Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Re: What did Ed Martin say?

33 posts by 17 people · 19 Nov 2000 - 25 Nov 2000

Debate over Ed Martin leaving r.a.s.

Users asked what Hasbro's Ed Martin had said to cause a backlash, and his last post and the replies were quoted. Many defended him as a dedicated developer driven away by abuse, as Papyrus staff had been, while others said his reply was out of line. The discussion also covered NASCAR Heat's lack of online yellow flags and pit-stop AI problems.

community/metaindustry/businessNASCAR Heat

Automated summary.

(unknown) 19 Nov 2000#220439
I saw this one too, Jim. Didn't think it was all that harsh. They didn't want to hear what he had to say, so they bounced him. It's THEIR board, it's their call. That's why RAS is a public board. Granted, I think NHeat fell WAY short of the mark overall, though the graphics and physics are lovely. The first time I had an AI car plow into me under yellow during a full race, I had a feeling the sim wouldn't last long on my HDD. It's an intelligent move to alienate the developers who actually show the intitiative to come out here and contribute, that way fewer will do it in the future! I think we should all head over and bash the Wests because they have not yet offered up a functional demo!! (I'm kidding, in case Chris or Tony happen to read this. ::)) In article <7USR5.102494$[email hidden]>, "Jim Dombrowski" <[email hidden]> wrote: > This is the only thing I could find. All problems with the gameaside, I'm > glad I'm not in his shoes. People expect him to just eat all theinsults > thrown at him because of his position and not ever say anythingback. If it > was me, I would have probably lost it a long time ago and told em allto
Quoted text (7 lines)> fuck off. > > Jim D. > > "Fenech" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:ZspJ5.21382$[email hidden]... > > Seeing that this post got deleted from the Nascar Heat official
board > since > > Hasbro will not post anything with the truth, I will post it here. > > ... > > The officail Nascar Heat board is a joke. anything you postsaying > > anything negative about the game, just gets deleted. Try it. Theydon't
Quoted text (7 lines)> > want anyone to know the truth over there. > > > > Matt > > > > > > Actually, Matt, we don't have a problem at all with "negative" posts
and we > especially encourage the truth. What we do have a problem with off-topic, > counter-productive and inflammatory posts over on the NASCAR Heatforum > (http://www.nascarheat.com). Unfortunately, your postings over theretended > to fit into that category of stuff that we won't put up with so someof your > posts got deleted and your ID over there is now banned & gagged. > > The Heat forum is a moderated forum, Matt. So while the truth iswelcome, > your style & attitude were not, and in a moderated forum, we are ableto
Quoted text (8 lines)> handle that. Sorry if that truth hurts. > > --ed. > > [email hidden] wrote in message <8v8rl7$fai$[email hidden]>... > >I must have missed something, as I haven't been following the NASCAR > >Heat stuff very closely. I have read that Ed Martin said some > >offensive things on the NG, but a search didn't find much that I
would
Quoted text (8 lines)> >deem offensive? Can someone point me toward the specific thread or > >paraphrase the comments? Grazie. > > > > > >Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > >Before you buy. > >
Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
(unknown) 19 Nov 2000#220579
I must have missed something, as I haven't been following the NASCAR Heat stuff very closely. I have read that Ed Martin said some offensive things on the NG, but a search didn't find much that I would deem offensive? Can someone point me toward the specific thread or paraphrase the comments? Grazie. Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
Jim Dombrowski 19 Nov 2000 16:06 UTC#220580
This is the only thing I could find. All problems with the game aside, I'm glad I'm not in his shoes. People expect him to just eat all the insults thrown at him because of his position and not ever say anything back. If it was me, I would have probably lost it a long time ago and told em all to fuck off. Jim D. "Fenech" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:ZspJ5.21382$[email hidden]... > Seeing that this post got deleted from the Nascar Heat official boardsince
Quoted text (9 lines)> Hasbro will not post anything with the truth, I will post it here. > ... > The officail Nascar Heat board is a joke. anything you post saying > anything negative about the game, just gets deleted. Try it. They don't > want anyone to know the truth over there. > > Matt > >
Actually, Matt, we don't have a problem at all with "negative" posts and we especially encourage the truth. What we do have a problem with off-topic, counter-productive and inflammatory posts over on the NASCAR Heat forum (http://www.nascarheat.com). Unfortunately, your postings over there tended to fit into that category of stuff that we won't put up with so some of your posts got deleted and your ID over there is now banned & gagged. The Heat forum is a moderated forum, Matt. So while the truth is welcome, your style & attitude were not, and in a moderated forum, we are able to handle that. Sorry if that truth hurts. --ed. [email hidden] wrote in message <8v8rl7$fai$[email hidden]>...
Quoted text (9 lines)>I must have missed something, as I haven't been following the NASCAR >Heat stuff very closely. I have read that Ed Martin said some >offensive things on the NG, but a search didn't find much that I would >deem offensive? Can someone point me toward the specific thread or >paraphrase the comments? Grazie. > > >Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ >Before you buy.
