Hi,
1) I would like to know if the graph slip angle/lateral forces is the same
for every surfaces/tires by a coefficient on lateral force. Or the same by a
coefficient on slip angles . Or completly different.
IMO this how i see the different graphs
TARMAC
Lat force
^
6� 15�
DIRT
Lat force
^
10� 20�
2) If it is do you know where could i find those graphs for
dirt/snow/tarmac/gravel/etc... surfaces ?
Thanks in advance
--
Seb
Game Developer
GPLRank -41.68
http://magicfr.multimania.com
Notable threadHow tyre slip-angle curves change on different surfaces
Sebastien Tixier asked whether a tyre's lateral force curve peaks at the same slip angle on tarmac, dirt and ice. Ashley McConnell cited friction ratios, while Gregor Veble, J. Todd Wasson and Dave Pollatsek argued the linear slope stays similar so peaks occur at smaller angles on low grip, and that loose surfaces need an added slip-velocity-dependent force. Tixier revealed he had worked on PlayStation versions of V-Rally 2 and Need for Speed Porsche Unleashed.
With Sebastien Tixier (game developer, V-Rally 2 and NFS Porsche Unleashed PSX)
physics/realism debate
Automated summary.
Hi Seb,
From what I understand (from G.Genta's book) the peak force is reduced by a
ratio in these graphs. This would lead to the sort of graphs that you have
presented below. In terms of the Pacekja formula i'd say this translates to
multiplying the "D" coefficient by the ratio, eg. 1 = tarmac, 0.7 = grass,
0.5 = ice. Sorry I dont know the specific ratios, although I will have a
look in the book tonight to see if there are any guidelines.
You will of course want to do this for the Longitudnal Force AND Lateral
Force Calculations
Please someone correct me if this is wrong, cause this is what I will be
using!!
Hope this helps a bit
Ash
"S�bastien Tixier" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
| Hi,
|
| 1) I would like to know if the graph slip angle/lateral forces is the same
| for every surfaces/tires by a coefficient on lateral force. Or the same bya
Quoted text (54 lines)
| coefficient on slip angles . Or completly different. | | IMO this how i see the different graphs | | TARMAC | | | Lat force | ^ | | | | * | | * * | | * * | | * ** | | * *** | | * ********* | | * ********** | | * | |* | |* | |--------------------------------> angle deg | 6� 15� | | | | | DIRT | | Lat force | ^ | | | | | | | | | | ** | | ** ** | | * *** | | * **** | | * ****** | | * ********* | |* | |--------------------------------> angle deg | 10� 20� | | 2) If it is do you know where could i find those graphs for | dirt/snow/tarmac/gravel/etc... surfaces ? | | Thanks in advance | | -- | Seb | Game Developer | GPLRank -41.68 | http://magicfr.multimania.comSeb,
Just had a quick look in the book it has the following (converted into
ratios) :-
Concrete - Dry 0.94 Wet 0.72
Tarmac - Dry 1.0 Wet 0.88 Snow 0.42 Ice 0.16
This is for radial tyres.
Hope this helps
Ash
"Ashley McConnell" <[email hidden]> wrote in
<9dtv50$o7o$[email hidden]>:
Hum, i was not clear in my question :o(
I know that the peak force is reduced when grip is reduced.
I would like to know if peak force is moved on slip angle axle with
different grips , for exemple:
on tarmac, the peak force appeared at 6� of slip angle, i would like to know
if the peak force on ice appeared also at 6� or another angle ? 10� ? 2� ?
I also would like to know if after the peak force the force decreased the
same amount on tarmac and ice , for exemple.
On tarmac on high slip angle ( > 15� ) coef is .75, does it the same on
grass, or less ?
anyway thanks for the peak force coefficients !
regards,
--
Seb
Game Developer
GPLRank -41.68
http://magicfr.multimania.com
Quoted text (10 lines)
>Hi Seb, > >From what I understand (from G.Genta's book) the peak force is reduced >by a ratio in these graphs. This would lead to the sort of graphs that >you have presented below. In terms of the Pacekja formula i'd say this >translates to multiplying the "D" coefficient by the ratio, eg. 1 = >tarmac, 0.7 = grass, 0.5 = ice. Sorry I dont know the specific ratios, >although I will have a look in the book tonight to see if there are any >guidelines. >Ok, I see what you mean,
I think that the peak will appear in exactly the same slip angle, however
the peak will be lower. This is based on the fact that u(yp) is the peak and
D = u(yp) x Fz. So basically you are multiplying every point on the graph
by the ratio...which wouldnt move the peak, just raise or lower it.
