote: > I can see that when I explain my hobby to others, they assume that > it's a game, but staying at it happliy for 8 years and more, they must > realize that it's a serious activity. For me, the main aspect of simracing that has kept me hooked on it ever since a friend "lent" me his 2 amiga floppies with F1GP on it is the multiplayer / community part. I've been online since 1990, and pretty soon after starting to race F1GP I joined Oliver Robert's "offline league" that featured soon-to-become community celebreties like Grant Reeve and myself, just to name a few ;-) We'd run a full-length gp offline, then submit our race times to Oliver who'd compile them into a "virtual" race, handing out points, keeping the standings and so on. Good times! Even with all the advances in AI and cpu power, online racing is still where it's at for me, and while I've gone through phases where I did not touch a wheel for a week or two, there's always something new to try out or a new season to organize and I keep coming back to this great pastime. Speaking of leagues, The Screamers are still looking to fill some slots on the grid for season18 starting on Oct. 25th. Follow up here if you're interested in joining one of the oldest race clubs on the net and we'll sort something out! Looking forward to hearing from you, Uwe
On Oct 16, 11:26 am, hoover <[email hidden]> wrote: > Speaking of leagues, The Screamers are still looking to fill some > slots on the grid for season18 starting on Oct. 25th. Follow up here > if you're interested in joining one of the oldest race clubs on the > net and we'll sort something out! > > Looking forward to hearing from you, Many thanks for the invite, but I'm not in a situation where I can do any simming at the moment. I'll be back in my normal environment (i.e. through with my job assignment) come February and will be trying to set up iRacing at that point. -Dirt-
Plowboy 17 Oct 2008 02:02 UTC↳ reply to Dirt#2236
save up a few bucks, get a newer wheel with USB connections, g25's are fab if you can find them and they aint cheap but I live the hell out of mine so far, there are others out there. Im Iracing with my Vista box, so it (iRacing that is) works with what is new out there and old, if you can get Windows to friggin work correctly... "Dirt" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... On Oct 16, 11:26 am, hoover <[email hidden]> wrote: > Speaking of leagues, The Screamers are still looking to fill some > slots on the grid for season18 starting on Oct. 25th. Follow up here > if you're interested in joining one of the oldest race clubs on the > net and we'll sort something out! > > Looking forward to hearing from you, Many thanks for the invite, but I'm not in a situation where I can do any simming at the moment. I'll be back in my normal environment (i.e. through with my job assignment) come February and will be trying to set up iRacing at that point. -Dirt-
On Mon, 13 Oct 2008 03:32:14 -0700 (PDT), Dirt <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (7 lines)>On Oct 13, 10:49�am, no@email (Remco Moedt) wrote: >> >> I've an AMD 3500+ and a nVidia 6800 ultra. Granted, I had to cut down >> a lot, up to class 5, but then I had an fps of 50, and not the feeling >> I was missing out too much regarding graphics. > >I haven't simmed since GPL, so I'm used to 30 fps!
Since I'm on GPL (sim-wise exclusively) I had no reason to upgrade my trusty old Athlon 2600+ and Rad 9600 Pro (iirc, long time since I opened the box :-) Jens
Jeff Reid 17 Oct 2008 17:25 UTC↳ reply to GaryR#2238
>>PS: Any of you approaching 40 like me and wondering just what the >>hell you're still doing thinking about sim racing all the time? ;) 56 years old, here, but for me, sim-racing is just another game. Realistic physics in a game is fine, but it's not really much of a learning tool, even for those (unlike me) who actually race. My real world experience is maybe a couple of autocross sessions, and some indoor go-kart stuff, not real racing, so I don't need a learning tool. The only learning tool software I own is a radio control aircraft similator called RealFlight. Since there is no force feedback in the real world, the only difference is visual, but this doesn't matter much. The main issue is dealing with orientation (flying a rc heli upsidedown and sideways mixes up the control inputs you use), and how the model responds to control inputs, which the rc simulators do quite well. Back to racing sims, unlike radio control, a bit part of racing is the feedback you get from forces while driving at the limits, and no amount of visual, audio, or steering force feedback is going to replace it. Some real world racers use these games to get an idea of track layouts, but point out that even the simplest things, like braking points, are significantly different between game and real world. For me there are racing games, some have realistic physics, and some like Need For Speed, have pursuits and cool graphics. Regarding online play, I'm not as active as I was, because I play a larger variety of games (I also play games like TombRaider), and my gaming time is limited. In my opinion, online racing attendance peaked somewhere in 2005, and slow diminished since then with a few blips as new games got released.