Scott 19 Nov 2000 23:42 UTC#220482
Here's what he said, I still can't believe it. It is the last post he has made on this newsgroup ever. There were at least 15 replies to Ed that told him he made a poor reply and asking for an apology. He never apologized. Someone asked the people on this newsgroup if they saw a message from DanHasbro on the NHeat forum. He was looking for opinions on this newsgroup. Ed ripped into him, asking why he would come to this newsgroup and talk about what is being said on another web board. He asked why people on rec.autos.sims would talk about Nascar Heat on this forum, he said the r.a.s. people are here and the NHeat people are there, and that we shouldn't talk about what's going on in the other forums LOL!!! A couple of people asked Ed why HE comes to this newsgroup to answer questions, if he says OTHER people shouldn't do it. Hypocrite indeed. "Ed Martin" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:6ZgL5.1135$[email hidden]... > Matt, > > Exactly what is the point of asking people in this forum if they read a > thread in the NASCAR Heat forum? Last time I checked, rec.autos.simsfolks > were here and NASCAR Heat forum folks were there. Sure, a lot of people > read both by why would you expect commentary in this forum for thingstalked > about in another forum? Perhaps we should start posting here in RAS about > things in all the other news groups? > > > <[email hidden]> wrote in messagenews:8tj6ls$t60$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (20 lines)> > Did anyone see the post on Hasbro's board where someone just asked a > > simple question "Why was Nascar heat released the way it was, with > > uplayable yellow flags (laps lasting forever, cars ramming you). Even > > with the patch there are still numerous problems. > > Anyway, Dan from Hasbro answered by saying "None of the problems were > > seen in testing" > > Excuse me? Anyone who bought this game saw them within 10 minutes of > > playing. > > Then he defends the Beta Testers by saying that everone makes > > mistakes. > > The game was released unfinished and Hasbro knew it. They just > > wanted to get the game out by the end of Nascar season and beat Nascar > > 4 to market (Which at the time was sceduled for a November release) > > And Hasbro, when using Beta Testers, don't use the same testers who > > test Frogger 1 and 2 for you. Look for real Beta Testers who know a > > little about racing sims. > > > > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > > Before you buy.
Dave Henrie 19 Nov 2000 23:51 UTC#220481
Hey I have NO Problem with what Ed said. We only saw the last bit of a long running series of messages from the Hasbro forum and RAS. The pressures we apply to developers and the exterior pressure applied by publishers (hasbro) can be tremendous. I don't expect everyone to be Prince Charming all of the time. I feel the yellow problem is a major stumbling block to NH but I still enjoy it's racing online...(when I shuttup enough here to get online...) seeya. dave henrie <
Scott 19 Nov 2000 23:54 UTC#220484
Here were some of the replies to Ed: -------------------------------------------------------------------- "Last time I checked this was : Rec auto Simulators, but then again Nascar Heat in its present state would not qualify to be subject matter of the newsgroup." --------------------------------------------------------------------- "Then what exactly are you doing here Ed ???? He posted about Heat and you replied. If it's not necessary to post about heat here then I ask again what are you doing here. I haven't posted anything about Heat since I took it back and got my refund, but If I were to post it somewhere it would be on topic here. I see nothing wrong with posting info from one forum to the next if it's on topic. I believe that you once again didn't like the way Hasbro is being portrayed and you once again in desperation are trying to defend the BS Hasbro pulled on us. This time it appears to be with a cheap shot at the original poster for posting something from one forum to another. IT'S ON TOPIC if you don't like people reading negatively into your post over there then one word for ya "Proofread" , Your reply is so silly it's pathetic. " -------------------------------------------------------------- "I'm sorry Ed, but that was a stupid reply. This is a racing newsgroup, and he was discussing an issue that came up elsewhere. I look at you in a different light now. :(" ------------------------------------------------------------- "Wow Ed. Just wow. Very poor reply." ------------------------------------------------------------- "You're right Ed, Nascar Heat DEFINATELY should not be discussed in a simulator newsgroup. Does rec.autos.arcade even exist yet? By the way Ed, that was a shitty way to reply.....in case you havn't been able to tell that yet. This is a racing newsgroup, it belongs here as much as GPL, Nascar 3, GP3, or any other racing game." ------------------------------------------------------------ "Your correct Mr Martin, maybe we shoud start bringing items from other forums to here. I'll be right back with some news from the <comp.hasbro-employees.ed.martin.is.an.a-hole> newsgroup as soon as possible!" ------------------------------------------------------------ "Well, I thought you were a pretty straight-up guy, Ed, but this non-reply seems to indicate otherwise. You've been posting in RAS for months, specifically on the subject of NH, so why should the post to which you refer be some sort of surprise to you?" ----------------------------------------------------------- "You can't have it both ways: if you're going to maintain a presence in the newsgroup, you're going to get questions about your product -- isn't that the point? Or is the point to make it *look* like Hasbro actually cares about the people who buy their product, without having the hassle of actually making the product work like it *ought* to work?" ------------------------------------------------------------- "The reason for posting here is because you can say what you want and not get it deleted..." ------------------------------------------------------------- "Oops...bad reply, Ed. But you seem like a straight-up guy, so I'll assume you are just having a bad day. We all do sometimes."