If you see any probs with my idea, please tell me - i want to get it right
too :)
Hope this helps
Ash
know
Quoted text (8 lines)
| Hum, i was not clear in my question :o( | | I know that the peak force is reduced when grip is reduced. | | I would like to know if peak force is moved on slip angle axle with | different grips , for exemple: | | on tarmac, the peak force appeared at 6� of slip angle, i would like toQuoted text (18 lines)
| if the peak force on ice appeared also at 6� or another angle ? 10� ? 2� ? | | I also would like to know if after the peak force the force decreased the | same amount on tarmac and ice , for exemple. | | On tarmac on high slip angle ( > 15� ) coef is .75, does it the same on | grass, or less ? | | | anyway thanks for the peak force coefficients ! | | regards, | | -- | Seb | Game Developer | GPLRank -41.68 | http://magicfr.multimania.comHi Sebastian!
In principle there is no reason why the peak should be reached at the
same angle on all surfaces, and indeed I would think it in fact isn't.
Let's assume that the behaviour of the tire in the linear regime (very
small slip angles) depends entirely on the structure of the tire and not
on the surface properties itself. It's a plausible assumption since a
very small portion of the contact patch is actually slipping in this
regime, and the maximum ammount of grip doesn't come into the picture
yet. In this case, the cornering stiffness of the tyre, which is the
slope of the force vs. the slip angle curve (dF/dS) close to S=0, should
not depend on the maximum grip available and should be constant for all
surfaces.
Therefore, if the same (rescaled) shape of the force vs. slip curve is
used for all surfaces, the maximum grip and the optimal slip angle
(where peak force is reached) are directly proportional in the above
model, assuming the vertical load is kept constant. The model could be
completely wrong, of course :).
-Gregor
"S�bastien Tixier" wrote:
Quoted text (26 lines)
> > Hum, i was not clear in my question :o( > > I know that the peak force is reduced when grip is reduced. > > I would like to know if peak force is moved on slip angle axle with > different grips , for exemple: > > on tarmac, the peak force appeared at 6� of slip angle, i would like to know > if the peak force on ice appeared also at 6� or another angle ? 10� ? 2� ? > > I also would like to know if after the peak force the force decreased the > same amount on tarmac and ice , for exemple. > > On tarmac on high slip angle ( > 15� ) coef is .75, does it the same on > grass, or less ? > > anyway thanks for the peak force coefficients ! > > regards, > > -- > Seb > Game Developer > GPLRank -41.68 > http://magicfr.multimania.comGregor Veble <[email hidden]> wrote in
<[email hidden]>:
>Hi Sebastian!
>
>In principle there is no reason why the peak should be reached at the
>same angle on all surfaces,
Okey, i understand that. Moreover i'll say that the angle where the peak is
reached depend of the couple tyre/surface.
> and indeed I would think it in fact isn't.
>
>Let's assume that the behaviour of the tire in the linear regime (very[SNIP]
>completely wrong, of course :).
Waow ... my english is not enough well simulated to understand completly
what you said ... could you try with word more simple ? :o)))
thanks in advance.
Maybe you could try in French ;o)
--
Seb
Game Developer
GPLRank -41.68
http://magicfr.multimania.com
"Ashley McConnell" <[email hidden]> wrote in
<9du24k$pvj$[email hidden]>:
>Ok, I see what you mean,
>
>I think that the peak will appear in exactly the same slip angle,
I drove real cars on different kind of tire on different kind of surfaces,
and the feeling i had was in contradiction with this.
On earth, for exemple, everything is smoother, you have to turn more the
wheel to find the peak of force , i mean longer and smoother motion than on
tarmac. IMHO.
>however the peak will be lower. This is based on the fact that u(yp) is
>the peak and D = u(yp) x Fz. So basically you are multiplying every
>point on the graph by the ratio...which wouldnt move the peak, just
>raise or lower it.
Well, currently this is the model i used, and the feeling is not good on
dirt/ice tracks, the sliding is too sharp but with smaller grip.
>If you see any probs with my idea, please tell me - i want to get it
>right too :)
IMO a graph on earth/ice will be like a tarmac graph but larger i.e. the
peak force will be reach at higher slip angle, and also the force will be
slower at high slip angle.
for exemple, if this array is MAX = F( slip angle ) and lat = MAX * grip
tarmac earth ice
slip angle
0 0 0 0
6 1 .5 .5
10 .75 1 1
15 .65 .5 .5
20 .6 .45 .4
25 .55 .4 .35
grip 1 .5 .15
to be sure, we need graph of real experience, do you know somebody working
at GoodYear or Michellin ??? ;o)))
regards,
--
Seb
Game Developer
GPLRank -41.68
http://magicfr.multimania.com
Hehe Sebastien!
(sorry for misspelling your name the first time; still, I can't produce
the accents ;) )
In simpler terms; slip angle is produced because the tyres flex under
sideways forces. The stronger the sideways force, the more the tyre
twists and the higher the slip angle. If the maximum force is lower due
to the lower coefficient of grip, then the corresponding peak slip angle
will also be lower.
In the theory I've given, the peak slip angle is directly proportional
to the maximum grip (if the general shape of the curve remains the same).
-Gregor
S�bastien Tixier wrote:
Quoted text (30 lines)
> Gregor Veble <[email hidden]> wrote in > <[email hidden]>: > > >> Hi Sebastian! >> >> In principle there is no reason why the peak should be reached at the >> same angle on all surfaces, > > > Okey, i understand that. Moreover i'll say that the angle where the peak is > reached depend of the couple tyre/surface. > > > >> and indeed I would think it in fact isn't. >> >> Let's assume that the behaviour of the tire in the linear regime (very > > [SNIP] > >> completely wrong, of course :). > > > Waow ... my english is not enough well simulated to understand completly > what you said ... could you try with word more simple ? :o))) > > thanks in advance. > > Maybe you could try in French ;o) Hi Sebastien,
I agree with Gregor's posts. According to a lateral "brush" model I wrote a
couple months ago, his descriptions are valid. The slope of the graph in the
"linear" part (not yet sliding much, or at low slip angles below the peak,
before the graph curves towards the peak grip), should remain approximately
constant at a given load/vertical force. The peak force slip angle (according
to my model anyway) varies along according to the peak grip coefficient
available.
For instance, my brush model shows results something like this:
Tarmac
* ***********
*
*
*
*
*
*
*
Mud
* ********
*
*
*
*
*
The peak force slip angle moves along the initial sloped line.
Todd Wasson
---
Performance Simulations
Drag Racing and Top Speed Prediction
Software
http://PerformanceSimulations.Com
I've never been able to find slip angle curves for non-asphalt tire
behavior, probably because you can't coat the roller on a tire dyno with
dirt or snow! I've had fantasies of bolting a 5th wheel with force sensors
off the side of a big school bus or something and driving around on dirt
roads with the wheel at different angles and loads... maybe we could all
chip in or something ;)
So in place of actual facts or knowlege, here's some pure speculation:
I had thought that the slip angle effect was a combination of the sidewall
flex and also the transition of each piece of rubber from sliding to
gripping to sliding as it passes under the contact patch. So the sidewall
flex component would lead to an early peak on slippy surfaces, while the
slip/grip effect would probably cause the peak to be later...
From personal experience, it feels like snow and dirt have very wide slip
angles, just because you can really hang the back end out and get it to come
back with just getting off the gas. I've used higher peak slip angles when
modeling dirt/offroad, and it feels okay... the bigger problem being the
lack of a more interesting surface with deformable bits and ruts and all
that.
Wet asphalt seems weirder--sometimes it feels more like the low-friction,
narrow-angle thing, but occasionally you can get some large slip angles that
still feel like you're on the near side of the peak--I suppose wet asphalt
has a very high variability because many surfaces that have similar grip
while dry (e.g. rubber and concrete) have completely different grip levels
while wet (as I saw a wrecked Merkur at Brainerd), plus the effect of
hydroplaning.
I also have often wondered with snow and dirt if there is a combination of
more traditional tire-deformation slip angle stuff at low angles, and more
of a viscous drag-type of effects at wider slip angles. Another factor is
that on loose surfaces there is motion within the driving surface, so that
will also widen the peak--here's a thought experiment that may or may not
relate to any real-world phenomena--picture a car driving on a thin but
large-area sheet of concrete laid over a dirt surface... a car could be
driving in a large circle on this object at the peak-friction slip angle,
_relative to the concrete_, however, the concrete is also sliding laterally
on the dirt due to the force of the car, and if this was say a linear
viscous drag it would cause the car to be driving at a wide slip angle
relative to the dirt...
"Gregor Veble" <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
is
Quoted text (29 lines)
> Hehe Sebastien! > > (sorry for misspelling your name the first time; still, I can't produce > the accents ;) ) > > In simpler terms; slip angle is produced because the tyres flex under > sideways forces. The stronger the sideways force, the more the tyre > twists and the higher the slip angle. If the maximum force is lower due > to the lower coefficient of grip, then the corresponding peak slip angle > will also be lower. > > In the theory I've given, the peak slip angle is directly proportional > to the maximum grip (if the general shape of the curve remains the same). > > -Gregor > > S�bastien Tixier wrote: > > > Gregor Veble <[email hidden]> wrote in > > <[email hidden]>: > > > > > >> Hi Sebastian! > >> > >> In principle there is no reason why the peak should be reached at the > >> same angle on all surfaces, > > > > > > Okey, i understand that. Moreover i'll say that the angle where the peakQuoted text (20 lines)
> > reached depend of the couple tyre/surface. > > > > > > > >> and indeed I would think it in fact isn't. > >> > >> Let's assume that the behaviour of the tire in the linear regime (very > > > > [SNIP] > > > >> completely wrong, of course :). > > > > > > Waow ... my english is not enough well simulated to understand completly > > what you said ... could you try with word more simple ? :o))) > > > > thanks in advance. > > > > Maybe you could try in French ;o) >Hi Dave!
A very interesting post. What you say about loose surfaces is absolutely
true, the rear can be hanged out more than on asphalt, we all see that
in rallying. I posted a while ago that in such circumstances the force
doesn't depend on the slip angle anymore, but that there must also exist
a component that is proportional directly to the slipping velocity,
which is exactly the viscous component you suggested. I'm glad that you
find it in accord with real world experience as well (it's what it's all
about, isn;t it?).
To summarize, I still believe that in a low grip situation the component
of the force that comes from the slip angle peaks at a lower slip angle
that on a high grip surface, but if that surface is also loose (dirt,
snow), an additional component exists that is proportional to the
slipping velocity itself and as such allows cars to drift at large
angles.
-Gregor
Dave Pollatsek wrote:
<snip>
Quoted text (14 lines)
> > I also have often wondered with snow and dirt if there is a combination of > more traditional tire-deformation slip angle stuff at low angles, and more > of a viscous drag-type of effects at wider slip angles. Another factor is > that on loose surfaces there is motion within the driving surface, so that > will also widen the peak--here's a thought experiment that may or may not > relate to any real-world phenomena--picture a car driving on a thin but > large-area sheet of concrete laid over a dirt surface... a car could be > driving in a large circle on this object at the peak-friction slip angle, > _relative to the concrete_, however, the concrete is also sliding laterally > on the dirt due to the force of the car, and if this was say a linear > viscous drag it would cause the car to be driving at a wide slip angle > relative to the dirt... >Hi Todd,
I'm glad numerical experimentation confirmed my thoughts. Phew :).
-Gregor
"J. Todd Wasson" wrote:
Quoted text (11 lines)
> > Hi Sebastien, > > I agree with Gregor's posts. According to a lateral "brush" model I wrote a > couple months ago, his descriptions are valid. The slope of the graph in the > "linear" part (not yet sliding much, or at low slip angles below the peak, > before the graph curves towards the peak grip), should remain approximately > constant at a given load/vertical force. The peak force slip angle (according > to my model anyway) varies along according to the peak grip coefficient > available. >I'm a little surprised that nobody has suggested looking at how *real*
cars behave. On asphalt all racing cars have a fairly low slip angle,
much less visible than in the 1950s, probably due to much wider tires
and using radial construction. On dirt all racing cars hang out the
tail to a very considerable degree. I think there's an additional
aspect that isn't being modelled with the tradional tire models I
suspsect that it's due to the tire "leaning" on the dirt to the side
of the tire. When the slip angle is sufficiently large the dirt seems
to build up on the side to the point where it assists the tire. And
of course at these large slip angles there is a radial component to
the force produced by the spinning tires. I haven't seen any
literature on the subject, but it certainly seems more complex than
taking an asphalt tire curve and reducing the available friction.
Bob
On Thu, 17 May 2001 09:43:47 +0200, Gregor Veble
<[email hidden]> wrote:
Quoted text (36 lines)
>Hi Dave! > >A very interesting post. What you say about loose surfaces is absolutely >true, the rear can be hanged out more than on asphalt, we all see that >in rallying. I posted a while ago that in such circumstances the force >doesn't depend on the slip angle anymore, but that there must also exist >a component that is proportional directly to the slipping velocity, >which is exactly the viscous component you suggested. I'm glad that you >find it in accord with real world experience as well (it's what it's all >about, isn;t it?). > >To summarize, I still believe that in a low grip situation the component >of the force that comes from the slip angle peaks at a lower slip angle >that on a high grip surface, but if that surface is also loose (dirt, >snow), an additional component exists that is proportional to the >slipping velocity itself and as such allows cars to drift at large >angles. > >-Gregor > >Dave Pollatsek wrote: ><snip> >> >> I also have often wondered with snow and dirt if there is a combination of >> more traditional tire-deformation slip angle stuff at low angles, and more >> of a viscous drag-type of effects at wider slip angles. Another factor is >> that on loose surfaces there is motion within the driving surface, so that >> will also widen the peak--here's a thought experiment that may or may not >> relate to any real-world phenomena--picture a car driving on a thin but >> large-area sheet of concrete laid over a dirt surface... a car could be >> driving in a large circle on this object at the peak-friction slip angle, >> _relative to the concrete_, however, the concrete is also sliding laterally >> on the dirt due to the force of the car, and if this was say a linear >> viscous drag it would cause the car to be driving at a wide slip angle >> relative to the dirt... >>Hi Bob,
actually, that's what is implied with the component of force that is
proportional to the slip velocity. Such a component arises since some
material is accelerated in proportion to the slipping velocity, and this
is exactly the buildup you are talking about.
-Gregor
Bob Norton wrote:
Quoted text (16 lines)
> I'm a little surprised that nobody has suggested looking at how *real* > cars behave. On asphalt all racing cars have a fairly low slip angle, > much less visible than in the 1950s, probably due to much wider tires > and using radial construction. On dirt all racing cars hang out the > tail to a very considerable degree. I think there's an additional > aspect that isn't being modelled with the tradional tire models I > suspsect that it's due to the tire "leaning" on the dirt to the side > of the tire. When the slip angle is sufficiently large the dirt seems > to build up on the side to the point where it assists the tire. And > of course at these large slip angles there is a radial component to > the force produced by the spinning tires. I haven't seen any > literature on the subject, but it certainly seems more complex than > taking an asphalt tire curve and reducing the available friction. > > Bob >Great !
very interesting infos here !
Let me summurize, correct me if i'm wrong
Okey so for a couple tyre/surface we have 3 parameters
Grip
Longitudinal viscosity
Lateral viscosity
Longitudinal_Force = F_long( slip_angle, slip_ratio ) * Grip * Load
+ Long_visc * Long_speed
Lateral_Force = F_lat( slip_angle, slip_ratio ) * Grip * Load
+ Lat_visc * Lat_speed
Of course long_visc is much smaller than lat_visc and close to zero except
for surface like sand/water.
We can also say that those viscosity coef depend of tyre depth in the
material.
well thanks everybody of those very usefull informations !
regards,
--
Seb
Game Developer
http://www.eden-studios.fr
GPLRank -41.68
http://magicfr.multimania.com
Sebastien,
yup, that's a simple theory I would start with if I did this. Although,
what you name Long_speed should not be the speed of the tyre but the
slip speed (i.e. Long_Speed - Ang_Vel*R), the same that enters the
slip_ratio equation. But you probably know that already :).
Also, I have absolutely no idea how Lat_visc should change with Load,
but making it proportional to the Load on the tyres is probably a good
initial approximation (much like the usual grip).
-Gregor
"S�bastien Tixier" wrote:
Quoted text (34 lines)
> > Great ! > > very interesting infos here ! > > Let me summurize, correct me if i'm wrong > > Okey so for a couple tyre/surface we have 3 parameters > > Grip > Longitudinal viscosity > Lateral viscosity > > Longitudinal_Force = F_long( slip_angle, slip_ratio ) * Grip * Load > + Long_visc * Long_speed > > Lateral_Force = F_lat( slip_angle, slip_ratio ) * Grip * Load > + Lat_visc * Lat_speed > > Of course long_visc is much smaller than lat_visc and close to zero except > for surface like sand/water. > We can also say that those viscosity coef depend of tyre depth in the > material. > > well thanks everybody of those very usefull informations ! > > regards, > > -- > Seb > Game Developer > http://www.eden-studios.fr > GPLRank -41.68 > http://magicfr.multimania.com>I also have often wondered with snow and dirt if there is a combination of
>more traditional tire-deformation slip angle stuff at low angles, and more
>of a viscous drag-type of effects at wider slip angles. Another factor is
>that on loose surfaces there is motion within the driving surface, so that
>will also widen the peak-
Good thinking, Dave. My hack attempt at a brush model doesn't let the parts
of the ground surface move. This would probably warp the curves more towards
what the original poster was indicating.
Todd Wasson
---
Performance Simulations
Drag Racing and Top Speed Prediction
Software
http://PerformanceSimulations.Com
Gregor Veble <[email hidden]> wrote in
<[email hidden]>:
>Sebastien,
>
>yup, that's a simple theory I would start with if I did this. Although,
>what you name Long_speed should not be the speed of the tyre but the
>slip speed (i.e. Long_Speed - Ang_Vel*R), the same that enters the
>slip_ratio equation. But you probably know that already :).
Well,i really meant longitudinal speed. long_visc will be a resistive force
. It will be Null on tarmac, and very high on deep sand. It's a viscosity
and not a friction force. I mean if you'r driving in sand/water without
spinning there is high resistive force because of fluid's mechanics issue.
In fact its more complicated because long_visc must be dependant of wheel
rotation. It's obvious that longitudinal viscosity is lower when the wheel
is rotating.
>
>Also, I have absolutely no idea how Lat_visc should change with Load,
>but making it proportional to the Load on the tyres is probably a good
>initial approximation (much like the usual grip).
Again, because we are talking about viscosity, i thought that lat_visc would
be more proportional with the tire depth in the material than the load.But
it's obvious that tire depth in material is proportional to the load, but
the funcion depth = F( load) is different for every surface.
So, the funcions could be this :
Longitudinal Grip Force = F( slip_ratio, slip_angle ) * Grip * Load
Longitudinal Viscosity Force = ( F( slip_ratio ) + long_speed ) *
Long_visc * F( Surface,Load )
Longitudinal Force = Longitudinal Grip Force + Longitudinal Viscosity Force
Lateral Grip Force = F( slip_angle, slip_ratio ) * Grip * Load
Lateral Viscosity Force = lat_speed * Lat_visc * F( Surface,Load )
Lateral Force = Lateral Grip Force + LonLateral gitudinal Viscosity Force
So, what do you think about this ?
--
Seb
Game Developer
http://www.eden-studios.fr
GPLRank -41.68
http://magicfr.multimania.com
Hi Sebastien!
"S�bastien Tixier" wrote:
Actually, I would treat this resistive force as an additional component
and separately to the slipping velocity. I fully agree, there is
resistance simply from driving with no slip, but that should IMHO be
less than when, for example, the wheel is locked and is pushing the
material forward as well.
I would introduce two components, one (typically smaller) that is
proportional to the longitudinal velocity itself, and another one that
has a higher viscosity coefficient and is proportinal to the
longitudinal slip velocity. I think this is something you took into
account in the following equation
> Longitudinal Viscosity Force = ( F( slip_ratio ) + long_speed ) *
> Long_visc * F( Surface,Load )
but I would actually write it as
Longitudinal Viscosity Force = ( long_slip_speed * Long_visc +
long_speed * Long_visc_small) *
F( Surface,Load )
where
long_slip_speed = long_speed - Angular_velocity * R
-Gregor
Quoted text (9 lines)
> > Well,i really meant longitudinal speed. long_visc will be a resistive force > . It will be Null on tarmac, and very high on deep sand. It's a viscosity > and not a friction force. I mean if you'r driving in sand/water without > spinning there is high resistive force because of fluid's mechanics issue. > In fact its more complicated because long_visc must be dependant of wheel > rotation. It's obvious that longitudinal viscosity is lower when the wheel > is rotating. >Quoted text (9 lines)
>but I would actually write it as > >Longitudinal Viscosity Force = ( long_slip_speed * Long_visc + >long_speed * Long_visc_small) * > F( Surface,Load ) > >where > >long_slip_speed = long_speed - Angular_velocity * RHi Sebastien!
"S�bastien Tixier" wrote:
>
> hehehe, it's very intersting because this is just what i had modeled after
> sending my previous post :o)
> Moreover long_slip_speed info is very usefull for all Graphicals effects,
> tire skids, tarmac burning smoke, gravel projections,etc.
>
That's great to hear, probably this means we're on the right track ;).
Be sure to let me know how it turned out!
-Gregor
Gregor Veble <[email hidden]> wrote in
<[email hidden]>:
Well, for now, my team-mate and i are working to making work correctly the
"ellipse" grip and the chain engine->gearbox->differential->wheels->
differential->gearbox->engine, we have some oscilation problem when backing
up the ground resistence to the enigne through gearbox/differential inertia.
Then we'll implement the ground viscosity.
I'll surely post again about car physics on r.a.s :o)
>
>-Gregor
>
--
Seb -
Game Developer
http://www.eden-studios.fr
GPLRank -41.68
http://magicfr.multimania.com
Quoted text (13 lines)
>Hi Sebastien! > >"S�bastien Tixier" wrote: >> >> hehehe, it's very intersting because this is just what i had modeled >> after sending my previous post :o) >> Moreover long_slip_speed info is very usefull for all Graphicals >> effects, tire skids, tarmac burning smoke, gravel projections,etc. >> > >That's great to hear, probably this means we're on the right track ;). > >Be sure to let me know how it turned out!I took a quick look at your website;
Are you behind V-Rally 2 and NFSPU ?
Is it V-Rally 3 you are developing now?
/Carl
S�bastien Tixier <[email hidden]> wrote in message
news:[email hidden]...
backing
> up the ground resistence to the enigne through gearbox/differentialinertia.
Quoted text (20 lines)
> Gregor Veble <[email hidden]> wrote in > <[email hidden]>: > > >Hi Sebastien! > > > >"S�bastien Tixier" wrote: > >> > >> hehehe, it's very intersting because this is just what i had modeled > >> after sending my previous post :o) > >> Moreover long_slip_speed info is very usefull for all Graphicals > >> effects, tire skids, tarmac burning smoke, gravel projections,etc. > >> > > > >That's great to hear, probably this means we're on the right track ;). > > > >Be sure to let me know how it turned out! > > Well, for now, my team-mate and i are working to making work correctly the > "ellipse" grip and the chain engine->gearbox->differential->wheels-> > differential->gearbox->engine, we have some oscilation problem whenQuoted text (16 lines)
> Then we'll implement the ground viscosity. > > I'll surely post again about car physics on r.a.s :o) > > > > >-Gregor > > > > > > -- > Seb - > Game Developer > http://www.eden-studios.fr > GPLRank -41.68 > http://magicfr.multimania.comOn Wed, 23 May 2001 13:47:41 +0200, "Carl Ribbegaardh" <no.spam@all>
wrote:
>I took a quick look at your website;
>Are you behind V-Rally 2 and NFSPU ?
V-Rally 2 (utter garbage) and NFSPU (excellent game) from the same
developers? Nah, can't be..
Andre
[email hidden] (Andre Warringa) wrote in <3b0ba35c.1023908040
@news.xs4all.nl>:
I've worked on VR2 PSX1 and NFSPU PSX1,
NFSPU PC was made by EA ... wich "borrowed" our body deformation alogorithm,
and NFSPU PSX1 was made by my Co.
VR2 PC is an adaptation from the DC version, and the kernel was'nt made at
all for heterogeneous platform as the PCs.. with got lot of problems to
making works dynamic kernel . And i agree with you VR2 PC is crap. But we
sold 1 million of VR2 PSX1, wich i'm proud of. The only Racing game on PSX1
with modelised driver and co-driver .
By the way, i think that NFSPU PSX1 is more interesting to play that the PC
versions , tracks tighter, more actions. In My Humble Objective Opinion.
And about VRally3 ... no coment .. ;o)
regards,
--
Seb -
Game Developer
http://www.eden-studios.fr
GPLRank -41.68
http://magicfr.multimania.com
Quoted text (8 lines)
>On Wed, 23 May 2001 13:47:41 +0200, "Carl Ribbegaardh" <no.spam@all> >wrote: > >>I took a quick look at your website; >>Are you behind V-Rally 2 and NFSPU ? > >V-Rally 2 (utter garbage) and NFSPU (excellent game) from the same >developers? Nah, can't be..Great thanks!
/Carl


































