RG at http://simpaddock.com/ recieved a nice letter yesterday, from Alston & Bird,
(http://www.alston.com), attorneys for Tommy Bahama (http://www.tommybahama.com/).
Why?
Because he was putting together the 2001 Trans Am cars for SCGT, and Tommy Bahama is the
sponsor for the #88 Brian Simo Mangusta. They didn't like his paintscheme being given
out for free...
First Ubisoft, now them, who's next? It's starting to spread, folks...I mentioned this
about a year ago in this post...
http://www.theuspits.com/pirate1.html
So, what can we do about it? Really only two choices...ignore it, or email the people in
question. Refusal to purchase their products goes a long way...
Cheers!
--
�� Jan Kohl ��
SECURITY CONSULTANT
The Pits - http://www.theuspits.com
Castle Graphics - http://www.castlegraphics.com
Notable threadTommy Bahama lawyers target SCGT Trans-Am carset
Jan Kohl reported that lawyers for Tommy Bahama had written to SimPaddock over a 2001 Trans-Am carset for Sports Car GT. Posters debated whether non-commercial paint schemes infringe trademarks, with J. Todd Wasson arguing that licensing rights have real value to developers and others calling sponsors foolish for blocking free advertising. One poster said the SCCA had sold exclusive gaming rights for a Trans-Am sim, and the Ubi Soft add-on dispute resurfaced with some personal insults.
Automated summary.
"Jan Kohl" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:h2OF6.14108$[email hidden]...
> RG at http://simpaddock.com/ recieved a nice letter yesterday, fromAlston & Bird,
> (http://www.alston.com), attorneys for Tommy Bahama(http://www.tommybahama.com/).
>
> Why?
>
> Because he was putting together the 2001 Trans Am cars for SCGT, and TommyBahama is the
> sponsor for the #88 Brian Simo Mangusta. They didn't like his paintschemebeing given
> out for free...
>
> First Ubisoft, now them, who's next? It's starting to spread, folks...Imentioned this
> about a year ago in this post...
> http://www.theuspits.com/pirate1.html
>
> So, what can we do about it? Really only two choices...ignore it, or emailthe people in
> question. Refusal to purchase their products goes a long way...
>
> Cheers!
Bizarre. They pay lots of money in order for people to see their logos and
then complain when hobbyists duplicate it for non-commercial purposes?
Doesn't make much sense to me from a business standpoint. You'll alienate
some of the very fans you're trying to attract.
I think this is a case of a mis-informed lawyer. He/She probably believes
that RG is somehow profiting by making his patch available. I don't think
that any legal action can be taken if the so called copyright/trademark
"violator" isn't making any money.
If the still he/she still insists that he take it down then make that lawyer
explain the legality of these situations:
If I go to a Trans-Am race and take a picture of the #88 Mangusta, then put
it up on my website can they make me take it down? Fat chance.
If I model a box in VRML with that picture on it and put it on my website
can they make me take it down? I doubt it.
If I model the #88 Mangusta, apply accurate textures, render a scene and
then stick that on my website am I breaking any laws? Don't think so.
If I make that model available as a free download on my website....
All of these are "free downloads" aren't they?
I don't think RG has anything to worry about.
T.O.
>"Jan Kohl" <[email hidden]> wrote
> Because he was putting together the 2001 Trans Am cars for SCGT, and TommyBahama is the
> sponsor for the #88 Brian Simo Mangusta. They didn't like his paintschemebeing given
> out for free...
I would then take his paintscheme, take out every form of non-copyrighted
sponsorship they didn't want on it and repaint the car with a big "F*CK YOU"
on it. I would then upload my website with a nice picture of it. Global
paintschemes are not copyrighted. I would also send a nice picture of the
car in SCGT to those lawyers.
> First Ubisoft, now them, who's next? It's starting to spread, folks...Imentioned this
> about a year ago in this post...
> http://www.theuspits.com/pirate1.html
What can we do? Corporate America is there to protect itself and will
continue forever to harass us. Ubisoft is only doing that for their own
satisfying needs, they have no vision of a "community". For them, the pile
of cash is the only form of community. That's why I have never wanted the
community to go too much mainstream. Keep the sales good so new sims can be
produced, but not too high. Who cares if GPL bombed? Track owners don't
know of it's existence and we can have new tracks for it now.
p.s. : Don't forget to boycott Tommy Bahama because of that.
--
-- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard>
-- May the Downforce be with you...
-- http://www.ymenard.com/
-- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimato Dominguez
Corporation - helping America into the New World...
>"Toe out" <[email hidden]> wrote
> I think this is a case of a mis-informed lawyer. He/She probably believes
> that RG is somehow profiting by making his patch available. I don't think
> that any legal action can be taken if the so called copyright/trademark
> "violator" isn't making any money.
It's not a case of making profit or not. Was there any kind of copyright
agreement on XYZ sponsor? If there wasn't, it's illegal. The company did
not approve it. Same thing to link a website on your site.
--
-- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard>
-- May the Downforce be with you...
-- http://www.ymenard.com/
-- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimato Dominguez
Corporation - helping America into the New World...
"Jan Kohl" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:h2OF6.14108$[email hidden]...
> RG at http://simpaddock.com/ recieved a nice letter yesterday, fromAlston & Bird,
> (http://www.alston.com), attorneys for Tommy Bahama(http://www.tommybahama.com/).
>
> Why?
>
> Because he was putting together the 2001 Trans Am cars for SCGT, and TommyBahama is the
> sponsor for the #88 Brian Simo Mangusta. They didn't like his paintschemebeing given
> out for free...
>
> First Ubisoft, now them, who's next? It's starting to spread, folks...Imentioned this
> about a year ago in this post...
> http://www.theuspits.com/pirate1.html
>
> So, what can we do about it? Really only two choices...ignore it, or emailthe people in
An interesting response might be to send them a *bill* in consideration of
the advertising and promotional effort.
KFG
Quoted text (11 lines)
> question. Refusal to purchase their products goes a long way... > > Cheers! > > -- > �� Jan Kohl �� > SECURITY CONSULTANT > The Pits - http://www.theuspits.com > Castle Graphics - http://www.castlegraphics.com > >As a matter of interest, how does this all work with say paintings. If I was
at a race and painted a race scene and then sold my paintings and prints? Or
I was producing a book on the race series and took a lot of pictures to use
in the book?
"Chris West" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:NwXF6.1413$[email hidden]...
> As a matter of interest, how does this all work with say paintings. If Iwas
> at a race and painted a race scene and then sold my paintings and prints?Or
> I was producing a book on the race series and took a lot of pictures touse
> in the book?
>
>
>
Let's just say that Campbell's didn't sue Andy Warhol. It has also been
legally declared by the Supreme court that you have the right to take a
picture of anything you can see from a public place. That would include
billboards and various other advertising signs. Such pictures may be
published, even for profit, without permission of the people, places or
things included in the photographs. ( Please note that a football stadium,
or a racetrack, may NOT legally be such a public place, depending on many
factors that only judge with a particular case before him can truely
decide).
On the other hand the lawyers are starting to make things pretty weird out
there.
KFG
"Chris West" <[email hidden]> wrote
> If I was at a race and painted a race scene and then sold my paintings andprints?
>Or I was producing a book on the race series and took a lot of pictures touse
> in the book?
There are some artistic freedom in those situations, no? Painting a car in a
game can't be considered by lawyers as "artistic", no?
--
-- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard>
-- May the Downforce be with you...
-- http://www.ymenard.com/
-- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimato Dominguez
Corporation - helping America into the New World...
It's a me, me, me world, especially in corporate america.
Things are too damned possessive these days :(
-Larry
"Jan Kohl" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:h2OF6.14108$[email hidden]...
> RG at http://simpaddock.com/ recieved a nice letter yesterday, fromAlston & Bird,
> (http://www.alston.com), attorneys for Tommy Bahama(http://www.tommybahama.com/).
>
> Why?
>
> Because he was putting together the 2001 Trans Am cars for SCGT, and TommyBahama is the
> sponsor for the #88 Brian Simo Mangusta. They didn't like his paintschemebeing given
> out for free...
>
> First Ubisoft, now them, who's next? It's starting to spread, folks...Imentioned this
> about a year ago in this post...
> http://www.theuspits.com/pirate1.html
>
> So, what can we do about it? Really only two choices...ignore it, or emailthe people in
Quoted text (11 lines)
> question. Refusal to purchase their products goes a long way... > > Cheers! > > -- > �� Jan Kohl �� > SECURITY CONSULTANT > The Pits - http://www.theuspits.com > Castle Graphics - http://www.castlegraphics.com > >It's ALWAYS about money.
-Larry
"ymenard" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:1wPF6.722282$[email hidden]...
> >"Toe out" <[email hidden]> wrote
> > I think this is a case of a mis-informed lawyer. He/She probablybelieves
> > that RG is somehow profiting by making his patch available. I don'tthink
Quoted text (22 lines)
> > that any legal action can be taken if the so called copyright/trademark > > "violator" isn't making any money. > > > > It's not a case of making profit or not. Was there any kind of copyright > agreement on XYZ sponsor? If there wasn't, it's illegal. The company did > not approve it. Same thing to link a website on your site. > > > > > > -- > -- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard> > -- May the Downforce be with you... > -- http://www.ymenard.com/ > -- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimato Dominguez > Corporation - helping America into the New World... > > >It used to be "Hockey Night in Canada" would make an announcement every
game that went roughly: "rebroadcast or retransmission of this broadcast in
whole or in part is expressly forbidden..."
So technically I couldn't tell you the score of the game without risking
getting sued.
"Chris West" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:NwXF6.1413$[email hidden]...
> As a matter of interest, how does this all work with say paintings. If Iwas
> at a race and painted a race scene and then sold my paintings and prints?Or
> I was producing a book on the race series and took a lot of pictures touse
> in the book?
>
>
>
>Bizarre. They pay lots of money in order for people to see their logos and
>then complain when hobbyists duplicate it for non-commercial purposes?
>Doesn't make much sense to me from a business standpoint. You'll alienate
>some of the very fans you're trying to attract.
>
>
The money from those logos are being paid to the racing team/series owners.
The right to use the car(s) in a video game can be sold for quite a lot of
money, so why would they allow folks to do it for free? If you write and sell
a racing game, it'll make a lot more money if it's got all the real
Indycars/whatever from this year, the real driver names and paintschemes, etc.,
then if you just made up a series that wasn't real. Therefore, the licensing
fees paid to team/series owners is an investment. If the owners *choose* to
allow free distribution because they believe the "advertising" is worth more
than the potential licensing fees, they can do so. My point is, it's their
decision, not ours, since it's their money on the line.
Don't get me wrong, I'd love to see a racing sim with every car in the world
too (except mine, blech!), but the fact is most of us would pay for expansion
packs with new cars and whatever else. I don't blame them for protecting
themselves. Any of us would probably do the same thing once we sat down and
figured how much money we were losing to "hobbyists", even though they might
make better products.
Of course, as Jan Kohl mentioned, people that disagree with this view can
also choose to simply not purchase these sims.
Todd Wasson
---
Performance Simulations
Drag Racing and Top Speed Prediction
Software
http://PerformanceSimulations.Com
>I think this is a case of a mis-informed lawyer. He/She probably believes
>that RG is somehow profiting by making his patch available. I don't think
>that any legal action can be taken if the so called copyright/trademark
>"violator" isn't making any money.
What if a gaming company was considering including the Trans-Am car(s)
mentioned in a future videogame? Since there were a few free extremely high
quality Trans-Am patches for existing games made by people who created the work
for free, the gaming company may not bother to approach the car/series owner at
all about purchasing the right to do so in a commercial game, and may look to
another series instead. Even though the "violator" has made no money for
his/her work, it could be strongly argued that the "violator's" actions have
prevented licensing sales, causing financial damages. Probably a case for a
civil suit.
I agree with you here because what you'd be doing in these situations is
probably financially harmless to the copyright owners, but it's still the
owners' decision whether to contact you or not on those matters.
Todd Wasson
---
Performance Simulations
Drag Racing and Top Speed Prediction
Software
http://PerformanceSimulations.Com
Quoted text (9 lines)
>If the still he/she still insists that he take it down then make that lawyer >explain the legality of these situations: >If I go to a Trans-Am race and take a picture of the #88 Mangusta, then put >it up on my website can they make me take it down? Fat chance. >If I model a box in VRML with that picture on it and put it on my website >can they make me take it down? I doubt it. >If I model the #88 Mangusta, apply accurate textures, render a scene and >then stick that on my website am I breaking any laws? Don't think so. >If I make that model available as a free download on my website....In article <[email hidden]>, [email hidden]
says...
Bullshit. Corps can do whatever they want for profit. Us real people
can do nothing. You're a fucking corporate ass licker.
-Tim
Quoted text (9 lines)
>all about purchasing the right to do so in a commercial game, and may look to >another series instead. Even though the "violator" has made no money for >his/her work, it could be strongly argued that the "violator's" actions have >prevented licensing sales, causing financial damages. Probably a case for a >civil suit. > I agree with you here because what you'd be doing in these situations is >probably financially harmless to the copyright owners, but it's still the >owners' decision whether to contact you or not on those matters.says...
Bullshit. Corps can do whatever they want for profit. Us real people
can do nothing. You're a ***ing corporate ass***er.
-Tim
"Jan Kohl" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:h2OF6.14108$[email hidden]...
> RG at http://simpaddock.com/ recieved a nice letter yesterday, fromAlston & Bird,
> (http://www.alston.com), attorneys for Tommy Bahama(http://www.tommybahama.com/).
> Why?
> Because he was putting together the 2001 Trans Am cars for SCGT, andTommy Bahama is the
> sponsor for the #88 Brian Simo Mangusta. They didn't like hispaintscheme being given
> out for free...
Interesting... The "correct" approach is to "buy" the right from
simpaddock.com for a nominal
fee (donated to charity), and make the official site (tommybahama.com)
the official distribution
site of the skin. It would cost a lot less than the lawyer fees fur
sure. I'm sure simpaddock.com
would be glad to "donate" it to the rightful owners...
--KC
Guys,
I can say one thing. The SCCA has sold all gaming rights to one company.
That company is working on a Trans Am sim and well with that happening I
will say the SCCA, Qualve, and the company sponsoring the Mangusta all have
problems with that car and paint job showing up in another game.
With the SCGT Tiresmoke Autocross Challenge we ran into a problem with the
SCCA, till they did find out we are not making a game but just using a one
lap concept for an existing game it was not an issue anylonger. We were
not using any SCCA trademarked items. Trans Am is a SCCA trademarked word
so much so infact Pontiac pays the SCCA for every Trans Am they built. I
would be willing to bet all the interested parties were concerned with the
certain painted Trans Am car showing up in a game other then Trans Am being
made by Motorsim( ?).
I guess this is also a warning to guys making cars. They need to be
careful not to step on anyones toes.
Dave
Chris,
You'd better not be painting any pichurs of NASCARs in action, Bubba!
If they can copyright the Sydney skyline, they can copyright anything.
--Steve
Chris West <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:NwXF6.1413$[email hidden]...
> As a matter of interest, how does this all work with say paintings. If Iwas
> at a race and painted a race scene and then sold my paintings and prints?Or
> I was producing a book on the race series and took a lot of pictures touse
> in the book?
>
>
>
Ubi Soft had to pay the FIA for the rights to the '99 season.
The FIA wants them to buy the rights to the '00, '01, and '02 season. In
their contract, they force Ubi Soft to enforce the copyright laws so that
the rights to the upcoming seasons are a necessary purchase.
I don't see how Ubi Soft is doing anything wrong. They are doing what's
legally required to fullfill their contract. The FIA is protecting their
very valuable interests. Some people just don't think that contracts and
laws have to be followed when it comes to games and music.
David G Fisher
"Jan Kohl" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:h2OF6.14108$[email hidden]...
> RG at http://simpaddock.com/ recieved a nice letter yesterday, fromAlston & Bird,
> (http://www.alston.com), attorneys for Tommy Bahama(http://www.tommybahama.com/).
>
> Why?
>
> Because he was putting together the 2001 Trans Am cars for SCGT, and TommyBahama is the
> sponsor for the #88 Brian Simo Mangusta. They didn't like his paintschemebeing given
> out for free...
>
> First Ubisoft, now them, who's next? It's starting to spread, folks...Imentioned this
> about a year ago in this post...
> http://www.theuspits.com/pirate1.html
>
> So, what can we do about it? Really only two choices...ignore it, or emailthe people in
Quoted text (11 lines)
> question. Refusal to purchase their products goes a long way... > > Cheers! > > -- > �� Jan Kohl �� > SECURITY CONSULTANT > The Pits - http://www.theuspits.com > Castle Graphics - http://www.castlegraphics.com > >
"The Enigmatic One" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:I12G6.52$[email hidden]...
> In article <[email hidden]>,[email hidden]
> says...
>
> >all about purchasing the right to do so in a commercial game, and maylook to
> >another series instead. Even though the "violator" has made no money for
> >his/her work, it could be strongly argued that the "violator's" actionshave
> >prevented licensing sales, causing financial damages. Probably a casefor a
> >civil suit.
>
> > I agree with you here because what you'd be doing in these situationsis
> >probably financially harmless to the copyright owners, but it's still the
> >owners' decision whether to contact you or not on those matters.
>
> Bullshit. Corps can do whatever they want for profit. Us real people
> can do nothing. You're a fucking corporate ass licker.
You do OU proud, son. That can-do attitude is what made Oklahoma great.
If there was any sense or justice in the world of sim racing, commercial
sponsors would have to pay the game developers and publishers to include
their advertisements. Car manufacturers and so forth not included, but
paint schemes and bill boards...give me a break. The painters are doing
those people a favour by providing accurate simulations for free.
Marc.
"J. Todd Wasson" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> >Bizarre. They pay lots of money in order for people to see their logosand
owners.
> The right to use the car(s) in a video game can be sold for quite a lot of
> money, so why would they allow folks to do it for free? If you write andsell
> a racing game, it'll make a lot more money if it's got all the real
> Indycars/whatever from this year, the real driver names and paintschemes,etc.,
> then if you just made up a series that wasn't real. Therefore, thelicensing
> fees paid to team/series owners is an investment. If the owners *choose*to
> allow free distribution because they believe the "advertising" is worthmore
> than the potential licensing fees, they can do so. My point is, it'stheir
> decision, not ours, since it's their money on the line.
>
> Don't get me wrong, I'd love to see a racing sim with every car in theworld
> too (except mine, blech!), but the fact is most of us would pay forexpansion
> packs with new cars and whatever else. I don't blame them for protecting
> themselves. Any of us would probably do the same thing once we sat downand
> figured how much money we were losing to "hobbyists", even though theymight
> make better products.
>
> Of course, as Jan Kohl mentioned, people that disagree with this viewcan
Quoted text (7 lines)
> >then complain when hobbyists duplicate it for non-commercial purposes? > >Doesn't make much sense to me from a business standpoint. You'll alienate > >some of the very fans you're trying to attract. > > > > > > The money from those logos are being paid to the racing team/seriesQuoted text (8 lines)
> also choose to simply not purchase these sims. > > Todd Wasson > --- > Performance Simulations > Drag Racing and Top Speed Prediction > Software > http://PerformanceSimulations.ComQuoted text (8 lines)
>If there was any sense or justice in the world of sim racing, commercial >sponsors would have to pay the game developers and publishers to include >their advertisements. Car manufacturers and so forth not included, but >paint schemes and bill boards...give me a break. The painters are doing >those people a favour by providing accurate simulations for free. > >Marc. >Quoted text (18 lines)
>>all about purchasing the right to do so in a commercial game, and may look >to >>another series instead. Even though the "violator" has made no money for >>his/her work, it could be strongly argued that the "violator's" actions have >>prevented licensing sales, causing financial damages. Probably a case for a >>civil suit. > >> I agree with you here because what you'd be doing in these situations is >>probably financially harmless to the copyright owners, but it's still the >>owners' decision whether to contact you or not on those matters. > > Bullshit. Corps can do whatever they want for profit. Us real people >can do nothing. You're a fucking corporate ass licker. > > > -Tim>>I think this is a case of a mis-informed lawyer. He/She probably believes
>>that RG is somehow profiting by making his patch available. I don't think
>>that any legal action can be taken if the so called copyright/trademark
>>"violator" isn't making any money.
One more thing. If the "violator" happens to be distributing a product such
as this from a website (the only way to do it, right?) they will be getting
TONS of new traffic to their site. How much more can they charge for
advertising now? The "violator" can indeed profit rather well from their
"free" work if they want to. I'm not saying anyone in particular is indeed
doing this for anything other than their love of sim racing, but the option to
do so is there. I know of one site that is making a free game with the sole
intent of drawing traffic to sell more of their products. The game itself
*becomes* advertising to draw traffic to their site, therefore, it has value,
whether or not there was cash exchanged.
Just my thoughts,
Todd Wasson
---
Performance Simulations
Drag Racing and Top Speed Prediction
Software
http://PerformanceSimulations.Com
Quoted text (12 lines)
>Ubi Soft had to pay the FIA for the rights to the '99 season. > >The FIA wants them to buy the rights to the '00, '01, and '02 season. In >their contract, they force Ubi Soft to enforce the copyright laws so that >the rights to the upcoming seasons are a necessary purchase. > >I don't see how Ubi Soft is doing anything wrong. They are doing what's >legally required to fullfill their contract. The FIA is protecting their >very valuable interests. Some people just don't think that contracts and >laws have to be followed when it comes to games and music. > >David G Fisher[email hidden] (J. Todd Wasson) writes:
What about the stuff they don't think we want? Like a cart simulation?
How long will it take before cart heat gets shut down?
(What really really bugs me (totally off topic here) is the bloody
stupid dvd zone system. I live in Hong Kong, and want to buy the Hong
Kong movie "Hidden tiger crouching dragon". But the version that is
released for the Hong Kong market is a crappy version not much better
than the pirated vcds pushed at every street corner around here.
Compared to the US version with lots of special features, and
anamorphic image. But can I buy the US version and put it in my
player? Nah, that would probably violate someones rights to something,
never mind that I would actually have to pay more (And don't mind if I
get a nice version) to get the US version. And books; when you buy a
book in a bookshop, you can borrow it to friends and family if it is a
good book, so now publishers are starting to look into electronic
books with encryption and watermarks so this communist practice can be
put to an end. (I don't understand how people stand to read a book on
a computer myself.))
> Personally, I'll keep buying the games anyway because I like
> playing them and think $50 or so is worth it.
We all do.
--
-asbjxrn Consultant, n.:
An ordinary man a long way from home.
Quoted text (10 lines)
> We "real people" that had absolutely no part in making either the > Trans-Am racing series, or the video games that let us pretend we're > a part of it for awhile for entertainment, CAN do something. > Boycott them. Organize everyone you know and urge them to do the > same. If they don't have money coming in, you've killed off the > corporation, along with the jobs of all the "real people" with > families and so forth that work there, unless they change their > ways. We, the regular people of the world, choose how we spend our > money, not the corporations. They just make stuff they think we'll > want and hope we buy it.Quoted text (14 lines)
>> We "real people" that had absolutely no part in making either the >> Trans-Am racing series, or the video games that let us pretend we're >> a part of it for awhile for entertainment, CAN do something. >> Boycott them. Organize everyone you know and urge them to do the >> same. If they don't have money coming in, you've killed off the >> corporation, along with the jobs of all the "real people" with >> families and so forth that work there, unless they change their >> ways. We, the regular people of the world, choose how we spend our >> money, not the corporations. They just make stuff they think we'll >> want and hope we buy it. > >What about the stuff they don't think we want? Like a cart simulation? >How long will it take before cart heat gets shut down? >Quoted text (15 lines)
>(What really really bugs me (totally off topic here) is the bloody >stupid dvd zone system. I live in Hong Kong, and want to buy the Hong >Kong movie "Hidden tiger crouching dragon". But the version that is >released for the Hong Kong market is a crappy version not much better >than the pirated vcds pushed at every street corner around here. >Compared to the US version with lots of special features, and >anamorphic image. But can I buy the US version and put it in my >player? Nah, that would probably violate someones rights to something, >never mind that I would actually have to pay more (And don't mind if I >get a nice version) to get the US version. And books; when you buy a >book in a bookshop, you can borrow it to friends and family if it is a >good book, so now publishers are starting to look into electronic >books with encryption and watermarks so this communist practice can be >put to an end. (I don't understand how people stand to read a book on >a computer myself.))
"David" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:01c0ce8e$24bfc780$48d3fc3f@packardbell...
> Guys,
>
> I can say one thing. The SCCA has sold all gaming rights to one company.
> That company is working on a Trans Am sim and well with that happening I
> will say the SCCA, Qualve, and the company sponsoring the Mangusta allhave
being
> made by Motorsim( ?).
>
> I guess this is also a warning to guys making cars. They need to be
> careful not to step on anyones toes.
>
> Dave
Considering that Motorsims hasn't updated their own website in over a year I
don't hold out much hope for this title. :)
KFG
Quoted text (9 lines)
> problems with that car and paint job showing up in another game. > > With the SCGT Tiresmoke Autocross Challenge we ran into a problem with the > SCCA, till they did find out we are not making a game but just using a one > lap concept for an existing game it was not an issue anylonger. We were > not using any SCCA trademarked items. Trans Am is a SCCA trademarked word > so much so infact Pontiac pays the SCCA for every Trans Am they built. I > would be willing to bet all the interested parties were concerned with the > certain painted Trans Am car showing up in a game other then Trans Am
"J. Todd Wasson" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> >>I think this is a case of a mis-informed lawyer. He/She probablybelieves
> >>that RG is somehow profiting by making his patch available. I don'tthink
> >>that any legal action can be taken if the so called copyright/trademark
> >>"violator" isn't making any money.
>
> One more thing. If the "violator" happens to be distributing a productsuch
> as this from a website (the only way to do it, right?) they will begetting
> TONS of new traffic to their site. How much more can they charge for
> advertising now? The "violator" can indeed profit rather well from their
> "free" work if they want to. I'm not saying anyone in particular isindeed
> doing this for anything other than their love of sim racing, but theoption to
> do so is there. I know of one site that is making a free game with thesole
> intent of drawing traffic to sell more of their products. The game itself
> *becomes* advertising to draw traffic to their site, therefore, it hasvalue,
> whether or not there was cash exchanged.
>
> Just my thoughts,
And a good one. That hadn't occurred to me, but it should have. great point
[email hidden] (J. Todd Wasson) writes:
I can buy the disc, that's not the problem, but since my dvdplayer is
bought in HK, I can't play the disc legally bought and imported from
the USA because a collection of corporations (As opposed to any legal
part of any goverment) has decided that I shouldn't be allowed
to. (Apparently buying a movie doesn't give me the right to watch it
from their point of view.)
And since piracy unfortunally is rampant and the market is small, HK
releases are "budget" versions.
> Loaning a book to someone is ok because they can't copy it. An electronic
> book can easily be copied, so I can understand why they might protect it,
> although I wouldn't particularly want to read a book on a computer either :-)
Of course you can copy a book. Copyright law wasn't established as a
response to digital media. (If you think of e.g. educational material
and not just fiction, you understand that you don't neccessarily want
to read the whole book.)
--
-asbjxrn Consultant, n.:
An ordinary man a long way from home.
Quoted text (19 lines)
> >(What really really bugs me (totally off topic here) is the bloody > >stupid dvd zone system. I live in Hong Kong, and want to buy the Hong > >Kong movie "Hidden tiger crouching dragon". But the version that is > >released for the Hong Kong market is a crappy version not much better > >than the pirated vcds pushed at every street corner around here. > >Compared to the US version with lots of special features, and > >anamorphic image. But can I buy the US version and put it in my > >player? Nah, that would probably violate someones rights to something, > >never mind that I would actually have to pay more (And don't mind if I > >get a nice version) to get the US version. And books; when you buy a > >book in a bookshop, you can borrow it to friends and family if it is a > >good book, so now publishers are starting to look into electronic > >books with encryption and watermarks so this communist practice can be > >put to an end. (I don't understand how people stand to read a book on > >a computer myself.)) > > That looks like a great movie, haven't seen it yet though. I > don't know why you can't buy the US version <shrug>. Maybe a > government somewhere won't allow it.
> Considering that Motorsims hasn't updated their own website in over ayear I
> don't hold out much hope for this title. :)
>
> KFG
>
>
>
I understand that, but they have the rights to produce anything relating to
the SCCA and well Dennis Dean made the very very clear to me late last year
when we were searching for more info on autocross courses. WE are still
running the series, but we are careful not to use any SCCA trademarked
names for our little series.
Dave
David G Fisher wrote:
> I don't see how Ubi Soft is doing anything wrong. They are doing what's
> legally required to fullfill their contract. The FIA is protecting their
> very valuable interests. Some people just don't think that contracts and
> laws have to be followed when it comes to games and music.
Paint jobs-valuable assets? Seems like intellectual property to me...
and if people want to afford the same rights to intellectual property as
they do to real property, there should also be a TAX on said property as
well. And not just on the income derived from the sale of that
intellectual property.
Stinking Capitalists. It's all about legalized theft of people's
money...
--
Fester
"David" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:01c0ceea$bb5d58e0$0bd3fc3f@packardbell...
to
> the SCCA and well Dennis Dean made the very very clear to me late lastyear
> when we were searching for more info on autocross courses. WE are still
> running the series, but we are careful not to use any SCCA trademarked
> names for our little series.
>
> Dave
Certainly. And I have no doubt that for some reason Motorsims still
considers itself a viable and going concern and would defend its license
vociferously.
The solution has always been to find a name far enough away from the
trademark to avoid legal conflict, but evocative enough so that everyone
knows what you're really talking about anyway.
Traditionally though, *sponsors* have never objected to their logos being
distributed to the masses. That is, after all, what the logos are FOR!
In this day and age when the consumer will pay *extra* to have someone elses
name embroidered across their arse or a Pepsi logo on their T-shirt the
advertising logo itself has become an actual marketable commodity. The
consumer is now willing to PAY to advertise someone else's company and Pepsi
is compelled to defend their right to collect the proceeds of distributing
their promotional items that they used to give away or sell at a loss.
This is bizarre. This is, like, way out there weird. This is a sign that the
four horsemen of social implosion are about to take a little ride.
KFG
Quoted text (12 lines)
> > > > Considering that Motorsims hasn't updated their own website in over a > year I > > don't hold out much hope for this title. :) > > > > KFG > > > > > > > > I understand that, but they have the rights to produce anything relatingFunny how you know so much about this David....
Me thinks you got a very good 'connection' with Ubi Soft...
Perhaps a too good one....
ed_
David G Fisher <[email hidden]> skrev i
meldingsnyheter:5j4G6.33977$[email hidden]...
Tommy
> Bahama is the
> > sponsor for the #88 Brian Simo Mangusta. They didn't like hispaintscheme
email
Quoted text (24 lines)
> Ubi Soft had to pay the FIA for the rights to the '99 season. > > The FIA wants them to buy the rights to the '00, '01, and '02 season. In > their contract, they force Ubi Soft to enforce the copyright laws so that > the rights to the upcoming seasons are a necessary purchase. > > I don't see how Ubi Soft is doing anything wrong. They are doing what's > legally required to fullfill their contract. The FIA is protecting their > very valuable interests. Some people just don't think that contracts and > laws have to be followed when it comes to games and music. > > David G Fisher > > > "Jan Kohl" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:h2OF6.14108$[email hidden]... > > RG at http://simpaddock.com/ recieved a nice letter yesterday, from > Alston & Bird, > > (http://www.alston.com), attorneys for Tommy Bahama > (http://www.tommybahama.com/). > > > > Why? > > > > Because he was putting together the 2001 Trans Am cars for SCGT, andQuoted text (9 lines)
> being given > > out for free... > > > > First Ubisoft, now them, who's next? It's starting to spread, folks...I > mentioned this > > about a year ago in this post... > > http://www.theuspits.com/pirate1.html > > > > So, what can we do about it? Really only two choices...ignore it, orQuoted text (13 lines)
> the people in > > question. Refusal to purchase their products goes a long way... > > > > Cheers! > > > > -- > > �� Jan Kohl �� > > SECURITY CONSULTANT > > The Pits - http://www.theuspits.com > > Castle Graphics - http://www.castlegraphics.com > > > > >I don't know anyone at Ubi Soft. It just takes a few minutes of research, a
little logic, and a cool head to figure things out.
David G Fisher
"Ed Solheim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:zYHG6.3936$[email hidden]...
that
folks...I
Quoted text (14 lines)
> Funny how you know so much about this David.... > > Me thinks you got a very good 'connection' with Ubi Soft... > Perhaps a too good one.... > > ed_ > > > David G Fisher <[email hidden]> skrev i > meldingsnyheter:5j4G6.33977$[email hidden]... > > Ubi Soft had to pay the FIA for the rights to the '99 season. > > > > The FIA wants them to buy the rights to the '00, '01, and '02 season. In > > their contract, they force Ubi Soft to enforce the copyright laws soQuoted text (28 lines)
> > the rights to the upcoming seasons are a necessary purchase. > > > > I don't see how Ubi Soft is doing anything wrong. They are doing what's > > legally required to fullfill their contract. The FIA is protecting their > > very valuable interests. Some people just don't think that contracts and > > laws have to be followed when it comes to games and music. > > > > David G Fisher > > > > > > "Jan Kohl" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:h2OF6.14108$[email hidden]... > > > RG at http://simpaddock.com/ recieved a nice letter yesterday, from > > Alston & Bird, > > > (http://www.alston.com), attorneys for Tommy Bahama > > (http://www.tommybahama.com/). > > > > > > Why? > > > > > > Because he was putting together the 2001 Trans Am cars for SCGT, and > Tommy > > Bahama is the > > > sponsor for the #88 Brian Simo Mangusta. They didn't like his > paintscheme > > being given > > > out for free... > > > > > > First Ubisoft, now them, who's next? It's starting to spread,Quoted text (21 lines)
> > mentioned this > > > about a year ago in this post... > > > http://www.theuspits.com/pirate1.html > > > > > > So, what can we do about it? Really only two choices...ignore it, or > email > > the people in > > > question. Refusal to purchase their products goes a long way... > > > > > > Cheers! > > > > > > -- > > > �� Jan Kohl �� > > > SECURITY CONSULTANT > > > The Pits - http://www.theuspits.com > > > Castle Graphics - http://www.castlegraphics.com > > > > > > > > > >BTW, would ymenard, Ben Coleman, and Dave Henrie please tell me what other
sites were attacked by the evil Ubi Soft empire. A week ago, they said I was
full of shit when I said that only one site was to be targeted by them for
removal of add-ons.
David G Fisher
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:r7JG6.37219$[email hidden]...
> I don't know anyone at Ubi Soft. It just takes a few minutes of research,a
In
> > > their contract, they force Ubi Soft to enforce the copyright laws so
> that
> > > the rights to the upcoming seasons are a necessary purchase.
> > >
> > > I don't see how Ubi Soft is doing anything wrong. They are doingwhat's
> > > legally required to fullfill their contract. The FIA is protectingtheir
> > > very valuable interests. Some people just don't think that contractsand
Quoted text (19 lines)
> little logic, and a cool head to figure things out. > > David G Fisher > > "Ed Solheim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > news:zYHG6.3936$[email hidden]... > > Funny how you know so much about this David.... > > > > Me thinks you got a very good 'connection' with Ubi Soft... > > Perhaps a too good one.... > > > > ed_ > > > > > > David G Fisher <[email hidden]> skrev i > > meldingsnyheter:5j4G6.33977$[email hidden]... > > > Ubi Soft had to pay the FIA for the rights to the '99 season. > > > > > > The FIA wants them to buy the rights to the '00, '01, and '02 season.Quoted text (46 lines)
> > > laws have to be followed when it comes to games and music. > > > > > > David G Fisher > > > > > > > > > "Jan Kohl" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > > news:h2OF6.14108$[email hidden]... > > > > RG at http://simpaddock.com/ recieved a nice letter yesterday, from > > > Alston & Bird, > > > > (http://www.alston.com), attorneys for Tommy Bahama > > > (http://www.tommybahama.com/). > > > > > > > > Why? > > > > > > > > Because he was putting together the 2001 Trans Am cars for SCGT, and > > Tommy > > > Bahama is the > > > > sponsor for the #88 Brian Simo Mangusta. They didn't like his > > paintscheme > > > being given > > > > out for free... > > > > > > > > First Ubisoft, now them, who's next? It's starting to spread, > folks...I > > > mentioned this > > > > about a year ago in this post... > > > > http://www.theuspits.com/pirate1.html > > > > > > > > So, what can we do about it? Really only two choices...ignore it, or > > email > > > the people in > > > > question. Refusal to purchase their products goes a long way... > > > > > > > > Cheers! > > > > > > > > -- > > > > �� Jan Kohl �� > > > > SECURITY CONSULTANT > > > > The Pits - http://www.theuspits.com > > > > Castle Graphics - http://www.castlegraphics.com > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > >
"David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:baJG6.37220$[email hidden]...
> BTW, would ymenard, Ben Coleman, and Dave Henrie please tell me what other
> sites were attacked by the evil Ubi Soft empire. A week ago, they said Iwas
> full of shit when I said that only one site was to be targeted by them for
> removal of add-ons.
>
> David G Fisher
>Near as I can figure, here is the relavent part of one of my replies on this
subject:::
____
From the sound of their statements they are using the ol Sledgehamer when
a diamond
striker was needed. They chose to go after ALL addons rather than sift
through all the
various sites and utilities and patches and addons and and....you get the
picture.
dave henrie
_______
(you can tell it's mine because of all the cutup lines...)
This statement was made before I heard about the ubi-formulasim
connection. Thats what I get for jumping in before all the story is out.
I will re-affirm tho, that the Both parties at first were not candid with
users. Certainly we couldn't expect UBI to reveal a connection, but the
website authors, who were the ones who leaked the letter, should have made
their connection to UBI known right away. While I have often disagreed
with your determined arguments, I've never said you were full of anything.
(or at least not that I can recall--Mark Furman should have said that too!)
However, I have to thank you for getting me to dig through that thread
again...my good ol newsreader had apparently not sent me all the thread, I
missed the start of the FIXTURE=SHED YULE ...I might add that fixtures
here(in the USA) are faucets & toilets or lightbulb holders.
This all reminds me of the hullabaloo over the lack of the Daytona track
in the early versions of the Papyrus Nascar line. Some guys built it..but
Sierra went after them with Legal Beagles and got them to take it down from
the net. As I have said before and most likely will again...This can only
get worse in the future.
dh
>
> "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> news:r7JG6.37219$[email hidden]...
> > I don't know anyone at Ubi Soft. It just takes a few minutes ofresearch,
season.
from
and
or
Quoted text (20 lines)
> a > > little logic, and a cool head to figure things out. > > > > David G Fisher > > > > "Ed Solheim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:zYHG6.3936$[email hidden]... > > > Funny how you know so much about this David.... > > > > > > Me thinks you got a very good 'connection' with Ubi Soft... > > > Perhaps a too good one.... > > > > > > ed_ > > > > > > > > > David G Fisher <[email hidden]> skrev i > > > meldingsnyheter:5j4G6.33977$[email hidden]... > > > > Ubi Soft had to pay the FIA for the rights to the '99 season. > > > > > > > > The FIA wants them to buy the rights to the '00, '01, and '02Quoted text (19 lines)
> In > > > > their contract, they force Ubi Soft to enforce the copyright laws so > > that > > > > the rights to the upcoming seasons are a necessary purchase. > > > > > > > > I don't see how Ubi Soft is doing anything wrong. They are doing > what's > > > > legally required to fullfill their contract. The FIA is protecting > their > > > > very valuable interests. Some people just don't think that contracts > and > > > > laws have to be followed when it comes to games and music. > > > > > > > > David G Fisher > > > > > > > > > > > > "Jan Kohl" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > > > news:h2OF6.14108$[email hidden]... > > > > > RG at http://simpaddock.com/ recieved a nice letter yesterday,Quoted text (7 lines)
> > > > Alston & Bird, > > > > > (http://www.alston.com), attorneys for Tommy Bahama > > > > (http://www.tommybahama.com/). > > > > > > > > > > Why? > > > > > > > > > > Because he was putting together the 2001 Trans Am cars for SCGT,Quoted text (14 lines)
> > > Tommy > > > > Bahama is the > > > > > sponsor for the #88 Brian Simo Mangusta. They didn't like his > > > paintscheme > > > > being given > > > > > out for free... > > > > > > > > > > First Ubisoft, now them, who's next? It's starting to spread, > > folks...I > > > > mentioned this > > > > > about a year ago in this post... > > > > > http://www.theuspits.com/pirate1.html > > > > > > > > > > So, what can we do about it? Really only two choices...ignore it,Quoted text (18 lines)
> > > email > > > > the people in > > > > > question. Refusal to purchase their products goes a long way... > > > > > > > > > > Cheers! > > > > > > > > > > -- > > > > > �� Jan Kohl �� > > > > > SECURITY CONSULTANT > > > > > The Pits - http://www.theuspits.com > > > > > Castle Graphics - http://www.castlegraphics.com > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > >You don't remember the following?
"Ben Coleman" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> Oh, DGF appears to be full of shit again....!
>
> Ha, ha.
>
> Ben We are all adults here..surely we can use a more scientific word to
describ
the above...how about Poo Poo???
dave :) henrie
"Dave Henrie" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:9AKG6.74013$[email hidden]...
>
> "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
> news:baJG6.37220$[email hidden]...
> > BTW, would ymenard, Ben Coleman, and Dave Henrie please tell me whatother
> > sites were attacked by the evil Ubi Soft empire. A week ago, they said I
> was
> > full of shit when I said that only one site was to be targeted by themfor
> > removal of add-ons.
> >
> > David G Fisher
> >
> Near as I can figure, here is the relavent part of one of my replies onthis
too!)
from
> the net. As I have said before and most likely will again...This canonly
so
contracts
it,
Quoted text (19 lines)
> subject::: > ____ > From the sound of their statements they are using the ol Sledgehamer when > a diamond > striker was needed. They chose to go after ALL addons rather than sift > through all the > various sites and utilities and patches and addons and and....you get the > picture. > dave henrie > _______ > (you can tell it's mine because of all the cutup lines...) > This statement was made before I heard about the ubi-formulasim > connection. Thats what I get for jumping in before all the story is out. > I will re-affirm tho, that the Both parties at first were not candid with > users. Certainly we couldn't expect UBI to reveal a connection, but the > website authors, who were the ones who leaked the letter, should have made > their connection to UBI known right away. While I have often disagreed > with your determined arguments, I've never said you were full of anything. > (or at least not that I can recall--Mark Furman should have said thatQuoted text (7 lines)
> However, I have to thank you for getting me to dig through that thread > again...my good ol newsreader had apparently not sent me all the thread, I > missed the start of the FIXTURE=SHED YULE ...I might add that fixtures > here(in the USA) are faucets & toilets or lightbulb holders. > This all reminds me of the hullabaloo over the lack of the Daytona track > in the early versions of the Papyrus Nascar line. Some guys built it..but > Sierra went after them with Legal Beagles and got them to take it downQuoted text (35 lines)
> get worse in the future. > dh > > > > > > > > > "David G Fisher" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > news:r7JG6.37219$[email hidden]... > > > I don't know anyone at Ubi Soft. It just takes a few minutes of > research, > > a > > > little logic, and a cool head to figure things out. > > > > > > David G Fisher > > > > > > "Ed Solheim" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > > news:zYHG6.3936$[email hidden]... > > > > Funny how you know so much about this David.... > > > > > > > > Me thinks you got a very good 'connection' with Ubi Soft... > > > > Perhaps a too good one.... > > > > > > > > ed_ > > > > > > > > > > > > David G Fisher <[email hidden]> skrev i > > > > meldingsnyheter:5j4G6.33977$[email hidden]... > > > > > Ubi Soft had to pay the FIA for the rights to the '99 season. > > > > > > > > > > The FIA wants them to buy the rights to the '00, '01, and '02 > season. > > In > > > > > their contract, they force Ubi Soft to enforce the copyright lawsQuoted text (8 lines)
> > > that > > > > > the rights to the upcoming seasons are a necessary purchase. > > > > > > > > > > I don't see how Ubi Soft is doing anything wrong. They are doing > > what's > > > > > legally required to fullfill their contract. The FIA is protecting > > their > > > > > very valuable interests. Some people just don't think thatQuoted text (32 lines)
> > and > > > > > laws have to be followed when it comes to games and music. > > > > > > > > > > David G Fisher > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > "Jan Kohl" <[email hidden]> wrote in message > > > > > news:h2OF6.14108$[email hidden]... > > > > > > RG at http://simpaddock.com/ recieved a nice letter yesterday, > from > > > > > Alston & Bird, > > > > > > (http://www.alston.com), attorneys for Tommy Bahama > > > > > (http://www.tommybahama.com/). > > > > > > > > > > > > Why? > > > > > > > > > > > > Because he was putting together the 2001 Trans Am cars for SCGT, > and > > > > Tommy > > > > > Bahama is the > > > > > > sponsor for the #88 Brian Simo Mangusta. They didn't like his > > > > paintscheme > > > > > being given > > > > > > out for free... > > > > > > > > > > > > First Ubisoft, now them, who's next? It's starting to spread, > > > folks...I > > > > > mentioned this > > > > > > about a year ago in this post... > > > > > > http://www.theuspits.com/pirate1.html > > > > > > > > > > > > So, what can we do about it? Really only two choices...ignoreQuoted text (21 lines)
> or > > > > email > > > > > the people in > > > > > > question. Refusal to purchase their products goes a long way... > > > > > > > > > > > > Cheers! > > > > > > > > > > > > -- > > > > > > �� Jan Kohl �� > > > > > > SECURITY CONSULTANT > > > > > > The Pits - http://www.theuspits.com > > > > > > Castle Graphics - http://www.castlegraphics.com > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > > >Sorry, David, but you being full of shit has nothing to do with Ubisoft.
Don't try to pass the blame!
Ben
>"Ben Coleman" <[email hidden]> wrote
> Sorry, David, but you being full of shit has nothing to do with Ubisoft.
> Don't try to pass the blame!
Both are mutually inclusive ;-)
--
-- Fran�ois M�nard <ymenard>
-- May the Downforce be with you...
-- http://www.ymenard.com/
-- This announcement is brought to you by the Shimato Dominguez
Corporation - helping America into the New World...
In article <[email hidden]>, [email hidden] (J.
Todd Wasson) writes:
> The money from those logos are being paid to the racing team/series owners.
>
>The right to use the car(s) in a video game can be sold for quite a lot of
>money, so why would they allow folks to do it for free?
This is what I don't understand. Companies *pay* racing teams to put their
logos on the cars. Companies *pay* TV stations to air their commercials. But,
the companies CHARGE computer game manufacturers? Sound bass-ackwards to me...
:(
Eldred
--
Dale Earnhardt, Sr. R.I.P. 1951-2001
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
F1 hcp. +28.67...F2 +151.26...
Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you
with experience...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
>This is what I don't understand. Companies *pay* racing teams to put their
>logos on the cars. Companies *pay* TV stations to air their commercials.
>But,
>the companies CHARGE computer game manufacturers? Sound bass-ackwards to
>me...
>:(
The way I see it, Pepsi might pay racing teams to put its logo on their cars
because it's advertising for Pepsi. The logo itself won't make the real car
faster or have any value in itself obviously, except to Pepsi, because if we
see enough Pepsi logos in one day, we get thirsty and the first thing that pops
into our minds is "Pepsi". Pepsi would pay a TV station to air a commercial
for advertising for the same reason. The TV station wouldn't want to do it for
free because then we switch the channel, causing their commercial slots to lose
value. Basically, they pay the TV station to do it because it's valuable
enough to Pepsi to kick out $xxxx. You know that already, I'm sure.
What about computer game manufacturers? What if a game company released a
game entitled "Really Fast Racecars" with a bunch of American looking "stock"
cars that you've never seen on TV before, had no idea where the cars are from
or what kind they are, nor had any other reason to get excited about it because
you've never heard of them, while another game company releases a game entitled
"Nascar Racing", with all the real race tracks, real drivers, etc., from the
Nascar series?
I'd bet that the "Nascar Racing" title would make TONS more money, even
though it really didn't cost substantially more to actually produce. If you
stood to make $5 million more by licensing your company's game as "Nascar
Racing", and Nascar's marketing department figured that out as well, would you
pay them maybe a cool million for the rights if they "asked"? I sure would if
I could (not anytime this millenium :-))
Sure, the Nascar series would probably get slightly more viewers and ticket
sales because of the "promotional advertising", but let's face it, the reason
the "Nascar Racing" title would be so popular is because the Nascar series is
already famous among the people that are purchasing the game. There are people
all over r.a.s. screaming for a CART game. The "advertising" is wasted on them
because they're already avid CART fans. That's the reason they'll buy the next
CART game in the first place. Not too many people were probably first exposed
to the CART series AFTER having bought a game, resulting in millions of new
money spending, TV-advertisement-during-a-race watching fans.
I'm sure you'd agree that Nascar (or whatever car team, racing series, track
owner, etc.,) has a marketing team that looks at sales figures and decides
whether it's worth it to pay the game company for their "promotional
advertising", or whether they could attempt to charge them instead. However,
as Tom Pabst pointed out in another post, this might be the way it is today
primarily because of the first couple of game companies that approached a track
or racing series about including their stuff in a game, perhaps foolishly
neglecting to make a good sales presentation and offering them a check instead
(probably knowing full well that the game's sales would increase *dramatically*
because of the series or track inclusion). However, I find it difficult to
believe that it would have continued this way. I'm no marketing expert and
don't have much experience here, so I'm open to reading other views on this,
but I think eventually racing series and track owners would have figured out
how much more money a game makes when it has the Laguna Seca raceway in it, and
all the cars are Champ cars :-)
On the other hand, perhaps a small, unheard-of racing series or track might
benefit from the "advertising" created by including the series or track in a
game. You could go to the store and think, "Hmmm.. This looks kinda neat.
Never heard of this series before and those tracks, although I've never seen
them on TV or anything, look fun to drive on. I think I'll try the game,"
Then, you might try it, fall in love, and dart out to the game track or turn on
the boob-tube and check out a rerun race at 2am, then buy the T-shirt for
$19.95 and tell all your friends about the Speedo-BOB racing series that's
running this weekend at the Shakopee 3/8th mile raceway. In that case, it
would be financially in the best interest of the "unheard-of" series or track
to pay the game company for the advertising, since they really aren't producing
as much money in sales for the game company as they receive as a result of the
"advertising".
It think the deciding factor in the end of all this is really, who is making
more money for whom? Is the game making more money because the racing series
is included in it, or is it the other way around? Apparantly, even though we
don't like it, the game title makes the truckload of cash because of the
inclusion of a big racing series, set of teams from one particular year or
another "that we all want" and will pay the series a chunk of it. After all,
the Nascar series would STILL get their "promotional advertising", but now they
get paid, too :-)
Just my theory on why it is the way it is. I don't think a clever sales pitch
to a track early on would have made things stick one way or the other. It's
just a matter of time before everyone knows how much $ the other side is
making. Maybe it'll change though, I'd be a happier person too :-)
Todd Wasson
---
Performance Simulations
Drag Racing and Top Speed Prediction
Software
http://PerformanceSimulations.Com
In article <[email hidden]>, [email hidden] (J.
Todd Wasson) writes:
Can you say, Mercedes-Benz Truck Racing? I never really cared to watch
it(truck racing), until I played the demo. Now I *want* to watch it, but it
doesn't air in the US... :(
Eldred
--
Dale Earnhardt, Sr. R.I.P. 1951-2001
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
F1 hcp. +27.07...F2 +151.26...
Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you
with experience...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Quoted text (16 lines)
> On the other hand, perhaps a small, unheard-of racing series or track might >benefit from the "advertising" created by including the series or track in a >game. You could go to the store and think, "Hmmm.. This looks kinda neat. >Never heard of this series before and those tracks, although I've never seen >them on TV or anything, look fun to drive on. I think I'll try the game," >Then, you might try it, fall in love, and dart out to the game track or turn >on >the boob-tube and check out a rerun race at 2am, then buy the T-shirt for >$19.95 and tell all your friends about the Speedo-BOB racing series that's >running this weekend at the Shakopee 3/8th mile raceway. In that case, it >would be financially in the best interest of the "unheard-of" series or track >to pay the game company for the advertising, since they really aren't >producing >as much money in sales for the game company as they receive as a result of >the >"advertising". Speedvision on Friday afternoon/evening there is a British program called
Motorsport Mundial which covers in short little segments all kinds of racing
INCLUDING some truck races. You will get a dose of rallye and indoor
Observed Trials motorcycling...I've often wondered how to pronounce that is
it..Observ-ED trials or Observd trials???? Whatever, those guys will
amaaaaaaaaze you with the control they have with those tiny little popcorn
engines...where was I?? Oh yes Trucks...they are sometimes on the show...I
just read in Auto-week that portions of Detroit, where the Ford Corporate
Offices are located, don't get Speedvision, Hence..the Ford bigwigs can't
watch the Jaguar's they paid big money for.....hmmmmm maybe that's not a bad
thing....
rambling over...
dave henrie
"EldredP" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
> In article <[email hidden]>,[email hidden] (J.
> Todd Wasson) writes:
>
> > On the other hand, perhaps a small, unheard-of racing series or trackmight
> >benefit from the "advertising" created by including the series or trackin a
> >game. You could go to the store and think, "Hmmm.. This looks kindaneat.
> >Never heard of this series before and those tracks, although I've neverseen
> >them on TV or anything, look fun to drive on. I think I'll try thegame,"
> >Then, you might try it, fall in love, and dart out to the game track orturn
> >on
> >the boob-tube and check out a rerun race at 2am, then buy the T-shirt for
> >$19.95 and tell all your friends about the Speedo-BOB racing seriesthat's
> >running this weekend at the Shakopee 3/8th mile raceway. In that case,it
> >would be financially in the best interest of the "unheard-of" series ortrack
> >to pay the game company for the advertising, since they really aren't
> >producing
> >as much money in sales for the game company as they receive as a resultof
> >the
> >"advertising".
>
> Can you say, Mercedes-Benz Truck Racing? I never really cared to watch
> it(truck racing), until I played the demo. Now I *want* to watch it, butit
you
> with experience...
> Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Quoted text (9 lines)
> doesn't air in the US... :( > > Eldred > -- > Dale Earnhardt, Sr. R.I.P. 1951-2001 > Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett > F1 hcp. +27.07...F2 +151.26... > > Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beatsQuoted text (18 lines)
>>Then, you might try it, fall in love, and dart out to the game track or turn >>on >>the boob-tube and check out a rerun race at 2am, then buy the T-shirt for >>$19.95 and tell all your friends about the Speedo-BOB racing series that's >>running this weekend at the Shakopee 3/8th mile raceway. In that case, it >>would be financially in the best interest of the "unheard-of" series or >track >>to pay the game company for the advertising, since they really aren't >>producing >>as much money in sales for the game company as they receive as a result of >>the >>"advertising". > >Can you say, Mercedes-Benz Truck Racing? I never really cared to watch >it(truck racing), until I played the demo. Now I *want* to watch it, but it >doesn't air in the US... :( > >EldredIn article <XILH6.93005$[email hidden]>, "Dave Henrie"
<[email hidden]> writes:
The Mowtown pak for Comcast Cablevision includes Speedvision. At least it did
in MY zip code... I'll have to check the schedule for that program.
I've seen the Trials before. That's where the ride over all sorts of
obstacles? Yes, truly amazing...
Eldred
--
Dale Earnhardt, Sr. R.I.P. 1951-2001
Homepage - http://www.umich.edu/~epickett
F1 hcp. +27.07...F2 +151.26...
Never argue with an idiot. He brings you down to his level, then beats you
with experience...
Remove SPAM-OFF to reply.
Quoted text (11 lines)
> Speedvision on Friday afternoon/evening there is a British program called >Motorsport Mundial which covers in short little segments all kinds of racing >INCLUDING some truck races. You will get a dose of rallye and indoor >Observed Trials motorcycling...I've often wondered how to pronounce that is >it..Observ-ED trials or Observd trials???? Whatever, those guys will >amaaaaaaaaze you with the control they have with those tiny little popcorn >engines...where was I?? Oh yes Trucks...they are sometimes on the show...I >just read in Auto-week that portions of Detroit, where the Ford Corporate >Offices are located, don't get Speedvision, Hence..the Ford bigwigs can't >watch the Jaguar's they paid big money for.....hmmmmm maybe that's not a bad >thing....I remember watching some semi's racing on Speedvision. It was quite
a site! I'd love to see more of it! Is the Mercedes truck racing
the ones with semi's?
The only downside was there was a speedlimit on some parts of the
track (enforced by radar).
Tim.
N4 Online: Van@BRS
"Dave Henrie" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:XILH6.93005$[email hidden]...
> it..Observ-ED trials or Observd trials???? Whatever, those guys will
observD
Go Dougie Lampkin!
:)
cheers
John
yes
Euro heavy haulers.
dave henrie
"Tim Vannaman" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...


