jeffareid:
Quoted text (10 lines)> Back to racing sims, unlike radio control, a bit part of racing is the > feedback you get from forces while driving at the limits, and no amount > of visual, audio, or steering force feedback is going to replace it. Some > real world racers use these games to get an idea of track layouts, but > point > out that even the simplest things, like braking points, are significantly > different between game and real world. For me there are racing games, some > have realistic physics, and some like Need For Speed, have pursuits and > cool > graphics.
46, here. Just the other day I watched Rfactor on Laguna Seca. Compared to iRacing, the difference is enormous. The difference is in small things, but those small things makes track completely different. Well, like they said in one episode of Inside Simracing, little differences, not big deal. Only, the one track is real, and the other is not, this is what makes iRacing useful. Rfactor version isn't good for anything, and it only confuses real life driver. iRacing version is spot on, and it really can help real life driver (I am not one of them). Showing him track layout exactly. And this is what laser scanning is about, the exact computer representation of the track. In your sport training is simple, in car racing training is expensive, very expensive, and knowing the exact layout, can help (I would say, pretty much). Braking points aren't big deal. One car has one braking point, the other has another. You change a setup, you change braking point a little. You adjust your braking point to real situation, to the REAL track. And you already know real track pretty well, if you raced it on iRacing a hundreds of times. The behavior of the car? Well, every car behaves differently, and even the same car behaves differently, regarding on tire pressure. Even on the same tires, the car behaves differently during time, and in changing weather conditions. Comes a rain, everything changes. But, the track layout doesn't change. Knowing that there is a crest on the track in some corner, and driving accordingly (using that crest), helps you a lot when you finally come to the track in real life, and other drivers only just spot that, and they need some time to "figure" it out. You are already way ahead. At least, this is how I see the whole thing. -- Mario Petrinovic
Mario Petrinovic: > At least, this is how I see the whole thing. -- Mario Petrinovic Oh yes, the other thing is that iRacing provides a controlled environment with sanctioning body, and thus can give infrastructure to develop sim racing into a real sport. It is the only of this kind. Iracing team is awaible 24/7/365, constantly maintaing and building this infrastructure. This is just fantastic, compared to anything else, way ahead, revolutionary. Whatever Kaemmer did in the past, it was always revolutionary for sim racing. Hat down to him, he is way ahead of everybody. I simply cannot undarstand anybody who bashes iRacing. -- Mario Petrinovic
Mario Petrinovic wrote:
Quoted text (15 lines)> jeffareid: >> Back to racing sims, unlike radio control, a bit part of racing is the >> feedback you get from forces while driving at the limits, and no amount >> of visual, audio, or steering force feedback is going to replace it. Some >> real world racers use these games to get an idea of track layouts, but >> point >> out that even the simplest things, like braking points, are significantly >> different between game and real world. For me there are racing games, >> some >> have realistic physics, and some like Need For Speed, have pursuits and >> cool >> graphics. > > 46, here. Just the other day I watched Rfactor on Laguna Seca. > Compared to iRacing, the difference is enormous. The difference is in small
Oh please, you picked one of the worst tracks for rF. Big deal... Mid Ohio, Rouen, LeMans (Virtua_LM) Nordschleife Zandvoort Spa Bugatti and on, and on, and on Oh wait, you can't drive most of them with iRacing. Damn... l8er ronny
Mario Petrinovic wrote:
Quoted text (12 lines)> Mario Petrinovic: >> At least, this is how I see the whole thing. -- Mario Petrinovic > > Oh yes, the other thing is that iRacing provides a controlled > environment with sanctioning body, and thus can give infrastructure to > develop sim racing into a real sport. It is the only of this kind. > Iracing team is awaible 24/7/365, constantly maintaing and building this > infrastructure. This is just fantastic, compared to anything else, way > ahead, revolutionary. Whatever Kaemmer did in the past, it was always > revolutionary for sim racing. Hat down to him, he is way ahead of > everybody. I simply cannot undarstand anybody who bashes iRacing. -- > Mario Petrinovic
Who's bashing iRacing? If you want the stuff iRacing is offering, good for you. But it's not the holy grail if one rather wants lots of tracks, lots of cars and good physics on top. I cannot understand anybody who glorifies iRacing... l8er ronny
Ronald Stoehr:
Quoted text (20 lines)> Mario Petrinovic: >> Mario Petrinovic: >>> At least, this is how I see the whole thing. -- Mario Petrinovic >> >> Oh yes, the other thing is that iRacing provides a controlled >> environment with sanctioning body, and thus can give infrastructure to >> develop sim racing into a real sport. It is the only of this kind. >> Iracing team is awaible 24/7/365, constantly maintaing and building this >> infrastructure. This is just fantastic, compared to anything else, way >> ahead, revolutionary. Whatever Kaemmer did in the past, it was always >> revolutionary for sim racing. Hat down to him, he is way ahead of >> everybody. I simply cannot undarstand anybody who bashes iRacing. -- >> Mario Petrinovic > > Who's bashing iRacing? If you want the stuff iRacing is offering, good for > you. > But it's not the holy grail if one rather wants lots of tracks, lots of > cars > and good physics on top. I cannot understand anybody who glorifies > iRacing...
Yes, you are right. I just watched Grid review at Inside Simracing. It sure can get you a lot of fun (it looks like). At first I didn't understand what the iRacing stuff is talking about when they talked how they will not steal anybody's share of market. Now I do understand. At first I just thought that iRacing will be in competition with other sims. Now I know that iRacing is a completely different thing. And this is what they announced on their public release. They said, who wants to play games doesn't need to come to iRacing. As simple as it is. iRacing is a sport, real sport, and it is developed for sportsmen, not for playing around. Other sims will have better looks, more fun, better graphics, more tracks, more cars. iRacing will always try to give the best physics, accurate laser scanning tracks, and controlled environment. The market is splitting. There will not be anymore fun games trying to act like the real thing. There will be iRacing trying to BE real thing, and other stuff offering plenty of fun. It is one interesting thing, iRacing is actually recruiting its membership from "fun sims" buyers. So, the more fun "fun sims" are offering, and the more people "fun sims" are attracting, the bigger pool of potential iRacing customers. -- Mario Petrinovic
Mario Petrinovic wrote:
Quoted text (30 lines)> Ronald Stoehr: >> Mario Petrinovic: >>> Mario Petrinovic: >>>> At least, this is how I see the whole thing. -- Mario Petrinovic >>> >>> Oh yes, the other thing is that iRacing provides a controlled >>> environment with sanctioning body, and thus can give infrastructure >>> to develop sim racing into a real sport. It is the only of this kind. >>> Iracing team is awaible 24/7/365, constantly maintaing and building >>> this infrastructure. This is just fantastic, compared to anything >>> else, way ahead, revolutionary. Whatever Kaemmer did in the past, it >>> was always revolutionary for sim racing. Hat down to him, he is way >>> ahead of everybody. I simply cannot undarstand anybody who bashes >>> iRacing. -- Mario Petrinovic >> >> Who's bashing iRacing? If you want the stuff iRacing is offering, good >> for you. >> But it's not the holy grail if one rather wants lots of tracks, lots >> of cars >> and good physics on top. I cannot understand anybody who glorifies >> iRacing... > > Yes, you are right. I just watched Grid review at Inside > Simracing. It sure can get you a lot of fun (it looks like). > At first I didn't understand what the iRacing stuff is talking > about when they talked how they will not steal anybody's share of > market. Now I do understand. At first I just thought that iRacing will > be in competition with other sims. Now I know that iRacing is a > completely different thing. And this is what they announced on their > public release. They said, who wants to play games doesn't need to come
Gimme a break, Mr. BigHead! It's still a GAME, just like rFactor... <snipped marketing bullshit> l8er ronny
Ronald Stoehr:
Quoted text (34 lines)> Mario Petrinovic: >> Ronald Stoehr: >>> Mario Petrinovic: >>>> Mario Petrinovic: >>>>> At least, this is how I see the whole thing. >>>> >>>> Oh yes, the other thing is that iRacing provides a controlled >>>> environment with sanctioning body, and thus can give infrastructure to >>>> develop sim racing into a real sport. It is the only of this kind. >>>> Iracing team is awaible 24/7/365, constantly maintaing and building >>>> this infrastructure. This is just fantastic, compared to anything else, >>>> way ahead, revolutionary. Whatever Kaemmer did in the past, it was >>>> always revolutionary for sim racing. Hat down to him, he is way ahead >>>> of everybody. I simply cannot undarstand anybody who bashes iRacing. >>> >>> Who's bashing iRacing? If you want the stuff iRacing is offering, good >>> for you. >>> But it's not the holy grail if one rather wants lots of tracks, lots of >>> cars >>> and good physics on top. I cannot understand anybody who glorifies >>> iRacing... >> >> Yes, you are right. I just watched Grid review at Inside >> Simracing. It sure can get you a lot of fun (it looks like). >> At first I didn't understand what the iRacing stuff is talking >> about when they talked how they will not steal anybody's share of market. >> Now I do understand. At first I just thought that iRacing will be in >> competition with other sims. Now I know that iRacing is a completely >> different thing. And this is what they announced on their public release. >> They said, who wants to play games doesn't need to come > > Gimme a break, Mr. BigHead! It's still a GAME, just like rFactor... > > <snipped marketing bullshit> ronny
Well, one can argue whether life is a game. But, the FACT is that iRacing HAS sanctioning body which works 24/7, the FACT is that iRacing HAS laser scanned tracks. Now, these are the main characteristics of iRacing, sanctioning body and laser scanned tracks. Now, what would be the purpose of those things? What do you think? To act like BigHeads, or what? The purpose of those things is exactly to develop a sport, and to make iRacing a tool for sportsmen. I don't see any other purpose for these (and these things are EXPENSIVE, no way they would be used without a purpose), and also I don't see any other "game" that has those things, and that has put so much money into those things. Why? Well, because no other company has these goals. -- Mario Petrinovic
I bought a wireless PC adapter today that will let me use my XBox 360 wheel with my PC. When it comes next week I'm going to ante up for the $20 trial membership. Depending on how it goes and how much time I'm able to spend with it I'll probably set up a dedicated spot in my basement in February when I return home and sign up for the full year. -Dirt-
> iRacing ... sport I wouldn't call any computer activity a sport. Some claim that flying radio control models is a sport. I fly radio control gliders, mostly at a slope site where there's an updraft, and most of the time, I'm just twiddling a pair of small joysticks. The only sport aspect in this is if the updraft goes away, and I have to go down and back up the slope to retieve the model. > that has put so much money Most popular games cost that much to make or more. Electronic Arts spends about $10 million per year or so for the yearly released versions of Need For Speed. These games sell at around 5 million (ProStreet) to 9 million (Carbon, Most Wanted, Underdround 2), so it's business model that works. (Compare this to the 6000 or so iRacing "renters").
On Sat, 18 Oct 2008 12:34:48 +0200, Mario Petrinovic wrote:
Quoted text (14 lines)> jeffareid: >> Back to racing sims, unlike radio control, a bit part of racing is the >> feedback you get from forces while driving at the limits, and no amount >> of visual, audio, or steering force feedback is going to replace it. Some >> real world racers use these games to get an idea of track layouts, but >> point >> out that even the simplest things, like braking points, are significantly >> different between game and real world. For me there are racing games, some >> have realistic physics, and some like Need For Speed, have pursuits and >> cool >> graphics. > > 46, here. Just the other day I watched Rfactor on Laguna Seca. > Compared to iRacing, the difference is enormous. The difference is in small
I don't think it's exactly fair to compare a community created track to the one in iRacing. A better comparison might be ISI's "BritishGP" to the iRacing version, but then again the ISI version is a couple of years old already. Cheers, uwe --
jeffareid:
Quoted text (10 lines)>> iRacing ... sport > > I wouldn't call any computer activity a sport. Some claim that flying > radio control > models is a sport. I fly radio control gliders, mostly at a slope site > where there's > an updraft, and most of the time, I'm just twiddling a pair of small > joysticks. > The only sport aspect in this is if the updraft goes away, and I have to > go down and back up the slope to retieve the model.
Well, I don't know. In my language chess is called sport. In real life racing you are mostly sitting in your car, and the only "sport" is performed by crew that changes tires.
Quoted text (10 lines)>> that has put so much money > > Most popular games cost that much to make or more. Electronic Arts spends > about > $10 million per year or so for the yearly released versions of Need For > Speed. > These games sell at around 5 million (ProStreet) to 9 million (Carbon, > Most Wanted, > Underdround 2), so it's business model that works. (Compare this to the > 6000 or so iRacing "renters").
My point isn't actually in the amount of money to achieve good selling numbers. It is the thing into which the money is put on. N4S puts their money in good explosions (or something). iRacing puts its money into things which makes it a good tool for real life racers, and in sanctioning body and things like that. It is their goals we are discussing. Their goal is to make this a sport. -- Mario Petrinovic
"Dirt" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... On Oct 13, 10:49 am, no@email (Remco Moedt) wrote: > > I've an AMD 3500+ and a nVidia 6800 ultra. Granted, I had to cut down > a lot, up to class 5, but then I had an fps of 50, and not the feeling > I was missing out too much regarding graphics. >I haven't simmed since GPL, so I'm used to 30 fps! Only 30? I had 36FPS. :o)
"jeffareid" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:lZPKk.3$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (12 lines)>> iRacing ... sport > > I wouldn't call any computer activity a sport. Some claim that flying > radio control > models is a sport. I fly radio control gliders, mostly at a slope site > where there's > an updraft, and most of the time, I'm just twiddling a pair of small > joysticks. > The only sport aspect in this is if the updraft goes away, and I have to > go down > and back up the slope to retieve the model. >
The point made has nothing to do with being pedantic about ones use of the word "Sport". The point is that tRacing caters to the more serious simmer who wants regulation and structure for proper competition as opposed to pickup races without any of that. Also, I believe that in the not too distant future, we will have competitions in place where the champion of the top class will have a legitimate claim to being the "World's" best simmer for that seasons duration, much the same as formula 1. Unless another company follows iRacing's lead, then an iRacing champion will be just that - "World Champion"!
"Byron Forbes" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:48fda300$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (20 lines)> > "jeffareid" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:lZPKk.3$[email hidden]... >>> iRacing ... sport >> >> I wouldn't call any computer activity a sport. Some claim that flying >> radio control >> models is a sport. I fly radio control gliders, mostly at a slope site >> where there's >> an updraft, and most of the time, I'm just twiddling a pair of small >> joysticks. >> The only sport aspect in this is if the updraft goes away, and I have to >> go down >> and back up the slope to retieve the model. >> > > The point made has nothing to do with being pedantic about ones use of > the word "Sport". The point is that tRacing caters to the more serious > simmer who wants regulation and structure for proper competition as > opposed to pickup races without any of that.
Leagues have offerred much of this now for years.
schooner: >Byron Forbes: >> The point is that tRacing caters to the more serious simmer who wants >> regulation and structure for proper competition as opposed to pickup >> races without any of that. > > Leagues have offerred much of this now for years. But isn't iRacing "the league of the leagues", or however you are saying. This means, the greatest of them all. -- Mario Petrinovic
"schooner" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:dxhLk.2958$%%2.2012@edtnps82...
Quoted text (25 lines)> "Byron Forbes" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:48fda300$[email hidden]... >> >> "jeffareid" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >> news:lZPKk.3$[email hidden]... >>>> iRacing ... sport >>> >>> I wouldn't call any computer activity a sport. Some claim that flying >>> radio control >>> models is a sport. I fly radio control gliders, mostly at a slope site >>> where there's >>> an updraft, and most of the time, I'm just twiddling a pair of small >>> joysticks. >>> The only sport aspect in this is if the updraft goes away, and I have to >>> go down >>> and back up the slope to retieve the model. >>> >> >> The point made has nothing to do with being pedantic about ones use of >> the word "Sport". The point is that tRacing caters to the more serious >> simmer who wants regulation and structure for proper competition as >> opposed to pickup races without any of that. > > Leagues have offerred much of this now for years. >
Tell me of a league where it's champion had a claim to call himself "World Champion".
"Byron Forbes" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:48feae02$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (32 lines)> > "schooner" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:dxhLk.2958$%%2.2012@edtnps82... >> "Byron Forbes" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >> news:48fda300$[email hidden]... >>> >>> "jeffareid" <[email hidden]> wrote in message >>> news:lZPKk.3$[email hidden]... >>>>> iRacing ... sport >>>> >>>> I wouldn't call any computer activity a sport. Some claim that flying >>>> radio control >>>> models is a sport. I fly radio control gliders, mostly at a slope site >>>> where there's >>>> an updraft, and most of the time, I'm just twiddling a pair of small >>>> joysticks. >>>> The only sport aspect in this is if the updraft goes away, and I have >>>> to go down >>>> and back up the slope to retieve the model. >>>> >>> >>> The point made has nothing to do with being pedantic about ones use >>> of the word "Sport". The point is that tRacing caters to the more >>> serious simmer who wants regulation and structure for proper competition >>> as opposed to pickup races without any of that. >> >> Leagues have offerred much of this now for years. >> > > Tell me of a league where it's champion had a claim to call himself > "World Champion". >
So iRacing deemed themselves the head of all things sim racing so they could say their winner is world champion? Any league could have made up the same title since it is merely that, a made up title. What makes iRacing the defacto standard and authority for handing out such a title? Just curious.
Dirt 22 Oct 2008 12:05 UTC↳ reply to Schooner#2413
On Oct 22, 10:57 am, "schooner" <[email hidden]> wrote: > What makes iRacing the defacto standard and authority for handing out such a > title?  Just curious. They can use "world" because anybody from any country in the world with an internet connection can join. They can use "champion" because they hold structured competitions intended to crown a series champion. Technically there's nothing wrong with a "world champion" claim because it's true; a series champion can come from anywhere in the world. Even if another sim starts a "world championship" that doesn't invalidate the truth of iRacing's claim because I doubt iRacing have specifically claimed to have the ONLY world champion, just A world champion.
Schooner 22 Oct 2008 12:24 UTC↳ reply to Dirt#2414
Exactly, so any league coudl do the same with any sim, whic hwas my orginal point. "Dirt" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... On Oct 22, 10:57 am, "schooner" <[email hidden]> wrote: > What makes iRacing the defacto standard and authority for handing out such > a > title? Just curious. They can use "world" because anybody from any country in the world with an internet connection can join. They can use "champion" because they hold structured competitions intended to crown a series champion. Technically there's nothing wrong with a "world champion" claim because it's true; a series champion can come from anywhere in the world. Even if another sim starts a "world championship" that doesn't invalidate the truth of iRacing's claim because I doubt iRacing have specifically claimed to have the ONLY world champion, just A world champion.
schooner: > Exactly, so any league coudl do the same with any sim, whic hwas my > orginal point. So, go to any league. Or any "sim". Do and race anything, if that is your point. I don't vaste my time on anything. iRacing is the best of its kind, and by every day it is better. rFactor "physics" makes me laugh (one guy on iRacing forum made a joke, by requesting that iRacing also have that chasis "shaking" thing that rFactor has, "it's so cool", lol). Real life drivers have benefit of racing iRacing. iRacing has the quality, the quantity, and one day it will have the money to back all this up, and to expand all over the World. You have something against it? I don't have. iRacing has good idea, actually excellent idea. -- Mario Petrinovic
I have nothing against it either, was an early alpha tester in fact, I'm jsut saying it isn't all new and innovative as many want to believe. it also isn't the be all and end all for all simmers. It also falls short in a number of areas that other sims already do. "Mario Petrinovic" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:gdn924$4bh$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (15 lines)> schooner: >> Exactly, so any league coudl do the same with any sim, whic hwas my >> orginal point. > > So, go to any league. Or any "sim". Do and race anything, if that > is > your point. I don't vaste my time on anything. iRacing is the best of its > kind, and by every day it is better. rFactor "physics" makes me laugh (one > guy on iRacing forum made a joke, by requesting that iRacing also have > that > chasis "shaking" thing that rFactor has, "it's so cool", lol). Real life > drivers have benefit of racing iRacing. iRacing has the quality, the > quantity, and one day it will have the money to back all this up, and to > expand all over the World. You have something against it? I don't have. > iRacing has good idea, actually excellent idea. -- Mario Petrinovic
schooner: >I have nothing against it either, was an early alpha tester in fact, I'm >jsut saying it isn't all new and innovative as many want to believe. > it also isn't the be all and end all for all simmers. It also falls short > in a number of areas that other sims already do. Yes, you are right about that, thanks. Although, when I read your post again I notice that you are not that much right. I would say that introducing laser scanned tracks, and the whole concept of sanctioning body and all this, is revolutionary for sim racing, there is no doubt about it. Plus, iRacing developed the most important things, like incident penalty, physics, FF. OTOH, it lacks on less important things. Like a lot of people, I think that Kaemmer is the guy who very well (actually, the best) places priorities. For example, weather would only confuse things (for now). He excluded weather ON PURPOSE, not because iRacing is unable to deliver. Smart guy. Once thing expand, then weather can have some SENSE in the whole project. -- Mario Petrinovic
Quoted text (17 lines)>Mario Petrinovic: >> schooner: >>> Exactly, so any league coudl do the same with any sim, whic hwas my >>> orginal point. >> >> So, go to any league. Or any "sim". Do and race anything, if that >> is >> your point. I don't vaste my time on anything. iRacing is the best of its >> kind, and by every day it is better. rFactor "physics" makes me laugh >> (one >> guy on iRacing forum made a joke, by requesting that iRacing also have >> that >> chasis "shaking" thing that rFactor has, "it's so cool", lol). Real life >> drivers have benefit of racing iRacing. iRacing has the quality, the >> quantity, and one day it will have the money to back all this up, and to >> expand all over the World. You have something against it? I don't have. >> iRacing has good idea, actually excellent idea. -- Mario Petrinovic
Well I'm still waiting for an answer to my original question - what league? BTW, I have no idea if iRacing have any intention of doing what I suggest. But with their setup and a little balls, inititive and desire I believe they could do it. How did Formula 1 get started? "schooner" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:dYELk.3131$%%2.2963@edtnps82...
Quoted text (20 lines)> Exactly, so any league coudl do the same with any sim, whic hwas my > orginal point. > > "Dirt" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > On Oct 22, 10:57 am, "schooner" <[email hidden]> wrote: > >> What makes iRacing the defacto standard and authority for handing out >> such a >> title? Just curious. > > They can use "world" because anybody from any country in the world > with an internet connection can join. They can use "champion" because > they hold structured competitions intended to crown a series > champion. Technically there's nothing wrong with a "world champion" > claim because it's true; a series champion can come from anywhere in > the world. Even if another sim starts a "world championship" that > doesn't invalidate the truth of iRacing's claim because I doubt > iRacing have specifically claimed to have the ONLY world champion, > just A world champion.
Back to the original topic, I got my wireless adapter and XP recognized the 360 wheel and it calibrated fine. I dove in and joined iRacing and spend a couple of hours with it last night. To my relief, everything installed smoothly and there were no problems. The base program was two downloads totaling ~750 meg! I let it auto-config and I'm seeing a steady 50 fps at 1280x1024 resolution with pretty good graphics. I'm not sure what is being left out because I haven't explored the graphics options yet. I drove Sebring and there weren't any grandstands along the pit straight, so I think some of the track side objects are turned off. I may knock the resolution down tonight and see if I can improve the fps a bit and add a few more track side objects. The little bit of driving I've done has me somewhat, <thinks a minute> not disappointed, but just not as impressed as I was hoping. It's not that anything is wrong, it's just that I suspect I had my expectations set a little too high. It feels like NR2003 and, to a lesser extent GPL, only with better graphics and a little more refinement from the driving model. I'm not sure exactly what I was expecting so I'll refrain from saying anything bad because it wouldn't be fair to criticize it for my own failings. One bit of disappointment is that the 360 wheel doesn't have any force feedback and the force feedback box is grayed out in the control config screen. Other than that it works brilliantly. I'll have to check into it tonight to see if I've mis-configured something or if it just isn't supported by a PC the way I'm using it. I haven't searched the menu system enough to find a rookie session that allows me to drive against others. I skipped most of the intro reading because I was anxious to drive a bit before bed time, so I've nobody but myself to blame. -Dirt-

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy