Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

Some wheel questions for the experts here

4 posts by 4 people · 05 Dec 2000 01:28 UTC - 08 Dec 2000 20:59 UTC

Howard Roark 05 Dec 2000 01:28 UTC#217064
The facts: I have an old (almost 3 years) Thrustmaster Nascar Pro wheel, which still works fine. I'm wondering if there is any benefit in moving on to any of the newer wheels on the market today. I have a new PIII-1 GHZ machine, reluctantly running Windows ME. The sims I drive are GPL, some N3, and I anticipate becoming obsessed with F1CS2K. I suppose I'll buy N4 next year. I don't want to spend (read: I'm forbidden from spending by the wife) more than $150. My questions are: 1. Is force feedback alone a good reason to replace the old Thrustmaster? Is FF implemented well in any of the games above? 2. How about non-FF wheels? Are any of them superior enough to my old wheel to warrant replacing it? 3. My old wheel obviously connects via the old gameport. Are the USB wheels any better or worse? 4. I hear good things about the Guillemot Ferrari Wheel, and the Act Labs wheel. Do you think either of these is significantly better than my old Nascar wheel? 5. How about any other suggestions? It would seem most folks don't care for the MS wheels, or the newer Logitech wheel. What about the new Thrustmaster wheels? 6. I've got one of those desks with a 2 inch lip on the front. The clamping mechanism on my old Nascar wheel works fine with. What about the Guillemot or the Act labs, or other wheels? Thanks in advance for any feedback.
On Tue, 05 Dec 2000 01:28:18 GMT, Fountainhead <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (14 lines)>The facts: > >I have an old (almost 3 years) Thrustmaster Nascar Pro wheel, which still >works fine. I'm wondering if there is any benefit in moving on to any of >the newer wheels on the market today. I have a new PIII-1 GHZ machine, >reluctantly running Windows ME. The sims I drive are GPL, some N3, and I >anticipate becoming obsessed with F1CS2K. I suppose I'll buy N4 next >year. I don't want to spend (read: I'm forbidden from spending by the >wife) more than $150. > >My questions are: > >1. Is force feedback alone a good reason to replace the old >Thrustmaster? Is FF implemented well in any of the games above?
uhmmmm...if you have enough cash to buy a wheel without being on water and bread for the next month yeah...it is. Never regreted buying an FF wheel >2. How about non-FF wheels? Are any of them superior enough to my old >wheel to warrant replacing it? There are some very very good and thus expensive normal wheels out there... >3. My old wheel obviously connects via the old gameport. Are the USB >wheels any better or worse? Not sure...never had a wheel hooked up to the gameport... USB sure is handy...if it works(see below) >4. I hear good things about the Guillemot Ferrari Wheel, and the Act >Labs wheel. Do you think either of these is significantly better than my >old Nascar wheel? I have the ferrari wheel. I love how it's build...love the pedals...love the feel..love the strength of the FFB 'engine' One negative i did have to replace the paddles on the wheel...shifters...cause they broke after about a week..ggg..but now it's fine.. Second negative...it seems to have a problem with USB port.. I had mine on the USB port..and it kept suddenly steering right..or losing FF all together in the middle of a race....and my USBport is setup right...no sharing IRQs or conflicts... Guillemot is aware of the problem according to tech help but sofar they haven't solved it it seems...urgh. So now i have it hooked up to the serial port and it works great... >5. How about any other suggestions? It would seem most folks don't care >for the MS wheels, or the newer Logitech wheel. What about the new >Thrustmaster wheels? MS wheel i tried....hated it.. >6. I've got one of those desks with a 2 inch lip on the front. The >clamping mechanism on my old Nascar wheel works fine with. What about the >Guillemot or the Act labs, or other wheels? I can stick about 3 fingers between the clamp and the desk...both vertically and depth wise... So it should probably fit...else you just rip the 2 inch lip of the desk..or grind it off;) To be sure...Just take the measurements to a store and check it out >Thanks in advance for any feedback. good luck Willem
"Fountainhead" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (9 lines)> The facts: > > I have an old (almost 3 years) Thrustmaster Nascar Pro wheel, which still > works fine. I'm wondering if there is any benefit in moving on to any of > the newer wheels on the market today. I have a new PIII-1 GHZ machine, > reluctantly running Windows ME. The sims I drive are GPL, some N3, and I > anticipate becoming obsessed with F1CS2K. I suppose I'll buy N4 next > year. I don't want to spend (read: I'm forbidden from spending by the > wife) more than $150.
I too had a TM NASCAR Pro that suited me just fine but was getting in really ratty shape. I have since bought a LWFF (the all red one) and a TM Nascar Pro digital 1 wheel neither of which has been an entirely satisfactory replacement. > > My questions are: > > 1. Is force feedback alone a good reason to replace the old > Thrustmaster? Is FF implemented well in any of the games above? GPL has good FF implementation as far as feeling what your car is up too ( once you get all the various fiddly settings set where you like them.). Unfortuneately I can't seem to equal my old lap NAS Pro times with the LWFF. FF adds a great deal to the immersiveness of Mobile One Rally Championship though it doesn't really help in feeling what the car is up to. N3 doesn't have really useful FF, IMHO . I could easily enjoy any decent driving sim without FF. > > 2. How about non-FF wheels? Are any of them superior enough to my old > wheel to warrant replacing it? Can't speak for all the wheels but DON'T bother with the TM Pro Digital 1 model no matter how good the price is . Nothing but trouble getting it to recognize split axis pedals and an ugly deadzone right at center that won't go away despite going through every driver the TM site offered. I bought this because it *looked* like an nice USB improvement over the old NASPro and because it was on sale. Regretted it right from the first day. The new TM Pro digital 2 may be an improvement but I'll let someone else go first. > > 3. My old wheel obviously connects via the old gameport. Are the USB > wheels any better or worse? The USB of the LWFF works fine with all the benefits of USB apparent . The USB TM Pro digital 1, on the other hand, is................ :( !
Quoted text (14 lines)> > 4. I hear good things about the Guillemot Ferrari Wheel, and the Act > Labs wheel. Do you think either of these is significantly better than my > old Nascar wheel? > > 5. How about any other suggestions? It would seem most folks don't care > for the MS wheels, or the newer Logitech wheel. What about the new > Thrustmaster wheels? > > 6. I've got one of those desks with a 2 inch lip on the front. The > clamping mechanism on my old Nascar wheel works fine with. What about the > Guillemot or the Act labs, or other wheels? > > Thanks in advance for any feedback.
In retrospect I kind of wish I'd just sprung for one of Thomas Enterprises little jewels. Probably wouldn't have totalled up to much more than what I've spent chaseing rainbows and probably a lot less frustrating. A little over your $150 limit but maybe if you were *really* nice to her ( read : kiss up bigtime :) ) she'll cut you some slack. Hey Christmas is coming! David >
Hello, FYI, the ACT LABS clamps will work over a desk as thick as 1 3/4 inches. Raymond ACT LABS www.act-labs.com On Tue, 05 Dec 2000 01:28:18 GMT, Fountainhead <[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (35 lines)>The facts: > >I have an old (almost 3 years) Thrustmaster Nascar Pro wheel, which still >works fine. I'm wondering if there is any benefit in moving on to any of >the newer wheels on the market today. I have a new PIII-1 GHZ machine, >reluctantly running Windows ME. The sims I drive are GPL, some N3, and I >anticipate becoming obsessed with F1CS2K. I suppose I'll buy N4 next >year. I don't want to spend (read: I'm forbidden from spending by the >wife) more than $150. > >My questions are: > >1. Is force feedback alone a good reason to replace the old >Thrustmaster? Is FF implemented well in any of the games above? > >2. How about non-FF wheels? Are any of them superior enough to my old >wheel to warrant replacing it? > >3. My old wheel obviously connects via the old gameport. Are the USB >wheels any better or worse? > >4. I hear good things about the Guillemot Ferrari Wheel, and the Act >Labs wheel. Do you think either of these is significantly better than my >old Nascar wheel? > >5. How about any other suggestions? It would seem most folks don't care >for the MS wheels, or the newer Logitech wheel. What about the new >Thrustmaster wheels? > >6. I've got one of those desks with a 2 inch lip on the front. The >clamping mechanism on my old Nascar wheel works fine with. What about the >Guillemot or the Act labs, or other wheels? > >Thanks in advance for any feedback. >

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy