Race Sim Central
Rec.Autos.Simulators Archive

"new" GPL Online

27 posts by 14 people · 09 Dec 2000 13:56 UTC - 19 Dec 2000 06:53 UTC

Should engine swaps be allowed in GPL pickup races?

An observer suggested allowing swapped engines in pickup races and leaving restrictions to leagues. Opponents said a cheat is still a cheat even if everyone has access to it, while supporters argued the field stays level if anyone can swap. Some suggested VROC could restrict combinations, and others noted 1967 privateers did mix chassis and engines.

online racing/leaguesmods/tracks/carsGrand Prix Legends

Automated summary.

(unknown) 09 Dec 2000 13:56 UTC#216170
As an observer, having played many games online, but not (yet) GPL (have been recently preparing/practicing) why not allow the "cheat" for pickup races and let the leagues create and administer the necessary restrictions? Some posts I have read here indicate that the code already exists to check for modifications prior to a race - it seems simple for league administrators to check this, no? You could also or alternatively have the winner of the race "drug tested" like they do in other sports? Unless (probably more like until) the cheat affects the physics model itself, this seems like a very easy problem to deal with. Dont panic! This is not a cheat if everyone has it...the playing field remains level. Baseball did not end when they lowered the pitcher's mound and allowed more homeruns to be hit, but you can bet the old timer's whined about their previous records about to be erased. Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
wrote on 09 Dec 2000: >As an observer, having played many games online, but not (yet) GPL >(have been recently preparing/practicing) why not allow the "cheat" for >pickup races and let the leagues create and administer the necessary >restrictions?<snip> From my point of view... because I can't keep a regular schedule that a league needs, so VROC pickups are my obly online races. And I *don't* want to have to worry about whether the Cooper on pole has a 28.5 at Monza because he's good, or because there's a bloody great Honda in the back. *IF* an official "Allow Modifieds Y/N" flag were built into VROC, I could live with it, but I *DON't* want *all* races to allow them. -- David. (final [?] GPLRank handicap: -5.92) The GPL Scrapyard - http://www.hillclimbfan.f2s.com "After all, a mere thousand yards - such a harmless little knoll, really" - Raymond Mays on Shelsley Walsh.
Quoted text (16 lines)> >As an observer, having played many games online, but not (yet) GPL > >(have been recently preparing/practicing) why not allow the "cheat" > >for pickup races and let the leagues create and administer the > >necessary restrictions? > <snip> > > From my point of view... because I can't keep a regular schedule > that a league needs, so VROC pickups are my obly online races. And > I *don't* want to have to worry about whether the Cooper on pole > has a 28.5 at Monza because he's good, or because there's a bloody > great Honda in the back. > > *IF* an official "Allow Modifieds Y/N" flag were built into VROC, > I could live with it, but I *DON't* want *all* races to allow them. > > David. (final [?] GPLRank handicap: -5.92)
I'd bet a small amount of money that it wouldn't be very hard for those who know how to program to extend the admissions/restrictions tab on VROC to include all the different engine combinations. You couldn't force other drivers into a BRM-Repco, but you could disallow drivers in Brabham-Hondas. I think that will show up on VROC probably by the middle of January unless it's much harder to implement that it seems. -Dirt- **Jesus saves sinners and redeems them for valuable cash prizes** Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
>VROC pickups are my obly online races. And I *don't* > want to have to worry about whether the Cooper on pole has a 28.5 at > Monza because he's good, or because there's a bloody great Honda inthe back But if everyone has the ability to change engines, why not change to the same engine and then out-drive the guy with the big engine? How is this changing the game other than making it less authentic? Everyone still has a level playingfield, no? Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
[email hidden] wrote:
Quoted text (9 lines)>>VROC pickups are my obly online races. And I *don't* >> want to have to worry about whether the Cooper on pole has a 28.5 at >> Monza because he's good, or because there's a bloody great Honda in > the back > But if everyone has the ability to change engines, why not change to > the same engine and then out-drive the guy with the big engine? How is > this changing the game other than making it less authentic? Everyone > still has a level playingfield, no?
True, but that's like saying that every athlete has to start using steroids to make competition fair. +Cinquo
Quoted text (7 lines)>Everyone still has a level playingfield, no? > > True, but that's like saying that every athlete has to start using > steroids to make competition fair. > > +Cinquo >
Well, it would appear that the creation of this utility removed "fairness" from the equation. The genie cannot be put back in the bottle. Respectfully to everyone else's opinion on this subject (and this is one of those subjects everyone has an opinion on and will never agree on) unless we want to suspect everyone and hear constant accusations, allow ppl to use the utility openly. Then the only issue for open/pick-up racing is the set up of the car. Post the utility on VROC and encourage everyone to use it -- that is unless someone is going to spend hundreds of hours policing its use. Anyone who is compentent enough on a computer to find and figure out how to use VROC can certainly read about and utilize this util also. Those who object to its use can agree to participate in races where the winner is not "officially" declared the winner until someone verifies that stock engine and chassis were used. In real racing the winner's car is generally examined to see if cheating was involved. Couldnt something like that be done here? It would work great in league, and possibly in open racing also. Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
Quoted text (7 lines)>Everyone still has a level playingfield, no? > > True, but that's like saying that every athlete has to start using > steroids to make competition fair. > > +Cinquo >
Well, it would appear that the creation of this utility removed "fairness" from the equation. The genie cannot be put back in the bottle. Respectfully to everyone else's opinion on this subject (and this is one of those subjects everyone has an opinion on and will never agree on) unless we want to suspect everyone and hear constant accusations, allow ppl to use the utility openly. Then the only issue for open/pick-up racing is the set up of the car. Post the utility on VROC and encourage everyone to use it -- that is unless someone is going to spend hundreds of hours policing its use. Anyone who is compentent enough on a computer to find and figure out how to use VROC can certainly read about and utilize this util also. Those who object to its use can agree to participate in races where the winner is not "officially" declared the winner until someone verifies that stock engine and chassis were used. In real racing the winner's car is generally examined to see if cheating was involved. Couldnt something like that be done here? It would work great in league, and possibly in open racing also. Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ Before you buy.
Well how the playing field not level since you now have more choices. If anyone can put any motor in the cars then anyone has the same chances. It does make for more testing to see if you could handle driving a Brabham Cossie or a Brabham Honda, or Lotus honda, but if everyone does have the same ability to make the same changes I am not sure if the playing field in not level. I would say that its tough at least for me to drive the Brabham as is so It may not be any easier to drive it with the extra 50 hp a cossie will give or the extra power the Honda will give. Everyone seems to think Hp is the end all be all answer, but its usually not. It might get rid of some cars for some tracks, but I would say most tracks it would not be a problem. dave Ville V Sinkko <[email hidden]> wrote in article <90tqsu$s7p$[email hidden]>...
Quoted text (17 lines)> [email hidden] wrote: > > >>VROC pickups are my obly online races. And I *don't* > >> want to have to worry about whether the Cooper on pole has a 28.5 at > >> Monza because he's good, or because there's a bloody great Honda in > > the back > > > But if everyone has the ability to change engines, why not change to > > the same engine and then out-drive the guy with the big engine? How is > > this changing the game other than making it less authentic? Everyone > > still has a level playingfield, no? > > True, but that's like saying that every athlete has to start using > steroids to make competition fair. > > +Cinquo >
I love that...It isn't a cheat if everyone has it...what a funny statement. Everyone can rail ride at monza, but it is still considered cheating...Look at Rogue Spear...there is a web site with some cheat programs to download that allow increased armor and auto aiming and increased speed (shooting game)...just because everyone can download it doesnt mean it isnt a cheat. Maybe it is just an excuse for you to go out and cheat. JB <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:90tdm4$fr1$[email hidden]...
Quoted text (18 lines)> As an observer, having played many games online, but not (yet) GPL > (have been recently preparing/practicing) why not allow the "cheat" for > pickup races and let the leagues create and administer the necessary > restrictions? Some posts I have read here indicate that the code > already exists to check for modifications prior to a race - it seems > simple for league administrators to check this, no? You could also or > alternatively have the winner of the race "drug tested" like they do in > other sports? Unless (probably more like until) the cheat affects the > physics model itself, this seems like a very easy problem to deal > with. Dont panic! This is not a cheat if everyone has it...the > playing field remains level. Baseball did not end when they lowered > the pitcher's mound and allowed more homeruns to be hit, but you can > bet the old timer's whined about their previous records about to be > erased. > > > Sent via Deja.com http://www.deja.com/ > Before you buy.
You keep the sound of the chassis you are driving...so if you throw a honda motor into your cooper chassis, it will sound like a cooper just with higher revs. JB "BC" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (19 lines)> On 9 Dec 2000 14:33:32 GMT, [email hidden] (David > Buttery) wrote: > > > wrote on 09 Dec 2000: > > > >>As an observer, having played many games online, but not (yet) GPL > >>(have been recently preparing/practicing) why not allow the "cheat" for > >>pickup races and let the leagues create and administer the necessary > >>restrictions? > ><snip> > > > >From my point of view... because I can't keep a regular schedule that a > >league needs, so VROC pickups are my obly online races. And I *don't* > >want to have to worry about whether the Cooper on pole has a 28.5 at > >Monza because he's good, or because there's a bloody great Honda in the > >back. > > > > Is it going to sound like a Honda or a Cooper?
Wosco 09 Dec 2000 22:48 UTC↳ reply to David#216219
HP isn't the end all answer...but it sure does help. You are racing a guy and come onto the front straight at monza side by side...tell me the guy with less HP is going to win the drag race. He won't...sure more HP won't make you a god...but having less horsepower sure doesn't help you out. JB "David" <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:01c061df$50c59060$06d3fc3f@packardbell... > Well how the playing field not level since you now have more choices. If > anyone can put any motor in the cars then anyone has the same chances. It > does make for more testing to see if you could handle driving a Brabham > Cossie or a Brabham Honda, or Lotus honda, but if everyone does have the > same ability to make the same changes I am not sure if the playing fieldin > not level. I would say that its tough at least for me to drive theBrabham > as is so It may not be any easier to drive it with the extra 50 hp acossie
Quoted text (19 lines)> will give or the extra power the Honda will give. > > Everyone seems to think Hp is the end all be all answer, but its usually > not. It might get rid of some cars for some tracks, but I would say most > tracks it would not be a problem. > > dave > > Ville V Sinkko <[email hidden]> wrote in article > <90tqsu$s7p$[email hidden]>... > > [email hidden] wrote: > > > > >>VROC pickups are my obly online races. And I *don't* > > >> want to have to worry about whether the Cooper on pole has a 28.5 at > > >> Monza because he's good, or because there's a bloody great Honda in > > > the back > > > > > But if everyone has the ability to change engines, why not change to > > > the same engine and then out-drive the guy with the big engine? How
is
Quoted text (8 lines)> > > this changing the game other than making it less authentic? Everyone > > > still has a level playingfield, no? > > > > True, but that's like saying that every athlete has to start using > > steroids to make competition fair. > > > > +Cinquo > >
>with. Dont panic! This is not a cheat if everyone has it...the >playing field remains level. Baseball did not end when they lowered I wonder what would happen if Earnhardt showed up at Daytona with a 400ci engine. Would everyone just roll over and say, "oh, I guess it's okay because anyone could have one if they wanted one"? Just because a cheat is widely available and anyone can run it doesn't make it any less a cheat. And defending it by saying everyone can run it if they want just makes the cheater look even more idiotic. I know that falling back on the age-old "cheaters never prosper" is kind of hokey but, one of the reasons it's true is becasue the rest of the community usually bands together and takes action against them. If I come up with a cheat that allows me to run a 2001 Reynard chassis in GPL then I guess I should be allowed to run it. Sounds fine to me. Dave Casey Casey_94 (NASCAR Racing 3 & 4) www.teamcasey.net www.lvkc.com www.buycoolcrap.com
David 10 Dec 2000 00:28 UTC↳ reply to Wosco#216048
I think I did say it will get rid of some cars use at some tracks did I not? Monza is a hp track end of story. I personally find it boring unless racing online with a good group of racers. Dave Wosco <[email hidden]> wrote in article <WEyY5.907$[email hidden]>... > HP isn't the end all answer...but it sure does help. You are racing aguy > and come onto the front straight at monza side by side...tell me the guy > with less HP is going to win the drag race. He won't...sure more HPwon't
Quoted text (7 lines)> make you a god...but having less horsepower sure doesn't help you out. > > JB > > "David" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:01c061df$50c59060$06d3fc3f@packardbell... > > Well how the playing field not level since you now have more choices.
If > > anyone can put any motor in the cars then anyone has the same chances. It > > does make for more testing to see if you could handle driving a Brabham > > Cossie or a Brabham Honda, or Lotus honda, but if everyone does havethe > > same ability to make the same changes I am not sure if the playingfield
Quoted text (8 lines)> in > > not level. I would say that its tough at least for me to drive the > Brabham > > as is so It may not be any easier to drive it with the extra 50 hp a > cossie > > will give or the extra power the Honda will give. > > > > Everyone seems to think Hp is the end all be all answer, but its
usually > > not. It might get rid of some cars for some tracks, but I would saymost
Quoted text (10 lines)> > tracks it would not be a problem. > > > > dave > > > > Ville V Sinkko <[email hidden]> wrote in article > > <90tqsu$s7p$[email hidden]>... > > > [email hidden] wrote: > > > > > > >>VROC pickups are my obly online races. And I *don't* > > > >> want to have to worry about whether the Cooper on pole has a 28.5
at > > > >> Monza because he's good, or because there's a bloody great Hondain > > > > the back > > > > > > > But if everyone has the ability to change engines, why not changeto > > > > the same engine and then out-drive the guy with the big engine? How > is > > > > this changing the game other than making it less authentic? Everyone
Quoted text (10 lines)> > > > still has a level playingfield, no? > > > > > > True, but that's like saying that every athlete has to start using > > > steroids to make competition fair. > > > > > > +Cinquo > > > > > >
David wrote on 10 Dec 2000: <snip> >Monza is a hp track end of story. I personally find it boring unless >racing online with a good group of racers. <snip> No argument - I can't remember when I last hotlapped Monza, but I've just had two terrific scraps there: Race 1: Came 2nd by 0.39s, 3rd place bloke had been on my tail until right at the end. Top 3 had best laps within a tenth. Race 2: Racing lower down the field, but locked together with the other guy for 10 laps before the bloody server collapsed halfway around the last lap. Monza is a fantastic track *if* you have a close, clean(ish) grid. Otherwise, it's boring as you say. -- David. (final [?] GPLRank handicap: -5.92) The GPL Scrapyard - http://www.hillclimbfan.f2s.com "After all, a mere thousand yards - such a harmless little knoll, really" - Raymond Mays on Shelsley Walsh.
In article <90tdm4$fr1$[email hidden]>, [email hidden] writes: >This is not a cheat if everyone has it...the >playing field remains level. The playing field doesn't remain level if some choose not to use it. Why wouldn't someone use it? Morals, purist views, even lack of technical skill. Just because it's out there doesn't me EVERYONE wants it. No flame, just fact. Eldred -- Tiger Stadium R.I.P. 1912-1999 Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett GPL hcp. +40.48 Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
In <EVyY5.53475$[email hidden]> [email hidden] (Dave Casey) writes: >>with. Dont panic! This is not a cheat if everyone has it...the >>playing field remains level. Baseball did not end when they lowered >I wonder what would happen if Earnhardt showed up at Daytona with a 400ci >engine. Would everyone just roll over and say, "oh, I guess it's okay because >anyone could have one if they wanted one"? Is a 400ci engine legal at Daytona? I'm a bit confused at the outrage some are expressing here. Wasn't the same kind of thing legal in F1 at the time? I look at the old race schedules and I see a lot of private entries where a Lotus or Cooper is entered with an engine it never shipped with. As long as the engine meets the specs for a legal F1 engine it would have been legal, assuming a private owner could have got say Cooper to sell them a chassis and Honda to sell them an engine. I guess if you want to consider GPL on VROC a little subset of the real F1 season, where only works cars are allowed and the rules are that if the factory didn't race it, it isn't legal then that's ok, but claiming that it's the same as stuffing an illegal engine into the chassis as the above is seems a bit over the top. -- Artificial Intelligence stands no chance against Natural Stupidity. GAT d- -p+(--) c++++ l++ u++ t- m--- W--- !v b+++ e* s-/+ n-(?) h++ f+g+ w+++ y*
John Henders <[email hidden]> wrote in article <91gapl$[email hidden]>... > In <EVyY5.53475$[email hidden]>[email hidden] (Dave Casey) writes: > > >>with. Dont panic! This is not a cheat if everyone has it...the > >>playing field remains level. Baseball did not end when they lowered > > >I wonder what would happen if Earnhardt showed up at Daytona with a400ci > >engine. Would everyone just roll over and say, "oh, I guess it's okaybecause > >anyone could have one if they wanted one"? > Formula One in 1967 had a 3 liter limit and that was it, end of story. Brabham if he could have would have given his first born for Honda power and even admitted wanting it. Also Cooper did a deal with Maser due to that was the only motor they could get. You can bet if they could have had a cosworth motor in the car they would have. Dave
On 16 Dec 2000 10:03:33 -0800, [email hidden] (John Henders) wrote:
Quoted text (18 lines)>In <EVyY5.53475$[email hidden]> [email hidden] (Dave Casey) writes: > >>>with. Dont panic! This is not a cheat if everyone has it...the >>>playing field remains level. Baseball did not end when they lowered > >>I wonder what would happen if Earnhardt showed up at Daytona with a 400ci >>engine. Would everyone just roll over and say, "oh, I guess it's okay because >>anyone could have one if they wanted one"? > > >Is a 400ci engine legal at Daytona? I'm a bit confused at the outrage >some are expressing here. Wasn't the same kind of thing legal in F1 at >the time? I look at the old race schedules and I see a lot of private >entries where a Lotus or Cooper is entered with an engine it never >shipped with. As long as the engine meets the specs for a legal F1 >engine it would have been legal, assuming a private owner could have got >say Cooper to sell them a chassis and Honda to sell them an engine. >
I believe the issue is that the weight remains the same. Put a big, heavy Honda in the Brabham Chasis, it still weighs the same as if there was a Repco in there. Seriously though, I don't know how much of a problem this is unless you are a die hard realism freak - in which case you should be bitching about the fact that there is no wind to make driving in a straight line more difficult. I've also taken to pointing out Steve Smith's comments, in Four Wheel Drift, about fuel regulations and how easily they were flaunted in 1967. DG
Disgruntled Goat wrote on 17 Dec 2000: <snip> >I don't know how much of >a problem this is unless you are a die hard realism freak This is *GPL* we're talking about here, man! Who do you *expect* to be playing it but "die hard realism freaks"...? ;-) >- in which >case you should be bitching about the fact that there is no wind to >make driving in a straight line more difficult. <snip> I'd be delighted if weather was in the game, wind and all. But it isn't, so we have to make do with what we've got. >I've also taken to pointing out Steve Smith's comments, in Four Wheel >Drift, about fuel regulations and how easily they were >flaunted in 1967. Before Bruce gets in here: you mean "flouted"! Flaunting fuel regs would mean waving them around saying, "I've got the fuel regs! Na-na-na-na-na!"! -- David. (GPLRank handicap: -5.92) The GPL Scrapyard - http://www.hillclimbfan.f2s.com "After all, a mere thousand yards - such a harmless little knoll, really" - Raymond Mays on Shelsley Walsh.
David Buttery <[email hidden]> wrote in message news:[email hidden]...
Quoted text (11 lines)> Disgruntled Goat wrote on 17 Dec 2000: > > <snip> > > >I've also taken to pointing out Steve Smith's comments, in Four Wheel > >Drift, about fuel regulations and how easily they were > >flaunted in 1967. > > Before Bruce gets in here: you mean "flouted"! Flaunting fuel regs would > mean waving them around saying, "I've got the fuel regs! Na-na-na-na-na!"! >
David, I believe that the official 1967 Fuel Reg Flaunt had six "na"s, as in "Na-na-na-na-naaaaa-naaaa". Of course many teams flouted the regulations on the length of the last two "na"s.
Jim Allison wrote on 17 Dec 2000: >I believe that the official 1967 Fuel Reg Flaunt had six "na"s, as in >"Na-na-na-na-naaaaa-naaaa". Of course many teams flouted the regulations >on the length of the last two "na"s. NOt in the UK. The Flaunt Advisory Board saw to that... -- David. (GPLRank handicap: -5.92) The GPL Scrapyard - http://www.hillclimbfan.f2s.com "After all, a mere thousand yards - such a harmless little knoll, really" - Raymond Mays on Shelsley Walsh.
<[email hidden]> wrote ... > > But if everyone has the ability to change engines, why not change to > the same engine and then out-drive the guy with the big engine? How is > this changing the game other than making it less authentic? Everyone > still has a level playingfield, no? No. I could be wrong, but I suspect that the majority of people racing on-line do other things with their life as well. Having the "ability to change engines" gives a decided advantage to those with the *time* to mess around with changing engines.
EldredP wrote ... > > The playing field doesn't remain level if some choose not to use it. Why > wouldn't someone use it? Morals, purist views, even lack of technical skill. Or even time.
Don Jennings wrote on 18 Dec 2000: >No. I could be wrong, but I suspect that the majority of people racing >on-line do other things with their life as well.<snip> This *is* GPL we're talking about, here... :-) -- David. (GPLRank handicap: -5.92) The GPL Scrapyard - http://www.hillclimbfan.f2s.com "After all, a mere thousand yards - such a harmless little knoll, really" - Raymond Mays on Shelsley Walsh.
In article <91lo6i$4fpv0$[email hidden]>, [email hidden] (Don Jennings) wrote: > > No. I could be wrong, but I suspect that the majority of people racing > on-line do other things with their life as well. Having the "ability to > change engines" gives a decided advantage to those with the *time* to mess > around with changing engines. Having the *time* to practice gives a decided advantage. I think it makes little difference to casual racing. I tend to drive a Ferrari, and I'm not surprised when I'm out-dragged by a Lotus... Cheers, Steve.
In article <91lojj$4h335$[email hidden]>, "Don Jennings" <[email hidden]> writes:
Quoted text (9 lines)>EldredP wrote ... >>=20 >> The playing field doesn't remain level if some choose not to use it. = >Why >> wouldn't someone use it? Morals, purist views, even lack of technical = >skill.=20 > >Or even time. >
Yeah, that too, I guess... -- Tiger Stadium R.I.P. 1912-1999 Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett GPL F1 hcp. +39.11/F3 hcp. +373.73 Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you with experience... Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.

Sponsors

Affiliate Links

Sim Gaming Expo MOZA Racing Sim-Lab Fanatec TrakRacer Asetek Internet Privacy From NordVPN Dreamhost Capital One Credit Card Application Fanatical CDKeys Amazon Amazon UK Project Motor Racing iRacing Get your racing gloves, boots and more from Demon Tweeks. Enlist at Roberts Space Industries, developers of Star Citizen and Squadron 42


Back from the ashes since July, 2019. First created in 2001 with the merger of Legends Central (founded 1999) and simracing.dk.

A site by a sort of sim racer, for sim racers, about racing sims. News and information on both modern and historic sim racing software titles.

All products and licenses property of their respective owners.


Facebook Threads Bluesky Twitter Mastodon Instagram YouTube Tiktok Twitch Reddit Google News Apple News Subscribe via WordPress Flipboard eBay

Race Sim Central © 1999-2026 | Some links pay RSC a commission. Advertising does not equal endorsement.Cookie Policy