Scott 19 Nov 2000 23:56 UTC#220485
That's not it, see above. "Dave Henrie" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:RHZR5.48815$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (12 lines)> Hey I have NO Problem with what Ed said. We only saw the last bit of a > long running series of messages from the Hasbro forum and RAS. The > pressures we apply to developers and the exterior pressure applied by > publishers (hasbro) can be tremendous. I don't expect everyone to be > Prince Charming all of the time. > I feel the yellow problem is a major stumbling block to NH but I still > enjoy it's racing online...(when I shuttup enough here to get online...) > seeya. > dave henrie > < > >
EldredP 20 Nov 2000#220255
In article <zDaS5.1288$[email hidden]>, "GTX_SlotCar" <[email hidden]> writes: >As far as I know, a second patch is still forthcoming and it will address a >lot of the issues left with NH. The exception being there will still be no >yellow flags in multi-player. I realize this is important to some people, >but it could be the only real fault left in the game. Does it just have problems, or not exist at ALL? I haven't run multiplayer yet... Eldred -- Tiger Stadium R.I.P. 1912-1999 Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett GPL hcp. +49.12 Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
(unknown) 20 Nov 2000 00:53 UTC#220405
I read Ed's comments and didn't think much of it. Wasn't aware it created such a stir with everyone. He was probably frustrated and gave up hope of making everyone happy. Personally, I think GP3 was a bigger insult to the gaming community than NASCAR Heat. GP3 was a BARELY rehashed version of a sim that was already four years out of date. If you ask me, THAT was inexcusable. We should have all gone screaming for Geoff Crammond's head as well. There's no doubt NHeat has problems...I no longer have it installed on my machine, but I think the last thing we should do is alienate developers even when they DO say something objectionable, so long as they have shown a genuine concern for the sim-racing community. There are not that many companies developing racing simulations, so we should do what we can to keep the ones who do. In article <LKZR5.9931$[email hidden]>, "Scott" <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (9 lines)> Here were some of the replies to Ed: > > -------------------------------------------------------------------- > "Last time I checked this was : Rec auto Simulators, but then > again Nascar Heat in its present state would not qualify to > be subject matter of the newsgroup." > > --------------------------------------------------------------------- > "Then what exactly are you doing here Ed ???? He posted about Heat
and you > replied. If it's not necessary to post about heat here then I askagain > what are you doing here. I haven't posted anything about Heat since Itook > it back and got my refund, but If I were to post it somewhere itwould be on > topic here. I see nothing wrong with posting info from one forum tothe next > if it's on topic. I believe that you once again didn't like the wayHasbro > is being portrayed and you once again in desperation are trying todefend > the BS Hasbro pulled on us. This time it appears to be with a cheapshot at > the original poster for posting something from one forum to another.IT'S > ON TOPIC if you don't like people reading negatively into your postover > there then one word for ya "Proofread" , Your reply is so silly it's > pathetic. " > > -------------------------------------------------------------- > "I'm sorry Ed, but that was a stupid reply. This is a racingnewsgroup, and
Quoted text (9 lines)> he was discussing an issue that came up elsewhere. I look at you in a > different light now. :(" > > ------------------------------------------------------------- > "Wow Ed. Just wow. Very poor reply." > > ------------------------------------------------------------- > "You're right Ed, Nascar Heat DEFINATELY should not be discussed in a > simulator newsgroup. Does rec.autos.arcade even exist yet? By the
way Ed, > that was a shitty way to reply.....in case you havn't been able totell that > yet. This is a racing newsgroup, it belongs here as much as GPL,Nascar 3, > GP3, or any other racing game." > > ------------------------------------------------------------ > "Your correct Mr Martin, maybe we shoud start bringing items fromother
Quoted text (8 lines)> forums to here. I'll be right back with some news from the > <comp.hasbro-employees.ed.martin.is.an.a-hole> newsgroup as soon as > possible!" > > ------------------------------------------------------------ > "Well, I thought you were a pretty straight-up guy, Ed, but this > non-reply seems to indicate otherwise. You've been posting in RAS for > months, specifically on the subject of NH, so why should the post to
which > you refer be some sort of surprise to you?" > > ----------------------------------------------------------- > "You can't have it both ways: if you're going to maintain a presencein the > newsgroup, you're going to get questions about your product -- isn'tthat > the point? Or is the point to make it *look* like Hasbro actuallycares > about the people who buy their product, without having the hassle of > actually making the product work like it *ought* to work?" > > ------------------------------------------------------------- > "The reason for posting here is because you can say what you want andnot > get it deleted..." > > ------------------------------------------------------------- > "Oops...bad reply, Ed. But you seem like a straight-up guy, so I'llassume > you are just having a bad day. We all do sometimes." > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
ymenard 20 Nov 2000 02:35 UTC#220416
"Dave Henrie" <[email hidden]> wrote > The pressures we apply to developers and the exterior pressure applied by > publishers (hasbro) can be tremendous. Oh please, they are NOT a martyr. -- -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> -- May the Downforce be with you... -- http://www.WeRace.net -- People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world.
><[email hidden]> wrote > Personally, I think GP3 was a bigger insult to the gaming community > than NASCAR Heat. Geoff Crammond would never have the guts to show himself in a public newsgroup for the horror he has created with GP3 (and at some extent GP2 which back in the days was raved but also hated). NH is years ahead of GP3 even if it has major problems. In fact, you never see him doing much interviews or pictures of him. He keeps himself quiet. As much as in the gaming industry he is known to be an incredible programmer, he is also known to have no clue about the gaming business. I'll always give credits to MGI for at least facing the problems, even if at one moment they just dissapeared. > There's no doubt NHeat has problems...I no longer have it installed on > my machine, but I think the last thing we should do is alienate > developers even when they DO say something objectionable, so long as > they have shown a genuine concern for the sim-racing community. Both sides are at fault with NH, compared to GP3 which only Geoff is at fault. Still, the problem resides in the fact that MGI didn't cared much about multiplayer and the AI problems. You do your racing against either one of those (human or AI), so such problem is evidently enhanced even if minor. -- -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> -- May the Downforce be with you... -- http://www.WeRace.net -- People think it must be fun to be a super genius, but they don't realise how hard it is to put up with all the idiots in the world.
CK 20 Nov 2000 03:37 UTC#220419
One less developer around this shitty ol' newsgroup. Enjoy!
Rod Prince 20 Nov 2000 04:55 UTC#220425
In article <7AZR5.9928$[email hidden]>, [email hidden] says... > Here's what he said, I still can't believe it. It is the last post he has > made on this newsgroup ever. There were at least 15 replies to Ed that told > him he made a poor reply and asking for an apology. He never apologized. Seemed like a dedicated developer who took pride in a product his team produced who got ripped into by people who didn't care for the product, and the inevitable frustration caused by those who yell far and wide about it. Believe it or not, some of us actually enjoy the game, You can't please everyone all of the time, and it was a given that not everyone who purchased the product would like the product, but the scrutiny that software is put under often travels well beyond the absurd. NH, comparitively speaking, is a very cheap piece of entertainment software. I'll pay near half the price to take my partner to a 2hr flick and stock up on munchees, and if the movie is a stinker, I have no recourse to get my money back, yet my reaction isn't to immediately jump on the net and rag on it. Over the years, those that produce entertainment software are in a position where they're 'damned if they do or damned if they don't'. Offhand, I can't think of any other facet of the entertainment industry who get ragged on more than software developers. However, I doubt you'll see either an apology or another post from Ed in here, and quite frankly, I don't blame him. Cheers, Rod.
I agree, Ed has taken a beating here. The night the first patch came out, I lashed out at him in a post. After reading that post the next day I apologized and re-wrote the it with a more constructive tone. After seeing the beating Ed has taken since, it makes me regret my original post even more. As far as I know, a second patch is still forthcoming and it will address a lot of the issues left with NH. The exception being there will still be no yellow flags in multi-player. I realize this is important to some people, but it could be the only real fault left in the game. Off hand, I can't think of any other game that I can honestly say only has one major fault. -- Slot Tweaks & Reviews www.slottweak.com "Rod Prince" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:MPG.1483596d640a030d98975c@news-server... > In article <7AZR5.9928$[email hidden]>, [email hidden] says... > > Here's what he said, I still can't believe it. It is the last post he has > > made on this newsgroup ever. There were at least 15 replies to Ed that told > > him he made a poor reply and asking for an apology. He never apologized. > > Seemed like a dedicated developer who took pride in a product his team > produced who got ripped into by people who didn't care for the product, > and the inevitable frustration caused by those who yell far and wide > about it. Believe it or not, some of us actually enjoy the game, > > You can't please everyone all of the time, and it was a given that not > everyone who purchased the product would like the product, but the > scrutiny that software is put under often travels well beyond the absurd. > > NH, comparitively speaking, is a very cheap piece of entertainment > software. I'll pay near half the price to take my partner to a 2hr > flick and stock up on munchees, and if the movie is a stinker, I have > no recourse to get my money back, yet my reaction isn't to immediately > jump on the net and rag on it. Over the years, those that produce > entertainment software are in a position where they're 'damned if they > do or damned if they don't'. > > Offhand, I can't think of any other facet of the entertainment industry > who get ragged on more than software developers. However, I doubt you'll see > either an apology or another post from Ed in here, and quite frankly, I don't > blame him. > > Cheers, > Rod.
And to add to Slot's post... Ed has said more than once that the Multiplayer issues will not be solved until licensing with Nascar for Multiplayer is resolved. There is only so much they could do with Multiplayer without the proper licensing from Nascar. I have a feeling this is one of the reasons N4 was delayed. At least 3 companies (MGI/Hasbro, Papyrus/Sierra/Havas, and EA Sports) are trying to nail down some kind of licensing agreement from Nascar for Multiplayer. What we're talking about here is something like TEN was, I think. From what I understand, the AI will be improved in the upcoming patch, as well as improved damage model. Ed has said several times that the save game option will not be added as it's not feasible with the advanced physics model that Heat obviously has. This is probably the same reason why GPL didn't have a save game, and why you shouldn't be expecting it in N4. <venting>... MGI/Hasbro could have very easily left out the awesome physics model in Heat, gotten the game out sooner with less bugs, still sold a bundle, and probably made a better profit. Just look at the list of hosted races on IRF some time and see how many "normal" mode races there are. Also, think about EA Sports Nascar series, how aradish it is, and how much money they're obviously making by their continued support and release of new versions. Developers like MGI and Papyrus have a love for sims like we do. Yet most of us continue to bash them after releases of new products because the sim portions of their racing titles just aren't perfect enough. The developers even show their good will by releasing patches and corresponding with us sim'ers on forums and such... and what do they get in return? more and even harsher bashing. If you want a perfect driving experience... get in your Honda Accord, wind it out as fast as she'll go, drive into that turn as fast as she'll go basically driving like you do in your favorite sim, wrap it around that telephone pole or tree and crawl your lazy ass out of the pile of junk you just created and think about how much fun you just had... if you're still alive. Papyrus and MGI really are trying to make good racing sims for us. But they also have to make money to stay in business and that means meeting deadlines, making trade-offs for options in the game, etc... The only developer I know of that has, and is using, the luxury of taking their time in creating a racing sim is the West Bros and their creation of World Sports Cars. Will it be perfect and without bugs? No... no complex gaming software is without bugs. Will they add every option that every one of us wants? Doubful. Will people bash them for not putting out a perfect game with every option they wanted? Yes. It's truly sad, but people just think since they paid $30-$50 for a CD with a game on it that it should be perfect, yet they can't honestly say they've ever bought the perfect car/house where nothing ever went wrong with them yet they spent tens to hundreds of thousands of dollars on. Before you whine... think! If you want to report bugs or have suggestions for what you'd like to see in a game, then report the information to the developer through the proper forum in a courteous manner. Being rude and obnoxious only makes you look like a driveling whiner with no class. </venting> Personally, I can't wait for the NH release patch, N4, NH2, etc..... I love these sims because they help me live my dream without the danger of being in a real car. It's called entertainment, rarely perfect but almost always entertaining... :-) Dave Ericson "MomoBoy" JDB Racing <frantically trying to find flame suit> GTX_SlotCar wrote:
Quoted text (55 lines)> > I agree, Ed has taken a beating here. The night the first patch came out, I > lashed out at him in a post. After reading that post the next day I > apologized and re-wrote the it with a more constructive tone. After seeing > the beating Ed has taken since, it makes me regret my original post even > more. > As far as I know, a second patch is still forthcoming and it will address a > lot of the issues left with NH. The exception being there will still be no > yellow flags in multi-player. I realize this is important to some people, > but it could be the only real fault left in the game. Off hand, I can't > think of any other game that I can honestly say only has one major fault. > > -- > Slot > > Tweaks & Reviews > www.slottweak.com > > "Rod Prince" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:MPG.1483596d640a030d98975c@news-server... > > In article <7AZR5.9928$[email hidden]>, > [email hidden] says... > > > Here's what he said, I still can't believe it. It is the last post he > has > > > made on this newsgroup ever. There were at least 15 replies to Ed that > told > > > him he made a poor reply and asking for an apology. He never > apologized. > > > > Seemed like a dedicated developer who took pride in a product his team > > produced who got ripped into by people who didn't care for the product, > > and the inevitable frustration caused by those who yell far and wide > > about it. Believe it or not, some of us actually enjoy the game, > > > > You can't please everyone all of the time, and it was a given that not > > everyone who purchased the product would like the product, but the > > scrutiny that software is put under often travels well beyond the absurd. > > > > NH, comparitively speaking, is a very cheap piece of entertainment > > software. I'll pay near half the price to take my partner to a 2hr > > flick and stock up on munchees, and if the movie is a stinker, I have > > no recourse to get my money back, yet my reaction isn't to immediately > > jump on the net and rag on it. Over the years, those that produce > > entertainment software are in a position where they're 'damned if they > > do or damned if they don't'. > > > > Offhand, I can't think of any other facet of the entertainment industry > > who get ragged on more than software developers. However, I doubt you'll > see > > either an apology or another post from Ed in here, and quite frankly, I > don't > > blame him. > > > > Cheers, > > Rod.
"David R. Ericson" wrote:
Quoted text (7 lines)> > and even harsher bashing. If you want a perfect driving experience... get > in your Honda Accord, wind it out as fast as she'll go, drive into that turn > as fast as she'll go basically driving like you do in your favorite sim, wrap > it around that telephone pole or tree and crawl your lazy ass out of the pile > of junk you just created and think about how much fun you just had... if > you're still alive.
OK, after reading this part of the post, I admit this was a bad example. We're all allowed one brain fart a day... right? ;-)
here here well said Rod, Slot and David ... my sentiments exactly. Shane David R. Ericson <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > And to add to Slot's post... Ed has said more than once that theMultiplayer > issues will not be solved until licensing with Nascar for Multiplayer is > resolved. There is only so much they could do with Multiplayer withoutthe
Quoted text (7 lines)> proper licensing from Nascar. I have a feeling this is one of the > reasons N4 was delayed. At least 3 companies (MGI/Hasbro, > Papyrus/Sierra/Havas, and EA Sports) are trying to nail down some kind of > licensing agreement from Nascar for Multiplayer. What we're talking about > here is something like TEN was, I think. > > From what I understand, the AI will be improved in the upcoming patch, as
well > as improved damage model. Ed has said several times that the save gameoption > will not be added as it's not feasible with the advanced physics modelthat > Heat obviously has. This is probably the same reason why GPL didn't havea > save game, and why you shouldn't be expecting it in N4. > > <venting>... MGI/Hasbro could have very easily left out the awesome > physics model in Heat, gotten the game out sooner with less bugs, stillsold > a bundle, and probably made a better profit. Just look at the list ofhosted > races on IRF some time and see how many "normal" mode races there are.Also, > think about EA Sports Nascar series, how aradish it is, and how much money > they're obviously making by their continued support and release of new > versions. Developers like MGI and Papyrus have a love for sims like wedo. > Yet most of us continue to bash them after releases of new productsbecause > the sim portions of their racing titles just aren't perfect enough. The > developers even show their good will by releasing patches andcorresponding > with us sim'ers on forums and such... and what do they get in return?more > and even harsher bashing. If you want a perfect driving experience... get > in your Honda Accord, wind it out as fast as she'll go, drive into thatturn > as fast as she'll go basically driving like you do in your favorite sim,wrap > it around that telephone pole or tree and crawl your lazy ass out of thepile > of junk you just created and think about how much fun you just had... if > you're still alive. > > Papyrus and MGI really are trying to make good racing sims for us. Butthey > also have to make money to stay in business and that means meetingdeadlines, > making trade-offs for options in the game, etc... The only developer Iknow > of that has, and is using, the luxury of taking their time in creating a > racing sim is the West Bros and their creation of World Sports Cars. Willit > be perfect and without bugs? No... no complex gaming software is withoutbugs. > Will they add every option that every one of us wants? Doubful. Willpeople > bash them for not putting out a perfect game with every option theywanted? > Yes. It's truly sad, but people just think since they paid $30-$50 for aCD > with a game on it that it should be perfect, yet they can't honestly say > they've ever bought the perfect car/house where nothing ever went wrongwith
Quoted text (9 lines)> them yet they spent tens to hundreds of thousands of dollars on. > > Before you whine... think! If you want to report bugs or have suggestions > for what you'd like to see in a game, then report the information to the > developer through the proper forum in a courteous manner. Being rude and > obnoxious only makes you look like a driveling whiner with no class. > </venting> > > Personally, I can't wait for the NH release patch, N4, NH2, etc..... I
love > these sims because they help me live my dream without the danger of beingin
Quoted text (13 lines)> a real car. It's called entertainment, rarely perfect but almost > always entertaining... :-) > > Dave Ericson > "MomoBoy" > JDB Racing > > <frantically trying to find flame suit> > > > GTX_SlotCar wrote: > > > > I agree, Ed has taken a beating here. The night the first patch came
out, I > > lashed out at him in a post. After reading that post the next day I > > apologized and re-wrote the it with a more constructive tone. Afterseeing > > the beating Ed has taken since, it makes me regret my original post even > > more. > > As far as I know, a second patch is still forthcoming and it willaddress a > > lot of the issues left with NH. The exception being there will still beno > > yellow flags in multi-player. I realize this is important to somepeople, > > but it could be the only real fault left in the game. Off hand, I can't > > think of any other game that I can honestly say only has one majorfault.
Quoted text (12 lines)> > > > -- > > Slot > > > > Tweaks & Reviews > > www.slottweak.com > > > > "Rod Prince" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:MPG.1483596d640a030d98975c@news-server... > > > In article <7AZR5.9928$[email hidden]>, > > [email hidden] says... > > > > Here's what he said, I still can't believe it. It is the last post
he > > has > > > > made on this newsgroup ever. There were at least 15 replies to Edthat > > told > > > > him he made a poor reply and asking for an apology. He never > > apologized. > > > > > > Seemed like a dedicated developer who took pride in a product his team > > > produced who got ripped into by people who didn't care for theproduct, > > > and the inevitable frustration caused by those who yell far and wide > > > about it. Believe it or not, some of us actually enjoy the game, > > > > > > You can't please everyone all of the time, and it was a given that not > > > everyone who purchased the product would like the product, but the > > > scrutiny that software is put under often travels well beyond theabsurd.
Quoted text (10 lines)> > > > > > NH, comparitively speaking, is a very cheap piece of entertainment > > > software. I'll pay near half the price to take my partner to a 2hr > > > flick and stock up on munchees, and if the movie is a stinker, I have > > > no recourse to get my money back, yet my reaction isn't to immediately > > > jump on the net and rag on it. Over the years, those that produce > > > entertainment software are in a position where they're 'damned if they > > > do or damned if they don't'. > > > > > > Offhand, I can't think of any other facet of the entertainment
industry > > > who get ragged on more than software developers. However, I doubtyou'll > > see > > > either an apology or another post from Ed in here, and quite frankly,I > > don't > > > blame him. > > > > > > Cheers, > > > Rod.
Brilliant. My thoughts exactly. :) -- ------------------------------------- Morgan Vincent Wooten GPLRank: +15.49 http://home.earthlink.net/~morganv00/ ------------------------------------- "David R. Ericson" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > And to add to Slot's post... Ed has said more than once that the Multiplayer [] > a real car. It's called entertainment, rarely perfect but almost > always entertaining... :-) > > Dave Ericson > "MomoBoy" > JDB Racing > > <frantically trying to find flame suit> >
Larry 20 Nov 2000 23:47 UTC↳ reply to CK#220298
Which is EXACTLY the problem... These guys take the time to come here and talk with the people buying the game, and they aren't shown the slightest shred of respect. Why the hell would _any_ of them bother... I wouldn't blame them if they never posted again. The Nascar Heat team really broke the mold when it came to communicating with their users, and in return they got the shit beat out of themselves online. It's pathetic. -Larry "blah" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]... > One less developer around this shitty ol' newsgroup. Enjoy!
>Ah... but you don't see Papy posting in here and communicating with ussim racing addicts on a regular basis, now do you? Why? Because of the flammers who couldn't give constructive criticism in a polite manner. Papy reacted the SAME way. The finger seems to be pointing to RAS, don't you think? They can police their own forums, but there is no way to police RAS so why take the abuse that absolutely no one deserves? < No, I don't. But so what? Surely you don't expect RAS to be some guiding light for developer help, etc., with no flaming, etc.? It never has been, nor will be such. It can't be expected to be such, as a public forum used by so many people. In answer, the developers do what they do; make their own moderated forums, which if how it should be. They then have "their" place, the public has theirs, if you will. RAS is a PUBLIC forum to talk ABOUT auto sims. Not a "Developer A, how are you today, here's how to make you sim better" forum. It never was intended to be that, nor should never be expected to be such. Not with the wide number of people, interests, age level, etc. that visit it. If someone wants to constructively help a developer, there's plenty of avenues to do that besides RAS. I agree with your points. That's the main reason I rarely post here, though I've read it for years. :) I just accept RAS for what it is, a public, basically unmoderated forum, good or bad. If there's something else to be done, it can be done elsewhere. -John Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
We should probably remember that a majority of sim-racers are not adults. I believe the last time I read an article on the subject(this goes back at least a couple of years) the *primary* target demo for racing simulations was Males aged 13-30. The immature or even irrational behavior of some is to be expected. Difficulties in dealing with such a wide range of ages in a medium that promotes anonymity and subsequently confrontation shoudl also be expected. My point? I'm 23 and still have my moments of ranting(see some of my posts about GP3 at its launch), so I can only imagine what a kid with his hormones all in a bunch would say. Ed and other developers should keep this in mind. The ignorant and immature should be ignored in favor of the few with something constructive to say. It is certainly easier said than done when you care about your product, but it is a necessity if you are going to bridge the gap and communicate with intelligent people who really care about the hobby. The problems with Heat are glaring, the patch did not fix all of them, but the core of the product was solid and it DID show potential. After paying for a buggy program, we have every right to be upset, but an adult channels that frustration into constructive criticism or he goes home. I do not know what was said on the Heat board, but I'm sure it must have been pretty inflammatory, as Ed was getting reemed on this NG as well, but kept posting anyway. If WSC is not a perfect sim, or N4 has shortcomings, but both show great promise, I only hope the few fools who try to ruin everything for the greater whole keep their mouths shut and leave the developers alone. Of course, we won't see Papy on this NG, as their people were run out of town long ago. In article <7KiS5.917$[email hidden]>, "Larry" <[email hidden]> wrote: > Which is EXACTLY the problem... > > These guys take the time to come here and talk with the people buyingthe
Quoted text (7 lines)> game, and they aren't shown the slightest shred of respect. > > Why the hell would _any_ of them bother... > > I wouldn't blame them if they never posted again. > > The Nascar Heat team really broke the mold when it came to
communicating > with their users, and in return they got the shit beat out ofthemselves
Quoted text (11 lines)> online. > > It's pathetic. > > -Larry > > "blah" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:[email hidden]... > > One less developer around this shitty ol' newsgroup. Enjoy! > >
Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
Well, with all due respect, Ed was WAY out of line, period. Also, this line about, "Don't pick on the poor developers, we won't have any racing sims, etc." is off base, IMO. that kind of thinking directly contributes to some of the problems in the industry, IMO. Getting unnecessary flak(and some of it definately is), is now, and always has been part of the industry, whether it's a game of checkers or a sim. If a developer can't handle that, get another job. One where I won't be paying his salary for a sub-par product. There's not a business out there that doesn't deal with jerk customers. And in the meantime, someone else will produce the racing sim they abandoned because some posters are just to mean :) Maturity goes both ways; a developer has to have enough to simply ignore those that need it, not add fuel to the fire. Heat was released/still is with GLARING problems, both for off and online. If you truly believe none of the testing showed this, I have a bridge to sell you :) Think about that next time some other developer is slammed for, ahem, questionable marketing. Patches are to fix bugs. A bug is something already in the game not functioning correctly. A total omission of something is not a bug, nor is a patch to add it great customer service; that's called living up to your obligations. Question: If EA released a game that had no save feature, massive pc requirements, massive yellow flag problems, rolling starts, canned aspects, and negligable online use, no AI wrecks/breakdowns, this place would be yelling as usual. They did/have of course, so why not the same for Heat, which was released, and basically still is, problem wise, just like NR, N2000, etc. Funny that for some reason Hasbro was treated different. Just my .02. I don't feel a bit sorry for Hasbro/Ed. Not that any flaming posts were "right", but it's part of the job. Don't like it, find another. Same thing happened to Papy/EA. They're far from quitting. -John Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
GTX_SlotCar 21 Nov 2000 01:01 UTC#220306
As far as I know, Eldred, it has no yellow flags at all in multi-player. -- Slot www.slottweak.com Tweaks & Reviews > > Does it just have problems, or not exist at ALL? I haven't run multiplayer > yet... > > Eldred > -- > Tiger Stadium R.I.P. 1912-1999 > Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett > GPL hcp. +49.12 > > Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you > with experience... > Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Rogers 21 Nov 2000 05:58 UTC↳ reply to CK#220317
"> These guys take the time to come here and talk with the people buying the > game, and they aren't shown the slightest shred of respect. They come here for marketing purposes. Respect is earned.
Rod Prince 21 Nov 2000 06:54 UTC↳ reply to CK#220215
In article <kaoS5.509$[email hidden]>, [email hidden] says... > > "> These guys take the time to come here and talk with the people buying the > > game, and they aren't shown the slightest shred of respect. > > They come here for marketing purposes. Respect is earned. Marketing purposes? How many potential customers of theirs do you actually believe frequent rec.auto.simulators and are swayed by the developer answering questions? Certainly they want to promote their software, but I doubt their presence here sells significantly more product (or even enough for them to justify the cost of them answering anything here) Call me nutty, but I tend to respect others until they give me reason not to, not the other way around. Cheers, Rod.
John, [email hidden] wrote: > ... > Just my .02. I don't feel a bit sorry for Hasbro/Ed. Not that any > flaming posts were "right", but it's part of the job. Don't like it, > find another. > Same thing happened to Papy/EA. They're far from quitting. Ah... but you don't see Papy posting in here and communicating with us sim racing addicts on a regular basis, now do you? Why? Because of the flammers who couldn't give constructive criticism in a polite manner. Papy reacted the SAME way. The finger seems to be pointing to RAS, don't you think? They can police their own forums, but there is no way to police RAS so why take the abuse that absolutely no one deserves? The way I see it, if a game/sim that I bought causes me to want to flame the developer in an immature manner, I should re-think that purchase and just take the game back and/or chalk it up to experience. My point... I should stay away from anything that causes me to react in that manner. This is why I don't particpate in or watch synchronized swimming. Anytime I'm exposed to it I have a very adverse reaction... :-) Personally, I feel MGI/Hasbro did an incredible job with Heat for their first Nascar title. I love it for the sheer pleasure of driving in Hardcore mode and still can't believe they dethroned Papy as the best "driving" Nascar sim to date (for now). The way I see it, they got the core phyics and graphics engine just right. Fine tuning and adding features via the release patch and Heat2 will only make the simulation experience better for me. The driving experience is already spot-on IMHO (try it with a FF wheel and you'll appreciate it even more). As I keep saying (to myself mostly)... I can't wait for the NH release patch, N4 and NH2!! I'm currently having a blast and look forward to the future of sim racing. Dave Ericson "MomoBoy" JDB Racing
GTX_SlotCar 21 Nov 2000 17:17 UTC↳ reply to CK#220091
Just for general information ---(not aimed at maddkap) I think the average age in this newsgroup is somewhere around 33. Old enough to run for President (but not the Senate). Quite a few of us are 50 or more - though we, of course, don't look a day over 35 ;-) As a side note, the average age in the GP3 forum was even higher. I don't really think that 13 year olds are into sim racing too much, more likely they're into arcade games, and they probably have no idea how a real car handles. From emails I've received referring to this newsgroup, I've learned that there is a large, silent following and that many manufacturers also visit almost daily. I'd guess that the population of r.a.s. is about 3000. I don't know how many copies of NH Hasbro intends to sell. I'll figure about 500,000 copies (am I way off)? Maybe half of the r.a.s. readers care about problems with the game. So the hardcore racers here could represent 3/10's of one percent of their sales. Of course, the impact we have is a little more than that because reviewers writing for some of the larger sites also drop in here quite often, and they may be cued to look for problems in a game by the tone of the posts. Less favorable reviews from some of the larger sites may have additional impact on sales. Still, all in all, I can't see it changing sales by more than 5 or 10 thousand copies. Guys like Ed from Hasbro are just regular guys. Everyone has a limit. He started out being very helpful and pleasant. I'm sure the 1st patch for NH was by his recommendation, and I assume the forthcoming patch is also. If his attitude has changed, I think we should ask ourselves why. We can behave any way we please here. When my wife cooks a meal I don't like, I don't tell her it tastes like dog meat. I say, 'well, it's not something I'd want every day'. From now on, if I don't like a game because of it's gameplay, I hope I have the sense to tell the manufacturer that, 'it wasn't quite what I expected'. As far as NH goes, we had a demo, a few reviews, a newsgroup to consult, and a representative that answered our questions honestly before we spent our money. I just can't honestly say, gents, that I feel I was duped into buying this game. There may be things I'd like to see changed, but I still enjoy it a lot. -- Slot Tweaks & Reviews www.slottweak.com
[email hidden] wrote:
Quoted text (26 lines)> > >Ah... but you don't see Papy posting in here and communicating with us > sim racing addicts on a regular basis, now do you? Why? Because of > the flammers who couldn't give constructive criticism in a polite > manner. Papy reacted the SAME way. The finger seems to be pointing to > RAS, don't you think? They can police their own forums, but there is no > way to police RAS so why take the abuse that absolutely no one deserves? > < > > No, I don't. But so what? Surely you don't expect RAS to be some > guiding light for developer help, etc., with no flaming, etc.? > It never has been, nor will be such. It can't be expected to be > such, as a public forum used by so many people. > > In answer, the developers do what they do; make their own moderated > forums, which if how it should be. They then have "their" place, the > public has theirs, if you will. > > RAS is a PUBLIC forum to talk ABOUT auto sims. Not a "Developer A, > how are you today, here's how to make you sim better" forum. It never > was intended to be that, nor should never be expected to be such. > Not with the wide number of people, interests, age level, etc. that > visit it. > > If someone wants to constructively help a developer, there's plenty > of avenues to do that besides RAS.
Good points! Well... so it was an unrealistic wish. I just really like it when developers are in here corresponding closely with us. I still don't like the negative, immature, flaming posts and since this is a public forum I have a right to say so... :-) Was nice discussing this with ya and thanks for doing it at a mature level... it's refreshing around here. Dave
Excellent post Slot! GTX_SlotCar wrote:
Quoted text (44 lines)> > Just for general information ---(not aimed at maddkap) > > I think the average age in this newsgroup is somewhere around 33. Old enough > to run for President (but not the Senate). Quite a few of us are 50 or > more - though we, of course, don't look a day over 35 ;-) As a side note, > the average age in the GP3 forum was even higher. I don't really think that > 13 year olds are into sim racing too much, more likely they're into arcade > games, and they probably have no idea how a real car handles. > From emails I've received referring to this newsgroup, I've learned that > there is a large, silent following and that many manufacturers also visit > almost daily. I'd guess that the population of r.a.s. is about 3000. > > I don't know how many copies of NH Hasbro intends to sell. I'll figure about > 500,000 copies (am I way off)? Maybe half of the r.a.s. readers care about > problems with the game. So the hardcore racers here could represent 3/10's > of one percent of their sales. Of course, the impact we have is a little > more than that because reviewers writing for some of the larger sites also > drop in here quite often, and they may be cued to look for problems in a > game by the tone of the posts. Less favorable reviews from some of the > larger sites may have additional impact on sales. Still, all in all, I can't > see it changing sales by more than 5 or 10 thousand copies. > > Guys like Ed from Hasbro are just regular guys. Everyone has a limit. He > started out being very helpful and pleasant. I'm sure the 1st patch for NH > was by his recommendation, and I assume the forthcoming patch is also. If > his attitude has changed, I think we should ask ourselves why. > > We can behave any way we please here. When my wife cooks a meal I don't > like, I don't tell her it tastes like dog meat. I say, 'well, it's not > something I'd want every day'. From now on, if I don't like a game because > of it's gameplay, I hope I have the sense to tell the manufacturer that, > 'it wasn't quite what I expected'. > > As far as NH goes, we had a demo, a few reviews, a newsgroup to consult, and > a representative that answered our questions honestly before we spent our > money. I just can't honestly say, gents, that I feel I was duped into buying > this game. There may be things I'd like to see changed, but I still enjoy it > a lot. > -- > Slot > > Tweaks & Reviews > www.slottweak.com
Dave Henrie 22 Nov 2000 03:38 UTC↳ reply to CK#220022
"GTX_SlotCar" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:27yS5.1861$[email hidden]...> > As far as NH goes, we had a demo, a few reviews, a newsgroup to consult,and > a representative that answered our questions honestly before we spent our > money. I just can't honestly say, gents, that I feel I was duped intobuying > this game. There may be things I'd like to see changed, but I still enjoyit > a lot. > -- > Slot A good point, we should have all remembered that the serious sim fan was NOT the target audience of Nascar Heat. They told us that prior to releasing the product. We knew the focus of the sim was NOT going to be items that leant themselves to pro-league events. However, the first patch addressed serious sim issues almost exclusively. And what did they get for their efforts? wha wha wha... We need to look at ourselves...if you came up to me on the street and started MOUTHING off complaining about my work, you'd probably see my back immeadiately. But if you came to me with constructive criticism and a non-abusive behaivior, I'd probably be at least willing to listen. I know many of us felt ripped off...well shucks...a little research would have easily saved you the expense. Do developers deserve a free ride here? NO WAY! But do they deserve to be treated with respect? You BETCHA! Just like I expect everyone here to treat each other, even rrevved. dave henrie
Quoted text (7 lines)> A good point, we should have all remembered that the serious sim fan was > NOT the target audience of Nascar Heat. They told us that prior to > releasing the product. We knew the focus of the sim was NOT going to be > items that > leant themselves to pro-league events. However, the first patch addressed > serious sim issues almost exclusively. And what did they get for their > efforts?
Unfortunately, NH is basically unplayable in any race long enough to require a pit stop--or any race that has a caution flag--for *any* player, serious sim fan or otherwise. I've had it shelved for a couple of months and just decided to check back to see if NH's "gamekiller" issues had ever been adequately addressed or were going to be. Guess not. Basically, NH is a "Twinkie". Jerry Morelock

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy